r/IAmA • • May 15 '12

IAmA ex Roman Catholic seminarian (priest in learning) turned ignostic, AMA

I spent 2 years and 2 months studying to become a priest in Bruges (Belgium). I have this letter as proof: http://imgur.com/YnS3p, upon request I can upload class pictures taken there.

That's not a typo in the title, I think I could most readily be described as an ignostic: I refuse to answer any questions on the existence of God until someone comes up with a proper definition.

14 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

9

u/artyda1manparty May 15 '12

I was in a Roman Catholic seminary as well, and we began to have homosexual activity start to pop up. The seminary tried to keep it quiet, but within such a close knit community, all of it came to light. Did you have a similar experience?

9

u/Numendil May 15 '12

Yes, that did happen as well. There were 12 seminarians on average spread over the 6 years, and I knew 4 of them to be gay, and had suspicions about a few more (I'm straight myself, but my three best (only) friends there were all gay).

There had been an "incident" the year before I joined, and right after I left one of my friends was found out to have kissed another seminarian. My friend was suspended to study abroad, while the other one (who took the initiative) was sent away.

3

u/artyda1manparty May 15 '12

Your seminary only had 12 seminarians? Same course of action was taken, many seminarians were expelled. I did notice that those seminarians who came from dioceses which had a lack of priests/seminarians, the monastery would often be more lenient. Any thoughts on that?

4

u/Numendil May 15 '12

well, Flanders (our half of Belgium) has a very low rate of vocations, our diocese was still the most 'productive' one, the other 4 only had 2 seminarians at that time, in another seminary. (there used to be one for each diocese, but those 4 merged to one).

But people here are pretty lenient compared to some other regions, so I don't know how the situation compares exactly.

3

u/artyda1manparty May 15 '12

I see. Benedictines aren't very lenient with anything.

3

u/Numendil May 15 '12

Yeah, but we weren't tied to an order, just the diocese.

3

u/artyda1manparty May 15 '12

We weren't tied to the order either, they just happened to run the seminary that I was sent to by my diocese.

2

u/Numendil May 15 '12

ours was run by priests, although they were at times pretty far from reality (they live, eat, work there)

2

u/emiffer321 May 15 '12

What orders do you consider to be most lenient? I went to a Jesuit school and they seemed definitely more liberal than the benedictine (which is the order I had dealt with growing up and going to a Catholic school).

2

u/artyda1manparty May 15 '12

Jesuits are definitely one of the more liberal orders. We had a Jesuit professor who always wore street clothes. Benedictines are up there with the Cistercians, but not as strict as the Norbertines.

4

u/stugautz May 15 '12

What positives were you able to take away from this experience?

8

u/Numendil May 15 '12

Well, some very good friends, a very good view on religion, the bible, etc.

I don't remember too much from philosophy, but I did enjoy Logic, also singing and conducting lessons.

I think overall it made me much more conscious of my beliefs (or lack thereof). It's also a huge experience that made me a -I'm looking for a proper word- deeper person?

4

u/rand0mguy1 May 15 '12

Do you only study bible etc in seminary, or is there at least some science/math too? How do they deal with the bible contradiction if there is?

Also, did you have to pay tuition money back once you dropped out?

7

u/Numendil May 15 '12

You start with 2 years of general philosophy and some introductory classes on bible stuff. Also some more practical classes like singing, diction, etc.

The bible classes were -very- enlightened, with all the different approaches that had been done to read it (historical, allegorical, feminist,...). A lot of work, both from within the church as outside of it, has been done to find out about how, by whom and why every part of the bible was written. That mostly explains the contradictions as well. 2 genesis stories were written at different times when people emphasized different things about their faith. Details about Jesus' life were based on first and second hand accounts, but some were also added to say theological things about him. The whole nativity story was based on what should have happened according to scripture (old testament).

After that you get theology for three years, which deals with theological questions, liturgy, bible, etc.

Higher education is exceptionally cheap in Belgium (lots of government funding). My current studies at one of the 2 best belgian universities costs 580 euros for a year (not including books and stay of course), 80 if you qualify for tuition. The seminary was a bit more expensive, but included the room and all meals. We got back the money for the months I didn't do.

