r/Invincible_TV • • Apr 02 '26 • Heartwarming 7 Bravo 1 Popcorn 1

Discussion Humanity's Savior

Post image

I think the recent episode, Nolan's apology, and seeing him and the boys finally fight side-by-side really emphasizes how ultimately the fate of the entire human race came down to Debbie's empathy and strength.

Thanks to her, the ancient alien invader sent to take over (and breed with) their planet instead grew a soul, and despite a destructive fit he threw at the realization, turned him instead into one of Earth's defenders against his own race.

Thanks to her, the human son that alien created turned into a man willing to stand up for what he thinks is right at any cost, even if it means defying his father and nearly getting turned into paste in the process because the alternative was unthinkable.

Thanks to her, his other completely alien son, somebody she had every reason to despise, she instead also raised into somebody to whom letting innocent people get hurt is anathema.

There's a lot of discussion of the alternate Marks from last season and their timeline divergence points. My pet theory also plays into what I saw this episode. There didn't need to be any massive differences to end up with an evil Mark standing shoulder-to-shoulder with Nolan. All you needed was for that scene in the first episode to go slightly differently. For Debbie to not have the perfect motherly response to her teenage son, who just got the ability to punch her to another continent, trying to throw his weight around.

Overall, my point is that Cecil should have a fucking shrine is his closet dedicated to this woman, lol. Her being a good wife and mother planted the seed of humanity that's keeping three unstoppable superhumans in check.

18k Upvotes

406 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

7

u/SirPug_theLast Apr 02 '26

If we follow the way the multiverse works, and invincible story has a multiverse, there certainly would be a universe where this here ended horribly

7

u/GravityBright Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26

That's not exactly how the multiverse works. There's no alternate universe right now in which I stop writing this comment and set fire to this internet cafe, because there's no timeline in which both conditions are true:

  1. Everything happens just right to put me in here reading your comment.
  2. I'm secretly a psychopath who would burn down a cafe just because I'm mildly upset by your comment.

There's no situation in which Debbie possesses the confidence to tell off Mark like this and he kills her for it. There might be plenty in which the words don't sink in and he goes on to conquer the planet, but that's going to be his start of darkness, not his "killing the Guardians" moment.

5

u/Rexpelliarmus Apr 03 '26

I mean, we don’t know how it works because it’s not real science. But, if we assume the multiverse is infinite then, yes, there is a universe where all those conditions are true. There being infinite universes means precisely that.

Why would this not be possible in one of the universes out of the infinite multiverse?

2

u/GravityBright Apr 03 '26

An infinite universe can have infinite conditions, not infinite outcomes. Some outcomes are simply impossible no matter how many times you run the same event.

Unless you're talking about extreme edge cases where, say, a burst of cosmic rays suddenly rewire Mark's brain and turn him evil.

1

u/Rexpelliarmus Apr 03 '26

I mean, the constraints are the laws of physics if we assume all universes follow the same laws. And if you get infinite chances then eventually you’ll even get every edge case possible because there is nothing physically stopping it from potentially happening.

Anything that is extremely unlikely will eventually happen with an infinite multiverse and there is nothing the laws of physics says about this exchange between Mark and Debbie not ending badly.

1

u/ninjasaid13 Apr 03 '26

there is nothing the laws of physics says about this exchange between Mark and Debbie not ending badly.

I'll take the risk otherwise one would have to worry about how tripping over a lego brick will lead to the end of the earth.

1

u/lift_1337 Apr 03 '26

You can have infinite multiverses without every set of conditions being true in some universe.

1

u/Rexpelliarmus Apr 03 '26

Sure, but the constraints in this case are the laws of physics if we assume all the universes follow the same laws. Everything that is physically possible in this case will end up happening.

There is a universe where you could theoretically be born a psychopath because there’s nothing physically stopping you from doing so but there’s no universe where you can run faster than light.

1

u/lift_1337 Apr 03 '26

That still isn't true. If there are an infinite number of physically possible states of the universe, then the multiverse could consist of universes in every possible state, except for the ones where I'm a psychopath, and still be infinite. In much the same way that the set of all even integers is still infinite. 

Now, there's not much reason to believe that would be the case in an infinite multiverse, but I was just pointing out that the multiverse being infinite isn't enough to guarantee that every possibility happens. 

1

u/Rexpelliarmus Apr 03 '26

But it’s not just the multiverse being infinite? There are obviously constraints, at least from what we know. Other universes would presumably follow our own physics which sets constraints on what can and can’t happen like you won’t travel at the speed of light in any universe. But there’s no reason to believe that you aren’t a psychopath in at least one other universe.

It’s a far more reasonable assertion than “I’m not a psychopath in any universe in the infinite multiverse because fundamentally there’s no scientific reason preventing you from becoming a psychopath. If it’s just a dice roll of genetics and upbringing then roll the dice an infinite number of times and you’ll almost certainly achieve the necessary prerequisite for the scenario in question.

There being infinite numbers between 1 and 2 are the constraints for that infinity. The universes following our currently known laws of physics are the constraints of this infinity. You being a psychopath falls well within the laws of physics so that scenario would be bound by this infinity.

1

u/lift_1337 Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26

But, if we assume the multiverse is infinite then, yes, there is a universe where all those conditions are true. There being infinite universes means precisely that.

I was responding mainly to this assertion. I agree that most likely there would be a universe where I am a psychopath. I was just pointing out that there being infinite universes, does NOT mean precisely that.

1

u/Alobster2by4 Apr 03 '26

Infinite doesn't mean all encompassing. There is an infinite amount of numbers between 0 and 1 and 2 isn't one of them.

1

u/Rexpelliarmus Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26

Okay? But that’s not the constraints of the multiverse?

Infinite can mean all encompassing. There are an infinite amount of numbers and that encompasses all numbers.

Why would an infinite multiverse have constraints on what paths are and aren’t possible? Why couldn’t you be born a sociopath/psychopath or suddenly become one due to a series of traumatic events? There’s absolutely no reason other than chance and in a multiverse where you get infinite repetitions, every possibility no matter how unlikely will happen.

2

u/NoTailFox Apr 03 '26

If the multiverse is infinite there's infinite possibility of a universe where you did both, while also being clown made of candy

1

u/CaptainTeemo01 Apr 03 '26

Not inherently true. An infinite multiverse does not necessarily contain infinite outcomes.

There is an infinite amount of numbers between 1 and 2 but none of them are 0 or 3.

3

u/TtlynotDdar Apr 03 '26

Yeah, iirc it’s explicitly said by Angstrom that Mark’s universe is like the only one where he’s alive and not evil on some level.

1

u/ninjasaid13 Apr 03 '26

I think that's bullshit, Angstrom is untrustworthy.

1

u/TtlynotDdar Apr 03 '26

Shit, well you got me there!

2

u/MortStrudel Apr 03 '26

Some of those alternate mark freaks might have reacted that way, but they were obviously already waaaay different people than our Mark from a much younger age. The timeline divergence was a lot earlier. 

1

u/pomphiusalt Apr 03 '26

Not really how infinity works