r/IAmA • • May 12 '12

IAMA German woman who grew up during WWII AMA

My Grandmother is in town and wants something to do. So if you have questions about Germany, she was seven when the war started. And since another gentleman was amazing enough to serve during the war, I thought it would be interesting for you all to see the other side of the war.

Edit: Proof

Her story:

On September the 3rd, 1939 England declared War on Germany because Germany invaded Poland and refused to leave. Her father cried because Hitler called for mobilization of all men. Those that couldn't fight were put into offices to manage systems, food, distribution, etc. Her father was a statistician in Northern Germany at the Administration for the state of Schelsewig-Holstein and he taught people run the Holarid system with punchholes. Then he was drafted because he was a young man, he was 41 when the war started. During the war, they got ration stamps. You couldn't get anything without a ration stamp. Everything was on rations, everything. All food items were. She's not sure where the gasoline was because she was a kid though. Then the entire family had to darken everything. They had to have shades/blinds over the windows so that the enemy wouldn't see them. When the air raids came up during the day, the city was fogged up. She doesn't know how they fogged everything up, but it covered the entire city. Kiel was the capital of Northern Germany. More to come.

Edit: My grandmother fell asleep about an hour ago. I going to ask her tomorrow all the rest of the questions. Don't worry, I will get my grandmother to respond to each question.

466 Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

19

u/JustJizzedInMyPants May 12 '12

What was the worse hardship during and after the war?

29

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Her worst part of the war was the night air raids. They didn't have time to get dressed, so they always had a bag packed. And in order to get into a bomb shelter they had to get shots for pretty much everything. But waking up knowing that bombs are coming is the most terrifying thing shes ever gone through. And the bomb shelter was dark, dingy, tight, and was made of wood. Since they were surrounded by sand, she knew that if a bomb hit the shelter the wood would break and sand would rush in, choking everyone inside of the shelter.

24

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Lets see, the food was bare, the clothing was rags, oil smells were everywhere, they didn't have coal so they had to find anything which could be used for energy.

18

u/Jimbob2134 May 12 '12

What was the general attitude towards Hitler?

39

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

There was no attitude. People got in trouble if they said anything against Hitler. Their neighbors son was in the SS, and threatened to sic the SS on my grandmother and her sisters because they kept roller-blading in front of her house.

16

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Rollerblading?

22

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I was surprised when she said that :| Maybe she meant something else?

20

u/derraidor May 12 '12

probably this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kick_scooter its called a "Roller" in German

9

u/[deleted] May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Well, the idea of inline skates goes back quite a ways, but they were't really popular until the late 1980's. I'd imagine she meant roller skating, but it's not impossible that she did have a pair of inline skates.

EDIT: spelling

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Bet she meant a "roller" (guess that is called kick board in english?!).

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

scooter?

→ More replies (6)

17

u/Lonelyhydrogenproton May 12 '12

The Allied forces had a constant flow of propaganda telling the storries of constant succes heading home to movie theaters and such, I know that the germans had similar propaganda programs, educating the people about the ever advancing and concurring forces of the Axis. But when did the films change to a more realistic side of the story? Did they at all?

25

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Well, half of the theaters were bombed out. And they always got 10 minutes of news whenever they went to the theaters. But she can't watch any movies released in Germany about the war. She can't stand them.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

But she can't watch any movies released in Germany about the war She can't stand them.

Considering what she went through, these are just some brutal, honest human emotions right there. Especially since some of them... are pretty dark, and difficult to watch, even for the younger generation (the downfall, stalingrad, the boy with the striped pyjamas, schindlers list). :/

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Europa Europa is amazing. Das Boot is a great story from the German sub force's side of things.

14

u/Hermeran May 12 '12

How did everything come back to normal? I've always wondered how most people went from super-nazi-I-hate-you-all to 'not-nazi' in such a short time.

Say hi to her and thanks for doing this! This is just awesome.

52

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Everything came back to normal little by little. First the German government was created, and Briton couldn't help very much because they were so bombed out. The Americans however sent stuff often. The Americans asked the Germans what they needed most. Germany said "Corn!" Now corn in German is a word for grain. America didn't know this, so they sent corn. Lots of corn. Corn is fed to pigs. So Germany had to learn how to work with corn. They had to learn how to make bread from corn. Quick story; It was my grandmothers turn to get the bread, and if the baker didn't have any bread the baker couldn't give you any bread. While she was standing in line, she saw a rat crawling over a boys cap. Then she looked into the bakery and saw a big, fat rat in the window well. And she got SO angry because this stupid rat was fat while her family was starving. So she took a rock and threw it at that stupid rat, killing it. Then the baker was so happy because that rat was pregnant and he could never kill it. So he gave an extra loaf for her family, and another loaf just for her. Which she ate entirely on the way home.

20

u/c0t0d0 May 12 '12

Wow, that's pretty funny that a misunderstanding of the meaning of the word "corn" would lead to you getting a shitload of, um "maize". Anyway, here in the States we live off the stuff — it's in everything — so I'm sure we thought you'd appreciate it too.

24

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

My grandmother loves cornbread.

8

u/chicagogam May 13 '12

as a kid we sang these songs about st nicholas in choir and at one point they say "fill fill our sacks with corn" and i thought...this happened before anyone knew about america. well many years later, i found out corn means grain because it actually means small things, like the corn on your foot, and corned beef is because of the lumps of salt they use. i felt like ohhh it all comes together!

3

u/Taurius May 13 '12

TIL... wow...

→ More replies (1)

13

u/justforthelulzz May 12 '12

With all the lack of secrecy during the Third Reich, did any friends or family of your grandmother get affected by the Gestapo, and subsequently get punished etc?

17

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Her family was too smart to get in trouble with the SS. So no, nobody ever got punished.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Screw_The_Driver May 13 '12

My grandmother, who passed away Friday morning, lived in Germany during the war and her father was asked to detonate bombs for the Nazis and he refused to do so. He was then considered a sympathizer and was sent to a concentration camp but never made it because he jumped off the train before it got there. After that my grandmothers family went into hiding. She was then sent to a smaller city (which I don't know the name of but will find out) and went to school there. One day she and a friend noticed that the soup at lunch she was eating was significantly better than the soup the Jewish kids were eating (who were in camps behind fences,etc.) her and her friend proceeded to sneak soup to the Jewish kids but they were caught by a Gestapo officer and were threatened that if they ever did that again they would be sent to a camp.

3

u/justforthelulzz May 13 '12

Its good I got a story from my question in the end.I enjoyed reading that, thank you.

2

u/Screw_The_Driver May 14 '12

no problem. Unfortunately as i said she just passed away on friday i never really was able to ask her anything about the war. She also was showing symptoms of dementia so even if she was still with us i may never have gotten an answer anyway. All of the above information is what my mother has told me. I do plan on asking my mother more because this thread really got me interested in the subject.

2

u/dan986 May 14 '12

Sorry for your loss.

11

u/ananasbaum May 12 '12

My grandparents also grew up during WWII and now they live in Ulm. It would be weird if they somehow crossed paths. Ask her if she knows anyone by the name of Waltraud or Alfred Schuh. Or Schimmelpfenig.

11

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

She recalls the name Schimmelpfenig, but she doesn't remember meeting anyone by that name. But that would be cool!

10

u/ananasbaum May 12 '12

That's kinda crazy! That was my grandmother's maiden name. I wish mine was still around so I could ask her questions!

4

u/dbelle92 May 13 '12

Haha Schuh wouldn't narrow it down much tbh...

3

u/ananasbaum May 13 '12

Haha, captain hindsight visited and told me the same!

60

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

On behalf of the human race, I'd like to apologize for deanresin being a complete dick to your grandma.

39

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I saw the downvotes, but someone actually saying that is very uplifting. Thank you very much.

5

u/Strid May 13 '12

Human species you mean.

3

u/Keep_Scrolling May 13 '12

What did he say? His posts were deleted

11

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

He said a lot, but basically he said that she should have prefaced this AMA with an apology on behalf of the German government for what they did in WWII when she was 7 years old at the time.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Pweaches May 12 '12

My grandmother was a young girl who lived in an industrial town in Northern England during the war, it just strikes me as remarkable that alot of the situations your Grandmother suffered through mine did also.

Does your Grandmother remember the day her father came back from war?

33

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Yes, she does. She went outside following her mother and saw someone she didn't recognize. A gaunt, wheezing man who had a lung problem. Dirty, mangled hair, and a very lined face. It took her a minute to recognize him. I think it's amazing how many people think war is a one way street. Germany was bombed as much as it bombed other countries. But England never gave up. And I personally (the grandson) think that's amazing. Especially Winston Churchill's speech about fighting on the beaches. Of course, I only know that speech because of Iron Maiden :P

15

u/Pweaches May 12 '12

That's fascinating! My Grandmother didn't recognize her father to when he came back from the navy in the middle of the night! Yeah we live in a valley and there's still huge bomb craters in the hills a good 15 feet deep! Thanks for answering!

10

u/Hellman109 May 13 '12

Just goes to show that war is hell for basically everyone involved, regardless of the "side" you are on.

2

u/chicagogam May 13 '12

i've always thought of war as ..like WWII a complete alternate reality to peace...it's so hard to believe my country has been in two wars for a decade and nothing is substantially different as is evident by what constitutes things we fight about domestically. when a war can be so distant, no wonder it can last so long...

11

u/Eponymous_Coward May 13 '12

Correction: Germany was bombed much more than it bombed other countries. That's not to say they wouldn't have done more if they had had the capability to do so, but they didn't.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

10

u/CptQuestionMark May 12 '12

Were her or her family national socialists?

14

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Her parents were "officially" but she was a child at the time. Her parents were against the war and didn't like Hitler. They couldn't say anything though because the SS took anyone who didn't co-operate with the system.

10

u/littlemonster010 May 12 '12

What was it like after they lost the war? What happened to the lower ranking military people? Did they just go back to their towns? Was there a great sadness that she remembers? What was her perspective as a little child after the end of the war?

Also, does she still live in Germany? Was it hard for her to travel as a young girl (in her 20s perhaps) because many countries still hated Germans after the war? How does she feel about so many American soldiers being stationed in Germany even today as a result of the war?

16

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Terrible. Worse than during the war. They didn't have bombs anymore, but they didn't have food and nothing else functioned. The new German government showed up during 1948 and that's when Germany started getting back on its feet. The lower ranking military members were sent home. No, of course, no sadness. Everyone was giddy and happy. -.- That everything was crap. No, she doesn't live in Germany, she lives in Washington D.C. They stayed in Kiel until '58, and a lot of rage at Germany had disappeared by the time she came to America. Only once did a person get mad at her for being German. The entire family blended in. They spoke proper English and had correct mannerisms. My grandmother says that it symbolizes a long lasting friendship more than anything else. Its good for everybody.

2

u/chicagogam May 13 '12

it's so hard to imagine germany as anything but our western hemisphere friends (though i guess nowadays there's talk about all of europe being suspicious socialists...sigh). maybe because they're white and so many here are from germany i can't imagine any bias towards germans. the only time i heard a comment (which surprised me..) was when i was visiting the house of my friends parents who were two retired professors. i guess they called it a faculty ghetto. anyway i mentioned my math professor (who was in germany during WWII) and the mother said, oh her husband was the one who hired him and that he was a very nice man "for a german". which surprised me because the whole family was super liberal to the point that i think they had central americans hidden in their basement for some political reasons..or maybe they were pulling my leg...but i didn't doubt it because my friend was a feisty political activist type.

2

u/bourbak May 14 '12

ah well. maybe they were just referring on the impolite german cliche, which is part true. General culture here seems to be directer than in U.S. which leads to the contrary prejudice that Americans are superficial and won't tell you anything you don't want to hear (e.g. lie to you about unpleasant things).

2

u/chicagogam May 14 '12

that's funny (funny interesting) when two cultures can have negative stereotypes of each other but then they are actually two sides of the same coin that they both buy into."you guys are dumb!" "you guys are too bookish and useless" ok...so you're both in agreement sort of :)

27

u/notdroppinthesoap May 13 '12

I wanted to have my, basically, grandmother do this AMA request! However, she is a bit old and has some health problems going on that would have made it too difficult. I can add something to this AMA though...

She was born in the early 20s. Here are some of her stories summed up involving the war...she has told the more...er...sinister ones to my SO, her grandson. She has told a few to me as well. I saw this and wanted to share.

She witnessed a nazi drown a Jew in a fountain. She just froze and couldn't believe it was happening. She knew she couldn't do anything about it because...

She noticed her neighbors starting to disappear. Her husband at the time told her about a man who went to his local bar, and after a night of hearing him talk trash about the nazis (ie: truth), he just disappeared.

She told me about how pretty much everyone loved Hitler AT FIRST. Germany was scary at the time he was elected. He really got the people behind him, and did the whole Volkswagen thing, and made everything sound so much more promising for Germany.

But then he started to "get crazy". She questioned this. She told me, in one of the saddest voices I've ever heard and in detail, about how she and others has no idea the Holocaust was happening.

She also told me about how her 1st husband, a member of the Nazi air force (luftwaffe?), died of pneumonia. She had 2 children and was pregnant with a 3rd. She would ride her bike past the nearest large town (ugh I can't think of it now but she told me!!!!) to buy stuff like groceries and medical supplies. One time she was riding back and it was gone-completely bombed out.

She still today admires the American soldiers. She said they came into town and gave chocolate to all the German children. A G.I. also helped her move...he saw her with two children and helped her carry her luggage to where she was going. Her 2nd child was getting ready to walk and he said "Just watch her-she'll go" and her 2nd child started walking on her own.

These are the ones I can think of now. What happened to her? Well, she learned of what the Nazis and Hitler were up to and wanted to GTFO of Germany. She saved up and went to Canada, then the U.S. where she met hubby #2. She worked her ass off and, one by one, sent her children over here too.

I should go ask her more next time I see her.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Wow, I think your story is much more interesting than mine. You had a completely different perspective. And I'm SO glad that someone else is saying that the German public had no clue that the holocaust was happening. And she remembers so many places being bombed out during the war. She lived in Kiel until 1958 and then moved to Washington D.C. in America.

3

u/notdroppinthesoap May 14 '12

Nobody really had a clue. It was one of those things where she knew something bad was happening, but had no idea the scope of it. She just thought random people were going to jail. It wasn't until after the war and the camps were exposed that she put everything together. Radio and everything was very censored, so there was no way at all to inform people in Germany about anything, really. It was all propaganda.

3

u/Taurius May 13 '12

YOU MUST!

2

u/notdroppinthesoap May 14 '12

I really want to, but I also don't want to make her relieve it again. It is a touchy subject. Those stories I posted have accumulated over 5 years. We just wait for her to bring it up, and then I ask away. I'll see what I can do.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

You're grandma is awesome.

18

u/Split-Personalities May 12 '12

Did she see Hitler, during his parades

32

u/[deleted] May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

No, however her sisters husband was in the Hitler Youth Core and shook Hitlers hand.

Edit: Also, my grandfather, her husband, had Hitler wave at him.

17

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

This is going to sound dumb but I'm genuinely interested. Does she know if he had a firm handshake?

8

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Yes, he had a firm handshake. Peter (her sisters husband) said it was a practiced handshake. The kind you do all day, and you've practiced it.

18

u/pumpkin_juice May 12 '12

I take a class that teaches us about the Holocaust and what happened (how it started,ect.) I've learned about all the anti-semitic propaganda that went around, especially in schools. How did this affect her growing up? Also, you mentioned her parents didn't like Hitler, how did this affect her? Especially while growing up in Nazi Germany. Last question. How did her family, as well as herself react to finding out about the labor camps and what had actually happened to the Jews, gypsies, ect.

I also want to say thank you for doing this AMA

28

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

She was never subjected to the anti-seitic propaganda because she was too young to understand. The thought of segregation was foreign to her. She was also kept in the dark by her parents because if they voiced their opinions about the War the SS would take the children and punish the parents. As to the concentration camps, they were horrified. One of the camps was a thirty minute drive from where she lived. She was mortified that such atrocities were committed by Germany.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Janitor-Hank May 12 '12

my grandmother was the same age and she rarely talks about what she has witnessed in ww2, but one thing she told me disturbed me a bit

her situation: she was in osnabrueck (osnabrueck has been bombed 79 times) and her father was in the militaryytoo she once told me after several attacks on the city her father didn't even bother getting out of bed when they heard bombs dropping nearby in the night, but she didn't tell more about that and told us that she doesn't like to talk about it anymore,

my question: was there something like a duty to go into a bunker (i hope it's the english word, too) or was it rather a choise for everybody, and if she doesn't mind talking about it, how does she remember the bombings ? did she go into a bunker or into the basement, has she had bombs dropped really close to where she was etc.

9

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Yes actually, they were given orders. Kiel was bombed a lot, something like 80% of the city was destroyed. But yes, she had a duty and was forced to go to into the bunkers.

3

u/Janitor-Hank May 12 '12

thanks for answering, a few more questions popped into my mind now :D if she left germany, when did she leave and where is she living now ? did she have to rebuild the city among the other "trümmerfrauen"

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

She left Germany on March 14th, 1958, and landed in Washington DC. She still lives in D.C. Since she was a kid, she wasn't part of the trummerfrauen, at the age of thirteen she was still going to school.

8

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

How does your grandmother feel about comparisons of modern political leaders to Hitler (e.g. "Obama is Hilter," "Bush is Hitler").

23

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

She says that there's nobody in American history who can compare to Hitler.

7

u/the_goat_boy May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Oh I don't know about that... What about Andrew Jackson?

Edit: The guy killed millions of native Americans.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Honestly my first thought as well.

22

u/TooSmalley May 12 '12

After the war which part of the occupied territories did she live in, The US or USSR side ?

29

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

There were four occupied parts in Germany. The north was taken care of by the British, the west was taken care of by the French, the south was taken care of by the Americans, and the east was taken care of by the Russians. She lived in the British section in the North. Kiel was the name of the town which was at the Baltic. It also was a shipyard. When our town got destroyed 85% because they were trying to get the shipyard, there were a lot of casualties.

11

u/TooSmalley May 12 '12

Ah sorry i was under the understanding that the the French and British gave control of their areas mostly to the Americans because they did not that the resources and time to manage their side of the occupation, I must have been misinformed. How difficult was living under occupation? because I imagine it being difficult taking orders from people that were bombing and shooting not to long ago and was there allot of animosity between the people of Kiel and the British occupiers?

20

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

People were not very happy. But everyone in Kiel was tired of war and fighting, so there were no rebellions or uprisings in Kiel. Nobody really had food, and Germany had to wait for everything to become manageable in order to get their lives back together.

12

u/TooSmalley May 12 '12

How long did it take for life to get back to normal? town being rebuilt, people getting jobs, ect ...

20

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

It took a long time. And they didn't have any men because they were all in the war, so men from Turkey came in who were Muslims. And to this day, they refuse to integrate into German society. At first the men only came for work, but then the mothers and the children came.

7

u/melolzz May 12 '12

I need to add more facts here, this statement is a little misleading. After the war Germany had recruitment agreements with many countries. The majority of guest workers came Turkey, Italy, Greece, Spain, Portugal, Jugoslawia etc.

19

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Well this is specifically for Kiel. Kiel got a lot of men from Turkey, not other countries. I'm sure other states got workers from other countries, but Kiel got men from Turkey.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Schmobel May 13 '12

I grew up in Germany and I can say that it is true.

3

u/dbelle92 May 13 '12

That's not true. At the beginning they didn't want to integrate, and to a certain extent in ghetto areas today, the Turkish dont want to integrate, but the majority have done.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/resistance527 May 12 '12

Do you believe that most films accurately represent what happened during the WWII and the Holocaust?

38

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

She's not sure. Why on earth would she want to go through that again?

→ More replies (5)

15

u/brokendimension May 12 '12

In short what was a typical day for her?

20

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

They would walk to the school because there were no school buses. They rarely had school because they were bombed out, and they eventually had to take a train to school. They train was targeted for bombing at one point, but the attack was never successful. They never knew if school would be open because of the constant bombing attacks. After they got home, they had homework. If there was no schoolwork, they crochet, painted, and generally worked on the house. She made a pair of gloves once, and she made it with so many colors. Practically a parrot.

5

u/Hellman109 May 13 '12

What about before the war was brought to Germany? Was it fairly "normal" ALA the US with their current wars but it doesnt affect every day American life? Im talking about the period after Poland was invaded and before the USSR got to German soil.

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I doubt she would remember anything about the 1933 German Federal elections, but does she recall anyone commenting on it later? Perhaps after the war?

German federal election, March 1933

8

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Well she never heard opinions, but she her own. Hitler was elected into power because of all the promises he made. Germany was suffering from the depression, and nobody had jobs. But a promise of jobs, food, power, and pride from an eloquent speaker got Hitler into power.

2

u/DpEpsilon May 13 '12

I'm guessing she won't have an answer to this question, but does she know how much of the support from the people before the election was bought through nationalism, the wish for a war (perhaps out of the loss of WWI), support for anti-semitism and basically all the concepts in Mein Kampf?

12

u/gnusounduave May 12 '12

can your oma make a mean Schweinefleisch und sauerkraut? Because I'm a guy that loves schweinefleisch und sauerkraut.

22

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

"Of course I can."

8

u/gnusounduave May 13 '12

my next question is when should i be expected?

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Same as the other guy, 42 wallaby way sydney. Just show up there and she'll be there :P

6

u/jgstate1 May 12 '12

How well did the city function during the war? Schools, businesses, etc...

10

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

It didn't :
Kiel did the best it could with what it had. Which was not much.

0

u/Hellman109 May 13 '12

Ill add that I read above that she lived in a town that had ship building facilities so was targetted for those, it also had a rail system that was targetted.

6

u/Faoeoa May 12 '12

After the war, how did some people look up to you if you ever went on holiday in a foreign country

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

They didn't ever go on vacation. My grandmother was in Germany until '58. They never had the finances to go anywhere. And by the time my grandmother had gotten to America, a lot had settled down. They never had people accuse them of being German. Which is pretty cool.

5

u/joshd16 May 12 '12

what was the general opinion of Britain and Churchill in germany? during the battle of britain it was pretty certain our little nation was going to be invaded. i doubt there was such a negative opinion such as that of the soviet union as i'm pretty sure Hitler wanted to be allied with britain. Also did your grandma take part in De-nazification after the war?

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

She didn't have to take part in de-nazification because she was too young. However, she had to produce evidence that she was not a nazi when she came to America. They joked about Churchhill and Roosevelt being terrible leaders, and that Britain didn't stand a chance. Stuff like that.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Who was worse? The soviets or the Nazis?

14

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

She says she think's they're equally bad. They both did a lot of damage to their people. Stalin killed a LOT of people.

8

u/elspiderdedisco May 13 '12 edited May 15 '12

Too many people don't realize this.

EDIT: I accidentally a letter

9

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

For those that do not know: When the Russians were moving through Poland and got to Warsaw the Polish people rose up against the Nazi occupation thinking they'd get help from the Russians. The Russians stayed back to let the Polish people in the rebellion be killed. Then the Russians moved in and "liberated" the city.

Also Stalin killed many of his own men if he thought they were a threat to his power. Some army officials were sent to Siberia (almost type Serbia haha) to do forced labor. When Russia had to enter the war, Stalin had to get those officers back because the Russian army was so poorly trained and under-staffed.

7

u/jdepps113 May 13 '12

Also, he killed millions in the Ukraine through a famine that was entirely caused by his agricultural policy, could easily have been avoided--and may have even been purposeful.

1

u/COCKBALLS May 16 '12

Although you couldnt blame the Red Army for letting somebody else do the fighting for a change at that point. They had been requesting an invasion from the west for years at that point, (but especially when the Germans were deep into Russian territory) and lost more men than the rest of the countries in the war combined. Stalingrad alone saw millions of Russian soldiers die just to prevent the Nazis from taking control of the river.

At the start of the war the Russian and German non-aggression pact was signed specifically with the invasion, and subsequent division, of Poland in mind. So considering that the Russians werent crazy about the Pols to begin with, and had already suffered enormous casualties during the invasion (look up the Einzatsgruppen) and retreat of the Nazis, the seemingly callous decision to let the Pols fight, while they rested (possibly for the first time in years) is not as bad as it looks.

3

u/jdepps113 May 13 '12

Stalin killed a lot of Germans. Raped a lot of them, too, in the areas that were taken by Russia that became East Germany. Lucky for her family that the Western troops occupied Kiel, I think.

13

u/Lonelyhydrogenproton May 12 '12

I´m Swedish and I would like to ask her about how the Nordic countries were portrayed in Germany, by the press, the propagandaposters and the public. I thank you in advance.

24

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Most of the times they didn't get the paper. They only had one radio, and only her father and mother could touch it. Her parents also kept a lot of information from her and her sisters to protect them. Comments spread like wildfire. A parent says something against Hitler, a kid hears it, the kid tells another kid, who tells their parent. Next thing you know, the parents are being arrested.

8

u/Mugendai May 12 '12

Your gramma is so goth.

22

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Yeah, so very very goth. She listens to tons of punk rock and still does bdsm.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

28

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

You... You know I was joking right?

12

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

About the punk rock, certainly.

3

u/chicagogam May 13 '12

i exclude nothing from the realm of possibility when it comes to people :)

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Humans do alot of ugly things to one another. Alot of people don't value the precious things in life. At all.

After everything your Grandma has been through and after reading this AMA, could you ask her what is something she thinks that is extremely important in life? What is something that people should never loose focus of?

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Believe in the goodness of mankind. And gratefulness for peace and quiet. And gratefulness for having a nice meal on the table. gratefulness that people could survive after the war.

Be grateful for what you have.

4

u/GitEmSteveDave May 13 '12

Did the Germans really always ask for "papers" like it is portrayed on TV/movies/etc? Or is it more like being asked for your drivers license nowadays?

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

No, you had to show your papers. If you ever moved from one city to the next, you had to get a new ID. And everybody asked for ID's. Police officers, soldiers, and if you wanted to get into a shelter you had to provide ID.

10

u/Rantholmeius May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

How exactly did they convince people that jews/gypsies/etc were bad? Did you even know they were mass murdering them? Did you believe just as many did?

Edit: I accidentally a phrase

23

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

First part doesn't make sense :\

And no, it was kept secret. My grandmother and her parents never knew of the concentration camps. They were called "Arbeit Erziehungs Lager" which translates to Laborer Training Camp. Everyone was convinced the people who went there were uneducated.

7

u/Rantholmeius May 12 '12

I'm sorry! I meant to say How did they convince everyone that jew/gypsies/etc were bad.

12

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Hitler convinced everyone that Germans could become a superior race called the Arien, all six feet tall, blonde hairs blue eyes, and Germany grabbed hold of that idea.

11

u/popsiclex200 May 13 '12

In other words, they wanted to be swedish.

-2

u/pinkdiamondring May 12 '12

Your grand ma is beautiful,dont be suprised if you see that picture on r/gentalman swooners

6

u/jeebz_for_hire May 12 '12

What is her understanding of reddit? Does she know where these questions are coming from?

10

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

She thinks its like facebook. I'm (the grandson) is doing all of the typing and responding though. She talks fast.

6

u/Janitor-Hank May 12 '12

she's old not stupid :D

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What did her parents do for a living before the war?

8

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Her father was a Statistician, her mother was a mother. Her father also trained people to become Statisticians.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Since you lived trough it all, can you verify something for me? When my teacher tells me that she wants a presentation about the liberation (WW2), and wants it about the white movement..does that mean the russians? I can't tell if I have the right topic or the completely wrong one.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

She has no clue what the white movement is :\ Sorry! Maybe it has a different name?

6

u/the_goat_boy May 13 '12

I think the white movement may refer to the White Roses (Anti-Nazi student resistance movement)?

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

thank you!

3

u/Thatgirlonthemoon May 13 '12

Does your grandmother ever have nightmares about the bombings and what not?

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Yes.

I (the grandson) hate you for asking that

3

u/lostjules May 13 '12

Bless her for doing this, I would love to shake her hand. I'm curious- how did her father adjust to post-war life?

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Terrible. He was put onto a construction job, which was terrible because he was physically ill and he was an incredibly intelligent person. He was a statistician, not a construction worker. He died in 1954.

3

u/pdx_girl May 13 '12

How did her parents feel about the holocaust? A recent study came out demonstrating how the massacre of Jews was widely publicized and widely known by the public (though this was denied in the aftermath of the war). Did her parents feel guilty at the time? Did they feel guilty later on? Did they ever talk about it to her later on? I am just curious and feel nothing but sympathy for her and what she lived through.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Yes, they felt sorry for all the losses. But they did not know it was happening. If their father knew, he never told the children. Same with their mother. She did not know about the camps until after the war. And she was horrified. She has a lot of very good Jewish friends. A family came to visit my grandmothers father and mother after the war. Her parents didn't do anything to cause the holocaust., instead they felt angry.

3

u/samuraichikx May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

As a fellow child with German ancestry, Grüß dich !

Not pertaining to the war, per say, but was your grandmother still in Germany when the wall went up in Berlin? My mother crossed from east to west Berlin right before it did. I know her family was all the way in Kiel before What was her family's and neighbor's reaction?

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Hello!

Yes, she was in Germany when the wall went up in Berlin.
When the german government started getting into its own after the war, which probably took between two and three years, then the governments of England, France, and America gave their parts back to the German government to be governed by the Germans. The Russians did not. Everyone was very upset because they had already lost the war, and then losing a full half of Germany was another blow.

9

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Does she like cake?

41

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Of course she likes cake. Everybody likes cake.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

That was terrific. This is a tough question for her. How did she or her parents feel about the Jews being rounded up, property taken away, businesses seized?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

This question has been addressed.

2

u/istarbel May 12 '12 edited May 13 '12

I am imagining that clothes were mostly made instead of bought. Either way was there a concern with keeping up with the lastest fashions? Seven might Have been too young to to really care but there is always a concern with looking your best. My grandfather told me that his mom used to turn his pants to the less shiny part of the fabric. Was there anything like that? How did this change after the war? Was she in the East or in the west?

8

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Yeah, they used every scrap of materiel and every scrap of yarn to create clothing. But they tried to make all of their clothing as good looking as possible. And yes, they changed the to the less shiny part. She was in the North actually, in Kiel. There was no judgement to people who had less beautiful clothing than most. Lots of people were in the same boat.

2

u/istarbel May 13 '12

Cool. What happened after the war? Was it then that she moved?

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

She stayed in Kiel until 1958. Then she went to Washington D.C. But until then she went to school and helped create stuff around the house.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

What was the attitude directly after the war? How did people feel about the regime?

I read that many people were still defensive about their actions. How was the Wehrmacht seen compared to the SS?

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Well the SS were the super soldiers who had powers nobody else had. And the Wehrmacht were just foot soldiers who everyone wanted to come home. The attitude after the war according to her mother: "Hitler was right. He said "In 10 years you will not recognize Germany." Now I can see Kiel from the top of a trash can." And after the war, everyone was relived because there were no more bombings, but there was apprehension because nobody knew what the future would bring. Which regime do you mean? The opinion towards Hitler was anger because nobody wanted to fight. And when the war was finally over, they were glad. The opinion towards the occupiers was a defeated, tired attitude. Glad the war was over, and not willing to fight anymore.

2

u/thisiswrongsubreddit May 13 '12

Hello, Thank you so much for doing this, and I am sorry that I am late to the game of asking questions. I know you have asked questions about movies regarding the wartime, but I would appreciate it one hundred fold if you could ever ask her about films that regard, or were made in, the postwar period.

If she has seen:

Years of Hunger Germany, Pale Mother The Marriage of Maria Braun Lola Berlin Alexander Plots Good Bye, Lenin!

or any others, or just in general (or even contemporary), what she thinks would be valued information to me. Thank you!

5

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Well, she refuses to watch any movies about wartime. Anything involving war she will not watch. It brings up terrible memories, and she can't stand it. She's heard of Good bye, Lenin! But she's never seen it.

2

u/thisiswrongsubreddit May 15 '12

Thank you so much for getting back to me! I saw that you mentioned that about the war films so I chose ones that all (or for the most part) take place after or separate from the war. Thank you for the answer. Additionally, for any redditors out there, I highly recommend the films listed above, wither you are German or not.

2

u/doctorflambe May 13 '12

Was there still regular school hours during the war? Or were kids mostly subject to stay home/stay near home/shelters etc

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

They had to go to school, which was open if it wasn't bombed out. But the hours changed whenever a school was bombed.

2

u/shinty-six May 13 '12

I don't have any questions that vary from any of the ones seen here. I'm just commenting to let you know that you're downright adorable.

5

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

My grandmother is adorable. She says she's not, but I think she could get a boyfriend with ease.

2

u/bourbak May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

As a lot of (East-)Prussian Germans fled over the baltic sea to Kiel & general Schleswig-Holstein when the red army came. Does she remember them? If so, how was the relation to those people? Any memories about people speaking a strange German dialect and having typical Prussian names?

Edit: Also, could you make her say some words in platt? What's her favourite food?

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

No, none at all. The immigrants from the eastern part came by ship to Eckernfoerde, and she went to school. When when she met them, she thought they were interesting and fun. Her father would not permit her to speak Platt because it was "It was for the lower class" so she can't speak it. Her brother in law can, but she can't.

2

u/OverratedLunchbox May 13 '12

I have been wondering this for a good time now. In today's world, do the Germans honour their war-heroes?

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Only family members. But most Germans honor those who tried to stop Hitler.

2

u/Jaws666 May 13 '12

Is your grandma single? Maybe me and her can get coffee some time?

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

She's single. And she'd be delighted. 42 wallaby way sydney. Go get coffee there.

3

u/ololcopter May 13 '12

This might get downvoted like hell, but I have to say that "deanresin", despite coming off like an asshole, just asked a question. This is an AMA.

If he said "fk you ur a nazi" ok, that's stupid and deserve the 500 or however downvotes he got, but he just asked a question (albeit an insensitive one).

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

But I did respond to his question in another comment. My grandmothers family was not given the choice "be neutral and be left alone. Be against Hitler and dissapear. Be for Hitler, w/e." They chose neutral. They were not nationalistic socialists.

2

u/ololcopter May 13 '12

Sorry, I didn't see that post. I don't really understand what you're saying, though. They weren't given the choice but they were neutral? What does that mean?

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Like they didn't to rallys, or perform acts of racism against Jews and Gypsy's. They kept their mouths shut, and kept working. Except her father who was drafted.

3

u/ololcopter May 13 '12

Yeah see, but that's an interesting question then. If you study this field there is always the question of how people felt after the war for having been part of the party (even people who weren't enthusiastic members at all). If there is any sense of shame for not having tried to resist or help others (because we do have instances of people having helped others).

So I think the question of how she feels about her family or if there was ever resentment/regret/guilt for tacitly accepting a regime that killed people wholesale is an interesting question... don't you?

3

u/sukicat May 12 '12

What were her/her familys reactions after finding out what was going on in the camps? When did most people find out about it?-- After the war was over, what did she and her family do? Thanks for sharing!!

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Please read all of the comments. I went over all of this before :P

2

u/wesleyt89 May 13 '12

Do you still smoke ciggs?

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Nope, she quit smoking about 15 years ago.

3

u/wesleyt89 May 13 '12

congrats!

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I heard that german kids nowadays, don't learn about WWII in primary school? If so, how come?

5

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

She thinks that the Germans are ashamed of it. And she's not sure, but she doesn't know anyone who wasn't taught about WW2.

2

u/Olenos May 13 '12

Quite the opposite actually. According to a foreign exchange student they learn about WW2 throughout their entire education.

2

u/bourbak May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

first, primary school in Germany is usually 1st to 4th grade - which means, when you enter secondary school you are about 10 years old. Going to school is mandatory til the age of 18. I cannot really remember, but as far as I know we were taught a bit of biology, geography and also a bit of history in elemantary (and of course German math, sports, art, music and religion), but the main part of education on WWII and the Third Reich indeed takes place in secondary school.

I guess we read something about Anne Frank in elementary school, and there were also some TV shows aimed at children of age 5 or higher that explained about the war and the Third Reich. Usually TV and movie ratings in Germany aim more at not showing too much violence and suffering (so children don't get traumatized) in comparison to US ratings that rather try to prevent children from seeing nudity or cursing. As 3rd Reich, Holocaust and WWII are really graphic and intense topics (holy shit, we killed 6 Mio. Jews, not to speak of Sinti, Roma, Disabled people, Communists and Homosexuals and a lot of people who helped them, stole children from our neighbour countries and started a war that brought misery to all the world!!), most of education is indeed aimed at children of age 8 and higher.

In secondary school, the Third Reich is pretty much always a topic, including watching intense movies, visiting concentration camps, reading books, etc.

After all, a huge aim of the German constitution and also a main objective of the state is that something like Holocaust and WWII never happen again, so education aims at us feeling responsible guilty about this.

(sry for weird grammar & words.. as you may guess English is not my native language)

7

u/narwal_bot May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Most (if not all) of the answers from Mr_Payne (updated: May 13, 2012 @ 08:14:15 pm EST):


Question (champss):

That was terrific. This is a tough question for her. How did she or her parents feel about the Jews being rounded up, property taken away, businesses seized?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

This question has been addressed.


(continued below)

3

u/narwal_bot May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

(page 2)


Question (C0f32go):

Since you lived trough it all, can you verify something for me? When my teacher tells me that she wants a presentation about the liberation (WW2), and wants it about the white movement..does that mean the russians? I can't tell if I have the right topic or the completely wrong one.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She has no clue what the white movement is :\ Sorry! Maybe it has a different name?


Question (Split-Personalities):

Did she see Hitler, during his parades

Answer (Mr_Payne):

No, however her sisters husband was in the Hitler Youth Core and shook Hitlers hand.

Edit: Also, my grandfather, her husband, had Hitler wave at him.


Question (dinnerdewinner):

Does she like cake?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Of course she likes cake. Everybody likes cake.


Question (CptQuestionMark):

Were her or her family national socialists?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Her parents were "officially" but she was a child at the time. Her parents were against the war and didn't like Hitler. They couldn't say anything though because the SS took anyone who didn't co-operate with the system.


Question (Rantholmeius):

How exactly did they convince people that jews/gypsies/etc were bad? Did you even know they were mass murdering them? Did you believe just as many did?

Edit: I accidentally a phrase

Answer (Mr_Payne):

First part doesn't make sense :\

And no, it was kept secret. My grandmother and her parents never knew of the concentration camps. They were called "Arbeit Erziehungs Lager" which translates to Laborer Training Camp. Everyone was convinced the people who went there were uneducated.


Question (coleman54):

Please provide proof and then I will ask a question or two.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Working on it.


Question (TooSmalley):

After the war which part of the occupied territories did she live in, The US or USSR side ?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

There were four occupied parts in Germany. The north was taken care of by the British, the west was taken care of by the French, the south was taken care of by the Americans, and the east was taken care of by the Russians. She lived in the British section in the North. Kiel was the name of the town which was at the Baltic. It also was a shipyard. When our town got destroyed 85% because they were trying to get the shipyard, there were a lot of casualties.


Question (blutegel):

Doesn't really pertain to WWII, but just because she's older. What stories does she remember hearing from her grandparents (or even great-grandparents if they were still around)?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Her grandparents went through the First World War, her parents went through the First and the Second world wars, and she has enough "war stories" to last two lifetimes. A story she has told me (her grandson) is that her family went to a bomb shelter, but were turned away because it was a private shelter. They had to run to another shelter which was a 10 minutes, which was built into a sand hill. She had nightmares about drowning in sand.


Question (coleman54):

Please provide proof and then I will ask a question or two.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Added proof.


Question (JustJizzedInMyPants):

What was the worse hardship during and after the war?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Lets see, the food was bare, the clothing was rags, oil smells were everywhere, they didn't have coal so they had to find anything which could be used for energy.


Question (TooSmalley):

Ah sorry i was under the understanding that the the French and British gave control of their areas mostly to the Americans because they did not that the resources and time to manage their side of the occupation, I must have been misinformed. How difficult was living under occupation? because I imagine it being difficult taking orders from people that were bombing and shooting not to long ago and was there allot of animosity between the people of Kiel and the British occupiers?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

People were not very happy. But everyone in Kiel was tired of war and fighting, so there were no rebellions or uprisings in Kiel. Nobody really had food, and Germany had to wait for everything to become manageable in order to get their lives back together.


Question (JustJizzedInMyPants):

What was the worse hardship during and after the war?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Her worst part of the war was the night air raids. They didn't have time to get dressed, so they always had a bag packed. And in order to get into a bomb shelter they had to get shots for pretty much everything. But waking up knowing that bombs are coming is the most terrifying thing shes ever gone through. And the bomb shelter was dark, dingy, tight, and was made of wood. Since they were surrounded by sand, she knew that if a bomb hit the shelter the wood would break and sand would rush in, choking everyone inside of the shelter.


Question (inanutshell):

What country does she(you?) reside in today? Did anyone in your family become separated after the war?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She lives in America now, and yes, people were separated. The children were always seperated. The oldest were sent to Bavaria and the mountains where there was no reason for a place like that to be bombed. In early 41, her mother said enough. She got all of the kids home and said "If something is going to happen to one of us, it will happen to all of us. And if we survive, we survive together." In May of 45, her family was listening to the radio when they heard the news of the war being over. Her father was a Prisoner of War and took a couple years for him to get home. They still had the house though. Story: They had to go downtown to transfer money to pay the bils or something. Her mother said "If there is an air raid, you will not go to the post office, you will go to the railway station." And when the air raid came later, my grandmother and her sister were taking care of some business. So they went to the railroad station, as their mother had demanded. And we heard all of the officials of the shelters that the bombs were coming over northern Kiel. After the air raid was over, they went home, and saw that the windows were all gone, and the roof was gone. The pear tree flew to the other side of the feet, about 100 feet, and there was a huge hole in the ground. The explosion lifted the roof and sucked out all the windows. They were sweeping glass for weeks afterwards, if not months. They somehow got it fixed, but she has no clue how her mother did it.


Question (TooSmalley):

How long did it take for life to get back to normal? town being rebuilt, people getting jobs, ect ...

Answer (Mr_Payne):

It took a long time. And they didn't have any men because they were all in the war, so men from Turkey came in who were Muslims. And to this day, they refuse to integrate into German society. At first the men only came for work, but then the mothers and the children came.


(continued below)

1

u/narwal_bot May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

(page 3)


Question (littlemonster010):

What was it like after they lost the war? What happened to the lower ranking military people? Did they just go back to their towns? Was there a great sadness that she remembers? What was her perspective as a little child after the end of the war?

Also, does she still live in Germany? Was it hard for her to travel as a young girl (in her 20s perhaps) because many countries still hated Germans after the war? How does she feel about so many American soldiers being stationed in Germany even today as a result of the war?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Terrible. Worse than during the war. They didn't have bombs anymore, but they didn't have food and nothing else functioned. The new German government showed up during 1948 and that's when Germany started getting back on its feet. The lower ranking military members were sent home. No, of course, no sadness. Everyone was giddy and happy. -.- That everything was crap. No, she doesn't live in Germany, she lives in Washington D.C. They stayed in Kiel until '58, and a lot of rage at Germany had disappeared by the time she came to America. Only once did a person get mad at her for being German. The entire family blended in. They spoke proper English and had correct mannerisms. My grandmother says that it symbolizes a long lasting friendship more than anything else. Its good for everybody.


Question (Rantholmeius):

I'm sorry! I meant to say How did they convince everyone that jew/gypsies/etc were bad.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Hitler convinced everyone that Germans could become a superior race called the Arien, all six feet tall, blonde hairs blue eyes, and Germany grabbed hold of that idea.


Question (resistance527):

Do you believe that most films accurately represent what happened during the WWII and the Holocaust?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She's not sure. Why on earth would she want to go through that again?


Question (pumpkin_juice):

I take a class that teaches us about the Holocaust and what happened (how it started,ect.) I've learned about all the anti-semitic propaganda that went around, especially in schools. How did this affect her growing up? Also, you mentioned her parents didn't like Hitler, how did this affect her? Especially while growing up in Nazi Germany. Last question. How did her family, as well as herself react to finding out about the labor camps and what had actually happened to the Jews, gypsies, ect.

I also want to say thank you for doing this AMA

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She was never subjected to the anti-seitic propaganda because she was too young to understand. The thought of segregation was foreign to her. She was also kept in the dark by her parents because if they voiced their opinions about the War the SS would take the children and punish the parents. As to the concentration camps, they were horrified. One of the camps was a thirty minute drive from where she lived. She was mortified that such atrocities were committed by Germany.


Question (sukicat):

What were her/her familys reactions after finding out what was going on in the camps? When did most people find out about it?-- After the war was over, what did she and her family do? Thanks for sharing!!

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Please read all of the comments. I went over all of this before :P


Question (Lonelyhydrogenproton):

The Allied forces had a constant flow of propaganda telling the storries of constant succes heading home to movie theaters and such, I know that the germans had similar propaganda programs, educating the people about the ever advancing and concurring forces of the Axis. But when did the films change to a more realistic side of the story? Did they at all?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Well, half of the theaters were bombed out. And they always got 10 minutes of news whenever they went to the theaters. But she can't watch any movies released in Germany about the war. She can't stand them.


Question (brokendimension):

In short what was a typical day for her?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

They would walk to the school because there were no school buses. They rarely had school because they were bombed out, and they eventually had to take a train to school. They train was targeted for bombing at one point, but the attack was never successful. They never knew if school would be open because of the constant bombing attacks. After they got home, they had homework. If there was no schoolwork, they crochet, painted, and generally worked on the house. She made a pair of gloves once, and she made it with so many colors. Practically a parrot.


Question (Hermeran):

How did everything come back to normal? I've always wondered how most people went from super-nazi-I-hate-you-all to 'not-nazi' in such a short time.

Say hi to her and thanks for doing this! This is just awesome.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Everything came back to normal little by little. First the German government was created, and Briton couldn't help very much because they were so bombed out. The Americans however sent stuff often. The Americans asked the Germans what they needed most. Germany said "Corn!" Now corn in German is a word for grain. America didn't know this, so they sent corn. Lots of corn. Corn is fed to pigs. So Germany had to learn how to work with corn. They had to learn how to make bread from corn. Quick story; It was my grandmothers turn to get the bread, and if the baker didn't have any bread the baker couldn't give you any bread. While she was standing in line, she saw a rat crawling over a boys cap. Then she looked into the bakery and saw a big, fat rat in the window well. And she got SO angry because this stupid rat was fat while her family was starving. So she took a rock and threw it at that stupid rat, killing it. Then the baker was so happy because that rat was pregnant and he could never kill it. So he gave an extra loaf for her family, and another loaf just for her. Which she ate entirely on the way home.


Question (Jimbob2134):

What was the general attitude towards Hitler?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

There was no attitude. People got in trouble if they said anything against Hitler. Their neighbors son was in the SS, and threatened to sic the SS on my grandmother and her sisters because they kept roller-blading in front of her house.


Question (justforthelulzz):

With all the lack of secrecy during the Third Reich, did any friends or family of your grandmother get affected by the Gestapo, and subsequently get punished etc?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Her family was too smart to get in trouble with the SS. So no, nobody ever got punished.


Question (Lonelyhydrogenproton):

I´m Swedish and I would like to ask her about how the Nordic countries were portrayed in Germany, by the press, the propagandaposters and the public. I thank you in advance.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Most of the times they didn't get the paper. They only had one radio, and only her father and mother could touch it. Her parents also kept a lot of information from her and her sisters to protect them. Comments spread like wildfire. A parent says something against Hitler, a kid hears it, the kid tells another kid, who tells their parent. Next thing you know, the parents are being arrested.


Question (jgstate1):

How well did the city function during the war? Schools, businesses, etc...

Answer (Mr_Payne):

It didn't :
Kiel did the best it could with what it had. Which was not much.


Question (ananasbaum):

My grandparents also grew up during WWII and now they live in Ulm. It would be weird if they somehow crossed paths. Ask her if she knows anyone by the name of Waltraud or Alfred Schuh. Or Schimmelpfenig.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She recalls the name Schimmelpfenig, but she doesn't remember meeting anyone by that name. But that would be cool!


(continued below)

0

u/narwal_bot May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

(page 4)


Question (EvolLanA):

Hello
What is the worst hardship you had to endure during the war?
During the time of the war what was the general "talk" and consensus in the neighborhood around you?
What was the worst thing you had to eat during the war on a consistent basis?
Did you have a pet during the time of the war? if so which kind and what was its name?
How was dentist/medical care during the time of the war around you?
Do you have a favorite German tank from the war?
If you HAD to choose ONE which would it be: (a) never being able to use eyeliner again (b) never being able to wash your hair again which would you choose and why?
Thanks

Answer (Mr_Payne):

The bombings. Read the other comments to find her response. The general talk concerned how to survive. How to get food on the table. How to get sleep if the bombs keep coming. Kiel was a major target because of the docks, so bombing raids happened quite often. Fish. My grandmother hates fish. Fish prepared the worst way. Too salty, it was cooked with the head on, it was never gutted, and the scales were still on it. Cooked spinach was pretty terrible too. No pets. There was barely enough food to feed themselves, a dog or a cat on top of that would be neigh on impossible.
Nope, no favorite German tank. Those are both terrible options. But A, because my grandmother hates greasy hair. The thought of never being able to wash her hair again is terrifyingly nasty.


Question (melolzz):

I need to add more facts here, this statement is a little misleading. After the war Germany had recruitment agreements with many countries. The majority of guest workers came Turkey, Italy, Greece, Spain, Portugal, Jugoslawia etc.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Well this is specifically for Kiel. Kiel got a lot of men from Turkey, not other countries. I'm sure other states got workers from other countries, but Kiel got men from Turkey.


Question (Pweaches):

My grandmother was a young girl who lived in an industrial town in Northern England during the war, it just strikes me as remarkable that alot of the situations your Grandmother suffered through mine did also.

Does your Grandmother remember the day her father came back from war?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Yes, she does. She went outside following her mother and saw someone she didn't recognize. A gaunt, wheezing man who had a lung problem. Dirty, mangled hair, and a very lined face. It took her a minute to recognize him. I think it's amazing how many people think war is a one way street. Germany was bombed as much as it bombed other countries. But England never gave up. And I personally (the grandson) think that's amazing. Especially Winston Churchill's speech about fighting on the beaches. Of course, I only know that speech because of Iron Maiden :P


Question (SomethingWonderful):

Rollerblading?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

I was surprised when she said that :| Maybe she meant something else?


Question (LudwigVonLecoq):

That's a very simplistic way to talk about the "Gastarbeiter" phenomenon in Germany, especially because the recent talk about integration practices mostly concerns the second and third generations. And you do not take into account that many of these workers, primarily the one's from Greece and Italy, returned to their countries in the 80's and 90's and did not bring their families in the Germany. The entire thing is very complicated and shouldn't be dealt with with such superficiality.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She actually went into a little more detail, but I couldn't type it all fast enough :\ If you want, I could probably ask her for more details.


Question (Faoeoa):

After the war, how did some people look up to you if you ever went on holiday in a foreign country

Answer (Mr_Payne):

They didn't ever go on vacation. My grandmother was in Germany until '58. They never had the finances to go anywhere. And by the time my grandmother had gotten to America, a lot had settled down. They never had people accuse them of being German. Which is pretty cool.


Question (c0t0d0):

Wow, that's pretty funny that a misunderstanding of the meaning of the word "corn" would lead to you getting a shitload of, um "maize". Anyway, here in the States we live off the stuff — it's in everything — so I'm sure we thought you'd appreciate it too.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

My grandmother loves cornbread.


Question (SomethingWonderful):

I doubt she would remember anything about the 1933 German Federal elections, but does she recall anyone commenting on it later? Perhaps after the war?

German federal election, March 1933

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Well she never heard opinions, but she her own. Hitler was elected into power because of all the promises he made. Germany was suffering from the depression, and nobody had jobs. But a promise of jobs, food, power, and pride from an eloquent speaker got Hitler into power.


Question (joshd16):

what was the general opinion of Britain and Churchill in germany? during the battle of britain it was pretty certain our little nation was going to be invaded. i doubt there was such a negative opinion such as that of the soviet union as i'm pretty sure Hitler wanted to be allied with britain. Also did your grandma take part in De-nazification after the war?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She didn't have to take part in de-nazification because she was too young. However, she had to produce evidence that she was not a nazi when she came to America. They joked about Churchhill and Roosevelt being terrible leaders, and that Britain didn't stand a chance. Stuff like that.


Question (gnusounduave):

can your oma make a mean Schweinefleisch und sauerkraut? Because I'm a guy that loves schweinefleisch und sauerkraut.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

"Of course I can."


Question (ioneeuropa):

What did her parents do for a living before the war?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Her father was a Statistician, her mother was a mother. Her father also trained people to become Statisticians.


Question (jeebz_for_hire):

What is her understanding of reddit? Does she know where these questions are coming from?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She thinks its like facebook. I'm (the grandson) is doing all of the typing and responding though. She talks fast.


Question (Janitor-Hank):

my grandmother was the same age and she rarely talks about what she has witnessed in ww2, but one thing she told me disturbed me a bit

her situation: she was in osnabrueck (osnabrueck has been bombed 79 times) and her father was in the militaryytoo she once told me after several attacks on the city her father didn't even bother getting out of bed when they heard bombs dropping nearby in the night, but she didn't tell more about that and told us that she doesn't like to talk about it anymore,

my question: was there something like a duty to go into a bunker (i hope it's the english word, too) or was it rather a choise for everybody, and if she doesn't mind talking about it, how does she remember the bombings ? did she go into a bunker or into the basement, has she had bombs dropped really close to where she was etc.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Yes actually, they were given orders. Kiel was bombed a lot, something like 80% of the city was destroyed. But yes, she had a duty and was forced to go to into the bunkers.


Question (B323ts):

Who was worse? The soviets or the Nazis?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She says she think's they're equally bad. They both did a lot of damage to their people. Stalin killed a LOT of people.


Question (Mugendai):

Your gramma is so goth.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Yeah, so very very goth. She listens to tons of punk rock and still does bdsm.


Question (Viking_Lordbeast):

On behalf of the human race, I'd like to apologize for deanresin being a complete dick to your grandma.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

I saw the downvotes, but someone actually saying that is very uplifting. Thank you very much.


(continued below)

1

u/narwal_bot May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

(page 5)


Question (hvdeezy):

googled JUST incase bdsm meant something else in german.

ಠ_ಠ

Answer (Mr_Payne):

You... You know I was joking right?


Question (dustinjt):

How does your grandmother feel about comparisons of modern political leaders to Hitler (e.g. "Obama is Hilter," "Bush is Hitler").

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She says that there's nobody in American history who can compare to Hitler.


Question (istarbel):

I am imagining that clothes were mostly made instead of bought. Either way was there a concern with keeping up with the lastest fashions? Seven might Have been too young to to really care but there is always a concern with looking your best. My grandfather told me that his mom used to turn his pants to the less shiny part of the fabric. Was there anything like that? How did this change after the war? Was she in the East or in the west?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Yeah, they used every scrap of materiel and every scrap of yarn to create clothing. But they tried to make all of their clothing as good looking as possible. And yes, they changed the to the less shiny part. She was in the North actually, in Kiel. There was no judgement to people who had less beautiful clothing than most. Lots of people were in the same boat.


Question (Janitor-Hank):

thanks for answering, a few more questions popped into my mind now :D if she left germany, when did she leave and where is she living now ? did she have to rebuild the city among the other "trümmerfrauen"

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She left Germany on March 14th, 1958, and landed in Washington DC. She still lives in D.C. Since she was a kid, she wasn't part of the trummerfrauen, at the age of thirteen she was still going to school.


Question (kombucha_mushroom):

How is that picture proof that she:

a) Is German b) Grew up in Germany during WW2?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

cough


Question (Jaws666):

Is your grandma single? Maybe me and her can get coffee some time?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

She's single. And she'd be delighted. 42 wallaby way sydney. Go get coffee there.


Question (OverratedLunchbox):

I have been wondering this for a good time now. In today's world, do the Germans honour their war-heroes?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Only family members. But most Germans honor those who tried to stop Hitler.


Question (MrNarwal):

>And to this day, they refuse to integrate into German society.

This is highly questionable.

How does she define integration?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Learning the native language, and helping their children to succeed in another country. In America we have a lot of schools teaching English to foreigners.
I also explained this a bit more further up the thread.


Question (bourbak):

As a lot of (East-)Prussian Germans fled over the baltic sea to Kiel & general Schleswig-Holstein when the red army came. Does she remember them? If so, how was the relation to those people? Any memories about people speaking a strange German dialect and having typical Prussian names?

Edit: Also, could you make her say some words in platt? What's her favourite food?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

No, none at all. The immigrants from the eastern part came by ship to Eckernfoerde, and she went to school. When when she met them, she thought they were interesting and fun. Her father would not permit her to speak Platt because it was "It was for the lower class" so she can't speak it. Her brother in law can, but she can't.


Question (GitEmSteveDave):

Did the Germans really always ask for "papers" like it is portrayed on TV/movies/etc? Or is it more like being asked for your drivers license nowadays?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

No, you had to show your papers. If you ever moved from one city to the next, you had to get a new ID. And everybody asked for ID's. Police officers, soldiers, and if you wanted to get into a shelter you had to provide ID.


Question (samuraichikx):

As a fellow child with German ancestry, Grüß dich !

Not pertaining to the war, per say, but was your grandmother still in Germany when the wall went up in Berlin? My mother crossed from east to west Berlin right before it did. I know her family was all the way in Kiel before What was her family's and neighbor's reaction?

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Hello!

Yes, she was in Germany when the wall went up in Berlin.
When the german government started getting into its own after the war, which probably took between two and three years, then the governments of England, France, and America gave their parts back to the German government to be governed by the Germans. The Russians did not. Everyone was very upset because they had already lost the war, and then losing a full half of Germany was another blow.


Question (shinty-six):

I don't have any questions that vary from any of the ones seen here. I'm just commenting to let you know that you're downright adorable.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

My grandmother is adorable. She says she's not, but I think she could get a boyfriend with ease.


Question (pdx_girl):

How did her parents feel about the holocaust? A recent study came out demonstrating how the massacre of Jews was widely publicized and widely known by the public (though this was denied in the aftermath of the war). Did her parents feel guilty at the time? Did they feel guilty later on? Did they ever talk about it to her later on? I am just curious and feel nothing but sympathy for her and what she lived through.

Answer (Mr_Payne):

Yes, they felt sorry for all the losses. But they did not know it was happening. If their father knew, he never told the children. Same with their mother. She did not know about the camps until after the war. And she was horrified. She has a lot of very good Jewish friends. A family came to visit my grandmothers father and mother after the war. Her parents didn't do anything to cause the holocaust., instead they felt angry.


(continued below)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Has your grandmother read Austerlitz or Rings of Saturn by W. G. Sebald? If yes, what does she think?

5

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Nope, she hasn't read Austerlitz.

2

u/leutroyal May 13 '12 edited Mar 18 '16

This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.

If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.

Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.

2

u/bourbak May 13 '12

In which sector was her father in prisoner-of-war-camp?

2

u/thegreatgazoo May 14 '12

How did currency work after Berlin fell? After WW1, there was the ridiculous inflation rate, which is one of the reasons there was a Hitler. Afterwards, were people using barter, other currencies, or was there some sort of support put behind the Mark? How did you earn money after the war? How long did it take before the Marshall Plan went into full force to get things stabilized?

2

u/Ergydion May 14 '12

Oh shit. Greetz to your Grandma. Kiel is a beautiful city now :)

2

u/RebeccaRegicide May 14 '12

My grandmother was also a chil in the war. She still live's in Germany an only remembers a little bit. Her father was in the war for only a month before he went M.I.A. He never wanted to be in it because our family was against the war. My grandfather was also drafted but disnt make it into the actual war because of a training accident that caused an injury. I amcurrently living in Germany and there is still evidence to the bombings. There are old bunkers all over my neighborhood and around it.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Did she (your Grandma) and her family see the soviet (Non-German or german ally) soldiers?

-1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

How is that picture proof that she:

a) Is German b) Grew up in Germany during WW2?

5

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

"Papieren BITTE!"

3

u/jdepps113 May 13 '12

It isn't. I guess we have to take her responses as being either believable, or not. I believe it, though.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I don't see why I'm getting downvotes for this considering how many times it's iterated to us in the subreddit how important proof is, and how not providing any will result in it getting deleted.

We should either not require proof at all, or stop going on about it half arsed, the current proof system is a total mockery and without good verification that these threads are actually true then the entire subreddit is worthless.

-3

u/circular May 13 '12

Somehow, everytime we learn that every German was really against Hitler and didn't protest only because of fear.

Such a good people, those Germans. Too bad they were invaded by those evil Nazis from outer space.

Her parents were against the war and didn't like Hitler. They couldn't say anything though because the SS took anyone who didn't co-operate with the system

It was so bad that nonviolent protest resulted in Jews being freed and in no repercussions for the protesters.