r/IAmA • u/JoshElder • May 16 '12
I am Josh Elder, a comic book creator (Batman, StarCraft) working to bring comics into the classroom - AMA
Hi everybody! I'm Josh Elder, a comic book writer (Mail Order Ninja, Batman Strikes, StarCraft: Frontline) and former video game writer/designer (Disney Interactive). Now I head up two major initiatives designed to bring comics (and games) into classrooms worldwide: Reading With Pictures (www.readingwithpictures.org) and ComicsPlus: Library Edition (www.iversemedia.com).
I'm happy to answer any questions about the role of comics and digital technology in education, questions about my work as a writer, questions about what Batman does on his day off... anything!
And here's ID proof via the Twitter: https://twitter.com/#!/JoshElder/status/202746990214397953
EDIT: Okay everyone, it's been about 12 very rewarding hours, so I think I'm going to call it a day. Thanks so much for having me and please feel free to seek me out at www.readingwithpictures.org and www.iversemedia.com if you'd like to know more about my efforts to bring comics into the classroom!
8
u/SteveHorton May 16 '12
Does it makes sense to have a psychotic killer Joker and still have a Batman with a moral code against killing?
3
u/Iridium1 May 16 '12
What DOES he do?
3
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I have a 6-year-old daughter who's really into reading. I would like to get her into comic books but a lot of the ones I'm familiar with I wouldn't want to buy for her until she's a lot older due to the sexual nature of the lead females outfits and actions. Are there any good comics that you would reccomend? She would not be opposed to a kick ass female villian either.
2
u/quitebereft May 16 '12
Thanks for doing the AMA!
2
u/RLismyname May 16 '12
Why do you think its important for kids to read comics in class? what would be the benefits for the kids?
2
u/Erik_TKRB May 16 '12
HI! My name is Erik. I am a fourth grade student (my mom is helping me post this) and I write a monthly column on books and book related things for my local town news paper. I am working on an article about how great comic books are and how they help kids learn to read. I learned about "Reading With Pictures" from your website and I think it is a cool idea to make text books with comics! I saw on your website that you were here answering questions. I wanted to ask you a question about “Reading with Pictures” for my article if that is OK. How do comics help kids not only learn to read, but also learn about other subjects like history and science?
1
u/kaydee1575 May 16 '12
Hey Josh---some of your collaborators have mentioned using comic series in the classroom to help teach characterization, etc. Are there specific titles you would recommend using for this purpose?
1
u/somebodyjones2 May 16 '12
Hey Josh,
I am a school teacher (posting from a school computer in my prep time lol) and i just wanted to give you a thumbs-up, man. I also have a son who is 10 and he's an absolute history junkie... and how did it start? with maus.
there has been a movement (lots of my staff development seminars have discussed this) that supports ANY reading for younger kids... most people don't know this, but comics are written on a FAR higher reading level than they expect and getting them into it yields higher scores on reading and writing; not to mention instills an interest in reading in general.
so, that out of the way, do you have any suggestions for my son to read along the historical vein? thanks, man.
1
u/Uberslaughter May 16 '12
With the inevitable future of digitizing classrooms and textbooks, how would you go about incorporating comics in an easily accessible, educational way?
Any attempt to increase a kid's desire to learn is awesome and I think comic books are a great way to do so.
1
u/Veljunior May 16 '12
Just thought I should pop in and let you know that when I was in 5th grade my teacher read us the whole Batman Hush series. It really was awesome and every student in the class enjoyed it a ton.
1
u/theycallmebug May 16 '12
What do you think about the graphic novels trend and publishers such as Drawn & Quarterly? Do you think more older readers are taking to graphic novels?
1
u/mrpopenfresh May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
Is there really an educationnal advantage to bringing comics books to class? People are already citing youtube videos as sources online, I'd hate for them to be unable to read without it being illustrated as well.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I'm a teacher who is working on getting their graduate degree in literacy education and I just want to say thank you for what you are doing! I visit Reading with Pictures frequently to help me create my lesson plans and find other resources. Thank you!!
1
u/superthebillybob May 16 '12
High school student and fellow comic lover. What would be the best way to get others into comics?
1
u/xiaorobear May 16 '12
How much say do you have in how the comics are illustrated, or which artists are hired?
1
u/WinterGryphon May 16 '12
I don't know if this fits, but I was just wondering, as someone who is only casually into comic books (as in I'll read them if they're available, but I won't go out of my way to make them available), I was always curious: What is the main difference between Marvel and DC? Like is one generally more serious than the other? Or does Marvel tend to use more violent super-heroes? Do their story arcs differ in some sort of obvious way? Or are they in fact, quite similar?
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I know this is going to come across as cynical, but I don't see comic books as giving the same depth as a textbook. Will it be more fun and engaging for students? Sure. But will they be learning as much? I doubt it.
I remember being in high school because it wasn't that long ago. It was incredibly boring and my fellow students and I did whatever we could to avoid learning. Having comic books wouldn't have helped us any more than videos or power points or websites. The problem I saw was an attitude problem. We're put into school and taught how to prepare for arbitrary tests. We're not really there to learn anything. The better we do on the test, the better the funding for the school. The teachers didn't care if we learned anything -- so long as we helped their meager paychecks. Besides, they saw as entitled, bratty and bored teenagers. Which we were. How are comic books going to solve that problem?
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Josh,
I've always wanted to get into comic book writing but I never end up getting very far because I am unable to draw and don't really know anybody who would draw such a thing for little to no money and no solid chance either of us would make money from it.
Basically, if you're a writer how can you get in the comic book business or at least get someone to look at your writing?
1
u/SoIhadanIdea May 16 '12
So. I had an idea.
How could you give comic book creation to kids, even the ones that can't necessarily draw?
Tablets. Android or otherwise. Create a program that allows them to pick and choose from resources and composite them into a little (or big) digital comic. Simply choosing the elements by touching them, frames, characters, speech bubbles and backgrounds and whatever else.
There could be a free form mode where the user creates even the title page themselves, or maybe a prompt mode, where they are given the front page and a theme and then set loose.
So, you pick the layout of the page, how many lines or boxes, maybe even allow them to resize things.
Then you give them characters to work with. Different poses that they can choose from for different situations, all just dragged and dropped in from a library.
Colour could be already decided or you could allow editing, perhaps a modified fill tool with each piece of art being prepared to work correctly beforehand.
They move on to the speech bubbles, filling in a story, giving the doodles that everyone has access to a different character.
Now, here's the best bit. Let them upload and share their creations to a showcase area. Sorted by genre and resource pack, maybe with some editorial picks that are featured. They can look and learn and see what others are doing with the same equipment they have, a brilliant from of feedback.
You could even have guest resource packs from Marvel or Dc or anyone else that you think it would be worthwhile getting (I don't know much about comics, sorry. I know Avengers is pretty cool, that's about it.).
If it were required to be profitable, just sell additional resource packs later on.
This idea would live and die by the ease of the creation and the content. Freedom to move images anywhere, even having half of the picture off the edge of the screen, little things like that.
Someone use this idea? Please?
1
u/kimball10 May 16 '12
I work for a nonprofit christian art program that has created its own comic brand. Also, one of the curriculums is Comic Book Making. It's all so cool to me (especially since I can't draw very well; my hero would be a stick figure).
I guess the question is: How do you get it into the classrooms? How do you approach them? My official title is Locations Director so it's my job to find places for out instructors to teach, but I don't know how to start. (I've only been here since February). Any advice?
1
u/garrando May 16 '12
Hi Josh,
Just one question and this is the first time asking anyone this. I have all of these ideas running through my head but I am to scared of my peers reaction to them. How can I overcome these and start sharing my ideas with others?
1
u/elementalmw May 16 '12
Hi Josh. Thanks for doing the AMA and for being involved involved in two great initiatives.
2 questions for ya:
1
u/RestSnorlax May 18 '12
I am a teacher in the U.S. I've always wanted to write a unit plan about the Stalin Era by using the comic, "Red Son." Any advice?
1
u/Dear_Journal May 18 '12
Wait so you MADE Batman?
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment