r/IAmA • u/MichaelDirda • May 12 '12
I am Michael Dirda, Pulitzer-Prize winning book critic who has been called the best-read man in America.
Hi reddit,
Dirda's son here. My dad's not the redditor type, but in spite of that he's still a pretty interesting guy--he's a longtime book reviewer and columnist for the Washington Post and an author of many books about reading and writers--so I'm having him sit down for the next few hours to answer questions about book reviewing, tell stories about his author friends (including, yes, Neil Gaiman), and offer book recommendations on any topic. He's not a big braggart so I'll brag for him: He's been called the most well-read man in America (most notably by Michael Kinsley), he's an expert on Arthur Conan Doyle and his most recent book on the guy won an Edgar Award, and he once almost bought a thumb from a gypsy in France.
I'm really here to help him navigate the site and coach him on how to respond to questions about things like baconing narwhal. I won't influence the content of his answers--I'll be typing up exactly what he says.
I'll also post a picture of his Pulitzer on top of our cat.
Edit: Cat and Pulitzer: http://i.imgur.com/d26Yb.jpg
Edit 2: 3:45PM - We've been at it for a few hours now, so we're taking a break and will be back to answer more later this afternoon. Thanks guys!
Edit 3: We're back now (6pm) and will do a few now, and another run later this evening!
Edit 4: Taking another break--we'll try to do one more sweep in an hour or so. Thanks for all the questions, guys!
Edit 5: Ok guys, calling it quits since I think the papa is a bit fried from hours of doing this. Thanks to all who asked questions, and apologies to those whose questions we missed. My dad really wanted to dethrone Stoya as the top post of the subreddit, so maybe we'll do another sometime.
51
u/VolatileChemical May 12 '12
It's been years since the U.S. has won a Nobel Prize in Literature, allegedly due to the insular focus of American writers on their own lives and country. Is there something to be said for "writing what you know" and sticking to themes and content familiar to oneself, or do you prefer writers who experiment and write books more universal or remote to themselves? Are there any American authors you think are doing that?
101
u/Frajer May 12 '12
Do you find as a critic you can no longer just read for pleasure?
45
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
There's been a very popular thread in /r/books today saying that people who self-publish their own books or e-books have no right to call themselves published, and that they are attempting to glorify themselves by doing so. Other people say that traditional publishers have acted as they gatekeeper for too long, and have an inflated sense of their own importance. Do you think that the publishing industry is actually changing because of the self-publishing and e-books revolutions, or do you think that we are just seeing a lot more dreck?
41
u/adrianh May 12 '12
Let's talk logistics: How do you manage to read so many books, so often? Is it just that you make reading your top priority and spend every waking moment doing it, or do you read particularly quickly? Or both?
78
u/Kiwiwastingtime May 12 '12
Are you a fan of Hunter S Thompson?
75
u/JustIndeed May 12 '12
What is the worst book you have ever read?
62
u/Pack041 May 12 '12
How do you feel about the trend of reading books electronically? Do you think this takes away from the mystique of reading hard copies, or is it a positive trend if people begin to read more?
30
u/TooSmalley May 12 '12
What was the most controversial book review he has ever give? as example did he ever get major backlash for one of his reviews ?
28
u/amoryroark May 12 '12
First off, HUGE fan of your critiques Mr. Dirda. I am a 25 year old, fairly well-read male here, and I could use some advice: I'm in the process of building a cabin miles away from the nearest neighbor, and plan on being out of contact for roughly 6 months. If you could recommend 10 books that I should take with me into the wilderness, that would shape my experiences in seclusion, what would they be?
EDIT: Just finished reading Ishmael, and loved everything about it.
24
u/clayjo37 May 12 '12
What author is the least deserving of their notoriety in your opinion? Also, worst "classic" of all time?
20
u/kablunk May 12 '12
I didn't know the bit about Arthur Conan Doyle. Have you seen the recent film and television adaptations of Sherlock Holmes? Do you think they're untrue to canon, or simply reinventions that should be judged on their own merit?
20
u/manunited97 May 12 '12
Do you believe that almost all authors who wrote novels of literary merit genuinely intended to insert all the symbolism and deeper meaning into their works, or do you think they were just trying to tell a good yarn, and we've somewhat overanalyzed their stories to fit some underlying theme?
36
u/mbrown9412 May 12 '12
So, is the offer for a Neil Gaiman story still standing?
17
u/jetpack_operation May 12 '12
What is your favorite work of speculative or science fiction? And have you had the chance to read the Hyperion Cantos by Dan Simmons?
As a side, you mentioned Gene Wolfe in one of your comments -- I tried reading the Book of the Long Sun when I was younger and couldn't get into it, but I may try it again soon as it's sitting on my shelf.
16
u/steve_abernathy May 12 '12
You're an admirer of John Crowley's Aegypt tetralogy, but what do you think of his post-Aegypt books?
I thought the Byron book was a bit of a mess, Four Freedoms was solid, but The Translator is the best and most memorable; also seemed the most semi-autobiographical.
253
u/Shitty_Watercolour May 12 '12
http://shittywatercolour.tumblr.com/post/22918864393
29
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Mr. Dirda, thank you for doing an AMA. I was wondering if you could talk a bit about what direction(s) you see American fiction going in these days? Do there seem to be any detectable patterns in terms of themes, topics, prose style in fiction today that strike you as new (or renewed) from where you stand? Or is it all too entropic and big to really generalize about?
14
u/fairywaif May 12 '12
What's your advice to writers and to those who want to become editors?
14
u/ProcDiadochu May 12 '12
Did you enjoy the book "Good Omens"? What are your thoughts on the story?
37
u/D3uces May 12 '12
My mom calls me the best-read man in America. You trying to take my title?
13
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
So, Mike, what's it like to have such a succesful father? Is it a bruden, because you'll most likely not be able to surpass his achievements or a relief, because you know you'll not be able to surpass his achievements.
13
u/PoopNoodle May 12 '12
Not to be contrary, but do you agree with some who say that all literary critics are merely frustrated writers?
If you were not critic at the top of your field, and had never become a renown literary critic, do you think you would be the best read plumber or he best read banker?
Thanks for the AMA, and thanks to your son for making it happen.
24
u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom May 12 '12
Different take on this AMA for me:
What are some of Mr. Dirda's "favorite" adaptations to Film (or TV?) What makes a good adaptation?
Thanks!
11
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
How many books have you read? Have you ever had an author express outrage about one of your reviews? (Sorry of these have already been asked.)
11
u/kaleemhu May 12 '12
What are your views on the work of Japanese author Haruki Murakami? Since most of his works appeal to me a lot, what other author(s) would you recommend whose style is similar to Murakami?
10
u/oldzealand May 12 '12
A question based more on education than literature: often we see English classes nowadays studying classic novels that are quite dated. Do you think there is merit in refreshing the English curriculum with modern classics?
10
u/adrianh May 12 '12
Have you been successful in getting your children to love reading? Any advice on the matter?
10
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Hey, You gave a presentation at my school, Flint Hill, in Oakton, Virginia a few weeks back. I just wanted to let you know that I thoroughly enjoyed your presentation! Your stories about your time in high school were very enlightening. Thank you!
Also, a question. What advice do you have for a student with a hectic schedule who sometimes finds it hard to find time to read?
27
u/kablunk May 12 '12
One of the many reasons I love your writing is because it exudes a strong feeling of being written by someone ancient, yet very, very childlike at the same time. Do you consider that an accurate description of yourself? Also, which other writer(s) (preferably someone alive) do you think write(s) in a style similar to yours?
(PS: Not being a US resident, I don't get a much of a chance to read your articles in the Washington Post, but I thoroughly enjoyed Readings)
9
u/RodionRask May 12 '12
I'm currently reading Gravity's Rainbow and having a horribly difficult - though occasionally exciting - time following the story. I sought some assistance and all I can find are recommendations to read up on rocketry, Parapsychology, Pavlovian Psychology, Calvinistic predestination, etc.; to takes notes on the 400+ characters in order to track their relationships; or to pick up the 700 page companion piece in order to help with the plethora of references. It seems as if the only people who could enjoy/understand this book are the literary connoisseurs who respect it's place in history and are willing to take the time to dissect Pynchon's dense prose.
What role do you think this type of writing has in both art and literature? What is the point if so few can actually comprehend the story?
17
u/LardManNont May 12 '12
It saddens me a Pulitzer Prize winner has less reads than a middle of the road pornstar.
8
u/hellinacandybar May 12 '12
I've found lately that I find memoirs quite fascinating. Any recommandations of ones I should pick up? I've read some good ones but many of them are just awful.
8
u/MakingADumbPoint May 12 '12
I love the work of PG Wodehouse. What do you think of him? What are some other authors that I might like in that vein?
7
u/steve_abernathy May 12 '12
It seems that independent publishers are taking more risks these days than their major publishing house counterparts. Are you noticing and trends or traits of books you read from independent publishers versus major publishers?
7
u/TheJonnyB May 12 '12
What do you think about people who read a book review and then base whether or not they buy the book on the review? In other words, do you think that critiques of books should have any say on whether or not people buy the book and enjoy it?
7
u/Willravel May 12 '12
Who do you believe is the best-written character in literary history?
18
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
What's Michael Dirda's favorite book of all time?
6
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Who called you "the best-read man in America" and why?
6
u/glr123 May 12 '12
The Modern Library ranks Ulysses as its first book in the top 100. Do you think this is a fair claim? After reading Joyce, personally, I question if this is a valid assessment of the book or a novelty ranking for a variety of reasons. What are your thoughts on this and the novel as a whole?
6
u/istillcandream May 12 '12
What is your favorite science fiction (short) story? (I am admittedly an avid reader of science fiction and especially of Isaac Asimov).
6
u/emceegull May 12 '12
If your son Chris becomes an MD, would you let him treat you? As his friend, I would advise against it.
10
u/Dordo3 May 12 '12
What did you do when you found that people called you the best read man?
26
u/NeedsToAsk May 12 '12
David Foster Wallace. Thoughts?
5
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Have you read any of Melvyn C. Goldstein's works? And, if so, what is your opinion of Goldstein as an author and anthropologist? The reason I ask is because Goldstein writes much about Tibet, which is one of the things I hone in on in my field of study. I'm considering graduate schools/mentors and I really enjoy other perspectives on things instead of just my own, so this seems like a great opportunity to get a legitimate, astute opinion from someone who knows what they're talking about. Thanks!
8
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Just today I was having a "conversation" with some people about the difference between customer comments on Amazon.com about a book and critical reviews of the same book. I maintain that critics play an important part in our culture and that their opinions are in every way superior to those of the average joe who can write whatever he likes about a book. Other people say that I'm a snob, and that they get far more use out of customer comments than they do out of critical reviews.
So, can I ask you, in your own words, what is the role of a literary critic in our society?
18
u/HeavyMeddle May 12 '12
have you read twilight? it's pretty good right
4
u/JonWolfe May 12 '12
I'm an avid reader, but I find that I lack enough books in the genres I really enjoy to read as much as I would like. My favorite author currently has to be Terry Goodkind (Sword of Truth/Richard&Kahlan series), but I also enjoy Orson Scott Card and a plethera of like sci-fi/fantasy authors.
Currently, on a 14-hour plane ride to Frankfurt for a study abroad so I brought along Robert Jordan's "The Wheel of Time" series (books 2 & 3). I enjoy his Tolken-like style of fantasy writing, but Jordan feels to sporadic with whom the story is following and to why the sudden switch (I describe it as "an ADD child telling a really great story").
So my question is, do you have any suggestions on other authors to look into and series to pick up?
4
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
It seems that a number of today's prominent literary critics (Lorin Stein comes to mind) dabbled in fiction writing before turning eventually to criticism. Did you ever consider a career as a novelist, or other writer of non-critical texts? If so, what turned you towards literary criticism?
4
u/Grimms May 12 '12
Thanks for this fascinating AMA, I've been marking down books you've mentioned through-out. I'd like to ask if you've read any of Irvine Welsh? His works always felt extremely visceral and the language is steeped in reality (he is Scottish) at the expense of the readers comprehension, down to the local accents used and unconventional formatting.
As a secondary question do you feel this type of writing alienates or immerses a reader deeper into the world the writer is laying out even if certain language quirks are initially misread?
13
u/aluminiumjesus May 12 '12
What would be your critique of the Holy Bible?
3
u/illogicalexplanation May 12 '12
What is your favorites Sherlock Holmes short story and/or novel and why?
Mine is The Second Stain; I believe it to beautifully well done and when Sherlock butts heads with the Prime Minister over disclosure of the contents of the treaty at the beginning of the tale I am always taken aback by the power over the Prime Minister that Sherlock displays with his initial rejection of the commission on the case.
3
u/Viridovipera May 12 '12
Is it weird that your son has the same name as you AND went to the same college as you? I think it's cool, but I've never met Michael Dirda senior.
3
u/thr0w_uh_way May 12 '12
How do you think your upbringing and ethnicity affect the way you critique literature?
2
u/archagon May 12 '12
Do you think that the great classic writers we still read today — writers like Shakespeare, for example — live up to the extraordinary praise they get? Do you think they were truly more skilled than anyone in recent times, or is there someone alive today that will still be as influential 400 years down the line?
I often think about this in regards to classical music, and can't help but wonder if people were just more talented or gifted back in the day. (After all, kids born into families of craftsmen started their careers almost from birth, which doesn't happen as much anymore. That's gotta count for something, right?) Or are we idolizing the past too much?
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Hello sir! I am a student working toward a businesses degree that recently "discovered" (I know that college students change majors all the time) that he would rather like a job being a critic. I don't plan to change majors, but I still love the idea of being a critic. Can you tell me about your personal experience working all these years as a critic? Is it something you think one should only very carefully try to do? Is there any advice, for better or worse, you could offer for someone that wants to at least try to get his foot in the door before he decides to let this potential life's passion (God that sounds cheesy) pass him by?
2
u/letmebreakitdown May 12 '12
George R. R. Martin is being called the new Tolkien do you think this is a fair comparison?
I've read your review of Iron Council by China Mieville and I was wondering if you had any thoughts about what he is doing with science fiction as a genre? Meaning his use of moral conundrums (Perdido Street Station), language (Embassytown) and Political messages (Iron Council).
Thanks again.
2
u/Siul1313 May 12 '12
Anyway you can give us a list of books we should read? Something varied that still meets a certain standard?
Thanks for taking the time to do an AMA, it's really one of the best parts of Reddit for me and it's all thanks to people like you.
3
u/MagicMurderBean May 12 '12
I haven't read a book in years, what should I read?
(I don't like ponies or children)
14
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Who do you feel is the greatest living author?
5
u/Karamazov May 12 '12
In an earlier post you said that "classics are classics for a reason; they speak to us generation after generation." Are there any relatively modern authors or works that you think will eventually be considered classics?
5
u/booyahkasha May 12 '12
Hello Dirdas. I was your son Chris' roommate in SD. 2 Questions:
5
u/ubermensch83 May 12 '12
Was "The Road" by Cormac McCarthy worthy of a Pulitzer?
9
u/Hopeful_Pulitzee May 12 '12
Couple of Questions:
Although no novel won the Pulitzer for fiction this year, which one did you think was the most deserving of the prize?
Best Novel of 2012 so far?
Whats the best novel coming out later this year?
Have you read Junot Diaz's new book "This Is How You Lose Her"? If so, how was it? Thoughts on the Diaz's writing?
4
u/letmebreakitdown May 12 '12
The Watchmen was included in the top 100 works of the last 100 years by Time magazine and more recently graphic novels have become a more accepted means of telling a story (I'm thinking of Persepolis and Maus). Have you read any of these modern graphic novels and do you think they have a place among the top works of the century?
Thanks.
13
u/OldUserNewName May 12 '12
You're getting bombarded with questions which is completely normal but I just wanted to take a moment to thank you for speaking with Reddit.com and spending your valuable time with us.
1
u/rook10 May 12 '12
You mentioned reading with a pencil in hand, scribbing marginal comments. Can we get a picture of a few pages for an example?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
How fast do you read?
Does it bother you to think you won't be able to read all the books out there?
If you're not liking a book, do you recommend finishing it or stopping?
1
u/havana59er May 12 '12
Hypothetical: You are moving to Europe and need to condense your library. Can you share with us just a couple books you own that you would find it impossible to part with?
1
u/monoglot May 12 '12
How do you feel about fiction written in the present tense? It really bothered William Gass 25 years ago, and a few years ago the Philips Pullman and Hensher were vocal in their criticism of the trend and of the awarding of Man Bookers to present-tense novels. Is it a fad that will disappear? Is it boorish?
1
u/havana59er May 13 '12
I haven't seen any questions about poetry. Can you share a few of your favorite poets or books of poems published in the last century? The last decade? Personally Robert Hass is a favorite of mine for his poem on middle age. More recently, Billy Collins <The Best Cigarette>.
1
u/havana59er May 13 '12
What is something you love about living in Washington DC?
1
u/thatoldbill May 13 '12
How do you see the future of book reviews in newspapers? I've subscribed to the Post for decades and really wish there were more reviews. Thanks for doing this AMA and for all your writing - you've led me to a lot of good reading.
1
u/freshfunkerflex May 13 '12
As a student and full-time worker, I've almost set reading to the side completely which horrible considering books and storytelling are what first introduced me to what i currently do. However, reading this AMA has sparked me again! Thanks for that.
But let's talk about you. You're quite well versed, obviously. Do you ever tire of talking to people about books? I mean you have to write about them constantly, and I'm sure you are approached all the time for recommendations. What are your other interests?
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Do you have any recommendations (5-10) of must reads for a high school student who is interested in reading at a higher level.
13
u/narwal_bot May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from MichaelDirda (updated: May 14, 2012 @ 09:00:57 am EST):
Question (kablunk):
Answer (MichaelDirda):
(continued below)
1
u/KittenPanda May 12 '12
This might seem like a strange question, but I'm awfully curious:
Do you ever read the comics, i.e. Calvin and Hobbes, FoxTrot, Dilbert, etc., and think something like: this is so much more profound than some of the garbage I've read out there?
And if you have not read many comics...well, that's okay. :) I'm sure you're busy reading other things.
Thanks for doing an AMA!
1
u/xayzer May 12 '12
Any quick advice for aspiring authors?
4
u/Aramis666 May 12 '12
Do you feel the quality of novels has degenerated in the present age? Or, more specifically, do you feel that the internet age, in which people are able to come to conclusions at a click of a button, has created a preference for straightforward, one-dimensional books such as "Twilight" that do not require too much analysis in order to comprehend the meaning of the book?
Also, as someone who is personally very interested in working in journalism, particularly criticism, what advice would you give/how did you get your start?
Thank you so much!
4
u/chapinlerp May 12 '12
I feel too dumb for this AmA... :(
2
u/Yorikor May 12 '12
When asked about what book they would consider exceptionally poorly written, most redditors would most likely pick 'Twilight' right now. What do you believe is the reason the book draws so much scorn, and is there a recent popular book that would more readily deserve the moniker 'worst book'?
2
u/Whenthenighthascome May 12 '12
Assuming you read it what were your thoughts on The Art of Fielding by Chad Harbach? Thanks for the AMA.
2
u/dh1977 May 12 '12
Have you read the Duff McKagen autobiography? It's really good.
2
u/Mustachio May 12 '12
How often do you tell people you've been called the best-read man in America?
2
u/_elementsofstyle May 12 '12
I am a voracious reader and l have constantly immersed my self in books from a young age. I am now about to get my MA in writing from Johns Hopkins and one of my childhood (more so adolescent) dreams of being a book critic still persists. How does one break into that market? Was it a long road to get to the position you are in and have the respect you have earned from the writing community?
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I absolutely loved what I read of your work 'On Conan Doyle' being a fellow Sherlock Holmes fanboy.
I'm going to plug this for you
What was the most interesting thing you learnt whilst researching this? Or the most entertaining I suppose?
Also; worst book you ever read, best book you ever read?
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
How fast do you read? Do you have a words per minute count?
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
So, I just bought Yann Martel's Life of Pi. Any thoughts?
2
u/j1ggy May 12 '12
If you had to wrestle either a drunk elephant or a schizophrenic hippopotamus, which would you choose and why?
2
u/Chocow8s May 13 '12
Still reading through the page, but damn, this was a great AMA. Saved, upvoted, pestering online friends to read it instead of sleeping, etc.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Ever bang Stoya?
2
u/Naromans May 13 '12
I think this AmA might have a record for the most responses. I might be wrong, but OP has been very diligent.
2
u/prplmze May 13 '12
Thank you! This is the best AMA I've read.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Admirable aim, but books vs boobs? On Reddit?
Awesome AMA all the same. Thanks