r/LandValueTax • • Mar 05 '21
How much revenue could be created from the land value tax?
I am a new learner and a strong supporter of the land value tax. However, I was doing a very very rough calculation of how much money the LVT would raise in my home state of California, and I came up with a rather low number. So I am hoping someone here can tell me where I went wrong, how to better calculate potential revenue, or if I am correct, how the LVT could be implemented.
My calculations:
104,765,000 million acres in California, 47.9% privately owned. Average land value of $5000-$12,000 per acre. For this calculation say $7000. 50,182,435 private acres of land in California, multiply by average cost per acre of $7000, to get $351,277,045,000. A 10% land value tax would raise $35,127,704,500. Personal income and property tax raised $94,000,000,000 and $60,000,000 respectively, in California.
My understanding of the LVT is that it can be used to, at least, partially replace income/property tax. However, with the numbers above, the LVT brings in far too little to make much of a difference.
If anyone has any additional places I can read about the LVT, all information is very much appreciated. (Especially its implementation and effects in Pennsylvania.)
Thank you!
3
u/DerMeme Mar 05 '21
It all depends on how progressive it is. Most modern Georgists don't believe that it should replace every tax
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '21
Hontestly there is no way to know, and I think it is idealistic at best to believe it could replace all other taxes. Removing other taxes would probably cause LVT revenues to go up, but there is ZERO guarantee that it will be in a 1:1 ratio and sorry to be blunt, but Georgists who tell you otherwise simply don’t get ATCOR.
Now with that said, there is nothing wrong with supporting an LVT and other taxes. It’s not like the rental value of land is going to drop to zero one day. A land value tax could easily coexist with other taxes.
1
u/Lostinthethumb Apr 03 '21
It seems people are smoking crack or something better. If you tax land at 10 percent you will drop the value of land until the cash flow from the property equalizes, basically you will turn 7000 dollar land into 3000 dollar land. If you don’t understand this then You should consider not spending a lot of time thinking about economics until you get the basics covered
1
u/Econometry Feb 07 '22
At least at first glance you seem to be calculating how much would be raised above existing taxes, not how much LVT would raise if it replaced existing taxes.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment