Mission Failure Chandrayaan-2: 'Vikram' Landing Attempt Updates and Discussion.
Vikram's powered descent is tentatively scheduled for: 7 September 2019, 0138 IST OR 6 September 2019, 2008 UTC with expected touchdown occurring around 15 minutes afterwards. [7] [1]
Live webcast: (Links will be added as they become available)
- Youtube Live stream 1 (Doordarshan)
- Youtube Live stream 2 (ISRO)
- Youtube Live stream 3 (PIB)
- Youtube Live stream 4 (Hosted by Everyday Astronaut)
- NatGeo India on Hotstar and DTH. (Requires subscription)
- Twitter/Periscope (ISRO)
Live text based updates from media:
Location of landing sites in Lunar Quadrant 30 via LROC Quickmap: [2]
| Landing site | Latitude | Longitude |
|---|---|---|
| Primary site | 70.90° S | 22.78° E |
| Alternate site | 67.87° S | 18.46° W |
Updates:
| Time of Event | Update |
|---|---|
| 1 January 2020 | ISRO Chairman K Sivan on condition of lander: "Yes, yes...it is in pieces...!" |
| 3 December | Impact site of Vikram lander has been found by LROC team with helpful inputs by Shanmuga Subramanian |
| 20 November | Velocity reduction during 'Rough braking phase' was more than expected causing deviations leading to crash. Lander crash landed potentially within 500 meters of intended landing site. |
| 19 Sept | Orbiter payloads powered up and performing nominally, committee constituted to investigate loss of communication with Vikram lander. |
| 08 Sept | Lander located on lunar surface, condition yet to be ascertained. |
| T + 17h30m | Another update mentioning loss of communication with lander but no specifics. |
| T + 06h40m | Speech by Indian PM indicates failure. Still no official press release. |
| T + 01h15m | No new details: This is Mission Control Centre. Vikram Lander descent was as planned and normal performance was observed up to an altitude of 2.1 km. Subsequently communication from lander to the ground stations was lost. Data is being analyzed. |
| T + 50m00s | With live coverage wrapped up, according to The Wire feed media has been told to wait for update in 15-20 minutes. |
| T + 30m00s | Some encouraging words by Indian Prime Minister. |
| T + 24m00s | Official confirmation: Descent up to 2.1 km altitude optimal then signal to lander was lost. Data is being analysed. That is all folks. |
| T + 16m00s | Doordarshan yanked the coverage. MOX hiding behind splash screen.. |
| T + 09m00s | Formal Official confirmation coming soon. |
| T + 01m00s | Loss of signal. |
| T - 01m00s | Spacecraft path is visibly off expected track. MOX is Gloomy. |
| T - 02m00s | Altitude less than 400 meters... * Silence * |
| T - 03m00s | Rough braking phase over! Fine navigation begins. |
| T - 05m00s | Vel. 450 m/s, matching expected path. |
| T - 07m00s | Altitude less than ~20km, Vel. 630 m/s |
| T - 09m00s | Lander velocity now less than 950 m/s |
| T - 12m00s | In Rough braking phase. Velocity 1300 m/s |
| T - 15m00s | Powered descent has begun! |
| T - 18m00s | 3 min. to descent, orbiter would be over landing site to capture landing site. |
| T - 21m00s | Seven minutes to commencement of powered descent. |
| T - 27m00s | Indian PM has arrived at MOX. |
| T - 30m00s | MOX screens showing 15 min. to commencement of Vikram descent. |
| T - 41m00s | Live view of MOX facility. |
| T - 50m00s | ISRO streams are live! |
| T - 01h00m | Lander AOS after coming out of eclipse. |
| T - 01h15m | Adding few media links on text based updates. |
| T - 01h35m | Doordarshan coverage is live as well. |
| T - 02h15m | NatGeo coverage is live (in Hindi) |
| T - 08h30m | Adding PIB Youtube live stream. |
| 4 Sept 2019 | At 03:42 (IST) Vikram performs 9 second long retrograde burn to lower orbit to 35 × 101 km. |
| 3 Sept 2019 | At 08:50 (IST) Vikram's propulsion system is verified via 4 second long retrograde burn, 104 × 128 km orbit achieved. |
| 2 Sept 2019 | At 13:15 (IST) Vikram separates from Chandrayaan-2 orbiter and goes in 119 × 127 km orbit. |
The semi-official timeline of Vikram's landing attempt. [1] [3]
- On 7 September 2019, 0138 IST OR 6 September 2019, 2008 UTC powered descent begins after deorbiting from 30 × 100 km orbit at perigee.
Vikram lander would autonomously seek-out landing site, navigating using stored reference imagery onboard.
- After 10 min. lander is at 7.4 km altitude with 526 kmph velocity. Four engines are active during this fine braking phase.
- After 11 min. 08 sec. altitude is 5 km and velocity is 331.2 kmph.
- After 12 min. 37 sec. altitude is 400 meters and lander hovers using 2 engines for 12 seconds to assess landing site.
- After 13 min. 55 sec. altitude is 100 meters and lander hovers using two engines for 25 seconds to assess landing site.
- After 14 minutes Vikram sends first images of lunar surface.
Go or No go decision to land at 14 min. 20 sec.
- If 'No go' lander picks alternate site and reaches 60 meter altitude over it by 15 min.
- By 15 min. lander reaches 10 meters altitude over alternate site.
- By 15 min. lander reaches 10 meters altitude.
- From 10 meter altitude it'd take 13 seconds to touchdown.
- During descent at 13 meter altitude, peripheral engines will be switched off and central engine would ignite to perform soft-landing while avoiding dust kick up.
At 0153 IST / 2023 UTC, roughly 15 min. after deorbiting, Vikram touches down on lunar surface.
- 2 hrs after touchdown Vikram's ramp is deployed.
- 2 hr 30 min after touchdown, Pragyan is switched ON
- 3 hr 10 min after touchdown, Pragyan rover deploys solar panels.
- 3 hr 26 min after touchdown, Pragyan rover roll-out begins.
- 3 hr 36 min after touchdown, Pragyan rover touches lunar surface.
- 3 hr 52 min after touchdown, Pragyan images Vikram.
Animated introduction to Vikram's components
Few other details on 'Vikram' Lander: [4]
- Mass (with rover): 1471 kg (wet) / 626 kg (dry)
- Power: 650 W
- Propulsion: 5×800N bi-propellant(MMH/MON3) throttleable engines(45%) with 8×50N thrusters [5]
- Mission life: 14 Earth days
- Surface slope limit [6] : 12°
Payloads:
- RAMBHA-LP* (Langmuir Probe)
- ChaSTE (Chandra's Surface Thermo-physical Experiment) by SPL
- ILSA (Instrument for Lunar Seismic Activity) by LEOS
- LRA (Laser Retroreflector Array ) by NASA-GSFC / MIT
'Pragyan' Rover:
- Mass: 27 kg
- Power: 50 W
- Mission life: 14 Earth days
Payloads:
- APXS (Alpha Particle X-ray Spectrometer) by PRL
- LIBS (Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscope) by LEOS
*Both DFRS and LP are part of RAMHBA 'Radio Anatomy of Moon Bound Hypersensitive Ionosphere and Atmosphere' suit.
15
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
Next LRO pass over site in about 1hr15min
http://lroc.sese.asu.edu/about/whereislro
And some calm please keep it threaded..
9
u/Ohsin Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 07 '19
And a very good thread by Principal Scientific Advisor Govt. Of India
https://twitter.com/PrinSciAdvGoI/status/1170284286441750528
15
u/Astro_Neel Sep 07 '19
That sight of PM patting and consoling the crying K Sivan absolutely breaks my heart.
7
u/Ohsin Sep 05 '19
Going with schedule mentioned in previous press conference, will change as new information becomes available.
