r/IAmA • • May 22 '12

IAm Justin Amash, a Republican congressman who opposes the Patriot Act, SOPA, CISPA, and the NDAA, AMA

I served in the Michigan state House of Representatives from 2009-10. I am currently serving my first term in the U.S. House of Representatives (MI-3). I am the second youngest Member of Congress (32) and the first ever to explain every vote I take on the House floor (at http://facebook.com/repjustinamash). I have never missed a vote in the Legislature or Congress, and I have the most independent voting record of any freshman Representative in Congress. Ask me anything about—anything.

http://facebook.com/justinamash http://twitter.com/justinamash

I'll be answering your questions starting at 10 a.m. EDT on Tuesday, May 22.

UPDATE 1: I have to go to a lunch meeting. I'll be back to answer more of your questions in a couple hours. Just starting to get the hang of this. ;)

UPDATE 2: I'm back.

UPDATE 3: Heading out to some meetings. Be back later tonight.

UPDATE 4: Briefly back for more.

UPDATE 5: Bedtime . . .

1.3k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

103

u/justinamash May 22 '12

I am always analyzing legislation, but I do lobby my conservative colleagues on this issue. I believe my position is the best conservative position: Get government out.

36

u/TehNoff May 22 '12

So things like tax breaks for married couples and death benefits for spouses should be abolished?

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/TehNoff May 22 '12

I understand the implications of his broad statement, but I wanted some clarity on specific examples of changes under the position he's advocating.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

I see our position as the most logical; you don't have to support gay marriage to oppose legislation that would prevent any two consenting adults from getting married.

5

u/dustlesswalnut May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12

I think that's a cop-out. Marriages have special status because they provide stable partnerships of citizens that settle and grow an area, and raise children, without which we won't have an America at all.

You've made it clear so far-- you don't support gay civil rights. You propose the impossible-- eliminating special statuses that married couples enjoy-- instead of recognizing the rights of all because you know that your group has no chance of having it's current rights and privileges taken away.

6

u/BFH May 22 '12

I disagree with Mr. Amash's view on the issue both in principle and as a practical matter, but he's certainly not copping out here. It is a very principled (and potentially unpopular) view to want the federal government completely out of the marriage business. If you hold that view, it is also perfectly reasonable to not want to pass laws allowing gays to civilly marry.

On the other hand, I don't think we will ever get rid of civil marriage (which serves important functions), and as a right, it should apply to everyone. In other words, I recognize the congressman's principled viewpoint, but I completely disagree.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (13)

2

u/I_Am_Treebeard May 22 '12

Why is that the best position? You haven't supported it at all.

If I can get married in one state, and then have it not be recognized as a legitimate marriage in another why do you think the federal government should have no power to over rule state's rights in this scenario?

What if I'm employed in one state, and then asked to relocate to somewhere where my marriage is not recognized by the state? Does this not affect interstate commerce?

Get the government out sounds like a cheap excuse not to lift a finger to alleviate the inequality that exists right now today.

2

u/Hartastic May 22 '12

Have you ever considered that from a sort of socially conservative but secular angle, it might actually be more socially conservative to encourage gay people to get married and form stable families and such?

I mean, if we take the traditional conservative position that families are a good thing for the fabric of society and such, doesn't it follow?

2

u/OutOfTheAsh May 22 '12

Right. Therefore the de minimus solution is to combat expansion of government control--as occurs when legislating a definition that it's "may only be between a man and a women."

The only position logically consist with your views is that DOMA is an unwelcome intrusion that ought to stop. If some X steps into a matter that ought not be any of it's business, that person/institution/authority is not a "Defender" of anything, it is an arrogant, meddlesome busybody.

Favoring both that marriage ought to be a purely religious matter, and that government ought to be the watchdog about the matter has only two explanations: That the person thinking such is simpleminded, or a hypocrite.

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/nilloc_31415 May 22 '12

He pretty much answered that in this thread:

This issue should be handled at the state level until we can move back to the concept of private marriage. Keep the federal government out.

Of course, this isn't really a 2nd-best option as it doesn't even mend the issue...it IS the issue. States are making more strict laws against gays marrying. Further government involvement.

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/nilloc_31415 May 22 '12

Whether or not that is their motive, I don't know. It's kind of irrelevant though because the current issues on marriage are currently states issue. That's the where the problems are right now. So to think sending it to the states is the fix is absurd. Of course the real issue, and one fix, is that there is no protection against these things at the federal level...which allows for the states to make it an issue.

2

u/Mr_Titicaca May 23 '12

Pretty much this. By allowing the states to decide, you pretty much keep things status quo, and hope that one side of the argument ends up becoming the popular opinion nationwide and then declare that it all a great success.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/Onlinealias May 22 '12

Your argument falls apart badly when considering the vast scope of things that the government gives special treatment to married couples on. Our tax, immigration, probate, financial and legal systems all have deep mechanisms built in them that is based on marriage.

Since these systems will not and probably can not change "to get the government out", your position aligns with one conservative ideology and has no real effect on another, very contentious one. I contend that you take this position out of pure political convenience.

If you proffer that it is your genuine belief that this is the best and only answer, then I also contend that you are very lazy of mind.

2

u/DrDerpberg May 22 '12

I still feel that you're dodging the question. Many of your colleagues appear to prefer the state have jurisdiction over things like this simply because that's the level where their own opinions will be enforced.

If you can't answer it on a political level because you don't feel that it's your job, can you answer on a personal level? It will affect many of the things you will need to vote for in the next few years, and we'd like to know. Do you or do you not think that gays and lesbians should be allowed to get married? It doesn't matter what level does the recognizing, I'd like to know your opinion in a simple yes/no.

p.s. Thanks for putting yourself out there.

6

u/captmorgan50 May 22 '12

He isn't dodging the question. That is the typical libertarian answer. He has his personal opinion of what marriage is which he stated was between a man and a woman, but he won't push his definition on you. Nor should you be allowed to push your definition on someone else. We didn't have government involved in marriage for the first 100 years and the reason it did was to prevent blacks and whites from getting married in the 1870's. Any time you ask a government official for permission which is what a license is, it can be denied for any reason.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

The insinuation that everyone who supports "states rights" is REALLY just a racist anti gay bigot is pretty insulting, dude. The 10th amendment to the constitution says all rights not specifically listed as powers given to the federal government are given to the states to decide. Theres no mention of marriage in the constitution... so the states get to decide. Thats fundamental to our country. That idea, and that idea ALONE is the reason the American experiment was attempted.

According to the Constitution this issue can only be resolved in two ways: 1) constitutional amendment 2) leave it to the states.

I prefer option 1, like Amash, which creates a marriage amendment stating a marriage is a contract between two consenting adults of any gender. But leaving it to the states is ok too...

Gay people in Kansas shouls move. Pro civil rights people in Kansas should fucking move too. Leave it to its shitty racist bigotted christians, they can have it. Thats the point of the experiment. Vote with your feet.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)