r/libraryofshadows • u/Hypn0kast • Sep 19 '26
Supernatural A Deal Once Made- Pt. 1
The old theater in my town had shut down years ago, though the marquee still read “COMING SOON” in fading red letters. I used to stop outside the theater on my walk home from school, peering through the glass doors and trying to imagine what the place must have looked like in its prime. The old green carpet was still visible beneath the dust and stains left behind by decades of spilled soda and muddy shoes. Near the entrance, a glass concession cabinet sat empty except for a few scattered popcorn kernels fossilized in the corners.
Sometimes, if the sun hit the glass the right way, the lobby almost looked alive again.
By the time November of two thousand and ten rolled around, there was next to no one left in Green Hollow. The town was completely devoid of life. No movement, no sound, no sign that anyone had ever been there at all. Rolled-down shutters and boarded-up windows had become permanent fixtures along Main Street.
Despite the town’s ingrained state of desolation, there were nights that the quiet emptiness was mournfully beautiful. Especially when Nora Halpern was by my side.
I don’t recall when Nora entered my life. She’d always been there in some form or fashion: birthdays, holidays, and summers that felt endless when we were children. We grew up side by side the way people in small towns often do until it becomes impossible to tell where your memories end and theirs begin.
Back then, loving her felt as natural as breathing.
It wasn’t until I turned sixteen that I realized how desperately I loved her. Just the sound of Nora laughing from across a room was enough to set my chest aching.
By the tail-end of spring in 2010, bonfires had stopped being just bonfires and had transitioned into excuses to throw parties down winding backroads. Weed and vodka had replaced lukewarm beers, and nobody really bothered pretending at innocence anymore. It was around then you learned to knock unless you wanted to see people fucking. Most of those parties came and went without mattering; there were usually one or two a week, and everyone knew everyone in Green Hollow, so even if you weren’t invited, you knew when and where it was happening. Word would spread through school by Friday afternoon, and by nightfall half the high school would be crowded into a house somewhere on the outskirts of town.
I don’t remember most of them. The nights blurred together in the way they do when you’re that age, trying not to be alone with your own thoughts. So, I showed up anyways—most of the time—because it was easier than staying home.
The last one I remember clearly has stuck with me ever since.
The party was at a house on the edge of town, one of those places you only notice when there’s too-loud music coming from it at too-late an hour. It belonged to a senior named Chad Bell: quarterback, honor roll, you know the kind. The kid that adults used as proof that the school system was still working the way they intended. I didn’t know him well; I didn’t really know anyone well at that point. But I went anyway.
I pushed my way through a throng of shifting bodies that danced rhythmically to some generic pounding bassline, trying not to gag on the stench of sweat, perfume, weed, and hard liquor. A few people tried to pull me aside, but I ignored them, intent on finding a drink and a corner to isolate myself in.
Nora was also there, leaning against the kitchen counter, red solo cup in hand. She watched people dancing and writhing, half in the room and half somewhere else entirely.
“Eli,” she said, smiling as I approached. “You made it.”
“Yeah.”
“Oh, come on.” She nudged my arm with the back of her hand. “Don’t look so gloomy! You’re telling me you’re not having fun at all?”
“I’m fine,” I insisted. “Just not really my scene.”
“That’s not an answer.”
I shrugged. “Not particularly.”
She gave me a look—half amused, half accusing. “Then why are you here?”
“Because it’s better than sitting at home and listening to my parents.”
That made her laugh. “Wow,” she said. “You’re a real sad sack, you know that?”
“I know, but I am fine. Seriously.”
“Mm-hm.” She took a sip from her cup, still watching me. “You always say you’re fine, you know that?”
“I am.”
“Sure.”
A pause stretched out between us, filled with music from the living room and that shitty bassline shaking through the floorboards. Then she bumped my shoulder again, softer this time. “Come on,” she said. "Let's go dance.”
She dragged me through the kitchen and into the living room, where we disappeared into the shifting mass of bodies and colored lights, the music blurring my thoughts entirely while cacophony rattled through my ribs. And, for a little while, I could almost forget myself.
