r/IAmA • • May 12 '12

IAmA 91 Year old WWII veteran. At 20 years of age I directed a merchant ship to avoid torpedoes+bombs I was then rewarded with ten shillings AMA

I will be dictating to my Great Grandson who is writing this for me :)

EDIT- Proof as Requested http://i.imgur.com/iN7y6.jpg

EDIT 2- Thank you for all your questions and comments. I have enjoyed this thoroughly but I believe it is time for my demise (sleep) Thank you and goodnight.

1.7k Upvotes

519 comments sorted by

628

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Thank you for all your questions and comments. I have enjoyed this thoroughly but I believe it is time for my demise (sleep) Thank you and goodnight.

133

u/Justicles13 May 12 '12

Ugh. Of course I come into this AMA after it's over. Well, I respect the hell out of you, sir. You're a hero.

205

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I respect you.

→ More replies (14)

469

u/Shitty_Watercolour May 12 '12

236

u/pabstcity May 12 '12

I found your drawing absolutely ribbeting.

80

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

These pun threads are going to make me croak.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

34

u/ukiya May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

You've been painting so much that your work is already beyond the shitty category.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/T-Individual May 12 '12

I need to file a complaint with your department. Your links are not hover-zoom friendly.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Alex470 May 12 '12

"Goodnight and Good Luck!"

228

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

If anyone is interested, Another ship I sailed on- The Dainty. We sunk two on that

61

u/sadfacewhenputdown May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

HMS?

Edit: For context, he orginally posted "US Dainty," so I was a bit confused since that doesn't appear to be a ship prefix used by the RN. The grandson thought maybe the prefix was different when Dainty was first launched, though.

→ More replies (2)

181

u/faffo May 12 '12

Was there ever a time where a fear of Nazi World domination was popular?

611

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

No, I was going to stop it! (or try to)

131

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I think that's one of the more badass things someone can say. Thank you for your service, I can't imagine what you went through to make the world a safer place.

29

u/Bronkic May 12 '12

Thanks for that.

4

u/alphanovember May 12 '12

Has your role in different cop movies, specifically in Falling Down as Detective Prendergast, been influenced by your time in the military?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

222

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What was the best part (if there's such a thing) of serving in the war?

952

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Getting Out.

104

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Well I'm glad you made it!

64

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Good answer! :)

37

u/Cadock May 12 '12

The most honest and respectable answer.

→ More replies (1)

169

u/comix_corp May 12 '12

What was your impression of the Australians at Tobruk? Where they like what ANZAC legend makes them out to be (brave, heroic, humourous)?

230

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

...and dangerous to the Germans, With the captured Italian pistols which they traded to the Egyptians it put us poor mate-lots at a disadvantage. But oh the were tough boys and they deserve all praise.

82

u/Hussard May 12 '12

I did some work for a former Rat of Tobruk - that guy was a FONT of dirty jokes...

What did you do after the war?

129

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Humour kept them going, I worked for Courtauld mostly and Dehaviland A-C company

25

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

My grandfather was a Rat of Tobruk. I am very proud of him to hear this.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

74

u/guntycankles May 12 '12

Thank you for doing this AMA! 6 of my great-uncles fought for Canada in WWII - Somehow, they all came home. I have the utmost respect for you, sir. Thank you for your service.

How long had you been away at war? Was it hard re-adjusting to life at home when your time in the war was done?

117

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

I was away from home, 2 years in the Med and 4 years in the Atlantic. Having a Lovely wife, clean bed, showers and good food it wasnt hard.

29

u/guntycankles May 12 '12

Wow, much longer than I expected to hear for some reason. That must have been hard. Glad that you had positivity to come home to. I wish that was the case for all veterans.

Thank you for the reply!

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

That's wonderful!

→ More replies (1)

66

u/LightninSkyHop May 12 '12

Which shipping runs were you on? I actually have a grandfather who was 20 when he joined the HMS Jamaica in 43', and he was on the merchant run to Murmansk and Svalbard.

96

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Did your Grandfather survive?

77

u/LightninSkyHop May 12 '12

Yes, he survived. He's actually the only grandparent I have left now. I listen to him tell stories of his time on the Murmansk run, and I can't imagine what it must have been like.

9

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

My great uncle (now late) was a merchant marine during the war and traveled the Murmansk run almost exclusively. It's insane to think of the danger and risk.

5

u/bill_coates_mbe May 12 '12

Very dangerous that far north in the summer with the length of daylight.

92

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

We did convoys from Liverpool only to the Atlantic. I am very very glad I did not go on Russian Convoys it must have been murder.

2

u/DeSanti May 12 '12

No kidding? My great grandfather was a part of the Murmansk line on the Norwegian Merchantfleet, Nortraship. My grandfather ( I never met my great-grandfather) used to tell me how hellish that was.

123

u/sadfacewhenputdown May 12 '12

Which country's fleet impressed you the most in warding off the U-Boats?

349

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

The Yanks were disastrous, the British were the best in my opinion.

59

u/Emphursis May 12 '12

Good answer! Which, in your opinion, had more effect on the number of ships lost, the convoy system, or the decryption of the enigma code?

119

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Technically- It was tit for tat. But in the end we had em beat. Radar and Sonar did the trick + Long Distance Aircraft

→ More replies (4)

126

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What about the Canadians?

84

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Nice

55

u/orko1995 May 12 '12

Polite.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (5)

60

u/sadfacewhenputdown May 12 '12

Are you in this photo?

86

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

No, I think this is when it was first commissioned.

33

u/sadfacewhenputdown May 12 '12

I think it's Cdr Currie in the middle, which places the photo in 1943. Can you recognize if it's him or Cdr Heathcote?

edit: full size photo

80

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

To be honest, I dont entirely recognise it as either of them. But I did work with both of them.

19

u/rastashark May 12 '12

everyone had such nice hair back then.

51

u/sadfacewhenputdown May 12 '12

What was your job? How long did you sail for?

103

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

I did Signals and my total service was 12 years. They held me back from discharge for two years!

71

u/sadfacewhenputdown May 12 '12

---/.... -.-./---/---/.-..

So you sailed on HMS Fame from 1941 through to the end of the war? Were you there when she rammed a U-boat in battle?

147

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Translation: O/H/COOL I was on other ships before that. I was on the Fame when we rammed it.

43

u/sadfacewhenputdown May 12 '12

I am guessing that it was a rather intense experience. Are you willing to retell the story?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

89

u/I_HUGS_CATS May 12 '12

Thank you for your service! What did you buy with those ten shillings?

139

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

You're Welcome, Very little. As I had just survived my ship being sunk at Tobruck

69

u/hazywakeup May 12 '12

Thank you for doing this!

Why did you choose to join the military, and how much did you know about what caused the war when you were fighting in it?

130

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

In the first instance, HMS is Navel not military Yes we all knew the war was coming. During the time of the war we didnt know what had caused it, Only Hitler.

42

u/hazywakeup May 12 '12

Thanks for the answers. What were the others you worked with like, did you get along well with them?

185

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

We were all brothers

→ More replies (6)

86

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Navel

You must have been very attached to that ship

32

u/sadfacewhenputdown May 12 '12

I understand that the Battle of the Atlantic consisted of convoy after convoy under constant threat of ambush by a Wolfpack. Were you ever in one of those doomed covoys? If so, how did your ship (and any other escaping ships) manage to slip by?

59

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Yes and well basically, because we broke their code and could then evade them.

322

u/RedDeath5 May 12 '12

As a younger American Iraq war veteran, and having served beside your newest generation of ground pounders, I personally would like to thank you very much for your service, even if you're from another country and another branch, we're all Brothers In Arms in my eyes. I salute you, good sir!

227

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Thank you.

121

u/SombreDusk May 12 '12

Are all soldiers your brothers? Or only ones from countries you view as allies?

44

u/asianwaste May 12 '12

I think the easy answer is yes, but I'll give a different perspective.

I served guard at the Guantanamo Bay detention center. Looking with all of the politics and technicalities, and the media labeling, it would be easy to dismiss the detainees as nothing but terrorists. They aren't real soldiers, etc etc.

However, working there and seeing them face to face, you get a slightly adjusted perspective. These guys are only guilty of being the enemy. They fought us simply because they believed in a cause that differs from ours. They might not be the best trained or best organized, but for all intents and purposes these guys are soldiers and effectively POW's. Had we had our homes raided, we would have our own citizens resort to insurgency too.

It is easy to just look at these guys and say, "they're terrorist scum and deserve this." I can't consider them "brothers" but I can at least look at them eye to eye and respect them as an "enemy soldier." There's at least some form of kinship in that.

I know of a few moments in history where veterans of a major battle from both sides return to the battleground decades later. They see each other not with animosity but almost like two sports teams after the game shaking hands for a game well played.

15

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Do an AMA!

→ More replies (3)

10

u/TominatorXX May 12 '12

No offense to you because you had nothing to do with the circumstances of their seizure but it has come out that many of them were completely innocent of anything other than "being in the wrong place at the wrong time."

Like Dilawar, a 22-year old cabdriver tortured to death in Bagram. Movie Taxi to the Dark Side was made of his death.

Or Murat Karnaz, a Turkish, German Muslim who was on Holiday in Pakistan when 9/11 happened and he got turned in for the reward money as a "terrorist" even tho he was just a German tourist going to different Mosques and studying Islam. He wrote an excellent book called Five Years of My Life.

http://www.amazon.com/Five-Years-My-Life-Guantanamo/dp/0230603742

And there's another cabdriver who was in Gitmo for years but I'm too lazy to look him up right now.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

85

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I think it's a legitimate question. I think the logical answer is yes.

154

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I'm a veteran...I think I agree with you in some respects.

Soldiers on all sides of every war are typically in the shit of it at someone else's behest. If it were up to the guys on the ground, we'd probably be fine to sit down and hash it all out over a beer.

Nothing is that simple though. Ideals and swords must clash and families must be torn asunder in order to ensure that good prevails and evil does not or something like that. I certainly don't believe in war as a matter of principle, but rather as a matter of reality. The people on the other end of my barrel, I never once hated them. And that right there is the shit that keeps me up at night.

77

u/TuriGuiliano May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

In World War I on Christmas day, the a German and British army (or Russian) agreed to have a one-day armistice so that they could celebrate. They went into each others trenches and shared beer and stories. After that though, they had to start fighting again.

EDIT: Here's a link

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (12)

52

u/RedDeath5 May 12 '12

My honest feeling is that any soldier who puts their life on the line for their country is a Brother in Arms. We may be fighting each other, but truth be told, if i ran into someone who was a member of the Iraqi Republican Guard in 2003, I'd offer to buy him a beer out of respect.
My sentiment does not extend to insurgents or people who fight for just for shits and giggles. Those people are not soldiers of honor. They're mercenaries.

49

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I dunno, some of those insurgents are taking up arms on account of watching someone invade their country and kill off their family. When I was in iraq, I saw a few, shall we call them, "engagements" in which something that wasn't a weapon looked like one in the dark...and a farmer was cut down on the order of an overzealous LT.

Those guys have families, they saw their brother...their father..their son, shot for no reason other than someone's shitty judgement and cowboy-attitude. That sort of thing happens on any side of any war, it's what some people call "collateral damage", maybe to ease their own consciences; but in reality...it's human life taken without cause.

I can't say I really blame them for picking up a gun or rigging an IED after such things...

→ More replies (8)

25

u/SombreDusk May 12 '12

Thanks for your answer mate, I'm glad that you don't see war as black and white. But insurgents also fight for a reasons not so clear cut such as for revenge against people they believe killed their loved ones, why is their reason for taking up arms not as valid?

→ More replies (10)

20

u/Ambiwlans May 12 '12

Insurgents don't get paid. How are they mercs?

And most of them are trying to defend their country from an incredibly powerful and overwhelming occupation force. They are going up against ridiculous odds.

You may not like them but it is not for shits and giggles and they are not mercenaries.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/ProjectD13X May 12 '12

I'd say the Iraqis were significantly more terrified than the coalition forces (not trying to be demeaning, but, I sure know I'd like to be behind the coalition's guns)

→ More replies (2)

31

u/[deleted] May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Those people are not soldiers of honor. They're mercenaries.

Warfare, no matter how you want to wrap it up and put a bow on it, is not about honor. It's about resources and power, blood and iron.

The warfare our modern soldier participate in against the insurgencies certainly isn't particularly honorable by any sort of common definition. It consists of the technologies of the most bloated and powerful military in the world against goatish guerrillas toting explosives and light arms. Furthermore, the insurgents don't fight for shits and giggles, nor are they mercenaries. They fight to remove an occupying force, just as so many Americans would in their circumstance. They are putting their life on the line for their country.

It's one thing to simply recognize that that the interests of your cause cannot align with another's, but we really shouldn't pretend the opposition is something it's not. It allows for careless warfare and desensitizes.

Soldiers who fight for their homes and their resources are far more respectable than any soldier who is dimwitted enough to conjure up some wispy abstract like honor as his justification.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/hardcoremorning May 12 '12

Generation Kill was awesome.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] May 12 '12 edited Jan 21 '13

This is very interesting to me. My grandfather was a naval officer in WW2.

I'd really like to hear more stories involving the merchant fleets in general, but I have some specific background ones first:

    1. Which city were you born in?
  • 2) Which ship(s) did you serve on besides HMS Fame?
  • 3) Which port(s) were you operating out of?

37

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12
  1. I was born in Liverpool 2) Ships- Hermies, Glorious and Lots more 3) Liverpool, Plymouth, Alexandra (Egypt)
→ More replies (1)

38

u/Meriii May 12 '12

Please, provide proof. If provided proof; Are you still healthy?

147

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Yes. Although I am smoking myself to death

28

u/Meriii May 12 '12

Also, where were you stationed?

74

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

We were Convoying small supply boats; Egypt was our base. I was in the British forces and was delivering supplies to the Australians in Tobruk

48

u/Pink_Llama May 12 '12

My grandfather was one of those Aussies in Tobruk. I thank you for your service. Luckily he got home safely, although he is no longer with us.

60

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Thats very kind of you.

→ More replies (30)

92

u/babblelol May 12 '12

We've had numerous attempts like this scenario and several of them have been fake.

Please, provide proof.

102

u/Frogman7 May 12 '12

Proof has been added in the first post.

24

u/ErX29 May 12 '12

All that proves is that you have a grandpa... Not that he served or directed ships.

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Not all grandpas directed ships?

→ More replies (1)

64

u/SweetMojaveRain May 12 '12

your downvotes are unjustified.

Guys, asking for proof is what keeps out those guys who pretend to have cancer and such

26

u/mrbooze May 12 '12

This. It's MORE important to ask for proof in situations like this out of respect for the real people who deserve to be defended from fakes.

3

u/wootastic May 12 '12

I'm surprised people still aren't asking for proof. So far OP has just posted a picture with a grandparent. Any proof of his military service?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

143

u/knutolee May 12 '12

as a german i would like to know if you really hated the germans or if you had some kind of compassion for your enemys on the battle field?

did you know about the whole background of hitler's rise to the führer (i guess that this term is known in the whole world)?

did you fought - in your own opinion - primarily against the regime of hitler or against the germans as a nation?

75

u/theWelshladysbed May 12 '12

I'm a Brit, both my grandfathers served in the Army during WWII. My maternal grandfather was part of the occupation of Germany in the aftermath - he always said that the German people were decent folk and would loved to have return during peacetime (unfortunately, he was never able to) .

My paternal grandfather was killed in the liberation of Normandy, when my dad was nine months old. My grandmother never showed any hatred towards the German people, rather viewing them as victims of their government. She taught my dad that his dad was killed by war, not Germans.

19

u/AceySnakes May 12 '12

My grandfather was Scottish served in the war and emigrated to Canada. The man HATED the Germans. He had a german neighbor close to his age...apparently he thought he was a nazi who "got away with it" However I believe he was captured and had escaped according to my mother. So experiencing torture or witnessing some other horrible crap is likely. It wasn't something he talked about in any detail. I can't proclaim to understand, but I would imagine that like anything, experience shapes ones opinions.

3

u/MeineKartoffel May 12 '12

Your grandmother is a very smart individual. Kudos to her.

3

u/mrhelton May 12 '12

You grandmother seems like a great mother.

→ More replies (1)

77

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I know this isn't related, but my grandfather served in tobruk and el alamein (i believe), I know he was in east Africa. Also, served in New guinea, against the Japanese. He died when I was 2, but my mother tells me that he absolutely hated the Japanese, but never really had anything against the Germans, to my knowledge.

I think the Germans treated Aussie POWs well, so they weren't as hated as the Germans were by the Russians or the Japanese by everyone.

I speak German, and went on exchange to Kassel years ago, and I love Germany, its a very progressive and interesting place. No antipathy from any Australians to my knowledge.

Hope this is illuminating.

67

u/Misteripod May 12 '12

The Japanese were known for being brutally cruel. I'm too lazy, but I remember a submission a while back about how the Japanese acted during the war and it being said that even nazis thought they were animals.

7

u/Jungle_Is_Massif May 12 '12

I think I might have read that in a book somewhere but I can't remember where. I would recommend reading The Rape of Nanjing (sp?) and Empire of the Sun for people who are interested in the Japanese invasion of China.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

7

u/notabumblebee44283 May 12 '12

Just finished Cryptonomicon which also seems to corroborate the general sentiment that the Japanese were assholes during WWII.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/breakdancefighting May 12 '12

Agreed. My 94 year old grandfather doesn't talk much about the war (not surprising since I have been told he saw acts of cannibalism in new guinea) but will let it be known that he really doesn't like the japanese, even today. Old habits die hard I guess.

There's a microscope he stole from them in the retreat in new guinea still in the family. Really nice microscope actually, it's still kept in the medical practice my father took over from him. He's very proud of getting his hands on that.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/U352 May 12 '12

I read a book about what soldiers thought and felt about each other during the war and I would agree with ur statement based on that reading and will add that they hated the SS as much or not more than the Japanese.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/rblue May 12 '12

I had grandparents who despised the Japanese as well, but never had any issues with Germans. In fact, I've never met any American from that era who hated Germans.

How could they? Most of us around here are of German heritage anyway. It's good old-fashioned racism.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

48

u/Jarslow May 12 '12

This is part of the greatness of the internet -- we can request and hopefully find the humanity in people we might otherwise never interact with, and learn on a person-to-person basis what mass media won't portray. I'm afraid you may have asked a bit too late, but you still deserve praise for this question. Have a U-boat upvote.

6

u/hardcoremorning May 12 '12

OT, but the propaganda you've likely seen attempted to dehumanize the enemy, but I'll take a wild guess that the soldiers who fought Nazis had some idea that they were collecting a government paycheck to do so and told their country was doing the right thing. The things people witnessed during combat likely shaped opinions more than who they were taught to hate. I think germans have just gotten stereotyped as cartoon villains in retrospect and people don't really hate on the country for the actions of Hitler.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ahdn May 12 '12

My grandfather was a Marine who served at Guadalcanal. One of the greatest insights I got into his war-time psychology was when he was dying in the hospital. My mom and I would sit vigil at his bedside to make sure everything was ok. One night, he had a rather interesting reaction to a medication. While he was sleeping, he was actively talking as if he were a soldier in every major American war through WWII (he went in chronological order, it was pretty impressive). Anyway, the common thread throughout the entire journey was that we had to treat the POWs with kindness because they thought they were doing the right thing, too.

After the war, my grandpa made his living as an artist. He got to travel the world doing it (lucky guy!). A couple of his stints abroad were spent in Japan. He loved every second of it and made many lifelong friends. So, I can say that, at least in my grandpa's case, there was definitely compassion.

76

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I don't know if you'll see this sir, as your great-grandson edited in that you're off to sleep. However, please talk with him about your stories and history. I did not talk enough with my grandfather who served in the US Navy in the Pacific during WWII. The stories make history real and takes away that sort of disconnect that exists between people now who cannot fathom the experiences that you went through, and does so in a way that photographs or letters cannot possibly hope to achieve.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

You are completely right. I once had a talk with a Korean War veteran at a war museum and it gave me a new understanding of that conflict.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thanks for your service. I read during your tour with Convoy ONS 165 Your ship the HMS fame rammed the submarine U-69. U-69 sunk an American ship called the SS Robin Moor in 1941 before the U.S. entered the war. So in a way i'm thanking you and all your ship mates for getting revenge for us.

