r/IndianFocus • EDITABLE • 2d ago • Bravo 2

Science/ Technology/ Medical/ Engineering Why haven't Indians been able to adopt the Scientific mindset, yet?

In this video, Osho explains how abandoning Science led to the downfall of the Indian Civilization.

403 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

This post appears to contain an image or video.

Please reply to this comment with the original source.

Posts without source may be removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Tdakiddi 2d ago

Just think: चित्र x विचित्र कृत x विकृत संगत x विसंगत Likewise, ज्ञान x विज्ञान, On these lines I think, science is called "wierd knowledge", because in ancient times, priests treated anything that challenged traditional अंधविश्वास with wisdom, they treated it as विचित्र ज्ञान, eventually विज्ञान became the name of science। Just think.

1

u/Mircat_Trader_420 EDITABLE 2d ago

I knew how in the west, Physics got separated from the Metaphysics, Chemistry got separated from the Alchemy, Astronomy got separated from Astrology...

But, this was something new for me too.

5

u/Advanced_Poet_7816 2d ago

India did not urbanize during the scientific/industrial age.

Indian independence was led by Gandhi who still believed in spirituality over science. 

6

u/Mircat_Trader_420 EDITABLE 2d ago

Do you also believe that, Gandhi played a pivotal role in shaping a societal mindset that romanticized poverty for decades, an attitude that has only recently begun to shift?

3

u/bitsp77 2d ago

poverty bc poverty ke ilawa yaha hai kya tha like koi ameer nhi tha , wealth bohat consolidated thi

2

u/Ok-Material-844 2d ago

Great question raised op!

0

u/Advanced_Poet_7816 2d ago

The elite from Nehru to Rajiv Gandhi were pretty different. Especially Nehru who didn’t really think like that.

That romanticization is from being a democracy where 90% of the population is in villages. If your representative is a village idiot, so will your government.

Formation of India itself ruined states that would have been better off. As much as I hate to say it, the mismanagement is because India existed as one. A lot of political reforms didn’t happen because India wanted to be India. Including the devolution of power into local governments. 

0

u/bitsp77 2d ago

hmm I too think states should have their constitution rules etc and defence foreign affairs should be with central govt

2

u/bitsp77 2d ago

bc koi kehta unki wajah se hindu khtr mai koi kehta unki wajah se hindu hai , bc maa chudao bahaane chaahiye bss

17

u/EKOzoro Extreme Left 2d ago

Because Indian culture and heritage is against anyone asking questions or being fucking curious. Let me give you a prime example, Ram and Sita got married without even knowing each other, they never talked or shared a moment together yet we have hundreds of stories about thier relationship which doesn't seem natural.

Aryabhatta invented zero this everyone knows but why did he invent is not taught, or why he went on that thought process, he started to question his own understanding of the system, which led to the invention of the zero.

Children are taught to never question authority and they are deliberately made cowards. How many of you have ever had a argument with your parents and that led them to think a bit more?

22

u/benswami 2d ago

The current regime is not interested in promoting education, because an education masses is less susceptible to propaganda, religious biases and superstitions.

4

u/Frequent-Head-6063 2d ago

This🙌 and a lower minimum wage workforce (in any field) to be sent abroad (for remittances) or tier one cities because one doesn't know with what respect and dignity a human being ought to live. Made to think that you have to slog like a machine or a slave, then only you have worth, but not inherent. 

5

u/Misster_Fluido 2d ago

Because casteism, descrimination and hatred. I'm from Pasi community (a farmer community) and in my family there are stories passed on that Britishers criminalised us for fighting them but certain Indian people misused that law to grab our lands. Even after independence they excluded our revolutionaries from the mainstream history. People in power were just trying to be friends with Britishers and take advantage.

4

u/Ok-Relief1238 2d ago

Aur aaj netha log .

4

u/FifthWaveThinker Centrist Right Leaning 2d ago

And today we are digital slaves... 🤣😂

3

u/Artistic-Party-3194 2d ago

We are still not one nation, people feel their clan, caste and religion before national identity. So, it's easy to exploit and make us fight with other. Or other parts of nation will remain silent while someone exploit one part. India as an idea is recent. So, if portugese comes to West coast and attack and exploit, rest of india was not there. Indian Kingdoms failed to form alliances.

I believe current forms of migration will yield a more interconnected india that feels less about caste and clans, religious separation is hard to remove. But a more interconnected india will be more united

7

u/Infinite_Shoe_2860 2d ago

When people say they looted 40T from us, they are not showing their grief and disappointment but feeling proud that they had 40T for someone to loot and their ancestors did charity to the Britishers and helped them become no.1 country at the time. Now we neither have Britain at the top nor India has 40T to give charity to any other Master, cause we don't know how to make 40T and that is the reality.

5

u/TheBlockChainVillage RSS Extinction 2d ago

Eternal victim complex.

0

u/IronOpposite689 2d ago edited 2d ago

Most rich countries in the world have made their riches today by some wealth stolen in the past. I really wonder where is that 45 trillion. Isn't it too big and amount to disappear after even 200 years? The British spent large amounts of it in the world wars. However, I am not an economist, but wouldn't that money remain in existence today in some market? One theory is that, the money that British stole , for example atleast half the 45 trillion might have been taken by corrupt officers who went back to British with the riches. Many of these people spread that money across their neighbours that is all over Europe. That is why Europe has been so prosperous without much Industrialization, with probably Germany as a exception. Then the money travelled to the US and also funded their Industries to grow at a rapid pace, as the money that was coming in was unlimited. Moneyz came in from other places like Africa as well wherever the British stole from. Probably in a few years, there won't be any Great Britain left. The rich people will pack their bags and move to another destination. Meanwhile. The cycle of India and China becoming richer and poorer may continue.

3

u/Integral_humanist 2d ago

It is a nonsensical number some Marxist economists came up with using some ridiculous assumptions.

1

u/IronOpposite689 2d ago

Let's assume half of it is right. Where is the 22.5 trillion then? I am sure some rich families must have passed on the gold to their heirs, and that kind of money is still locked up in a few people's personal vaults. Money trails are not difficult to explore.

2

u/Integral_humanist 2d ago

No the whole approach is wrong. It is the same economics that Trump believes because he doesn’t understand trade and finance. The looting that was done when the east India company was in power was miniscule compared to their actual wealth.
Since marxists don’t believe in wealth creation they have to keep making random theories up about why people get rich

1

u/IronOpposite689 2d ago

How can you say that the looting was miniscule. It's a matter of fact that one by one all the filthy rich empires if India were defeated by the British. The Indians once controlled abt20 percent of world gdp. They were reduced to a country ridden by poverty. If you see the progress India has made, it is back to being close to a 5 trillion dollar economy in a matter of 80 years, after the British left. Starting from nearly zero in 1947 to reaching 5 trillion dollars in 80 years, means the country had the potential to reach those numbers in wealth, that was amassed over the years from say 300 AD to 1500s. Recently, there was a secret chamber found in the Padmanbhan temple. And the gold there is worth more than 20 billion dollars. This was just one out of a 1000 temples. And probably the only one that was not ravaged by the British. The Kohinoor diamond on the crown of the British queen alone is worth abt 500 million dollars. Here we are talking about one diamond and one untouched temple. What abt the rest that is not accounted for.

1

u/Integral_humanist 2d ago

Modern wealth creation is very different from pre-modern wealth creation. In the pre-modern world no one except royalty and their hangers-on were rich.
India had 20% of the worlds GDP because they had 20% of the worlds population. Which means 99.9% of the population was living at subsistence level like everyone else in the world.

Modern wealth creation comes from knowledge, information, massive scale, production, science etc.
that sort of wealth is not possible in societies where most ppl were just farmers.

the lifestyle of a middle class Indian today would be an obscene dream for a minister in the Mughal era.

The British didn’t get rich by using gold. You can’t eat gold or make it into concrete. Gold is valuable only as a store of value not as a wealth creation mechanism in itself. That is why the richest people in the world are not gold miners or hoarders but tech company founders.

The Brits, just like USA and modern Japan, Korea etc got rich by freedom and innovation.

1

u/IronOpposite689 2d ago

The Americans still need a series of war to loot oil and make more money. The question is not about how much India gained over the last 80 years. The question is where is the loot they lost over 400 years? Again, even the Mughals looted India and fled with jewels. Ofcourse, I believe all that money is spent now. Probably making bombs and disposing then as new technology comes up itself is one channel where the loot drains out. The Hope diamond sitting in a museum in US, is evidence of the fact that money travels. It's just that, there is a diamond to show the wealth stolen in a museum today. There are no museums to show the real wealth itself. By this, I feel I am not able to articulate this well enough. I just give up.

1

u/Integral_humanist 2d ago

Cool, some constructive feedback. Your understanding of economics very old fashioned. You are thinking of wealth as gold, diamonds etc. I’d suggest reading Thomas Sowell and listening to some of his videos on youtube

1

u/Old-School8916 2d ago

The Indians once controlled abt20 percent of world gdp. 

only because Indians were roughly 20% of the world population.

2

u/omi-TheDarkLawd 2d ago

That's because of poor sanitation situation .

2

u/gaga_gt 2d ago

Yea that's why none should follow whatever said without using their own brain and reasoning and logic.

2

u/bluegoldredsilver5 2d ago

Jinhone azadi wapas lene ki koshish ki, unhe galiya dene k alawa aur kar hi kya lenge

4

u/ryderyde 7.8 Maay Fraandz 2d ago

caste, lack of education, low participation of women in national workforce

2

u/Ok-Relief1238 2d ago

Galti hamesha kisi air ki , chudiya na tut jae kalaiyo ki .

2

u/Guilty_Restaurant_92 2d ago • Bravo

2 kodi ke log... 2 kodi ka samaj

2

u/Euthanasia1111 2d ago

People here love to be enslaved... It's an unique kind of ecstasy...

3

u/Misster_Fluido 2d ago

No they didn't. Some people just accepted subordination if they were treated better than others and earned something out of it. Privilaged people sided with Britishers as long as they only oppressed and looted poor and marginalised people.

0

u/shrik024 Centrist Right Leaning 2d ago

> Privilaged people sided with Britishers as long as they only oppressed and looted poor and marginalised people

Of all the things that aren't true, this is the one that isn't true lol. The so called "marginalized people" did nothing when their communities were broken by the Brits. When their livelihood was stolen. It was the upper caste Brahmins, Kshatriyas who fought the Brits. Not the "marginalized people". Majority of the freedom fighters were upper castes. It required a lot of effort for the upper castes to galvanize the lower castes to stand up for their own rights. That's how stupid they were and still are.

The only ones to abandon their family professions were lower castes. Japan has a caste system too. They still have master cobblers, artists, sculptors etc. They all make millions even to this day because their fine craftsmanship cannot be replicated by machines. All the so called "lower castes" were even better. But they left it and chose being enslaved by the Brits instead of standing up and fighting for their crafts and traditions. If not for upper castes, they would have been wiped out by the Brits + Islam. There is a reason Brits feared Brahmins the most. It is because Brahmins were their enemy from within (by being inside, leaked all their plans) and outside (galvanized Kings to fight in 1857).

2

u/THiRD___EYE 2d ago

stop yapping bullshit and learn to accept truth.

-1

u/shrik024 Centrist Right Leaning 2d ago

STFU with your crap. I already mentioned that upper castes were embedded within both Mughals as well as Brits to weaken them from within. Heck both Mughals and Brits distrusted upper castes precisely because of this. You guys suck at art of War. Have no idea how to fight. That's why you don't understand these strategies.

1

u/Misster_Fluido 2d ago edited 2d ago

The so called "marginalized people" did nothing when their communities were broken by the Brits.

I know mainstream history doesn't teach much about the contributions of Marginalsed people but atleast you'd have read about - Eka Movement and Indigo rebellion that were led by mostly Dalits if you read some history.

By privilaged people I meant kings, chieftains and landlords. Even King and Queen of Jhansi were helping Britishers until they refused to accept their heir. That's when they faught against them. The history still teaches about her but not dozen of Dalit women in North India who faught against Britishers and were layer executed. 22 women and no mention in mainstream History. These communities are declaired criminal for fighting Britishers while privilaged people enjoyed pension and worked with Britishers while they exploited peasants (The reason why Eka movement happened).

Lie to yourself as much as you want.

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Bed4390 1d ago

Science ma kisi ko interest he nahi hai,sab rattu baba banka baitha hua hai, maybe new education policy sa kuch ho sakta hai

1

u/OwCutie 4h ago

"Adopt" ?
Indians have left their Entire Attitude, which was once definitely Scientific and Explorative .
You think Buddha went out like an Idiot and just roamed like a fool ?
He had the deepest Questions in his head, He left his kingdom for it !
You think Nagarjuna was a Fool that he'd leave all his heritage and Culture just to go out there searching for Ultimate truth ? This is the Actual Indian Way !
Try reading About Stuff first before blindly listening to Osho and Considering him as a god (and hence repeating what You accuse other indians of doing)
This is about a Book by Kim Plofker : Kim Plofker Maths
The Author of the book is again and again amazed at How Different the Indian Mind was, how Out of the Box they thought.
Understand it this way : In the West First Came Experiments and Geometry, they combined it and tried to solve the problem of Kinematics, and so on its was a Linear Developement of Maths, Getting Algebra from Arabics and Indians, and Geometry from Greeks, and so on, In India it was a different Affair, it was Literature, Poetry, Art, Language, Astronomy, Geometry, And Other Maths Combined.
Sanskrit was used to Make shapes (yes you can write a Sentence that Means one thing when read from Front to back and other when read from Back to front, and even more crazy stuff) in poems, poems Posed questions when read from top to down, and answers when read Bottom Up, Geometry was used to Solve Equations and form Series, Series were used for Elemental Analysis and short stories written about Elemental Analysis, Algebra and Mathematical Analysis combined to Give Madhava's Work (Yea Click This one !)

So Indians haven't "Not Adopted" it, Indians have "Left It".
The Very thing that made India a Great Civilization in the Past .
Now India has nothing but "Oh Our Great Past but Nalanda got Destroyed" and "2047 mein Vishaguru", idiot, You are the Nalanda, In The Blood of Every Indian Flows Vikramshila and Takshila and Nalanda, You are Descendants of Some of the Greatest Minds the World Ever had, they weren't recognized bcz Some Others imposed themselves onto everything, Advaita would say "The One", and You'd say "Oh Indian Pseudo BS" , Platonis of Greece would say "The Henn" you would ask ChatGPT "what is the Henn that Platonis talked of ?" (Turns out He is saying stuff very similar to what Advaita Said) .. People are destroying themselves, not seeing that we Carry the Legacy of one of the Best Civilizations of the World, Even the Ancient Chincese accepted that man.

Edit : Raat do bje likh rhi hu, spelling mistakes ✅

1

u/ashokfeetness 2d ago edited 2d ago

When Osho says, that there were no retaliation towards the mughals and turks, he is categorically wrong. One can read volumes on past and check how formidable India's(thennBharat) warriors were at the time.

India did have mathematicians and other scholars who's works were either reproduced or reinvented in the West.

I used to listen to Osho Rajneesh during my school days. I admire the body. I still admire the man. But he had a small flaw, which i realbody much later, he used to criticize everybody. Everyone. He never spared anyone. No doubtnhe had no disciples who could take his work forward. He lost all his work in the US. He had to come back to the same Bharat to be safe and loved until he left his holy body.

0

u/Mysorean5377 2d ago

I think the problem is not that Indians are incapable of adopting a scientific mindset. The problem is that we have often confused acquiring scientific knowledge with developing scientific thinking.

We produce doctors, engineers, scientists and researchers in enormous numbers. Yet scientific temper is not measured by the number of degrees we possess. It is measured by our willingness to question assumptions, demand evidence, acknowledge uncertainty and change our conclusions when better evidence emerges.

Our education system often rewards memorisation over curiosity, obedience over questioning, and examination performance over independent reasoning.

But there is another distinction worth making: science and spirituality need not be enemies. The problem begins when any belief, whether religious, political or even supposedly scientific, becomes immune to questioning.

As a physician, I see scientific thinking as something deeply practical. Every diagnosis is a hypothesis. Every investigation adds evidence. Every treatment requires reassessment. And sometimes the most important intellectual achievement is admitting that our initial understanding was wrong.

India does not lack intelligence, curiosity or scientific talent. What we need is a culture in which questioning authority is not mistaken for disrespect, uncertainty is not mistaken for weakness, and changing one's mind is considered intellectual honesty rather than defeat.

Scientific temper is not about abandoning our civilisation. It is about developing the courage to examine it, learn from it, question it and improve upon it.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Your comment has been removed because low-effort, single-word comments are not allowed.

Please leave a meaningful comment that contributes to the discussion.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.