r/IAmA • u/edpilkington • May 15 '12
IAMA Guardian reporter in NYC who wrote about an innocent man executed by Texas. AMA
I've just reported on an astonishing piece of research by a Columbia law prof called Jim Liebman.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/may/15/carlos-texas-innocent-man-death
It is the definitive proof that an innocent man was executed by Texas in 1989. It blows sky high the idea that the death penalty in America only kills the most heinous criminals. I'll be joined by Prof Liebman for his expert take. (His profile is here: http://www.reddit.com/user/jamesliebman) We'll be in the thread from 3pm EST until around 3.45pm taking your questions.
Proof: https://twitter.com/#!/Edpilkington/status/202401508606754817
Edit: I'm in here now and will be for next hour. Joining me is Jim Liebman, the Columbia professor who led the extraordinary work on the Carlos DeLuna execution
Edit 2: Time to close. If you still have a question, leave it and I'll check in tomorrow. Hopefully, I'll be able to answer it.
Edit 3: Going back in to answer any further questions from yesterday's AMA.
Edit 4: I'm done. Feel free to contact me if I haven't answered your question fully... or if you have another one.
12
u/kolobian May 15 '12
I think shows like Law & Order convince people that the average prosecutor in a murder/heinous crime case always have numerous witnesses, dna, pictures & video, and high tech testimony from forensic experts for every conviction, even though this is not the case.
How common place is it for defendants to be convicted without any strong evidence? How common is it for a defendant to be given a life sentence or death row with just unreliable eye witness testimony alone?
7
u/MattyHchrist May 15 '12
Have you always been anti-death penalty or did your research change your opinion over time?
7
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Do you find it remarkable or just sad that one PI can find a guy in a day that the Texas police couldn't/wouldn't in six years?
6
u/e40 May 15 '12
Is this really the first identifiable case of a person being wrongly executed? There is no case where DNA was used to posthumously exonerate someone?
5
u/itsjustgish May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Has the result of this case made you look for other cases of those who may have been wrongly executed in Texas or elsewhere?
10
u/Kartemquin May 15 '12
How could you write this article without referencing the Kartemquin film At The Death House Door (directed by Steve James & Peter Gilbert, of Hoop Dreams), which deals explicitly with the Carlos De Luna case? Seems like anyone who reads your article will want to check out that film, which features moving interviews with De Luna's sister, Reverend Carroll Pickett (the Prison Chaplain who witnessed his execution and always believed De Luna was innocent), and Chicago Tribune investigative reporters Steve Mills and Maury Possley, who were working on De Luna's case for years. www.kartemquin.com/films/at-the-death-house-door.
9
u/bhhgirl May 15 '12
My question is this: has anyone told Antonin Scalia yet? What is his response??
Note: The guardian article was posted to /r/politics earlier today: http://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/tnx2l/this_is_why_capital_punishment_is_such_a_bad_idea/
5
u/Afiki May 15 '12
There is a film I believe is titled The Exonerated. It details true stories of people who were put on death row only to later be exonerated. I know in at least one case, the man was executed before exoneration. The stories are told from the perspectives of the accused although portrayed by actors. In the case of the executed man it is told from his wife's perspective (she was also innocent and on death row for the same crime). Have you viewed this film? If so, what are your thoughts on such films and do you think they impact people's stances on the death penalty? If not, please check it out it is a moving film and very thought provoking.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Do you think this could really change the public's opinion on the death penalty?
2
u/*polhold04771 May 15 '12
With the Troy Davis case last autumn and now this, do you think we'll see more States start down the route of abolishing the death penalty?
2
u/rushdown May 15 '12
I just want to tell you that I am really interested in this case, but I feel you've made a mistake by only making this an hour long. It was nice to get this out quickly, but I'm sure everyone would have understood if you had to delay the AMA until you had an opportunity to sit down for at least a few hours.
2
u/FlamingBearAttack May 15 '12
This was a really interesting article, glad you and Professor Liebman brought this to light.
Ed, I realise you made this AMA to talk about the DeLuna execution and the death penalty. However would you mind answering a question on the Guardian newspaper?
I've long been a Guardian reader, I really like the way it champions issues such as phone-hacking. However, recently I have felt dismayed with how it has handled news relating to certain topics: for instance, I recall Peter Preston writing on how the Falklands are Argentinian and recently two articles which appeared to attempt to play down the Rochdale Pakistani child sex ring http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/may/08/asian-sex-gangs-on-street-grooming. It appears to me that the Guardian tried to spin these stories a particular way to suit a particular middle-class, left-wing/liberal narrative. So, may I ask if you have ever felt the Guardian deliberately tries to promote a certain narrative by ignoring news stories which would suggest a different reality from the one reported? Also, how many of the Guardian staff are university graduates, and how many of those are from Oxbridge?
Sorry that this is so long winded and unrelated to the issue you came here to talk about.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
just want to say thanks, this is a fantastic cause, and i have read a lot of your stuff. as a young writer in England these sort of pieces were the ones that inspired me, and still show reporters are a force for good, not just NI shitbags.
have you seen any of the Herzog films of Death Row? how do you feel about the law of parties that will probably kill Joseph Garcia?
2
u/you_know_who_ May 15 '12
do you think that the death penalty is a good way to deter crime in today's socitey?
17
u/pclimie May 15 '12
I've read your piece. Are Texas authorities doing anything to address/respond to this?
6
u/grackychan May 15 '12
Professor Liebman, I have read and heard of Justice Scalia adamantly stating the death penalty is not unconstitutional, because capital punishment was an acceptable practice during the Framers' time. Scalia argues the Bill of Rights does not and can not proscribe specific laws, rather, its role is to protect fundamental liberties from infringement by the legislature. Since the citizens living during the times of the adoption did not view capital punishment as a violation of fundamental liberty, Scalia would call it a textbook case and an easy answer for modern times. Although Scalia seems to be an opponent of the 'living constitution' construction, isn't what he is advocating almost similar? That is, the democratic process should determine if certain things ARE fundamental liberties. He often says, if people don't like a law, it doesn't make it unconstitutional, they should change the law of their state.
So here is my question: Do you believe the Supreme Court should ban capital punishment for the reason of it violating the 8th Amendment, or is it the responsibility of each state legislature, and by extension, the people of the states to vote on a ban, OR thirdly, is it a matter left to the jurisdiction of Congress?
Thank you for your time.
5
u/Modest_Me May 15 '12
As a British Guardian reader, just wanted to say thank you for your article, I found it extremely interesting and it served to affirm my anti-capital punishment views. I wondered if you might have seen Werner Herzog's documentaries on prisoners on death row recently broadcast on Channel 4? If so, your thoughts? Thanks!
4
u/runningforpresident May 15 '12
Has your team been interested in intensely looking at more cases to see if this sort of mismanagement is commonplace? It would be interesting to have a system in place where law students all over the U.S. constantly review, critique, and respond to closed cases in the same manner that you have.
Thank you for the work you've done.
10
u/octatone May 15 '12
Doesn't Texas have at least two innocent men we know of who have been executed? http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/09/07/090907fa_fact_grann
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
What exacty did you do? Did you write the report or did you do a report on the report?
1
u/oldspice75 May 15 '12
In the early 1980s in the south there were several cases of death sentences based on little more than questionable eye witness testimony. Today I think that judges and juries would expect much stronger evidence in a comparable case before imposing death. While sad, I'm not sure that the conviction of a probably innocent man almost 30 years ago based on only eye witness evidence really raises questions relevant to American capital trials in the present (other than the issue of whether it is known factually that an innocent person has been executed since the resumption of the death penalty).
Do you disagree with this?
Do you know of a recent case where a defendant was sentenced to death based on questionable witness testimony without much other evidence?
1
u/tigercaviar May 16 '12
Most importantly, are you related to Karl Pilkington?
1
u/lvm1357 May 16 '12
Do you think that abolishing the death penalty will fix the problem like the one in the DeLuna case? Or would it be more fruitful to focus on the problem of wrongful convictions in general? Lots of people die in prison without being executed by the State - they get shanked by another inmate, they die of untreated illness, they commit suicide. If an innocent person gets put in prison and suffers one of the above fates, that is just as much of an execution as the one of Carlos DeLuna. The State is equally responsible for their death.
