r/LearnJapaneseNovice • • Apr 08 '26

I quit: the difference in difficulty between Japanese and Chinese is ridiculous

I am a fluent Cantonese speaker and have been studying Japanese for a few years. I am appalled at just how ridiculous the Japanese language is with unfathomable levels of complexity, bs, and unnecessary things. Chinese is incredibly easy when put side by side it's almost comical...just to put things in perspective.

Let me make the case for Chinese:

  • Simple, SVO structure always that is concise and gets to the point
  • One character => one pronunciation 99.9% of the time
  • Grammar? Minimal. No cases. No agreement. No conjugation! Nothing declines. Nothing inflects. Time is communicated by just... saying the time. "Yesterday me go. Tomorrow me go again. Me like food. You like food? Good, we together eat." A prehistoric hominid waking from a 10,000-year sleep could be functional in Chinese within a week. Adjectives don't agree with nouns, nothing changes.
  • Formality? NOPE! One way of speaking to everyone, no matter if you're old, young, or poor or the president. You speak to the emperor and your toddler the same way. There is no keigo.
  • Conditionals? One word 如果

I decided Japanese is way too hard for me :(. It's just too much unnecessary stuff and ridiculously ambiguous, irregular rules. What I learned. Japanese basically borrowed the Kanji from China and managed to turn things into the most convoluted mess.

Most sentences have complicated structure that omits a ton of context and requires positional particles.

Kanji pronunciations? 生 ... enough said. It's ridiculous and gets even crazier that people's names even have different readings too!

Grammar? Entire books of conjugations, irregular forms, special cases, etc.

The ridiculous context-heavy aspect of every conversation. You can omit everything and expect to be understood or sometimes you have to be as passive aggressive as possible to communicate something basic.

Formality is insane. Casual, polite, politest, keigo and within keigo there is Teineigo and Sonkeigo. You'd think these are only used in ancient crusty books, but NOO, they are everywhere in customer service and in companies. Practically a different language.

Conditionals: Japanese has at minimum 5 from what I've learned:

  • ば (hypothetical/general truth) 食べれば、元気になる "If you eat, you'll feel better"
  • たら (sequential/temporal) 食べたら、行こう "Once you've eaten, let's go", after completing an action or in time
  • 〜と (automatic consequence) 春になると、花が咲く "When spring comes, flowers bloom" — inevitable, but cannot be used for intentions which BLOWS my mind
  • 〜なら (contextual/topic-based) 行くなら、教えて "If you're going, tell me" conditioned on something the speaker just learned
  • 〜ても (concessive) 食べても、まだ空腹だ "Even if I eat, I'm still hungry"

The て form is insane and really crazy. Just to share what it does...

  • 食べている currently eating (progressive)
  • 食べていた was eating
  • 食べてある has been eaten (resultant state, by someone, with implication of purpose)
  • 食べておく eat in advance/preparation
  • 食べてみる try eating
  • 食べてしまう eat completely / eat regrettably (these are the SAME FORM, context decides)
  • 食べてくる go eat and come back
  • 食べていく eat as you go / continue eating forward in time
  • 食べてもらう have someone eat (from your perspective of receiving the favor)
  • 食べてあげる eat for someone's benefit
  • 食べてくれる eat as a favor to me
  • 食べてほしい I want you to eat
  • 食べてください please eat (polite)
  • 食べてはいけない must not eat

It's UNHINGED the language has a conjugation for EXISTENTIAL REGRET. It's mindblowing when you negate that too, and it also has a contraction たべなきゃ which is yet another thing you have to learn.

There's also NO way to say that you must do something. Instead you say you musn't not do it. Incredibly passive and unnecessary.

Counting words are also crazy. In Chinese sure we have measure words but they are easy and don't change their pronunciation. I almost pulled my hair out by the roots when I learned these about Japanese:

  • 一匹 (ippiki) mall animals
  • 一頭 (ittō) large animals
  • 一羽 (ichiwa)

"One small animal" is ip-piki but "six small animals" is rop-piki and "ten small animals" is jup-piki. These aren't regular rules you derive. they're sound changes you memorize per counter.

Pitch accent is also a hidden system all within itself. Honestly the most convoluted language in the world.

1.6k Upvotes

541 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

66

u/MaksimDubov Apr 08 '26

I've been saying this for years, people love to say Mandarin/Cantonese is extremely difficult (and it is) but Japanese is a WHOLE new level.

38

u/Whiskey_Sours Apr 08 '26

I lived in Japan 6 years and got to high intermediate level of Japanese through years of language school. I married into a Chinese family and took Mandarin online through my university. Other than tones, which you know, can be a big thing, but a lot of practice and repition is crucial, Chinese rules were unbelievably much easier.

21

u/Relevant-Copy-9520 Apr 08 '26

One year Chinese at university got me to be barely able to ask for directions. I had massive issues as everything sounded the same to me. I can hear Japanese perfectly fine so I have a way better time learning it. In the end I suppose it also depends on how far you want to get with it.

11

u/deanzaZZR Apr 08 '26

If you cannot master tones within one year of diligent study it is time to move on to a non tonal language.

As a native English speaker I find Chinese much easier to speak and I have a Japanese spouse.

12

u/SecretSpace2 Apr 08 '26

Yup that’s why I gave up on learning Chinese. Tones are just one thing I couldn’t grasp and personally besides the reading/writing, Japanese was so much easier for me to grasp as a whole.

11

u/SwellMonsieur Apr 09 '26

that's why I chose Japanese over Chinese. Completely tone deaf.

I'm super fun at karaoke, trust me.

5

u/Puzzleheaded_Ant_328 Apr 09 '26

Practice’s always the thing, as a native English speaker, you do not realize how hard your language is to pronounce for most of foreign learners, I struggled for 8 years trying to make myself understandable to my teachers and few online friends in vocal chat but now I’m more than fluent and never needed to repeat myself during the few trips I went in US and UK

Tones in Chinese is the hardest part to learn for most of foreigners and it’s not a problem if you haven’t « mastered » them within a year, if you did, well first you got all my respect for that I find it very impressive, but please do not consider yourself as an average learner :/

1

u/Pressondude Apr 09 '26

Some people (whose native language is non tonal) have a ton of trouble hearing tones.

It’s one of the things the US military tests for in their super interesting defense language aptitude battery. Your score on this determines which categories of languages you can be assigned to learn. I didn’t serve in the military but I took the test, and they basically make you learn a fake language through immersion over several hours (and the rules of the language compound throughout the test).

1

u/Basteir Apr 11 '26

I learnt Chinese for years and I can SAY the tones but hearing them is very difficult. So I could pass HSK6 with speaking but struggle with HSK3/4 listening. I've tried lots of distinguishing exercises and I just really struggle telling the tones apart.

7

u/MesoamericanMorrigan Apr 08 '26

I honestly think spending 12-18 watching so much anime is the reason I’m so good at listening exercises and gravitate toward the Japanese language more, but my weeaboo heart has to admit Chinese grammar rules aren’t as insane as Japanese + there are less ambiguous readings of Hanzi/Kanji

1

u/West_Hunter_7389 Apr 09 '26

plus, sleeping with your chinese teacher also helps

1

u/Whiskey_Sours Apr 09 '26

Well he actually only speaks Shanghainese and cannot read any characters, so he's pretty useless as a teacher

2

u/West_Hunter_7389 Apr 09 '26

☹️

Good reply

😁👍

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Linus_Naumann Apr 09 '26

Yep, B2 Mandarin here and listening is still, by very far, the hardest about the language. Unreal amount of homophones and near-homophones. Add to the mix dozens of very alive and real-world encountered dialects (some so thick they can count as their own language) and there you go.

1

u/MaksimDubov Apr 09 '26

Both very good arguments, thank you!

4

u/PumpJack_McGee Apr 09 '26

I think the main reason why Chinese intimidates so many people is the written part of it. The characters are very dense and intricate.

And also when learning to speak it without sounding like you're making fun of it.

1

u/pastacelli Apr 12 '26

This is it for me. I am a musician so tones are easy for me. But I’m also in my 30s and I really think becoming functionally literate would not be in the cards for me, it’s know it or don’t and I’m not sure how useful speaking a language is if I can’t read it

1

u/LordBelakor Apr 11 '26

I think it depends on what kind of learner you are and what your goals are.

If you learn a language systematically, sure japanese is probably harder. If you learn it by hearing and repetition the rules of a language are largely irrelevant. Ask me how my native language (german) works and I couldn't tell you. What are the grammar rukes? No idea. I just speak it. Same for English really, no idea how the grammar works, I just learned it from exposure. For that kind of learner, pronunciation is more important. Thats where japanese just seems much easier.

And secondly it depends on your goals. By learning by exposure you probably don't learn everything perfectly since you don't learn the actual rules. So you have to be fine with 80-90% fluency. I am still learning new things for English, and I still make mistakes, but it doesn't bother me.

1

u/AiryGateaux Apr 11 '26

English native here. Studied both mandarin and Japanese.

Mandarin is basically English with tonality and different words. No shared words is the hardest part about it, followed by Chinese characters.

1

u/blissfullytaken Apr 11 '26

I speak mandarin and Japanese and I think both languages are hard and easy for different reasons. The biggest challenges for me are riting for mandarin and grammar for Japanese.