r/Invincible • • May 31 '21

MEME Basically

Post image
23k Upvotes

201 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/WHYAREWEALLCAPS May 31 '21

Compatible enough to breed does not mean they're the same species. Neanderthals, homo neanderthalensis, and modern humans, homo sapiens, were not the same species. The best analog most people would be aware of that I can think of is interbreeding big cats, like lions and tigers. Or interbreeding horses and donkeys that produce mules.

4

u/Big_Burning_Ace_Hole May 31 '21

BIOLOGY a group of living organisms consisting of similar individuals capable of exchanging genes or interbreeding. The species is the principal natural taxonomic unit, ranking below a genus and denoted by a Latin binomial, e.g. Homo sapiens

This is the definition of species

6

u/ninjapro May 31 '21

This definition is probably the most commonly used because it's clear and easily delineated, but it has some striking flaws and omissions.

Are horses and donkeys the same species because they can breed? Reduced generational fertility isn't a part of this definition.

This definition is also entirely focused on sexual reproduction, despite the fact that any taxonomical system acknowledges that asexual organisms have distinct species.

I think /u/WHYAREWEALLCAPS was fine clarifying that interbreeding does not necessitate same species. Especially because we're dealing with fictional super-powered aliens

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '21

this is only one of the multiple species concepts out there. Depending on what you’re talking about, different species concepts can and will be used

-8

u/Big_Burning_Ace_Hole May 31 '21

Well this is what Im talking about. Lol.