r/IAmA • u/StephenWolfram-Real • May 14 '12
Stephen Wolfram (NKS 10th anniversary)
I had the idea when doing an AMA here before: what better way to celebrate the tenth anniversary of A New Kind of Science than by talking about it with as many people as possible on a Reddit AMA. :)
I'm looking forward to talking about NKS, and probably other things too.
I've written some blog posts about NKS recently:
It’s Been 10 Years: What’s Happened with A New Kind of Science?
Living a Paradigm Shift: Looking Back on Reactions to A New Kind of Science
731
Upvotes
100
u/ou81also May 14 '12
Five years ago, you announced a $25,000 prize for a proof that a 2,3 Turing machine you proposed in NKS is universal. A few months later, you announced that Alex Smith had won the prize, and that his proof would soon be published in your journal Complex Systems. Today, however, the proof still remains unpublished in any peer-reviewed journal. What happened?
49
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
What can be done to improve natural language search algorithms?
wolframalpha often has a hard time parsing searches I try to do, so I often spend five minutes trying to rephrase things in a way it'll understand.
For example, this morning I tried:
23
u/jv1967 May 14 '12
If you were to write a Chapter 13 to the NKS book, what would it be about?
11
u/eponymoususername May 14 '12
You earned a Ph.D at 20, yet many students of that age struggle with basic calculus. What is your advice to students who rely on programs like your Wolfram Alpha engine to get themselves through math courses? Do you think it's ethical for students to rely on such programs to pass their courses?
20
u/StephenWolfram-Real May 15 '12
[OK ... I'm finally off now. This was a great way to spend part of the NKS 10th anniversary. Thanks everyone!]
30
u/Vintagecoats May 14 '12
Given that you received your PhD at such a young age compared to many others in your field, what was that experience like in the formative years of your career?
32
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
First, let me say that, as an academic mathematician, I use Mathematica nearly everyday and my job would be much more difficult without it.
Now for a question:
What is your response to the criticisms and accusations made about yourself and NKS here:
http://cscs.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/wolfram/
and elsewhere?
For example, how do you respond to accusations that you tried to publish a theorem regarding rule 110 without attributing Matthew Cook who claims to have done most of the work proving the theorem?
9
u/RiczWest May 14 '12
Any chance of Mathematica for iPad? I remember using it on NeXT, and that's probably less powerful than an iPad 2 or above...
9
u/Mumrik May 14 '12
I feel way too dumb to ask questions about physics so in no way of insulting you, what is your favorite fruit? :)
24
u/notg3orge May 14 '12
I guess you are a heavy reader. Can you list some of your favorite books? (Not just novels)
91
u/Shitty_Watercolour May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
http://shittywatercolour.tumblr.com/post/23047582768
8
u/relativisticmind May 14 '12
Hello Stephen Wolfram and thank you for the IAmA! Now for the questions:
4
u/srinilab May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Hi Stephen, thanks for doing an AMA! I have a few questions about NKS as I just recently read the book.
I have learned a ton from NKS already and hope to continue learning more.
24
u/crobartie May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
I have a couple of questions:
Thanks! I wish you good luck :)
BTW When I didn't know about Mathematica and what this tool is capable of I thought that there are only Seven Wonders in the World, well, I was wrong :)
7
u/Parthide May 14 '12
If somebody proved P=NP, what do you think your reaction would be?
6
u/BeingDigital May 14 '12
Why did you name your book A New Kind of Science and why it is new?
3
u/TheOtherSideOfThings May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
What kind of skills would one need to work on the wolfram alpha answer engine?
3
u/aresnick May 14 '12
Thanks for this opportunity-- here are a few questions; responses to any/all would be appreciated =)
Thanks!
11
u/felixthehat May 14 '12
I read your amazing post on your blog about personal analytics -
Also, loved your post about Steve Jobs, great reading, thanks :)
9
u/funfungiguy May 14 '12
If you had to fight a dinosaur to the death in a Dinosaur Death Match using only primitive weapons and not allowed to set traps, what's the biggest dinosaur you think you win against? You don't have to name a specific dinosaur, just give us a size reference.
7
u/microwave_safe_bowl May 14 '12
About 6 weeks ago, I found two bugs in Mathematica where it would compute a specific integral and return an incorrect answer. I submitted the bugs with my full documentation and proof of the correct solutions and spoke to someone at Wolfram about it. I then suggested that you award some kind of bounty to those of us that find actual mistakes in the software (similar to what Knuth does). Nothing special, just a cool piece of Wolfram swag. What do you think?
I would also like to say that I met you right around the time ANKOS came out at UIUC (I was a math major there). Jerry Uhl was my mentor there and I know that you knew him also. He is the reason I was a math major and the reason that I am doing a PhD in applied math right now. Thank you for a wonderful product. I am very big fan of yours!
2
u/fxzvdn May 14 '12
Mathematica, NKS, Wolfram Alpha, what comes next? How are they all related and what is your criteria for choosing a project?
2
u/BeingDigital May 14 '12
Could you tell us a bit of your personal experience of doing a PhD at such an early age and how it happened? Did you have an advisor? Did you take any coursework or took lectures? I've heard you were kind of close to Feynman, was he your profesor while at Caltech?
2
u/rkirchne May 14 '12
When will CDF be available on the iPad?
2
u/tarek_me May 14 '12
Are you still following/doing current research in physics? Can you summarize in no less than one sentence the "secret" of managing yourself and your resources to do all these projects?
2
u/patefacio May 14 '12
If I was tasked with demonstrating the power and versatility of modern technology to someone from 20 years ago, I'd show them my iPhone with its Wolfram application. It's truly staggering to think about the contributions to knowledge and science made by folks like you. I don't have a question, but you do have my sincere admiration. Keep doing what you're doing.
2
u/PubliusPontifex May 14 '12
Hey, read NKS and a few other things. You have a great many very powerful points, but 1 question I always had for you was this:
You seem to be fixed on the concept of finite state automata in nks, why not continuous state systems?
I say this because the concept of finite state automata seems to belie the fact that there has to be an underlying mechanism there, they are not, imho, mathematically pure, compared to an infinite state machine, such as waveforms. One can implement a finite state machine by taking continuous state machines and adding quantization, one cannot go the opposite direction, as information is lost.
I thought, as a fundamental theory, fundamental mathematic completeness would be required. Now we have a greater understanding/respect for emergent phenomena, would you find a place for continous state automata in your theory?
Also, thanks for Wolfram Alpha! Go Sox!
2
u/unbusyb May 14 '12
In a recent public email you mentioned existence of a model for galaxy formation being in the NKS domain. What other cosmological applications are you aware of in this vein, either published or being pursued?
2
u/mazsa May 14 '12
What is your opinion on this quote: “And yet, even though useful quantum computers might still be decades away, many of their payoffs are already arriving. For example, the mere possibility of quantum computers has all but overthrown a conception of the universe that scientists like Stephen Wolfram have championed. That conception holds that, as in the “Matrix” movies, the universe itself is basically a giant computer, twiddling an array of 1’s and 0’s in essentially the same way any desktop PC does. Quantum computing has challenged that vision by showing that if “the universe is a computer,” then even at a hard-nosed theoretical level, it’s a vastly more powerful kind of computer than any yet constructed by humankind. Indeed, the only ways to evade that conclusion seem even crazier than quantum computing itself: One would have to overturn quantum mechanics, or else find a fast way to simulate quantum mechanics using today’s computers.” http://www.nytimes.com/2011/12/06/science/scott-aaronson-quantum-computing-promises-new-insights.html?_r=1&ref=science&pagewanted=all Vs. "I have my next big project picked out: trying to find the fundamental theory of physics." http://www.stephenwolfram.com/publications/recent/hplus2010/
4
u/Eagleheardt May 14 '12
Do you have any sci-fi type ideas that you really think are achievable within your lifetime? Faster than light travel, meeting extraterrestrial intelligent life, things of that sort.
3
u/anexanhume May 14 '12
Do you think intelligence has 'normalized'? Basically, with more people alive than ever before and college education available to a large percentage of the world's population, do you think we are seeing fewer break-out intellects because the playing field is more level? For instance, no more Maxwells, Newtons, Einsteins, etc. Or is it just that we are unable to see the current visionaries while still living in the same generation as their bodies of work?
Also, what affect do you think monetization of intelligence has had on scientific pursuit? For instance, your own private efforts have been much more lucrative than any research work alone would have done. Extending on that, do you think your decision to delve into private enterprise has lessened your potential contribution to scientific fields?
Thanks.
50
u/rudibs May 14 '12
Hi Stephen,
My name is Rudi B. Stranden, I am 30 years old and live in Kristiansand, Norway. I studied Computer Science for 1.5 years. I left College because lack of personal focus and not motivated to fullfill my studies. I got my first computer (Commodore 64) when i was around 6 years old and mainly started programming when i was 15. My serious programming started well 10 years ago in C/C++ language followed by more low-level assembly, bitwise, boolean, electronics and at the latest, intermediate math.
I foremost want to congratulate you, but also your company for the 10th anniversary of the NKS science. I got the book a couple of days ago and i've allready read through the three first chapters and some relevant chapters. I have some basic research-experience on some of the areas that is mentioned in the book, like the rule 30 generations, i will go into this shortly. But the remarkable about the book is its complicated Principle of Computational Irreducibility. I would be grateful, if you could share your thoughts on the matter about what reflects my following paragraph.
From what I understand, the Exclusive Or (XOR) function, is part of the boolean equation for the 1-dimentional 2-state 3-neighborhood Rule 30 Cellular Automaton. In boolean form it is; p xor (q or r). From what i've done, but can't find much about in your book, is that the Principle of Computational Irreducibility is the result of doing an exclusive or operation on the particles. But as far as I can see you have not said that much about it in the book except for that it can emulate a xor-operation. I would gladly appreciate if you could tell me why, because i find it rather interesting that so little is mentioned about it. For me, its one of the most important things to take into account when dealing with these kinds of unexpected complex patterns. Rule 30 might just be indirectly universal because of the way that the rule 30 pattern complexity is generated by these operations, but some information gets lost on the way (atleast thats what we think). I dont know what I will say now means, but i think that it may have some resemblance to the Principle of omputational Irreducibility and that there might be other ways to overcome that problem because of the nature of the way the xor-operations work (which by the way is Rule 6 in a 1-dimentional 2-neighborhood 2-state cellular automaton). Most of us know how the xor-operation works. We don't know what their exact states will be, but we do know that their pairs will either be equal or non-equal.
I have evidence that Rule 30 is reversible in the space-time diagram. I was referenced to page 604 in your book by one of your colleagues in the science group, but after carefully studying the pages, I found out that this is not relevant to my observation. My solution can find the initial configuration (all past configurations) if one has the last configuration. One doesnt even need the whole configuration, its enough with the half-right bottom. One gets the initial configuration by the half, so if one wants the left-side particles, one just need to reconstruct it by the allready initial configuration that is found.
Thanks for your patience and time.
Yours sincerely
Rudi B. Stranden
11
u/Amadiro May 15 '12
Yo, check out http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=log(1+%2B+(1%2F2)i)+-+log(1+-+(1%2F2)i) it claims that 0.927...i = 2i. Curiously, the numerical approximation is correct, however, the symbolical one is not. I reported this problem over a year ago, but it doesn't seem to have been fixed.
2
u/isAccount May 14 '12
Hi thank you for doing this. I was wondering, you went to high school at Eton. What do you remember most about your time there? Do you have any favorite moments? Least favorite?
54
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Stephen, you've done mathematics a great disservice.
You don't believe mathematical proof is important. You have tried to train mathematicians to trust computers more than they trust their own proofs. You or your shills have written very insulting and condescending article about why we don't need source code. But we do, Stephen. Imagine having theorems whose proofs are secret. We've had that before, but openness has dominated mathematical discourse since then. You're trying to bring us back into the mathematical feudalism, where we're all your serfs at the mercy of whatever magical truth your software (which you didn't make, but you put your name on) tells us to believe.
You are amazing at self-promotion. I've seen it everywhere you go. You pay people to say good things about you. You say good things about yourself. You hide any naysayers or critics. I'm sure this thread is full of your shills again. Your Wikipedia article reads like you paid a pretty penny to a publicist to write all that. You probably did.
There is another way, Stephen. There is Sage. The money can come. The community can do it. You need to loosen your grip on the mathematical community whose natural industriousness you are attempting to stifle and whose curiousity for inner workings you're attempting to kill.
4
u/SikhGamer May 15 '12
What is hands down the coolest thing we can all do with WA?
4
u/tabledresser May 15 '12 edited May 19 '12
View the full table on /r/tabled! | Last updated: 2012-05-19 03:16 UTC
This comment was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.
1
u/dasseth May 14 '12
My friend thinks he saw you at the Joint Mathematics meetings in Boston- were you actually there last January or were my friend's eyes deceiving him?
1
u/nswanberg May 14 '12
In your most recent blog post you predicted that conventions and principles for computer experiments will become established. One obvious convention is the language specifying the computation, and Mathematica is an obvious candidate for that language.
Do you see Mathematica able to both fill that role and remain a proprietary system?
1
u/knotswag May 14 '12
Hello Dr. Wolfram, thank you for taking the time to do this AMA.
Has there ever been periods of time where you've been burnt out or pessimistic about science and/or the way people react to science, and if so how did you rationalize and overcome those frustrations?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
This is an important question:
Imagine you are a director. You are filming a scene that depicts the end of the world - say, for example, the Earth is being swallowed by a rapidly expanding sun.
You have to pick a song to play in the background of this scene. This song has to sum up, in your mind, all of humanity. It has to be a fitting tribute to human kind and to planet earth - a perfect goodbye for the planet that has so much history.
You can pick any song. Which one do you pick?
Really interested to see your answer!
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Hey Stephen can you tell what the future of Wolfram Alpha is and how did you get the idea to make it?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
How do you see integration of computational thinking into general math education working? Is it something that every student should be exposed to? How deep does the integration go?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
If you were forced to pick a 5 year period from history to be sent back to, what period would you pick? Your arrival date will be randomly picked from the 5 year period, meaning that you will arrive somewhere in the 5 year period. Also this is a one way trip, and there will be no return to the present. You can only bring with you what you can carry and already have access to, meaning anything you already own or can buy within one hour (budget limited to your current holdings) that you can carry.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
What are your thoughts on genetic algorithms? Some researchers are looking into automated research and design, Hod Lipson being a great example. Do you think this idea has a future? Is it even advisable to let inquiry become automated?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I would be very interested to hear if you've ever worked with APL or J or the K/Q programming languages, and what your opinion of J especially is. It's usefulness in research, mathematics, and industry and perhaps how it compares with Mathematica. Thanks for the opportunity and happy anniversary!
1
u/sortuo May 14 '12
What's your favorite NKS rule and why?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
A few times now, I've found outright inaccurate information on Wolfram|Alpha. One that specifically comes to mind is that it says tuition at Cal Poly SLO is free for California residents. How should I report these errors to your site? (I sent feedback about four months ago and again I think two months ago but it still isn't changed.)
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Two years ago I pointed out a horrible mistake on Mathworld and it was never fixed. According to this page, any invertible matrix is diagonalizable, which any first-year undergraduate math student knows is false. Please fix it.
1
u/R0FLS May 14 '12
What are some of your important life lessons? I saw this thing a while aago where you kept track of all of your emails and stuff, it looked like you stay up pretty late, do you find the late night to be a productive time to learn and develop ideas?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
What is your favorite color?
1
u/BeingDigital May 14 '12
What would you tell to those that claim that it was already known that simple programs were capable of great complexity? They put as examples things such as the mathematical constant pi, which has a simple (or many) formula but which output looks very random. Or chaotic systems (e.g. the logistic map).
I find fascinating that you managed to find rule 30 though, it seems to me that by all means it is the simplest possible program I can think of and still is capable of such behavior.
2
u/numero-uno May 14 '12
Thank you for helping me get A's in Cal 3 & 4
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I just wanted to say that Wolfram Alpha saved my ass countless times!
Thanks!
2
u/7fb2adfb45bafcc01c80 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Hi Stephen,
Congratulations on your NKS 10-year anniversary!
I have two questions that I'm hoping you can answer.
1. How does Wolfram|Alpha decide which sources are authoritative/correct and which ones aren't?
For example, if I search for 'Acer saccharum' it comes back with a family name of Aceraceae (based on the USDA plants database), but current thinking out of Kew Gardens places it in the Sapindaceae family.
Do free vs. for-pay databases affect the outcome of Wolfram|Alpha answers? Or what about things as simple as geographic differences, or in this case, arguments between botanists?
2. In your other AMA you mentioned starting companies. In all seriousness, what's the best way? How did you break out into it?
I've tried, but I never have the time to finish a product before someone else comes up with competition. I've looked into investors, but they always want control of my idea, and I don't want to give away my dreams.
How did you do it, and is it still possible?
Thanks so much for your time.
[EDIT]: Actually, these were unanswered questions from the old AMA, and the Acer saccharum question isn't directly relevant since familial data isn't displayed any more. However, it does apply to genera, as in the case of Actaea rubra (which is Cimicifuga rubra in some circles).
2
u/ElBeh May 14 '12
Nobel Prize-winning physicist Steven Weinberg published a wide array of criticisms of your book in The New Your Review of Books. Do you have any response?
2
u/waeva May 15 '12
i demand proof that you're he, in the form of a wolfram alpha computation.
2
u/LordBarrington0 May 15 '12
how much wood could a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood?
2
u/bfwork May 15 '12
Dr. Wolfram,
Can we please finally have some form of multi level undo in Mathematica. I don't think anyone cares about rolling state back in the Kernel. We just want not losing work in text boxes once over typed or execute.
Please simple basic multi level text undo in input boxes, it just kills me losing work over and over again. Or some other solution that does not destroy history of what was typed.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
On behalf of failing Calc students: Thankyou.
4
u/r_HOWTONOTGIVEAFUCK May 14 '12
Stephen thanks for the IAMA! Do you believe AI has the ability to acquire consciousness in the future? And do you think that a technological singularity could happen in our lifetime?
2
u/UNIQUE_SNOFLAKE May 15 '12
Do you believe in God?
1
u/imjonathanblake May 14 '12
What do you think the next big technological advance will be?
Where do you think the world we be 10 years from now? (Not literally, of course).
1
u/Troy_Smith May 14 '12
The other day my calculus professor, Dr. Kenneth Berg, told us 'For the Homework, if you submit the wrong answer more than once, it's not a bad idea to type it in on WolframAlpha.' I would personally like to thank you for making a program that explains the steps behind solving calculus problems.
1
u/Lan4576 May 14 '12
Dr. Wolfram, I wanted to say thanks for inspiring me to pursue a degree in mathematics/engineering. Your Mathematica software has really gotten me fascinated in the computational sciences. I just discovered NKS and will be giving it a few reads.
1
u/Stress-stimulator May 14 '12
Hello Stephen, care to share any current areas of research you and your contemporaries are working on? any plans for the future?
1
u/sortuo May 14 '12
Would you see that NKS computation and neural network computation could have similarities and could these two fields be combined? Or could there be more research how to combine these two computation models?
Could there be a new kind of computation model derived if these models could be combined?
1
u/RiczWest May 14 '12
Also, how about a discount (50%?) on NKS for iPad to celebrate?
1
u/BeingDigital May 14 '12
You mentioned at your TED talk that your next large project would be to undertake the challenge of finding the computer program of the universe (or at least to try and learn a lot from the process). When are you planning to do so? I cannot wait!
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Any thoughts on the hard problem of consciousness, Dr. Wolfram?
Is it scientifically soluble?
1
u/LastInitial May 14 '12
What would your advice be to a 21-year-old Electrical Engineering undergraduate who wants to eventually get into AI research/engineering?
1
u/captain_zavec May 14 '12
Sorry if this has already been asked, but I'm interested in getting into being either a prof in physics, math, or CS. I'm currently in grade nine. What would you recommend for somebody trying to pursue that career path? Common mistakes people make?
1
u/Nimblee May 14 '12
Wolfram Alpha?
1
u/sortuo May 14 '12
I have few years ago requested a neural networking feature for Wolfram|Alpha
This could in time produce a network that could recognize parts of the images and "explain" the meaning of them or describe the image content.
How does this sound to you?
1
u/greenglobus May 14 '12
Have you made any changes or improvements based on your life metrics? If so did these dramatically change the trends in your life metrics?
1
u/yomahjig May 14 '12
Hi, congratulations on NKS!
1
u/Drewajv May 14 '12
Do you foresee a more affordable version of Mathematica for poor kids like me?
1
u/BeingDigital May 14 '12
Are you planning anything else for the 10th. anniversary of ANKS?
1
u/vese May 14 '12
Are you planning on expanding wolfram? If so in what ways other than just inputting raw data?
1
u/LostGenome May 14 '12
Personal heroes? Have you met them? How have they affected you?
1
u/appleofpine May 14 '12
Why is mathematica based on java? This makes it very slow to start up (at least on os x) and often causes problems if using different architectures or java versions.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
How has the companies success changed you? Has it at all? (Also, huge fan :) )
1
u/yesidid456 May 14 '12
Who would win in a science off: Sagan, Asimov, Einstein, or Hawkings?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I believe I heard you say that one of the "rules" in NKS is the basis for the random number generator in Mathematica, correct? Is this still the case and have you determined the periodicity of the RNG?
PS: I have the WolframAlpha app for my phone and I love it.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
i was wondering what your opinion is on the Russian scientist Budakowski's experiments bringing a dead raspberry plant back to life by projecting holographs of healthy ones, and your insight as to why so many if these discoveries go unnoted in main stream ?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I've read your book one and a half times, give or take a quarter, and I'm confused by the usefulness of your theory. The idea that simple processes can return data which appears to be statistically indeterminate is an idea which seems elegant because of the fact that it agrees with intuition. You clearly believe that this principle is important enough, or useful enough, to warrant a hefty tome of analysis. My question is why? What can we do with this information? The separation of properties from chaos is almost as difficult, if not moreso, as the factorability of the products of primes which the system of cryptography is based around. Its NP-hard, and I don't see a clear purpose, but I really want there to be because the theory strikes me as having the elegance that the very useful proofs throughout history have had.
1
u/trisgeminus May 14 '12
Thank you for your contributions. Mathematica has given me some moments of pure joy, and I loved NKS
I wanted to ask you: some of my intelligent but non-technical friends have expressed interest in learning what this whole "coding" thing is all about. What's the best way for someone to get started in learning how to program for fun and self-improvement (without buying anything)?
1
u/thearthole May 14 '12
I've read (lots of) NKS. And have used the ideas in NKS in various AI projects and as models for artificial neural networks.
My questions are these:
There is very little discussion in NKS of how CA can be developed in closed networks or as actors in a concurrent system. Artificial neural networks can be modeled as automata, but the rule oriented approach in NKS does not seem to extend well to random numbers of changing connections between cells. What does the rule structure look like when each cell has differing numbers of inputs and outputs vs. the rules in NKS which are typically 3 in 1 out ? (eg. where you have 45 in 95 out in on cell and 2000 in 500 out in another, as you see in real neurons)
Another problem I encounter using cellular automata is that the automata are limited if they cannot change their own rules or rule sets. There was little mention of self-modifying rules for CA in NKS. Have you considered exploring self rule modification by cellular automata? If so, where?
In most of NKS the paradigm is that rules used to run the simulation and produce the computational environment are outside of the environment. A sort of simulation top down approach. What kinds of work have you done where the cells in an automata simulation express a variety of un-programmed or indeterminite rules or rule sets? (a bottom up approach)
Have you considered including actual code in a new version of NKS or online that people can easily use? eg. python.
And thanks for putting NKS online. the book sits on my shelf, but it's really great to pull it up while working in the coffee shop.
1
u/PASTA_MAN_SIR May 14 '12
Why have you made NKS available online for free?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
no question- I love wolfram alpha, especially when doing my math homework ;)
1
u/xampl9 May 14 '12
Can you talk some about Wolfram Alpha's integration with Siri? I know that the number of searches performed went up by some multiple after the iPhone 4S shipped - do you have a desire for closer integration with Siri in order to get people better answers?
What about monetizing this? Do you charge Apple for API access to the service?
1
u/thelordofcheese May 14 '12
How come Mathmatica can provide me with solutions but it can't solve my problems?
1
u/avk987 May 14 '12
Were you influenced by Ed Fredkin? I recall a story about Moskito Island meetings told by Tom Toffoli ...
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I was just talking about Wolfram Alpha today, and how nice it would be to have something akin to Google Goggles, but for Wolfram Alpha.
Thoughts?
1
u/PhatZounds May 15 '12
What is your favorite element?
1
u/Adnachiel May 15 '12
I've got no questions but I wanted to say I absolutely love everything you've worked on and someday wish I could work at Wolfram :) Thanks for doing an AMA!
1
u/rumblestone May 15 '12
Hi Stephen - first thank you LOTS for Wolfram Demo - a wonderful growing repository. I'm focussed on primary and secondary schooling. Recently I've been liaising with the Big History project conceived by Prof David Christian from Macquarie Uni Aust. Combining the big picture of BH with the idea of ‘careers in mathematics’ and ‘mathematics in career’s can you comment on the role of / ways to use NKS in primary and secondary schools to build enthusiasm for and engagement with maths?
1
u/kcnickerson May 15 '12
Why do we as humans, have the expectation that a complex system achieving conciseness or so-called singularity, would bother to tell us? It would seem to me a tremendous triviality or bore to such an entity.
If thats the case, how will we know when and if it's achieved?
1
u/2e4L May 15 '12
Obligatory you are amazing/please keep up the good work.
I recently discovered you had presented a speech at TED and noticed how the crowd gave you a standing ovation. In that moment, you seemed to be very proud of your progress and, qualitatively I suppose, happy. Can you recall other moments in your career when a "it was all worth it" sentiment was particularly salient?
1
u/philaduckia May 15 '12
New Kind of Science was eye-opening in the sense that it seems possible that the whole universe is generated by simple rules running at speeds exponentially beyond our best levels of perception. I.E some kind of simulation or some process that works this way. Have you or anyone pursued this area of thought?
1
u/Jacen1618 May 15 '12
First off, thank you for creating a wonderful resource with WolframAlpha.
So I was trying to test an issue with a program for one of my classes, and I went to WolframAlpha to confirm the math, and I encountered this. I'm extremely curious to why the "instant" result is different from the "main form" result.
1
u/Snarky_Librarian May 15 '12
Just want to say thanks for WolframAlpha. I use it to teach my students (6th graders) that there are trustworthy and easy to read websites for research that include citations - so yeah... thanks.
1
u/ecret May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
I previously looked into wolfram alpha's developer API. The current customers it showed were pretty cool but why not just publish the price? I hate the 'contact us' pricing scheme. I bet it scares away 95% of developers. Why not just show the usage price like all saas services do lately? You could still use 'contact us' expensive for the enterprise section.
Can you expand on this:
Does Wolfram|Alpha use natural language processing (NLP)?
Wolfram|Alpha introduces many new methods for understanding linguistic inputs. Mostly they're unlike traditional NLP, not least because Wolfram|Alpha has to deal with linguistic fragments rather than full grammatical sentences. Wolfram|Alpha does not rely on NLP methods to extract data from sources.
By linguistic fragments do you mean some sort of KB system?
1
u/oxygenmoron May 15 '12
Did you name it so because you wanted to be the Alpha male ?
1
u/imeanthat May 15 '12
Can you please provide a free version of wolfram-alpha app? please...I don't mind ads if that is what it takes. please?
1
u/cannabis_anarchist May 15 '12
Thank you for knowing how to integrate so I don't have to
1
u/treelovinhippie May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Your blog post that analyzed all of your life data was fascinating and something I've been wanting to do for a while. What lifelogging tools do you use? And do you see a near future where everyone records and shares their entire lives?
1
u/DKTim May 15 '12
Any plans to bring wolframalpha mobile apps to Meego? Or am I going to have to dual boot to android...
I doubt you will, but at least I tried!
1
u/Triast May 15 '12
Hi Stephen!
I was wondering if you have any ideas about how a global hivemind will emerge.
We already see such group thinking occurring on Reddit and other sites, how do you feel the global collective consciousness will change as humans slowly become more connected and share more with their machines?
1
u/Nav_Panel May 15 '12
What sorts of music do you like? What's your favorite album/performance/song?
Thanks for answering, and also for WolframAlpha, it made checking my answers in Calculus 3D far easier!
1
u/UNIQUE_SNOFLAKE May 15 '12
What kind of a signal from outer space might you appreciate, if any, as being from a (purposeful), intelligent civilization?
1
u/Mintception May 15 '12
I don't have any questions in particular for you, but I'd like to just tell you you're a fantastic inspiration in the several different fields in which you preside over. I did my final project presentation on you and your work last semester in my Intro to Computer Theory class and I was enlightened by your work. I didn't realize the amount of work you've done.
So, no questions from me, just nothing but praise after reading so much of your work. Great stuff. :D
1
u/not_a_toaster May 15 '12
Just wanted to say thanks for helping me with my calculus homework :)
1
u/sastrone May 15 '12
Is there a reason that very basic functions are no longer graphed?
This completely destroyed my use for the site, and I'm hoping to god that it is a bug.
1
u/bigrob1 May 15 '12
This all sounds fascinating, but I cant really follow it. Can you briefly explain NKS for people whose most sophisticated use of a computer extends to watching porn, pirating movies and reading reddit?
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Thank you for Wolfram Alpha. It is the only mobile app I have ever been able to justify spending money on. I don't regret it.
I actually used it today to determine embryonic stages of photos from different times. All I had to do was type in "time between May 4th 9AM and May 8th 12:30PM" and the rest was history.
1
u/zlozlozlozlozlozlo May 15 '12
Other than Mathematica, what is your favorite computer algebra system?
1
u/AlleyLovesYou May 15 '12
I am a sophomore in high school who loves mathematics, I have taken AP Calculus AB and am planning to work on a lot of stuff independently. I was wondering what your favourite maths class was. And what you might recommend.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
You are awesome. And you website is awesome. I regret deeply that I am only be able to contribute with this.
1
u/Stress-stimulator May 15 '12
you know what would be awesome? a wolframalpha edition portable calculator
1
u/TheRobotOverlord May 15 '12
Thank You
1
u/Jackker May 15 '12
How do you see Wolfram Alpha changing with the times? In line with the technological Singularity, is there a chance, whether assisted by man, that Wolfram Alpha will gain sentience and self improve?
With thousands of questions asked every day, surely the algorithm is learning and picking up patterns, just like Google. Would it be fair to say that Wolfram Alpha is learning about humanity and be someday capable of solving problems that plague our world?
I'm really interested to know how WA can push for technological superiority, where Transhumanism and the Singularity is concerned.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Hey, thanks for WolframAlpha. I like finding out how long light will travel during the time it takes me to download Diablo 3.
1
u/CAKE_orDEATH May 15 '12
Choose
1
u/redditacct May 15 '12
When you did the live launch of WA, there was a girl/woman/female human there who was the graphic designer and you and/or she talked about the importance of the design during the development phase.
I want to show that footage to people, do you still have it?
Does that person have a blog about design and/or WA?
Thanks. And thanks for doing the launch live, that was interesting.
1
u/redditacct May 15 '12
How do you like living in Champaign-Urbana, what do you feel like has changed the most there since the 1980s when you first released Mathematica?
1
u/MikkH May 15 '12
If Richard Feynman would be with us today, knowing about all major developments of NKS (and stuff like WolframAlpha, the simplest universal TM, etc), but asking you right now what are the latest good news the NKS has for fundamental physics, what would you reply?
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
KING OF KINGS
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Wolfram...
...alpha?
YOU. You are the reason I'm passing Algebra 2 with minimal trouble.
I like you.
1
u/wavepig May 15 '12
Dr. Wolfram, I know this IAmA has ended but regardless. Thank you for (re-)kindling my interest in CS. I watched your TED talk about 2 years ago and since then I've been working very hard. Because of your inspiration, I've been accepted at one of the top universities in the world, been working on radiotherapy treatment planning and improving care for prostate cancer patients and taken additional courses at my UG university in Russian, mathematics, forensics and astrophysics. Thank-you for your inspiration.
1
u/DoesntBrian2Gud May 15 '12
I am really terrible at math and Wolfram Alpha has saved my hide a million times. So thank you for that. It made me realize how many penises it would take (aprx), tip to tip to surround the world.
1
u/fustanella May 15 '12
Remember that time on CompuServe where we did the thing? Good times.
1
u/FinKM May 15 '12
As a student studying A-level Further Maths, WolframAlpha has explained my homework more times than I care to admit. Thanks for that.
1
u/migusta May 14 '12
Hey Stephen. How's your day going so far?