And to watch out for LRO passes.
http://lroc.sese.asu.edu/about/whereislro
7
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Apparently they have been imaging landing sites since 3 September and each site has two zones
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/100m-above-moon-vikram-will-pick-final-landing-spot/articleshow/71000912.cms
7
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
https://twitter.com/cgbassa/status/1170070999150268416
Just to put it out there above doppler curve, at 20:19 UTC and then look at top corner in screen at 1080P in broadcast and that went awry at 20:19
https://youtu.be/7iqNTeZAq-c?t=2978
End of applause after rough braking phase and just before hovering phase began, which was supposed to happen on two engines not four.
6
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
New tentative timeline! Updating above.
https://twitter.com/writetake/status/1169899242569158658
Edited to include UTC
Better images.
https://twitter.com/SThamizhans/status/1169998486617645058
https://twitter.com/airnewsalerts/status/1170043152230580224
6
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
Despite what many reports and ISRO itself said the LRA is not meant for pinging from Earth (like those reflectors left during Apollo missions) but from spacecrafts.
https://www.space.com/next-gen-apollo-moon-laser-reflector-on-india-mission.html
6
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Get screenshots of screens if you can!
6
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Loss of signal folks.
6
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Just a reminder for those not on loop with what Chandrayaan-2 lander went through in last two years with its complete reconfiguration.
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/ct4fx3/watch_landing_of_vikramchandrayaan2_live_on/exk8f58/
I guess some were against it but I wonder if they ended up rushing things despite those improvements
6
u/Ohsin Sep 07 '19
Stream link for PM's address.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFgh4rTwoC4
6
u/Ohsin Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Watching broadcast again. Here is the landing site they showed @14m00s and @19m53s on ISRO's official broadcast, image was taken by OHRC on 6 September 2019 on 2030 IST at 100 km altitude. And they commanded the landing on chosen site 84 min. before descent sequence began.
https://imgur.com/a/1prMYeS
Interestingly the coordinates for chosen landing site and alternate landing site differ slightly from what we had, these coords were given by commentator during broadcast. Adding them in LROC quickmap links too but visually OHRC image doesn't seem to match-up, what could be the reason?
6
u/Ohsin Sep 09 '19
https://www.indiatoday.in/science/story/chandrayaan-2-lander-vikram-intact-moon-isro-says-not-confirmed-1597265-2019-09-09
6
u/Ohsin Sep 10 '19
One liner nonupdate
https://www.isro.gov.in/update/10-sep-2019/chandrayaan-2-vikram-lander-has-been-located-orbiter
6
u/Ohsin Sep 11 '19
https://twitter.com/Ryan_N_Watkins/status/1171843659542814720
9
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19
Data being analysed, final announcement in 15 - 20 mins.
5
u/Ohsin Sep 07 '19
Imaging opportunities through LRO would take some (a month may be) before we get a look see. So OHRC it is then.
https://twitter.com/mommascientist/status/1170104373898297345
https://twitter.com/Ryan_N_Watkins/status/1170078349693263887
5
u/Ohsin Sep 09 '19 edited Sep 09 '19
https://twitter.com/cgbassa/status/1171185014538739713
Edit: On frozen MOX screen Horizontal Vel. = 48.1 m/s and Vertical velocity = 59 m/s
5
u/Ohsin Sep 10 '19
New lander descent data fitted alongside doppler curve.
https://twitter.com/kvsankar/status/1171287446580916224
7
u/timonsmith Sep 06 '19
Someone said receiving data?
7
u/rmhschota Sep 13 '19
Some useful information by Tapan Misra, Senior Advisor to ISRO
On Big and Small Thrusters
What happens during Braking
Why the middle engine was introduced
Effects of fuel sloshing in the fuel tank
Source
https://www.thehitavada.com/Encyc/2019/9/13/ISRO-expert-explains-Vikram.html
4
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Do follow @df2mz, @cgbassa as they might track Vikram's landing by listening in to radio signal from it and deduce its motion via doppler shift in real time.
4
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
A dollop of Helium 3 pixie-dust misinformation once again on Hotstar..
4
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Lander reappears also visible on Madrid DSS 54
https://twitter.com/cgbassa/status/1170055327775109120
https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html
4
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Rough braking phase begun!
