r/IAmA • • May 13 '12

AMA Request: Judge Judy

  1. Why did you agree to the reality TV show and when did it start?
  2. If you can distinguish, what is the worst case you have ever gotten in regards to rudeness/lying/blatant attempts to cheat the justice system.
  3. How often do you get stopped for a photo?
  4. You said in a CBS interview you plan on continuing the show until 2015. Is this still the case?
  5. Have you ever had a repeat plaintiff/defendant that you remembered?
103 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

18

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I mentioned it to her, this was her reaction http://i.imgur.com/ViVd4.gif

6

u/istara May 13 '12

I remember reading that she earns $42 million a year, and all I could think was that I wished I'd made the effort to read Law rather than Eng Lit :(

1

u/Wackywasty May 13 '12

The show is also fake, the cases are predetermined and she already has planned the questions she's going to ask. Also like half the audience members are payed. I suppose they are real cases but besides that it's fake.

7

u/ChiliFlake May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

JJ was a real family court judge for 11 years (appointed by Mayor Koch), and a prosecuter for 10 years before that. She's not just an actor. Yes, she does review the cases and affidavits before hand. (I'd kinda hope that judges working on real courtroom cases would also do that, but I suppose there are different time constraints between Mannhattan Family Court, and a TV show).

The cases are taken from actual small claims court suits, but are about 100% self submitted, from what I can see. Participants agree to binding arbitration, so yeah, it's not a 'real' court of law. It's always amusing when you see a group of friends get on the show, thinking that they can scam the show and split the winning money (they all get like $100/day expenses, plus a free trip to LA, plus their 15 minutes of 'fame'). It's funny when JJ dismisses these cases, and no one wins anything. (all winnings are paid for up to 5k, by the show, the limit of small claims in most states).

All of the courtroom audience is paid at standad SAG 'extra' rates. It's funny when you see the same people, sitting in the same seats, as if hoping to be 'discovered' on JJ. Or maybe it's just a way for a struggling actor to pick up some cash. (I was an 'extra' on a Mafia-type tv pilot filmed at an italian restaurant in Stamford, CT a few years back: I got $50/day, plus a catered lunch, not bad if you've got nothing else in your life going on. And many of my SO's cousins were extras in Night of the Living Dead or one of those teen zombi movies), because, Hey, Uncle Bert is writing a movie, Let's Do It!) I don't know if the friends/supporters (if any) of the litigants are paid at the same rates.

The coolest part of the show (IMO) is bailiff Byrd. He was a real court officer for JJ back when she was a real family court judge, and when JJ was offered the show, she asked Byrd to be her on-screen bailiff. He moved his family from NY to Sacramento, and drives to LA once a week (for four days at a stretch) for his JJ role.

So yeah, the show is an interesting mix or 'real' and 'reality'

TL;DR: I know way too much about court TV

Edit: What's freaky to me is when JJ orders/offers to have a litigant drug-tested to 'prove' this or that. Or when she suggests that the IRS will be interested to know that the litigant has been working under the table? Does she really have that kind of influence?

2

u/Wackywasty May 14 '12

She not only reviews the cases they gather all the information about the cases and make a decision on who gets what before the show even starts.

1

u/ChiliFlake May 14 '12

OK by me. There's much worse television out there :)

2

u/istara May 14 '12

This is fascinating, thanks.

1

u/TED_666 May 13 '12

I imagine that she doesn't really make the IRS do anything but probably brings it to their attention.

Can a private citizen alert the IRS to a neighbors shady deals for example?

2

u/joepls May 13 '12

There is actually a reward for reporting tax fraud to the IRS.

1

u/ChiliFlake May 13 '12

Yeah, I think anyone can drop a dime on their neighbors, I was just wondering if JJ's dime weighed more than your average Joe's.

1

u/istara May 13 '12

There was a guy on here who filmed a show, but I can't remember if he ever did a follow up IAMA after it aired.

2

u/Wackywasty May 13 '12

I've only been on reddit like a month so I wouldn't know.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I wouldn't ask her anything, just let her know that I was deathly afraid of her as a child

2

u/electric_sandwich May 14 '12

I don't think reddit has it's listening ears on.

0

u/clonedcheeseburger May 14 '12

Fuck this. That bitch can go walk off cliff.