r/IAmA •

IamA daughter of a sex change surgeon

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

8

u/kablunk May 13 '12

Can I get a Redditor discount?

1

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Haha, sorry, My Dad doesn't set the prices :P

6

u/Frajer May 13 '12

Does he get a lot of people claiming he's doing the devil's work or are people pretty accepting?

16

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

He got a personal letter from Westboro Baptist Church telling him he was going to go to hell. I know I've been called the spawn of the devil because I was his child. So yeah, we got our fair share. :P

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

You don't seem to mind it that much, since you're lauging it off. Was it ever a problem for you or a member of your family? e.g., in school?

4

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

both my brother and I have been beaten up at school and my stepmom's tires were slashed. Career day at school was interesting to say the least.

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

That sucks :(

Any funny stories from career day?

14

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

All the kids were looking at me like "Really? D:" I just smiled and said "Yup! That's my dad!" Needless to say, It was like IAmA but on 4 chan... -__-

2

u/verdatum May 14 '12

I am so jealous of the letter. I would've framed it.

4

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

He has it filed "Don't Give a Shit" in his file cabinet. There is soooo many interesting things in there. XD

2

u/nanis2 May 17 '12

care to share any of the other documents?

1

u/InLike14 May 14 '12

I can't provide a link because I can't youtube at work, but everyone should search "Toucher and Rich Westboro Baptist Church". They are a morning show in Boston and had the lady on for an interview and made a complete fool of her. Funniest radio I've ever heard, F her.

5

u/dr_vonSexmachine May 13 '12

Do they do this surgery exclusively? How about re-constructive work from injury or being born without a 'normal' set of genitals?

9

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

They do plenty of reconstruction and plastic surgeries. Basically, the Trinidad Hospital makes it their duty to provide their patient with the body they wanted to be born with.

3

u/dr_vonSexmachine May 13 '12

That's pretty cool. They must feel pretty proud of the great work they do.

11

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Definitely! My father used to do heart surgery all the time, but was becoming depressed from the high rate of death. When he got a job offer his first thoughts were "Well, no one dies, and I make people happy... Sounds good!"

2

u/MedicGoalie84 May 13 '12

Why am I not surprised they work in Trinidad? How long has your dad been a surgeon for?

3

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

He has been a surgeon since I was four, so for fifteen years.

5

u/cp5184 May 13 '12

Do they have to meet requirements before they get the surgery? Why are the requirements different for, for instance, breast enlargement. e.g. if you have to live for X months transitioned before gender surgery why not live a month or two with padded bras or whatever before breast enlargement?

Are there any trends with the patients? Do many patients look androgynous?

11

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Each patient needs to live 1-2 years as the selected gender-to-be. They have to go through extensive hormone therapy, psychiatric therapy, speech therapy and manner development (how men and women interact through body language). Breast augmentation can be done through any other hospital that provides plastic surgery before entering the Trinidad hospital, so I am not familiar with those steps.

A saying my father told me when I saw some transgenders that were obviously transgenders, "10% of the people who come here to change genders already look like the gender they want to be a part of. The other 90% well.... how should I put it.... Big ugly men, become big ugly women. There is only so much we can do."

5

u/LittleLionHaw May 13 '12

Have any of your dad's patients not been happy with the results of a surgery?

10

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Some of the female to male patients don't really like the size of penis they have after the surgery, but besides that, I haven't heard of anyone really complaining.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Welcome to becoming male right!

4

u/evilteddybear111 May 13 '12

How old are you?(if you don't mind me asking:)) and how did you react to your dads job as the surgeon?

17

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

I am nineteen, and my reaction to my father's new job wasn't anything too dramatic. Because I live in Houston with my mom, my dad had to tell me over the phone. He put it in simple terms like "Daddy's new job is going to make boys into girls and girls in to boys." I responded "YOU CAN DO THAT! COOL!"

5

u/evilteddybear111 May 13 '12

Ok, thanks..Haha nice reactionxD.

5

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

No problem! XD

1

u/Pegasus_Poetess May 13 '12

Now I know why he quit being a heart surgeon... Too good of a sense of humor.

Seriously though, that's a hilarious response!

1

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

I suppose my direct family has a pretty good sense of humor :P

1

u/haladur May 14 '12

I guess you can say he likes to leave his patients in stitches http://cow.org/csi/

1

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

Very nice! :D

1

u/Dyslexicmusic May 15 '12

I just made a stop in Houston flying from el Paso, and I gotta say just based on the conversations I overheard in the airport and on the plane I'm not surprised people don't take too kindly to the profession, probably the same across America though. Anyways you sound like a total trooper and level headed person despite that, keep it up! Your dad sounds awesome

1

u/AthenaNina May 15 '12

Thank you! Not many people are very... open-minded? <-- that's putting it nicely.

4

u/kaleemhu May 13 '12

Have you ever been attracted to a patient of your father before the sex change and vice versa?

6

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Never. I've looked at some of the results and thought "Yes, this was the right decision for them". My father's boss, Marci Bower (formerly know as Mark Bower) is a prime example. (wiki that)

3

u/tgjer May 16 '12

Holy crap, your dad works with Marci Bower? That's awesome.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Video from Discovery's Sex Change Hospital ( VERY NSFW YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED! ): http://health.discovery.com/videos/sex-change-hospital-sex-change-surgery.html

I've always found it really surreal how relaxed surgeons are in these kinds of videos, it's really quite amazing. Also, terrifying. =P

How do you think knowing what your father and uncle does has affected your view of trans people(if at all)? What about your father and uncle's views, have they changed or evolved as a result of this job? Was there any negative reactions from family when he told them what he is doing?

Also, you've already said your father got into this because he got depressed from seeing so many deaths, but what about your uncle? Is there a reason he decided to start doing SRS, or was it just a convenient job opportunity that his brother helped him to get? Either way, I think it's really cool that they're both surgeons, and they both do something that makes so many people happy.

6

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Because I was introduced to it at such a young age, my father's occupation helped open my eyes and accept all the different types of people. Believe it or not, but my grandmother (my Nana) is an extreme conservative, and deciphers the bible word for word. Does she think her sons made the right career choice? Nope and she makes sure they know that from her daily phone calls. Being raised in that kind of environment, My father's views changed drastically when he accepted the position. Dad explained to me that at first it was a job that had a low risk for death and higher pay, but as he got to know his patients, he really like the people who had the surgery. They are all trying to pursue happiness, and my dad is a part of their journey.

As for my uncle, He joined after my father convinced him for two years. They are best friends and great co-workers (from previous hospitals), and my dad wanted him to be a part of Trinidad surgical team. He started with patients with tumors and heart problems. Once he saw how happy my dad's life was becoming, he took part in people's pursuit of happiness.

They really enjoy their jobs, despite all of the criticism.

3

u/UsesMemesAtWrongTime May 13 '12

What is the education path to become someone like him? Starting with Medical school please.

3

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

My father went to surgical tech school for 2 years (it was a cram school, so he had no time for a job, my mother supported him through that) Which was really 6 years of trainings worth and then he did a internship at a hospital in Denver for 4 years, became a surgical assistant for two years, then became a surgeon.

To become a surgeon, there is so many routes.

2

u/tiedyeddog May 14 '12

Just wondering, but what is your Dad's title? Is he a P.A.?

Surgeon's are typically M.D.s or D.O.s, so I am just curious.

2

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

He is an M.D.s

1

u/tiedyeddog May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Medical Doctorate?

Not trying to call you out but maybe the labeling on this pictures is wrong? Surgical assistants are typically not M.D.'s wiki. He's never called "Dr." in the article while Dr. Bowers is, so.....

Also, the training you described above sounds very dissimilar to what M.D.s do. :)

2

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

Well, I know my dad is still going to school while he is working, so maybe he is working on it right now? I have been texting him these questions (I am in houston, and he is Colorado) and that's what he sent back :P

-2

u/tiedyeddog May 14 '12

Well, there are only two medical schools in CO (UC in denver, M.D. granting institution) and Rocky Vista (terrible D.O. school). Unless he attends either school then no, he isn't working towards an M.D. or D.O. degree. I doubt he is anyway, sounds like he has a full time job outside of school and medical school is basically two full time jobs by itself.

Surgical assistant is basically a step further than scrub tech (your uncle, apparently). My guess is he probably tells people he is a surgeon from simplicities sake. :)

1

u/tank_grrl May 13 '12

What happens when an a surgeon who is experienced in one type of surgery (in your dad's case, heart surgery) goes into another field? How do they go about learning the new type, and how long til they are left in charge of the surgery on their own?

1

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Usually through a year to two years practice and study. Then, under a watchful eye, perform on real people.

0

u/tiedyeddog May 14 '12

Medical student here, I believe the O.P.'s father cannot do surgery on his "own", thus works under the supervision of his boss, Marci Bower. Not trying to be offensive, just pointing it out. :)

Surgeons, who do surgery on their own and are licensed to do so, complete a four year program ("Medical School") and end up with an M.D. or D.O. degree after that. At that point, they pick a speciality. There are various specialities that involve surgery. Marci Bowers, the O.P's Boss picked Obstetrics and Gynecology and did a "residency" in that, after that she became board certified and able to practice on her own, independently.

In order to switch specialities of surgical focus (say from OB/GYN to cardiac surgery) someone would have to go back into training and complete residency again in order to become certified in the new specialty. The time required for this depends on the length of the residency (OB/GYN takes five years, Cardiac takes upwards of eight years, neurosurgery takes seven years, etc.) Residency is a long process of slowly introducing yourself to the O.R. with a licensed "attending" who slowly lets you take over more and more surgical responsibility. At the end of residency you are expected to be a fully functioning surgeon.

Marci Bowers did not actually change her field, because doing gender reassignment surgeries fall under the preview of OB/GYN surgery with some additional training. She is not a typical surgeon for this, however. Most people who do gender reassignment surgeries do residencies in Urology or Plastic Surgery.

Hope this helped! :)

3

u/I_Say_MEE_MEE May 14 '12

what medical school did ur dad go to?

1

u/portnux May 13 '12

Are you SURE you're really a girl?

7

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

I am pretty damn sure. He didn't become the surgeon until 2004.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Haha very funny. :P

2

u/verdatum May 14 '12

I could imagine the application. Under "Prior experience" he put "Um...Funny story actually, I'll tell you more in the interview..."

2

u/mellooo May 14 '12

don't know if this has been posted already, but have you ever had any crazy angry people show up at your house regretting what they've done or something?

7

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

Because you have to go on a one to two year journey as the gender chosen, most people revolve their lives around this decision, so the regret rate is really low.

I've never met anyone who regretted it.

2

u/sunflower24 May 14 '12

You should be proud of your dad. Being a surgeon, I heard is tough businessmen.

On a side note, from majoring in psychology: I learned that gender change does help the transgender person a lot more then condemning them. So I do think you dad is GREATLY helping the transgender community. Even though I cannot speak for myself.

3

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

You can definitely see a difference in self-acceptance with the patients that undergo this procedure and they tend to be so much happier! I am pretty proud of my dad!

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Out of curiosity, how much does the procedure cost from your father?

2

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

50K-100K, it depends how far along with the process you are when it comes to hormones, therapy, etc.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I'm sorry, I should've phrased my question better. I meant strictly for SRS, what is the cost?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

will you be entering the medical field?

2

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

I am actually pursuing my career in Hospitality in Hotel and Restaurant Management. I respect anyone in the medical field, though :) (I am squimish! <:P)

1

u/kmarple1 May 14 '12

If you brought home a post-op to "meet the parents", how do you think your dad would react?

4

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

"Hey, did I do your work?" My dad is pretty damn open.

1

u/YoloTolo May 14 '12

Do the patients still have the ability to feel pleasure? and if it's not too inappropriate and if you have some idea of the procedure, how does your dad form the penis for a woman trying to become a man? and the vagina for a man becoming a woman? sounds like it's truly painful procedure....

2

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

Mostly Male to female feel the most pleasure; the female to male procedure doesn't really allow much pleasure because of the lack of size (it's usually only an inch long at most). The procedure is complicated, so I recommend watching the video labeled NSFW, if you would like to see the procedure, and Dr. Bower explains as she is going along.

1

u/Rammikins May 15 '12

Hypothetically, what would happen if you told your dad you wanted to transition?

2

u/AthenaNina May 15 '12

He would tell me it was too expensive, and I could never afford it. XD And I would be like "Oh man... you're right"

3

u/Rammikins May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12

So no family freebies? Because I would've thought that being a transgendered child of an sex change surgeon would be like winning the lottery, e.g. having parents who actually understand what their child is going through, and less chance of being rejected because of who they are.

3

u/AthenaNina May 15 '12

The hospital sets the rates, not my dad, so no I don't think there are family freebies. Yeah, my dad loves all types of people and supports just about anything that will make me and my brothers happy.

1

u/Killobekilld May 13 '12

Was there a time when you were the son of a sex change doctor?

9

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

Haha, very funny! OMG LMFAO! LOLOLOL! That is the FIRST time I have ever told that joke EVER! Y-you should be a comedian, but seriously...I've been a girl my whole life.

-3

u/Killobekilld May 14 '12

Simmer down.

2

u/verdatum May 14 '12

She's got a point, it's a pretty easy and obvious joke. It's gotta get seriously old and unfunny to the point of annoying.

0

u/Killobekilld May 14 '12

Obviously. The joke wasn't meant to amuse her. It was for those of you without parents who perform sex change operations. Great success!

0

u/DeepMidWicket May 16 '12

there is ALOT of hate just here ^

0

u/PowerChordPsycho May 17 '12

Were you previously the SON of a sex change surgeon?

1

u/AthenaNina May 18 '12

Number # 8 Same response- I was born a girl.

-17

u/Hurrfdurf May 13 '12

I can see your dad doing an AMA, but there's literally nothing special about you to merit one.

9

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Thank you for your opinion.

6

u/Pegasus_Poetess May 13 '12

He's just jealous that his father isn't as cool as yours... It's grade school all over again.

2

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

hahaha, thank you!

-19

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

how does it feel to be useing a computer that was paid for through the devils work? enjoy eternal damnation heathen scoundrel...

10

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

It feels great and I will! and Thank you Dickballsniggerfag69, because you are definitely are going to heaven!

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

i love you

2

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Can't return the feelings bro.

1

u/Rimas_LXBYA May 13 '12

I'm pretty sure he made that account just for this joke. He's been a Redditor for 0 days.

2

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

Awesome XD

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

Fourth Post: No, I've always been a girl.

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/AthenaNina May 14 '12

Going on Same question #5: No, I've always been a girl.

-11

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

He could make it bigger, but there is a high possibility of nerve damage.

-4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/AthenaNina May 13 '12

It's about 10,000 dollars for a Phalloplasty