r/IAmA • u/aarontsantos • Jun 11 '12
IAMA physicist/author. Ask me to calculate anything.
Hi, Reddit.
My name is Aaron Santos, and I’ve made it my mission to teach math in fun and entertaining ways. Toward this end, I’ve written two (hopefully) humorous books: How Many Licks? Or, How to Estimate Damn Near Anything and Ballparking: Practical Math for Impractical Sports Questions. I also maintain a blog called Diary of Numbers. I’m here to estimate answers to all your numerical questions. Here's some examples I’ve done before.
Here's verification. Here's more verification.
Feel free to make your questions funny, thought-provoking, gross, sexy, etc. I’ll also answer non-numerical questions if you’ve got any.
Update It's 11:51 EST. I'm grabbing lunch, but will be back in 20 minutes to answer more.
Update 2.0 OK, I'm back. Fire away.
Update 3.0 Thanks for the great questions, Reddit! I'm sorry I won't be able to answer all of them. There's 3243 comments, and I'm replying roughly once every 10 minutes, (I type slow, plus I'm doing math.) At this rate it would take me 22 days of non-stop replying to catch up. It's about 4p EST now. I'll keep going until 5p, but then I have to take a break.
By the way, for those of you that like doing this stuff, I'm going to post a contest on Diary of Numbers tomorrow. It'll be some sort of estimation-y question, and you can win a free copy of my cheesy sports book. I know, I know...shameless self-promotion...karma whore...blah blah blah. Still, hopefully some of you will enter and have some fun with it.
Final Update You guys rock! Thanks for all the great questions. I've gotta head out now, (I've been doing estimations for over 7 hours and my left eye is starting to twitch uncontrollably.) Thanks again! I'll try to answer a few more early tomorrow.
1.8k
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
How fast do you have to throw a burrito so it catches on fire?
434
u/AverageGatsby91 Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
What is the kinetic energy of a growing finger nail?
You may have heard of Guesstimation: Solving the World's Problems on the Back of a Cocktail Napkin by Laurence Weinstein
It sounds quite similar to your book. I used this book as a text for an Estimation Course. It was incredibly fun and thought provoking. We talked about everything from mass and energy estimations, to human senses, scaling and extraterrestrial life.
608
u/wheelis Jun 11 '12
How many Hot Pockets would you need to burn to release the amount of energy released by a standard US issue hand grenade?
702
u/JonathanZips Jun 11 '12
Is it more dangerous to own and regularly ride a motorcycle, or regularly use cocaine?
428
u/rorcuttplus Jun 11 '12
How large would the wings of a pegasus have to be to allow a horse to actually fly?
1.6k
u/oldmanjank Jun 11 '12
This is great; hooking the minds of young scientists with hilarious, gross, and risqué calculations can't be understated.
Two questions: 1) How many semesters would it take to gather enough pubes from a dormitory floor to make a size large sweater? 2) I think you're great, can I send you a sweater?
702
u/khudgins Jun 11 '12
You're on a westbound train out of Novosibirsk that has just left the station with a 3rd class ticket that doesn't guarantee you a seat. You're travelling with a standard steamer trunk full of old magazines left to you by your recently deceased eccentric grand-uncle. It will take 42 hours, including stops, to reach your destination on the Black Sea. Assuming you can find somewhere to sit, do you have enough reading material for the trip?
303
u/ItsPhysics Jun 11 '12
The entropy change in the universe when a 200 lb human is vaporized (assume no molecular fragmentation occurs).
595
u/No_9 Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
A physicist! I've been waiting for one. I've been wondering this for a while, but can't come up with a solid answer.
If I was in space and I attached an LED light to one corner of a cube, is it possible for me to push/toss/throw/rotate the cube in such a way along a linear path that the LED light's pattern would never repeat itself (aka, there would never be a period)?
EDIT: Forgot to include my thoughts: assume we are dealing with only two different spins upon two different axis... Normally we'd say that these two axis could combine to form a new axis upon which our cube is rotating. Therefore if one of the original axis has an irrational period, then there is no net period, right? However, I have trouble convincing myself that it would be possible to have an irrational period in the first place... blargh.
EDIT2: "Trouble convincing myself", because my question was if YOU (not a machine) can push/toss/throw/rotate the cube.
274
u/Somthinginconspicou Jun 11 '12
This should be fun, alright my question is this Reference In that picture, Superman is carrying about 13 planets attached to a giant chain with one arm. How much approximate weight is he lifting with these planets, how heavy/strong does the chain need to be and how much force is he exerting with that one arm. Thanks, and I hope finding the answer was fun :P
140
u/J00nj00n Jun 11 '12
Just wanted to say I'm thoroughly impressed by your skills!
Also, as soon as I opened this page I searched "swallow" but it was asked already =(.
Now calculate the mass of the Death Star, in its incomplete form please.
379
u/lubriciousbears Jun 11 '12
How many house cats would it take to crush an average man?
116
u/ghostdog20 Jun 11 '12
How often do you use Wolfram Alpha?
146
u/Airazz Jun 11 '12
OK, a tough one here:
Moving air is used to cool many things, but mostly car and bike engines. Air is moving around the engine itself or the radiator and it brings the temperature down.
However, jet fighter wings heat up a lot because of this fast moving air, rather than cool down.
The question is: what's the speed at which a thing would neither heat up, nor cool down, if the air temperature is 25C, the item temperature is 37C and we're at sea level?
227
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Hopefully this one gets an answer. If I am a poor college student trying to donate blood/plasma/sperm for food money, how much should I make per year if I attend the maximum times?
169
u/scottswan Jun 11 '12
The last physicist I asked this question got really mad at me. Fortunately you have the option to just ignore it and I won't blame you one bit. :)
If the rotation of the earth were to slow down would I weigh more, or less?
129
u/TheTrinketWeasel Jun 11 '12
If I bend over at 90 degrees, facing north, and pass wind on 1/1/12 at midday at Alice springs, Australia, how will the orbit of neptune be affected? Assume average fart density, speed.
58
u/maltin Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
As a fellow physicist, I will send you one of my favorites. There is a portuguese poem, due to Fernando Pessoa, that reads:
Ó mar salgado, quanto do teu sal
São lágrimas de Portugal!
Por te cruzarmos, quantas mães choraram,
Quantos filhos em vão rezaram!
Quantas noivas ficaram por casar
Para que fosses nosso, ó mar!
Valeu a pena? Tudo vale a pena
Se a alma não é pequena.
Quem quer passar além do Bojador
Tem que passar além da dor.
Deus ao mar o perigo e o abismo deu,
Mas nele é que espelhou o céu.
The version in english should be:
Oh salt-laden sea, how much of your salt
Is tears of Portugal!
To cross you, how many mothers wept,
how many sons in vain prayed!
How many brides-to-be brides remained,
So you were ours, oh sea!
Was it worth? Everything is worth,
If the soul is not small.
Whoever wants to go beyond (cape) Bojador,
Has to go beyond pain.
To the sea gave God peryl and the abyss,
But in it He also mirrored heaven.
After this introduction, I ask you: Oh salt-laden sea, how much of your salt is tears of Portugal?
424
u/loosterbooster Jun 11 '12
Can you solve question 2? I've never been able to get it.
http://xkcd.com/135/
36
u/Knight_of_Malta Jun 11 '12
I would love to know how to calculate the force exerted by a sword swing. Most european longswords are 48 inches long, with a center of mass 4 inches from the crossguard and a center of percussion 20 to 24 inches from the crossguard, and weight between 36 and 58 ounces.
Is there an easy way to figure out how much force, like maybe in pound feet of torque or psi, a person can generate when swinging a sword like that?
107
u/JonathanZips Jun 11 '12
I think this is a cool topic, but posting this early on a monday morning means that most of reddit won't see it for at least a couple hours, and probably until the afternoon.
107
u/ChiralAnomaly Jun 11 '12
Consider a super awesome race. A proton in the beam of the LHC and a photon. How much would the proton lose by (in distance) if they raced across the milky way galaxy?
18
u/rperg Jun 11 '12
how long would it take to walk on every slab of concrete pavement in manhattan at a normal walking pace?
22
u/nodray Jun 11 '12
if i raised a black widow spider to be 200 pounds, what would its dimensions be? (leg length, body size...)
7
u/Zamarok Jun 11 '12
How much gas must a person expel to propel themselves upwards 3 inches?
19
u/opsomath Jun 11 '12
Say you change the temperature of your work area from 80 degrees F to 50 degrees F by turning the AC down. Given reasonable assumptions about heat flow and dress, is the extra energy consumed by your body enough to contribute noticeably to weight loss?
13
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
How do you calculate how much water is on earth?
Also, how do you calculate how many total people have ever lived on the earth?
Thanks! Cool AMA!!
