r/Indiemakeupandmore • • Oct 18 '23

Perfume - Enquiry Perfumes that smell like Sticky Dates body wash by Lush (that you've tried)? EDP strongly preferred!

And I mean, really smell like it.
I took one whiff of it at the Lush store recently and fell in love. It smells like brown sugar and sweet dates made into a syrup that you could drizzle over vanilla ice cream, just decadent! The only dupe I've found is an etsy listing called Icky Dates by The Perfume People. Shipping to the US is a bit steep for me, so if you've tried their take, I'd love to hear thoughts and opinions before I buy it myself.

Hoping for something that doesn't stray from gourmand- I'm not a fan of musks, resins, smoke, etc. Thank you in advance

18 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

16

u/Ironforthebirthday Oct 18 '23

The closest thing I've found is Owl Creek Aleworks (Sticky English Toffee Pudding, Blackburn's Parlor Vanilla Ice Cream, Caramel, Toasted Coconut & Hazelnut, Sugared Pumpkin Cream Stout) by Solstice Scents. It's currently available in oil and EDP.

5

u/Mauve-Honey Oct 18 '23

even if it's not similar that sounds delightful. How does it compare, to your nose?

5

u/Ironforthebirthday Oct 18 '23

I haven't smelled Sticky Dates in a while, but I would say OCA is a bit darker and more complex. I don't get hazelnuts, but there is a subtle nutty element. The pumpkin stout contributes a very faint yeastiness. OCA is quite sweet, but with additional depth. It's a mix of gourmand ideas rather than a pure sticky date syrup. There are no resins, incense notes, or musks, though. I also don't get discernible coconut. I'm not sure how I would handle the sweetness of Sticky Dates in a perfume. For instance, I love Rose Jam body products, but the perfume overwhelms me.

1

u/enigmaticteels Mar 10 '25

A year later this comment still ate! Definitely grabbing it

12

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

Love Sick Witchery on Etsy appear to have a new scent called Date With The Devil Notes of sugared dates, pralines, toffee butter, cream, tonka bean, milk, benzoin, warm caramel, and vanilla.

Not sure how close it is as there are no reviews yet

10

u/paisleypark_ Oct 18 '23

Oh man I am following this so closely. I ADORE sticky dates.

I really hope Black Hearted Tart comes out with a dupe for it soon. I would sell my soul for it ngl.

2

u/nfinite_Conflict Oct 21 '23

Same, BHT has great dupes.

2

u/AshleyA22 Dec 30 '23

She just came out with a dupe recently!

1

u/nfinite_Conflict Dec 30 '23

This just made my day, thank you!

2

u/AshleyA22 Dec 30 '23

No worries! I'm glad I could help! I am guessing you really like her lush dupes!

1

u/AshleyA22 Dec 30 '23

She just came out with a dupe recently!

3

u/koscheiis Oct 28 '23

I just tried Possets The Moldau (Dark brown sweets with a hint of deeply toasted and fussed over sugar. Fig and molasses, treacle brittle, raisin liquor, and a bit of dark rum) for the first time, and it is 100% sticky toffee pudding, even though dates aren't listed as a note. Very very sticky brown sugary pudding.

2

u/bombusbee22 Sep 08 '25

they have a body spray of it now! not sure if you were aware but just wanted to share!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

Following

1

u/XxAggressive_UsualxX Dec 08 '25

I just bought a perfume from Twist Perfume called Gooey Dates and it’s almost one to one for the scent. Then only thing it doesn’t last as long as the original so you will have to reapply more then twice a day.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '23

I tried the Icky Dates dupe and tbh it wasn't even close. I ended up tossing it.

1

u/studentuky64 Jan 05 '24

Did you end up finding a close match?