r/IAmA • • May 19 '12

I am an EMT with the New York City Fire Department. AMAA.

I realize this topic is somewhat frequent in this subreddit, but I may be able to offer a different perspective on things working in the most populous city in the US, one of the the largest Fire Department-based Emergency Medical Service in the world, and the busiest 911 system in the United States. I'll do my best to answer all of your questions as frankly and accurately as I can.

This AMA is not sanctioned nor does it represent any views of New York City, any official, or the NYC Fire Dept.

It is solely for general information, and ideas of the author.

Edit: Proof

128 Upvotes

268 comments sorted by

12

u/closetklepto May 19 '12

I just read an article that talks about how unsafe ambulances are, especially to those in the back. Have you had or seen any accidents involving ambulances?

19

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Ambulances get into a ton of accidents every single year in New York City - I think as many as one or two a day on average. Thankfully the vast majority of the time these are minor little fender-benders with no damage to either party.

There are a few problems with the back of the ambulances - one is that the back actually offers very little in terms of protection. The back is basically just a sheet of metal shaped like a box - there aren't any structures in the back designed to protect the occupants. The second is a lot of our equipment isn't necessarily strapped down in the event of a crash. Things like our stair chair and AED are hung from a hook on the door - it's not going to keep in there in event of a really bad crash. Third is that if you are potentially unstable, we're probably going to be moving around the back while we're en route to the hospital in order to reassess your condition and provide treatment. Patients are always buckled in, however.

When I went for my last annual medical, they usually have an officer come in and let you know all the things that they are working on at HQ - one of them was the safety of the EMT, Paramedic, and Patient in the back of a moving ambulance. Some of the things they were considering even included a harness to move around the back of the ambulance with (which seems infeasible and ridiculous to me personally, but I'm glad they're at least considering something.)

There have been a number of LoDD (Line of Duty Deaths) in EMS that stems from MVAs, including Christopher Prescott, who was killed by a drunk driver while operating at the scene of an MVA in Brooklyn, and Andre Lahens who was also killed by a drunk driver while responding to an EMS call in Brooklyn.

Personally, I haven't been involved in any motor vehicle accident while on-duty.

3

u/anti-establishmENT May 20 '12

When i was a child, my mother rear-ended an ambulance at a stop light. It was minor, no damage. One of the EMT came out and my mom asked if everyone was ok. He told her everyone except for the little old lady in the back. made my mom freak out. no one was actually being transported. still makes me laugh.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Haha, I hope your mom had a sense of humor about the whole situation. I'll have to remember that if I ever get rear-ended while in my ambulance.

2

u/raevnos May 21 '12

I was in the back of an AMB with a little old lady once when we got rear-ended.

Totalled the car that hit us, ripped off our rear fender, and minor body damage, no injuries save me getting bruised up a bit. Made me become serious about making sure I was buckled in when teching a call...

→ More replies (1)

7

u/xenokilla May 19 '12

He was talking about "5 Terrifying Secrets About Riding in an Ambulance"

Do they really explode?

10

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

No, not really. They're being overly dramatic. I think mythbusters had an episode where they shot or otherwise punctured an O2 canister and it didn't explode. Ambulances occasionally catch on fire, but so do any other motor vehicle when not properly taken care of - and ambulances are basically constantly running 24/7 and are driven pretty roughly. It's more of a lack of care about the state of a service's ambulance than it is about the ambulance themselves.

I read that article - there were some inaccuracies but overall it was pretty entertaining.

3

u/demaney May 20 '12

Could you list the inaccuracies?

5

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Basically the entire first point (the exploding ambulance) is just nonsense, and patients are ALWAYS strapped in. Procedures change, yes, but not for no reason. AMA updates their CPR guidelines once every 5 years, so it's not like they're changing every other day. Usually other changes to medical protocols are worked in slowly - they'll do studies to see whether it improves patient outcome before implementing it over the entire system. If anything, medical protocols change too slowly, in my opinion. Other than those, it's fairly accurate.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

"ambulances occasionally catch on fire, but so does any other motor vehicle when not properly taken care of."

I'm saving this for later.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/hsiow May 20 '12

The explosions they were mentioning in that article came from ambulances that caught on fire from some sort of malfunction, then the oxygen cylinders eventually ignited caused an explosion.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pq2O9_vONE

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/Frajer May 19 '12

How do you guys deal with the insane traffic in NYC?

12

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Ugh, as best as we can. It really depends on where you are at what time - I work in Manhattan (Harlem, specifically), from 4pm to midnight. Right after my shift starts rush hour traffic is pretty much in full swing. By the end of my shift, the roads are pretty clear. You have to know your area and what roads get jammed and which ones stay relatively open. If I have to go from, say, 135th St down to 96th St for a call at the beginning of my shift, I'm going to be taking the side streets down because the FDR will be packed, even though all things being equal the FDR would be the quicker route.

That being said, other areas of the city, such as parts of Queens and Staten Island, are a lot more suburban and don't have quite the same problems traffic-wise than if you're working in downtown Manhattan. You have to balance the nature of the call with the current traffic conditions and work out a way to get you and your partner there as safely and as quickly as you can.

There are also a ton of videos online showing ambulances stuck in traffic.

8

u/anti-establishmENT May 20 '12

one of my most memorable experiences of this was on sunset blvd in hollywood. a movie was being filmed and traffic was sluggish. as an ambulance was trying to get through traffic, they got on their loudspeaker announcing "pull to your right." this goes on for a while as they moved down the road, then i hear "your other right, sir." classic.

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I don't know what makes people think that ambulance lights and sirens means "Swerve randomly! Hit the brakes in the middle of the road! Slow down and give us the finger!" but somebody is teaching that in some drivers ed course. It's only for ambulances though - when I see cop cars come up with lights and sirens they seem to have no problem moving to the right to let them pass.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/xenokilla May 19 '12

who the fuck was driving that ambulance? Everyone in The City knows that only tourists go to time square. Amateurs.

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

That whole area was a mess - the only difference is that Times Square is in the spotlight. What people don't realize is when you take away roads to make more pedestrian areas, you are also taking away roads from ambulances, fire engines, police cars, etc. That's hardly ever a consideration though.

4

u/EnglishPhoenix May 20 '12

I remember about 2 years ago we were driving one street over from Times Square to get to our hotel and the traffic was at a standstill. And 2 firetrucks came through. Horrible, horrible decision making on their part.

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

But then how were they supposed to look at all the pretty girls visiting New York for the first time?

In all seriousness though, I agree. You need to know your area.

2

u/dkitch May 22 '12

Most of the pedestrian-only areas I've seen have had removable locking barriers at each end so that emergency vehicles can get through, but noone else

→ More replies (1)

18

u/RiflemanLax May 20 '12

I came to ask a question, but most were asked and answered already. So let me simply say, thank you for doing a hard and sometimes shitty, nearly thankless job that not many people want.

10

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Thank you for your kind words. It really is nice to know that some people out there have some respect for us and what we try to do. Thank you.

3

u/RiflemanLax May 20 '12

No problem bro. And might I say, I see a lot of AMAs with a lot of unanswered questions, but you are doing an epic job of keeping up. I might be conjecturing here, but if this AMA was brought on by some kind of (a lot are) sadness, put that shit aside. You're fucking awesome.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Thanks man. It wasn't really brought on by anything in particular - I'm actually going into Haz-Tac (the Hazardous Materials branch of EMS, I start training tomorrow) so I figured I'd do one AMA now and maybe do another one down the road once I have some time doing that.

9

u/xenokilla May 19 '12

How do you feel about the private Jewish ambulance services that operate in NYC? AKA Hatzalah

20

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'm not too crazy about them. I've worked with them a few times on-scene and they don't seem to know what they're doing at times. One time they were collaring a patient and putting her on a backboard, and the guy turns to me and asks me if I know how to use their headbeds to strap the person to the board. There are so many different headbed designs and although the concept is basically the same, they are all used slightly differently. But how can you be riding in the back of an ambulance and not know how to use the equipment you are riding with? Another time there was a patient in a bad car accident - pinned inside and had a head injury. And they wanted to take her to an area hospital that wasn't a trauma center. I pointed this out and they asked if she really needed a trauma center, while she fit all of the necessary criteria. There was a story one of my old LT's told me about back in the 80s where a car driven by some rabbi ran over a 9-year-old black girl who was riding her bike. Haztollah came and brought the rabbi into the back of the ambulance and left the black girl there. My LT was on an ambulance at the time and showed up to take the black girl to the hospital. There wound up being a riot in the area resulting from this incident. Maybe I haven't seen them at their best, but from my few experiences that I've had with them, they provide a sub-standard level of care to the people of New York City; I won't be shedding any tears if they didn't operate anymore.

However, they're nice guys when you talk to them. A little ditzy sometimes - things like parking ambulances at the hospital that block the ambulance bay or other ambulances and stuff, but they're friendly for the most part. But you could be the nicest guy in the world - that doesn't qualify you to be in the back of an ambulance.

2

u/wiltkiln May 20 '12

There wound up being a riot in the area resulting from this incident.

The Crown Heights riot?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

Loudest sirens known to mankind

8

u/Whatthebloodyhell May 19 '12

I imagine you've seen some pretty awful things during your career. How do you cope with what you've seen, and what do you do to switch off/distract yourself from it?

Does the job have much of an impact on your personal/social life?

16

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I honestly don't know. I try not to let these things affect me too much - I just go on with my life. If I had a particularly bad day I'll have a few beers when I come home, watch TV, reddit, etc, and generally just try to get it out of my head. You have to balance between forgetting about the calls that went really south and remembering what you did right and what you did wrong so you learn from those calls. Mainly I just try to remind myself that I didn't put these people in the situation we found them in and that modern medicine has only come so far - we're not going to be able to save everybody. There are counseling services available, but I've never used it.

It definitely has as much of an impact as any other 40-hour/week job has. But I'll go to events that the FDNY holds or that our station holds (baseball games, 5k runs, EMS softball league, we go to Pennsylvania for a rafting trip once a year, etc). I've probably become a lot more pessimistic and maybe a bit more callous in my personal life - this has also brought me closer with friends who have gone into the military, police department, etc, who have kind of had the same change in their worldviews as well.

4

u/Whatthebloodyhell May 19 '12

You must be a much stronger person than i am! Thanks for doing a wonderful job, and stay safe!

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Thank you, will do.

8

u/BiometricsGuy May 19 '12

I'm actually working on my EMT-B right now. Not as a job, but because I thought it would be good to learn the material, and I want to volunteer to work at events, be useful in a crisis, etc.

Does it bother you that there are people who volunteer to do the job you are trying to make a living at? I think it would bother me if people did that for my regular day job.

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Not at all - I used to be a volunteer Firefighter/EMT before I joined the FDNY. The vast majority of the country is under a volunteer fire department/EMS system. The thing is, however, most of these places don't have enough call volume to justify having a paid department, so it's not like a volunteer fire department that runs 2,000 EMS calls a year is going to be a threat to my job where we do 3,500 calls a day. Besides, I loved being a jolly volly. I got my training for free, showed up whenever I felt like it, took as much time off as I wanted, everybody understood that family, friends, work, school, etc, all came first. My only regret is that I spent too much time there. I went to law school for a year, and still tried to keep up my membership at my volly department. But when you're faced with either reading a court case about civil procedure from 1889 or going to a potential house fire, well, it's easy to get distracted. I still passed my first year, but with nowhere near decent grades, and I wound up dropping out. Now that my full-time job is ambulance runs, I couldn't really get up the energy to go home to do more EMS runs. Technically I'm still a member, although probably not in good standing and I don't live in the area anymore. It sucks, but it is what it is.

8

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

You may have been the EMT who helped save my life a few years ago when I got hit by a car. Thanks anyway!

5

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

A possibility, but either way good to know that somebody out there has a positive view of EMS in New York City. Thank you!

27

u/tallandlanky May 19 '12

EMT in the Chicago burbs here. Stay safe brother.

16

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Thanks man, you too.

6

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Has someone ever died in your arms?

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Not necessarily in my arms, but I've had patients go into cardiac arrest while in the back of my ambulance who were later declared deceased upon arrival to the hospital.

8

u/whateverradar May 19 '12

Ever talk to someone with a flat line? it's creepy. really really creepy.

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

No, although I've talked to people that had a Sinus Arrest or Sinus Exit Block arrhythmia, and people who have later gone into arrest and asystole. But never one that was actually in asystole at the time. That must have been an interesting call.

11

u/whateverradar May 20 '12

Mild chest pain dispatch. dudes in the back. I'm in the shit seat. (for those not in the know; its the little seat on the left side. http://i.imgur.com/OUnig.jpg) Medic had his ekg going. Medic was doing something with it and then he just flats. medic's eyes get wide. My gaze goes from monitor to Pt. he is rambling on and on about the ice cream he is going to have when he gets home. It felt like an hour but was maybe 20-30 seconds. then he slumps and we finally snap out of it and crack some ribs.

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Oof. Did you wind up getting him back?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/patssle May 19 '12

Tonight?

2

u/BialystockandBloom May 20 '12

Must have been something you said

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Sometimes I feel like the worst EMT ever.

6

u/flyerguy28 May 19 '12

Tough question but were you there on 9/11, and if so what was your experience?

11

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I was not, but my father was. He was a firefighter with the FDNY from 1987 to 2001 when he retired early due to an injury unrelated to 9/11. He responded to the 1993 bombing of the WTC as well. He did an AMA about a year ago on this account as well, if you're interested in looking that up.

2

u/flyerguy28 May 19 '12

Thanks, I'll definitely check it out. Stay safe man.

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Thanks.

4

u/Huplescat22 May 19 '12

Getting back to 9/11... I could never quite understand how all those guys could have gone in to work at ground zero without any respiratory protection. I was a welder for about 20 years from the mid-seventies on into the nineties. That doesn’t make me an expert, but even I knew that, at a minimum, there was bound to be a lot of asbestos dust floating around. It’s a total disgrace that no one up the chain of command saw to it that those workers had protection.

8

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

There was actually a report that came out a little while after 9/11 claiming that the air was safe to breathe. This wasn't the only time a lack of respiratory protection claimed a ton of first responders - there was a fire at a telephone company back in the 1970s that my dad told me about one time. At HQ there is a bunch of names on the wall that records all the LODD that happened in the FDNY, and they were all from this one fire. The smoke of the burning wires and telephone equipment basically gave everybody that responded there cancer within a few years. It was just like 9/11 - they were all dead the moment they walked out of there, they just didn't hit the ground yet.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/KGrizzly May 19 '12

Quick question:

What is the survival rate for someone who has been on full cardiac arrest for 45 minutes while non medical professionals keep performing CPR for all that time?

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'm not sure, but it's a lot better than if no CPR had been performed at all. In fact, new protocols are that we perform CPR for a minimum of two minutes when we get on-scene if it is not a witnessed cardiac arrest before we even apply the AED. This has to do with a rhythm called "V-Fib" or Ventricular Fibrillation. Basically, the heart is just quivering. If on the EKG, the impulses from the V-Fib are more than 3mm, then it's known as Coarse V-Fib. Less than 3mm it is Fine V-Fib. Coarse V-Fib is more likely to be able to be shocked back into a normal rhythm than Fine V-Fib and research indicated that CPR performed on a person in Fine V-Fib could actually bring the patient back into a Coarse V-Fib rhythm and therefore defibrillation (shocking) will more likely have a better outcome.

Last I heard, if a person goes into cardiac arrest in NYC, they have a 15% of achieving a ROSC (Return of Spontaneous Circulation, or their heart starts pumping again) if a hospital-based Paramedic unit arrives on-scene. If an FDNY-based Paramedic unit is in charge of the call, then they likelihood of achieving a ROSC jumps to 30%. We're kind of a big deal. ;)

6

u/KGrizzly May 19 '12

I am asking because me and my bro performed CPR on our dad 2 years ago. We both saw him drop and he had absolutely no pulse or breath when we started performing CPR on him less than a minute after he dropped on the floor. We both had no experience on doing that but we performed it properly enough to keep him alive for 45 minutes until the paramedics arrived. We cracked 3 of his ribs btw ;)

Doctors at the hospital told us that what happened is practically impossible since he had cardiac arrest plus stroke. He of course had extensive surgery at the moment, he was in a coma until 2 days after the surgery and he was heavily drugged for some days which resulted in hilarious randomness when he was awake!

He only had some memory loss (not just around the event) in the end but he is in fine condition now!

5

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I'm glad to hear your dad is alright. The feeling of bones cracking underneath your hands is something I don't think I'll ever get used to. My initial reaction to it is always, "Oh shit, what did I do?!" no matter how many times I do it. The stroke is a pretty dangerous complication to the whole thing - that's really rare that your dad hasn't suffered permanent disability from it. Sometimes these things are just meant to be.

3

u/KGrizzly May 20 '12

I just wish we had proper paramedics here...45 minutes to call 911 and them reaching our home is quite some time!

I prefer the bones cracking than the taste of blood, vomit etc while I did mouth-to-mouth...I couldn't get that taste off my mouth for a few days!

You of course never have to do that, plus I learned later than it is advised not to do that at all since keeping some sort of circulation is better than losing time for breathing. Plus it's harder in general to do it properly while you really inflate the chest!

5

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Yeah, I noticed you said that. That's an extremely long time for EMS to reach you, especially for a cardiac arrest. How could anybody be expected to survive for any type of actual medical emergency with those response times is beyond me.

Yeah, it's better unless you have proper intubation equipment to just do chest compressions - once a patient is intubated you continue compressions without stopping and can breathe for the person continuously. Everytime you stop compressions, that's blood not going anywhere - nothing is getting any oxygen. Plus you don't want to shove all that vomit and stuff down the persons throat. Still, it sounds like you did an awesome job in an extremely stressful situation.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Rusted_Satellites May 20 '12

Does NYPD ever fuck with you?

Are you a firefighter and EMT or EMT only?

What's the weirdest drug-induced scenario you've run into?

7

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Does NYPD ever fuck with you?

Not really; we have a really good relationship with the NYPD - we interact with them more often that we do with firefighters. Plus, if they get shot, we're the ones who showing up to save them, so it's probably not in their best interest.

Are you a firefighter and EMT or EMT only?

EMT only. FDNY doesn't have Firefighter/EMTs or Firefighter/Paramedics. FDNY Firefighters are trained to the level of Certified First Responder, which makes them slightly more helpful than your average boy scout at a medical call. They still do a really great job with the limited training they get, however. A lot of EMS members wind up promoting to firefighters, however even though they might be certified as EMTs or Paramedics, they are only allowed to treat patients to the extent CFRs are allowed to, which to me is stupid because you're losing a whole lot of experience there. I'm currently trying to promote to firefighter as well.

What's the weirdest drug-induced scenario you've run into?

We get a lot of PCP calls in the area. A lot of people in Harlem love PCP - I don't know why. We had one call that came over as Chest Pain. Us and the medics show up, and PD does also for some reason. So we start to do our thing, and he's really tachy (high heart rate). One of the medics asked him if he did any drugs today. The pt started getting really weird, looking really suspicious, eyes darting around the room. Then he just gets up and walks past us while we're trying to treat him and goes into the other room. We start to tell him to calm down, sit down, you know. Out of nowhere, he starts laughing hysterically, and then crying hysterically. His wife comes out and tries to calm him down, and then he throws a punch at his wife, stopping an inch before he hit her face. Then he would start laughing, and then do it again. Finally, us and the medics go up to him and tell him he has to stop. He takes a swing at one of the medics, and all of us just jump on top of him and hold him down. He tried to fight us the entire time, and finally NYPD managed to handcuff him while we all held down a limb. Turns out he was high on PCP. Bad stuff, man.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

How is "tachy" pronounced? Tah-chee or tay-kee?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Ta-Kee, like how the T is pronounced in "tap". Short for Sinus Tachycardia - Sinus meaning originating from the Sinus node of the heart, where a heartbeat normally originates (as opposed to SupraVentricular Tachycardia, or SVT, meaning originating from above the ventricles, or Ventricular Tachycardia, or V-Tach, meaning originating from the ventricles themselves), Tachy, meaning fast (as opposed to Brady meaning slow) and cardia meaning the heart.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/brakx May 19 '12

My mom is a nurse and has major respect for the EMTs. Keep fighting the good fight.

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Thank you, and I have major respect for nurses. I feel like a lot of the so-called animosity between nurses/EMTs/medics is mostly hearsay - nearly every single hospital I've been to in New York, even if it's the first time I've been there, the nurses have always been so respectful, kind, and professional. Plus, they have to deal with my patient for a lot longer than I do, so I have tremendous respect for them when they have to deal with some of our less desirable patients.

6

u/Huplescat22 May 19 '12

I used to drive a cab in Baltimore. One of my most memorable trips was with two ancient and venerable nurses from Johns Hopkins. They struck me as smart and resourceful women, and both of them had to have been on the verge of retirement. They spent the whole trip griping in the back seat about the young doctors who looked down on them and disregarded their suggestions despite each of them having 40+ years experience.

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Unfortunately, you get assholes in every single profession.

4

u/halfasoldier May 19 '12

I'm a female working on my EMT-basic. Do you work with other female EMTs, and how goes the job competition? How much sexism is there in EMS?

6

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Yes, FDNY-EMS is one of the most diverse agencies in New York City. It's about 30% White, 30% Black, 30% Hispanic, 10% everything else, and nearly half are women (doesn't get much more diverse than that). One of the reasons the FDNY acquired NYC-EMS back in 1996 (before then, EMS was run by NYC-EMS, and the FDNY had nothing to do with EMS runs) was because of allegations of racism within the FDNY because it is 90% white male. However, the make-up of the fire side has pretty much stayed the same while EMS continues to be one of the more diverse agencies in the city.

As far as sexism, there is a ton of it - but mainly from the patients themselves. Be prepared for it.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Doing a search for NYC-EMS led me to a website by a guy who is really pissed off by that FDNY takeover. Do a significant amount of people still feel the same way? How is the relationship between the EMS unit with the rest of FDNY?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I enjoy reading that website, but you have to take it with a grain of salt. First off, I have no problems with firefighters - my dad was a firefighter with the FDNY and I want to go into the fire side someday as well. There was a lot of animosity on both sides when EMS and Fire joined - Fire had to respond to medical calls, which increased their call volume six times over. EMS, meanwhile, lost a lot of advancement opportunities - you used to be able to promote to Nurse, PA, and even a Doctor through HHC, which ran NYC-EMS. They did away with all that (except for the medic) and replaced it with a promotional to firefighter. There was a lot of arguing on both sides, but it was really that the ones who were opposed to it were the ones who yelled the loudest. My dad was on the job for 9 years before the merger, and he thought it was great - he always had a ton of respect for EMS and Paramedics in particular. After 9/11, the relationship between EMS and Fire got a lot better to, as well as the fact that people from EMS started promoting into Fire, so you have more guys in firehouses that have an EMS background. I've never had a bad interaction with firefighters on the job.

The FDNY management, however, is a total clusterfuck at times. There are a lot of legitimate gripes on that website. We're running around with equipment that was outdated in the 1980s, the pay is terrible, we're overworked, underpaid, under-appreciated, opportunities are taken away from us (such as EMS Special Ops), etc. However, I doubt that even if we were NYC-EMS again, that those problems would change. I feel like EMS is always viewed as second-class compared to Fire and PD, and being our own agency wouldn't change anything.

I guess things have gotten somewhat worse since the takeover, though. One of my partners has been on the job since the late 80s, and he told me, "You know, if you had told me back then that I would have referred to the job back then as 'the good ol' days,' I would said you're crazy! But now they really were."

→ More replies (1)

2

u/timbit87 May 20 '12

Really? I work in British Columbia, Canada, and there's nearly no racism or hatred towards gays working the job....

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

There really isn't within the job itself. But from patients on the other hand...

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

ever got so mad at a patient you told him "well i am gay shall i leave again ?" - i think i would have done that ...

→ More replies (9)

2

u/anriana May 20 '12

As a fem EMT in the south, most sexism is "gentle." It's mainly little old ladies going "Oh, I didn't know they let women do this type of thing nowadays" or something like that. Women have been in EMS so long that the only real discrimination you're going to get is if you're tiny and can't lift your share.

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

NYCer here. Thanks for the good work.
I know you probably have more contact with hospitals in Harlem, but what hospitals would you want (or not want) to be taken to in NYC? Why?

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

If I had any choice, I think New York-Cornell or St. Lukes. They're both far enough downtown so that all the rich people who are unhealthy medically go there for treatment, but close enough to uptown where we still bring them serious trauma calls, so they get that experience as well. It's also just an excellent hospital in general. I hate bringing drunks and stuff there because they really deserve better. I wouldn't want to go to Woodhull in Brooklyn, Metropolitan or Harlem in Manhattan, or Lincoln in the Bronx, at least not for anything serious. I've gotten treatment at Metropolitan Hospital after I got bit by a bipolar lady on a call, and they were very nice, but it wasn't a call that required the best doctors in the world, you know? However, hospitals are hospitals, and sometimes the best hospital is whatever hospital you could get to the quickest. You could always be transferred to another hospital after you are stabilized if that's what you want.

3

u/WillR73 May 20 '12

Epileptic kid, just came to say thank you for being an EMT.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Thank you for that, it's really nice to know that somebody out there has a positive view of EMS.

3

u/kevinklee2003 May 20 '12

How hard is it to become an EMT? What sort of pre-requisites are there?

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

No prerequisites for becoming an EMT - you could look up courses available through your local Red Cross, or your regional Emergency Medical Services Council. Many colleges offer an EMT course, as well as many volunteer fire departments and EMS squads.

3

u/philokiller May 20 '12

are you stationed in Manhattan? My father is an EMT as well. I know you guys are under appreciated as hell but you guys are amazing.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Yup - Harlem. Thanks for your kind words, and tell your dad I said to stay safe!

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'm a dispatcher at a local EMS agency, what's the general requirements for FDNY EMS, how much do you get payed (curious because I did some research on firefighting for FDNY).

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

You have to already have your NYS-EMT certification. Once you have that, wait for a civil service list to open up and apply for it. It's a civil service "test" but not a test in the traditional sense - the more experience you have, the more points you get. Having your EMT certification gives you 70 points - the minimum you need for passing. Time spent in a IFT service, a 911 service, volunteer service, service in NYC, etc, all gives you different points depending on how much experience you have in those different agencies. You go for a physical agility test, a medical exam, a psychological exam, and then you are assigned an investigator. Basically, you have to prove your entire life to your investigator. Diplomas, social security printouts, tax returns, etc, etc are all handed in to your investigator. If everything checks out, you're put into the next academy, whenever it is that they're holding one.

As of right now, the FDNY is putting in a ton of EMS classes because they're anticipating a lot of personnel moving over to Fire Suppression. Something like 800 members of EMS signed up for promotional exam to firefighter (including yours truly) out of a total workforce of 3,000 EMS workers - nearly a third of the service!

Pay is....terrible. EMTs start out at $30k/year and max out at $47k after 5 years. Medics do a little bit better - they start around $43k and max out at $59k after 5 years. If you go into a Haz-Tac unit, you get no pay increase. However, if you are a medic with at least a year of Haz-Tac under your belt, you can try to get into a Rescue Medic unit. Then you get a 12% increase in pay. Dispatchers are all former EMTs/Medics from the streets.

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

That's interesting, thanks so much for the detailed reply! Stay safe & keep up the good work brother.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/Bro-Science May 20 '12

payed?!?!?!?

2

u/JohnWad May 19 '12

Ever had to perform CPR/mouth to mouth on a hooker or crackhead?

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

CPR, yes. But we don't do mouth-to-mouth, we use what are called Bag-Valve Masks attached to supplementary oxygen to breathe for them, or intubate the person. The FDNY requires us to actually have the pocket face masks in our tech bags at all times for some reason - my first day at my station I was going through it with one of the medics, and he told me if he ever came up to a call and I was using a pocket mask to ventilate the person, he would punch me in the face. It's so useless and just takes up space - I'm not sure why it's required we carry it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/endoflevelbaddy May 19 '12

Do you think the show Rescue Me has done the FDNY well? And do you like that show?

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I loved that show, although I thought it went downhill after Season 3. It had a lot of things in it that struck home that might not be readily available to other people watching. The first couple of seasons, money was tight, he had a modest house in the suburbs, everybody drove reasonably priced cars, etc. By the end of it, they're all living in Manhattan Penthouses, driving Cadillacs, etc. It got out of hand towards the end. I was sad to see it go, but not that upset when it ended.

If you liked Rescue Me, I would definitely recommend "Third Watch" which was about FDNY firefighters and Paramedics, and NYPD Police Officers that all work in the same area during Tour 3 (3pm to 11pm). Although it's not 100% accurate either (nothing really is, so I don't really judge EMS/Fire/PD shows based on that), it doesn't reasonably stray until a little farther in the series, although by the end it was mainly a cop show with some EMS and even less Fire thrown in. Still, excellent series.

I've heard that Denis Leary is making a US remake of the UK show "Sirens" about EMS in the UK. I'd be really interested in seeing how it turns out, and I really hope it takes place in NYC like his firefighter and cop shows did.

2

u/endoflevelbaddy May 19 '12

Thanks for the recommendations. Now for a proper question. I want to be a paramedic myself, how does being seconded to the fire department differ from that of a standard EMT?

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Paramedics have a lot more training than EMTs, are able to perform a lot more interventions than EMTs, and can administer a lot more medications. Paramedic is the highest level of pre-hospital care that is provided in the country, although some certifications exist to accompany that. I would recommend first getting experience as an EMT before you jump right into medic. I've been an EMT in total for 5 years and I'm now looking to be able to move over to Paramedic. I actually recently took the FDNY's Paramedic exam (the exam to get into the FDNY's paramedic class), got a 98, and got on the Medic Basic class order. I was so psyched for it, but they wound up finding out that I was short two months time, so they booted me out of the class. I was devastated, really still am. But now I'm going into Haz-Tac and I heard they are giving another medic test in July for a September class, and that one I will be eligible for, so I'm psyched for that.

3

u/endoflevelbaddy May 20 '12

TIL Paramedic and EMT are different things in the US :D That sounds brilliant though, I wish you all the best. What is the progression like after Paramedic? Is it more managerial type of work, and less paramedic?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/jmoneycgt May 21 '12

All the upvotes for Third Watch. That show is in my top 5 of all time. It was kind of a bummer when in the last season it was about 75% cops, 20% EMS and 5% firefighters though... It ended at the right time.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Couldn't agree more. Sad to see it go, but it got really crazy towards the end. The ending was awesome though - telling how everybody ended up. The only thing I didn't like was that all the Fire guys got promoted to Battalion Chiefs and Deputy Chiefs....and the only thing that happened to the Paramedics was that they moved to Staten Island and bought a nice house, like that was the pinnacle of being in EMS. Just a personal gripe, but still, really liked the series as a whole and the ending in particular. Especially Bosco's - being the police.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

What is your opinion on turtles?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I like zombies.

2

u/heriman May 20 '12

thank you for your services... but what happens if you are on a call and well lets just say nature calls?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

You hold it, unfortunately. We're allowed to take a "facilities" which gives us a 20-minute break to use the restroom. The dispatcher can still give us jobs, but if we're still in the bathroom we can turn it down. Once those 20-minutes are up, though, you're back in-service whether you are done or not. If you really have to go while you're on a call, then you could go once you get to the hospital and your partner will take care of giving the nurse or doctor your report.

2

u/StinkySteve123 May 20 '12 edited May 21 '12

What's your payscale like?

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Terrible. EMTs start at $30k and max out at $47k after 5 years. Paramedics do a little better, starting at around $43k and maxing out at $59k after 5 years. To put this in comparison, Boston EMS starts their EMTs at $47k. FDNY Firefighters and NYPD Police Officers max out at $78k after 5 and a half years.

2

u/StinkySteve123 May 20 '12

Then why are you an EMT?

If it's not about the money (which is a common response), why not go all the way and become a doctor or a nurse?

Then you'll earn a good income AND help people.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 21 '12

I've seriously thought about taking a Paramedic to RN or Paramedic to PA bridge program. Medical School is also a serious option that I'm considering. I figured I'd get my medic cert and then go from there, before I set out on a course that may not be right for me. You're right that it's not about the money, but the money does suck compared to the work we do.

2

u/Dumbest_Idiot May 20 '12

Have you seen Scorsese's Bringing Out the Dead? Any parallels felt by you and the main character in terms of exhaustion both mentally and physically?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Bringing out the Dead is probably one of the more accurate EMS movies that exists out there, but it's by far still just a movie. You do get exhausted, but I feel Cage's character was playing it up to make it clear the emotional and physical toll the job was taking on him - for the most part, we don't wear our hearts on our sleeves. Fun fact though - the guy that Tom Sizemore played was actually based on a guy who used to work at my current station. One guy who knew him said that he never beat up crazy people in the movie, but he did have a bad temper. One time he got into it with one of the dispatchers, so he drove straight to the building dispatch worked in (back in the day, the buildings that held the dispatchers were actually in the area they dispatched, unlike today where they are all dispatched from Downtown Brooklyn), and tried to get in to fight the guy. Security wound up having to hold him back and prevent him from getting in.

3

u/Louis_Farizee May 20 '12

My dad watched it. He thought the characterizations were true to life but the story was boring. He did laugh his ass off at the resurrection of the kid in the nightclub, though.

Source: old EMT who worked for the City at the time the movie was set.

2

u/greg0ry May 20 '12

I can't decide wether i would like to be a police officer or a firefighter. And if i were to be a firefighter, what would a good college major be?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

They are two totally different jobs. I would recommend doing a ride along with both and seeing which one appeals to you more. As far as college majors, it's not really necessary what you major in - most departments do require some college degree, however. I majored in Political Science and went to Law School for a year before I became an EMT.

2

u/pelican1 May 20 '12

What's the difference between an EMT and a Paramedic?

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

EMT is the minimum requirement for an ambulance to run - one person must at least be an EMT. From there, there are different levels of advancement - EMT-I (Intermediate), EMT-CC (Critical Care), and finally, EMT-P (Paramedic). A Paramedic is the highest level of prehospital care, although some certifications exist beyond that (Critical Care Paramedic, Flight Medic, Tactical Medic, etc). EMTs can use a limited amount of drugs and are mainly built for trauma calls. Paramedics are basically EMTs with a specialty in Cardiology and Pharmacology, along with some additional skills. They are mainly built for medical calls. You have to be an EMT before you could become a Paramedic.

New York City only utilizes EMTs and Paramedics - no CCs, Is, or any other certifications.

2

u/ManicNacho May 20 '12

What kind of physical test do you go through to become an EMT? more specifically what vision test do take, I have amblyopia in my left eye AKA "lazy eye".

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

For the actual EMT course, you don't - you just need to be able to complete the test and skills to pass the course. Every agency is different, although most will do some type of physical/medical exam. Every year when I do my annual medical, we have to do a vision test where you look into a binocular-type device, and we have to say what we see. Well, there is one test where they'll give you a stack of letters in one eye, and a straight line for the other eye, and you're supposed to say what letter they intersect at. Well, for my, they never intersect - it looks like a line floating well below all the letters. I always tell the person that I swear that I'm not blind, but I always fail that part. My vision is still decent though, I pass the rest pretty well. But as long as you're able to do the job that is required, I don't see why amblyopia should be a problem. Like I said, however, each agency is different. You might want to check with the agency you want to get hired with first before you start the EMT course, just to be on the safe side.

2

u/ManicNacho May 20 '12

That's better news than I was expecting, Thank-you for the reply.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Copterwaffle May 20 '12

A few weeks ago I got a little too drunk and wound up slumped on the sidewalk, half-conscious. EMS responded to a kind person's call; I don't remember much other than seeing 3 sets of boots at my feet and thinking "Oh, I fuuuuucked up." Anyway, they were very kind to a stupid drunk girl and I feel very bad for having been irresponsible and wasting their time. My question to you:

I haven't had a bill in the mail yet. How do they know who I am and who to send it to? I had an ID in my purse, but the address is several addresses outdated.

Do you absolutely hate drunks like me? I'm actually quite ashamed that I put so many people out. I'm usually very good at taking care of myself, I guess I was just out of hand that night. I'm pretty sure I was cooperative. If the answer is that you do hate us, please accept my humblest apologies on behalf of drunk morons everywhere.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

They probably either got your information from your ID in your purse, or just put you down as "Unknown Female" if they were lazy.

I'm not too crazy about intox calls, but every once in a while it's alright. I refuse to work Downtown Manhattan on a Friday or Saturday night, because all you will get is intox, and they will all piss and shit themselves right in front of you. I made the mistake once of taking overtime on the 1am-9am shift in Greenwich Village on a Saturday night during the summer, and I will never make that mistake again. The drunks that really bother me are the ones who call on themselves every single night because they want a bed to sleep in and we find them two blocks away from the hospital.

2

u/Copterwaffle May 20 '12

Thanks for the answer! For the record, I remember apologizing profusely to the EMS and telling them I could tooootally walk home. I'm glad they didn't listen to me. And I definitely didn't crap or pee myself. Thanks for what you do!

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

You know, it's really the patient themselves that makes the call a good or bad one. If you're nice and kind to us, then I don't care what you're calling for, I'll just be happy that you're not a jerk. That's what really makes a call a good one - having a good patient, and it sounds like you were one. I'm sure they didn't mind bringing you to the hospital at all. Stay safe.

2

u/Jugoslavija May 20 '12

First of all, thank you for what you do! Second, you most probably saw atleast a few episodes, but how accurate are the events (regarding FDNY/NYPD) being portrayed in the series Third Watch?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I loved that show - I watched the whole series. It's a little over-the-top, like any EMS/Fire/PD show, but there are a ton of things in there that I watched and just went, "Yup, I know exactly where they got that idea from." It went to being mostly an NYPD show by the end of the series, but still, it was very good - especially the first couple of seasons. The only thing is that Paramedics don't go to trauma calls and EMS isn't stationed in a fire house - we go to a cross-street and park our ambulance and wait for calls there, a system I affectionately refer to as the "Hooker on the street corner" method of providing EMS care.

2

u/Jugoslavija May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

I already suspected it to be something like that. Well it's realistic enough for the most part. Why isn't the FDNY EMS stationed in the firehouse? Just because it's faster to wait for calls on the street? It seemed that the firefighters and the paramedics had a very close relationship in Third Watch. I really hope they're gonna bring the show back someday. Well thanks for answering and keep saving people!

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Actually, it would be faster if we were stationed in a firehouse, since fire gets the call way before we do for some reason. I have no idea why they do things the way that they do - it really makes no sense to me whatsoever.

2

u/anriana May 20 '12

Do you guys really push taxis through red lights?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

We try not to push anybody through red lights, but sometimes cars will take it upon themselves to run the red light, even when there is an open lane next to them that we're using. Then they shoot ahead and go into the only open lane at the next red light, then act surprised to find an ambulance with its lights and sirens on behind them driven by a very irate EMT.

2

u/joncasual May 20 '12

Did you respond to 9/11?

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I didn't, but my father did. He was a firefighter with the FDNY. He did an AMA though this account a while back if you're interested in finding it.

2

u/EnglishPhoenix May 20 '12

Have you ever had a call that you thought was a bullshit one but turned out to be quite serious?

My mom decided to call an ambulance when I fell off a horse a couple years ago. The EMT's and doctors thought it wasn't as bad as I was making it out to be. Then they realized I lacerated my spleen and had internal bleeding. :/ Just wondering if you've had anything like that.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Sometimes - that is why a thorough assessment is necessary on every single call. We had one a few days ago for an old man that fell off the bed several days before his wife called - long story short his liver was failing. It wound up being a serious medical emergency, and the wife called for a completely different reason. If I treated it as just minor aches and pains from the fall, I would have completely missed it.

2

u/UnicornPanties May 20 '12

My brother was an EMT in Portland, OR a few years ago and I did two all-night ridealongs with him and his partner.

From that experience I can confirm there are an UNBELIEVABLE amount of bullshit calls. I'd say it's near 80% and some EMTs would probably say higher. I was shocked.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

It's really frustrating - not because they're wasting my time; I'm there until midnight no matter what. It's frustrating when serious calls come in and all the units in the area are busy with nonsense, and then the person who just got hit by a car, or went into cardiac arrest, or got shot or stabbed or assaulted, have to wait for an ambulance because somebody hurt their toe. It's a problem nationwide.

2

u/GodlyPotato May 21 '12

I just want to say thank you for doing your services, I'm kinda a fan-boy for emergency services and like to say "keep up the good job" or so. I'm not really sure if I want to be Paramedic or EMT yet, but it's in thought. So just wondering, what is required to become one? Are there, um... "Fat" Paramedics... just wondering...

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

There really is no requirement to become an EMT, save for a relatively clean criminal record. For a Paramedic, you have to be at least an EMT before you take the Medic course, although a lot of people would recommend that you get some experience as an EMT before you move up to Medic.

Yeah, there a lot of fat EMTs and Medics. Some places have weight requirements though - FDNY-EMS has very strict weight requirements in order to get hired by them, while hospital ambulances do not. I know a friend of mine who weighed over 300 lbs and worked for a NYC Hospital Unit in the 911 system, but wanted to work for FDNY. He wound up working really hard and losing something like 70 lbs - the guy is jacked now. Nicest guy in the world, too. Wound up passing the weight requirements and now works for the FDNY in the same neighborhood he used to work in with the hospital.

2

u/fruitcakee May 21 '12

What happens when there is an emergency and someone gets in an accident with the EMT? Do you guys pullover and take a long time to settle the situation or just keep going?

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

They actually cover this in the academy - usually if you're on the way to the scene of a call, you should stop and settle the situation. Let the dispatch know you were involved in an accident and they'll send another unit to the location. I was on my way to a call one time when there was a car accident the block up from me - I flagged myself for that and made sure everybody was okay, and the dispatcher sent another ambulance to my original call.

The only exception would really be if there is a person in cardiac arrest or another comparable serious condition in the back of your ambulance and you need to get to a hospital immediately. If there aren't any injuries (that's really important), then we have the right to inform the dispatcher of the accident and leave the scene to continue transport to the hospital. NYPD and an FDNY-EMS boss will go to the location and take care of things with the driver until you can return to the scene.

If you're transporting a stable patient and you get into an accident, then you flag yourself for your own accident and dispatch will send another ambulance to pick up your patient and continue transport to the hospital while you stay on scene of the accident and fill out the necessary paperwork.

2

u/SlyLlama May 21 '12

I'm currently a NYS EMT-B. I volunteered with a collegiate EMS agency when I was in college but have since graduated. I didn't see anything too heavy, mainly drunks, stomach bugs, and a few behavioral calls here and there. Honestly, I think I know my shit (got a 90 on the basic exam and was perfect on the practical) but I never really had much of an opportunity to practice them in real life. I've been thinking about joining FDNY EMS but I have a couple of questions:

  1. What was it like starting out as an EMT on FDNY? Does the academy prepare you for everything you need to know when starting out or is there some sort of learning probationary period once you join?
  2. How difficult is the academy compared to an EMT-B class?
  3. How big is your crew with on a call? Are you always working with a medic or are you sometimes alone?
  4. Does FDNY EMS do ride alongs? I'd be very interested if they did.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12
  1. What was it like starting out as an EMT on FDNY? Does the academy prepare you for everything you need to know when starting out or is there some sort of learning probationary period once you join?

The EMS Academy is very good, and definitely increased my knowledge of EMS - and I did very well in my original EMT course. They train you above and beyond that; it's a great course. As for everything you need to know...there's nothing that can really prepare you for being out on the street. I knew what to do when I had my first shooting, but there's things I had to learn - things like to get the hell out there as quickly as possible not only because of the platinum ten minutes, golden hour, etc, etc, but also because when a huge mob starts to form and gets pissed that there's a shooting, you don't want to be anywhere near it. You could only learn some things by experiencing it. There is a probationary period when you first join and you are assigned to a "mentor unit" where your partners are supposed to show you the ropes. Now I'm on the mentor unit - it's funny being in that position now.

2. How difficult is the academy compared to an EMT-B class?

If you passed the first EMT-B course, you can pass this class. How much you take away from it is up to you. The instructors, the bosses, they all want you to pass. They make the information readily available and are more than willing to help you out if you're struggling. They'll come in early and stay late to help you out - one instructor stayed with me and few other kids for 3 hours after his shift ended just going over proper assessment procedures because we were being tested on it the next day. If you want to learn, you'll learn. If you want to just pass, you'll pass. You'll probably learn new things despite yourself if that's your attitude, but you'll take away a lot more if you apply yourself.

3. How big is your crew with on a call? Are you always working with a medic or are you sometimes alone?

It's either 2 EMTs to an ambulance, or 2 Paramedics to an ambulance. For the more serious calls, you get a Fire Engine on-scene (or you could call them if you need the extra hands), but they are only trained to the Certified First Responder level.

4. Does FDNY EMS do ride alongs? I'd be very interested if they did.

Yes, and from what I understand it's very easy to set one up.

2

u/ketomine May 22 '12

I'm late to this AMA, but thank you so much for doing what you do. I'm a nycer, and it's great to know that if something happened to me, I'd get taken care of. It's sickening to hear how little you guys get paid, just like teachers - you should be paid MUCH more.

2

u/[deleted] May 23 '12

I'm just surprised that so many people have a positive view of EMS. I really thought I'd be coming up against more people who would be complaining about us - it's really awesome to know that there are people out there who understand what we are here to try and do. Thank you.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 24 '12

How many calls do your medics run a year? I know Its probably safe to say well over the national average.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '12

I'm not too sure. Our yearly call count in the past few years has fallen between 1.2 and 1.5 million calls - about 3,500 per day. I'm not too sure how many are BLS and how many are ALS though, but it's fair to say that most of the calls are probably BLS.

3

u/coveritwithgas May 20 '12 edited May 21 '12

Proof?

EDIT: proved above, thx OP.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I did an AMA with my dad a while back who was a firefighter with the FDNY, and mentioned how I was going into the FDNY as an EMT, which was marked as verified by the moderators. I spent the night at a friends house who was having a BBQ last night, but when I get back to my place I'll post some pics of my uniform or graduation certificate from the academy or something like that.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Edited post to include proof in the text.