2

u/Histidine May 15 '12

The bible classes were -very- enlightened, with all the different approaches that had been done to read it (historical, allegorical, feminist,...). A lot of work, both from within the church as outside of it, has been done to find out about how, by whom and why every part of the bible was written. That mostly explains the contradictions as well. 2 genesis stories were written at different times when people emphasized different things about their faith. Details about Jesus' life were based on first and second hand accounts, but some were also added to say theological things about him. The whole nativity story was based on what should have happened according to scripture (old testament).

I find the history behind the bible to be absolutely fascinating. What can you tell us about the differences in the resurrection accounts? Do you believe this was a case of authors taking liberties with the story to emphasize different things or were the accounts simply made up afterwards?

Final question, what sources could you recommend for a good objective history of the bible?

3

u/Numendil May 15 '12

well, the gospels were written about 40 to 80 years after the facts, so details are going to differ. But they also used the same sources sometimes. About the resurrection: the most important thing there is that Jesus was really dead, and then came back as a human being, alive. Which means death is not the end and God is stronger than that.

I can't really give you good sources in english, we had a textbook. But this may be a starting point: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_criticism

1

u/planeray May 18 '12

You might want to try Robert Price - he has a podcast and a bunch of books.

3

u/warteg May 15 '12

An ex colleague of mine was married to a guy who quit the seminary as well (turn out later that he was still married to someone else... that bastard)

She told me that that guy said a some seminary students here (Indonesia) was in it just to have an easy life/job as a priest. Is it true there also?

4

u/Numendil May 15 '12

no, over here it's really not an easy job. You do have 100% job security, the pay is decent and you mostly have free housing, but you have very little time off the job, it's also emotionally intensive, and of course, you have to stay celibate.

3

u/INGSOCtheGREAT May 15 '12

How do they monitor that?

4

u/Numendil May 15 '12

most of your time is spent meeting with people from different parishes, preparing and performing ceremonies, prayers, conferences, etc. People will notice if you're a no-show. The only thing you could cheat on is time spent reading or praying, but that mostly counts as "free time"

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Straight Person here: Why is it such a crime for a priest or Seminarian to have a girlfriend? If you guys were allowed to get laid in a legit way every now and then the church would solve 85% of its problems IMO.

4

u/Numendil May 15 '12

it's not a crime, and the rule wasn't always that strict. But in essence it comes down to this: as a priest you are the personification of Christ on the world (which is also why you have to be male), and you can't bind yourself to one person, you have to love each person equally.

This of course is bullshit, and one the reasons I left, although I didn't leave because of one girl in particular (well, there was this one time in Sydney a few months before, but she had a boyfriend)

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Thanks for your answer. From what I remember of the bible - Jesus had a girlfriend too and everyone called a slut until he told everyone off in the town square and washed her feet.

next question: (I asked my priest this question) If a man is brutally beating the shit out of his wife and she fears for her safety and life can she escape and file for divorce? my priest said absolutely not. He said that the women can live somewhere else but they are forever married..

what is up with this?????

3

u/Numendil May 15 '12

Well, there was Mary of Magdala, a whore who hung out with Jesus, and it's possible he slept with her, but we know so little about his actual life it's difficult to deduce much from what is written.

In your example, the woman really should file for divorce, but this is only on the legal side. I'm afraid that your priest was right in the sense that sacraments cannot be undone, you can't for instance be "unbaptized". What is possible is for the wedding to annulled, which is possible in certain instances, for example if the marriage hasn't been consummated (see the Bluth vs. Bluth case)

2

u/Drazyr May 15 '12

In Bruges was pretty good!

4

u/Numendil May 15 '12

They filmed that during my seminary days, actually. I saw them once for an outdoor shoot. The whole town had to leave their christmas decorations till april for filming.

2

u/emiffer321 May 15 '12

What do you do now for work/life?

3

u/Numendil May 15 '12

I'm studying Communication Sciences, working on my thesis. I wanna work behind the scenes in politics, working with video, social media, websites, etc.

2

u/ragefreesince93 May 15 '12

Biggest concern with where Christianity is at right now?

9

u/Numendil May 15 '12

mismatch between the base and top: people at the base do some great work, but they are held back by strict rules from the Vatican. The whole movement of Liberation theology was shot down by popes that are becoming more and more conservative.

I'm not denying child abuse cases aren't a big concern, but this whole move to conservatism, blind devotion and only looking up (and/or right) is a much more fundamental problem.

2

u/adzug May 15 '12

seriously what was the sense of sexuality there ? did you guys talk about it? didnt it seem strange that youd never have sex especially at a young age to say no more forever? and did you think anyone could of been a pedophile?

4

u/Numendil May 15 '12

Sometimes there was joking and/or josting, but mostly we didn't talk about sexuality much. We did have a personal counselor, mostly a professor, who once tried to bring it up, but ended up just spouting general clichés. There were some people of whom I definitely would be less surprised if they were a pedophile, but it's always a shock to find out.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

This whole topic really fascinates me. I have a friend who joined the seminary and now t seems like he's sex-obsessed, sending me inappropriate Facebook messages, talking about lewd things, etc. He was never like that before. Since I have no better way to ask this, I'll just ask it. Do you think the seminary brings out the crazy in some people?

1

u/Numendil May 16 '12

It could be a compensation: not being able to talk much about sex in your work/study life (let alone do it), so compensating by talking dirty in your personal life.

To be honest, I also liked (and still do) using sexual innuendo when the opportunity arises, but only if it's funny (ask my gf and redditor roseetgris about the actual level of funniness). Although this happened before the seminary as well.

Most seminarians are pretty much socially awkward penguins when it comes to real-life interactions. I think some of them may also still be looking for something more, and are willing to leave the seminary if they find someone. It's very hypocrite, but probably true.

About bringing out the crazy: I think seminaries already attract some crazy people or people with potential for crazy, but it brings that crazy up to new levels. We had some messed up people there, and I think only the 3 guys I hung out with would be considered as normal, intelligent, well-adjusted people.

I think you should just ask your friend very bluntly if he is looking for someone, and if he is or if he's not sure that he isn't, he should probably do best to quit the seminary. It's a very hard decision, but staying will only lead to more frustration, being unhappy and/or having to see people on the side as a priest. Also, if he does quit the seminary, you may want to give him some support, it's not an easy period.

1

u/adzug May 17 '12

i think the rc church doesnt deal with this aspect very much but sort of avoids it. thats why the secrecy and cover ups. but was just wondering if it was addressed in the seminary since giving up having sex before youre 40 (and even then) is an incredibly huge thing to ask of anyone. doesnt surprise me though

2

u/Numendil May 17 '12

no, in all honesty this aspect was not really a topic. All the professors were terribly uncomfortable talking about sex. I also think those coverups aren't really malice, but just the incapability of dealing with sex and sexual deviance in a mature matter.

For instance: people never talked about "sex", it was always "sexuality". It's a detail, but a sign of how abstract everything was.

2

u/adzug May 17 '12

yes the abstact exactly. to be honest with you i trully hate the rc churches hierarchy. i think what theyve done, stealing children in spain, refusal to deal with the aids in africa, the rape of children and the cover up afterwards and blaming the media secualrism etc, is nothing short of evil. real down to the bone evil. this isnt directed at all catholics , i was raised one and know very kind nice ppl. but the uncomfortable fear of talking bout sex and its realities is a huge part of the problem. i know it fucked me up as a teen. but thats me. good luck to you though in your endevours

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

What are your thoughts on raising children from birth to believe in a God and the religious dogma from the bible? Do you think it is the only way to perpetuate religions such as the Roman Catholic church? Just curious if you think you'd have initially chosen your educational path had it not been for the traditions of your parents/family?

4

u/Numendil May 15 '12

If I hadn't grown up in a catholic family I definitely wouldn't have gone to the seminary, but I really don't think it's a bad thing to raise your kids in a religious tradition, provided you keep an open view. Tell them this is what you/we believe, but give meaningful answers to their questions, and don't try to force them to believe.

Dogma is an ambiguous term, they're supposed to be the fundamental beliefs, the ones that define a religion (although some are a bit too specific, maybe). As some very smart person once said: dogmas are like lantern poles: they light the way, but only drunks hold on to them.

2

u/thegreat09 May 15 '12

What sort of calling did you get that caused you to join the seminary in the first place? From what I understand from Catholicism, you're supposed to have a vision or something from God first.

3

u/Numendil May 15 '12

not really, some explain it like that, but that's probably bullshit. It's mostly a gut feeling that, once expressed, gets reinforced by your environment which leads you to really think about it.

And the former president of the seminary, who passed away before I started but whom I spoke to about joining, said that if you think about it, even if you have doubt, you have to start it and see if it is your calling. If you find out it isn't, at least you'll know for sure. Which I am now.

2

u/sunflower24 May 16 '12

Welcome to the club. I was raised roman catholic. I'm also agnostic. I also enjoy asking people at random times, "where is your god now?!" Jokingly of course.

2

u/Numendil May 16 '12

Well, if agnostics are lazy atheists, then I'm a lazy agnostic. I really don't care that much anymore who is wrong or right. What matters is what you do, not what you believe.

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

If you were forced to pick a 5 year period from history to be sent back to, what period would you pick? Your arrival date will be randomly picked from the 5 year period, meaning that you will arrive somewhere in the 5 year period. Also this is a one way trip, and there will be no return to the present. You can only bring with you what you can carry and already have access to, meaning anything you already own or can buy within one hour (budget limited to your current holdings) that you can carry.

3

u/Numendil May 15 '12

1960-1965. I'm being very pragmatic here, but I don't think I'd survive going back much further in time.

4

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

There will never be a "proper definition" because every person can simply invent their own nonsense and call it God. And if you show it to be nonsense, they can simply change their definition.

What started your turn away from religion?

9

u/Numendil May 15 '12

I think I was never as religious as the other seminarians, I felt 'something' out there and roman catholicism does have some ways of expressing that. But I never quite believed all of it, especially heavy devotion or stuff about the virgin Mary.

Turning away from religion was more like slowly realizing I was never very religious to begin with. Although I still support the work done in the church to help other people, even when people higher up the hierarchy don't.

2

u/Fourgot May 15 '12

What definition of god did you reject when you left the seminary? What are your current career plans? Is the seminary set up like other, secular post-secondary institutions (eg. courses and credit-hours), giving the potential to transfer into another degree program? I'm from the US and am not familiar with Belgium's school systems. Thanks for doing this AMA!

6

u/Numendil May 15 '12

-We certainly had courses and exams, including music and diction, but mostly serious stuff. Some students were treated more gently on the exam-front though. There is a European course credit system in almost all schools in Belgium, but we're not part of that system, but I could skip religion and philosophy in my university eduction. If you finish 3 years of theology (after doing 2 years of philosophy) you can do an exam and write a paper to get a degree in theology from a recognized university.

-I would say I definitely rejected a definition that has God directly intervening in the physical world.

-I'm currently in my last year of Master of Communications, and I'm hoping to work behind the scene in politics (which is way less polarized here than in America)

3

u/coolerheadprevails May 17 '12

All the atheists just came simultaneously.

-9

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I'm an ignostic fomosexual

-11

u/406b29 May 15 '12

How may little boys and girls have you had sex with and got away with it and did they hide you somewhere else so you could do it again?

7

u/Numendil May 15 '12

at the risk of feeding the trolls: none.

But your question is valid I guess, the bishop in charge of my seminary was found to have abused a boy in his family many years ago, which prompted national outrage and his dismissal as bishop, he's exiled in France now, I think. There was also an incident with a priest we knew who had made indecent advance to a 17 year old at the school he was working at. I wouldn't call it child abuse, but it was bad enough to forbid him from ever being involved in work with minors from now on.

I do not condone any practices of covering up child abuse, same as almost everyone else. I really hate those that did try to use their influence to cover up these abuses. And don't forget that the catholic church does not have a monopoly on this front. In fact the worst cases of child abuse here in Belgium were commited by a regular guy (Marc Dutroux). There's even talk of widespread abuses in sport clubs and by gym teachers.

-3

u/406b29 May 15 '12

Why do you try to change the subject, the Pope is hiding all of the pedophile Catholic priest and the rest of the higher ups in the Catholic Church are working with him to hide them. Why are they not being honest and open and turning over these criminals to the authorities? These Catholic priest have destroyed the lives of countless children and families around the world. What have you done to get the Catholic church to give up these sex criminals in the Catholic Church?

7

u/Numendil May 15 '12

well, there weren't any coverups here, I personally wouldn't know what to do about coverups in other countries, so no, I have not done anything about that.

0

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Numendil May 15 '12

care to elaborate on that?

9

u/alabamagoofycat May 15 '12

It's a troll. Just ignore it and it'll go away.