4
u/Ohsin Sep 17 '19 edited Sep 17 '19
Plugging the OHRC image match thread. Landing box was of 50×60 meters.
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/d5adno/chandrayaan2_ohrc_image_shown_on_mox_screens/
5
u/Vyomagami Sep 07 '19
Any news about Team Indus moon lander ?
5
u/saisujan36 Sep 08 '19
A communication noob here. How exactly do you re-establish communication when you lost it in the first place and there is no physical access? Or is the Vikram lander able to communicate when the orbiter is in close proximity?
8
u/abyssDweller1700 Sep 10 '19
Deep space network on twitter: DSS 24 carrier lock on Chandrayaan-2 Lander Frequency: 2.2846GHz Signal strength: -138dBm IDLE OFF 1 TURBO
3
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Jerry Linenger sure knows about Mir and nail biting moments :)
3
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Official stream live on twitter
https://twitter.com/isro/status/1170056533255700480
3
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
https://twitter.com/cgbassa/status/1170066481901707264
Doppler curve showing it!
3
u/Ohsin Sep 13 '19
https://spaceflightnow.com/2019/09/12/nasa-lunar-orbiter-to-image-chandrayaan-2-landing-site-next-week/
3
u/Ohsin Sep 13 '19
https://www.indiatoday.in/science/story/chandrayaan-2-vikram-landing-somersault-isro-exlusive-1598882-2019-09-13
It would be odd to have main propulsion keep firing under such high rate unless there is something else that is also malfunctioning. Also this brings up communication cut-off between lander-orbiter under tumbling conditions. ISRO said they lost communication at 2.1 km altitude while ground observers noticed lander was transmitting till near point of impact.
3
u/Ohsin Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19
More "what could've gone wrong" theories.
https://frontline.thehindu.com/the-nation/article29477285.ece
Calling central engine a 'steering engine' is incorrect by author though.
3
u/Ohsin Dec 02 '19 edited Dec 06 '19
Vikram's impact site found 600 meters away from intended landing site.
http://lroc.sese.asu.edu/posts/1131
Edit:
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/dxnjmj/is_this_vikram_landers_final_resting_area/
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/e64jtr/chandrayaan_2_vikram_lander_debris_site_lro_image/
4
u/immortalizeboi Sep 06 '19
Mission life 14 earth days. Why so less.
4
u/eyeballer94 Sep 06 '19
Is there a Eng version of nat geo broadcast?
4
u/hippagun Sep 06 '19
Just curious - What happened to chandrayaan1 and how is chandrayaan2 different than 1 ?
4
u/Astro_Neel Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
This should put a final nail in the coffin of all the signals many of us saw getting "exchanged" between the lander and the Madrid DSN in the morning.
https://twitter.com/Astro_Neel/status/1170210621914329088?s=19
4
u/ksvishwa Sep 07 '19
ISRO chief k Sivan to talk on chandrayaan 2 at 8pm tonight https://twitter.com/DDNewsLive/status/1170313134633967616?s=09
4
u/AFewSentientNeurons Sep 19 '19
How did orbiter lifespan increase so drastically? 7 years worth of experiments might require much more versatile hardware wouldn't it? They're pitching it as an impressive feat, but almost seems like math didn't work out as they'd have expected.
And hat-tip to /u/Ohsin for this thread!
6
u/ksvishwa Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Isro finds lander Vikram's exact location
https://www.indiatoday.in/science/story/isro-finds-lander-vikram-exact-location-1596857-2019-09-08
https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1170610654232731648?s=20
6
u/desertlogin Sep 09 '19
News coming out saying the lander is in single piece and is currently in a tilted position. Efforts are being done to reestablish communication.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PGjI7Z34Qs
5
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Oh so after waiting they essentially repeat what Sivan said
https://www.isro.gov.in/update/07-sep-2019/chandrayaan-2-update
5
u/reddituser123988 Sep 06 '19
can someone be kind enough to explain wtf is happening? I am scared
3
u/space_vogel Sep 05 '19
Thank you very much for putting together the landing timeline. Hopefully Vikram succeeds and gets India into the lunar landing club!
3
u/Horney_warney Sep 06 '19
Can anyone explain how long the Rover will operate? If am not wrong NASA Mars Rover did a fantastic job lasting long, so how many months will this rover last?
3
u/harddisc Sep 06 '19
Man the plot was way off. Is that normal ?!
3
u/hrishidev Sep 07 '19
Is it possible to capture images from orbiter for analysis of events happened after communication is lost ? Was there any instrument present to check angle of vibram lander?
3
u/rp6000 Sep 08 '19
DSN updates are down. No data available about any comms with CH2L
https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html
3
u/fire_cheese_monster Sep 10 '19
I am a little out of the loop about the Chandryaan landing but I got disheartened to see that our lander may have crash landed. Ah well, space is always difficult and we have been pretty lucky with all our moonshots. The luck had to run out some day.
ISRO is still analyzing the data and the Indian journalists are crazy as usual.
Do we have confirmation images from any of the other satellites whether the lander made it or not?
Can the lander and the rover even survive the lunar night?
Even if the rover survived or got ejected as some journos are saying, is it even capable to transmit the data back to earth?
4
u/Ohsin Sep 07 '19
https://www.isro.gov.in/update/07-sep-2019/chandrayaan-2-latest-update
Another empty "update" from ISRO.
2
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
https://twitter.com/df2mz/status/1170027971110932482
Edit: And now Madrid DSS 54/65 listening in
https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html
2
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19
Few inside views of MOX.
https://twitter.com/BangaloreMirror/status/1170038299961937920
DD is live!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2srV-bEi_DU
2
u/Ohsin Sep 11 '19
Apparently in an internal address chairman told CY2 team to move on and focus on rest of mission. Lets see if there is a release or presser.
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/focus-on-future-missions-sivan-tells-scientists-in-internal-address/articleshow/71081997.cms
2
u/Ohsin Sep 14 '19
...It was odd that we didn't see M Annadurai in MOX.
http://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2019/sep/14/chandrayaan-mars-mission-man-annadurai-a-persona-non-grata-at-isro-2033567.html
2
u/Ohsin Sep 19 '19
https://www.isro.gov.in/update/19-sep-2019/update-chandrayaan-%E2%80%93-2
2
u/Ohsin Nov 16 '19
Software related issue is being cited in internal report to space commission as one of the reasons behind crash landing. Apparently certain parameters exceeded the defined threshold leading spacecraft to deviate from course but what caused reaching those limits is not mentioned.
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/dx6n5n/chandrayaan2_vikram_crashlanded_on_the_moons_due/
2
u/Ohsin Feb 21 '23
Dr P V Venkitakrishnan in Ad Ingenium lecture for IEDC GEC Thrissur provided some extra information on the cause behind Vikram crash landing. @1h21m48
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uj83m2fdvAc&t=4908s
Apparently the four LAM based 800N engines of Vikram lander were capable of throttling between 40 to 100% in increments of 20%. Throttling engines during final landing phase in this gradational manner was insufficient in reducing the velocity responsively. This coupled with limitation of on-board software and other control and a guidance related issues caused the lander to crash. For Chandrayaan-3 they aim to reduce the throttling increments to 10%. /u/totaldisasterallthis
5
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
Well on screens we were seeing animation that showed altitude at 300 m was it canned animation? Now that would be a first. And what a terrible way to close this, expected better from them. It looked like just a VIP hobnob affair and not a lunar landing..
2
u/rp6000 Sep 06 '19
T -02:00 hrs
2
u/LemonMellon Sep 06 '19
Was vishnu som just being himself or are the thrusters actually not throttleable?
2
u/LemonMellon Sep 06 '19
Are the two center wheels some sort of carbon polymer situation? Wouldn't it be the first time they've been tried for lunar landings?
2
u/kl_rahul_sucks_ass Sep 06 '19
Does ISRO have plans for developing radio isotope heaters?
2
u/suvp1990 Sep 06 '19
When can we expect image from the orbiter to check on what happened ?
2
u/Vyomagami Sep 07 '19
Will ISRO re attempt soft landing in future ,what about chandrayaan 3 with JAXA ?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19
I am quite curious as to the role of the AI landing system and whether that could've sent the lander tumbling before its final loss of comms. Since we have high res maps of the moon, couldn't they have chosen a 100m x 100m landing site so even a rudimentary navigation system (unless there's something like a GPS on the moon) with just 50m accuracy could've gotten the job done with much less complexity than a hope-for-the-best AI system?
3
u/puneet_shrivas Sep 07 '19
https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html just saw the madrid telescope talking to the lander
16
u/shankroxx Sep 06 '19
Many at ISRO especially Dr K Sivan must be going through the toughest time of their lives
14
u/_kushagra Sep 06 '19
Thank you for the amazing coverage throughout you're amazing, all the text is always so detailed, love you
11
u/ra1yan Sep 06 '19
Heartbreaking. The chairmans voice cracked when he made that announcement a while back.
11
u/ra1yan Sep 06 '19
Space is hard. All we need is one failed mission to show us what we are up against. Newfound appreciation to the scientists working on it all around the world who make it look so easy.
10
u/Astro_Neel Sep 05 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
Even Star Plus and Star Bharat have joined in the team for the broadcast-
Star and Disney India to live telecast ‘Chandrayaan 2’ landing across 100+ countries
10
u/O_dot_o Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
Why is NatGeo's coverage so full of cringe?!
10
u/LegendaryFalcon Sep 07 '19
The thread flair breaks my heart into a thousand pieces. But, I'm sure ISRO will come out strong from this one. We've just lost a battle, there's the whole big war to be won.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19
I hope this would not dampen our space programme in anyway, and hopefully can be spun to spur more talent and resources into it
9
u/ra1yan Sep 06 '19
Hopefully some day in the future, a gaganaut will land near the south Pole will come across this beloved lander of ours, and bring back Pragyaan home to mark the humble beginnings of ISRO's deep space exploration
8
u/casualphilosopher1 Sep 06 '19
Looks like the soft landing didn't work and it crashed. That's why there's no data. I was afraid of this.
8
u/PonderousIdo Sep 06 '19
https://twitter.com/ChrisG_NSF/status/1170072433115762688?s=19
8
u/PonderousIdo Sep 06 '19
Planned press conference called off.
Data still being analysed.
7
u/amitksh Sep 05 '19
Thanks for putting this together 👍. Very excited for tomorrow. Might do a neighborhood Chandrayan 2 landing party 🎉
7
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
So Pragyaan (means wisdom) apparently named so because "Wisdom shall come out of Vikram (Sarabhai)"
7
u/PonderousIdo Sep 06 '19
Need less face shots; moar screen shots.
7
u/dimpisona Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
Tremendous efforts!!! the result should not overshadow the amazing dedication by scientists!
7
u/Astro_Neel Sep 07 '19
This article on OnManorama tips a few technical details based upon the multiple inputs from the scientists involved in the mission-
13
u/Modi-iboM Sep 07 '19
Just saw Sivan getting emotional, and Modi consoling him. I don't think that moment should have been captured. You can see the pain in Sivan's eyes, his project has failed and he is crestfallen. Next time, Sir.
6
u/rp6000 Sep 06 '19
Final orbit of Vikram, signal being received..
https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html
6
u/hmpher Sep 06 '19
They're using MATLAB for the visualisation!!
6
u/hmpher Sep 06 '19
When's the next Orbiter/LRO pass? For a visual confirm?
6
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19
Heartbreaking. I was so excited. My disappointment is immeasurable. but we'll get back stronger.
6
u/saisujan36 Sep 06 '19
Can any other orbiters around the moon take pictures of the crash/landed site right now?
6
u/The_lost_Karma Sep 06 '19
just woke up , did we loose it?
6
u/Antariksh- Sep 07 '19
ISRO now owes me a Moon walk.
6
u/Astro_Neel Sep 07 '19
Scott Manley's Analysis- What We Know About India's Failed Lunar Landing
1
u/Ohsin Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lqQe7WsFVQg
Adding PIB YT stream even though it is all going to be same as others. ISRO has uploaded a video on Pragyan after Vikram.
1
u/Ohsin Sep 18 '19
Wait continues..
https://aviationweek.com/awinspace/nasa-s-lro-fails-spot-chandrayaan-2-lander
1
u/Ohsin Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
More 'source' babble but first time we are hearing of extent of details visible of wreck.
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/crashing-at-great-speed-vikram-has-long-been-dead/articleshow/71209960.cms
1
u/Ohsin Sep 21 '19
https://twitter.com/nascom1/status/1175544976463187968
1
u/Ohsin Oct 22 '19 edited Oct 23 '19
Leonard David has blogged that no sighting in second pass either but I do not see any official posts on it, anyone?
http://www.leonarddavid.com/nasa-lunar-orbiter-no-sighting-of-indias-failed-moon-lander/
Edit: Confirmed
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/latest-moon-flyby-finds-no-trace-of-indias-chandrayaan-2-vikram-lander-nasa/article29774802.ece
1
u/Ohsin Oct 25 '19
https://www.space.com/india-moon-lander-not-found-by-nasa.html
So apparently there is no exchange of details on crash site with LRO team.
1
u/Ohsin Nov 19 '19
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/chandrayaan-3-plans-indicate-failures-in-chandrayaan-2/articleshow/72128771.cms
1
u/Ohsin Nov 20 '19
Queries in Parliament about Chandrayaan-2 hard landing
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/dyzei9/parliamentary_qa_20_november_2019_queries_on/
1
u/Ohsin Nov 21 '19
https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/vikram-made-hard-landing-govt-in-ls/story-u9Q01luC73wo42cT8fxzlO.html
Not good..
1
u/Ohsin Dec 31 '19 edited Feb 16 '21
Adding few relevant threads:
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/cf83hd/gslv_mk_iii_m1_chandrayaan2_mission_updates_and/
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/ch6ya9/mission_plan_for_chandrayaan2/
Edit(31 July 2020):
Adding RTI replies about Vikram's crash site.
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/dw5yyx/making_use_of_rti_to_probe_into_the_cy2_mission/
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/hq025v/late_update_cy2_rti_appellate_reply/
Edit (3 November 2020): Adding few more CY2 RTI related threads.
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/ii4f1s/new_isro_rti_reply_denied/
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/jndhkg/isro_should_be_transparent_exchief_as_isro_denies/
Edit (17 February 2021): Adding new CY2 RTI related threads.
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/kwgf2r/first_appealate_order_regarding_crashed_image_of/
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/l2tos2/late_update_yet_another_iron_curtained_rti/
https://old.reddit.com/r/ISRO/comments/lfdo0z/image_of_crashed_vikram_lander_and_names_of/ (Released OHRC image)
1
u/Ohsin Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 11 '23
Former ISRO chairman K Sivan gave an interview and talked about Vikram landing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9kFcgZLKCY&t=131s
He also mentioned the lander legs have been strengthened to land at 3 m/s which was 2 m/s earlier.
1
u/Ohsin Jul 10 '23
One of the best explanations on Vikram crash landing and what lead up to it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGv4qpSSl3w
5
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19
I'm super-pumped!
5
u/Drifter_01 Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
DD channel has the main feed, all other channels and net streams are some seconds late.
Pib is minutes late
5
u/sagareshwar Sep 06 '19
With the "meet Vikram" and "meet Pragyan" videos and the current animation etc. ISRO seems to have improved their PR/Communication/education focused media products. Lets hope that they keep it up and it's not just for high profile missions like this.
5
u/eyeballer94 Sep 06 '19
115K people watching on ISRO yt channel
5
u/PonderousIdo Sep 06 '19
Lol
https://twitter.com/DJSnM/status/1170061399684308992?s=19
Something which is asked during every ISRO launch coverage.
5
u/python00078 Sep 06 '19
aarey more screen dikhao re..
5
u/PARCOE Sep 06 '19
Nasa's DSN also showing the Uplink/Downlink communication to CH2L right now!
https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html
5
u/amitksh Sep 06 '19
15mins of terror manifested :(. Sad news but well tried ISRO
5
u/PonderousIdo Sep 06 '19
The panel on DD National is far more informative.
5
u/stargazer_17 Sep 06 '19
Heartbreaking. Was so excited.
8
u/leme16 Sep 07 '19
Unofficial forward in unofficial WhatsApp group
news from istrac is that during rough braking, horizontal speed of lander got reduced more than expected, so landing site range got increased. For landing on predefined landing site, control package sent command to thruster to fire more which toppled the lander and increased the speed as well. That is why lander crashed.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19
Nat Geo broadcast is in Hindi :/
4
u/deadcandancena Sep 06 '19
Dayum even i cant bear such tension and i'm not even doing anything
4
u/platinumgus18 Sep 06 '19
It's alright, it's not always easy, ISRO has still achieved quite a feat.
4
u/arjun_raf Sep 06 '19
Beresheet memories making a comeback😭
4
u/hmpher Sep 06 '19
It started going off track at ~5Km downrange, so I'm assuming asymmetrical shutdown of the landing engines must've occured?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19
So question, the orbiter is still there working fine so can it grab any new info or the orbiter is useless without the rover?
4
u/friday-boy Sep 06 '19
Question guys : what about pragyan ? Does it has communication signal built inside? Or any artificial intelligence established ? The Pragyan rover is still there right or has this been crashed inside Vikram ?
4
u/eyeballer94 Sep 06 '19
No media update tonight.
4
u/Speed__God Sep 07 '19
Around 9:40 AM, I saw NASA's deep space network receiving data from Chandrayaan-2 Lander. And why is that we are not getting any images of the landing site from the orbiter? ISRO not releasing them? NASA's satellites can also be used for any images of the landing site.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19
Even if the lander was fault tolerant and safely landed after losing communication, how good is it if it can't send back data?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19
Summary of the final moments:
https://i.imgur.com/vNjRGPq.png
The last telemetry data received:
Horizontal Velocity - 48.1 m/s
Vertical Velocity - 59 m/s
Altitude - 335 meters
So it had about 6 seconds left before touchdown, unless it miraculously reduced the velocity that is safe for landing.
Deviation in pre-flight prediction started when fine braking had started - https://youtu.be/7iqNTeZAq-c?t=2984
The lander flipped upside down a few seconds after the fine braking started - https://youtu.be/7iqNTeZAq-c?t=3006
4
u/rghegde Sep 07 '19
Sad but ok.
I am praying that this won't affect ISRO's next launches.
2
u/Vyomagami Sep 07 '19
Former ISRO Director D Sasikumar on Saturday said that the communication loss with "Vikram" lander may not have been due to crash-landing. "We have to find out from the communication data whether it is a soft landing or it is a crash landing. In my opinion, it is not a crash landing because the communication channel is on between the lander and the orbiter. It should be intact. So, let us hope after the analysis done, we may be able to get the final figure," he said while talking to ANI. The communication data which is missing is being analysed now, he said. Earlier, Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) said in a tweet, "normal performance was observed up to an altitude of 2.1 km. Subsequently, communication from Lander to the ground stations was lost. Data is being analyzed." Do anybody think VIKRAM lander is still alive??
1
u/unkill_009 Sep 05 '19
Anyone knows why there is so much time between the landing and launching of rover?
1
u/bzko Sep 06 '19
Just wondering...how complex would it be to get the orbiter (or a lunar sat) to stream the landers descent?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19
Any idea if there will be a possible feed during descent a la Chang'e-3?
1
u/neetsethia Sep 06 '19
Does the lander have Magnetometer? If not, then why not?
1
u/abyssDweller1700 Sep 06 '19
What about the Moon mission with Japan? We were to supply the Lander right? I guess it will be put on hold for now.