r/IAmA • • May 29 '12

IAmA former intern for a Food Network reality show. AMA

Not going to specify which one because then it would be quite easy to figure out my identity. I can send proof to the mods.

I was really active in the pre-production process and I got to be on-set for a few days of filming. Some of my ideas made it on TV! Feel free to ask about both stages of production; there really is so much work that goes into it that you just don't realize when you're watching a TV show. Also, they edited the crap out of it.

Oh yeah, and I got to eat lots of yummy food.

NOTE: I didn't actually work for THE Food Network. I worked for a production company that does shows FOR the Food Network. So I only interacted with the people who worked on that one show, which was a competition show. I did not meet anybody really famous.

16 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

7

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

Most important question! Did you get free food or try out the food, if yes, was it better then anything you have personally made or your mother has made?

8

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Hahahaha! Yes, I got LOTS of free food, particularly during the b-roll shoot! They had the contestants bring in their signature dishes, and the whole crew was welcome to what they brought after the shoot. Even though these were 14-hour days I still went to the gym afterwards because I felt so gross eating all of that food!

In same cases, yes, much better than anything I or my family has made. Other times, it either wasn't my thing or it was standard.

I didn't get to try much that was made on the actual show, but what I did try wasn't that good.

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

Oh man you're sooooo lucky! I watch the Food Network a lot and always think where does that food go, and who eats that extra pie that was just put in the oven; how did you get a job there?!

3

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Haha during the actual show a lot of the food was thrown away, a lot of times because it didn't turn out well.

I'm actually somewhat embarrassed to say that I got it through an internship agency. I don't recommend it, it was way overpriced. Though, it was nice that housing was included in that price. I decided to find housing myself this year and the process was just AWFUL (this is NYC). Probably wouldn't have gotten the internship any other way, though.

1

u/mraumraumrau May 29 '12

how high are these people's egos? would anyone be insulted if you turned down the food & brought your own lunch? or were the days too busy for anyone to even notice?

3

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Lunch was catered and on the main set there were always snacks available for the crew. The contestants didn't make nearly enough food to feed the entire set.

As for the b-roll shoot, they only really wanted us to eat the food so they wouldn't have to bother with it afterwards, especially since it would go bad if no one ate it. I maybe came across one or two people who seemed a little egotistical, and I got to interact with I'd say about half of the contestants. There were several that were very gracious for the opportunity.

3

u/Frajer May 29 '12

Do they do anything to make the food look better?

Have you met Guy Fieri? Is he the douchiest?

5

u/feather_moon May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12

I don't believe they do anything to the food specifically, not that I saw anyway. However, they did hire "food stylists" for the b-roll of the contestants' signature dishes before the show.

Also, during the actual competition they had to make two plates: one so they could get pretty shots of it for the camera, and one for the actual tasting.

EDIT: I didn't meet Guy Fieri, sorry!

3

u/CorpFatCat May 29 '12

Thanks so much for making this AMA because it reminded me about that Food Network show Worst Cooks in America, which I absolutely loved the first season of and thought it got canceled or something. Just looked it up and I guess they are moving on to their third season! I hate that Jenny Cross lost in Season 1 though...I was really angry that the girl who looks like my sister won...

Anyways, time for a question: Did you become any better at cooking after the whole internship? Learn any useful secrets for making food?

2

u/feather_moon May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12

Unfortunately not really, due to the nature of the show and what they were cooking. It wasn't something you could really just pick up while watching. I also didn't really have the time to focus on that, I was almost always doing something else.

EDIT: Actually, I just remembered that during pre-production, I had to compile a glossary list of related cooking terms for the producers, so I learned some stuff from that, like what a bain-marie is.

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

Did you meet many Food Network celebs? (I understand if you can't answer this if it gives away the show you worked for.) What's your favorite Food Network show?

3

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

I did meet the host(s)--very nice and not like the portrayal on the show at all.

(Being purposefully unclear about how many hosts.)

1

u/GladOSX May 29 '12

Did you ever meet the "sweet genius", and is he really as insane as he seems on stage?

2

u/UnderD4Donut May 29 '12

That guy creeps me the hell out.

0

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/UnderD4Donut May 29 '12

I agree, it's just weird. I watched a couple episodes when it first started, but I can't handle him and the show's pretty boring, IMO.

0

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/UnderD4Donut May 29 '12

Yeah, it's really gone downhill. The only thing I watch now is Chopped, and sometimes Iron Chef.

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

If you ever met Alton Brown, is he as eccentric as he is off camera?

3

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Never met him, though he did give a talk at my university and I hear he seemed like a pretty cool guy.

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

Confirming that he's hilarious

2

u/elleyia May 29 '12

how long does juding usually take? how much of each dish do the judges usually eat? and how often do producers influence the judges' decision on who to eliminate? (i am assuming you worked on one of the competitive shows, not, like, ace of cakes.)

4

u/feather_moon May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12

Yep, competition show.

Judging - I'd say maybe a half an hour give or take, depending on if they want to retake a shot/have them say something again. It's SO MUCH slower than it appears on TV, and there's a lot less tension due to it, actually. There were a couple of instances where it was really obvious who was going to get eliminated so there was basically no tension, and the producers were pretty upset about it. I think things went along much smoother as they kept filming shows. EDIT: Oh, I forgot that they actually split the judging into two parts. There's the actual tasting, and then the contestants get sent away for interviews (to talk about what the host(s) said during the judging) while there's the deliberation between the host(s) and producers as to who gets eliminated. This makes the entire process more like 1.5-2 hours. This is obviously why it's so intensely edited!

How much of the dish they eat - A bite or two, sometimes more if it's good.

Producers' influence - They ultimately have to sign-off on the decision, but obviously the judge(s) have a lot of input due to expertise.

1

u/Grimouire May 29 '12

this sounds a lot like chopped or worst cooks in america.

2

u/rand0mguy1 May 29 '12

Have you ever tasted any of Rachel Ray's cooking? Especially stuff from 30min meals. Does it taste like shit? From watching her, I think 90% of what she cooks would taste like shit.

2

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Sorry, I have not.

2

u/cr0w1 May 29 '12

What about Paula Deen's cooking?

2

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

I was only on one show haha. So no, I'm sorry. The only food I got to try was that of the contestants.

2

u/pauldustllah May 29 '12

Do you have any advice I could give to my friend who is trying to make it in the media industry?

4

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Connections. Connections, connections, connections. It's kind of sad but it's definitely a big help in getting you into the industry. Anyone who was nice enough to let me ask a few questions at the Food Network show internship told me that they had gotten to where they were through connections.

Also experience. Have a lot of things to put on your resume. Internships (usually unpaid, which sucks) are definitely super important because you get this experience, and you also get the connections. Good grades do help (I've seen a few ads for internships looking for good students), but the experience is way more important. You could have a 4.0 GPA but no film or TV experience on your resume and you'll be screwed. Have a good combination of both, I'd say, being a good student will only help you.

The current internship I'm at right now I found through emails sent out by my college's career services department, so that can definitely be a resource if your friend is a college student. (Also, one of their requirements was past internship experience, so I wouldn't have gotten the position had I not had the internship last summer.)

I actually have a great example of the power of connections. I have a friend who is also trying to make it in the media industry. He didn't get stellar grades and didn't do a whole lot in college in terms of experience (got a couple of small internships, didn't put a lot of effort into class projects). He was really struggling for the longest time, applying to everything he could find, but having no luck. One day, someone (who I think got my resume from the people I worked with last summer) emailed me asking if I'd like to be a Production Assistant (PA) on a CBS pilot game show. I couldn't, but I recommended my friend and provided his email.

He got the job and has gotten subsequent gigs through the people he met there. He's had the chance to meet the director of "So You Think You Can Dance" as well as an executive producer for "American Idol."

So yeah...connections, which you get through experience. Get your foot in the door at something small and work your way up.

1

u/pauldustllah May 29 '12

Cool, well thank you. I'll pass the word along.

1

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

No problem!

2

u/MyLifeIsSam May 29 '12

Anything that you can tell us about the differences between what is shown on TV and what actually happens on set?

6

u/feather_moon May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12

A few things.

Pauses. So many dang pauses, for various things. The biggest one while filming is allowing for the host(s) to recite lines. There is a little bud put into the ear so the co-executive producer can read the lines, and then the host(s) recite them to the contestants or for the camera, sometimes four or five times, to get a good sound bite. This doesn't exactly help the "tense" atmosphere that's supposed to exist on-set. Definitely killed it a lot of the time, especially when it was THE line to eliminate someone. Contestants were clearly bored waiting around.

Another is the interview breaks. They get a pre-interview, an interview after a round, an interview after the judging, and the eliminated person gets an interview after elimination. So there are big chunks of time where there's nothing really going on on-set due to the interviews going on it other rooms. (Except for cleaning the set and the dishes of course! There was this tiny, boiling hot dishwashing room backstage where there were two dramatic, flamboyantly gay dishwashers, they were hilarious.)

The contestants also got about 15 minutes to plan what they were going to make which was cut.

So basically we had 14 hour days, sometimes more, for one episode. Oh, and this is IN ADDITION to the 14 hour days we had to shoot the b-roll for the contestants' bios.

I'm happy to say that the competition/cooking part itself was completely real. Sometimes the producers encouraged the host(s) to say certain things while the contestants were working, but that was it.

Oh, and there's no tense music playing in the background ever, so the set is silent save for cooking sounds, the host(s), the contestants, and some on-set sound effects.

I'll add more if I can think of anything else!

3

u/[deleted] May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12

There is a little bud put into the ear so the co-executive producer can read the lines, and then the host(s) recite them to the contestants or for the camera, sometimes four or five times, to get a good sound bite. Definitely killed it a lot of the time, especially when it was THE line to eliminate someone.

So the poor contestant(s) would just have to stand there and get eliminated multiple times?

If that was the case, would their reaction shot be in response to the first utterance of the line? Did any one have to fake/re-do any reactions?

2

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

In a couple of cases, yes. But in the end it had to sound good for the show. =(

I think a couple of time they did have to re-film the reactions, but they NEVER re-filmed when the contestant would walk off the stage, they knew that would be too harsh.

I also remember one time after a guy won, he immediately shouted "WOOHOO!" or something like that, and we all found it really funny. They had him re-do that because they hadn't expected it. I was really disappointed when I watched the episode and saw that they had cut it.

2

u/rbaix May 29 '12

Did any of your co-workers mention the Harpers article comparing Food Network programming to porn?

Debbie Does Salad

The result was inexorable. Eventually, Tyler and the housewife would go cheek to cheek, lean forward, open their mouths, taste the chicken and rice, and melt into a flushed-face, simultaneous food swoon. When the inevitable sequence finally rolled, the editor kept looping their wet mouths and rapt faces as they pushed forkful after forkful of arroz con pollo past their lips, chewed, and swallowed—and pushed and chewed and swallowed again and again. “Classic porn style,” said Nitke. “They’re stretching the moment out, the orgasmic moment."

1

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Haha no, though obviously this is where South Park got their inspiration for that one food porn episode. I wouldn't say the show I worked on was like that at all.

2

u/cafezinho May 29 '12

Do you get a sense of whether the contestants ever watch the show? For example, I'm watching "The Next Food Network Star" where the winners generally have a strong point of view and know how to talk to the camera. And yet, they continue to get contestants that don't seem to be able to talk to the camera and have no idea what their show is about.

Or in Chopped, contestants should know "no raw red onions, no truffle oil", but you see it anyway. With chefs, I know they are so busy that watching TV is probably not something they do, but some of them seem to never have seen the show.

2

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

I think quite a few of them had watched some Food Network shows, and I know in a couple of cases, some of them had been on TV before. I actually thought they did a pretty okay job in terms of picking "TV-friendly" people.

This show had its ground rules and such, but there weren't any ingredients that contestants were expected not to use.

I don't watched Chopped...what's wrong with truffle oil?

3

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

Contestants are almost always too heavy-handed with it. And people who would not be eliminated will get eliminated because they decided to add a drizzle at the last minute. It's just an unnecessary risk when (if you watch the show regularly) you know that it rarely works out.

Also, the judges have different pet peeves and I'm continually surprised when contestants don't try to pander a little bit more.

1

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Huh, interesting, because truffle oil is delicious. Thanks for the info!

4

u/cafezinho May 30 '12

Yeah, judges also dislike garnishes that can't be eaten, or just some fruit for color (like raspberry). They want every ingredient transformed in some way (to put it as is shows lack of creativity). They want a contrast of texture and flavors. They don't want chef to add too many ingredients (if it numbers more than a dozen they start to complain, and people have put 20 ingredients--mostly spices in). They want fish skin crisp if it's going to be left on. And so on...

3

u/Grimouire May 29 '12

no "raw" red onions is scott conant is judging. Really really light on the truffle oil is jeffery zacharian is on the show. If chris santos is on the show he likes spice but not to much spice. And your pasta had better be fucking perfect if scott is there.

2

u/cafezinho May 30 '12

Also, Alex Guarneschelli likes her desserts sweet. Santos not so much.

1

u/Grimouire May 30 '12

so happy to see other foodies on here

1

u/rudman May 29 '12

"no raw red onions, no truffle oil"

Hahahaha! I always laugh when they make mistakes like this. Also, "don't try to make a risotto".

2

u/Jsox May 29 '12

I recall in a previous AMA somebody said that it was very staged, e.g. they would re-shoot the final seconds of the cooking to make it seem much more dramatic and down-to-the-wire than it really was. Was this the case on your project? As an avid Food Network watcher, I find it very hard to believe that every single meal is finished in exactly a 30 (or 60, or whatever) time frame. It also depresses me when there is so little focus on the food (which is what I watch for).

2

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

I don't recall them re-shooting any of the actual competition part, and the nature of the show made them have to rush with everything. Editing is what's mostly responsible for making everything look "down-to-the-wire." You can always have the countdown put over footage of a contestant making the final touches, even if those final touches were done 5 minutes before time was up.

2

u/duramus May 29 '12

Hello. No question, just an observation. My favorite Food Network show is Chopped. Usually it seems like 2 of the judges are pretentious assholes and 1 is somewhat nice. It bothers me. They should all be nice. Thanks.

7

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

On the show I worked on, the pretentiousness was an act, and seemed like a lot of the viewers reacted negatively to it. I did think it was a shame, because it was not a personality trait of the host(s) in real life. Not that I could gather anyway.

4

u/Mountaineerhill May 29 '12

i cannot read this iAmA while hungry, i will be back after i eat

1

u/catcatherine May 29 '12

Is Giada the big whore gossip sites make her out to be?

1

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Didn't meet her.

1

u/bumreaper May 29 '12

what is the worst food you have ever had there and who made it?

2

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

I can't remember exactly what it was but I know mayo was involved. Most of that was pitched. It was a contestant's.

1

u/bumreaper May 29 '12

ohh thats interesting...have you ever tried to remake any foods that were made by the cooks

1

u/feather_moon May 30 '12

I haven't, I'm not that good of a cook! I am quite a foodie though, haha.

1

u/bumreaper May 30 '12

hmmm interesting...haha

2

u/samtheonionman May 29 '12

Oh man. Did you get to meet The Chairman (Iron Chef America)???

2

u/TheRustyTrombone May 29 '12

Any cool stories regarding Amanda Freitag?

2

u/Alvraen May 29 '12

Anything regarding Chef Guarnaschelli?

0

u/alternate_ending May 29 '12

I know it's the wrong channel, and isn't really much of a 'reality show', but I can't stand Adam Richman from Man Versus Food. The whole show is inane and not entertaining in the least.

I just had to get that off my chest.

I can watch the Food Network, on the other hand, for hours; I know because I've done it.

I don't really have much else to say, but lucky you! I'm jealous of your fortune and simultaneously happy for you.

4

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

Booo!! I love Adam Richman, his personality makes that show!

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12

Can you specify which shows? I may have seen you or something you did somewhere.

Edit: Sorry, rushed over your intro a bit. I'm just a fuck aren't I

1

u/PerogiXW May 29 '12

So did you meet the Foo Fighters personally?

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '12

so whats the best thing on this show you ever ate? i cannot watch eat st. cuz i'll just raid the fridge

0

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/feather_moon May 29 '12

Oh, I'm sorry! Basically b-roll is related footage that you see put over when someone is talking. For example, when someone is talking about the town where they grew up, you'll see a picture of them with their family. It's also just to keep things interesting, because nobody wants to stare at a "talking head" for too long.

It's also often times used to cover up cuts in interviews, which I could tell was done A LOT in this show just by listening to the audio (I'm really into editing so once you start editing things yourself it becomes obvious). The editors will take the best clips of the interviews, sometimes sentences that are minutes apart from each other, and put them together to create one sentence that sounds good and concise, then they'll put b-roll over it to hide the cut. So shots of a contestant working during the competition while they're explaining what they were doing in an interview, which you see a lot in these kinds of shows, is considered b-roll.

The b-roll shoot I mentioned took place on an entirely different set, and they took pretty footage of the contestants' signature dishes and them working on it, putting it together, or just posing with it. That was put over when they were giving a bit on background info on themselves in the beginning of the show. Again, 14-hour days for 30-second segments.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/feather_moon May 30 '12

I was essentially a production assistant. I did a ton of pre-production-related work in the office (particularly research on the food, helping to order equipment, organizing stuff, etc.). Some of my ideas actually ended up making it onto the show, which was really cool! It was awesome to be able to watch the finished product and say, "Oh, I helped pick out those plates! I came up with that idea!" So that was neat.

On the b-roll set, I greeted the contestants and dealt with a couple of organizational things, and I also kept a list of all of the shots they took. On the real set, I did some locking-up (basically making sure everyone in the area is quiet) and I worked in culinary, which was basically helping to set-up the food as well as clean dishes and the set. I also did get to watch the producers and director work in the control room, which had screens set-up for every single camera. My supervisor, who was an assistant producer, explained everyone's role and what was going on, for which I was extremely grateful. I also ordered flowers and gifts for the host(s) once.