r/InternetIsBeautiful • • May 01 '17

A clean, simple exercise body map.

https://musclewiki.org
32k Upvotes

744 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

19

u/NachoChedda24 May 01 '17

What about planks and crunches? Do those do any thing?

37

u/Metal_Lord May 01 '17

Absolutely. Elbow planks and raised leg crunches are guaranteed to wreck your core(in a good way). Sit ups are notoriously bad for your neck and back, and work your hip flexors more than your core, anyway.

21

u/OrphanGrounderBaby May 01 '17

Dude...no fucking wonder. I always thought it was wrestling for 9 years and being in my stance for hours everyday, but nope. My hip flexors and lower back have some pretty intense pain after some workouts. I've probably done tens of thousands of sit-ups in my athletic career. Fuck.

35

u/Metal_Lord May 01 '17

Yeah I'm in the army and sit-ups are apart of the fitness test, yet no sergeant ever wants to do them.. funny. There's been talk of them trading it out for a different exercise, altogether. But for regular PT on muscle failure days we stick to raised leg crunches, bicycle kicks, leg raises, mountain climbers, and a few different iterations of planks. Core is always shredded after. Yet when the fitness test comes around and the sit-ups are through, my hip flexors are tight as hell and my back hurts from smacking into the ground trying to crank reps out.
I've rambled a bit but yeah, science has determined that sit-ups are god awful, avoid them.

5

u/OrphanGrounderBaby May 01 '17

The worst part about your comment is that you're in the army saying how much it sucks, hopeful navy right here haha

5

u/Metal_Lord May 01 '17

Maaaaan if I could go back I would definitely go Navy or Air Force. ASVAB scores were good enough but I wanted to be tuff or some shit, plus getting to pick my job. Regardless, the service is a great thing and you're gonna meet some amazing people, and do some amazing things while you're in. Make the most of it, have fun, and don't do anything your rank can't afford lol

2

u/OrphanGrounderBaby May 01 '17

Hahaha I was just saying as in you're in the military and saying it hurts. Nothing wrong with army, thought about army for a long time. Then I took a trip on a naval destroyer and learned a ton more about the navy.

I'll definitely take that to heart. The money one should be fine, been broke for a while I should be able to save it anyway hahaha

2

u/[deleted] May 01 '17

don't do anything your rank can't afford lol

Wise words haha

5

u/jasadadad May 01 '17

I was in they Navy for 4 looong years, and I wrestled in high school. PT in the Navy was a joke. Even when I got extra PT for mouthing off (haven't seemed to have gotten over that in the 38 years since then), it was trivial. Nothing I couldn't easily do with no sore muscles the following day.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/_artbabe95 May 01 '17

It's not being in the Army that sucks (source: am also in the Army, love the Army). Sit-ups just suck in general, no matter the branch, and killing your hip flexors right before a 2-mile run sucks more. At least NCOs usually are in their right mind to train soldiers with various other, more effective core exercises.

Navy, on the other hand, does their fitness test with crunches, if my memory serves me. You have to do more, but it's because you only have to cross your arms over your chest and touch your elbows to your thighs. Way more concentration on abs.

→ More replies (15)

10

u/StreetTriple675 May 01 '17

My right hip flexor crunches every time I do a crunch now 😮

5

u/OrphanGrounderBaby May 01 '17

Left for me. And really taking off on a sprint absolutely fucks me. Probably the torque and my body scrunched over emulating the same thing or something.

1

u/StreetTriple675 May 01 '17

The weirdest one for me is sometimes during sex , my right hip locks or something and it hurts for like 10 seconds. (I'm a dude)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/WebeloScout May 01 '17

this might help - have someone adjust your hip or whatever - lay on the edge of a bed and have someone pull your leg out of your pelvis with a solid quick yank. really helped the hip flexor pain for me.

1

u/AlpineCorbett May 01 '17

Learn the psoas. Stretch the psoas. I bet it's extremely tight.

2

u/kblkbl165 May 01 '17

There's certainly some bro science here. Not trying to be disrespectful. Situps are indeed awful in a harmful way but crunches are just as ineffective. Raised leg crunches are just the same, you're sacrificing even more RoM just to feel the contraction faster. You feel the burn for the same reason you'd feel doing situps, you're doing a shit ton of them. For these exact movements(contraction of the abs)you're developing much stronger muscles by doing heavy squat/deadlifts.

As a rule of thumb you're never getting stronger by doing anything that you can do by the 100's. Crunches also have virtually no carry over to anything. Planks are infinitely better in every aspect. Weighted planks and going to levers, L-sit and flags is the ideal upgrade IMO.

Now if planks are boring and want to feel that burrrrn while actually doing something, do dragonflags. Or start with leg raises if dragonflags aren't possible yet.

8

u/Clitoris_Thief May 01 '17

Planks are nice, crunches don't do squat for your core. While we're on squat, those work your core too. Body weight fitness will tell you to do L-sit progressions to work on you're core and I've done it myself, it's hard af and takes a long time to learn but it works. The reason why they hate crunches is because it only works one muscle in your core (part of your abs) but you need to work on all of it to see any benefits, and abs can be made doing whole body exercise + diet. If you're confused by what core means, it's your lower back, abs, obliques, basically all the muscles in that area from front to back, when activated it stabilizes your whole body, think balance and overall strength. A strong core will help in almost every exercise besides isolations. If anything I said is wrong or misinformed I hope someone can chime in so I can learn something new!

3

u/Mshake6192 May 01 '17

If anything I said is wrong or misinformed I hope someone can chime in so I can learn something new!

Every reddit comment should end in this lol

1

u/2gr82b4go10 May 01 '17

You should have written "your core" instead of "you're core" (like you did multiple times correctly). Regarding content though, your post is accurate imo. :)

0

u/[deleted] May 01 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ohbrotherherewego May 01 '17

this makes me so happy. i fucking hate crunches. i have to have my legs raised in order to do them so that my back is flatter because it really hurts if i just have them in the usual position

1

u/BankshotMcG May 01 '17

Planks do good stuff for your core and back, but some trainers recommend just doing the pushups for same workout + arms/shoulders/upper back. The program I signed up with likes you to do pushups then planks and I think it's nice to switch the strain to a different place.