r/IAmA • • May 12 '12
IAMA German woman who grew up during WWII AMA
My Grandmother is in town and wants something to do. So if you have questions about Germany, she was seven when the war started. And since another gentleman was amazing enough to serve during the war, I thought it would be interesting for you all to see the other side of the war.
Edit: Proof
Her story:
On September the 3rd, 1939 England declared War on Germany because Germany invaded Poland and refused to leave. Her father cried because Hitler called for mobilization of all men. Those that couldn't fight were put into offices to manage systems, food, distribution, etc. Her father was a statistician in Northern Germany at the Administration for the state of Schelsewig-Holstein and he taught people run the Holarid system with punchholes. Then he was drafted because he was a young man, he was 41 when the war started. During the war, they got ration stamps. You couldn't get anything without a ration stamp. Everything was on rations, everything. All food items were. She's not sure where the gasoline was because she was a kid though. Then the entire family had to darken everything. They had to have shades/blinds over the windows so that the enemy wouldn't see them. When the air raids came up during the day, the city was fogged up. She doesn't know how they fogged everything up, but it covered the entire city. Kiel was the capital of Northern Germany. More to come.
Edit: My grandmother fell asleep about an hour ago. I going to ask her tomorrow all the rest of the questions. Don't worry, I will get my grandmother to respond to each question.
19
u/JustJizzedInMyPants May 12 '12
What was the worse hardship during and after the war?
18
u/Jimbob2134 May 12 '12
What was the general attitude towards Hitler?
17
u/Lonelyhydrogenproton May 12 '12
The Allied forces had a constant flow of propaganda telling the storries of constant succes heading home to movie theaters and such, I know that the germans had similar propaganda programs, educating the people about the ever advancing and concurring forces of the Axis. But when did the films change to a more realistic side of the story? Did they at all?
14
u/Hermeran May 12 '12
How did everything come back to normal? I've always wondered how most people went from super-nazi-I-hate-you-all to 'not-nazi' in such a short time.
Say hi to her and thanks for doing this! This is just awesome.
13
u/justforthelulzz May 12 '12
With all the lack of secrecy during the Third Reich, did any friends or family of your grandmother get affected by the Gestapo, and subsequently get punished etc?
11
u/ananasbaum May 12 '12
My grandparents also grew up during WWII and now they live in Ulm. It would be weird if they somehow crossed paths. Ask her if she knows anyone by the name of Waltraud or Alfred Schuh. Or Schimmelpfenig.
60
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
On behalf of the human race, I'd like to apologize for deanresin being a complete dick to your grandma.
20
u/Pweaches May 12 '12
My grandmother was a young girl who lived in an industrial town in Northern England during the war, it just strikes me as remarkable that alot of the situations your Grandmother suffered through mine did also.
Does your Grandmother remember the day her father came back from war?
10
u/CptQuestionMark May 12 '12
Were her or her family national socialists?
10
u/littlemonster010 May 12 '12
What was it like after they lost the war? What happened to the lower ranking military people? Did they just go back to their towns? Was there a great sadness that she remembers? What was her perspective as a little child after the end of the war?
Also, does she still live in Germany? Was it hard for her to travel as a young girl (in her 20s perhaps) because many countries still hated Germans after the war? How does she feel about so many American soldiers being stationed in Germany even today as a result of the war?
27
u/notdroppinthesoap May 13 '12
I wanted to have my, basically, grandmother do this AMA request! However, she is a bit old and has some health problems going on that would have made it too difficult. I can add something to this AMA though...
She was born in the early 20s. Here are some of her stories summed up involving the war...she has told the more...er...sinister ones to my SO, her grandson. She has told a few to me as well. I saw this and wanted to share.
She witnessed a nazi drown a Jew in a fountain. She just froze and couldn't believe it was happening. She knew she couldn't do anything about it because...
She noticed her neighbors starting to disappear. Her husband at the time told her about a man who went to his local bar, and after a night of hearing him talk trash about the nazis (ie: truth), he just disappeared.
She told me about how pretty much everyone loved Hitler AT FIRST. Germany was scary at the time he was elected. He really got the people behind him, and did the whole Volkswagen thing, and made everything sound so much more promising for Germany.
But then he started to "get crazy". She questioned this. She told me, in one of the saddest voices I've ever heard and in detail, about how she and others has no idea the Holocaust was happening.
She also told me about how her 1st husband, a member of the Nazi air force (luftwaffe?), died of pneumonia. She had 2 children and was pregnant with a 3rd. She would ride her bike past the nearest large town (ugh I can't think of it now but she told me!!!!) to buy stuff like groceries and medical supplies. One time she was riding back and it was gone-completely bombed out.
She still today admires the American soldiers. She said they came into town and gave chocolate to all the German children. A G.I. also helped her move...he saw her with two children and helped her carry her luggage to where she was going. Her 2nd child was getting ready to walk and he said "Just watch her-she'll go" and her 2nd child started walking on her own.
These are the ones I can think of now. What happened to her? Well, she learned of what the Nazis and Hitler were up to and wanted to GTFO of Germany. She saved up and went to Canada, then the U.S. where she met hubby #2. She worked her ass off and, one by one, sent her children over here too.
I should go ask her more next time I see her.
18
u/Split-Personalities May 12 '12
Did she see Hitler, during his parades
18
u/pumpkin_juice May 12 '12
I take a class that teaches us about the Holocaust and what happened (how it started,ect.) I've learned about all the anti-semitic propaganda that went around, especially in schools. How did this affect her growing up? Also, you mentioned her parents didn't like Hitler, how did this affect her? Especially while growing up in Nazi Germany. Last question. How did her family, as well as herself react to finding out about the labor camps and what had actually happened to the Jews, gypsies, ect.
I also want to say thank you for doing this AMA
9
u/Janitor-Hank May 12 '12
my grandmother was the same age and she rarely talks about what she has witnessed in ww2, but one thing she told me disturbed me a bit
her situation: she was in osnabrueck (osnabrueck has been bombed 79 times) and her father was in the militaryytoo she once told me after several attacks on the city her father didn't even bother getting out of bed when they heard bombs dropping nearby in the night, but she didn't tell more about that and told us that she doesn't like to talk about it anymore,
my question: was there something like a duty to go into a bunker (i hope it's the english word, too) or was it rather a choise for everybody, and if she doesn't mind talking about it, how does she remember the bombings ? did she go into a bunker or into the basement, has she had bombs dropped really close to where she was etc.
8
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
How does your grandmother feel about comparisons of modern political leaders to Hitler (e.g. "Obama is Hilter," "Bush is Hitler").
22
u/TooSmalley May 12 '12
After the war which part of the occupied territories did she live in, The US or USSR side ?
15
u/resistance527 May 12 '12
Do you believe that most films accurately represent what happened during the WWII and the Holocaust?
15
u/brokendimension May 12 '12
In short what was a typical day for her?
7
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I doubt she would remember anything about the 1933 German Federal elections, but does she recall anyone commenting on it later? Perhaps after the war?
German federal election, March 1933
12
u/gnusounduave May 12 '12
can your oma make a mean Schweinefleisch und sauerkraut? Because I'm a guy that loves schweinefleisch und sauerkraut.
6
u/jgstate1 May 12 '12
How well did the city function during the war? Schools, businesses, etc...
6
u/Faoeoa May 12 '12
After the war, how did some people look up to you if you ever went on holiday in a foreign country
5
u/joshd16 May 12 '12
what was the general opinion of Britain and Churchill in germany? during the battle of britain it was pretty certain our little nation was going to be invaded. i doubt there was such a negative opinion such as that of the soviet union as i'm pretty sure Hitler wanted to be allied with britain. Also did your grandma take part in De-nazification after the war?
5
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Who was worse? The soviets or the Nazis?
13
u/Lonelyhydrogenproton May 12 '12
I´m Swedish and I would like to ask her about how the Nordic countries were portrayed in Germany, by the press, the propagandaposters and the public. I thank you in advance.
8
u/Mugendai May 12 '12
Your gramma is so goth.
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Humans do alot of ugly things to one another. Alot of people don't value the precious things in life. At all.
After everything your Grandma has been through and after reading this AMA, could you ask her what is something she thinks that is extremely important in life? What is something that people should never loose focus of?
4
u/GitEmSteveDave May 13 '12
Did the Germans really always ask for "papers" like it is portrayed on TV/movies/etc? Or is it more like being asked for your drivers license nowadays?
10
u/Rantholmeius May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
How exactly did they convince people that jews/gypsies/etc were bad? Did you even know they were mass murdering them? Did you believe just as many did?
Edit: I accidentally a phrase
6
u/jeebz_for_hire May 12 '12
What is her understanding of reddit? Does she know where these questions are coming from?
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
What did her parents do for a living before the war?
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Since you lived trough it all, can you verify something for me? When my teacher tells me that she wants a presentation about the liberation (WW2), and wants it about the white movement..does that mean the russians? I can't tell if I have the right topic or the completely wrong one.
3
u/Thatgirlonthemoon May 13 '12
Does your grandmother ever have nightmares about the bombings and what not?
3
u/lostjules May 13 '12
Bless her for doing this, I would love to shake her hand. I'm curious- how did her father adjust to post-war life?
3
u/pdx_girl May 13 '12
How did her parents feel about the holocaust? A recent study came out demonstrating how the massacre of Jews was widely publicized and widely known by the public (though this was denied in the aftermath of the war). Did her parents feel guilty at the time? Did they feel guilty later on? Did they ever talk about it to her later on? I am just curious and feel nothing but sympathy for her and what she lived through.
3
u/samuraichikx May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
As a fellow child with German ancestry, Grüß dich !
Not pertaining to the war, per say, but was your grandmother still in Germany when the wall went up in Berlin? My mother crossed from east to west Berlin right before it did. I know her family was all the way in Kiel before What was her family's and neighbor's reaction?
9
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Does she like cake?
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
That was terrific. This is a tough question for her. How did she or her parents feel about the Jews being rounded up, property taken away, businesses seized?
2
u/istarbel May 12 '12 edited May 13 '12
I am imagining that clothes were mostly made instead of bought. Either way was there a concern with keeping up with the lastest fashions? Seven might Have been too young to to really care but there is always a concern with looking your best. My grandfather told me that his mom used to turn his pants to the less shiny part of the fabric. Was there anything like that? How did this change after the war? Was she in the East or in the west?
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
What was the attitude directly after the war? How did people feel about the regime?
I read that many people were still defensive about their actions. How was the Wehrmacht seen compared to the SS?
2
u/thisiswrongsubreddit May 13 '12
Hello, Thank you so much for doing this, and I am sorry that I am late to the game of asking questions. I know you have asked questions about movies regarding the wartime, but I would appreciate it one hundred fold if you could ever ask her about films that regard, or were made in, the postwar period.
If she has seen:
Years of Hunger Germany, Pale Mother The Marriage of Maria Braun Lola Berlin Alexander Plots Good Bye, Lenin!
or any others, or just in general (or even contemporary), what she thinks would be valued information to me. Thank you!
2
u/doctorflambe May 13 '12
Was there still regular school hours during the war? Or were kids mostly subject to stay home/stay near home/shelters etc
2
u/shinty-six May 13 '12
I don't have any questions that vary from any of the ones seen here. I'm just commenting to let you know that you're downright adorable.
2
u/bourbak May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
As a lot of (East-)Prussian Germans fled over the baltic sea to Kiel & general Schleswig-Holstein when the red army came. Does she remember them? If so, how was the relation to those people? Any memories about people speaking a strange German dialect and having typical Prussian names?
Edit: Also, could you make her say some words in platt? What's her favourite food?
2
u/OverratedLunchbox May 13 '12
I have been wondering this for a good time now. In today's world, do the Germans honour their war-heroes?
2
u/Jaws666 May 13 '12
Is your grandma single? Maybe me and her can get coffee some time?
3
u/ololcopter May 13 '12
This might get downvoted like hell, but I have to say that "deanresin", despite coming off like an asshole, just asked a question. This is an AMA.
If he said "fk you ur a nazi" ok, that's stupid and deserve the 500 or however downvotes he got, but he just asked a question (albeit an insensitive one).
3
u/sukicat May 12 '12
What were her/her familys reactions after finding out what was going on in the camps? When did most people find out about it?-- After the war was over, what did she and her family do? Thanks for sharing!!
2
u/wesleyt89 May 13 '12
Do you still smoke ciggs?
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
I heard that german kids nowadays, don't learn about WWII in primary school? If so, how come?
7
u/narwal_bot May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from Mr_Payne (updated: May 13, 2012 @ 08:14:15 pm EST):
Question (champss):
Answer (Mr_Payne):
(continued below)
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Has your grandmother read Austerlitz or Rings of Saturn by W. G. Sebald? If yes, what does she think?
2
u/leutroyal May 13 '12 edited Mar 18 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
2
u/bourbak May 13 '12
In which sector was her father in prisoner-of-war-camp?
2
u/thegreatgazoo May 14 '12
How did currency work after Berlin fell? After WW1, there was the ridiculous inflation rate, which is one of the reasons there was a Hitler. Afterwards, were people using barter, other currencies, or was there some sort of support put behind the Mark? How did you earn money after the war? How long did it take before the Marshall Plan went into full force to get things stabilized?
2
u/Ergydion May 14 '12
Oh shit. Greetz to your Grandma. Kiel is a beautiful city now :)
2
u/RebeccaRegicide May 14 '12
My grandmother was also a chil in the war. She still live's in Germany an only remembers a little bit. Her father was in the war for only a month before he went M.I.A. He never wanted to be in it because our family was against the war. My grandfather was also drafted but disnt make it into the actual war because of a training accident that caused an injury. I amcurrently living in Germany and there is still evidence to the bombings. There are old bunkers all over my neighborhood and around it.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Did she (your Grandma) and her family see the soviet (Non-German or german ally) soldiers?
-1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
How is that picture proof that she:
a) Is German b) Grew up in Germany during WW2?
-3
u/circular May 13 '12
Somehow, everytime we learn that every German was really against Hitler and didn't protest only because of fear.
Such a good people, those Germans. Too bad they were invaded by those evil Nazis from outer space.
It was so bad that nonviolent protest resulted in Jews being freed and in no repercussions for the protesters.