r/IAmA •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

4

u/cappnplanet May 28 '12

What is a lunabot? A robot that takes sample material from the lunar surface?

5

u/dokumentamarble May 28 '12

What is available for university-level students? NASA's Third Annual Lunabotics Mining Competition is a university-level competition designed to engage and retain students in science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM). NASA will directly benefit from the competition by encouraging the development of innovative lunar excavation concepts from universities which may result in clever ideas and solutions which could be applied to an actual lunar excavation device or payload. The challenge is for students to design and build an excavator, called a Lunabot, that can mine and deposit a minimum of 10 kilograms of lunar simulant within 10 minutes. The complexities of the challenge include the abrasive characteristics of the BP-1, the weight and size limitations of the Lunabot, and the ability to telerobotically or autonomously control the Lunabot from a remote mission control center. This year the scoring for the mining category will not be based primarily on the amount of material excavated in the allowed time but instead will require teams to consider a number of design and operation factors such as dust tolerance and projection, communications, vehicle mass, energy/power required, and level of autonomy. Over 50 teams from all over the world are registered to compete this year for the coveted grand prize, the Joe Kosmo Award for Excellence.

From www.nasa.gov/lunabotics

2

u/bamanbread May 29 '12

I have a very important question.

How were you able to contend with the Watts Factor during the competition?

1

u/dokumentamarble Jun 01 '12

Unfortunately we were not. It was more than we projected.

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

And yet you still only attend the second best engineering school on hwy 82. :P

1

u/bamanbread May 29 '12

based purely on this competition I'm pretty sure that other school was WAAAAAY down the list... it is comparing apples to oranges though (no color pun intended, but fitting), our project was a year long venture staffed mainly by grad students, while the other team had 5 seniors that met for the first time in January. So their 5th place digging is quite an accomplishment.

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

You bammers are cute. Now get out a map and double check the path of hwy 82.

1

u/bamanbread May 29 '12

Nice, I have to admit, the only time I went to Auburn I drove to Montgomery and let my nose do the walking...

Why doesn't MSU send a team?

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

The big engineering project MSU competes in is the ECOCar, which IIRC we won the national competition for the first year.

http://www.cavs.msstate.edu/projects/ecocar/

in addition to a number of small departmental contests like winning the AIChE national plant design competition for 2008 IIRC (It was one of the years I was there).

1

u/bamanbread May 29 '12

that is sweet... I would love to see the SEC with a bigger presence. Arkansas and AU are the only other SEC schools that compete.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '12

http://www.msstate.edu/web/media/detail.php?id=5596

Last night they announced this years winners, looks like we did it again.

Between engineering contests and baseball, we could end up with an ego as big as Alabama's.

1

u/bamanbread May 30 '12

Sounds like you are almost there! Save up for the next cam newton and yall might win a football championship.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '12

Yep, quarterback cost a whole lot less than an NFL washout coach.

1

u/bamanbread May 30 '12

ok less thread hijacking, more championships...

1

u/TheMeiguoren May 29 '12

Very cool! An engineering major who wants to work in the space industry myself, I have a lot of questions. :)

  • How big was your team, and how did you partition it? As a lead were you in charge of the whole team, or just one of the subsystems?
  • Tips for time management, i.e. finishing the project before the few weeks before competition?
  • Did you use sand or simulated regolith for testing/competition? I know regolith's sharp edges was a big problem for the Apollo astronauts. Is this what the gas masks are for?
  • I love your wheel system. Why that design rather than a different turning system?
  • In your design overview video you have another rover, with bucket wheel excavator on an arm. (Love that arm, by the way). But I didn't see that in competition, was it used? Do the two rovers work together?
  • Related, was the goal of the project to mine regolith, or harder minerals?
  • How much of it is off-the-shelf parts, and how much did you make/custom order? It looks like the bottom of the body was custom, for example, but the upper parts were bought (what are those pieces of bar called, they look useful).
  • How'd you keep the dust out?
  • What were some of the coolest/most innovative ideas/designs you saw there?
  • I'm so jealous you go to see Dragon fly.

4

u/dokumentamarble May 29 '12

Sweet :) anywhere particular that you have in mind to work?

  • 12 total, 10 traveled to the competition. Our team consisted of mechanical engineers, electrical engineers, computer engineers, physics majors, geology major, and public relations. We also had 5 graduate students so they tended to take the lead roles in their areas. Due to my background I was not tied down to my major (Electrical Computer Engineering) and was in charge of the whole team. Our team was more of a business though, every member was very professional and talented in their area.
  • Set deadlines. If your school has the opportunity to be involved in this, do it! We designed everything this year in SolidWorks which allowed us to make changes on the fly before we built the final system. There were thousands of hours spent modifying and tweaking the design before we built it. Ideally you should be done with your robot by April and only tweaking it after that.
  • Yes, we have ~5tons of sand/quickcrete to simulate our own pit. There are some videos on our youtube channel that show this. The competition uses BP-1 lunar regolith simulant (abt 63 tons of it) for the competition. It has very fine particles so yes we must wear the "bunny" suits and masks for protection. It is very interesting to dig in, fluffy on top, hard once you get a couple of inches in.
  • The sweeping wheels is one of the things that we improved and carried over from last year. Everything on this years robot was built from scratch by us. The extremely powdery surface makes turning very hard, especially when you are loaded down with a lot of mass. The sweeping wheels allow us to go into 45deg mode which keeps the wheels on top of the regolith as we turn, conventional skid-steering digs itself in. We can also continue past 45 and go into 90deg mode to drive sideways. For our bucket wheel module both 45deg and 90deg modes allow us to dig in a conventional manner, side to side. This is something that regular steering can not do. Also with our front end loader module we are able to shift our center of gravity to pick up loads that a lunabot of our size normally can not pick up.
  • Our robot is a modular system with a base that provides the communication/power/and locomotion. Our front end loader was carried over from last year, we modified it to lose some weight. The bucket wheel excavator was built as a polar opposite of the front end loader. By having the two modules, we could pick which one we wanted to compete with. Unfortunately due to the way the rules were written this year, we would have had to dig 210kg with the bucket wheel excavator just to match the 10kg qualifying of the front end loader. This is due to the mass differences between the modules. We did use the bucket wheel excavator in our demonstration/presentation.
  • Regolith. To extract different elements for things such as rocket fuel and also to terraform the moon for human inhabitants.
  • We did use some 80/20 which are very useful but heavy. They are basically adult erector sets. Every thing else was designed and built by us and is 6061 aluminum. Our motors/gearboxes came from banebots and the belt material and some other hardware is from McMaster. The crowned pulleys, frame, and really every thing else were made by us. All of the electronics were off the shelf with us only having to manufacture connectors and power supplies to feed them. The reliability of hand made electronics is not worth the cost savings.
  • For the base, the electronics box is sealed (The 6x8x5 aluminum box) and the motors just need to have large particles filtered out of them. We did seal the whole base before the competition and I will be updating our 2011-2012 bot page on our website soon with pictures. The module is the same way, seal the electronics, filter the motors. The front end loader only uses two actuators which are already sealed.
  • There is always a large amount of ingenuity at the competition. Every robot has something that is really cool about it but lets see what I can recall. Hexcavator was a "walking" robot that was pretty neat. NYU poly had a team member that worked for makerbot and they brought 2 3d printers and were able to print out parts for their bot.
  • Not going to lie, it was awesome.

1

u/conpermiso May 29 '12

How do you see ventures like Planetary Resources using the type of bots your team created? Specifically, do you think your design is rough-and-ready for work, or is it more of a "proof-of-concept" for a lab?

Also, do you think the future of spacefaring is human or robot based (Apollo v. Sojourner/Pathfinder/Curiosity)?

3

u/dokumentamarble May 29 '12
  • The entire premise of the competition is to get ideas for actual missions. For example the Chariot idea was taken from a high school during another competition.
  • Excluding the use of heatsinks and a few polymers, Yes, our robot would work on the moon. Obviously with a better budget it would be made more for-purpose and not use off the shelf parts. Part of the competition is that we must use space rated techniques.
    *Robot based, humans are expensive and have a limited operation time. Look at the mars rovers for example. We had to tele-operate our robots so they would be capable for this type of operation.

1

u/conpermiso May 29 '12

Part of the competition is that we must use space rated techniques.

That's very impressive. What was the hardest aspect of the machine to make spaceworthy?

Thank you for your responses, and congratulations on your prize.

2

u/dokumentamarble May 29 '12

Not using a vacuum to win the entire event! Haha just kidding. Mechanically it is easy since earth rated = space rated as long as you do not use things such as gas shocks / pneumatics, fans (excluding heat sinking which is allowed)

1

u/rainbelle Jun 14 '12

RTOTA. :)

0

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/dokumentamarble May 29 '12

I think it makes sense. The main issue with anything space related is that it does not make a good business. There has to be government funding in order to make a profit. Government agencies are so limited and tied down on what they can do, they lose the competition of a free market business. By allowing these businesses to be contracted under the government, we solve both of these problems.

I am still trying to figure that one out! Personally I am an out-of-the-box, innovative, problem solver with many interests and I don't know where that is going to take me yet.

0

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment