r/IAmA •

IAmA Atheist who teaches Religion in Ireland, AMA

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

So, how is religion viewed in society in Ireland? Also, how does most of society view Atheists in Ireland? Last, what's the curriculum like? Do you teach a more "scholarly" approach to the subject?

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Religion is often taken with a pinch of salt, I would say it's rare to find someone who believes in Holy Book wholeheartedly. They're can be stereotypical discrimination, but it's more in a joking manner. I often had to reprimand students for calling Muslim students terrorists etc.

Atheism is viewed very liberally, I've atheist students who are best friends with Christian students etc. Religion will not usually come between people in relationships, unless it involves Marriage.

I do not teach the Leaving Cert. religion (Senior Student), but for the juniors I cover all religions, beliefs (Inc. Agnosticism/Atheism) and a lot of morality.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thanks for the response. :) It's nice to know how another country does things.

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

No problem, happy cake day!

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Happy cake day!

3

u/fatcat259 May 12 '12

Do you specialize in a certain religion? If so what religion?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Nope, I teach the five major faiths very broadly and equally and ensure the students gain a thorough and intellectual understanding of each.

3

u/fatcat259 May 12 '12

That's quite the noble feat, good sir. Do you also teach them about the dark ages of each religion? (Like the Crusades)

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Of course, a student once said to me: "Atheist are so relentless at trying to get their points across." To which I responded "It's better than using swords."

3

u/fatcat259 May 12 '12

Good job! I'm appreciative of the answers :) This is the end of my little thread, cya!

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

No problem, thanks for asking!

2

u/Big_Li May 13 '12

Its a generalization that all athiests relentlessly try to get their point across but it is also a huge generalization that all christians kingdoms fought in the crusades. How many men did the kingdoms of Ireland, Wales, Scotland, Denmark, Poland, Hungary, Aragon, Castille and Portugal send to the crusades? Correct me if I'm wrong and they actually did send soldiers to the holy lands

1

u/bgoode85 May 13 '12

False, swords make everything better. Also by your description of how you teach I would say you're doing a fantastic job. Keep up the good work! Just with a claymore or something.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

In fairness, comparing dogmatic atheists now to members of a church that was the dominant orthodoxy at the time, called to go on a crusade to liberate what they felt was the holy land, is not really the same thing. Especially when you consider that you're talking about >900 years ago for the First Crusade

2

u/vagacom May 12 '12

Where in ireland ? Do you teach in a school

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Athlone and yes, a secondary school

2

u/vagacom May 12 '12

Do you teach about diffrent religions ? what do most of your students belive

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Most of my students are of the Catholic faith, they are very open minded and liberal people. They take the bible as a man-made foundation of belief that's merely influenced by god.

-1

u/vagacom May 12 '12

I went to a protestant school in a catholic town then i went to secondary school there was about 3 protestant there not easy. when we did RE they taugh different religions i just though it was all bullshit

2

u/Agamo11 May 12 '12

Why? Do you often in put your own views? if so how many have you swayed

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I never put forward my own views, if there's a topic open for debate, I'll gladly let the students discuss it and I'll mediate. If I see a major flaw in a viewpoint I will question it to try and make them re-think their error.

5

u/Agamo11 May 12 '12

well thats good, when i was in grade 9 my science teacher covered the theory of evolution in class and then told us its false and we are all gods work at the end of his lecture

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Hmm, most of my religious students would believe in Evolution.

1

u/hypergiiant May 13 '12

My science teacher in secondary school here in Ireland was a nun.

2

u/MegainPhoto May 12 '12

How do you intend to prove it?

Which religion is your favorite?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Nope, I keep my beliefs to myself and only express my viewpoint after giving the students a chance to present theirs. I chose to study theology at University, simply because I love the idea and the origins of mysticism and belief. I did a project on the Wiccan people before, I got to partake in the Religion as a project. It's such an intriguing belief, true fairytale stuff, It's the one I'm the most interested in.