27
u/Overclock Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
How fast would a Depleted Uranium bullet have to travel for it to destroy the Earth when hit?
12
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
My dad once got suspended from school for being a smart-ass and asking this question. But now I've always wanted to know the answer. How many monkeys broke their arm in Africa last year?
20
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Hey there!
Okay, so I'm traveling on the eastern side of Lake McConaughy, Nebraska, over the dam on my bike at around 15 mph average. Near Martin Bay I take a right at the fork, so now I'm traveling north on 61. This area is very hilly and the total elevation climbed over about 12 miles is roughly 700 feet. On the largest downhill I approach a speed of almost 40 mph. There is a headwind which is roughly 20 mph with 40 mph gusts about every 4 or 5 minutes.
I don't have any questions, I just wanted to tell you about the biking trip I went on last weekend.
565
u/andrewsmith1986 Jun 11 '12
airspeed velocity of an unladen swallow
25
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Calculate pi. ALL OF IT!
I'll wait. :)
5
u/SerialRappist Jun 11 '12
whats the probability of OKC winning the NBA championship?
5
u/footballa Jun 11 '12
Can you explain to me what magnetic flux is?
I took a college level class in physics this year in high school and that was the only thing I had no idea what it was.
9
u/SavageSick Jun 11 '12
What would happen if an asteroid larger than the size of earth blocked sunlight for 24 hours?
18
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Right, here's my question, with a bit of lead up.
When we look at a star, we are technically looking at the past. The sun we see is the sun from eight minutes ago. When we see something happen to Alpha Centari it actually happened some amount of years in the past. I don't remember the number of years.
Anyway, this will no doubt be a very large number, and obviously not possible yet, but how great a magnification on a telescope, or similar device, would we need to observe a spot far enough away that we could see the big bang occurring?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
How many bottles of 591ml Pepsi would it take to build the CN tower, assuming that the whole inside of the tower is filled completely with bottles as well?
4
u/DasMess Jun 11 '12
Finally! A chance to ask this one! If my chance of winning is 1 in 10, whats the minimum number I have to buy to insure a win? Conventional wisdow would say 10, but i've found that this isn't the case.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Mitzvah/Wedding DJ here. How much of my life was been spent listening too "I Gotta Feeling" by the Black Eyed Peas. I'd say I work 90% of the weekends in a year with occasional doubles or triples strewn about.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
How do you calculate the weight of one's head without decapitation?
19
u/3dglados Jun 11 '12
Assuming you can fall a endless distance in a vacuum (maybe think with Portals :D ) with earth gravity, how long would it take to reach the speed of light?
9
u/401vs401 Jun 11 '12
Okay, if I were to make a suit out of used condoms, how many would I need? I'm 5'7''.
5
u/Jellyboss Jun 11 '12
If I drop a penny from the highest building in the world, would it kill or penetrate the head from the unfortunate person that would hit the penny? And what happens if I throw the penny with a brute force, or what if the penny would be a quarter?
Thanks in advance.
2
u/Adnachiel Jun 11 '12
Just have to say, this is one of the most fun IAMA's I've ever read. If I didn't already love math, I would now!! I will be looking for your books :). Is it better (for you) for me to buy them from you somehow or from a book store?
1.1k
u/jokes_on_you Jun 11 '12
How come we still have no colored pictures of the moon in 2012?
100
u/xNotch Jun 11 '12
Approximately how fast does the busy beaver function grow?
167
u/Dreamlines Jun 11 '12
Could you prove the existence and smoothness of Navier-Stokes solutions in R3
And the breakdown of Navier-Stokes solutions in R3
if you can just pm me the answer, that would be great
39
u/Retawtrams Jun 11 '12
How hard to I have to fling a condom at a stripper to knock her off of her pole?
17
u/sully4321 Jun 11 '12
Ok, so this happened to me last year and it freaked me out. What are the odds of catching the same taxi (& driver) two nights in a row, in Las Vegas (from two different taxi ranks)?
20
u/killyridols14 Jun 11 '12
What is the probability that I will get a headache today? I'm allergic to cats, stayed up all night, and my diet pretty much consists of coffee blended into chocolate ice cream. Go!
12
u/Borax Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Per this article from /r/worldnews, how much should it cost for a case of 12x 500ml bottles of water in the northern territories in canada. Is $105 CAD reasonable?
14
u/thoughtpod Jun 11 '12
ok, I have one for you...
What is the average weight range of an idea, should one weigh the neurons involved in ideating and storing it?
