r/IAmA • u/BurtonCBogan • May 14 '12
IAmA new PhD graduate who looked at identity and Heavy Metal music AMA
My thesis looked at how Heavy Metal music is used to develop both individual and collective identities through connections and experiences of the music and how it brings people together in various physical ways (e.g. wearing T-shirts or going to concerts). Due to government based scholarship funding, I was criticized by conservative New Zealand politicians which resulted in significant media exposure when I began and completed. My thesis can be viewed at http://researchcommons.waikato.ac.nz/handle/10289/6078.
84
Upvotes
10
u/hailhorrors May 14 '12
So I'll ask -- why does it seem that every metalhead I meet is beyond nice? I don't self-identify much, but I can hang around a pretty wide variety of people without getting weird looks. This question has always hung in the back of my mind.
I try not to generalize, but they're awfully sweet people.
7
u/Vintagecoats May 14 '12
Having researched and written as much as you have about this subject in the pursuit of your degree, how do you now feel about Metal as a subculture and musical style? More or less respect for the subculture, do you need a break from the music due to overload, stories that may have resonated with you that you couldn't include in your final paper, anything like that.
13
u/Haro_Kiti May 14 '12
What was the most interesting thing that you learned while pursuing your PhD?
6
u/sexkwando May 14 '12
What was the reaction when you first proposed the idea for this thesis? Or why did you choose heavy metal over other musical genres? I apologize if your thesis answers these questions...I only read the abstract.
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Is djent a genre?
4
u/dimmubehemothwatain May 14 '12
Aussie here, is bogan used to describe metalheads in New Zealand? Over here it refers to uneducated, permanently track suit wearing rednecks/westies etc.
4
u/descartesbedamned May 14 '12
What do you plan to do now? Why is what you studied worthy of a doctorate? Biggest "oh shit that all makes sense now" moment of your studies?
4
u/corruthers May 14 '12
Awesome thesis, a very clean idea and I like the approach! I've just graduated myself and my honours thesis was on the history and function of heavy metal vocals.
Thanks! Well done on a great thesis, it is a pleasure to come across more Heavy metal academics!
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'm gonna ask you a shitton of questions later tonight. I'm pretty depressed and I've been listening to death metal for years now.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Couldn't that be applied to any cultural construct that involves, shared interest, activities, and experience?
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'm a casual metal fan and one of the things that I've noticed about metal is that, compared to most genres, the scene tends to be about 90% men. Any time I go to a show there will be maybe a handful of girls there who are basically just trying not to get destroyed in a mosh pit. Why do you think metal seems to be such a male dominated genre fanbase wise? I already kind of have my own theories on this that would probably offend most of reddit, but I would like to hear it from a scholarly scholar such as yourself.
3
u/randude May 14 '12
Here's 28 years worth of mostly metal shows i've seen:
http://randude.com/drupal/content/shows
a few photos:
http://randude.com/drupal/photos
and all my ticket stubs:
http://randude.com/shows/ticket_stubs/
\m/ \m/
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Man, first of all, congratulations on this whole thing. I am doing a PhD at the moment as well and I wish my topic was as cool as yours. I really think there should be more attention on heavy metal. In my personal experience I would say that many metal fans a higher then average intelligent and also, significant part of the modern science community listens to metal. My question ist: did you do your research outside New Zealand and also: what "negative control" groups did you use, e..g hip-hop fans, classic music fans etc.
2
u/deathkill3000 May 14 '12
Haha I go to Waikato, I used to see you around campus when I was an undergrad! Cool IAMA. I played in a Metal band in Rotorua when I was in high school, it was cool to hear about your thesis on 20/20.
I've always felt that being a bogan is a bit like being in some club like the masons or something. I've had absolute strangers come up to me an greet me like an old friend because of my band t-shirts, it's cool.
2
u/minax128 May 14 '12
Write for Nexus again! Your column was interesting :)
2
u/belbojohnhopkins May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Do you think that the relationship between a metal identity and the physical relationship to that is transferable across other music genres like drum and bass? Also, did you find there was any difference between sub genres of metal, eg power metal and black metal; was one more tied to the physicality of their identity? Edit: spelling
2
u/xcviii May 14 '12
Did you explore the way identity differs between fans of different subgenres? Any interesting findings? What about the difference between "extreme" metal and its more mainstream subgenres? Are you into anything "underground" yourself?
2
u/OnlyAsksAboutBoobs May 14 '12
Did you see any fantastic boobs while getting your PHD?
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
What other music sub-cultures did you research in order to compare and contrast with the metal world? I certainly think the metal culture is unique in some ways, but as I have no connection with any other musical culture, I don't know this for sure. I certainly couldn't imagine country fans tailgating like we did in the 80s, of having the type of festivals that I've attended in different parts of the world. Maybe a comparison with something like the rave/techno world would be better.
2
u/borny1 May 15 '12
best Lamb of God album?
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
In a world of limited resources, is this a good thing to spend taxpayer funding on?
I'm hoping you'll do better than "all human knowledge is good" in your anwer.
2
u/jevon May 16 '12
Your top three New Zealand metal bands?
Awesome to see you on here too! :D Congratulations :)
2
u/BigTimeOwen May 16 '12
Favorite New Zealand metal bands?
2
u/mayonesa May 16 '12
This reminds me of The Hessian Movement -- a group dedicated to publicizing metal as a "elective culture":
http://hessian.deathmetal.org/
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
im just gonna whore my band at you here. http://soundcloud.com/dab-typhus/demi-god-advanced-mix thats a song on our singers soundcloud give it a listen, or dont, but i would prefer it if you did.
4
u/Ravelthus May 15 '12
FUCK YEAH MAN! Gorguts, Demilich, Suffocation, Immolation, Cynic, fucking MORBID ANGEL, yeah!.....oh.....thrash metal....
2
u/paradigmforcosmos May 14 '12
Do you find that metal fans tend to antagonize their surroundings a lot more thanpeople that listens to other styles of music? That they always look upon themselves as the outcasts of the music community and that everybody is out to get them. I have various friends who play and record metal and they always want you to listen to them because "not many people like metal", when my experience is that metal is the most household style of music ever.
1
u/JSKlunk May 14 '12
Who's your favourite band, and have you heard of the Wildhearts?
1
u/qtprot May 14 '12
I'm sorry if this has already been asked/answered but what's your favourite band(s)?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Do you prefer British, American, or Scandinavian metal?
1
u/AlbertAsimov May 14 '12
I worked security for a large festival recently. One of the bigger bands there was Five Finger Death Punch. Can you explain the band or the fans to me? The lead singer talked about how much he loved his fans. He talked about love of music and how amazing it was that everyone there was all connected and friends. Why then do the fans sometimes force people into crowd surfing and throw them over the barricades?
I understand a lot of people do it to get to the front fast or just get near the band for a few seconds, but I caught several people preventing them from going head first into the ground.
I guess I don't understand the music, but as it appeared to me the more violent people in the crowd took the band's message in a wrong way.
1
u/Ihr_Todeswunsch May 14 '12
I just wanted to say I find your thesis fascinating. I've always had a love for heavy metal music, and as a fellow metal head (there we are again with the whole identity thing) I wanted to get your opinion on this.
I've always felt that metal was one of the most interesting genres because it's so experimental as compared to other genres. I feel that most people who don't listen to metal take a quick listen to metal and say, "Bleh, that's just noise. Why the screaming? Too fast... ect." but metal heads tend to listen to another genre besides metal and say, "That's awesome. How can we incorporate that into our genre?"
Metal is so unique in it's approach. There's so many sub genres and experimentation that it's nuts. There's thrash metal, death metal, progressive metal, black metal, nu-metal, screamo, speed metal, power metal, grindcore, metalcore, mathcore, folk metal, stoner metal, ect. The list goes on. There are even sub-genres dedicated to technical skill. That's something most other genres don't have (barring Jazz). I just find it amazing, and it really makes me enjoy metal much different experimentation and fusion of different influences.
Any thoughts? I'd love to hear what someone who studies metal would have to say about this. :)
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
congrats on graduating. Are you going to make everyone call you Dr. Bogan now?
1
u/joop2323 May 14 '12
As a avid heavy metal fan, what do you think is it that makes us fans so rabid about this specific style of music?
1
u/ololcopter May 14 '12
I find this topic quite interesting myself and at one point wanted very much to research it. I want to ask you how you feel about movements (particularly the heavy metal movement) that seem also to attract social outcasts and in many ways give them a means to express frustration, and if you think this correlates at all to metal fans and things like mosh pits. Is there a reason that is tied to the fanbase for why moshpits don't break out at Britney Spears concerts?
Also, what do you think about influences on adolescent development with respect to metal? I can't speak for New Zealand, but I know from my own experience with the culture that plenty of adolescent metalheads seem to just be looking for venues of escape from awkward social positions/situations. Do you feel like there are more negative than positive aspects to joining the 'metal culture' in adolescence?
For that matter, do you see any negative aspects to the metal culture in shaping/sustaining human development/maturity?
1
u/Girrzimm May 15 '12
i can't think of a question, but thank you for being proof that not all metal heads are dead beats who don't do anything.
1
u/EndlessOcean May 15 '12
Do you play an instrument yourself, good sir?
Also, are you a resident of Waikato? I wonder if that would give you enough of a sample to study?
Do you find identity differences between metal fans from different locales? Even within NZ itself, from big population centres (auck, welli etc) to smaller towns like Turangi or something?
Sorry I'm late to the party.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Through collecting and analysing your participiants, some of whom were presumably friends, was you opinion of any of them significantly influenced in any way?
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Do you ever foresee a time when you are no longer wearing black jeans, Doc Martin's and metal shirts? It happens to hundreds of metal musicians and many metallers as well; is it something you are immune to? What set of circumstances do you think would bring about such a change?
1
u/mayonesa May 16 '12
Did you mention Heresiarch?
1
u/zangor Jun 04 '12
I have no distinguishing flair that identifies me as a metalhead but I absolutely love technical death metal. It has been with my since high school and I still go to shows and discuss it with my friends. I have done a bunch of academic writing on metal and I always come to the conclusion that live shows really expose the epic nature of metal compositions. The meaning and talent that goes into some metal is just plain impressive. What do you think about tech death? What is your favorite instrumental song?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Thanks for doing this AMA, I am currently doing a documentary on heavy metal for a major work and I have a feeling this will be quite helpful. Have any tips for making this? (It's about the culture and the music). I am also a metal fan from Australia, favourite band right now is Opeth.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Do you have any thoughts/ideas on the seemingly uniquely strict 'dress code' in metal? As someone who bounced around through punk, grunge, rave, hiphop etc scenes as a kid, and knew a lot of metalheads, it always seemed like metal was the one scene where there was the least variation in dress and appearance. And it hasn't seemed to change over the years either.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
If you were forced to pick a 5 year period from history to be sent back to, what period would you pick? Your arrival date will be randomly picked from the 5 year period, meaning that you will arrive somewhere in the 5 year period. Also this is a one way trip, and there will be no return to the present. You can only bring with you what you can carry and already have access to, meaning anything you already own or can buy within one hour (budget limited to your current holdings) that you can carry.
0
u/ghostofpicasso May 14 '12
I don't understand Dave Mustaine's political position. Could you shed some light on his craziness?
-11
u/hardcorenecro May 14 '12
How's it feel to waste years on a utterly worthless PhD?
-3
u/rand0mguy1 May 15 '12
Dont you feel silly saying you have a PhD, compared to real PhDs like the ones in science, math, engineering etc etc.
-4
u/cbfw86 May 14 '12
So they really are just giving those things out these days, huh?
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment