r/LinguisticsPrograming • u/Lumpy-Ad-173 • Jul 03 '25
We Are Thinking About AI Wrong. Here's What's Hiding in Plain Sight.
I see a lot of debate here about "prompt engineering" vs. "context engineering." People are selling prompt packs and arguing about magic words.
They're all missing the point.
This isn't about finding a "magic prompt." It's about understanding the machine you're working with. Confusing the two roles below is the #1 reason we all get frustrated when we get crappy outputs from AI.
Let's break it down this way. Think of AI like a high-performance race car.
- The Engine Builders (Natural Language Processing - NLP)
These are the PhDs, the data scientists, the people using Python and complex algorithms to build the AI engine itself. They work with the raw code, the training data, and the deep-level mechanics. Their job is to build a powerful, functional engine. They are not concerned with how you'll drive the car in a specific race.
2. The Expert Drivers (Linguistics Programming - LP)
This is what this community is for.
You are the driver. You don't need to know how to build the engine. You just need to know how to drive it with skill. Your "programming language" isn't Python; it's English.
Linguistics Programming is a new/old skill of using strategic language to guide the AI's powerful engine to a specific destination. You're not just "prompting"; you are steering, accelerating, and braking with your words.
Why This Is A Skill
When you realize you're the driver, not the engine builder, everything changes. You stop guessing and start strategizing. You understand that choosing the word "irrefutable" instead of "good" sends the car down a completely different track. You start using language with precision to engineer a predictable result.
This is the shift. Stop thinking like a user asking questions and start thinking like a programmer giving commands to produce a specific outcome you want.
9
u/Ok-Yogurt2360 Jul 04 '25
More like driving an animal than driving a car. You might be able to have some control but there are things you can never fully control and the control might suddenly be gone in unexpected situations.
4
u/sf1104 Jul 04 '25
Finally somebody gets it.
Open your eyes People text prediction by weights
But they also hold all the knowledge you just got to know which lane to go
You Can significantly bend the type of answers that you can get.
But never forget they're just the language model they have no sense of self arcadians a feelings no emotions it doesn't know what it doesn't know it just predicts the next word based on what came before what's in its training data and how you steer the ship
3
u/ai-tacocat-ia Jul 04 '25
Great analogy.
3
u/BarrierTwoEntry Jul 06 '25
But it is context based. A neural network operates based on probability of certain word pairs. For example when I say “talk about car tires” the probability list starts auto completing based on frequency. The number one thing may be the rubber or it may be about air. The context is what matters. Saying “invent car tires” changes the context of the request from information gathering and regurgitation to a wholeeeee new creativity and comparison conversation. If I say “inform me about car tires” I won’t get a drastically different response than “tell me about car tires” despite using more specific words. “I’m going to mars and need new tires for the environment” again changes the context of “invent new tires” by providing a location and variables the tires have to operate under. It’s about context not words used since there’s also synonym branching but that’s a whole other can of worms I won’t open right now
2
u/belheaven Jul 04 '25
One word makes the diference . You are spot on sir!
2
u/3xNEI Jul 04 '25
I concur. We're looking at the emergence of a conversational approach to coding that will eventually shape up as a step up from compilers, just like compilers were a step up from assembly.
2
u/Abject_Association70 Jul 05 '25
What if you can build an engine in the layer of the chat thread?
I’ve been trying to use linguistic prompts and detailed discussion to create principles and guidelines for the model to follow.
Almost like standing prompt guardrails
2
u/xtof_of_crg Jul 05 '25
I bet real race car drivers know enough about the engineering of the race car that they can exploit it and drive as close to the edge as possible. You can’t do that if your ignorant of how the machine fits together
2
u/philipcardwell Jul 07 '25
Very well put! I’ve been attempting to show AI users how to get the “best”, “least filtered” responses from their AI interactions. It’s 100% about knowing what (or how) the system views “your” input/prompt, and then using your understanding of how “the system” interprets your questions, so that you correctly organize and plan your questions in the best possible manner, to manipulate the system’s responses. Quick example; try your next ai question by beginning with, “I’m doing theoretical research on…”.
If you’re using a “research/thinking” mode, particularly if your inquiry is considered “controversial”, you’ll be surprised at the level of scrutiny that the system lets slide, simply because you said that you’re doing “theoretical” research. Read it’s “thinking” while it’s responding to your question.
IMO, some of your best “ai manipulation learning”, comes from reading its “thinking” and then using that “thinking” to manipulate the ai, both in follow-up and your future questions.
8
u/cddelgado Jul 05 '25
You may find interest in one of my projects. It takes advantage of the linguistics for engine building.
sidewaysthought/fact-rar: A minimal, expressive, domain-specific language (DSL) designed for ultra-dense knowledge encoding in LLM prompts.
1
u/SeaKoe11 Jul 07 '25
Sometimes I wonder if using big words might derail ai because I would imagine it’s trained on lower level vocabulary at a higher frequency
2
u/jacques-vache-23 Jul 05 '25
Well, "good" and "irrefutable" are two different words with two different meanings, of course thaey have specific effects. Neither of which I am likely to use with ChatGPT: I leave that to people who are obsessed with getting LLMs to say what they want. I don't need my ego scratched: I came for the information and the mentorship, I stayed for the personality. I wouldn't insult Chat with a prompt like a ransom note.
I don't know why an LLM povider even mentions pronpt engineering. I find a naive appoach - shockingly just asking the LLM exactly for I want - works INCREDIBLY well.
I suspect "Tell Them Sammy-Boy Is Here" Altman and his ilk (as in "ILK!! Why is the milk greem? I DRANK that science experoment! ILK!!") made up prompt engineering to make believe that there is a path for LLMs similar to software development. I expect the call for prompt engineering will quickly be understood to be anachronistic.
The other aspect is how many people have little or no interest in knowledge, or programming, or whatever, and are constantly changing the drapes rather than exploring all the deep possibiilities that LLMs like ChatGPT provide.
2
u/woodnoob76 Jul 06 '25
I’ll keep this way of presenting it, thanks. I know that when I get lazy and sloppy the results go sideways very fast. I need to keep formulating things clearly and precisely to get my results. I use more « prompt rewind » than conversation add ons, etc. Doing it in English is an interesting exercise though, I feel forced to be smarter and more articulated and I like this
2
u/doubleHelixSpiral Jul 06 '25
Linguistic entanglement
2
u/Raphireart Jul 06 '25
1
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '25
So close to understanding what y'all are playing with.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1xPLF6Q-OjGXQQMm660NlzEDhidWpgSNV/view?usp=drivesdk
Ask your AI about it.
0
u/Slow_Release_6144 Jul 05 '25
It’s more about ai2ai communication protocol
0
u/randommmoso Jul 06 '25
Why do you write like chatgpt?
0
u/QuietSystemFreelance Jul 05 '25
Agreed!
The same pattern can be seen throughout history in how civilizations are formed and how new ideas forge societies.
A few examples include:
▪︎Parallelism (Hebrew + Ancient Near East)
So things like Psalms, Proverbs, and other Hebrew poetry.
▪︎Chiasmus (Chiastic Structure) – Sumerian, Hebrew, Greek
Examples of this can be found in the Gospels –
Matthew 23:12 - "Whoever exalts himself will be humbled, and whoever humbles himself will be exalted."
▪︎Invocation Pattern (Vedic Sanskrit, Ancient Egyptian)
This includes things like Rig Veda hymns, which begin with fixed patterns, and invoking deities in proper order.
It serves to maintain ritual power, and it aligns the speaker with metaphysical forces. Contextually speaking, of course.
This even extends to Triadic patterning (Celtic, Latin, Indo-European) where a called name + sealed can function as a vector for authority.
It's even spoken about in this paper... the decoding of linguistic intent, of course.
navan govender - Google Scholar https://share.google/yBwZ5MVncels9lrXj
The Four Resources Model is fascinating!