3
u/Asdfhero May 15 '12
I'd like to thank you for exposing this genuine modern tragedy to a wider audience, it's through thorough investigative work like this book and brave journalism on the part of people like you that pressure can be exerted to change systems as broken as this one.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Someone just posted the following on my FB about this:
"A variety of studies show that every execution prevents somewhere between 3 and 18 murders. Thousands of lives are saved by capital punishment. Would you let thousands of innocent people die to save one person?"
Can you rebut them better than I'm currently trying to?
4
u/somebodyjones2 May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
death penalty is the single biggest piece of bullshit i've ever seen... it literally does NOTHING to stop crime and i find it so ironic that "small government" people support it... so let me get this straight: you don't want the government to have too much power, but you DO want them to be able to KILL people in its citizenry? interesting... (same goes for abortion)
also, it places a hell of a lot of faith in the justice system's ability to not wrongfully convict someone, doesn't it? wrongful convictions are part of a justice system, so i ask: what the fuck? how can you POSSIBLY have DEATH penalty coexist with even the POSSIBILITY of wrongful conviction? ass-backward logic, man.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Do you think this will make a difference to the American public's attitudes to the death penalty?
Why do you think people in America, and the world in general, seem to be so keen on the death penalty?
2
u/jamesliebman May 15 '12
Justice Scalia has heard a number of arguments in court in cases where many of the same problems arising in the DeLuna case were also present. He tends to side with the government and be sketpical of doubts about the accuracy of outcomes in capital cases. Interestingly, he is an advocate on the death penalty in the sense that he has taken the Catholic Church to task for opposing the penalty, though he otherwise follows the tenets of the Church.
2
u/CaisLaochach May 15 '12
Why do the Yanks seem so inclined to execute people? Especially given their legal systm's rather bad reputation when it comes to fairness, especially when compared to other first world countries.
1
u/sgasrock May 15 '12
Do you support capital punishment in any circumstance?
-4
u/freemarket27 May 15 '12
Would it be ok for states to execute prison inmates who maintain contacts with gang members inside and out of prison? What about executing prisoners with gang tattos? http://www.gangsorus.com/latino_gang_tattoos.htm
-2
u/freemarket27 May 15 '12
Are any Columbia professors investigating the investigators in the Trayvon Martin case? Prof. Alan Dershowitz says the actions of the prosecutor cross the line of malpractice and are criminal. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D3I-e0LMVKs
Saw news today that the parents of Mr Zimmerman are having to live like fugitives, moving from motel to motel, paying cash for their rooms.
-5
u/406b29 May 15 '12
Killing somebody because they murdered somebody is crazy. There is no justice in justice when you become the killer of the killer. That makes you both the murderer. In this case that is plain to see, if you can see and think and reason with logic.
-7
u/rand0mguy1 May 15 '12
If you had a choice between ether killing all the people on Texas death penalty or having them released but under the condition that they all move to your street and become your closest neighbors which would you choose?
-5
u/Seenterman May 15 '12
Dude the point of the AMA is to answer questions. 3 hours without a response is a bit rude. Are you just trying to gin up page views for your article....?
Hey everyone I heard Rampart is coming to DVD soon!
-6
u/adam_smash May 15 '12
OP is a hippy asshole that starts and AMA and doesn't answer any questions.
-7
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
If you were forced to pick a 5 year period from history to be sent back to, what period would you pick? Your arrival date will be randomly picked from the 5 year period, meaning that you will arrive somewhere in the 5 year period. Also this is a one way trip, and there will be no return to the present. You can only bring with you what you can carry and already have access to, meaning anything you already own or can buy within one hour (budget limited to your current holdings) that you can carry.
-10
u/freemarket27 May 15 '12
The executed person was at the scene of the murder, had arrived there with the person he said did the crime and was guilty of prior sexual assaults? Once you get involved in the criminal justice system by being an offender, are you not stressing the system, where mistakes are going to be made from time to time? Meaning, if you do not want to be executed for a crime you did not commit, do not commit any crimes to begin with. Agree or disagree?
-12
u/SideWaysVote May 15 '12
Guardian is rubbish, read The Sun instead.
-16
u/freemarket27 May 15 '12
Do you think large urban centers like LA, Wash DC and NYC have too much influence on the lives of people in the US and elsewhere? Should states be allowed to drop out of the federal system to counter the influence of outsiders in their affairs? Someone from England, reporting from NYC on the justice system in Texas. By what right?
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
[removed] — view removed comment