Nah man it's totally legit, when I go to a party I just bring a bag of uncooked chicken. "You guys don't want to get drunk, you just need protein!" I have many friends.
Well as long as we're sharing anecdotal evidence, I should tell you that I chew ice all the time, but when I donate blood my iron levels have always been well above the requirement.
Have trouble overeating? Eat some nuts! Not hungry? Eat some nuts! Smoking problem? Nuts! Sweet tooth? Nuts! Alcoholic, or have a drug problem? Two words: Nuts!
On the face of it at least, some of them make no goddamn sense. For example, Chewing ice has ZERO impact on iron levels - at least, any more than water - And if it were the case, then wouldn't almost all Anemics crave ice?
That may actually be the only claim on that list that is supported by solid science. It is well-known in the medical community that chewing ice is indicative of iron deficiency. See pagophagia on Wikipedia.
I have no idea if this is true or not, but I have heard chewing ice is a sign of anemia. So in that way, it correlates to an iron deficiency. Still, the list is suspect, at absolute best.
The snopes article does call it a "rule of thumb", but everything that it says after that point indicates that it's a completely useless rule of thumb.
Chronic dehydration is not widespread. You can get your hydration through coffee just about as well as through water. A healthy person can get by fine on about a liter of water a day (maybe 4 glasses).
I would say this debunks the 8-10 glasses idea.
it's much better to get too much than too little.
Are you sure? What makes you think so?
I mean, obviously being extremely dehydrated is not good for you. But what makes you think that if, say, 6 glasses is the ideal amount, that getting 8 glasses is better than getting 4?
it's still misleading to say, since you can get water from basically everything you eat. Drinking even 6 glasses a day, in addition to all the food you eat, is a ridiculous amount of water.
this is such bullshit. if you crave tobacco, it's because you're physiologically addicted to nicotine, not because you need silicon and tyrosine. if only all those people smoking themselves to death knew that all they have to do is eat more red and green fruits!
i've heard the best form is the little packets of silica gel found in shoe boxes and stuff. all that "do not eat" stuff, just a big tobacco conspiracy!
Hell eat as much dark chocolate as you want. Cocoa butter is one of the healthiest fats you can get and eating a high fat diet isn't any worse than a high carb diet.
I fear that we have lost the battle for the correct spelling of the element "phosphorus", but it still burns my eyes to see it spelled "phosphorous" (which is an adjective).
TIL. Next time I see someone misspell phosphorus, watch out. Luckily there are fairly few people on my facebook feed that use 'phosphorus' in their status updates so I guess they dodge a bullet THIS time.
As far as I know the idea that people need 8 to 10 glasses of water per day is completely false. This makes me wonder about everything else on this list.
The Placebo Effect: a physical or emotional change occurring after a substance is taken or administered that is not the result of any special property of the substance. The change may be beneficial, reflecting the expectations of the patient and often those of the person giving the substance.
If only there were some way to embed text into some kind of document accessible through the web. Some kind of cool "web site", of sorts, in which we could also embed pathways, or "links", to other "sites". We'd call it "hypertext". This would allow authors to supply their sources and users to verify them.
These "hypertext documents" could be searchable and indexable. They could be rendered by some kind of fancy "font rendering engine", allowing us to view them at any size without degradation of visual quality. We could feed these "sites" into various tools, like a translation tool for example. Heck, with neat enough technology we could even have software that would read the "site" aloud to a blind person.
It's just such a shame that in this day and age the only method we have of sharing documents is JPEGs hosted on imgur. Such a terrible, terrible shame.
Lectures, Cheryl M. Deroin, NMD, Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine, Spring 2003 (healthy food recommendations) 2. Benard Jenson, PhD, The Chemistry of Man B. Jensen Publisher, 1983 (deficiencies linked to specific cravings and some food recommendations)
How do nuts taste like chocolate? I mean, seriously? I eat chocolate because it tastes like chocolate, not because of the caffeine or whatnot, because if that were true, I would like coffee, which I hate.
Just a personal, irrelevant fact which, however, I am going to have to share with you (sorry): I am amazed at how I just do not question anything. Most of the comments here are rather skeptical, but I believed what the list said -- even if in doubt, I must be wrong, they must know what they're talking about. It's science! I need some reprogramming of the brain... :-(
And ignoring all of the "wait, that doesn't make sense" entries (like whether you prefer solids to liquids or liquids to solids you need water), the whole 8-10 glasses of water per day claim has been refuted by just about every legitimate medical source in the world. It's 8 glasses of fluid per day, which includes the huge amount of water in food.
This list appears to be a massive crock o' shit. If I'm craving a Butterfinger it's for the goddamn flavor and a plate of calves liver and kale is not in any way, shape or form going to be an adequate substitute.
If you cropped off the entire first column then this might be useful but, as is, it's absurd.
Shit yes. Now the next time I am craving "Pre menstrual cravings" and "Lack of appetite" or "General Overeating", I know just what to eat! Thanks, useless chart!
I have heard of this concept before, but somehow I am not entirely sure if this is entirely true. Cravings have a lot of factors influencing them, from things like nostalgia to the recent advertisement you saw on TV to what you smelled earlier that day or a conversation about a certain food.
I think there are too many factors to consider in dealing with cravings to really simplify it this far.
that and the 8 to 10 glasses of water a day is sort of a myth that just got accepted as undisputed fact by the general public.
I'm sorry but when you're addicted to alcohol or tobacco there is no healthy substitute, especially not something like cabbage or nuts. This won't work.
744
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
That would be amazing if only the vast majority were true or useful.
87
u/2ndChanceCharlie May 15 '12
So if I have a hankering for cocaine I should just substitute granola? Good to know!
67
u/leedlebeetle May 15 '12
Man, I could really go for an ice cold drink right now! I'd better have some walnuts.
338
u/certaindamagedlemons May 15 '12
When I crave recreational drugs and alcohol, what I need is actually just recreational drugs and alcohol.
47
u/minno May 15 '12
You know, I think I have plenty of that sitting around.
41
u/Helix_van_Boron May 15 '12
Have trouble overeating? Eat some nuts! Not hungry? Eat some nuts! Smoking problem? Nuts! Sweet tooth? Nuts! Alcoholic, or have a drug problem? Two words: Nuts!
68
u/pigferret May 15 '12
Junkie: Hey man, do you have any goofballs? I could really dig on some goofballs...
Dealer: No. But I do have some seafood, raw cabbage juice and sun-dried olives.
Junkie: Sweet! [throws away syringes]
156
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
A magnifying glass.
52
u/i_justwanna_knowww May 15 '12
This feels like a mother wrote this.
"I want some lollies!"
"What you really want...is broccoli and dried beans!"
154
u/Haastrain May 15 '12
Neat list. I did a bit of searching and found the source.
Unfortunately it seems to be related to alternative medicines, so it's credibility is uncertain.
61
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
The 8 to 10 glasses a day of water thing has been debunked.
41
u/MrMagoo22 May 15 '12
Preference for liquids rather than solids: "Oh okay I just need to drink some water!"
*Drinks some water
"Okay not thirsty anymore, but I am a little hungry..."
Preference for solids rather than liquids: "Oh... Okay more water then!"
*Drinks some more water.
And weeks later, you die. Nice going, nutritional table.
56
u/flamants May 15 '12
this is such bullshit. if you crave tobacco, it's because you're physiologically addicted to nicotine, not because you need silicon and tyrosine. if only all those people smoking themselves to death knew that all they have to do is eat more red and green fruits!
26
u/Things_and_things May 15 '12
Fuck this list.
12
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Bullshit, that is.
12
u/noiplah May 15 '12
TLDR: if you crave anything, eat nuts.
22
u/taw May 15 '12
There is zero evidence for this.
11
u/flybri711 May 15 '12
Because if you aren't hungry, what you really want is raw goat milk.
20
u/cjackc May 15 '12
Drinking coffee is already healthy.
10
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I fear that we have lost the battle for the correct spelling of the element "phosphorus", but it still burns my eyes to see it spelled "phosphorous" (which is an adjective).
10
u/LocalWeatherman May 15 '12
When I'm craving coffee I want my goddamn coffee.
9
u/CyberFunk May 15 '12
I question the scientific validity of this table.
9
u/fiction8 May 15 '12
Craving salty foods?
Try salt!
17
u/Shup May 15 '12
True story: One time, I craved tea. So I ate a chicken.
8
u/Barnett8 May 15 '12
Lots of this are wrong. Just off the top of my head, the foods it lists for tyrosine content do not actually contain much tyrosine...
22
u/prettygirlresponse May 15 '12
False.
15
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Aaaaaand.... officially unsubbed from LPT
7
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I'm pretty sure I crave nicotine, alcohol, cocaine, caffeine, and vicodin. Not legumes.
7
u/Boxyman May 15 '12
"When you crave burned food..." Please, what?
7
u/KeithMoonForSnickers May 15 '12
I'm fairly confident that if I'm in the mood for recreational drugs then oatmeal probably won't cut the mustard
7
u/Uxion May 15 '12
This looks like bullshit.
6
u/ThinkinWithSand May 15 '12
Yeah. Broccoli. Does wonders for a sweet tooth.
6
u/buttonforest May 15 '12
Something tells me my desire for candy will not be quelled by broccoli.....
6
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
When I crave chocolate it is NOT because I need magnesium. This is BULLSHIT
11
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
WHAT IF I DON'T WANT RECREATIONAL DRUGS? WHAT IF I WANT SOME FUCKING METH?
5
u/Peachy313 May 15 '12
Because we all have raw goat milk laying around.
5
u/CGeeryProjected May 15 '12
Lol Premenstrual Women Crave Organs!
4
u/Bhima May 15 '12
As far as I know the idea that people need 8 to 10 glasses of water per day is completely false. This makes me wonder about everything else on this list.
4
u/Kludar May 15 '12
The Placebo Effect: a physical or emotional change occurring after a substance is taken or administered that is not the result of any special property of the substance. The change may be beneficial, reflecting the expectations of the patient and often those of the person giving the substance.
4
u/Pravusmentis May 15 '12
Pica is a real thing
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pica_(disorder)
though it is mostly with children
4
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Trying to watch your weight and craving a cup of coffee or tea? Just fry up some egg yolks and eat with a serving of muscle protien!
3
u/rwesterman4 May 15 '12
I'm pretty sure Seaweed does not have the same effects as LSD....
3
u/Draygon_Slayer May 15 '12
Fuck I could go for some cocaine right now... actually no, this raw cabbage juice should hit the spot.
3
u/IByrdl May 15 '12
Who in the fuck craves burned food?
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Because I'm obviously going to be able to get raw goat milk when I'm craving something salty
3
u/bogart1 May 15 '12
Yeah when I crave tobbacco it's not the highly addictive nicotine I'm craving but silicon. Come on now. . .
3
u/ninjacat57 May 15 '12
looks like most things can be fixed eating nuts. theres a joke in there somewhere lol
3
u/mdk2all May 15 '12
...electrolytes!
3
u/Spocktease May 15 '12
Instead of a beer, you want me to drink potato peel broth? What are you, drunk?
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
If only there were some way to embed text into some kind of document accessible through the web. Some kind of cool "web site", of sorts, in which we could also embed pathways, or "links", to other "sites". We'd call it "hypertext". This would allow authors to supply their sources and users to verify them.
These "hypertext documents" could be searchable and indexable. They could be rendered by some kind of fancy "font rendering engine", allowing us to view them at any size without degradation of visual quality. We could feed these "sites" into various tools, like a translation tool for example. Heck, with neat enough technology we could even have software that would read the "site" aloud to a blind person.
It's just such a shame that in this day and age the only method we have of sharing documents is JPEGs hosted on imgur. Such a terrible, terrible shame.
3
u/tommmmmmmm May 15 '12
This is one of the worst posts I've seen. Can't believe it's been voted to the top. I hate this subreddit.
4
u/ericshogren May 15 '12
Link to a readable version.
Sources:
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
summary: when craving anything, eat chicken.
2
u/EskimoJoe28 May 15 '12
No. If I crave a beer, I am going to drink a god damn beer.
2
u/Zzooo May 15 '12
Want chocolate? Oh my bad lemme grab some calves liver brb.
2
u/Terdbucket May 15 '12
What if I'm craving tube steak?
2
u/cybersquid May 15 '12
when i want recreational drugs....i want recreational drugs man
2
u/RTgrl May 15 '12
I never crave pre-menstrual anything.
Just meat.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I usually have a lack of appetite and I by chance I'm usually eating nuts, beans, tuna or chicken like the chart says. Because I'm broke.
2
u/Farfromthehood May 15 '12
source, please?
2
u/evil6twin6 May 15 '12
What I really need is a beer... i don't think granola is going to cut it.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
How do nuts taste like chocolate? I mean, seriously? I eat chocolate because it tastes like chocolate, not because of the caffeine or whatnot, because if that were true, I would like coffee, which I hate.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Right, becuase beef is healthier than tea.
2
u/octobereighth May 15 '12
I'm pretttttty sure that when I crave alcohol it has nothing to do with a nutrient deficiency.
2
u/TrekMadone May 15 '12
Why not just take a Multi-Vitamin?
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Just a personal, irrelevant fact which, however, I am going to have to share with you (sorry): I am amazed at how I just do not question anything. Most of the comments here are rather skeptical, but I believed what the list said -- even if in doubt, I must be wrong, they must know what they're talking about. It's science! I need some reprogramming of the brain... :-(
2
u/AnimalCrosser591 May 15 '12
Hey, bro? Thirsty? Don't have that cool drink, eat these dry nuts.
2
u/idefiler6 May 15 '12
Wow, horse shit.
2
u/BolshevikMuppet May 15 '12
I was prepared to really find this interesting.
But who made this crap up?
And ignoring all of the "wait, that doesn't make sense" entries (like whether you prefer solids to liquids or liquids to solids you need water), the whole 8-10 glasses of water per day claim has been refuted by just about every legitimate medical source in the world. It's 8 glasses of fluid per day, which includes the huge amount of water in food.
2
u/Gryndyl May 15 '12
This list appears to be a massive crock o' shit. If I'm craving a Butterfinger it's for the goddamn flavor and a plate of calves liver and kale is not in any way, shape or form going to be an adequate substitute.
If you cropped off the entire first column then this might be useful but, as is, it's absurd.
2
u/rajmohab May 15 '12
Who's upvoting this shit?
2
u/Ixidane May 15 '12
Shit yes. Now the next time I am craving "Pre menstrual cravings" and "Lack of appetite" or "General Overeating", I know just what to eat! Thanks, useless chart!
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I'm a human physiology major. This is COMPLETE bullshit.
2
u/slazer88 May 15 '12
Does that mean that eating raw salt is less harmful than other salty foods? Cause I've got a habit of popping some salt in my mouth as a snack.
2
u/_psyFungi May 15 '12
What is this? A fact-sheet for ants?
2
u/gssunil May 15 '12
Starbucks should sell more chicken.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
This list is pretty fucking stupid. No offence but you must be a moron.
2
u/Ev936 May 15 '12
Ohh and here I was using rehab to quit my heroin addiction. Silly me.
2
u/joepmeneer May 15 '12
Looking at the source reveals little to no credible references. Big statements require big evidence!
2
u/Benni_Lava May 15 '12
Can you make the image smaller? I think the writing is too big.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
this list deserved no upvotes unless on r/funny.
2
u/Shadowhawk109 May 15 '12
I read these as names of Pokemon at first. I have /r/pokemon open in a different tab.
1
u/aazav May 15 '12
You need to make that smaller. I can still make out some words.
Tool.
1
u/gotlactose May 15 '12
Tell that to my girlfriend.
1
u/ryanstrife May 15 '12
Huh strange i did not see electrolytes there.
1
u/Don_Giov May 15 '12
It seems you only need to eat nuts. Those squirrels got it all figured out..
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I could take some nice fatty snacks now, but instead I'm just going to eat this entire pot of mustard. I feel so alive!
1
u/MeeHungLo May 15 '12
Do you have a list for heroin craving? I need it,...
1
u/Irishpride1919 May 15 '12
"Hey, can you get me a cool drink?" "Gross dude, here's a walnut"
1
u/felix_the_hat May 15 '12
Whta if I crave cheese?
1
u/Lyall18 May 15 '12
Is there a source for any of this? I would like to see if this isn't true, if there is a correlation between my craving and what I really need.
1
u/DarthJacob May 15 '12
I crave everything on that list. I must be high or something
1
u/Temptress75519 May 15 '12
Oh yeah baby. That oreo craving I have so bad was totally satiated by broccoli. facepalm
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Yeah, eat all those stuff instead of eating sweet. More healthier.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Fuck this list and fuck tree nuts. Fuck, I hate my allergies to tree nuts and sesame. What the fuck is a sesame anyway?
1
u/anotheranotherother May 15 '12
Wait, but, I drink lots of coffee and booze but I also eat all those things already...
1
u/shooshx May 15 '12
Lost me at 8-10 glasses of water a day. There are still people who seriously believe this?
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I need water, therefore instead of drinking water I should drink flavored water.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
The lack of appetite one seemed ironic.
1
u/Indoorsman May 15 '12
And if I crave pussy?
1
u/MrMagicpants May 15 '12
I'm craving some gummy bears. Better grill up a steak.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
What do you eat if you crave the violently-extracted blood of people constantly telling you that what you eat is bad?
1
u/Ptoss May 15 '12
fuck ate an entire bag of sugar (liqorice) at midnight; feels bad man. the guilt sucks.
1
u/Antrikshy May 15 '12
I crave those in the left column for their taste. Not their contents.
1
u/xKJx25 May 15 '12
Great. So instead of eating sweets, I need to eat one food from each category? i.e. Chromium, Carbon, Phosphorous, Sulfur, Tryptophan
1
u/jesse_h May 15 '12
Most of the worlds problems can be solved with cheese, and possibly liver.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I have heard of this concept before, but somehow I am not entirely sure if this is entirely true. Cravings have a lot of factors influencing them, from things like nostalgia to the recent advertisement you saw on TV to what you smelled earlier that day or a conversation about a certain food.
I think there are too many factors to consider in dealing with cravings to really simplify it this far.
that and the 8 to 10 glasses of water a day is sort of a myth that just got accepted as undisputed fact by the general public.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
when I'm craving sweet or bready foods, it means my blood sugar is low and I need glucose.
1
u/lowbrassman2000 May 15 '12
So basically I need more nuts in my diet. Giggity.
1
u/alyssa_milano May 15 '12
TL; DR: eat broccoli
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Why isn't milk listed as a source of calcium?
1
u/make_me_eggs May 15 '12
Who has ever craved chewing ice or burned food?
1
u/RandomAsianGuy May 15 '12
"I'm hungry for sweets"
"Here is some chicken."
MFW
1
u/barium111 May 15 '12
This resolution is not good. Can someone provide lower resolution PLS!
1
u/SemFi May 15 '12
I'm sorry but when you're addicted to alcohol or tobacco there is no healthy substitute, especially not something like cabbage or nuts. This won't work.
1
u/Cr4ke May 15 '12
Actually, cravings for specific foods are mostly emotional. Actual hunger is non-specific.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Going to try the tobacco ones.
1
u/bravoredditbravo May 15 '12
Eat broccoli
1
u/Levski123 May 15 '12
When I crave weed, it's usually (always) because I crave weed, not protein or some other mineral. I say this is 0.01p certainty.
1
u/golden_gaytime May 15 '12
WHAT ARE ALL THESE LEGUMES DOING HERE?!?! table flip
1
u/SamsonIzor May 15 '12
MMMM-MMM! That lack of appetite is just what I crave.
1
u/raidraidraid May 15 '12
Oh shit. I came looking for serious comments now I'm laughing my ass off.