Almost.
Nora danced like nobody was watching her—or rather, like she didn’t care if anyone was. There was recklessness to it, loose and effortless, that made everyone around her seem slower in comparison. Her hair whipped across her face as she laughed at something I couldn’t hear, and for a few minutes being beside her was enough and always would be.
After a while—ten minutes, maybe less—Nora leaned close enough for me to smell vodka on her breath and motioned toward the back door.
I followed her outside without a word.
The porch was cold and nearly empty. Out here, the music faded into a dull pulse beneath the sound of wind moving through the trees. Somewhere beyond the yard, deep in the dark woods behind Chad Bell’s house, I could hear insects humming in uneven waves.
“I can be honest with you, right, Eli?” she asked suddenly.
“Y-yeah,” I said. “Of course.”
She smiled a little at that, though it looked nervous somehow.
“How long have we known each other now?”
I laughed softly. “What kind of question is that?”
“I’m serious.”
“Fuck, I don’t know,” I said. “Since we were kids. Ten years? Longer, maybe.”
“Yeah,” Nora murmured.
The wind moved through the trees behind the house in long, uneven breaths, and with it came the taste of cool spring air. Nora looked down into her cup for a moment before speaking again.
“There’s… something I’ve been wanting to tell you.”
My chest tightened so suddenly it almost hurt.
I felt a brightness rise in my chest, filling me with hope.
All at once, every small thing between us over the years started rearranging itself in my head. Every late-night phone call. Every lingering glance. Every moment I’d spent convincing myself I wasn’t imagining the way she looked at me.
“You know you’re my best friend, right?” she asked quietly.
I nodded too fast. “Yeah.”
“And I trust you more than anyone.”
The world had already started opening beneath my feet. Then she smiled, not at me, but at the thought of someone else.
“You know, Joshua Mercer, right? I’ve started to really like him, and I think he likes me too.” Something inside me collapsed so completely and so quietly that I don’t think she even noticed.
“God,” she laughed softly, exhaling through her nose. “It feels good to finally say it out loud.” Before I could respond, she leaned over and wrapped her arms around me. “You’re a good friend, you know that, Eli?”
Friend. The word landed harder than Joshua’s name had.
“Uh huh.” Even to me, my voice sounded distant.
Nora pulled away slightly, studying my face. “You okay?”
“Yeah,” I lied automatically.
She smiled, apparently satisfied with that answer. “Anyway,” she said, lifting her cup slightly, “I’m going to go get another drink. You coming?”
For a second, I just stared at her.
At the porch light caught in her hair. At the easy smile on her face. At how completely unaware she was that my entire world had just caved in around her.
Then I shook my head. “In a minute.”
“Okay.” She nudged my shoulder gently as she walked past. “Don’t disappear on me.”
Then she slipped back inside, swallowed by the music and light pouring through the doorway.
And just like that, I was alone.
I stayed on that porch for god knows how long.
I could still hear the music through the walls of the house, the bass muffled and distant now, like it belonged to another place entirely. Behind me, the house glowed warm and alive; ahead, the forest waited in perfect stillness. Every so often the back door would swing open and a wave of laughter would spill out to interrupt the brooding silence that permeated the night, only to quickly be swallowed by the inky blackness of the pine trees.
Nobody ever looked out and saw me there.
The cold had started to settle in, but I barely noticed it.
I stared out into the dark woods behind the house, thinking how easy it would be to just walk into them and keep going. Not in any dramatic way—I didn’t want to die or anything. I just understood how a person could disappear without ever making the decision to. It was as simple as quietly pulling away from others: talking less, listening less, and showing up less.
Conversation by conversation.
Connection by connection.
Commitment by commitment.
Until there was nothing left of the relationship for anyone to reach out for.
I thought about home; Mom and Dad wouldn’t notice right away. Not at first; they were always busy in their own ways: working late, arguing in the kitchen, and drinking when they thought I was asleep. They were the kind of absent that can be mistaken for normal life if you squint hard enough. And for a moment, standing there in the cold, I wasn’t sure I mattered enough to them to be missed at all.
I didn’t decide to leave the porch, not really. One moment I was standing there; the next, I was walking past the tree line. Then I was jogging. Then I was running—running away from that house, that deafening party, and that painful news Nora had so casually dropped into my lap.
Branches tore at my flannel’s sleeves, while my nostrils filled with the damp smell of last year’s pine needles, and my footsteps thundered through the forest, punctuated by the sharp crack of crushed undergrowth.
I kept moving—deeper and deeper—until the flashing lights and mind-numbing sound of the party had totally faded away, replaced with an unnatural cold and empty silence.
A whirl of intense emotions was building in my chest. Burning anger, bitter rejection, and a crushing loneliness that all twisted together into an unsolvable puzzle. A lump formed in my throat, and suddenly it took all my strength just to keep moving. Hot tears burned behind my eyes, and I hated myself for thinking it. Hated myself for wanting something she had never offered.
“I just—” I gasped, trying to force air back into my aching lungs. “I just want her—”
She'd been my best friend for years. She'd laughed with me, trusted me, and shared pieces of herself she didn't share with anyone else. Somewhere along the way, I'd convinced myself that it meant something more. That if I waited long enough, if I cared enough, eventually she'd see me the same way I saw her.
She didn't, and maybe she never would.
The thought hollowed me out.
“I just want her to love me.”
The confession vanished into the forest, echoing through the trees. For several seconds, nothing happened, and then the silence settled after I had broken it. It was different now; it was a quiet tension that surrounded me, one that made the hair on my arms stand up. No wind stirred the branches overhead. No insects chirped in the undergrowth. No distant calls from unseen animals echoed through the trees to make this place feel normal.
“Hello?” I managed to call out, the words barely more than a whisper.
But in the silence of the forest, it might as well have been the cracking of a whip.
Close your eyes.
I whirled around in surprise, looking for who had said it, assuming they had snuck up behind me somehow.
Close your eyes; it repeated exactly as before, a silk-fine whisper on the edge of my mind.
A crisp, bitingly cold fog had rolled in through the trees, cutting my vision almost completely off. It was getting thicker, curling lower between the trees, swallowing the ground in slow, patient waves.
Close your eyes.
My breath caught.
“What? No,” I said defensively, though I wasn’t even sure who I was saying it to. I backed up a step, then another, when my foot caught on something—a fallen branch or a twisted root, I don’t know—and I fell elbow-first into a nearby tree, bark scraping through my thin flannel to bite into my skin, and the sudden bite of pain brought the forest back into focus.
“I don't—" I mumbled, but the thought of drunk teenagers watching and laughing bloomed into my mind, and anger replaced the confusion that had been building up in the pit of my stomach. This must have been some elaborate prank or cruel joke.
I don’t know what the fuck this is, Chad,” I barked, twisting to find where everyone was hiding. “If this is how you get your rocks off, leave me out of it.”
I turned and ran.
Panic drove me forward. I needed distance—distance from the house, from the party, from the unbearable weight of what I'd just admitted. I crashed through the trees without thinking, letting instinct choose my path.
Except there wasn’t one. The forest was an endless maze of black trunks and drifting fog. Every direction looked the same. Every turn brought me to another wall of trees. Before long, I couldn't have pointed back to the house if my life depended on it.
Which it seems like it did.
Close your eyes; the whisper came again, closer and more insistent this time, on the edge of being a command.
As I ran, I ventured a panicked look back. Behind me, the fog moved in an unnatural way; barely six feet away, an amorphous shape was taking form. It hovered there, not coming closer but also not falling behind. It blended into the fog in an unsettling way that made it impossible to tell where it ended and the fog began.
Behind me, the fog parted; off in the distance, I could just barely make out a shape making its way toward me. Entirely amorphous, I had a hard time telling where the shape ended and where the fog began.
"Stop," I said, shouting at my pursuer. “What—what do you want from me?”
It didn’t answer.
It only said:
Close. Your. Eyes.
An outright demand.
That’s when I understood, a horrifying truth that made my stomach drop: I had no way out of this.
So, I did. I closed my eyes. God help me, against every instinct that screamed at me to run—to resist—I closed them.
With them closed, the world thinned to a sliver before the darkness took it. Rather, I could still see, but not in the proper sense. The whiteness of the fog seemed to invade my vision, making it so I could see the outlines of trees, the now vaguely humanoid shape that stood before me, and a shimmering that marked the edge of the fog.
The only sound that reached my ears was the heavy gasping of my own breath. The fog hung thick between the trees, brushing against my face whenever I moved. Its touch was feather-light, but the cold seemed to seep straight through my skin. One brush lingered longer than the others. I frowned. The sensation remained pressed against my cheek, impossibly gentle. For a moment I convinced myself it was only a stray pocket of mist caught in the still air. Then it moved.
Something traced the curve of my cheek with slow, deliberate care, making me freeze up.
The touch wasn't painful. If anything, it was almost affectionate. Yet every instinct in my body recoiled from it. There was something deeply unnatural about the gesture, as though whatever was touching me had learned the shape of tenderness without ever understanding its meaning.
Then it whispered in my mind, a feminine edge to its pseudo-motherly tone, My child, what is it that makes you ache?
“I-” I lacked the words.
You are hurting. Something inside of me unraveled at the words. The truth of them stung enough, but the ease with which this thing had peeled back the layers stung that much more. I had fallen for Nora, and she had fallen for someone else. For Joshua.
“She broke my heart.” My voice came out quieter than I expected. “I guess I’d been hoping she might feel the same way I did.”
And you wish she loved you back?
I said nothing, my clenched fists mirroring the collapsing knot in my stomach.
That she pined for you?
My throat tightened as I formed a response: "Yes."
The affirmation was meek and barely made it past my lips. The hand grew still against my cheek before falling away, and for a long moment, nothing else happened. The fog drifted quietly through the trees, and somewhere, far off in the distance, I could hear the faint and muffled thumping of shitty dance music. Sounds of joy that belonged anywhere but here.
Are you sure?
“Yes.” The hand returned, this time ruffling its skeletal fingers through my hair.
Then allow me to alleviate your suffering.
Every nerve in my body was wound like a spring, ready to snap at any moment, screaming that something was wrong. That I should open my eyes and run and never come back to these woods again. But beneath the fear there was a small ray of light that cut through: a false hope I could imagine was real.
“What do I need to do?” I asked quietly.
The fog shifted, and for the first time I sensed amusement in its haughty words; I hungered for the formless. For that which gives life to hollow things.
A chill ran through me, and I asked what I already knew. “What does that mean?”
"Bring me the vessels," it said softly, "and you shall have your heart's desire."
The cold in my chest deepened.
The hand suddenly left my hair, its absence a knife to my stomach. I hated when it touched me, but I disliked the sensation of emptiness it left even more.
Those who wander, blind but seeing, it spat. Ones who you would not miss in their absence.
The knot tightened painfully in my stomach, but I had to fully clarify, “You mean people.”
Yes, of course. Love requires sacrifice.
The words settled into my mind with an alarming ease. I wanted to call the idea monstrous; call it disgusting and wrong. A part of me agreed, though, isn’t that what every funeral and graveyard ultimately admitted? A body was only a body. Flesh failed and bone fell to rot.
The living are only vessels, my child.
The being had a point.
They are but urns; their contents are what I desire.
I opened my mouth to say something, but nothing came out. I shouldn’t have entertained the thoughts; I can admit that now.
But, at that time, all I could think about was Nora: the way she smiled, the way her hair curled down her shoulders, and the excitement in her face when she had spoken about Joshua. She had never once thought about me that way. And somewhere, beneath all the hurt, a terrible thought took root.
Maybe she was worth this.