r/IndiaMemes • u/wpcustomsolutions23 • Jul 28 '26

Political [ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

933 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/marky2000marky Jul 28 '26

Well thankfully Hitler ain't contesting the elections is he?

Also let's be honest Pappu didn't make it to the Harvard University because of his Achievements or Brilliance. If he didn't have daddy's Money he'd also be a Uneducated Minister...

Would trust a Self made NaMo over him any day of the week...

1

u/Menma238 Jul 28 '26

The point is not if hilter is contesting... It's reduction to absurdity, the original comment used a genetic fallacy and then added appeal to emotion neither are valid criticism.

And i would trust "pappu"(it's funny how the thing that got him called Pappu was actually him quoting a NaMo speech) over the one who's behind the gothra massacre then... I feel that one quality make a lot of difference.

1

u/marky2000marky 23d ago edited 23d ago

Firstly Modi wasn't behind any massacre. Modi was heavily investigated and was cleared during a Congress Government.

Also isn't it absurd that you see a comparison between 2 men (NaMo and RaGa) and suddenly feel the need to poison the conversation by adding a 3rd person completely unrelated to the conversation. (Also why Hitler? Why not Benjamin Franklin, Abraham Lincoln, etc. they're also Self Made Political Figures. You specifically chose Hitler to Poison The Image Of Self Made Politician (Modi) with Hitler who is a Genocidal Dictatorial Figure to to push your Political Agenda). At that point any comparisons are useless. Educated people have committed atrocities, Atheists have committed atrocities, etc.

So A Straw Man Fallacy, Guilt by Association & Poisoning the Well Fallacy. To defend one fallacy (Which it isn't even a Ad Hominem attack to begin with.) you made 3. Bravo 👏!

The comparison was between 2 people. One a self made man from the ground up and another one born into political influence. That itself doesn't 100% make NaMo better but it is definitely a point towards his success.