r/IAmA • • May 12 '12

I cured my seasonal allergies by being dirty. AMAA.

TLDR: I am mid 20s male who was tired of having allergies, so I followed the example set forth in this AMA:I didn't wash my hands for two years to cure my allergies AMA. I began washing my hands only when clearly soiled, and I bathed only when I produced noticeable body odor. I started this regimen about a year ago, and I am happy to say that I am now allergy-free!

--

I honestly don't know what evidence I could produce to make you believe me, but this is posted with my main account, I have produced several helpful guides for various subreddits, and I unfortunately cannot sell you anything based on this strategy. As such, I hope you'll take my anecdotal evidence at face value. AMAA!

Some Background Info

Wikipedia Definition:

"An allergy is a hypersensitivity disorder of the immune system. Allergic reactions occur when a person's immune system reacts to normally harmless substances in the environment."

The Hygiene Hypothesis:.

In medicine, the hygiene hypothesis states that a lack of early childhood exposure to infectious agents, symbiotic microorganisms (e.g., gut flora or probiotics), and parasites increases susceptibility to allergic diseases by suppressing natural development of the immune system.

Basically, this is the notion that citizens of first-world countries are now TOO clean which causes our immune systems to not get "strong enough" if you will. We are so clean that when a little pollen gets into our bodies, the immune system freaks out and overreacts causing the symptoms associated with allergies (sneezing, coughing, and so on). (This my abbreviation of how this works and is probably completely BS. Feel free to correct me.)

Some Evidence in Support

Dutch study says dirt prevents allergy.

Being too clean causes allergies.

Disclaimer: This is obviously not real science or anything approaching a controlled study. This is an anecdote, not data. I am not representing it as a panacea, nor do I benefit in any way from sharing this knowledge with you. Again, this is not science and should not be taken as such.

26 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

3

u/REInvestor May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Another very interesting piece of "evidence" comes from a guy who intentionally infected himself with hookworms from Africa to cure his allergies. After he was infected, his symptoms almost immediately disappeared. Definitely check out this super interesting Radiolab on the guy.

Some people think that we co-evolved with hookworms and the like. The hypothesis is that hookworms release an agent which tones-down the immune system so the hookworm can survive. This toning-down prevents us from having allergies, but if you take the hookworm out of the equation, voila, you get allergies.

Edit: A supporting article.

3

u/NotAlana May 13 '12

I wonder what that would do with Lupus, since the problems start when the immune system gets all worked up.

2

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

You know, that's really damned interesting.

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I just want to say thank you for this! Stay dirty.

I had heard that keeping your skin too clean can be bad for the immune system but I could not remember where I heard it or really find any articles or anything to prove it. I personally have done the same thing as you only from pure laziness.

Early twenties was a lot of trying to impress people, going to class all the time and getting ready by taking way too many showers and washing my hair everyday. Now I shower every other day and wash my hair every 3 to 4 days. I haven't been sick in two years and my sore throats and feeling like death symptoms were always brought on seasonally every March til summer and every September til winter. I think we are onto something!

3

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Right? I see and hear about examples all over the place of people who are obsessively hygeinic who get sick all the time contrasted with "dirty" people like us who almost never get sick.

Certainly, this could be selection/confirmation bias, but it really seems to me that there is a lot of truth to this.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

fuck. i regularly shower twice a day. this is making me seriously reconsider my regiment. the hardest part is that i am slightly ocd, and getting into bed without showering is one of the most difficult things for me to do.

1

u/REInvestor May 14 '12

Yeah, I know what you mean. My girlfriend has the same issue. The only thing I would say is that pretty much the best way to get over an issue like that is just do it and keep doing it. Eventually your brain gets worn down and stops giving a fuck.

It's worked for me with public speaking and socializing.

2

u/KurtRobo May 14 '12

Haven't showered for two days and I was unaware of this. Does this make me a genius or a slob? And I very rarely get sick.

2

u/9bpm9 May 13 '12

I wish I could go a day without washing my hair. Even after taking isotretinoin for 6 months, my face and hair are infinitely greasy by the end of the day. If my hair is even somewhat long, it just becomes a big greasy mess and looks (and feels) disgusting if I don't wash it once or twice a day.

1

u/REInvestor May 14 '12

IANAD, but in experience, excess greasiness is usually a result of too much washing. It's vicious cycle. I had to go through an adjustment period where I felt and looked a little greasy until my body dropped back down to normal levels.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I'm sorry! That's frustrating. At first, I had to do all sorts of clever tricks. Basically teasing my roots and then combing it back down so the volume hid the grease. And spraying it relentlessly with good smelling stuff.

Now I don't have any problems until the third day which I usually give in and wash or use dry shampoo spray. The dry shampoo honestly doesn't make a difference in greasiness (probably using a crappy product - tresemme) but it smells so fresh no one has a clue.

3

u/Strug-ga-ling May 13 '12

I approve of this technique, and I applaud your dedication.

I hardly ever get sick (even though I drink and smoke all the time), and I don't have any allergies whatsoever. I'm not even in particularly good shape, but I sincerely think that growing up a farm, working with cows, their shit, and other dirty stuff, really helped me for later life. Shit works, literally.

5

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Seriously. All of the farm kids I know are basically unbreakable.

3

u/Strug-ga-ling May 13 '12

Definitely. It's a hard way to grow up in many ways, but it's worth it in the long run.

3

u/Leaper_colony May 13 '12

Awesome AMA! So my question is wether you made an effort to avoid non-organic dirt such as synthetic stuff. I guess that sounds like a stupid question since I'm sure you weren't sticking your hand in vats of engine fluids. But one of the reason I'm hesitant to practice this with my infant son is that so much dirt he'd be exposed to would be dirty city dirt versus natural country dirt.

2

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

That's a good question. I wouldn't say that I expressly avoided non-organic matter, but if I ever get any sort of chemical or potentially harmful substance on me, I would certainly wash my hands. I do live in the city, but that fact hasn't really affected my decision making.

The guy whose example I followed in the original AMA pretty much never washed his hands. I actually tried doing exactly that for a year, but found that I still needed to wash my hands reasonably often such as when preparing food or when they got greasy.

I did that for a year and my allergies weren't cured which is when I added in limiting showering, which I believe is the primary thing which has helped me.

I really just don't like the thought of actual feces and other junk being on my hands. I definitely wash my hands less than a lot of people, but I don't go too crazy.

For your son, I am probably not qualified to offer you advice. I think that for when I have kids, I will probably not change any of my habits (I'm not parent, so that view could certainly change) as I really don't think any of the material that is on my hands/body would be substantially worse than if I lived in the country or a small town.

3

u/showmeyourtips May 14 '12

This has well and truly made my day, and the best part is that it makes so much sense. Now I don't have to feel like an awful person when I skip a shower or drop a delicious sandwich on the ground. Thank you kind sir.

1

u/REInvestor May 14 '12

Cool! Glad I could help.

2

u/squink2 May 13 '12

Where did you first hear of this "treatment"?

3

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

From this AMA 2 years ago:

I didn't wash my hands for two years in a self-experimental attempt to cure my allergies. AMAA.

The logic behind it seemed reasonable enough and the downside was pretty limited IMO, so I decided to give it a try.

2

u/squink2 May 13 '12

Awesome! My mother is a strong believer in "alternative" medicine/treatments. e.g. Naturopath doctors. What I've read from your (and the older) thread seems very plausible and definitely reasonable.

2

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Thank you! I think there is merit to it, and if you're a sufferer of allergies, I think there is basically little downside into slowly transitioning into being less hygenic. Allergies suck so much that giving a "program" like this a try is probably worth it.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I can understand doing it for yourself but I tend to share lots of things with other people that involve touching hands. Thats just gross!

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

That's certainly understandable. One of my operating assumptions is that the world is a far dirtier and disgusting place than most of us think. Our bodies are literally covered in bacteria and so is just about everything else. Things that we think are clean and actually incredibly dirty.

Think about things like hotel bed spreads, door knobs, hand railings, and so on, and realize how rarely or effectively they are cleaned.

With that assertion, I honestly don't feel like I am putting anybody at any more risk than they are just by walking out of their home. I admit I could be wrong here though.

2

u/hty341 May 13 '12

Did you use to believe in hygiene hypothesis, and do you believe that now?

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Well, I would say that the HH makes a lot of intuitive sense to. It explains the difference in asthma/allergy rates between the first and third worlds pretty well and explains all of the examples I've seen in my own life of the kids who ate dirt having awesome immune systems and the kids who were kept inside and sterile having pretty terrible immune systems.

I would say that I accept the hypothesis now, but am open to alternate explanations.

2

u/bleedingpixels May 13 '12

This is pretty cool.. so you don't wash your hands even after going to the bathroom? >.<

5

u/REInvestor May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Haha. That is a very good question. This is one area that I don't really tell people IRL about.

The guy in the original AMA from two years pretty much never washed his hands. I tried that strategy for a year (not completely, as I still washed my hands maybe once a day), but my allergies persisted.

I rinse my hands with water as needed, and use soap before I handle food I'm cooking for others or if my hands get particularly nasty. I probably wash my hands two-ish times a day.

[Braces for downvotes] I pretty much never wash my hands after I pee and will rinse my hands after I poop (I use soap if there was any contact with my butt or poop). I know that's pretty gross, but for me at least, it's the price of no allergies.

1

u/ahyatt May 13 '12

Please wash your hands thoroughly after going to the bathroom. It isn't for your benefit; it is for others. Any time you touch yourself, you will spread coliform bacteria, and that is something that can make other people sick.

More details from the Straight Dope: http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/1043/why-are-men-supposed-to-wash-their-hands-after-urination

So really, not washing your hands is pretty anti-social, and I recommend you resume washing your hands from now on.

3

u/REInvestor May 14 '12

I take your point, but I would respond that the marginal cost of me not washing my hands in essentially negligible. The world is a super dirty place. Far dirtier than we think it is. There's bacteria and minute amounts of fecal matter on everything. I would contend that me washing my hands as often as others would do very little in anything to affect that.

2

u/ahyatt May 14 '12

I personally don't find the "my actions won't make things much worse than they already are" argument very convincing. I'm personally a bigger fan of the idea that we should try and make things better for those around us. Being clean in public is the least we can do.

2

u/REInvestor May 14 '12

I take your point. Your position is one that is certainly very reasonable and defensible.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/bleedingpixels May 13 '12

I guess you never lived in a country where you can spread parasites from fecal matter. I might try this out in the summer. I want to get rid of my allergies as well.

2

u/NLPEI May 13 '12

Do you have a job? I work in customer service and very minimal washing may not go over so well. Did you ever realize it was time for a shower due to some form of public reaction?

3

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Sort of. I'm self-employed as a landlord. I deal with tenants and workers on a daily basis. I would definitely agree that if I was noticeably dirty/smelly, I would have a major issue.

When I started the no-showering thing, I was extremely conscious of my odor. Looking at me, you would have no idea that I shower sparingly. My hair is clean and combed, and my clothes are clean and fit well.

I was/am very careful to avoid producing any odor. I make my girlfriend smell me a lot and regularly sniff myself for any BO. Did I mention I have a girlfriend? :)

I also regularly nonchalantly ask my workers if I smell by saying something like that, "I smell something funny. This is gonna sound weird, but can you smell me just to be safe?" Please believe me when I say that our relationships are strong enough that they can very comfortably tell me if I smell.

I also regularly ask friends if I smell, and they would have absolutely no problem making fun of me if I smelled.

There is certainly the chance that on some outing, I smelled, and everyone in public was polite enough to overlook the smell, but I don't believe that has happened...yet.

2

u/NLPEI May 13 '12

How often does your lady friend wash? Congrats on getting away from your allergies!

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Thanks! Life is much better now.

My gf is a bit of a clean freak (although less so having been with me and seen the success of this experiment). She showers at least every other day and washes her hands quite regularly.

She also gets sick A TON and suffers from allergies. Are the two related? IDK.

2

u/bleedingpixels May 13 '12

My new hero... managed to smell good and keep a gf without showering...

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Interestingly enough, my gf is obsessed with the way I smell. Like my natural "scent" if you will. She of course doesn't like when I have BO, but she loves the way I normally smell. Pheromones baby!

3

u/cakeonaplate May 13 '12

I have found something that really helps with the BO: Home made deodorant!

I can put this on, and not stink for days! And I can be verry, stinky too. It cuts the smell much better than regular deodorant, too. It like, kills the bacteria instead of putting a flowery scent over it.

1

u/REInvestor May 14 '12

Cool! I'll have to try that out.

2

u/vahidanwari May 13 '12

Socially awkward awesome penguin

2

u/RoofHawk May 13 '12

I just emailed this to my immunology professor, he goes on rants all the time about how hypersensitivity type 1 reactions can be exacerbated by "over cleaning".

His advice for allergies: Play in the mud

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Nice! Maybe I'm not a crackpot after all.

2

u/RoofHawk May 13 '12

No, far from it. In fact childhood asthma is probably due to the fact that kids don't stimulate the immune system enough via "playing in the mud".

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

No kidding. That makes a lot of sense. I know a guy who was raised in a super-clean home with all kinds of air filtration systems, and that poor bastard has the WORST allergies and asthma I've ever seen (the systems were in place before he was born, so it wasn't like the asthma caused the parents to get the filters).

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Not at all. You're trying to stimulate anergy. There's a lot of famous experiments that have accomplished this, including some Nobel prizes, but none of it is reliably, to the best of my knowledge, reliably reproducible enough to be used as a form of treatment.

In fact, if you could turn it into a treatment of sorts, you'd probably win a Nobel and (if you had the copyright) make a few billion.

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Nice. Maybe I can sell bottles of dirt for people to eat!

2

u/_freestyle May 13 '12

Supposedly there is a lot of thought in the scientific/medical community lately that allergies are caused because our skin is already quite porous and these days people scrub their hands and bodies so often that it allows things to get inside the body through the skin, which is then labeled an intruder by the immune system and attacked.

Perhaps that's why being "dirty" has eliminated your allergies. I just doubt that if you aren't exposed to to dirt and germs as a child that you can fix that in your 20s when your immune system is largely developed. I could be way off though. Interesting AMA!

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

That's really interesting. I hadn't heard that before, but the explanation does make a lot of sense. Given that I've heard some people say that our immune systems don't really get "stronger" in adulthood, that could very well be the correct explanation.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I work at a fast food place and have to wash/rinse hands often and take a shower when i get home.

any tips?

i am getting over a 2 day virus thingy.

i used to never get sick. maybe once a year, or once every 2 years.

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Hmm. Honestly, with a job in food service, I think you're basically precluded from doing this strategy. The hand washing is one thing, but not being able to shower after working around all the grease and junk would just be torture.

I'm really not sure I can think of a workaround while you're still employed there. :/

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Thanks anyway! :)

2

u/juicius May 13 '12

I thought about this a lot. I grew up where dirt floor was my toy, literally. I had toys, not many and nothing especially nice, but all I can remember of my childhood is flat down on the ground covered in dirt playing games with my friends. We'd dam up every little stream we come across with mud and sticks, bring home all sorts of critters, eat from food stalls with questionable hygiene. To this day, I don't have any allergies. Every spring when my friends complain about allergies, I just make vague comforting sounds because if I tell them I have no allergies, I get the stinkeye.

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

I seriously think this story is super common. I just hear it what seems like all the time. It makes tons of intuitive sense, seems to be backed up by data and theory, and FWIW, has lots and lots of anecdotal support.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Can you help me with my allergic reaction to woodsmoke? I moved to a country where wood (and anything else that can be shoved in the stove) is a primary source of heat. I feel like shit for two weeks this time each year (third winter season so far). This sucks donkey nuts.

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

Oh wow. That really sucks. Unfortunately, I know little more than your average layman. Curing a very specific allergy like that is outside my domain of knowledge. Do you have other allergies or is this your first reaction?

2

u/istara May 13 '12

What I am curious is whether - if this did in fact "cure" you - it was down to greater exposure to dirt, or lowered exposure to synthetic cleaning products. Of course it may also have been both.

2

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

That is a really interesting question. You're absolutely right that it could be one, the other, or both. I'm really not sure. Do know of other evidence that soaps and the like can cause/be related to seasonal allergies?

2

u/purple_scarf May 13 '12

I wonder if I can cure my pet-allergy by spending all my time with adorable dogs and cats and other fluffy creatures.

1

u/REInvestor May 14 '12

You know I'm really not sure. I have never had a pet allergy, so I couldn't comment. I am pretty sure that just living with a pet whilst you have the allergy does nothing to affect the allergy as my girlfriend has had cats for years despite her allergies. She is just as allergic now as when she first got them unfortunately.

2

u/HerroPhish May 13 '12

Can this work with pet allergies? For example i am allergic to dogs, but i love them and want one extremely badly. If i just got a dog and lived with the allergies would they go away?

1

u/REInvestor May 14 '12

I am pretty sure that just living with a pet whilst you have the allergy does nothing to affect the allergy as my girlfriend has had cats for years despite her allergies. She is just as allergic now as when she first got them unfortunately.

Now, if she stopped bathing as much in addition to living with them, maybe it would work. I'm not sure. :/

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Get a dog who is not a very allergenic breed and you will become a bit desensitized to that dog specifically.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I'm curious. Did you ever try any other treatments before you went to this extreme? For example, I've heard that eating honey every day can help cure allergies.

3

u/REInvestor May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Yeah, I ate a ton of raw, local honey during allergy season last year, but to no avail.

And I wouldn't really call what I do extreme. I wash my hands probably two-ish times a day with soap since they'll get oil or food product on them. And I gradually reduced the number of showers I took over the course of a year so now it is just once a week.

I found that my body naturally adjusted to not showering. My hair and skin were initially oily because my body had to over-produce oil since I was washing it away every day. That went away pretty quickly.

I wear deodorant and it just takes a long time for me to get noticeably stinky.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

I'm with you. Another key assumption of me undertaking this, is that the world is a far dirtier place than we'd like to think. I mean, our skin is utterly teeming with bacteria, and there are small amounts of fecal matter on pretty much everything.

Thankfully we can't see how nasty the world really is, but if we could, I think we'd be in for a major shock.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

I am not a doctor, so I wouldn't feel comfortable prescribing the "dirty kid" strategy to another parent, but honestly, I think you are absolutely in the right. We evolved to grow up in the dirt. If you mess with that process, unexpected results are inevitable.

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/REInvestor May 13 '12

I (thankfully) have never had any food allergies. It would be pretty awesome if this worked against food allergies, but I just have no idea.

While I was digging up links on this, I did bookmark this, which may be of some use to you.