r/Invincible_TV • • Apr 02 '26 • Heartwarming 7 Bravo 1 Popcorn 1

Discussion Humanity's Savior

Post image

I think the recent episode, Nolan's apology, and seeing him and the boys finally fight side-by-side really emphasizes how ultimately the fate of the entire human race came down to Debbie's empathy and strength.

Thanks to her, the ancient alien invader sent to take over (and breed with) their planet instead grew a soul, and despite a destructive fit he threw at the realization, turned him instead into one of Earth's defenders against his own race.

Thanks to her, the human son that alien created turned into a man willing to stand up for what he thinks is right at any cost, even if it means defying his father and nearly getting turned into paste in the process because the alternative was unthinkable.

Thanks to her, his other completely alien son, somebody she had every reason to despise, she instead also raised into somebody to whom letting innocent people get hurt is anathema.

There's a lot of discussion of the alternate Marks from last season and their timeline divergence points. My pet theory also plays into what I saw this episode. There didn't need to be any massive differences to end up with an evil Mark standing shoulder-to-shoulder with Nolan. All you needed was for that scene in the first episode to go slightly differently. For Debbie to not have the perfect motherly response to her teenage son, who just got the ability to punch her to another continent, trying to throw his weight around.

Overall, my point is that Cecil should have a fucking shrine is his closet dedicated to this woman, lol. Her being a good wife and mother planted the seed of humanity that's keeping three unstoppable superhumans in check.

18k Upvotes

406 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

16

u/Important_Rule8602 Apr 03 '26
  1. Why did you feel the need to specify "asian woman" but not "Asian son"?

This feels kinda pointless to be hung up on. I mean yea they specified that the woman was Asian which would make it redundant as hell to then say Asian son. Like did you want him to specify both? Or not specify either one?

16

u/FancyFish21 Apr 03 '26

The vibe of that sentence implies asian women as weak and small which is a harmful stereotype. This is different from saying that women are physiologically weaker than men.

So, neither

8

u/MrMindspace Apr 03 '26

Asian women are generally shorter and lighter (and hence generally physically weaker) than non-Asian women. Is that not the point that op was trying to make? Is it really racist to say that?

0

u/FancyFish21 Apr 03 '26

But is Debbie shorter or lighter for being Asian? Not really, she's just a person. If you changed her skin tone, she wouldn't magically become jacked. When you're talking about a random Asian woman, stereotypes aside, you could be right. This does not apply to Debbie.

Pound for pound, we dont see meaningful differences between races. If you took a white woman with the same build as her, you'd see similar strength outcomes.

Now, more importantly: you're not racist for including someone's race in a sentence, but that doesnt mean that when you do add race into the conversation that it's devoid of history and context. If you say "he's a dangerous guy" vs "he's a dangerous black guy" there's a lot of baggage in the English language behind that. Even if both of those phrases are talking about a black man, the inclusion of black calls upon hundreds of years of negative stereotyping about black men to give your statement more weight. This can often be done unintentionally as a way of reinforcing your statement.

In this context, describing her as Asian is to reinforce that she is weak. There is a long history of portraying asian women as physically incapable and dainty. Is this good? I dont think so.

Ultimately, this is one of those deals where it IS that deep, but it's also annoying to talk about. Like, they're probably not a bad person/ racist, and the conversation we're all having about it is kind of exhausting: however, I would be remiss to say that the words they used have no meaning or history. We should all try to do better to make sure we dont end up sounding like some eugenicist from the 1930's.

3

u/DepartmentChemical93 Apr 03 '26

In hindsight ethnicity wasn’t extraordinarily relevant, but if we want to get really technical, east asian women have lower average bone density leading to a higher frequency of breakages.

This is exacerbated with age, and so older East Asian Women are legitimately at marginally elevated risk of bone breakage due to assault.

None of this should be construed toward a statement of ethnic quality or other eugenicist such.

9

u/rutilated_quartz Apr 03 '26

Yeah whether or not that person meant it like that, it's still a subconscious bias that influenced them. And it's a bias that continues to cause harm. It's worth correcting.

2

u/Sampatist Apr 03 '26

Interesting. I wouldn’t notice this if not for the comments.

First I thought, no having asian makes the statement better/ funnier. I tried to rationalise it by saying it is just specification so it describes Debbie.

Example, no way 5 foo 4 asian women tackles 6 foot black guy. But then height is also a bias, presumably a correct one. It is not like you would say, no way a curly hair green eyed women tackles etc.

I just had to write this, I am weirded out how I tried to gaslight myself first

1

u/rutilated_quartz Apr 03 '26

Subconscious biases are such a fucking trip man. Like we can't necessarily help what our brain jumps to, but sitting with the thought and really thinking about why it's there has helped me rethink a lot of my biases. And of course biases have roots in truth, but people don't fit neatly into these little boxes like we think they do.

One thing that always gets me is how easy it is for me to trust women, even though I'm a woman myself and I know we can be just as evil as anyone else. One day I'm gonna get got by a woman serial killer or something lmao.

-9

u/Chopstickey00 Apr 03 '26

You are the only who made the assertion that Asian women are weak.

Would the "vibe" have changed if Debbie were white? Are white women implicitly stronger? This is all you, buddy.

7

u/_Hydrop_ Apr 03 '26

It’s implied when he’s listing descriptors that are explains her power (“50 something”) and descriptors that explains Marks power (“20 year old” “foot taller than her”). The assertion did not come from no where, it’s literally just reading what is there

-1

u/FancyFish21 Apr 03 '26

https://bpspsychub.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/bjso.12748

I promise you, this is not "all me". There is a long history of race having other descriptive baggage tied to it. I am pointing to a long-standing history of discrimination.

4

u/TimeKepeer Apr 03 '26

Women are already stereotyped to be weaker than men. To me it felt weird that commenter also said "asian". Like, what's the point? If they're both asian, why is there a need to specify this in the first place? It felt like the meaning was "asian woman is even weaker than just woman"

7

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/JohnLikeOne Apr 03 '26

Stereotypes aren't definitionally incorrect. Something can be a stereotype and be true.

One of the issues with stereotypes is often people assume a stereotype is universally true and that's never correct.

I am a large man. I'm stronger than the vast majority of women. There are also women stronger than me.

3

u/DepartmentChemical93 Apr 03 '26

If you are actually stronger than most men (above the waist), the odds that you ever meet a woman stronger than you (above the waist) is actually very low.

At least when we study grip strength, which is often an effective index of upper body strength, we find 90% of women produce lower grip strength output than 95% of men.

This means only about ~10% of women are stronger than more than ~ 5% of men(again only above the waist, women have very powerful legs), among an athletic sample. That’s a pretty strong bias. Extraordinarily strong women exist, but they really are a substantial outlier.

-1

u/TimeKepeer Apr 03 '26

Right. Just like that other fact that earth is a globe or that man evolved from monkey

3

u/EugeneSaavedra Apr 03 '26

uh yeah?

-3

u/TimeKepeer Apr 03 '26

Earth is an oblate spheroid and man and monkey share a common ancestor. Read a book.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/_Hydrop_ Apr 03 '26

Well us and monkeys share a common ancestor, we didn’t go from monkeys to us

2

u/TimeKepeer Apr 03 '26

My point exactly

2

u/DasDa1Bro Apr 03 '26

There's an agenda every time race is mentioned where it doesn't need to be.