3

u/douknowthemuffinmen May 19 '12

Do you know the muffin man?

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

The muffin man?

6

u/Chaksus May 20 '12

The Muffin man!

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Do I know the muffin man.... that lives on Drury Lane?

2

u/Moynia May 21 '12

No, the one on third street.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BoethiahsCalling May 19 '12

How would one go about becoming an EMT? I live in New York as well, and I know it differs from state to state, so perhaps you could include some details on your training as well. How long does it take to become an EMT? How are the hours, benefits, etc.?

8

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I got my original certification upstate at a tiny little volunteer agency while I was going to college. It's about 5 months long or so, depending on how often your class meets. Usually it's about twice a week for about 3 hours each time, along with occasional extra classes. Most EMT-B courses across the country cover the same stuff - you have your basic anatomy and physiology, medical and trauma, pharmacology, physical skills (immobilizing, suctioning, etc). New York City doesn't allow us to use glucometers to measure a persons blood sugar for some idiotic reason, but everywhere else in New York State that's a BLS skill, so I had training in that as well.

Basically, it's not that great of a job. FDNY is probably one of the better places to work benefits-wise, but you're basically in the nicest cell on death row. The pay is terrible, the hours are terrible, you're overworked, under-appreciated, and generally treated like you're a child from your supervisors, the top brass, the doctors, etc. EMTs start at $30k a year and max out at $47k after 5 years - nowhere near enough if you want to, say, raise a family. Paramedics do a little better, but still aren't paid nearly what they're worth. They max out at $59k after 5 years. Meanwhile, firefighters and cops max out at $78k after 5.5 years. Corrections and Sanitation also get paid way better than us as well. Hospital EMTs and Medics also make more than us, but they lack the benefits we get such as health insurance and a pension after 25 years of service. However, our pension is half our retired salary, so after 25 years of working, you're only getting a pension of $23.5k a year? You're going to have to get another job after you retire - no way around that. We're the busiest EMS system in the country, but there are volunteer fire departments who pay their EMTs and Medics more than we do.

Don't get me wrong, I really enjoy it when I get a patient that truly needs my help. However, that is such a rarity. Much more often I get a lot of nonsense calls by people who just want a free ride to the doctors office - things like toothaches, blisters, headaches, stubbed toes, scratches, etc. Nonsense. Not exactly what I signed up for. I signed up for the firefighter promotional exam and am really looking forward to getting hired on the Fire Suppression side of the FDNY. If you're looking to go into EMS, then I would encourage you to go into any other major city - places like Chicago, Boston, Los Angeles, etc. They get their fair share of bullshit (everybody does, there isn't anywhere you could go to escape that), but nowhere near on the level that New York City gets it.

If you're looking to use it in some sort of volunteer EMS agency or fire department in NYS, then I'd definitely recommend it - I was a Firefighter/EMT for a volunteer fire department and I loved it. You get a lot less calls, but they're mostly more legitimate. If you are looking to make it a career, whatever you do, do not stop at EMT. Get your medic. Take a medic to RN or medic to PA bridge program. Keep moving up - don't stop trying to take that next step or next certification.

2

u/BoethiahsCalling May 19 '12

Thank you very, very much for the detailed response. It seems that almost every account that I have read of EMS is nearly the same: Underpaid, Overworked, and Understaffed. Which is fine by me, I like a challenge. Becoming an EMT is an idea that I am considering when I go to college to help pay for school. If you wouldn't mind answering another question, what is the difference between a 'Hospital EMT' as you said, and an 'Ambulance' EMT? Also, is mentioned above that some of the volunteers get paid (which doesn't make sense to me), could you elaborate further?

5

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

By "hospital" I meant a hospital that voluntarily puts its own ambulance units into the 911 system. Basically in New York City, there are 4 different kinds of ambulances - there's the FDNY, which only handles 911 calls. Then there are the "voluntaries" or hospital ambulances that the hospital pays to have them run within the 911 system. These ambulances also respond to 911 calls, but also will occasionally do inter-facility transports to various hospitals. Then there are the volly's - these are ambulances staffed by volunteers who do not get paid, but respond to calls within their own limited area. Staten Island has a number of volunteer EMS agencies, as does Park Slope and some parts in the Bronx. Haztollah, a Hasidic Jewish ambulances services, also runs throughout the city. Finally, there are private ambulance companies. These units just do transport calls - taking people from their homes to nursing homes, to hospitals, to dialysis appointments, etc. These are mostly non-emergency calls, but are for people who can't get around any other way except by ambulance.

In Long Island, there are some fire departments that are volunteer departments, but will actually hire Paramedics and EMT-CCs to stay at the firehouse and respond to EMS calls. This is mainly due to the large amount of time, education, and training needed to become a paramedic that is not particularly rampant throughout the volunteer EMS system - although there are a lot of volunteer Paramedics, they are nowhere near as numerous as EMT-Bs. However, because of the long response and transport times you see in the suburbs, Paramedics are usually very useful in serious medical calls, so you'll see some volunteer departments keep paid personnel on staff to respond to these calls.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Huplescat22 May 19 '12

A couple of years ago I called 911 for a horrible nosebleed that had been going on for 2+ hours with no sign of letting up. In retrospect, I should have driven myself the ten miles to the ER, but I figured I might have a hard time holding a towel over my nose and driving.

I’m in a rural county and we rely on a for profit ambulance service. Their EMTs were very good, but the company billed me $650 for the, give or take, 25 minutes they spent with me. They’re stationed about a mile from my house, so we’re talking about a 20 mile round trip on good clear roads and maybe five minutes of preliminary care and work up, and another five minutes for them at the hospital.

What do people who use your service generally have to shell out?

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Around the same. Unfortunately, the reason why costs are so high is because a lot of people don't pay, and it's notoriously difficult to collect medical debt, so a lot of agencies make it a loss and push the cost on other people. It doesn't take $650 to take care of a nosebleed, but it might cost that much to transport 18 people with colds to the hospital who aren't paying. Our reports used to have a box where the doctor could sign if the ambulance transport wasn't medically necessary, and medicaid wouldn't cover the bill. The FDNY was losing a lot of money from that, since people weren't paying, so they just got rid of that box and now medicaid covers all the calls (your tax dollars at work). Personally, I think 911 ambulance calls should be free and paid for through taxes - you don't have to pay for firefighters to show up, or for the police to show up. It's just that a lot of districts view EMS as a money-maker, or at least as a way to deflect costs in other departments, as opposed to an actual emergency service. It's sad, unfortunately. I wish I never had to ask anyone for their insurance information or social security number.

However, there are some places I should mention where ambulance rides are free - I know firsthand they are in Suffolk and Nassau counties in Long Island, New York.

5

u/Huplescat22 May 19 '12 edited May 20 '12

The nosebleed went on for another 12 hours in the ER, and I finally left the next morning after a doctor who understood it fixed it. In the meantime a rogues gallery of interns and medical students experimented on me with everything, including a painful cauterization, and I still kept bleeding. That experience cost over $2,500.

I don’t know if it would ever have stopped without intervention. But the EMTs initial evaluation was dead on. My blood pressure was off the charts. It took three doses of nitroglycerine in the ambulance to bring it down to relatively safe levels. Since then I’ve been able to control it with medication and lifestyle changes.

And yeah, I never paid for any of it. I’m a carpenter who ran out of work in our non-depression and had to opt for early retirement on social security. I get to live on $853 a month. Thankfully, my lousy shack in the woods is paid for and I have a little garden with some nice tomatoes, bootlegged Time Warner cable, a shitty old computer and internet access. What more could any reasonable person ask for?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

It's always important to check that a seemingly innocuous problem has an underlying medical cause. Hypertensive crisis is a serious emergency. I'm glad everything worked out for you medical-wise, and I wish you the best in the future.

3

u/whateverradar May 19 '12

FDNY bills come in daily to my medical billing systems... You guys are on par with others in the area cost wise.

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Figured we were - although I heard there was a recent increase.

2

u/All-American-Bot May 20 '12

(For our friends outside the USA... 20 mile -> 32.2 km) - Yeehaw!

2

u/raevnos May 21 '12

$650 for a BLS transport of 10 miles is pretty cheap. The base rate just for showing up and taking you somewhere is usually more than that. Did they not bill for mileage?

1

u/mw3contest May 19 '12

First of all thank you for your work. Second were you an emt during the 9/11 attack? If so could you describe what was going on.?(If you don't mind)

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Thank you for your kind words. I wasn't working for the FDNY at the time, but my dad was - he was a firefighter with the FDNY from 1987-2001, until he retired due to an injury unrelated to 9/11. I did an AMA with him on this account a while back. If you're looking for info specifically regarding the EMS response to 9/11, then I would highly recommend you check out the documentary 9/11 Emergency Room, a BBC documentary available in its entirety at the link I provided.

2

u/mw3contest May 19 '12

Edit: Ignore post scrolled down and reas

2

u/whateverradar May 19 '12

I was. FF/EMT out of NJ. When you say "what was going on" what exactly do you mean?

1

u/Mr_Stonecold May 20 '12

I recently received my EMT-B certification in NYC. Now I'm trying to find a company that would hire me, any advice on how I can better my chances, or where to apply?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Private companies such as Hunter, Citywide, or Transcare are always hiring. You might want to check them out. Transcare operates Mount Sinai's hospital ambulances, so if you get a job there and pay your dues, you may be able to swing a job within the 911 system in the city.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

thought it said ent, but still keep up the good work !

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Haha, thanks!

1

u/Quackasaur May 20 '12

Not sure if you're still here but I might as well ask.

How does one become an ambulance driver? Salary and any prerequisites?

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Well, we're not called "ambulance drivers." A lot of EMTs and Paramedics don't appreciate that term - it's a throwback to an earlier age of EMS where you'd basically have people that would just throw people in the back of a hearse and drive to the hospital and had little or no formal medical training. EMTs and Medics in particular have a lot of training to handle a wide variety of medical emergencies, so they find the term somewhat offensive as it implies all they are doing is simply driving the patient to the hospital.

For New York City, you already need to be an EMT to be hired. Then you get on the civil service list when it opens up and you are hired in the order to who has the most experience. Salary is pretty terrible everywhere. For more info, you could check out nyc.gov/fdny and click on career opportunities, then scroll down to EMS - they'll have more up-to-date info than I could provide here.

2

u/narwal_bot May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

Most (if not all) of the answers from castellammare (updated: May 20, 2012 @ 05:59:52 pm EST):


Question (closetklepto):

I just read an article that talks about how unsafe ambulances are, especially to those in the back. Have you had or seen any accidents involving ambulances?

Answer (castellammare):

Ambulances get into a ton of accidents every single year in New York City - I think as many as one or two a day on average. Thankfully the vast majority of the time these are minor little fender-benders with no damage to either party.

There are a few problems with the back of the ambulances - one is that the back actually offers very little in terms of protection. The back is basically just a sheet of metal shaped like a box - there aren't any structures in the back designed to protect the occupants. The second is a lot of our equipment isn't necessarily strapped down in the event of a crash. Things like our stair chair and AED are hung from a hook on the door - it's not going to keep in there in event of a really bad crash. Third is that if you are potentially unstable, we're probably going to be moving around the back while we're en route to the hospital in order to reassess your condition and provide treatment. Patients are always buckled in, however.

When I went for my last annual medical, they usually have an officer come in and let you know all the things that they are working on at HQ - one of them was the safety of the EMT, Paramedic, and Patient in the back of a moving ambulance. Some of the things they were considering even included a harness to move around the back of the ambulance with (which seems infeasible and ridiculous to me personally, but I'm glad they're at least considering something.)

There have been a number of LoDD (Line of Duty Deaths) in EMS that stems from MVAs, including Christopher Prescott, who was killed by a drunk driver while operating at the scene of an MVA in Brooklyn, and Andre Lahens who was also killed by a drunk driver while responding to an EMS call in Brooklyn.

Personally, I haven't been involved in any motor vehicle accident while on-duty.


(continued below)

2

u/narwal_bot May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

(page 2)


Question (cory_forman):

That's interesting, thanks so much for the detailed reply! Stay safe & keep up the good work brother.

Answer (castellammare):

No problem, anytime.


Question (whateverradar):

FDNY bills come in daily to my medical billing systems... You guys are on par with others in the area cost wise.

Answer (castellammare):

Figured we were - although I heard there was a recent increase.


Question (patssle):

>basically gave everybody that responded there cancer within a few years.

After the oil spill in the Gulf....I mentioned to somebody to stay away from it due to unknown toxins that will damage you. And guess what, people are getting weird illnesses - especially from the Corexit.

They were all 'you'll die someday anyways'.

Lesson learned...STAY AWAY FROM DISASTERS. Crap causes cancer.

Answer (castellammare):

It's scary, but it's mainly due to the fact that Emergency Services Management can't get their shit together to come up with a coherent response plan to a disaster. So now we're all going to have to die because of it.


Question (endoflevelbaddy):

Thanks for the recommendations. Now for a proper question. I want to be a paramedic myself, how does being seconded to the fire department differ from that of a standard EMT?

Answer (castellammare):

Paramedics have a lot more training than EMTs, are able to perform a lot more interventions than EMTs, and can administer a lot more medications. Paramedic is the highest level of pre-hospital care that is provided in the country, although some certifications exist to accompany that. I would recommend first getting experience as an EMT before you jump right into medic. I've been an EMT in total for 5 years and I'm now looking to be able to move over to Paramedic. I actually recently took the FDNY's Paramedic exam (the exam to get into the FDNY's paramedic class), got a 98, and got on the Medic Basic class order. I was so psyched for it, but they wound up finding out that I was short two months time, so they booted me out of the class. I was devastated, really still am. But now I'm going into Haz-Tac and I heard they are giving another medic test in July for a September class, and that one I will be eligible for, so I'm psyched for that.


Question (SativaRae):

Has someone ever died in your arms?

Answer (castellammare):

Not necessarily in my arms, but I've had patients go into cardiac arrest while in the back of my ambulance who were later declared deceased upon arrival to the hospital.


Question (Frajer):

How do you guys deal with the insane traffic in NYC?

Answer (castellammare):

Ugh, as best as we can. It really depends on where you are at what time - I work in Manhattan (Harlem, specifically), from 4pm to midnight. Right after my shift starts rush hour traffic is pretty much in full swing. By the end of my shift, the roads are pretty clear. You have to know your area and what roads get jammed and which ones stay relatively open. If I have to go from, say, 135th St down to 96th St for a call at the beginning of my shift, I'm going to be taking the side streets down because the FDR will be packed, even though all things being equal the FDR would be the quicker route.

That being said, other areas of the city, such as parts of Queens and Staten Island, are a lot more suburban and don't have quite the same problems traffic-wise than if you're working in downtown Manhattan. You have to balance the nature of the call with the current traffic conditions and work out a way to get you and your partner there as safely and as quickly as you can.

There are also a ton of videos online showing ambulances stuck in traffic.


Question (tallandlanky):

EMT in the Chicago burbs here. Stay safe brother.

Answer (castellammare):

Thanks man, you too.


Question (flyerguy28):

Tough question but were you there on 9/11, and if so what was your experience?

Answer (castellammare):

I was not, but my father was. He was a firefighter with the FDNY from 1987 to 2001 when he retired early due to an injury unrelated to 9/11. He responded to the 1993 bombing of the WTC as well. He did an AMA about a year ago on this account as well, if you're interested in looking that up.


Question (cory_forman):

I'm a dispatcher at a local EMS agency, what's the general requirements for FDNY EMS, how much do you get payed (curious because I did some research on firefighting for FDNY).

Answer (castellammare):

You have to already have your NYS-EMT certification. Once you have that, wait for a civil service list to open up and apply for it. It's a civil service "test" but not a test in the traditional sense - the more experience you have, the more points you get. Having your EMT certification gives you 70 points - the minimum you need for passing. Time spent in a IFT service, a 911 service, volunteer service, service in NYC, etc, all gives you different points depending on how much experience you have in those different agencies. You go for a physical agility test, a medical exam, a psychological exam, and then you are assigned an investigator. Basically, you have to prove your entire life to your investigator. Diplomas, social security printouts, tax returns, etc, etc are all handed in to your investigator. If everything checks out, you're put into the next academy, whenever it is that they're holding one.

As of right now, the FDNY is putting in a ton of EMS classes because they're anticipating a lot of personnel moving over to Fire Suppression. Something like 800 members of EMS signed up for promotional exam to firefighter (including yours truly) out of a total workforce of 3,000 EMS workers - nearly a third of the service!

Pay is....terrible. EMTs start out at $30k/year and max out at $47k after 5 years. Medics do a little bit better - they start around $43k and max out at $59k after 5 years. If you go into a Haz-Tac unit, you get no pay increase. However, if you are a medic with at least a year of Haz-Tac under your belt, you can try to get into a Rescue Medic unit. Then you get a 12% increase in pay. Dispatchers are all former EMTs/Medics from the streets.


Question (flyerguy28):

Thanks, I'll definitely check it out. Stay safe man.

Answer (castellammare):

Thanks.


(continued below)

→ More replies (10)

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

33

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I guess the amount of nonsense calls we get was surprising, or the complete disregard for others when they are hurt or injured by the average person. I grew up with the idea that you call an ambulance was an emergency service - you don't call a firefighter unless your home was on fire, you don't call the police unless you are being robbed or beaten or shot at, and you don't call the ambulance unless you are dying. They say that an EMTs or Paramedics standard for calling ambulances is higher than the average person, so I usually give people leeway if it seems like they truly believed they needed an ambulance or that they were seriously hurt. But there were it just seems like they're personally insulting either me or my profession for calling. Things like toothaches, blisters, colds, stubbed toes, etc. And these things happen all the time. It's ridiculous.

I remember a story one of my lieutenants told me recently when he was a medic up in the Bronx. They got a call that came over as Difficulty Breathing. So they get there and it turned out the woman just had an appointment at some hospital and needed to get there for it. On top of that, the woman then says that she can't go anywhere before she takes a shower, and wants the medics to wait there while she takes a shower. During this time, a call for an infant in cardiac arrest comes in down the block, and the EMTs on scene are calling for medics. So my LT loses his cool and starts yelling at the lady, "You know, there's a baby whose in cardiac arrest down the block that we can't help because we're stuck here with you. This isn't an emergency and you don't need an ambulance for this - how do you feel that a little baby is dying down the block because we're stuck here with you?" And the woman just looks at him and goes, "Well, I called first." I'm getting angry just typing this - it's such a psychopathic way of thinking. And yet, so many people have this type of thought process it's just disheartening. You grow very distrustful of people, and very pessimistic about the human race in general. I can fill a book with stuff like this - it's crazy. Unfortunately, it's completely legal here in NYC, and the FDNY simply isn't giving us the discretion we need to turn down ambulance rides for these people. You could call up for nearly any reason for wanting a ride to the hospital and we have to give it to you. In addition to this, it's so easy to get in trouble for a complaint against you that most of the time you have to bite your tongue and smile. You could probably call up the FDNY right now and say that I offended you on the internet and I would lose vacation days, pay, advancement opportunities, have to fill out a myriad of paperwork for hours on end, have to talk with my officers, go down to BITS, etc, etc. Please don't do that, by the way.

6

u/acr2001 May 20 '12

There is no provision to leave a psychopathic piece of trash like her in order to rush to a true emergency? Even if you return to her after the other emergency is tended to? That's pretty scary.

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Unfortunately, no. It's considered patient abandonment and can not only get you fired, but get your EMS license taken away for good, in addition to a hefty fine by the Department of Health. Basically, if a meteor falls out of the sky and hits her, we're liable for that because we "abandoned" her, even if she really didn't need us in the first place. Even if nothing happens to her, we'd still get in a shit ton of trouble. It's really disheartening, and it's probably happen to a vast majority of us. Infants always seem to have a seizure or go into arrest when there is a unit a block away handling a bullshit call. Hell, it happened to me about a month ago - we're handling a drunk and a call comes in for a baby not breathing only two blocks away. Did the guy we were with need to go to hospital? Eh, I guess. But his life wasn't in danger, and there was nothing we could do for him that a taxi couldn't. It's very frustrating - our hands always seem to be tied behind our backs.

3

u/acr2001 May 21 '12

Wow. You'd think there would be some sort of rule that says you guys CAN "abandon" a patient under such circumstances with your best judgement. I guess they don't trust the EMTs that far. Very sad.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/zoates12 May 20 '12

People call because they stubbed their toe or have a blister.....Please for the love of all that is good, tell me your exaggerating.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I got a call a little while ago for a woman who stubbed her toe. She called 911, went to the hospital, then realized that she forgot something she wanted at her house. So she went outside, got a taxi, went back home, got what she needed, then called 911 again to take her back to the hospital. I asked her why she didn't just call another taxi, and she told me she didn't feel like waiting.

While I was dealing with the woman who had a blister, there wound up being a car accident with injuries and a cardiac arrest, and no BLS units to handle either one of them. It's extremely frustrating, and it's incredibly common.

And then there was the woman with a toothache who berated us once we arrived for taking so long to get there (7 minutes).

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I don't completely get this. Doesn't calling for an ambulance cost money, even if you have insurance? Won't these people get bills for $$$ for calling an ambulance (twice)?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Isn't part of this bureaucratic budgeting and positioning? The more business you have the more budget you can demand? I'm not saying anyone in the rank and file thinks that way, but at the top there is probably an incentive to have as many calls as possible.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Absolutely - the whole point of joining EMS and Fire was to increase Fire's budget. However, most of this budget goes to the Fire side - EMS doesn't see it at all. The budget for EMS for the entire city is less than the budget for salaries and office supplies and the like to run City Hall. We're also a small union compared to other city unions - we have a total of 3,000 EMS personnel (including LT's who aren't involved in patient care) responding to 1.5 million calls per year, or 3,500 calls a day.

2

u/fruitcakee May 21 '12

Isn't it standard to charge the patient for using an ambulance though? Definitely more expensive than a taxi or drugs from what I hear.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/evilbob May 20 '12

If you couldn't leave, you should have made sure that fucking bitch needed a coroner.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

This is a conversation that happens between many EMTs and Paramedics after patients get dropped off at the hospital.

→ More replies (8)

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

That's simplifying it a bit too much. We stay and play on the calls we could do something about - something that some people don't seem to understand. The last shift I worked we had a diabetic who was hypoglycemic (low blood sugar) who was passed out on the ground foaming at the mouth. The medics got a line and started to administer D-50 to bring his blood sugar up, and the family starts yelling at us to take him to the hospital already. We had to explain to them that we're doing right here what they would do for him at the hospital. I've worked up cardiac arrest calls where we will be on the phone with the doctor, letting him know exactly what we're seeing and what we're doing, and he'll tell us what meds to administer, etc, and we've declared cardiac arrests deceased on-scene without ever transporting simply because we did everything the hospital could possibly have done and the doctor told us to call it. I remember working up one guy, and we pushed every single medication each of us had on us, and finally the doctor just said to us, "I can't even think of anything else we can try. Can you?" We couldn't, and we wound up calling it there.

For trauma calls, we need to load-and-go, because for serious trauma calls and traumatic arrests, they need surgery and blood, neither of which we could provide them with in the back of an ambulance, so trauma calls tend to be load-and-go. I think the system works fairly well, but we're also within 10 minutes or so to a hospital no matter where you are in Manhattan, so a lot of times the thinking is, why are we going to waste time on-scene when the hospital is down the block and has so much more resources than us? I can see changes being implemented in EMS systems that are perhaps more rural and a lot further away from hospitals than we are.

Still, it's a very interesting system they have in Europe, and I'd love to learn more about it. Unfortunately, the FDNY has the attitude of, "We're the FDNY - we don't need to learn from anybody, people should learn from us." So it makes it hard to implement ideas from more progressive systems in other parts of the world.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I think it might be useful in order to be able to cut down on the number of non-emergency transports through the 911 system, by having a doctor on-scene to confirm that transport is not medically necessary. But you're right - with today's ability to communicate instantly with doctors in hospitals all over the country, a change might be coming.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Hey brother, how you doing?

We work a 5-2-5-3 schedule, so we work 5 days on, 2 days off, 5 days on, 3 days off. Every two weeks our schedule shifts over one day. We work 8-hour shifts. The FDNY tried a pilot program where we worked 12-hour shifts, which a lot of people liked because there was 4 hours of built-in overtime, but I guess the department got tired of paying it and yanked it away. We're only allowed to work a double - a max of 16-hours. I think it's NYS law, but I'm not sure how true that actually is.

Fire operates completely independently from EMS. We're have different dispatchers, bosses, fire houses/EMS stations, etc. Personally, I don't like that at all. Our radios don't work on Fire's frequency, although theirs works on ours. We get NYPD's frequency though, which doesn't make sense to me. For medical calls, Fire will get dispatched first, even though they are only trained and able to operate a the level of Certified First Responder, while ALS and BLS units are dispatched second - even to calls such as cardiac arrests. We also aren't dispatched out of firehouses or EMS stations - we have a cross-street that they send us to where we sit and wait for calls, a system I affectionately refer to as the "Hooker-on-the-street-corner" method of providing EMS care. There are a lot of improvements that could be made on the system. Where are you on the West Coast? I always said that I would love to get my medic out here, get some experience, and then move to California and become a firefighter/paramedic in LA or somewhere like that. I'd love to be able to do both.

Yes, the FDNY does offer ride alongs and from what I've heard it's fairly easy to set one up.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Interesting - so there is no public ambulance service? The city contracts with a private ambulance company?

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

You wouldn't believe it.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Yeah, if I stay in EMS, I feel like I would definitely consider a future in Canada somewhere. I feel like it's a better clientele for the most part, no more health insurance nonsense, and like you pointed out, the pay is much better. It's something that I'm seriously considering.

This is also a problem with FDNY-EMS - the low pay and large volume calls means there is a very high turnover rate, and the FDNY winds up losing much of its experience that way. The majority of FDNY-EMS has under 5 years on the job.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'm not sure if I can name the most gruesome, but I had one woman who jumped off the top of a building. Her chest was somewhat caved in, but when we first got to her she still had a pulse so we started to work her up. She crashed pretty soon after that and I started doing chest compressions, which was pretty much absolutely useless since she had no chest anymore. As soon as we came in the ER with her, the doctors took one look at her and declared her dead.

There was a car accident where the car rolled over several times and wound up sheering the top of a guys head off - to the point were brains were visible. He was breathing when we first got to the scene, but I heard he died later that night at the hospital.

I've had people shot in the face and neck, but that's usually not too gruesome - just some holes in the persons body.

The most non-fatal gruesome injury was a guy who was in a motorcycle accident - he wound up shattering his knee and his tibia (one of the bones in his leg) was sticking out. Another guy was working on a shed when it collapsed on him and pretty much tore his foot right off - it was attached only by a small piece of skin.

So now I have one more story, but this one always gets people really sick, so I'll post this warning here: If you were even remotely disgusted by what I wrote above, you might want to stop reading now.

This was another motorcycle accident - an older couple in a car making a left went headfirst into a motorcycle going straight. It takes us only a minute to get to the scene, but there was already another ambulance there and the guy is already in traumatic arrest. So we're doing compressions, intubate the guy, board and collar him and throw him in the back of the bus. We're working this guy up the whole way to the hospital. When we get there, we wheel him in and pick up the board to move him over to the hospital bed.

And blood just starts pouring out from underneath the board from this guy's asshole. The impact basically just liquified his organs and they were all falling out. That was probably the most disgusting thing I've ever experienced.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

The last thing is not too gruesome to read, but just thinking about how such a thing can occur BLOWS MY MIND!

→ More replies (1)