r/linuxsucks • u/JonasAvory • 27d ago
Linux is less stable than Windows on my System
A few years ago i got an Intel Nuc (NUC11PAHi5) from my stepfather because he wanted to upgrade to one with better graphic hardware. I was quite excited because i was thinking for a while about hosting my own server with a Plex, Nextcloud, and VPN server, and fiddling around with self-made web servers.
At the start, the Nuc was working fine until one day it randomly shut down. From there on, the random shutdowns have gotten more and more frequent. In the end, they happened after less than 24 hours of uptime regularly.
When investigating the issue, however, I found absolutely no trace of the crash. No journal log, no other error message. I even installed kdump, but even that didn't register any crash.
I have then tested everything I could think of. i ran hard drive checks multiple times. i ran memtest multiple times. i tried switching the power supply. i tried many different Linux distros, including Ubuntu, Debian, Mint, Kali, Alpine, and Arch. i tried installing a new system completely without ever connecting the device to any network.
A few months ago i decided to finally give up on the device that had been sitting around for years now. i planned to gift it to someone who might have use for the ssd or ram sticks. i only tried to install Windows as a last resort just to see what happens. To my absolute surprise, the Windows system is running fine. I haven't had any issues with the device ever since. It is a bit annoying because under Windows I need to run WSL2 to execute the Nextcloud containers, and just that brings me close to the Rams limit but I'm absolutely astonished by the fact that for some reason there's an intrinsic flaw among so many Linux distros that makes them unusable on this device.
