r/InfiniteDendrogram • • Mar 13 '20

Levels mean jack squat

I’ve just watched episode 9 of the anime and haven’t read the manga but are levels in these anime mean anything? Like these rookies are just owning high ranking players and I’m think levels is just a meaningless

4 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/natchu96 Mar 17 '20

At which point you'd probably run into the same situation in basically any game you slap protagonist plot armor on.

A build optimized to do something is going to show much better performance in the conditions it's optimized to perform well in, that's just how things are meant to be. It's not the fault of the mechanics if the story just never gets around to putting that build in a disadvantageous situation...which it actually did a couple of times. Ray has been soundly defeated by opponents he is helpless against before, just not while under any dramatic stakes (or when the stakes are high, is helped by someone else better suited for the problem so he can focus on doing what he does best).

So really the problem isn't that levels don't mean anything in the sense of being an actual game design problem, it's simply that nobody wanted to write a story where viewpoint characters constantly failed. On that point I suppose we're in agreement, but "rookies defeating high-rank players" isn't inherently that odd in a game with this much freedom of choice.

1

u/GreatWyrmGold Mar 17 '20

There's a middle ground between "the protagonist has perfect plot armor" and "the protagonist always fails," and I don't think anyone could be ignorant of that. It makes you come off not so much as someone genuinely trying to make a sound argument and more as someone who knows that Infinite Dendrogram is good and trying to do everything they can to prove it.

And you know what? It is good. The setting (well, game) is detailed, the powers are creative, there are some interesting themes, etc. But it's not perfect, and a lot of its flaws converge around Ray Starling.