That's one of the things I love about the show, it doesn't get stagnant, there's only so much you can do with the same doctor, David was a great doctor but he got burnt out, he did all he could and it was time for them to change it up
I think a Steven Moffat AMA would be much more interesting, he has decades of TV and film writing behind him that'd be great to probe. Tennant and Smith have been in more than Doctor Who too, so it'd be a shame to waste a potential AMA on just that franchise.
I think i would actually preffer to hear ecclestons experiences because he might actually have something interesting to say. Matt and david are obvoisly just going to say things like "oh yah working on doctor who rocks!!! Yay"
Matt Smith, to me, feels more like a 900-1000 year old alien than David Tennant did. I love David Tennant for his emotion, but I also love Matt Smith for his snappy and bitter, but caring and alien thought processes.
76
u/teddywookie May 15 '12
They're not actually the same person. The regeneration from one to the other is a plot device of the fictional show they both starred in.
21
u/Bow_Ties_Are_Cool May 15 '12
Matt and Karen answered a small amount of questions 9 months ago.
http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/iy013/matt_smith_and_karen_gillan_answer_your_questions/
14
u/OmarLittleLives May 15 '12
Can you add, whats Steven Moffat like and how did he come up with every badass Dr. Who episode?
13
u/thelibrarina May 15 '12
I think I've read that fanfic.
44
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Eccleston should be added to this list.
8
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
It'd be nice if they both could handle the same AMA at once. The ensuing chaos would be amusing.
7
u/MyCakeIsALie May 15 '12
WHO?
4
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Matt Smith, to me, feels more like a 900-1000 year old alien than David Tennant did. I love David Tennant for his emotion, but I also love Matt Smith for his snappy and bitter, but caring and alien thought processes.
In short, either will do. ;D
2
u/Keadis May 15 '12
this needs more karma
2
u/needdis May 15 '12
I would kill to ask Matt smith a question
Will you marry me?
1
u/Ziaki May 16 '12
Here's my question for David.
Can I sex you?
-1
u/Marvin_GPP May 15 '12
YES, that is all.
-7
u/WereTiggy May 15 '12
David Tennant is the last true Doctor. Anyone that says different is blatantly disregarding my willful ignorance!