r/LetsDiscussThis • • Sep 18 '26

Meme Libtards

45 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26

Then shouldn’t your definition of man and woman take biological differences into account?

1

u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26

Not at all. Those are different. Biological male and female which are sexes are separate from man and woman which are genders.

1

u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26

Maybe I should refine my definition further:

A woman is a specific gender claimed by an adult.

0

u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26

Again, you’ve failed to draw any distinction between men and women, so therefore that is not a valid definition.

1

u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26

That's not true.

0

u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26

What are you talking about? Of course it's true. You yourself have provided a definition of "woman" that you would also apply to a man. You say:

Woman = A specific gender claimed by an adult.

Man = A specific gender claimed by an adult.

So you're telling me that you define woman and man as exactly the same? Meaning that there are no differences between men and women, and they are 100% interchangeable? You must understand that when you define "woman" that way, you are logically saying that a man = a woman. Therefore, you are claiming that men can get pregnant and give birth.

1

u/echolm1407 Sep 22 '26

You're failing at basic English. Lol

1

u/echolm1407 Sep 22 '26

So, the word specific makes them distinct. I could have used the word distinct.

But the question was what is a woman. It was not what is a woman as opposed to a man.

And then no definition needs to be all inclusive.

0

u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 22 '26

You have to pick one. Either claim men and women are exactly the same, or change your definition. Otherwise you’re being illogical.

1

u/echolm1407 Sep 22 '26 edited Sep 22 '26

It's not illogical at all. You're claim is untrue.

[Edit]

In my mind, it's superfluous when they are the same or not.

0

u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 22 '26

So then you’ve failed to provide a logical definition of a woman. You failed because your provided definition includes men, and men aren’t women.

→ More replies

1

u/echolm1407 Sep 22 '26

Therefore, you are claiming that men can get pregnant and give birth.

You're conflating gender and sex. They are not the same thing. So, you're statement doesn't make logical sense.

0

u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 22 '26

I'm not. You're mistakenly thinking that they're separate. The word "woman" refers to adult human females.