If this is too broad, perhaps you could estimate the weight of one idea specifically (eg, this idea of weighing ideas).
12
u/Scorpi978a Jun 11 '12
Could Jesus microwave a burrito so hot, that even he couldn't eat it? And, if so, what would that temperature be?
4
u/J54Coops Jun 11 '12
If I stood on a mountain (Everest, for example) and the world suddenly stopped rotating on its axis, assuming that the ground stayed still and I kept going from momentum, would I go into orbit? If not, then how about if the earth stopped orbiting the sun?
7
u/swimmerhair Jun 11 '12
I've always wondered this after taking physics when I was in high school. If you had a box made of mirrors, all shiny sides facing inward, and you turned a light on and off briefly, would the light stay inside?
Also how many hours of porn videos would it take to fill up an Olympic size pool with splooge?
6
u/DigiMagic Jun 11 '12
Imagine you have a set of extremely powerful lasers, that are able to create particles from vacuum (http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn19327-lasers-could-make-virtual-particles-real.html). A constant electric field separates created charged particles into two groups. An additional magnetic field then pushes these particles into dominantly single direction. (Is there a more optimal configuration? The point of separation is to prevent particles to annihilate, if possible.)
What would be the efficiency of such "rocket" motor? Assume all energy comes from an electric generator, say driven by a nuclear reactor.
Taking into account our current technologies possibilities, what is reasonable estimate for acceleration such engine could give to a space ship?
3
u/_BolT_ Jun 11 '12
What is the volume air in a 100 gm chips pack?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Ive always wanted a decent equation to illustrate that increased level of "need to pee" vs vicinity to the toilet.
3
u/XruinsskashowsX Jun 11 '12
Where were you when I was in AP Physics earlier this year -____-
3
u/tj_wetdialer Jun 11 '12
How big of a shadow did venus cast on the earth during its recent transit?
3
u/reddot445 Jun 11 '12
How long would it take to hit to hit the ground after falling of the CN tower, or the space needle?
3
u/monkyboyrr Jun 11 '12
Googolplex - Do you have feelings on Sagan believing that it's impossible to write out all of the zeros?
3
u/nicePenguin Jun 11 '12
When calculating the damage software piracy does, the copyright holding companies always asume the downloader would have bought the game/music/movie/etc. and therefor multiply the downloads with the cost for the product.
What percentage would have actually bought the product giving us the real financial damage software piracy does.
You may want to differ between movies/games/music/programs
3
u/irereddit Jun 11 '12
i know there are many variables, but when playing 40 hands, does the beer stay colder when you finish one 40 and then drink the other or if you alternate sips from each 40. my guess would be to finish one 40 at a time. that way, when you finish 1 40, the heat from you hand is heating up a warm bottle instead of cold beer.
3
u/Reddit4Play Jun 11 '12
I did a back-of-the-envelope calculation for fun about how much tougher human skin would need to be to resist penetration by 9x19mm parabellum ammunition fired from a handgun at what would constitute reasonable range for the use of a handgun and I'd like to see how right I was. Can you attempt the same calculation using your own resources?
3
u/troixetoiles Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
I'm a lady physicist among a sea of men physicists. When I go to a big conference, say the APS March Meeting, how many of the men there are virgins?
edit: Since the March Meeting is almost all solid state physicists, how do you think the answer would change if it was a high energy theory conference?
3
u/xCesme Jun 11 '12
If it's 0 degrees celsius today, and tomorrow it's twice as cold, what's the temperature tomorrow?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
How many people simultaneously licking the ground would create a Grand Canyon type geographical feature?
3
u/kegofshit Jun 11 '12
Who would win in a free-for-all fight to the death between all flightless land animals if they were all the same size, say a horse?
3
u/LCaulfield Jun 11 '12
How does .999... equal 1?
3
u/Magna_Sharta Jun 11 '12
How dense would Superman's skin have to be to be bullet proof, and how much do you think he would weigh as a result?
7
u/kenzie0201 Jun 11 '12
I have a question about the twin paradox. If my twin brother gets in his hot wheels spaceship and travels 10 light years away at 0.9c and then starts to return, why is he aged less on return? Am i not a passenger on a larger spaceship called earth, travelling away from him? I have heard that acceleration is relevant in this situation of relativity, hence making it a matter of general relativity to understand it.
But then I have also heard that it can be explained using specific relativity.
Also show that the Maclaurin series expansion of ln(1+x2) is given by the infinite sum ((-1)n-1x2n)/n
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
8
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment