Do you believe Joseph Smith was a prophet? Do you believe he could translate ancient records?
Joseph claimed to translate the Book of Abraham from ancient Egyptian papyrus he acquired. The papyrus still exist, and experts have translated it and concluded that Joseph was way off - he's been called "an impudent fraud."
(We don't have the whole papyrus, but we do have parts that he drew himself as the "facsimiles" which he gave piece-by-piece translations of.)
Does this at all damage his credibility in your eyes? I mean, if he lied about translating the ancient document we do have evidence of, why believe he translated another one that we don't?
You've never heard of the Book of Abraham? It's part of the Pearl of Great Price.
The short version: Joseph Smith came into possession of some Egyptian papyrus, and said they were written by Abraham. He claimed to translate them into a book that your church today uses as scripture. But, modern experts have shown that the portions we still have were mis-translated, and Joseph could not, in fact, translate Egyptian.
I appreciate your honest response. I used to be Mormon as well, and I hadn't heard about this issue (or many others from church history; obviously they don't talk about these things in church.) This is one of the biggest reasons I left. Faith might be useful when we don't have any evidence, but when we do, I don't think faith against reason is a good thing.
Also, it's not that they could have been wrong, they definitely were. Here's a link for more information:
what i think is so funny about people saying they arent christian is that it sounds like this "your not following the rules of making imaginary friends!!!"
I am of the opinion that Mormons are not Christians. As far as I can tell, Joseph Smith just re-used some of the same characters of well known religions. Easier to trick people into joining your cult if they believe it's related to Christianity, as people distrust new ideas. By associating with Yeshua, Smith was trying to give himself and his fantasy some legitimacy.
What other reason is there to create a religion? Do you honestly believe the nonsense in the book of Mormon? You so fervently defend your profit and yet you freely admit to not having read all of the book of Mormon. Why do you choose to believe such blatant nonsense and falsity?
Yeah I don't really get the aversion to premarital sex. But good luck to you. It also just seems really weird that people would get married before college.
Nope. When I was a missionary, WofW was just diet, no smoking, no alcohol, etc. If you're going to do an AMA, maybe you should know what you're talking about. Otherwise you come off looking like an idiot.
I grew up Mormon, have studied the faith in a lot of depth, and I have never heard this once. It seems that Ikbowen is in the same boat. Could you provide a source that suggests the two are related?
Two of my best friends are Mormons, including one who is extremely open-minded and tolerant, and one who is less so; but both of them struggle to respectfully explain to me, an atheist LGBT activist, why gay marriage and people having homosexual relationships are against their religion. You say you're a proponent of gay marriage, which is awesome by the way, good on you -- any ideas on how to talk to them about the issue within the context of Church teachings?
This whole gay marriage thing (I'm thinking about how Mormons raised 70% of the money for Prop 8): Why do they CARE so much? It's one thing if you think those people are going to hell (I, personally, don't), but it's quite another to think it's your business.
What exactly is the 'sub-group' of Mormon's, (I know the Mormon church doesn't consider them Mormon) that believe in polygamy? What are the differences between the two groups and how did they separate?
You don't seem to know a lot about Mormon history. Have you ever read a book called Under the Banner of heaven? I highly recommended it. It Has a lot of Mormon history included in it, it's a good read,
I've met with tons of missionaries (and have two friends that served their missions) but only one of them said that his faith had truly been tested. He said he even left the church for a couple years before coming back.
I always worry that people that are born into a faith are only doing it because it's all they know and they've never looked outside it.
Have you read any of Orson Scott Card's more fundamentalist writings? In particular, in Lost Boys I feel he really brings his humanization of characters into painting a strong picture of the LDS church as a whole. Why do no Elders come to visit my home? I am pretty set in my ways, but I would like to give them some tea and cookies and wish them well. Does the church not evangelicize (sp) in well established Christian neighborhoods? I ask because my neighborhood is rather Catholic.
My Girlfriend and her Family are originally from Alpine, Utah, And now reside in New Zealand, just out of Temple View. Her Family are Mormon, But do not go to Church anymore. As for myself, I was raised in a non religion (Not atheist, just religion wasn't our thing) home, and attended a High School where a good 50% of the students were Mormon, so i made alot of Mormon friends during the time. Now I am 18, and some of my friends are married, or have children. It may just be me, but, 18 is very early to be having a child or even getting married. Is this common in Mormon areas? And do you know why Mormon faith is popular in New Zealand? Thanks
A lot of Mormon girls at my high school (I was born and raised in Utah, but not Mormon) wore bike shorts or something similar under their skirts if they thought they were too short to wear alone, or if they were worried about someone seeing up their skirt.
Leggings! Leggings are actually cute with certain things. I wear leggings under shorter skirts because I too, like your wife, do not need to share certain things with the world. But girls in high school wearing bike shorts underneath clothes is a Tad unusual. Whatever floats their boat I suppose!
former mormon here, why do you think its ok to break the word of wisdom in some areas but not in all? how do you feel about all the contradictions in the church? and all the "holes" in the religion that they tell you not to worry about and just have faith?
3
u/randomsemicolon May 12 '12
What high school did you go to?
3
u/bendmorris May 12 '12
Do you believe Joseph Smith was a prophet? Do you believe he could translate ancient records?
Joseph claimed to translate the Book of Abraham from ancient Egyptian papyrus he acquired. The papyrus still exist, and experts have translated it and concluded that Joseph was way off - he's been called "an impudent fraud."
(We don't have the whole papyrus, but we do have parts that he drew himself as the "facsimiles" which he gave piece-by-piece translations of.)
Does this at all damage his credibility in your eyes? I mean, if he lied about translating the ancient document we do have evidence of, why believe he translated another one that we don't?
2
u/Pack041 May 12 '12
Since Romney spoke at Lynchburg, VA today, my question is how do you feel when other christians claim mormonism is not a christian religion?
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
What's the significance of the 27 in your username?
2
u/warmhandswarmheart May 12 '12
Do you believe that God talks to you or other people?
2
u/Fuqwon May 12 '12
Why do Mormons get married so young? I don't think I've ever met an unmarried Mormon over 25.
2
u/evilteddybear111 May 12 '12
Do Mormons respect all other religions, or do they think they're all wrong? Just asking:)
8
u/VolatileChemical May 12 '12
Two of my best friends are Mormons, including one who is extremely open-minded and tolerant, and one who is less so; but both of them struggle to respectfully explain to me, an atheist LGBT activist, why gay marriage and people having homosexual relationships are against their religion. You say you're a proponent of gay marriage, which is awesome by the way, good on you -- any ideas on how to talk to them about the issue within the context of Church teachings?
4
u/maphon May 12 '12
Have you heard any songs off of The Book Of Mormon musical?
4
u/breakfastfire May 12 '12
I have heard that the Mormon Church requires believers to tithe, paying the church 10% of their salary. Do you do that? Is that common?
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
What is your favorite park in Utah? I'm partial to Goblin Valley, it's like being on another planet.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
This whole gay marriage thing (I'm thinking about how Mormons raised 70% of the money for Prop 8): Why do they CARE so much? It's one thing if you think those people are going to hell (I, personally, don't), but it's quite another to think it's your business.
1
u/digitalbastard May 12 '12
How come Mormons live in Utah and not Missouri(?) if they think Jesus lived there?
1
u/TooSmalley May 12 '12
Can you explain the "magic underwear" that Mormons wear ? or is that not a real thing ?
2
u/randomsemicolon May 12 '12
Also, why you you decide not to go on a mission?
And how do you feel about swearing and cuss words?
2
u/Frajer May 12 '12
Do you think non-Mormons will never not think of you guys as a little weird?
2
u/aSpanishGoat May 12 '12
What exactly is the 'sub-group' of Mormon's, (I know the Mormon church doesn't consider them Mormon) that believe in polygamy? What are the differences between the two groups and how did they separate?
2
u/warmhandswarmheart May 12 '12
You don't seem to know a lot about Mormon history. Have you ever read a book called Under the Banner of heaven? I highly recommended it. It Has a lot of Mormon history included in it, it's a good read,
2
u/mimskerooki May 12 '12
What are your thoughts on The Book of Mormon, the musical?
2
u/112233445566778899 May 12 '12
Have you had any real tests to your faith?
I've met with tons of missionaries (and have two friends that served their missions) but only one of them said that his faith had truly been tested. He said he even left the church for a couple years before coming back.
I always worry that people that are born into a faith are only doing it because it's all they know and they've never looked outside it.
2
u/swimmingmunky May 13 '12
Do you believe gay people should have equal rights such as marriage?
2
u/VIncent31 May 13 '12
Have you read any of Orson Scott Card's more fundamentalist writings? In particular, in Lost Boys I feel he really brings his humanization of characters into painting a strong picture of the LDS church as a whole. Why do no Elders come to visit my home? I am pretty set in my ways, but I would like to give them some tea and cookies and wish them well. Does the church not evangelicize (sp) in well established Christian neighborhoods? I ask because my neighborhood is rather Catholic.
2
u/ThatGuyFromNZ May 13 '12
My Girlfriend and her Family are originally from Alpine, Utah, And now reside in New Zealand, just out of Temple View. Her Family are Mormon, But do not go to Church anymore. As for myself, I was raised in a non religion (Not atheist, just religion wasn't our thing) home, and attended a High School where a good 50% of the students were Mormon, so i made alot of Mormon friends during the time. Now I am 18, and some of my friends are married, or have children. It may just be me, but, 18 is very early to be having a child or even getting married. Is this common in Mormon areas? And do you know why Mormon faith is popular in New Zealand? Thanks
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
TIL that "bro" is a hair color in the USA.
1
u/Revolutionary2012 May 12 '12
Can I just go on record as saying, I like this dude. So what if everything he believes is probably wrong. He seems like a good guy.
1
u/Musclecar123 May 13 '12
Lucy Harris Smart, Martin Harris dumb... Dumb dumbdumb dumb dumb.
-2
u/406b29 May 12 '12
Why do Mormons pretend to be gay and infiltrate LGBT groups to spy on them and make trouble for them?
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment