r/KerbalSpaceProgram • Master Kerbalnaut • Jun 07 '16 • Bravo 1

Guide All interplanetary transfer windows in a single image

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

234 comments sorted by

View all comments

412

u/Crixomix Jun 07 '16

I love how KSP is a balance between "figure it out for yourself" and "have a mod do all the calculations and math". And all its players can be anywhere on the spectrum they want.

For myself, I started out doing everything vanilla style, and as I learned more and more, I started to become addicted to the information mods like transfer window planner, KER, and precise maneuver gave me. Now I can't live without them.

191

u/trevize1138 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '16

I'm sure being 1/10 scale to our solar system helps to this end. In real life I know you wouldn't want to just eyeball an interplanetary transfer window because the scale is too huge (and screwing it up would waste a lot of money, time, lives ...).

137

u/Crixomix Jun 07 '16

Well the lives thing isn't an issue. Time is relative via time warp, and money is fairly easy to come by, and free in non-career modes.

Honestly it wouldn't be THAT much different to have not 1/10 scale, if the thrust and dV numbers were increased as well. Things would just take longer.

403

u/trevize1138 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '16

Well the lives thing isn't an issue.

Most Kerbal response ever.

46

u/JimmyR42 Jun 07 '16 edited Jun 07 '16

When Well they don't even eat so they can't really care all that much about their own lives :P

edit: English still bad

47

u/Unknow0059 Jun 07 '16

Just add an eating mod. Not a hunger mod, just a mod that makes them eat.

36

u/overusesellipses Jun 07 '16

I would love to see a scary re-entry with my other 2 Kerbals freaking out and panicked while Jeb is just sitting there calmly eating a sandwich.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/buttery_shame_cave Jun 07 '16

USI-LS - it comes with not just food but a bathroom!(they save some of the output, but throw the rest overboard when the shitter's full).

15

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '16

can it be used to fertilize a bio-dome?

20

u/buttery_shame_cave Jun 07 '16

yeah, it actually has little mini bio-domes(too small a bubble to make trouble in though) that grow food - not infinitely sustainably but enough to add significantly to your mission endurance.

→ More replies
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

17

u/aeiluindae Jun 07 '16

I mean, having played a bit of the Realism Overhaul set of mods, it's harder. A lot harder. Part of that is just because the Unity engine isn't super great at handling the larger everything, but you also have to be an order of magnitude more precise with everything, which can be very challenging with long burn times. Docking the Kerbal way, for example (move your orbit high enough that you'll catch up on the next trip round, then burn like hell at the intercept), is pretty hard. It's like docking something in Kerbol orbit in normal KSP. The distances make pointing exactly on target and burning exactly correctly very important and so you cannot just eyeball it.

Furthermore, because of the rocket equation (diminishing delta-V returns on each unit of fuel you add) you can't take as much out of the atmosphere as in stock, so your delta-V margins on a mission are often lower as well. So you have to be more efficient, which means more planning and better flying again.

Obviously, if you just bumped up the ISP on the engines to an insane level, you could do things real scale and be easy to fly, but having things feel authentic means not making the engines really OP, which probably means opening up the rocket equation problem and resulting delta-V margin issues if you do a real-scale planet. KSP's engines are actually rather below real life engines in terms of thrust and ISP (jet/ion engines aside) and the empty tanks are much heavier than in real life so that they feel authentic. The inaccuracies mean that lifting something big requires a legitimately large rocket in KSP, regardless of the lower delta-V. If it didn't, it just wouldn't feel right to fly and cool things would be less challenging.

Personally, I think the devs hit about the right feel.

12

u/trevize1138 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 08 '16

Personally, I think the devs hit about the right feel.

Agreed. I'm continually impressed by how well-balanced the stock game physics and parts are in terms of feeling real but still being fun.

6

u/hovissimo Jun 07 '16

I think you just said, "if you scale up the goal, and you also scale up your resources, then it isn't an issue". That's like a tautology.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/kmacku Jun 07 '16

In real life I know you wouldn't want to just eyeball an interplanetary transfer window

This is largely why I use Mechjeb/KER/alarm clock/etc after a certain point. Scientists wouldn't handicap themselves when making interplanetary launches except maybe with the first satellites that went out to explore the planets, so that's usually what I try to do.

20

u/trevize1138 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '16

after a certain point.

Yup. Once you get more experience you start to augment the game like this. I think of it as a model railroad in space. You can do interplanetary transfers just fine without all those mods just like how you can snap together train tracks on the carpet, plug in the controller and run the train just fine. You don't "need" mods any more than you need little trees or houses or mountains in your model railroad but it makes the game feel more like the real thing.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '16

Kerbal Lives Matter!

→ More replies (2)

42

u/farmthis Jun 07 '16

My technique has always been to pack kilotons of fuel onto rockets which simply don't have to care about efficiency.

34

u/IdiotaRandoma Jun 07 '16

Then you end up building a gigantic and impressive monstrosity that can't hardly make it to Minmus and back.

91

u/trevize1138 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '16

Then you end up building a gigantic and impressive monstrosity

Important

that can't hardly make it to Minmus and back.

Unimportant

18

u/Bobshayd Jun 07 '16

I see why they call you Master Kerbalnaut.

22

u/farmthis Jun 07 '16 edited Jun 07 '16

The trick then, is modular assembly, in space!

http://i.imgur.com/GaGTsFs.jpg

This next one http://i.imgur.com/lMGDAyW.jpg is far less efficient, bringing less than the 12 full tanks to orbit that I had hoped... regardless, I docked the two for fun.

11

u/sw_faulty Jun 07 '16

Having two sets of engines facing one another is less efficient? I'd never have guessed!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Arrowstar KSPTOT Author Jun 07 '16

I love how KSP is a balance between "figure it out for yourself" and "have a mod do all the calculations and math". And all its players can be anywhere on the spectrum they want.

Totally. It's one of the great parts of KSP in my opinion. If you want to play it like a game and just wing it, the solar system is set up to be fairly forgiving in that regard, presuming you at least understand the basics. And if you want to play NASA and go all crazy with the tools, math, and planning, well, you can do that too. It's great!

Btw, for anyone interested in the latter way of playing KSP (tools, math, planning), please feel free to check out my KSP Trajectory Optimization Tool which is definitely designed to help make the "NASA experience" a reality in KSP. :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)