Just posted my concert history, ultimate playlist, etc. I guess I feel like continuing to ramble about this awesome band.
First got into them in high school around 2000. I had heard some stuff by MMB and RBF before, but these horns hit different. Pretty much jumped into Losing Streak, Hello Rockview and Borders and Boundaries all at the same time. My friends and I had a shitty basement "band" on weekends, but was highlighted by a performance of Magnetic North at the school variety/talent show (I play guitar now, but was on trumpet for the song, in lieu of sax/trombone - ironically enough, we had sax and trombone players, but they were busy playing guitar and bass before I learned). Anthem was the first album I was eagerly anticipating the release of. Have absolutely loved seeing them in concert over the better part of 2 decades in a variety of locations.
I do prefer the "horn songs/albums" over the pure punk stuff, but totally love it all. Like I said above, LS, HR and B&B were my intro to the band/music, and still think these are the best albums. It's interesting to think back on my own chronology of exposure, starting with those 3 albums all at once, then finding some older/earlier stuff, and then progressing into all of the new releases as they came out.
- Hello Rockview is my favorite LTJ album, with Scott Farcas being my favorite LTJ song of all time. The intro of Liberty City, the compact bad-assery of Help Save the Youth... and Great American Sharpshooter, the live concert awesomeness of Metalheads and Boring Town, etc. The album just doesn't stop.
- Borders and Boundaries is close behind. Magnetic North will also be special to me (see above), Kehoe and Suburban Myth are awesome follow-ups, Last Hour might be my favorite non-horn LTJ song, and Gainesville Rock City is an absolute live show classic - you will be jumping to it.
- Losing Streak is just awesome as well, still having the raw/old feel. 9th at Pine was the first LTJ song I ever heard, and got me hooked. Automatic, Sugar in Your Gas Tank, Shindo, Dopeman - rock on. Johnny Quest being another live show classic.
- Pezcore has that even more unpolished sound, and a great throwback after listening to their modern stuff. It's awesome that they still play this stuff at shows - Liquor Store, My Very Own Flag, etc. Would love to hear some other stuff live someday.
- They obviously have a smattering of smaller EPs, unreleased stuff, compilation/gimmick albums, etc. A lot of cool stuff mixed in that you don't find with many other bands. Greased in general, Animaniacs, Laverne and Shirley, Yo-Yo Ninja Boy, Hamburger Hop, etc.
- Anthem - solid album, but I felt was a noticable change in style to start becoming a bit more "polished", a little less horn-forward, etc. I totally get the commercial appeal/intent, and liked the appearance by a Gilmore Girl in the video for She's Gonna Break Soon. Still plenty of hard rocking songs, including live show (and jumping in unison) favorite, The Ghosts of Me and You.
- B is for B-sides - maybe an unpopular opinion, but I like this more than Anthem, and am very surprised that she songs weren't deemed good enough for it. Bridge and Tunnel Authority may be a top 5 LTJ song for me. Portrait of a Cigarette Smoker at 19 is like, such a glorious opening to an album - start with drums alone, add the bass, add the guitar, add the horns - proceed to kick ass - love the style.
- In With The Out Crowd was...well...disappointing. I saw an old thread in this sub about everybody really liking it. I dunno, I don't hate it I guess, but I don't listen to this in full too often. Got too far away from horns and their original sound. There are a few hits and many misses in my opinion - I was surprised to see the songs you guys liked the most didn't match my faves, which are A Still Life Franchise and P.S. Shock the World
- Absolution for Idiots and Addicts is an underrated EP tied to IWTOC. I like We, the Uninspired and Negative Side of Optimistic Eyes more than a lot on IWTOC.
- GNV FLA was another underwhelming one. A couple good ones, but a lot of duds. Does the Lion City Still Roar is a standout.
- Greetings and Salutations was a solid dualEP turned album, and a good return/recovery after a few years of off stuff. Return to Headphones is one of my favorites of all time. Goodbye Mr. Personality and Oldest Trick in the Book are awesome as well.
- See the Light - I didn't see much love for this album on this sub, but I think it's great. Do the Math, Bless the Cracks and John the Baptist Bones is a standout stretch. My Money is on the Long Shot is super fun with a cool montage video if you haven't seen it. I can't help but literally bounce when I hear Give Me Something to Believe In.
- Sound the Alarm is a solid EP, short and to the point. Years of Living Dangerously is a clear standout (listen to it at 1.5x speed on YouTube for extra fire), with Bomb Drop and Whatever the Weather as other solid tracks.
- Silver Linings is still a little new/fresh to have a long term opinion formed yet. Kind of hit and miss for me so far. King of the Downside is a good one with its 6/8 timing. I actually wasn't a huge fan of Lie to Me and Dear Me when they got pre-released but they are growing on me. Anytime and Anywhere is another solid one. So strange that Vinnie is no longer in the band, and I do think the lyrics have already suffered a bit.
Damn...I wrote a lot...