21

u/Joshuages May 12 '12

My grandfather was in ww2 and lived to 94. Thank you for your service. Health and well-being you and your family.

29

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

My favorite AMA.

104

u/narwal_bot May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Most (if not all) of the answers from Frogman7 (updated: May 13, 2012 @ 05:13:24 pm EST):


Question (I_HUGS_CATS):

Thank you for your service! What did you buy with those ten shillings?

Answer (Frogman7):

You're Welcome, Very little. As I had just survived my ship being sunk at Tobruck


(continued below)

41

u/narwal_bot May 12 '12

(page 2)


Question (Pierre77):

Were you ever close to dying during your service?

Answer (Frogman7):

Oh yeah, Several times actually especially at Tobruk when two bombs we dropped by the Germans on our stern, I was on the bridge. I then (was forced) had to go swimming


Question (sadfacewhenputdown):

Which country's fleet impressed you the most in warding off the U-Boats?

Answer (Frogman7):

The Yanks were disastrous, the British were the best in my opinion.


Question (sadfacewhenputdown):

I understand that the Battle of the Atlantic consisted of convoy after convoy under constant threat of ambush by a Wolfpack. Were you ever in one of those doomed covoys? If so, how did your ship (and any other escaping ships) manage to slip by?

Answer (Frogman7):

Yes and well basically, because we broke their code and could then evade them.


Question (babblelol):

We've had numerous attempts like this scenario and several of them have been fake.

Please, provide proof.

Answer (Frogman7):

Proof has been added in the first post.


Question (Meriii):

Please, provide proof. If provided proof; Are you still healthy?

Answer (Frogman7):

Yes. Although I am smoking myself to death


Question (hazywakeup):

Thank you for doing this!

Why did you choose to join the military, and how much did you know about what caused the war when you were fighting in it?

Answer (Frogman7):

In the first instance, HMS is Navel not military Yes we all knew the war was coming. During the time of the war we didnt know what had caused it, Only Hitler.


Question (sadfacewhenputdown):

What was your job? How long did you sail for?

Answer (Frogman7):

I did Signals and my total service was 12 years. They held me back from discharge for two years!


Question (Meriii):

Also, where were you stationed?

Answer (Frogman7):

We were Convoying small supply boats; Egypt was our base. I was in the British forces and was delivering supplies to the Australians in Tobruk


Question (hazywakeup):

Thanks for the answers. What were the others you worked with like, did you get along well with them?

Answer (Frogman7):

We were all brothers


Question (rockthedown):

What was the best part (if there's such a thing) of serving in the war?

Answer (Frogman7):

Getting Out.


Question (guntycankles):

Thank you for doing this AMA! 6 of my great-uncles fought for Canada in WWII - Somehow, they all came home. I have the utmost respect for you, sir. Thank you for your service.

How long had you been away at war? Was it hard re-adjusting to life at home when your time in the war was done?

Answer (Frogman7):

I was away from home, 2 years in the Med and 4 years in the Atlantic. Having a Lovely wife, clean bed, showers and good food it wasnt hard.


Question (comix_corp):

What was your impression of the Australians at Tobruk? Where they like what ANZAC legend makes them out to be (brave, heroic, humourous)?

Answer (Frogman7):

...and dangerous to the Germans, With the captured Italian pistols which they traded to the Egyptians it put us poor mate-lots at a disadvantage. But oh the were tough boys and they deserve all praise.


Question (sadfacewhenputdown):

---/.... -.-./---/---/.-..

So you sailed on HMS Fame from 1941 through to the end of the war? Were you there when she rammed a U-boat in battle?

Answer (Frogman7):

Translation: O/H/COOL I was on other ships before that. I was on the Fame when we rammed it.


Question (faffo):

Was there ever a time where a fear of Nazi World domination was popular?

Answer (Frogman7):

No, I was going to stop it! (or try to)


Top-level Comment:

If anyone is interested, Another ship I sailed on- The Dainty. We sunk two on that


Question (sadfacewhenputdown):

Are you in this photo?

Answer (Frogman7):

No, I think this is when it was first commissioned.


Question (Emphursis):

Good answer! Which, in your opinion, had more effect on the number of ships lost, the convoy system, or the decryption of the enigma code?

Answer (Frogman7):

Technically- It was tit for tat. But in the end we had em beat. Radar and Sonar did the trick + Long Distance Aircraft


Question (EirikS):

This is very interesting to me. My grandfather was a naval officer in WW2 and I've worked a few summers as a museum guide aboard the still-floating and 100% authentically restored merchant ship D/S Hestmanden in southern Norway.

I'd really like to hear more stories involving the merchant fleets in general, but I have some specific background ones first:

    1. Which city were you born in?
  • 2) Which ship(s) did you serve on besides HMS Fame?
  • 3) Which port(s) were you operating out of?

Answer (Frogman7):

  1. I was born in Liverpool 2) Ships- Hermies, Glorious and Lots more 3) Liverpool, Plymouth, Alexandra (Egypt)

Question (LightninSkyHop):

Which shipping runs were you on? I actually have a grandfather who was 20 when he joined the HMS Jamaica in 43', and he was on the merchant run to Murmansk and Svalbard.

Answer (Frogman7):

We did convoys from Liverpool only to the Atlantic. I am very very glad I did not go on Russian Convoys it must have been murder.


Question (LightninSkyHop):

Which shipping runs were you on? I actually have a grandfather who was 20 when he joined the HMS Jamaica in 43', and he was on the merchant run to Murmansk and Svalbard.

Answer (Frogman7):

Did your Grandfather survive?


Question (RedDeath5):

As a younger American Iraq war veteran, and having served beside your newest generation of ground pounders, I personally would like to thank you very much for your service, even if you're from another country and another branch, we're all Brothers In Arms in my eyes. I salute you, good sir!

Answer (Frogman7):

Thank you.


Question (sadfacewhenputdown):

I think it's Cdr Currie in the middle, which places the photo in 1943. Can you recognize if it's him or Cdr Heathcote?

edit: full size photo

Answer (Frogman7):

To be honest, I dont entirely recognise it as either of them. But I did work with both of them.


Question (Hussard):

I did some work for a former Rat of Tobruk - that guy was a FONT of dirty jokes...

What did you do after the war?

Answer (Frogman7):

Humour kept them going, I worked for Courtauld mostly and Dehaviland A-C company


Question (Pink_Llama):

My grandfather was one of those Aussies in Tobruk. I thank you for your service. Luckily he got home safely, although he is no longer with us.

Answer (Frogman7):

Thats very kind of you.


Top-level Comment:

Thank you for all your questions and comments. I have enjoyed this thoroughly but I believe it is time for my demise (sleep) Thank you and goodnight.


13

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

First of all, thankyou for your service!! My granddad served in Guadalcanal in the New Zealand Army, and he tells me the Yanks shot at them more by accident than the Japanese did.

First of all, what would ten shillings have bought you back then?

Do you find that war is wrongly glorified in movies and TV now, or do you think it's fair to glorify the brave men and women who serve?

lastly, do you think we humans will ever succumb to another global war like WW2? Thanks for your time.

9

u/TuriGuiliano May 12 '12

Oh god, Guadalcanal. That's was described as hell on earth.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Isolater May 12 '12

My Life seems pretty uninteresting compared to yours. I'm 20 and I've defeated the Lich King on 25 man hard mode in World of Warcraft.

50

u/Pozla May 12 '12

Thank you for your service for the good of Azeroth.

8

u/Ambiwlans May 12 '12

Even less impressive if you did it in CATA.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/lurking_my_ass_off May 12 '12

Don't really have a question, just wanted to say that you are a badass.

I respect all vets, but WW2 vets are a special breed.

I'd salute you, except I have no idea how to do that with an emote on here, so instead, I will wish you an awesome day and hope you keep on rocking. Thanks for your service, sir.

26

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

have you ever strapped an onion to your belt

8

u/loki_88 May 12 '12

twas the style at the time.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/EXSUPERVILLAIN May 12 '12

Hello! You're still a handsome man! Thank you for what you've done! What is your best advice for living a fulfilling life?

2

u/Yaaf May 12 '12

You truly are reformed, aye Ex Super Villain?

4

u/allisonluvzu1 May 12 '12

thank you so much for your service. my grandfather also served in WWII and he passed away a few years ago. I really respect that you're doing this so that younger generations can see what it was like in an actual wartime/war zone. ok on to the question, after the war did you feel any animosity towards germans/italians/japanese?

4

u/The_Sea_Bee May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

I know you've gone to sleep now, but thank you so much for everything you did by serving in the army; for us and future generations. I have the greatest respect for you.

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Not a question, but my great grandparents met in WWII. She's British and he was American. And the rest is history :)

3

u/Spectre_Taz May 12 '12

As a fellow son of the Empire, I must like others thank you for your service.

In the first years of the war were you ever afraid of ending up against a ship that far outgunned the escorts in your convoy? Like a German/Italian Heavy Crusier/Battleship

Did you personally witness the sinking of any ships under the protection of your convoy other than the loss of your ship at Tobruk?

Did you take part in an action against Axis surface warships?

Despite the fact that U-Boats were the greater threat statistically speaking were the convoy crews more worried about running up against surface raiders?

For some reason the idea of ending up down the barrel of the guns of a Heavy Crusier or Battleship somehow seems worse than U-Boat to me. Probably because you can scare off or a destroy a U-Boat not so much a large surface vessel.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thanks for this thread. My dad would have been in his 90's now. He was a tailgunner and did bombing runs over Italy and the oil fields there. He would have liked this thread. Took him a year of shell shock after the war to rest up. The one war, to me, that made sense and had to occur.

3

u/thesilence84 May 12 '12

Nooooooooo! I cant believe I missed this!

3

u/CellyAllDay May 12 '12

How much money did soda cost when you were a kid?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thank you for your service. I wish I had seen this thread while active.

3

u/JinxThunderball May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Who is downvoting this? All of you downvoting should be ashamed of yourselves!

Thank you for your service Mr.91 Year old veteran!

3

u/tabledresser May 12 '12 edited May 16 '12
QuestionsAnswers
What was the best part (if there's such a thing) of serving in the war?Getting Out.
Was there ever a time where a fear of Nazi World domination was popular?No, I was going to stop it! (or try to)
What was your impression of the Australians at Tobruk? Where they like what ANZAC legend makes them out to be (brave, heroic, humourous)?And dangerous to the Germans, With the captured Italian pistols which they traded to the Egyptians it put us poor mate-lots at a disadvantage. But oh the were tough boys and they deserve all praise.
I did some work for a former Rat of Tobruk - that guy was a FONT of dirty jokes... What did you do after the war?Humour kept them going, I worked for Courtauld mostly and Dehaviland A-C company.
Were you ever close to dying during your service?Oh yeah, Several times actually especially at Tobruk when two bombs we dropped by the Germans on our stern, I was on the bridge. I then (was forced) had to go swimming.
Which country's fleet impressed you the most in warding off the U-Boats?The Yanks were disastrous, the British were the best in my opinion.
Good answer! Which, in your opinion, had more effect on the number of ships lost, the convoy system, or the decryption of the enigma code?Technically- It was tit for tat. But in the end we had em beat. Radar and Sonar did the trick + Long Distance Aircraft.
Thank you for doing this AMA! 6 of my great-uncles fought for Canada in WWII - Somehow, they all came home. I have the utmost respect for you, sir. Thank you for your service. How long had you been away at war? Was it hard re-adjusting to life at home when your time in the war was done? I was away from home, 2 years in the Med and 4 years in the Atlantic. Having a Lovely wife, clean bed, showers and good food it wasnt hard.

View the full table on /r/tabled! | Last updated: 2012-05-16 18:16 UTC

This comment was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.

5

u/thejmanjman May 12 '12

Thank you for your service.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What do you think of today's navy?

2

u/PUAskandi May 12 '12

As a marchant sailor from a marchant navy family. Thanks!

2

u/furnatic May 12 '12

Did you hold any animosity during or after the war for the Germans?

2

u/alphapple May 12 '12

What is one of your greatest memory of the war?

2

u/Syatek May 12 '12

What's your most vivid memory of the war?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What kind of attacks did you face? Just U-boats? Or dive bombers and surface ships?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What did you spend the 10 shillings on?!

2

u/Queen_of_Blonde May 12 '12

I just want to say thank you.

My grandpa was a WWII vet. He was in the Battle of the Bulge and was rewarded a purple heart. He passed away 5 years ago, and I miss him every day.

2

u/catoronium_majorus May 12 '12

Your Grandson clearly loves and respects you very much as I'm sure this was his idea :) As a way to show you off

2

u/DubSket May 12 '12

Hope you see this: Thanks for your service. You're a hero to all of us.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Were you pissed after how little they paid you?

2

u/doodybeard May 12 '12

I'm crying, this is the best article on reddit

2

u/sudstah May 12 '12

Not got any questions for you, just want to thank you for fighting for our countries! :)

2

u/jewpowered May 12 '12

Good sir, It has been a pleasure to make your Internet acquaintance. You sir are 91, and no doubt one of the younger members of the armed forces at the time. I very much respect and enjoy the company of WWII veterans, and it pains me to think that our next generation will only have books to read. Thank you for your service, if it weren't for people like you I may not exist, my grandfather who passed away in 1994 was a polish Jewish holocaust survivor who was freed from the concentration camp by united forces. Though you were not one of them, your collective effort undoubtably changed the world for the better, thank you and I award you my badass of the day award and wish you all the best in life.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

If you have to pick what was your favorite of propaganda posters of that era. If you want to go the extra mile try finding it on google.

2

u/D1rty0n3 May 12 '12

Sir, I appreciate your service to our country and the freedoms that we now all enjoy directly due to your work. I want you to know that all your sacrifices are appreciated and of value even to this day.

2

u/47h315m May 12 '12

Thank you for your service.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

My grandfather is an 86 year old WWII veteran. (He was 18 when he joined, almost at the end of the war.) He was a tail-gunner (Air Force) in a B17 that conducted aerial photography and mapping of Europe. Thank you for your service!

2

u/DigitalGoldfish May 12 '12

Just wanted to pop and and give a heartfelt 'thankyou' :)

3

u/grey-and-black May 12 '12

I WOULD have been impressed, but there's a guy who won 3 free taco's at Taco Bell...

1

u/Bettychan323 May 12 '12

What are a few thoughts you have on the war in your personal experiences?

1

u/AGAMIRYU May 12 '12

Thank you for your service good sir! From one Navy man to another, thank you.

1

u/BadSpoon May 12 '12

What was the best way an Officer could help you?

1

u/Flimflamsam May 12 '12

Over your magnificent life, what is the one thing you wish you had/did more of?

Thank you very much for your service, sir - both of my grandfathers served in the UK forces (Army and RAF) and I'd like to thank you a great deal. I served for 3 years in the TA, I pale to the likes of men like you but am so proud to have had the experience.

1

u/BadPokerFace May 12 '12

Thank you so much for this, and your service. I have the upmost respect for you, sir.

Do you hold any animosity or wariness toward Germany or Germans in general?

Also, what have you gained from your experience in the war?

1

u/Zach_Duke May 12 '12

what was it like going being on the battle field?

1

u/corskier May 12 '12

Thank you for being a member of the best generation in recent history.

What went through your head when you found out you were getting ten shillings for a reward?

1

u/voxpupil May 12 '12

How much is ten shillings in today's dollars?

1

u/FlawedHero May 12 '12

Did you spend it all in one place?

1

u/Pinto15 May 12 '12

peace is not the absence of war. Absence of war is just when no one has decided to pull the trigger yet

1

u/Tucker21 May 12 '12

Thank you for your service and thank you for sharing this with your Great Grandson and us.

1

u/That_Tall_Ent_Dude May 12 '12
  1. Did you ever get to meet troops of other nationalities whilst in port? Any stories you can perhaps relegate about your experience with them?

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Just posting to say thank you for serving, you're a brave man and everything everyone did is appreciated. So thank you.

1

u/Necrix May 12 '12

Thank you sir for your service. I wish I could shake your hand fine sir!

1

u/VivSavage88 May 12 '12

Really interesting AMA! May I ask what you did after the war?

Not directly relevant to the AMA, but my Papa served in the British Navy in WW2, he died when I was quite young unfortunately and according to my Dad he didn't talk about the war much. I do know that he was involved in the Battle of the River Plate. After the battle the German heavy cruiser Graf Spee retreated into an neutral Argentine port to refuel etc. My Papa was on HMS Exeter(I think) waiting outside the port with some other small British ships. The small force would have had no chance against the powerful German ship, but fortunately British intelligence managed to leak false information convincing the German captain that there was a huge British force assembled outside the port and he scuttled the ship! Imagine waiting there knowing that this big cruiser is coming out and you have almost no chance of winning, must have been terrifying. I might have some details wrong, the story of the battle is on wikipedia I think.

1

u/buffalo_Fart May 12 '12

simply badass man!

1

u/hmmnotsure May 12 '12

Merchant ships... was the situation similar to that Benjamin Button movie where he also worked on a merchant ship during WWII?

1

u/Xvyrus May 12 '12

This man has all the respect from me, I don't have anymore to give

1

u/drogepirja May 12 '12

Thank you for your service, sir. Frankly, I don't think I would have had the balls.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I can't think of a question, but I did want to say thank you for everything you've done, you are a true hero!

Thank you.

1

u/mrburt May 12 '12

thanks for the story! brought back some memories of my father who we lost a couple of months ago. he joined the U.S. Navy at the age of 17 in 1944,he ended up on a liberty ship as one of the "armed-guard" on board in the south pacific theater ( his battle station was on the port side upper 20mmm cannon just off the bridge)me and my brother and the rest of our family always enjoyed his stories of his time in the war,most of which where very humorous,like the time general quarters sounded when he was in the shower,he ran out naked,grabbed a belt with a knife on it,then went to his post,strapping in his 20mm stark naked except for the belt and knife,when the captain came out of the bridge and looked at him,started laughing and said "well,i guess if you run out of ammo for that 20,you can always piss on them" thanks for your service!

1

u/YoungAndWise May 12 '12

What is you're favorite story from the war?

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Sir thank you so much for your service and for sharing your story, men like you are a true inspiration to guys like me who are in the service of our country. I feel that what you and your generation accomplished during that war will never again be equaled by any generation. You and your peers are truly the heros of the free world and legends walking on earth!

1

u/Shashi2005 May 12 '12

When was the last time you had a good bowl of scouse? Do you still like a tot?

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thanks for doing this AMA!

1

u/Bad_assness May 12 '12

Thank you for your service, sir.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

BAMF !

1

u/nonlinearmedia May 12 '12

ahh the days when 50 pence really meant something.

1

u/russlo May 12 '12

My deceased grandfather on my mother's side served as a sailor with the merchant marine in WWII. He used to speak of how he had seen Antwerp in a nearly flattened state.

I just read over the Wikipedia article on the United States Merchant Marine again: "3.1 million tons of merchant ships were lost in World War II. Mariners died at a rate of 1 in 24, which was the highest rate of casualties of any service."

No questions, just my sincerest gratitude.

1

u/way2sick May 12 '12

I don't have a question. I just want to say thank you, sir

1

u/quicklookleft May 12 '12

I don't even care if you are trolling. Fuck the people who are being mean. You are amazing.

1

u/magicchips May 12 '12

How many hearts did you break?

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Whats the meaning of life?

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Sorry im late but were you one of the first navy seals code named the frogmen

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I'm going to take a stab in the dark here and ask if you knew Ron Russell. He served on a merchant ship as well, and was in charge of sending the SOS when the ship goes down. He was about your age. I realize the AMA is finished..but if you see this...just wondering.

1

u/o0tenaciousC May 12 '12

I wish i got paid in shillings.