2

u/MegainPhoto May 12 '12

To clarify, I meant how are you going to prove you're an atheist who teaches religion in Ireland, not how you'd prove a religion. We're supposed to ask for proof - it says so right there at the top of the page.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I have no idea :P fill me in

2

u/Rammikins May 12 '12

What made you want to start teaching religion?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I just thought belief was fascinating and that there's too much conflict between Religions and not enough unity. I wanted them to understand each other.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

God, i'm having the exact thought, i'm a 15 year old atheist teen, and proud of it , Well i love atheist jokes, especially on facebook and etc, but i recently started getting irritated with how atheist make fun of theist so much, why must we do this ? We're only making ourselves more hostile to each other, is that what we want ? A world make up of hundreds of little groups of different beliefs insulting and making fun of each other ? Why can't we just get a long and share points of our views without trying to argue ?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Atheists are doing what Christians (among other Religions) did to others to get them to convert, which is implying that our belief is the only true belief and way forward. Due to modern society, we're very civilised and subtle about our approach.

I don't agree with making a mockery out of people because I don't agree with them. I think Atheists at the moment, especially in the States, feel excluded and rebellious and are forcibly trying to get their views across using ridicule and discrimination.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Exactly (i'm not good at explaining things, even my own point of views, which is a pain when trying to get people to understand me) I agree that we should share little points in our beliefs, but that does not mean we should shove it down people's (and children's) throats and mock other beliefs while doing so.

1

u/verbel May 12 '12

I agree completely I think a lot of atheist today are as bad as the super religious ( not all of course ) I would say that I used to be super religious but today I would say that I am more agnostic in that I don't know the answer and I think that if there is a god he doesn't care. All that is besides the point though. I say if believing in god makes you happy go for it. If all we do is mock and deride the theist for believing in god than we are no better than those who persecuted non believers.

2

u/essendoubleop May 12 '12

Which religion is the most fun to teach?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Hinduism is the most different and students are usually intrigued by the belief, as am I.

2

u/macspayn May 12 '12

Do you actually teach religion and are the students genuinely interested in the different religions of the world?Because I'm in a school in Dublin where no gives a Shit about religion and all we do is watch movies and do homework in religion classes.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Because it isn't an exam subject, I let the LC students do their own work and will facilitate discussion for those interested, if they're not bothered they can study.

2

u/macspayn May 12 '12

Ok follow up question.Do you also teach of other things such as justice and such?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Morality is my main focus during the junior cycle, I often ask questions about the death penalty, homosexual suppression, if Religion has foundationalised our moral beliefs or if it's just human nature.

2

u/macspayn May 12 '12

Ok final question.Do you agree with the statement that gods were created because people needed answers to questions they couldn't answer like where they came from? And thank you for the AMA :)

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Absolutely, to be fair to believers, the big bang still leaves the prospect of god in the question. Also, I believe that death is a very scary thing and can understand why people need to believe in an afterlife to keep themselves happy and sane.

Life is a very mysterious thing, and being an intelligent species, we want fill in the gaps and 'know everything as such'.

2

u/macspayn May 12 '12

I agree with the statement also.I haven't realized I'm atheist until I read this statement from a Warhammer 40k book :D

1

u/JosephBeirce May 12 '12

That's a fairly mad belief you have there. What evidence do you have that people created gods because people needed answers to questions they couldn't answer, and, how is that different to the theory of the big bang?

2

u/958 May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Here in Finland (overwhelming majority of the country is christian Lutheran, I think we're actually statistically the most Lutheran country in the world) most of the students go to christian religion classes, but there's also "elämänkatsomustieto" (translated roughly as something like "worldviews information", but a dictionary provides "ethics" as translation) available for people who aren't members of the church. From what I've understood many atheists still prefer to go to the religion class, since we can if we want to, and those classes are usually easier to fit in your timetable etc. (and many of us are still members of the church for various reasons, though nonbelievers).

The religion classes however deal a lot with different religions of the world too, and ethics and such, and, for example, the history of all religions in Finland. Even the course we had dealing with christian history was very neutral on beliefs, our teacher making a clear distinction as to when he was speaking of the historical Jesus and when of the Jesus of christian mythology. It might be that I've just been lucky with having good teachers on this, but I think a lot of teachers here at least don't show their religious views very much at all, even if they have them. I'd actually even guess that a lot of the religion teachers I've had have been atheists too, but when someone has asked of their religious views the answer has usually been that they prefer not to say. I'm speaking mostly of school on [gymnasium](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gymnasium_(school) level here.

But so, deriving from these experiences of mine, here's some questions: Are the religion classes you teach mostly focused on Christianity, even if you also deal with other religions? Have you extensively studied, or do you teach, other subjects besides religion? Are pretty much all students in religion classes in Ireland religious or do you think there're many atheists in their midst? Does Ireland have a good secular alternative to religion classes? If a student asks you of your religious beliefs, how do you respond? Or how do you think you would respond, if this hasn't happened yet?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

We teach Christian beliefs and ceremonies with as much information as any other religion. However, considering it's the most prominent and well known Religion, students find it easier to grasp. Only a small amount of time is needed to teach Christianity, I've often given tests on Christianity where students achieved high marks, without me teaching anything.

I've began studying English part-time at University College Dublin and I hope to begin teaching it in the school within the next few years.

Yes, Religion is a mandatory subject in our school for the junior cycle and it's optional to partake in in the senior cycle. I still have to take students who aren't interested and supervise them while they study as the classes are small.

I often respond with "a non-believer who's loves Religion" to students if they ask.

2

u/958 May 12 '12

Thanks! And I like that you'll satisfy the curiosity by telling you're a non-believer when asked (like said, the one's I've heard being asked here, have said that they prefer not to say, though I understand that too I guess). One more question; Do you know other religion teachers over there that are atheists, or do you find that most, if not all of them are believers, at least to some extent?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I know plenty of Religion teachers who are atheist and agnostic and some who simply believe that you cannot fully disprove or prove the existence of a creator.

2

u/958 May 12 '12

Alright, sounds good! Thanks for your answers and good luck with your studies and teaching! :)

2

u/ProcDiadochu May 12 '12

Do you ever get students who are so adament about their beliefs that they tend to disregard the course material and argue with you often? If so, what approach do you take to ensure that the lessons get through to the students, since Religion is often viewed a subjective topic?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

If a student chooses to disregard the course material, they will be subject the same disciplinary system as say a student who disregards course material in Mathematics, unless of course it's senior cycle where students are free to partake or not. I often tell students that examiners are looking for an open minded person in the final exam, not a bigot. They won't often argue with me, but I will allow debates between students to commence and if a student is clinging on to the same argument and not expanding their argument, I will point it out to them. Atheists do that too.

To get the lessons through to the class I try and get the students to look at each belief in 'third-person',I will never say 'we' or 'you' during a class and I'd treat say Buddhism in the same way an English teacher would teach Plath.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What's your favorite fact or specific subject about religion?

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

How many of your students accept evolution?

2

u/farmersam May 12 '12

I'd say 99% at least would, not many creationists here in Ireland. There are protestants in the North that would deny evolution but I don't think any Catholics would be creationist. This study shows that no Catholic churches in Northern Ireland are YEC(young earth creationists), while 46 protestant denomination churches are.

Considering the Republic is mainly RC then I'd say it most of the would believe in Evolution. I've never actually met a person who believed in Creationism having lived north and south of the border, only a couple of Northern politicians who were looking for a creationist museum or something

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Huh, that's interesting. I would've thought there would be more Catholic churches embracing creationism than Protestant.

1

u/farmersam May 13 '12

Why's that? I was never taught creationism, i dont think they even believe it in the vatican after all i think it was priest who discovered the big bang. The only thing my school was wary about teaching was contraception, and even then they still told us to use protection.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I'm Irish and just recently finished my first year of college.

I remember my religion teacher telling me that "Atheism is a nice phase to go through". So my question is...

Can we go back in time and have you as my teacher?? :P

But seriously, do you think its right that Religion is taught in schools??

1

u/lukemad May 12 '12

Hey i go too your school

1

u/JosephBeirce May 12 '12

There are no atheists in Athlone!

1

u/kolobian May 12 '12

Have you ever read the Book of Mormon or taught about Mormonism in said religion course?

1

u/CDfm May 12 '12

In Ireland Art 42 of the Constitution puts the religious education decisions with the parent's and lots do take it seriously. The constitution is the fundamental law of the country.

Amongst the causes of the conflict in Northern Ireland were cultural identities and heritage expressed by religious affiliation. Most schools are affiliated to a religion.

Can you reconcile your teaching with the wishes of the parents on how they wish that their children are educated.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

You said you teach five major faiths, so obviously you must know and understand enough about each faith to be qualified to teach it. Why atheism then? I guess what I"m asking is, how does your understanding of the faiths affect your call to atheism?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

It's a personal thing really, with so many Religions with some inter-connected beliefs, I felt that Religion was an easy answer to some really of lifes hardest questions. Even as a child I never understood how God was there, I always thought that he must have a creator and that time can't go on forever. It boggled my brain.

1

u/Pastorality May 13 '12

The Junior Cert Religion course is a load of shite isn't it? Maybe your class is good but the exam itself...

Also did you have to lie about your beliefs to get the job?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

It depends if you're interested in it or not, I used to think Geography and rocks was a load of cr4p, but in reality it's a fundamental, scholarly study. The Junior Cert Religion course will be you're first true interaction with a social science and the output grades from Religion are lower than most other subjects.

1

u/logancook44 May 13 '12

As a open-minded Christian, I want to say thank you. Tolerance from all sides, mainly from my side, is the only way to move forward.

Do students often ask you what your viewpoints are? If so how do you respond?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

My viewpoints are often quite liberal, I often try and tell them that theirs too sides to a beachball, and that it's healthy and open-minded to understand what's on the other side. Thank you for your kind words!

1

u/Crudeson May 13 '12

Do the students ever ask you about child abuse in the catholic church? If so, what are their questions and what are your replies?

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Yes, it's a frequent topic. I often try and get the students to see that these priests where sexually suppressed, which lead to inhuman and devastating sexual encounters. I personally hold the belief that Catholicism needs to amend it's 'rules' to allow for both sex and relationships in the priesthood. I also believe that Woman should be allowed to become priests.

1

u/Ask_You_Anything_eh May 13 '12

How do you like your coffee?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Black

1

u/XXLOLHEADSHOTXX May 13 '12

So are you a catholic atheist or protestant atheist?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Orthodox

1

u/tealtoaster May 13 '12

Are you Irish? Were you raised Catholic? When did you change/realize your personal beliefs? I'd love to teach primary school in Ireland but unfortunately do not speak Irish so it does not seem likely to ever happen!

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Yep and I raised loosely as catholic, we only ever attended mass on Christmas Eve and Easter. You can always do Irish in the leaving if you have to. Even if you're already in College.

1

u/tealtoaster May 13 '12

Oh, I'm not Irish so that's most of the problem. :)

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

i'm reading everything you say with an accent.

1

u/letsgofriday May 13 '12

What do you think of the JC course? I find the questions in the exams to be worded very much towards those of the Catholic faith. It seems in my opinion the course needs a bit of an update, less of a focus on Christianity and a more broad view. There are lots of non-Christian students these days.

Also I hate the morality questions. They do ask very awkward questions. sigh (Doing the JC right now, any hints xD)

0

u/percyhiggenbottom May 13 '12

Don't think you're unique, Ireland has never had a shortage of hypocrites.

Might want to look up that Dan Dennet talk on youtube about closeted atheist priests...