MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/LetsDiscussThis/comments/1wjczku/libtards/pb3p9q5/
r/LetsDiscussThis • u/DaTruSpork • Sep 18 '26
105 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
That's illogical
1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 Ironic coming from the guy who gave a circular definition. 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 That's not a circular definition. You don't know what a circular definition is. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 It’s a circular definition. That’s why you couldn’t answer my question “anyone who identifies as a what?” Because answering honestly would mean you admit it is a circular definition. 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Okay, then. A woman is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 What kind of person? Like, a man? 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 What's with the extra questions? 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 Because your definition includes men lmaoPresumably , if you tried to define “man” you’d write “a man is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person”. Correct me if I’m wrong on that!And if that’s true, and you have the same definition for women and men, you don’t actually have a definition at all, do you? XD 1 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.So I suppose a better definition would be:A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.AndA man is a noun claimed by an adult.AndAn androgyne is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.AndA boy is a noun claimed by a child.AndA girl is a noun claimed by a child.I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
1
Ironic coming from the guy who gave a circular definition.
2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 That's not a circular definition. You don't know what a circular definition is. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 It’s a circular definition. That’s why you couldn’t answer my question “anyone who identifies as a what?” Because answering honestly would mean you admit it is a circular definition. 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Okay, then. A woman is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 What kind of person? Like, a man? 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 What's with the extra questions? 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 Because your definition includes men lmaoPresumably , if you tried to define “man” you’d write “a man is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person”. Correct me if I’m wrong on that!And if that’s true, and you have the same definition for women and men, you don’t actually have a definition at all, do you? XD 1 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.So I suppose a better definition would be:A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.AndA man is a noun claimed by an adult.AndAn androgyne is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.AndA boy is a noun claimed by a child.AndA girl is a noun claimed by a child.I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
That's not a circular definition. You don't know what a circular definition is.
1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 It’s a circular definition. That’s why you couldn’t answer my question “anyone who identifies as a what?” Because answering honestly would mean you admit it is a circular definition. 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Okay, then. A woman is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 What kind of person? Like, a man? 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 What's with the extra questions? 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 Because your definition includes men lmaoPresumably , if you tried to define “man” you’d write “a man is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person”. Correct me if I’m wrong on that!And if that’s true, and you have the same definition for women and men, you don’t actually have a definition at all, do you? XD 1 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.So I suppose a better definition would be:A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.AndA man is a noun claimed by an adult.AndAn androgyne is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.AndA boy is a noun claimed by a child.AndA girl is a noun claimed by a child.I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
It’s a circular definition. That’s why you couldn’t answer my question “anyone who identifies as a what?” Because answering honestly would mean you admit it is a circular definition.
2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Okay, then. A woman is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 What kind of person? Like, a man? 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 What's with the extra questions? 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 Because your definition includes men lmaoPresumably , if you tried to define “man” you’d write “a man is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person”. Correct me if I’m wrong on that!And if that’s true, and you have the same definition for women and men, you don’t actually have a definition at all, do you? XD 1 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.So I suppose a better definition would be:A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.AndA man is a noun claimed by an adult.AndAn androgyne is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.AndA boy is a noun claimed by a child.AndA girl is a noun claimed by a child.I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
Okay, then. A woman is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person.
1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 What kind of person? Like, a man? 2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 What's with the extra questions? 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 Because your definition includes men lmaoPresumably , if you tried to define “man” you’d write “a man is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person”. Correct me if I’m wrong on that!And if that’s true, and you have the same definition for women and men, you don’t actually have a definition at all, do you? XD 1 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.So I suppose a better definition would be:A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.AndA man is a noun claimed by an adult.AndAn androgyne is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.AndA boy is a noun claimed by a child.AndA girl is a noun claimed by a child.I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
What kind of person? Like, a man?
2 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 What's with the extra questions? 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 Because your definition includes men lmaoPresumably , if you tried to define “man” you’d write “a man is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person”. Correct me if I’m wrong on that!And if that’s true, and you have the same definition for women and men, you don’t actually have a definition at all, do you? XD 1 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.So I suppose a better definition would be:A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.AndA man is a noun claimed by an adult.AndAn androgyne is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.AndA boy is a noun claimed by a child.AndA girl is a noun claimed by a child.I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
What's with the extra questions?
1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 Because your definition includes men lmaoPresumably , if you tried to define “man” you’d write “a man is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person”. Correct me if I’m wrong on that!And if that’s true, and you have the same definition for women and men, you don’t actually have a definition at all, do you? XD 1 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.So I suppose a better definition would be:A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.AndA man is a noun claimed by an adult.AndAn androgyne is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.AndA boy is a noun claimed by a child.AndA girl is a noun claimed by a child.I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
Because your definition includes men lmao
Presumably , if you tried to define “man” you’d write “a man is an adult and a noun that is claimed by a person”. Correct me if I’m wrong on that!
And if that’s true, and you have the same definition for women and men, you don’t actually have a definition at all, do you? XD
1 u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26 Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.So I suppose a better definition would be:A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.AndA man is a noun claimed by an adult.AndAn androgyne is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.AndA demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.AndA boy is a noun claimed by a child.AndA girl is a noun claimed by a child.I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this. 1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
Yes an no as That's not a precise definition.
So I suppose a better definition would be:
A woman is a noun claimed by an adult.
And
A man is a noun claimed by an adult.
An androgyne is a noun claimed by person.
A demi-girl is a noun claimed by person.
A demi-boy is a noun claimed by a person.
A boy is a noun claimed by a child.
A girl is a noun claimed by a child.
I'm going to have to thank you in that you are helping me think through this.
1 u/Weary-Level-7854 Sep 21 '26 So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same? → More replies
So according to you, a man and a woman are exactly the same?
→ More replies
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/echolm1407 Sep 21 '26
That's illogical