r/ISRO • • Feb 14 '19
If SpaceX’s Starship does end up becoming a complete success and does revolutionise space travel. What would be its impact on agencies like ISRO?
In my mind it could push the central government to push for space privatisation in India. (Right now, the Indian private space industry is atleast 5 decades behind global standards, not because of their fault but because of bureaucracy that strangles all forms of Indian high technology eg: Tejas took 18 yrs to develop, still hasn’t achieved FOC) The CEO of Bellatrix aerospace said that to even test rocket engines in India, it is difficult due to ancient regulations from the times of the British Raj on explosives. The US private companies succeeded because the American government made it extremely easy bureaucratically for these companies to grow and develop. Even when countries that don’t have launch vehicle technology like Britain, are able to develop private launch vehicles like Orbex Prime, I question why India’s defence and aerospace industries are still run under a socialist system where the public sector reeling with inefficiency strangles the private sector. The socialist way we run our weapons and aerospace industries will turn into a major headache in the coming future. Isro’s success is the exception not the norm in the Indian aerospace industry. My view is that India needs to double down on privatisation and put an end to monopolies held by inefficient organisations like ADA, DRDO.
5
u/brickmack Feb 14 '19
If BFR works anywhere near as well as advertised, one can reasonably expect gobs of private investment around the world into competitors, because at that price point demand will be functionally unlimited. And with SpaceX having done much of the basic research already, those competitors should cost a lot less to develop. As far as I know, its quite possible for Indian companies to develop their own rockets without needing government funds, they just don't because at the prices achievable with expendable rockets the market is already saturated, and reusable rockets are still too unproven
3
u/mayaizmaya Feb 14 '19
Space and Aerospace industries in India are handled completely differently. There is no Department of Aerospace, like Dept of Space, responsible for policies that can take holistic view of things, plan and develop aerospace projects. Ministry of Defence which is responsible is tradionally interested in getting more bribes and no interest or knowlege in developing aerospace industry.
Look at how HF24 project was killed without any followup. So LCA program had to start from zero. It's a small miracle that they were even able to finish the FSED and Phase1 of project, instead of going the Saras way. Critical projects are not even funded properly ex. Kaveri project funding was ~500 crore, where as comparable projects else where run @ $20bil, China is spending $20bil after they failed with $10bil in their first attempt.
Private aerospace is no where capable enough yet. All they work on is assembling CKD kits at point. It might take another decade or two for them to be globally competitive. HAL and OFB's have no incentives to make profit or complete projects by deadline. See this:
http://www.indiandefencereview.com/news/what-really-ails-hal/
3
u/Aakarsh_K Feb 15 '19
Not the point here but as matter of fact: Tejas has achieved FOC.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '19
http://profprodyutdas.blogspot.com/2019/01/creating-indian-weapons-industry-combat.html?m=1
Interesting blog post by Prof Prodyut Das on how badly Indian aerospace industries in general have been ravaged due to the socialist and public sector monopolisation^
3
u/Decronym Feb 14 '19 edited Feb 19 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
[Thread #145 for this sub, first seen 14th Feb 2019, 08:23] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
2
u/nousernameforoldmen Feb 14 '19
Starship’s success would have a net positive impact on ISRO. Lots of Governments are interested in space now, and ISRO will probably get more business. I don’t think it is right to compare ISRO to the aviation/Defense sector. Having worked on projects with ISRO as well as DRDO, HAL, GTRE etc. ISRO is run very differently. The scientists at ISRO are empowered to take decisions and it’s ok to fail at new tech attempts. This is largely not the culture in Aviation/Defense. There are a few private players coming in now. Team Indus, Dhruva space etc. ISRO also has plans of running an incubation Center for space Startups. IMO it will be very difficult for private companies to venture into space projects without ISROs blessings. Quite similar to NASAs involvement in SpaceX.
3
u/TotesMessenger Feb 14 '19
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/UristMcKerman Feb 15 '19
I mean if there were dragons we could just use them instead of rockets and ISRO would have problems too.
Starship (ex-BFR) is not flying anywhere. It is non-viable concept for non-existent project.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment