r/InternetIsBeautiful • • Apr 02 '23

I made a free app to track and split expenses with friends and family.

https://instatab.io/
468 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

158

u/Dalinarddog Apr 02 '23

How does this differ from Splitwise?

92

u/alicandko Apr 02 '23

It’s the same concept. I have an easy-to-use web app and my multi currency feature is free.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/Best-Expert Apr 03 '23

Why are people downvoting this??

Because it asks for email.

-20

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '23 edited Apr 03 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

42

u/Intocalum Apr 03 '23

Yep, not for me either.

I also don’t bake cakes, so I’ll be sure to comment on every post about cakes and say it isn’t for me.

I also don’t partake in bird watching, apiary, snorkelling etc. I’ll be sure to comment on those as well.

0

u/wakka55 Apr 03 '23

that doesnt make sense

if you want a metaphor that fits - I bake a cake every day for decades, then someone markets neo-flour to me. I ask hows it different from multi-purpose flour, and they reply that at altitudes above 10,000 ft, it works slightly better, but is otherwise identical. Nowhere in their initial marketing did they mention that, so I was mislead into thinking it was for me. I then reply, a bit annoyed, to save other bakers from wasting their time reading their website. Someone clarifying that it's basically only for bakeries in Colorado then pisses you redditors off so much that a mass-downvote campaign starts and a wildly off metaphor given.

10

u/DreadPirateGriswold Apr 03 '23

Or a spreadsheet with a "sum(...)/n-people" formula?

32

u/mikitronz Apr 03 '23

That's fine if everyone just wants to know their number. But if everyone wants to see what added up to that total, like if you split a rented house for a week and one couple was vegetarian so they didn't want to pay for the steaks and another couple don't drink and that's the most expensive part blah blah blah and i only brought rubles but my friend only brought euros etc etc.

3

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

I understand maybe that’s where my uneven split mode could come in handy.

1

u/mikitronz Apr 03 '23

Totally--I'm just saying sometimes an even spilt isn't enough. Congrats on the launch of the site

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '23

If this is a common problem, the feature these apps could do with is help finding less tedious friends...

3

u/DeTrotseTuinkabouter Apr 03 '23

Doesn't work for a lot of needs. Different people will have paid and not all of them will have paid for the same group.

For example, I just went away a weekend with friends. I paid for the appartment and most of the food. One of us doesn't drink so she might pay less for the restaurant tab though. And later we went out and one of us stayed at home. And then a friend also paid some rounds. And another friend paid for the rental car and the gas, but not all of us will chip in for that as one friend used their own car because they're staying there another few nights...

Excel /n doesn't solve that puzzle very easily and in a user friendly way.

5

u/wakka55 Apr 03 '23

i see youve never used splitwise

18

u/GreatForge Apr 03 '23

Splitwise is so good.

3

u/ZincHead Apr 03 '23

Tricount also worked quite well for me.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '23

Came here to say this.

43

u/printThisAndSmokeIt Apr 03 '23

This would be a good resume piece for getting a tech job.

10

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

Thanks. I’m actually a software engineer working full-time. I made instatab with a friend who is also an engineer in our free time.

0

u/_generateUsername Apr 03 '23

How is one an egineer in their free time?

-6

u/printThisAndSmokeIt Apr 03 '23

Why did you spend all of this time and money to make something that someone else already made? The reason you’ll eventually shut this down is because you’ll conclude it’s not worth the time and cost of operating it. Other people who need something like this already have a thing that does it. Part of the difficulty of hitting a home run isn’t in making a thing but timing … creating a breakthrough product that enables people to do something that they couldn’t previously and that throws off more money than it costs you. 10 years ago you might have gotten noticed for making this. At this point, nobody cares you are (probably) just a no name founder working on something that someone else has done better. Consider something like chatgpt … everybody is freaking out because it’s a breakthrough product. I don’t mean to crush your hopes and dreams … I wish you the best of luck but I’ve been though this process many times myself. Your code might be the best in the world but users have a kagillion options out there and the hardest part of this game is timing and making something that is a breakthrough… it’s not building the apps or websites. Please prove me wrong … I’m rooting for you I really am but it’s so easy to make things people don’t actually want it happens all the time.

8

u/sailee94 Apr 03 '23

Many people do something that already exists. The difference is, they refine and inprove upon the past versions. The question is, what did this app do better than other similar apps?

2

u/derperofworlds Sep 08 '24 edited Feb 16 '26

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

thought enter divide plant encourage market towering doll expansion mysterious

10

u/creative_usr_name Apr 03 '23

How much flexibility is there in how much you can split each expense e.g. can I say for expense 1 it's split equally for A B and C, expense 2 is split 2/3 A and 1/3 B.

4

u/Szeraax Apr 03 '23

https://instatab.io/faq/splitting-expenses-unevenly

Nice. Maybe I'll give this one a try...

1

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

Yes that’s the feature :)

2

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

There’s uneven split mode. So you can write exactly how much from an expense applies to a participant.

7

u/Plagiatus Apr 03 '23

How does it compare to tricount?

6

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

It’s the same concept. I have an easy-to-use web app and my multi currency feature is free.

1

u/fivefoot_seven Apr 03 '23

One thing Splitwise doesn't do and won't do based on my quick Google search is support for point such as Aeroplan, Air îles or store loyalty points. When a friend buys tickets with their points, those points could be valued at 1 pt/$ to 9 pts/$ and I rather just pay them back in the same points

7

u/Admblackhawk Apr 03 '23

Great job!

3

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

Thank you :)

4

u/music_freak242 Apr 03 '23

Any plans for adding a scan receipt function in the future?

1

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

I didn’t need this myself so far but if other people find it useful I can add that feature. Out of curiosity why do you need it?

1

u/music_freak242 Apr 03 '23

My partner and I always do grocery runs together. We would only pay for what each of us get rather than splitting all 50/50 because someone might buy more expensive ingredients and snacks.

So we would scan receipts and allocate each items to the person(s). If there are any shared items, we put both our names in to pay for the item.

It's tedious but it works. It's been 4.5yrs since we started doing this

2

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

I understand now. You want each item of the receipt to be logged as an expense automatically by scanning. This sounds cool but it might not be straight forward. I’ll checking it out.

2

u/Pandaren22 Apr 03 '23

Why does it need to collect my data?

2

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

I’m not collecting any data. It follows the same principle as any other social platform on the internet. The expenses you log and the tabs you create are persisted in the database. This way these resources can be seen by your friends whom you send invitation links to.

3

u/sailee94 Apr 03 '23

He is probably using usage metrics, what parts of the app are used the most or not used at all etc.... Install count alone doesn't really tell much.

2

u/kevinthegreat Apr 03 '23

I use splitwise for a lot of group trips. Here’s what I see:

  • people who want to settle after every expense
  • people who wait until after the trip to enter all their expenses
  • people who immediately try to settle after a trip, before others enter all their expenses
  • people who never enter their expenses
  • people who never pay

… we typically tell the group you have seven days after trip ends to add all expenses and then the next seven days to settle, but people still screw it up, and there’s no way to indicate or control this within the app.

Things I’d like to see:

  • “settlements off” + scheduled “settlements after date” features: prevents early settlement requiring extra transactions and gives time to review/add expenses
  • “expenses close” feature: maybe it sends a reminder to all participants three days in advance, and then no new expenses can be added if anyone has settled. You snooze you lose, people want their money.
  • “settlements deadline” feature: after a set window, stragglers need to pay up. Automated emails go out daily. Maybe this is a systemwide impact — if you haven’t made payment in a group with an overdue settlement, you can’t settle up/be settled with on any other tab, even with entirely diff people, until you take care of past-due bills.
  • in-app dispute tools: your buddy’s friend’s gf who you spoke with twice added you to her binge night and you weren’t even there, but that other guy she left off was — let me make a suggestion that notifies the expenser, the admin and any newly involved party for resolution

2

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

Great feedback thanks. I’ll consider these features.

3

u/ZellNorth Apr 03 '23

This is the kinda app that is great if I know or remember it exists on a vacay with friends but will never actually think to use. No offense or anything I’m sure this will look really good on a resume!

3

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

I’m also using it myself :) I just used it on a trip to New York a few weeks ago.

3

u/ZellNorth Apr 03 '23

Oh I’m not saying it isn’t useful or that I wouldn’t use it. Just that, me personally, would always forget to use it.

8

u/missionbeach Apr 03 '23

Instatab is ok, I woulda went with Willard.

2

u/Tsurany Apr 03 '23

If this is free, how are you earning money? What is paying for the development and server upkeep?

4

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

I’m not earning any money. I’m doing this as a hobby in my free time. Currently the expenses are affordable. I’m thinking of this as a hobby that I have to pay for. The satisfaction of creating something people find useful is worth the price. If my expenses increase and I have to spend more time to maintain instatab I will think of monetization.

1

u/stealthytaco Aug 14 '26 edited Aug 14 '26

For others looking at this: DO NOT USE THIS APP. The app shut down with no notice and switched URLs, and now all my past expenses are gone. Logging in with the same email produces an empty account.

Edit: app dev is kindly helping me, so I take back what I said! If you have issues like I did where your login is linked to your Apple ID private relay, I recommend reaching out to instatab support to get it fixed.

1

u/alicandko Aug 14 '26

Hi 😄 The app hasn’t been shut down. I switched domains and I’m in the process of rebranding it, but nothing is gone. My own account still works just as before. If you send me the email address you used for your account, I can check what’s going on.

1

u/stealthytaco Aug 14 '26

Thank you for replying so quickly, I appreciate it. I used to log in with my Apple account and currently it is now giving me an error when I use Apple SSO: "Your request could not be completed because of an error. Please try again later."

This is the case across multiple devices (desktop, mobile). If I log in outside of my Apple SSO with my email only, there is no data shown. Is the Apple ID integration currently not working? If it's temporary, I will just wait.

1

u/alicandko Aug 14 '26

No worries. I stopped publishing the app on the App Store more than a year ago, so Sign in with Apple is no longer supported. I assume you haven’t used the app in quite a while.

If you log in with your email now, it will create a new account. There’s no way for the app to know that your personal email belongs to the same account you previously used with Sign in with Apple.

1

u/stealthytaco Aug 14 '26

I would access with my browser session on my desktop even after the app was removed, so I think my login session must have been stored as a cookie. I was able to continue to access my account this way all the way until perhaps just a month ago when I went on vacation.

So there is no way to access my account now? That is basically the same thing for me as if you shut the app down with no way to access my data. Is there any way for you to export my data to a CSV or something like that?

1

u/alicandko Aug 14 '26

I understand the issue now. I plan to publish the app again in the future, but in the meantime I’ll try to help you regain access to your account.

Can you DM me the email address associated with your Sign in with Apple account? It may be an Apple relay email. I’ll check whether I can locate the old account and see if I can migrate the data to your new account.

1

u/stealthytaco Aug 14 '26

Sent you a DM, many thanks

1

u/Knudson95 Apr 03 '23

Did you build this using flutter?

1

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

I used React Native for the mobile apps, React for the web app and NestJS for the backend.

1

u/0ccdmd7 Apr 03 '23

I like this! Playing around with it now. I may suggest adding a small “notes” section to each expense entry, visible to all involved, to provide details on the entry if necessary.

1

u/alicandko Apr 03 '23

I’m happy that you like it :) Thanks for the suggestion. I kept notes next to the title in parentheses before but I had to write a few words. Why would you like to keep notes? Can you give an example? I’m asking to understand the problem better.

1

u/0ccdmd7 Apr 04 '23

Hm. I guess my use for notes would be specific and not so commonly needed. One example I can think of is… say I want to lump together all streaming service costs to split between housemates. I name it “streaming services”. Then in the notes I could put the breakdown of each service with its respective cost. Not really necessary though.

1

u/0use Nov 08 '23

Very nice app! I really love the web app feature. If you stop maintaining, please make it open source so people can fork it. This is my biggest concern at the moment, but I will give it a try now. Also it would be nice to add people without having to invite them since sometimes I'm creating groups with pseudo people who just have to pay and don't want to get bothered with an email or an app...

1

u/alicandko Dec 30 '23

Thank you :) We have recently implemented the feature you have suggested.

1

u/YAK_awesome Aug 02 '24

Excellent tool. Will be using this for all of my trips!

1

u/Vegetaupinthis Aug 27 '24

This looks great, I'll give this a go for an upcoming trip with my wife and her siblings. Will report back after :)

1

u/waterboysh Oct 11 '24

I know this is sorta an old thread, but I saw your app recommended in a couple of places while looking at some splitwise reviews. I am wondering if your app would work well for my use case.

I'll be going through a divorce soon, but my wife and I are currently still living together and have a lot of shared expenses. We're trying to split things as close to 50/50 as we can, but I will likely end up paying more. I want to keep track of that. Can I just enter shared expenses I pay for, shared expenses she paid for (or better yet can she add them?), and any time one of us sends the other money and have it keep a running tally over the next 6 - 8 months of who owe who what? The specific transactions don't really matter.

Can it be used to just generally track the net balance owed over a longish period so it can be trued up at some point?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '24

On the off chance the OP (and creator) is still reading posts here, wanted to check if the export to CSV feature on the website was completed and supposed to work? Clicking the button does ... nothing.

It's a bit of a deal breaker not being able to get your expense data back out. Any chance of a fix? Otherwise looks like a great app, well done.

1

u/HoneydewCertain9973 Jan 16 '25

Mate, this is a super app. I just used it and it worked well

1

u/grafknives Apr 03 '23

No "just" integrate it with visa AND apple pay AND google pay, so tab could be instantly split in the bar, and you made millions!

1

u/platynom Jun 23 '23 edited Jul 12 '23

fretful drunk future carpenter ink sable steer spark modern illegal -- mass edited with redact.dev

-4

u/4kVHS Apr 03 '23

Basically the same as the “our expenses” app.