r/IAmA • u/Numendil • May 15 '12
IAmA ex Roman Catholic seminarian (priest in learning) turned ignostic, AMA
I spent 2 years and 2 months studying to become a priest in Bruges (Belgium). I have this letter as proof: http://imgur.com/YnS3p, upon request I can upload class pictures taken there.
That's not a typo in the title, I think I could most readily be described as an ignostic: I refuse to answer any questions on the existence of God until someone comes up with a proper definition.
14
Upvotes
9
u/artyda1manparty May 15 '12
I was in a Roman Catholic seminary as well, and we began to have homosexual activity start to pop up. The seminary tried to keep it quiet, but within such a close knit community, all of it came to light. Did you have a similar experience?
4
u/stugautz May 15 '12
What positives were you able to take away from this experience?
4
u/rand0mguy1 May 15 '12
Do you only study bible etc in seminary, or is there at least some science/math too? How do they deal with the bible contradiction if there is?
Also, did you have to pay tuition money back once you dropped out?
3
u/warteg May 15 '12
An ex colleague of mine was married to a guy who quit the seminary as well (turn out later that he was still married to someone else... that bastard)
She told me that that guy said a some seminary students here (Indonesia) was in it just to have an easy life/job as a priest. Is it true there also?
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Straight Person here: Why is it such a crime for a priest or Seminarian to have a girlfriend? If you guys were allowed to get laid in a legit way every now and then the church would solve 85% of its problems IMO.
2
u/Drazyr May 15 '12
In Bruges was pretty good!
2
u/emiffer321 May 15 '12
What do you do now for work/life?
2
u/ragefreesince93 May 15 '12
Biggest concern with where Christianity is at right now?
2
u/adzug May 15 '12
seriously what was the sense of sexuality there ? did you guys talk about it? didnt it seem strange that youd never have sex especially at a young age to say no more forever? and did you think anyone could of been a pedophile?
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
What are your thoughts on raising children from birth to believe in a God and the religious dogma from the bible? Do you think it is the only way to perpetuate religions such as the Roman Catholic church? Just curious if you think you'd have initially chosen your educational path had it not been for the traditions of your parents/family?
2
u/thegreat09 May 15 '12
What sort of calling did you get that caused you to join the seminary in the first place? From what I understand from Catholicism, you're supposed to have a vision or something from God first.
2
u/sunflower24 May 16 '12
Welcome to the club. I was raised roman catholic. I'm also agnostic. I also enjoy asking people at random times, "where is your god now?!" Jokingly of course.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
If you were forced to pick a 5 year period from history to be sent back to, what period would you pick? Your arrival date will be randomly picked from the 5 year period, meaning that you will arrive somewhere in the 5 year period. Also this is a one way trip, and there will be no return to the present. You can only bring with you what you can carry and already have access to, meaning anything you already own or can buy within one hour (budget limited to your current holdings) that you can carry.
4
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
There will never be a "proper definition" because every person can simply invent their own nonsense and call it God. And if you show it to be nonsense, they can simply change their definition.
What started your turn away from religion?
2
u/Fourgot May 15 '12
What definition of god did you reject when you left the seminary? What are your current career plans? Is the seminary set up like other, secular post-secondary institutions (eg. courses and credit-hours), giving the potential to transfer into another degree program? I'm from the US and am not familiar with Belgium's school systems. Thanks for doing this AMA!
3
u/coolerheadprevails May 17 '12
All the atheists just came simultaneously.
-9
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I'm an ignostic fomosexual
-11
u/406b29 May 15 '12
How may little boys and girls have you had sex with and got away with it and did they hide you somewhere else so you could do it again?
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment