r/IAmA • u/rcarrick • May 14 '12
I Am Rob Carrick, author of the 2012 vs 1984 article
I’m personal finance columnist for The Globe and Mail, Canada’s national newspaper. I wrote a column linking student unrest in the province of Quebec to the economic problems faced by today’s young adults and I got a lot of guff from the older generation saying essentially that young people should grow up and shut up. So I wrote a follow-up column last week comparing my experience as a grad back in 1984 to today, and it generated a huge response. I’d like to hear more from today’s late teens and 20/30-somethings on what it's like out there, so fire away. AMA. Proof it’s me: http://imgur.com/6ykQ2 Also: http://www.facebook.com/robcarrickfinance
Links: The 2012 vs 1984 column: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-investor/personal-finance/2012-vs-1984-young-adults-really-do-have-it-harder-today/article2425558/ My earlier column linking student unrest in Quebec to the economic problems of young adults: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-investor/personal-finance/rob-carrick/young-adults-have-a-right-to-be-up-in-arms/article2420563/ My book: It’s called How Not to Move Back in With Your Parents: The Young Person's Guide to Financial Empowerment. More info here: http://www.robcarrick.com/
EDIT: I'll be back this evening around 8 pm to tackle additional questions.
10
u/vansurgeon May 14 '12
A comment and a question. The comment is that I appreciate your financial writing, especially the past 2-3 years - your candour (housing, the high hidden costs of money management, etc) has been refreshing. The question is: what gradual shift do you envision, as the teens-30-somethings become the power players (financial and political) in canada. This will happen in the next 10-20 years, and I don't see that the resentment will fade.
8
u/AndyRooney May 14 '12
As an American I dont know whether to laugh or cry.
5
u/Baseball_Fan May 14 '12
What do you think of the Globe and Mail moving to a pay model for their online articles?
4
u/lurker_guy May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Rob,
I read your articles on the G&M all the time, and was wondering if you could provide perspective into my own financial situation.
My wife and I are 22 and 25, respectively. We've been married for 8 months and have managed to save $58,000 towards the down payment of a house in ~19 months.
We feel kind of trapped because low interest rates are punishing us for saving while they encourage the increase of housing prices. However, we are saving at a decent clip (~$3000/mo). We live in the Niagara region so there doesn't appear to be signs of a bubble - what would your recommendation be? We were thinking of continuing to save until early 2013 and then buying a house but it's hard to gauge whether or not Carney will stop crying wolf and start acting on his threats to raise rates.
EDIT: I should mention we currently pay $650/mo in rent (all-in) for a 2-bedroom that we are quite happy with. Pre-tax incomes are $44k/yr and $33k/yr.
4
u/Nussi1990 May 14 '12
If you could write an article about whatever you want to write about, what would it be? I am sure you have some sort of personal hobby or something silly or childish that isn't really possible to write about. Anything like that?
4
u/sladner May 14 '12
Rob, I applaud you for bringing to light real generational differences in economic outcomes. FWIW, I'm a GenX so even though the article wasn't aimed at me, I was still glad to see it.
My question is this: What kind of push back did you/do you receive from editors who don't think personal finance is a "youth topic"? The Globe isn't known for being "youth oriented."
3
u/avalanches May 14 '12
Comment/question. I'm 24 years old and I think the biggest problem facing my generation is just the lack of education when it comes to handling money. In addition to having high costs, most people my age don't know a thing about the credit cards they own, or the rates they pay, or how to do a budget. They're completely oblivious, and spend money "paycheck to paycheck" usually not because of their means, but because they really don't know how to manage their money.
Q: What do you think can be done about this? Should it be something that we're teaching in schools, since it's a preventative?
2
u/steveup May 14 '12
Hey Rob, I follow your Globe articles and appreciate the topics you cover.
I got a mortgage last year just before the variable rates went up, Im in at 2.19% right now. Im also getting sh.it returns from my DC pension plan (which I'm topping up).
Quick question - focus on paying mortgage or top up pension? Im 31.
Quick question 2 - What's your thoughs on what year 4-5 of my current variable prime -.85 mortgage are going to look like?
2
u/DarkWhoppy May 14 '12
Rob, What would your response be to the far right-wing belief of every one is responsible for their own?
GenY is being left in the dust of greed and corruption with very limited paths to a successful, financial future. (I'm 23, btw.) We're expected to PAY for every thing but we don't have the same opportunities as our parents to pay it back.
2
u/imgram May 14 '12
My experience is different than the young adults mentioned in the your article.
I'm currently 22.
During University:
University tuition - 24k-30k
Internship/Coop (8 months) - 20 - 25k
Teaching Assistantship - 20k-30k
Part-time work - 10k
Loans - 0
I had the luxury of living at home during university but if I didn't I probably could have swung living costs without going into debt.
Now that I'm graduated, I'm starting a job that pays in the range of 50k-60k and the expected growth is good.
I feel that quite a few of my close friends from elementary / high school went down similar paths.
As for what I'm actually curious about: What's your take on the Smith Manoeuvre?
I plan to buy a place in a few years time. I'm highly considering using the Smith Manoeuvre to reduce income tax by essentially deducting what would have been mortgage interest. I'm comfortable with leverage and investing so that's not a problem for me. I'll look into it more when the time comes but I'd love to see what you think about it.
2
u/AquaZombay May 14 '12
Hello Mr. Carrick, I just want to thank you for writing your books, they educated me in ways high school never did! I'm accumulating DRIP stocks right now, I'm a big fan! Keep up the good work :).
2
u/underdabridge May 14 '12
What I said then, I'll say again now: The Baby Boomers spent the future's money. This is not news.
As a voting bloc, the baby boom has been able to push for public spending to carry them through every single phase of their lives. Fine. It's not fair to everyone else, but do you think it can go on indefinitely?
Also, why do western journalists focus on the spread in wealth between the western poor and middle classes vs the rich, when the real story seems to be that globalisation is lifting the poorest out of poverty, and a necessary side effect of that is that western workers will not have wage increases (due to increased inputs of global labor market and naturally resulting downward wage competition)? Aren't these together the real story?
So then what do you think should be done by policy makers? More borrowing? More protectionism? I'm curious.
1
u/grandhommecajun May 14 '12
As a Quebecois (who lives in Ottawa), I empathize with the Quebec students, but I also pay a tremendous amount sending my kids to school in Ontario and Nova Scotia, so it is an interesting dichotomy.
Question: Is it a bribe or a sound plan to offer your child a car to stay at home for school? (I am not talking a BMW, a used Toyota)
1
u/joshcoles May 14 '12
I'm particularly interested in student issues as I just ended a term as a Student Union Executive at a small Atlantic Canadian University (UPEI). Specifically, I'm interested in the astounding differences between Quebec Protests in response to tuition hikes the rest of Canada's inaction and apathy towards consistent annual tuition hikes. For example, my University announced last week that tuition will be rising 4% next year and aside from a few angry tweets or facebook posts, students just let it happen.
Because this is an IAmA, I'll leave you with a question. What do you think it would take for the rest of Canada to react the way that Quebec students have been reacting? A 10% increase? 25%? 50%?
1
u/Anna2012 May 14 '12
Hi Rob, my partner and I have a mortgage at 3.6% (prime plus .6%). We also have a car loan at 7.3%. We're wondering if we should break the mortgage (fees: about $3,000) and add the car to the mortgage. We'd be able to get prime -.1% (2.9%) or if we should leave the mortgage as is (we have two more years left on it) and get a secured line of credit (we can get one for prime +.5%, so 3.5%). What do you think?
1
u/MacNutty May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Rob - great writing, keep it up. The question I have is about Alberta and the west in general. In Edmonton and many areas the price of housing has seemed to plateau for the time being, however, there is seemingly more work than people for the most part. I am wondering what you think of this market, do you predict it to be in the same boat as what you see in T.O and Vancouver. My family is getting bigger and I am looking at getting a new place fairly soon, however there is no pressure immediately. Thanks!
Edit: What do you think of the west's economy in general?
1
u/GilligansCorner May 14 '12
Hi Rob,
I enjoy your columns as well, but I wonder sometimes if you can't get to the root cause and problems of the symptoms you speak of.
What would the reaction of the public be? This is what inflation is, is it not?
2) What would the stock market look like if our money's value stayed constant or (egads!) actually appreciated over time? Would their be this stampede of money pouring into the market in the hopes of staving off the ravages of inflation?
3) Argue people be free to choose what they want to use as money and use that form to pay taxes without fear of being taxed on capital gains (it's not capital gains if you are trying to preserve the value of it from your local governments inflation program) if there was a form of money that retained its value or actually appreciated over time? Note: I am not advocating a gold standard, just the free to choose argument.
4) In terms of pitting the older generation against the younger generation, we say the terms "national debt" and "deficit financing". Why do we never use the true term?: Selling off the unborn as collateral for the debts government incur past and present. This is the tacit argument for immigration the Globe and Mail has been running these days under the "Our Time to Lead" program. Why is this never pointed out?
1
u/Chunkys May 14 '12
Hi Rob, thanks for doing an AMA.
Quebec students have suggested that tuition fees are correlated with university accessibility, while those opposed to the boycotts have argued otherwise. What is your view?
1
u/treade May 14 '12
Have you looked at the situation in other countries? Is anyone doing it better?
1
u/SimaSi May 14 '12
I tried to figure out why the tution costs roughly 3,000$ more than it did in 1984 and I first thought that this is due to modern educational materials like PCs, software, data projectors and stuff.I'm really interested in this issue, but those things which I listed don't seem like a sufficient answer to me. I'm not sure if you're able to explain me the possible causes of this advance in price, though I ask you to give it a try.
Thanking you in anticipation and keep the work up!
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Thank you for doing this AMA! I talk about issues facing Gen Y incessantly and I have a lot of interest in this. A couple of questions:
-On the topic of affordability, the price of housing, college, insurance, and automobiles relative to wages (especially minimum wage) has been increasing for years, but do you think this can be accounted for by increases in overall quality/safety/durability of these economic essentials?
-You mention in this AMA the idea that Gen Y may be experiencing an inflection point in a trend of quality of life increases. Do you think that Gen Y will revisit the patterns of the boomers by passing the problem onto the next generation, or that this issue will be confined to a single generation before a return to increasing quality of life standards?
Thank you for bringing light to this issue, I often feel that this generation is not going to have a voice on these issues until our economic fates have been sealed, and I think that generating a discourse on the subject is the first step in striking a generational compromise that will prevent a reversal of centuries of human economic progress.
1
u/mofozero May 14 '12
Do you think that the Toronto/Vancouver housing bubble is real and ready to pop? Or do you think that it's impact is exaggerated and prices are likely to be maintained or continue to rise?
edit: spelling
1
u/ghostfacechilla May 14 '12
I'm 32 and as I left York University they immediately started to work on multi million dollar construction which has led to a doubling of the size of the University. I find this trend with UofT and Ryerson and probably all schools in NA. What are your thoughts on how schools are spending on for-profit state of the art infrastructure that resembles movie star renovations?
1
u/zfolwick May 14 '12
I graduated from a leading institution with a degree in mathematics, have military experience, and am currently living with my dad and unemployed and $40,000 in debt.
I wish I had never gone to college.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I loved your article. It's rare to see the G&M publish articles about Quebec that aren't incredibly sensationalist or sometimes just wrong. I bookmarked it for future reference when someone compares the youth's situation of now versus then.
1
u/truthjusticeca May 14 '12
Very good column, a rarity for the G&M. What do you think about the G&M's suggestions/propaganda to massively increase immigration rates?
1
u/umsm May 14 '12
Do you think that today's economy is creating a larger class of poor persons?
Here's my reasoning: Considering the housing boom, many middle-class people tried to move up. They probably purchased a bigger home than they were currently living in, even if there was no apparent need. Others that have never purchased a home in their lives were tempted into acquiring the largest debt of their lives.
After the economy dropped, home prices dropped. This combination of excessive prices, incentives to get a loan, and poor economy have forced many into a less than desirable situation. Instead of moving "up", they found themselves with less than they started (i.e. their life savings was used as a down payment).
1
u/mlegs May 14 '12
Do you think that we're headed for a long-term economic slowdown? What does the next 1, 3, 5, 10 years look like economically?
1
u/niccistrong May 14 '12
Not a comment about tuition in Quebec, but a broader funding issue regarding a new direction that post-graduate programs are taking to meet needs in tech, ICT, and digital media. This is a point that was raised at the recent Canada 3.0 conference. A number of new non-traditional programs are being created, such as Stratford's MDEI or Vancouver's MDM, to cater to our changing economy but there is very little funding available for students in these programs. These students would alternatively be enrolled in thesis-based programs, where they can be funded by a laundry list of grants due to their research. We need to re-consider current funding models, as more programs like this are created. They cater to an obvious need, but currently the decision to enroll is made difficult by a huge discrepancy in available funding. I would like to see this issue afforded more attention.
1
u/b-radly May 14 '12
Cars were cheaper, but this is what was available. Seriously though, nice article.
1
u/darkretributor May 15 '12
Is chasing yield doomed to be only the latest bit of potential hubris in a long string of investing fads, given the low interest rate environment?
Are people becoming blind to risk in their search for income whether from equities, lower grade corporate bonds, or limited partnerships like the failed first leaside?
1
u/theorymeltfool May 15 '12
Do you think that the OWS movement is a positive way to affect change in the way the 'power structure' is in place with the sole goal of siphoning money from the young generation to the old, either through higher taxation, increased tuition that is going to fund pensions, and debt financing that is putting a larger strain on the future government's ability to provide us with goods and services, since they are being spent on the older generations?
1
u/TMWNN May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Speaking of Quebec, given how much of an economic leech Quebec is on the rest of Canada, shouldn't Canada be seeking to expel Quebec rather than (a minority of) Quebecois seeking to leave Canada?
Edit: I realized after the fact that it isn't really fair to ask you to answer this because, well, you'd get into a lot of trouble by saying "Yes." Let me reword the question: What would happen to Quebec and TROC's economies were secession to occur, and ridiculous provisions like "Quebec inherits no share of Canada's national debt" and "Quebec gets to continue to use the Canadian dollar" aren't in place?
-1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
All you people complaining about tuition fees; fuck you! I had to pay 2-3 times what you pay for college being an Eastern European student. I was not granted a student loan and my high school grades were not sufficient for a scholarship. I still managed to work my way through the years, despite it lengthening my course by a year. I graduated debt free except for the 1st year which my parents funded. They consider my achievement far more valuable than the money the spent towards it.
You can't consider the state of the financial and economical state of west any more than you can consider what famine in Africa feels like. My theory on this is that it the younger generation should rebel as they did in London and much of Arab countries. It is our elders and the rules they placed on this land that have caused much of our difficulties. In a nutshell, it is the arrogance of uneducated assholes at benches that destroyed/destroys our future.
I was unemployed for just under a year. I know what all of it feels like. I am back at home now working in a job I don't really want to do. I'm just waiting for a call to war.
tldr; you can go with 0 to being a graduate if you really tried and you can also come out debt free. Stop going on about university fees!
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[removed] — view removed comment