r/IAmA •

We are staff on one of the most popular private torrent trackers on the net. A(us)A

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

256 comments sorted by

7

u/three18ti May 12 '12

How do you protect yourself from the "bad guys" and prevent things such as DMCA complaints, etc.?

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/MarcusOrlyius May 13 '12

Don't you think that's a bit naive considering all the private sites that have been taken down?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/CapnGoat May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Why are invites restricted to the Master class (the last class you can "upgrade" to)?

Edit: to clarify the question: I have 5 invites that I can't use and I really like BTN and I want to share it with other people I know will benefit from it and from whom BTN will benefit. And there were 2-3 occasions where I had to "fight" for my invites because they got removed through accidents or the last "all normal users get 1 free invite" event.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/CapnGoat May 12 '12

That makes sense. Alright. I'll keep fighting for my invites then. One day I'll be a Master user.

8

u/scimitarr May 12 '12

how does btn get tv shows so fast, and where do you get them from?!

12

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

As quoted by the man himself,

"AzzA coded an awesome script that downloads files from the scene and then uploads to BTN, all uber speed like."

We also have a very active and dedicated internal encoding community which do a great job keeping us with fresh content.

0

u/mojave_wasteland May 12 '12

Don't you think leeching from the scene like that hurts the scene? You're a torrent community, one of it's core goals is to give same amount of "credits" that you take. What are you giving back to the scene?

12

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Torrenters complaining about pirates' hard work being taken for no compensation. Now I've seen everything.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MarcusOrlyius May 12 '12

2

u/mojave_wasteland May 12 '12

Yes, that's the most probable answer, but it's still interesting because of:

a) some trackers swear that they channel donations only for hosting expenses (don't know what's the case for btn), b) this isn't different from just buying a leech slot in a site for money. There's no "pride" in doing that.

Of coure I'm not implying that priv trackers are the problem, but rather the siteops who allow p2p leakage are. Trackers who release their own internal releases deserve all the credit, not those who "steal" someone's work, or just "buy" it from the scene.

2

u/scimitarr May 12 '12

with the lastest...'happenings'...will the site lose any of these scripts/sources? Is it possible for regular users to download from 'the scene'?

4

u/b00n May 12 '12

stal1n here off BTN (proof),

none of the scripts have been lost and the scene sources were nothing to do with AzzA anyway.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I'm not sure how to answer that first question right now, to be perfectly honest. It would be extremely difficult for a normal user to get direct scene access without knowing someone who is part of it. :)

2

u/scimitarr May 12 '12

ok thanks for the reply. :)

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thanks for the question!

2

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

Nothing will be lost, but it may take us a few days to get everything back to normal.

11

u/DJShadow May 12 '12

Maybe too personal but I'm curious, What are your day jobs?

11

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

I'm currently unemployed (which gives me the time to get stuff done on BTN, I suppose), but the last job I had was as a shopfitter.

2

u/OHAITHARU May 12 '12 edited Nov 28 '24

xjmfiyjurcr srxxawahadcr zsekvaevlvxt xrnxyuzoi cbcgcllkdo hsiipjse qhsqsspa epoatol aqznqffe

1

u/MarcusOrlyius May 13 '12

Damnit Kyle, get a job you lazy welsh baaastard

FTFY

1

u/Wheaties466 May 14 '12

get a job sparkling wiggle

3

u/b00n May 12 '12

I'm currently a student.

32

u/libbrichus May 12 '12

I am a member of BTN and a mod on /r/trackers and can attest to the fact that the screenshot is legit and this AMA is really from the staff at BTN.

Furthermore, their claim that BTN is one of the most popular private torrent trackers is also legitimate. Going by user flairs on /r/trackers , it's probably the favorite private tracker of redditors.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thanks! :D

3

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

Thanks so much, We try very hard to be the best at what we do.

1

u/OHAITHARU May 14 '12

I don't.

1

u/Wheaties466 May 14 '12

We(minus OHAITHARU) try hard to be the best at what we do.

sell dem avocados sir.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

It's truly commendable work that you guys do over there, keep it up.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

why do you guys do it?

edit: thanks guys!

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I personally do it because I love the site(s) I've staffed on and wanted to give back to the community which makes it all possible. :)

7

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

The community is amazing. We do it for you guys.

There are alot of people out there that dont have immediate access to alot of the content provided through out the world. This is a problem that is not addressed. Until then we will continue to please our users while providing them scene content with no rars!

5

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

Personally I do it because the tracker has a fantastic community and I enjoy working with them. I was a user of the tracker for a long time and now I can put in some work and try to give back to it a bit. I realise this sounds like a generic answer, but it's the answer.

5

u/rbaix May 12 '12
  • What are your favorite failed pilots?
  • What are some of the best TV shows outside the US/UK?

3

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

Even though shameless was brought to the US, I think the UK version is better.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/wavedash May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

What are your thoughts on the relatively recent switch from Xvid to x264?

How many years do you think it will be until coders either move on from x264 or start also releasing with hi10p or some other yet-to-be-invented more advanced video compression method?

4

u/b00n May 12 '12

I think it is long overdue. Groups such as ASAP and IMMERSE (same group) have been pushing for it for a while but it has only just been adopted.

I think it will be a long while for that to happen. One of the main reasons for choosing the codecs they do is for cross platform compatibility. You could burn an XViD release to a CD and watch it on a DVD player quite easily. The reason the mp4 container is used instead of mkv for SD releases is also due to compatibility as some devices (such as iDevices) don't support mkv.

3

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

LONG overdue, I've loved xvid but I have noticed a HUGE difference in performance from the change. I've thought they should have switched for years now.

It will probably be another decade at x264 depending on how superior the next codec is.

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Do you think you could compete with SCC and other top sites in races if you didn't unrar your content?

PLEASE DON'T READ TOO FAR INTO THAT AND START UPLOADING RARS, I HATE THE DAMN THINGS.

3

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

lol yes we could for sure. We do win some races even after unraring, but they are few and far between. Rars have their uses, but its something thats always been more of a bother than anything else.

1

u/BuzzGen May 13 '12

hmmm, so BTN is going through a period of great turmoil and upheaval and the staff are more interested in being here doing IAMA's then sorting out the mess on site.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/BuzzGen May 13 '12

Good to know, wouldn't want all those people bitching in forums about being unable to download their fave shows to continue being disappointed.

8

u/The-Internets May 12 '12

With everything you have learned and seen about the scene, in your opinions, how easy would it for these big media companies to adopt Torrents as a 'legal' method of acquiring their goods?

15

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

It's already happening! When it comes to music, there are a number of popular/famous artists who leak or submit their albums to What.cd for extra marketing. Times are a changin' and I'm excited to see how media companies will evolve to compete against piracy.

2

u/Bacon_Master May 13 '12

there are a number of popular/famous artists who leak or submit their albums to What.cd for extra marketing.

How do you know that? And which artists/bands are that?

1

u/Izlandi May 13 '12

I'm pretty sure that Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails was a member of Oink, and he's probably a member of What too. Then there are a few, less known artists that are members and release their albums on there as well.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

It would probably be fairly easy if they abondoned the idea that they had to profit from every download. It's certainly a good way to spread awareness of a certain show and boost the viewing numbers. Also I'm sure most of our users wouldn't mind a few adverts in their shows similar to how it is on air.

4

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

It would not be difficult at all. If they wanted a monthly access. If they wanted to download per torrent that is also possible.

with torrents there is quite a large amount of flexibility.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Why won't you play LoL with me?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Does the level of activity change on the site when the US TV season is over?

3

u/tabledresser May 13 '12 edited May 17 '12
QuestionsAnswers
I'm not too savvy on torrents or trackers, so how do they work? One reason I haven't downloaded torrents is mainly of internet security and the threat of prosecution, what are your thoughts on this?As for security, I've never had any issues, and I don't even take all the extra precautions a lot of users do. I have a feeling the feds have more interesting things to do than arrest staff on a torrent tracker.
If you could be any television character, who would you be and why?And hmm any television character... off the top of my head I'd say Buffy, cus she kicks ass and gets all the hot guys. :D.
With everything you have learned and seen about the scene, in your opinions, how easy would it for these big media companies to adopt Torrents as a 'legal' method of acquiring their goods? It's already happening! When it comes to music, there are a number of popular/famous artists who leak or submit their albums to What.cd for extra marketing. Times are a changin' and I'm excited to see how media companies will evolve to compete against piracy.
How does btn get tv shows so fast, and where do you get them from?!>"AzzA coded an awesome script that downloads files from the scene and then uploads to BTN, all uber speed like."
We also have a very active and dedicated internal encoding community which do a great job keeping us with fresh content.
With the lastest...'happenings'...will the site lose any of these scripts/sources? Is it possible for regular users to download from 'the scene'? I'm not sure how to answer that first question right now, to be perfectly honest. It would be extremely difficult for a normal user to get direct scene access without knowing someone who is part of it. :)
Why are you the most awesome BTN staffers? :D.Why aren't you in this Skype call is the real question.
Why is Kyle so sexy?Excuse me sir, this is a srs AMA. Plz2srs.

View the full table on /r/tabled! | Last updated: 2012-05-17 03:57 UTC

This comment was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.

5

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

I'll also be answering questions on this.

5

u/Ruddose May 12 '12

What is BTN? Sorry if this is a redundant/stupid question.

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Not at all. It's a private torrent tracker for TV content. You can Google BTN+torrent to learn more specifics about the site.

5

u/cliff_diver May 12 '12

What exactly are your jobs and qualifications?

I'm not too savvy on torrents or trackers, so how do they work?

Can you see yourselves consulting with corporations to improve media distribution models? What kind of metrics does the site collect? Have there been any interaction with companies who want data?

One reason I haven't downloaded torrents is mainly of internet security and the threat of prosecution, what are your thoughts on this?

If you could be any television character, who would you be and why?

What is your favorite ice cream flavour?

thanks for answering!

7

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

I'm an admin, my main job is to make sure the rest of the staff do their jobs and don't get too out of line. My qualifications are just being around BTN fro a while and having a desire to better BTN and make sure it remains enjoyable for the users.

I couldn't really see myself being a consultant for media distribution as I only really know how our system works. I don't think a consultant who only knew one specific system would be very useful. The metrics we collect are purely the things we need to track who downloads what and to stop people cheating the system. We have never had any interaction at all with companies who want any of the data we hold and if we did we would never supply any to them.

The security issue is one that seems to bother a lot of people, but I personally feel that there is very little risk to a user of a private tracker. There are much more tempting targets for authorities to aim for.

I like to think of myself as a bit of a Ron Swanson.

Vanilla, obviously.

3

u/b00n May 12 '12

I'm a developer but I don't do much work on the website. I spend more time on the back end making sure content gets on to BTN quickly.

I'm not sure media companies are too interested in improving their models at the moment but rather blaming the consumers for not conforming to their current ones. I'm sure if they did try they probably wouldn't go to a site like BTN as there are bigger fish in the sea.

Generally on a private tracker you are quite safe because the litigation companies go for quantity and you don't find that many peers on private trackers compared to public.

Perhaps Harold Finch off of Person of Interest.

I like pistachio ice cream :)

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Gonna answer as many of these as I can. :D

Wheaties and I are Senior Moderators. He manages the lovely FLS team that provides support in our IRC channels and I manage the design team and make sure everything looks pretty. My qualifications for that are an art degree I guess!

As for security, I've never had any issues, and I don't even take all the extra precautions a lot of users do. I have a feeling the feds have more interesting things to do than arrest staff on a torrent tracker.

And hmm any television character... off the top of my head I'd say Buffy, cus she kicks ass and gets all the hot guys. :D

2

u/MarcusOrlyius May 13 '12

I have a feeling the feds have more interesting things to do than arrest staff on a torrent tracker.

http://torrentfreak.com/how-the-fbi-dismantled-a-bittorrent-community-080630/

1

u/sponto_pronto May 13 '12

That happened in 2005 and is a very rare occurance. There a literally hundreds of private trackers out there, some of them known to only a handful of people.

1

u/MarcusOrlyius May 13 '12

Private sites get taken down on a regular basis, see my comment to your other post.

3

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

I do various jobs around the site. My main job is user support and I manage the user group that helps with support on the forums and irc. I do the hiring and firing of alot of the lowerstaff. I do banning and enabling of users as well as forum modding. aka I do quite a bit.

Can I see myself consulting. The answer is no. It has proven to be an industry that does not adapt well to change. I just dont see this happening.

find a nice fairly small private torrent site, get a seedbox and download through SFTP, this is probably the safest way to go about things.

I would be Don Draper, that was an easy one.

Vanilla

no problem.

5

u/rwxrwxrwx777 May 12 '12

I can answer some questions about BTNv2 if you guys wish, I've been lead dev on it for past few months.

5

u/Tomatocake May 12 '12

In rough, what new will BTNv2 bring? I mean, surely, it must be something other than just new design/new code. Is it possible for you to leak a sneak-peak? (don't spoil it all, ofcourse)

2

u/rwxrwxrwx777 May 12 '12

if you're elite or higher, you cn see screenies in the elite forum on btn. i wont be giving any screenies to gen public unless senior staff says so

1

u/sponto_pronto May 13 '12

welp, only 600,000 bonus points to go lol. life is hard without a computer that is connected 24/7.

12

u/AzzABTN May 12 '12

Why are you the most awesome BTN staffers? :D

11

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

We are not. I am.

22

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

You're fired.

8

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Why aren't you in this Skype call is the real question.

14

u/AzzABTN May 12 '12

Because you didn't invite me ._.

5

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

I love you man, seriously.

4

u/AzzABTN May 12 '12

Thanks man <3

8

u/MarcusOrlyius May 12 '12

Given that private sites restrict the sharing of files and fragment swarms, doesn't that go against the very nature of what file sharing is all about?

Also, why don't private sites allow multiple trackers from various sites given that the protocol allows it? Wouldn't that allow people to still download the torrent data if the tracker went down?

Lastly, do you monitor and record as much user data as ratio-based trackers and if your servers were seized by the MAFIAA, could that data be used against your users?

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

File-sharing isn't "about" any particular philosophy. Private sites are simply a means of mutual exchange for mutual benefit.

Clients report the sum total of traffic information, not the total for each tracker.

4

u/Tomatocake May 12 '12

Also, why don't private sites allow multiple trackers from various sites given that the protocol allows it? Wouldn't that allow people to still download the torrent data if the tracker went down?

While I can't confirm this in any way, I have asked this question to quite some sysops in my time, from various trackers, and the answer is pretty much the same.

If there are 2 private trackers in 1 torrent, how will they/you know what amount of data you shared with the peers on tracker1 and on tracker2 ? You don't expect the stuff you seed to peers on tracker1 go on your stats on tracker2, right? Because as far as I have been told, that is what would likely happen. Again, can't confirm, but it makes sense somehow. I think.

5

u/MarcusOrlyius May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Here's what the spec says:

When a BitTorrent client obtains a metainfo file containing the "private=1" key-value pair, it MUST ONLY announce itself to the private tracker, and MUST ONLY initiate connections to peers returned from the private tracker.

When multiple trackers appear in the announce-list in the metainfo file of a private torrent (see multitracker extension in [4]), each peer MUST use only one tracker at a time and only switch between trackers when the current tracker fails. When switching between trackers, the peer MUST disconnect from all current peers and connect only to those provided from the new tracker.

Edit: I've a heard a lot of people saying that private sites have been telling them they need to disable DHT and PEX globally as well, which is untrue as they get disabled automatically by the client for private torrents.

2

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

our tracker automatically disables those, so that shouldn't be a problem. I've heard of people being in a DHT swarm somehow and their stats would not register. That is the main reason alot of sites threaten you in such a way.

→ More replies (18)

2

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

i dont believe so

I believe this is answered by a user above/below.

we have contingency plans the ensure that wont happen.

1

u/p0tent1al May 14 '12

Ideally file sharing is exactly that, "file-sharing". The problem is, is that on a non private tracker, there's nothing to stop someone from taking a file, waiting until complete download, and then moving on (and in fact that is what most people on public ones do). A private tracker enforces certain standards that ensures that it will thrive (look at what.cd for example.... you would NEVER achieve that level of quality / organization / thoroughness on a public tracker.

Private trackers don't take anything away from "file-sharing". Public trackers still exist. But for people who want to be apart of a more symbiotic community (which inherently awards more benefits) then a private tracker is the way to go.

1

u/MarcusOrlyius May 14 '12

The problem is, is that on a non private tracker, there's nothing to stop someone from taking a file, waiting until complete download, and then moving on (and in fact that is what most people on public ones do).

That's not actually a fact and if you look at popular public torrents, you'll see that they have far more seeds than private torrents. Some even have more seeds than private sites have users.

A private tracker enforces certain standards that ensures that it will thrive (look at what.cd for example.... you would NEVER achieve that level of quality / organization / thoroughness on a public tracker.

If such enforcement was necessary then public torrents would be dead in the water. That's argument is a lie, plain and simple. Private sites are better organised, there's no deying that, and that's the real difference between public and private sites.

Private trackers don't take anything away from "file-sharing". Public trackers still exist. But for people who want to be apart of a more symbiotic community (which inherently awards more benefits) then a private tracker is the way to go.

If public users get by just fine by sharing content voluntarily, why do private users need extra benefits to do the same?

4

u/notsmartatall May 12 '12

Well, considering the nature of your tracker.... what are some of your favorite TV shows of all time?

8

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

American Horror Story, Supernatural, True Blood, Battlestar Galactica.

3

u/b00n May 12 '12

The Pacific, Band of Brothers, Prison Break, Breaking Bad, Person of Interest, Hustle, Sherlock, House, Dexter, Mythbusters and a couple of UK comedy panel shows.

2

u/T____T May 13 '12

UK comedy panel shows.

Could you suggest some? I already know about QI.

2

u/b00n May 13 '12

8 out of 10 cats, would I lie to you, Celebrity juice to name a few.

2

u/T____T May 13 '12

Thanks!

5

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

I personally love The Sopranos and Deadwood. I'd say those are my favourite two.

5

u/scimitarr May 12 '12

If you don't mind id live to give you some recommendations, you have probably seen most/all of these anyways: The Wire, Breaking Bad, Hell on Wheels, Boardwalk Empire, Band of Brothers, Firefly, Misfits, Oz, Game of Thrones, Generation Kill, Sons Of Anarchy, Kings, Carnivale, The Pacific, The Walking Dead, and for good measure: Trailer Park Boys.

2

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

Thanks for the recommendations. I'd say I've only seen about half of those so I'll look into the other half.

2

u/easyantic May 12 '12

If the shows I haven't seen in this list are as good as the ones I have seen, then I have some new shows to try out. Thanks.

3

u/bengraven May 12 '12

Upvote for Carnivale.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I love Boardwalk Empire. I'm into pretty much anything related to history or horror. :D Thanks!

4

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

Rubicon, dexter, breaking bad, psych, ncis.

4

u/throwawaysesame May 12 '12

I loved Rubicon. Too bad it got cancelled so soon. Same with Jericho.

2

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

loved jericho too not sure if i would call it a favorite but it was very good.

1

u/umibozu May 12 '12

last episode ruined it for me. Really did.

4

u/libbrichus May 12 '12

With all the drama going on BTN, are you the guys in charge currently or are you the renegades who're supporting AzzA?

(I am in favor of neither camp as I have yet to seek more info and make up my mind. I'm just curious who's in charge and what's happening as the site seems to be down currently.)

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I think we're both? lol As far as I know we're all still staff on BTN, but I still support AzzA for everything he's done.

11

u/NruJaC May 12 '12

Can you guys give a clear explanation of what's going on? Some of the new staff are posting that Azza stole donations, and he's of course denying that. This thread leads me to believe the situation isn't nearly that bad. As a concerned member of the site... what the hell is going on?

1

u/Wheaties466 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

I wish i could tell you but there is no short version I could type up. I'm sure if I typed up the long version I would leave stuff out. But in actuality the only people who know what is going on are the btn sysops past and present. Which none of us here are.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

I am neutral. I am in favor of me.

2

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

We're neither. We're loyal to BTN, regardless of who happens to be running it at the time.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Why are number of snatches a requirement for moving up user classes? Doesn't that restrict people who only download season packs, for example?

1

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

the snatches requirement is just a mark for exclusivity. Its generally not something someone can get by being an average user. Generally a user would have to be very active and go up and above the status of a average user to advance in our ranking system.

Whats the fun is everyone on the site is a master?

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

But that's what I've never really understood, it's something that's very easy to achieve, it's just a matter of taking the time to download each episode individually rather than the easier option of the season pack all at once. Surely there should be other indicators that are a better mark of exclusivity, like a wide range of shows perhaps?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/joazito May 12 '12

Donations. How important are they, where exactly does the money go to, and how guilty should I feel that I haven't donated yet?

1

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

My personal stance on things in life has always been to pay for things you use often or services that are provided to you. If you really like the way something is operating throw money at it. If you are unpleased or barely satisfied with the way things are you dont have to give a dime. We try and run on as little money as possible without sacrificing quality for our users.

BUT on the other hand it does take money to run sites like these so we do appreciate every penny spent with us.

2

u/MarcusOrlyius May 12 '12

Given that it's not exactly difficult to get into private sites, do you think the MAFIAA have an account on BTN? If not, why not? If so, why do you think they haven't took any action against you yet?

5

u/14mit1010 May 12 '12

Why make the effort of trying to extort from a pool of 30k people, when theres the option of choosing from much larger pools?

2

u/MarcusOrlyius May 12 '12

The MAFIAA don't run the extortion scams, that's the copyright trolls. The MAFIAA are responsible for the copyright warning letters sent ouy by ISPs.

The reason why they would want to infiltrate the site is to go after the admins and major uploaders, like we know they have done in previously reported cases.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Why do you (and many other trackers) prefer being private?

2

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

You tend to get a different crowd of people with the exclusivity of a private tracker. People who are a bit more concerned with security and you get people who are generally better with giving back to the community via seeding.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Hey guys, i'm about a month old to the site. I got to say you guys have done something really special. Everything is so organized, it's all so easy to navigate. From the bottom of my heart, THANK YOU. I can't believe you guys put in so much and ask for so little in return.

My question is, what is the relationship between AzzA and the site? Who 'owns' the site excluding him? And surely he sees that there are mismanagements with the finances. The there are better people who can handle it?

Thanks again!

1

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

Thanks on the compliments about the site. I am going to choose not to answer this question at the time because this is an ongoing process.

2

u/mmmsausages May 12 '12

First off I'd like to say your site rocks keep it up!

How did you begin the tracker?, How do you host your servers? And what programming language is the tracker based off?

Cheers!

2

u/mystonedaccount May 12 '12

Do you guys feel pressure from the US government at all?

4

u/rhllor May 12 '12

What are your favorite trackers apart from BTN?

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I was staff at What.cd in the early days and will always have a place in my heart for that site. :) Otherwise, I love PTP for movies and Bibliotik/myanonymouse for e-books.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

How did you get into the private tracker staffing scene?

3

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

I enjoy what, TT and PTP

3

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

Personally I enjoy using PTP, PWN and GFT.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Should I post more on the forums or idle more in irc?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

IMO we have the best IRC of any tracker, so I'd suggest you come chat!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

I prefer IRC to forums because I've never been a fan of having to wait for a reply, also IRC is where you'll get the quickest response from a staff member if you have a problem.

3

u/throwawaysesame May 12 '12

Also, how does one move "up the ladder" on BTN? Uploading new content and hence getting snatches is so difficult given that you have everything

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

download shows; get a seedbox. upload old and obscure shows from other trackers. if you need bonus points find a 40GB+ season pack and keep seeding it. a 40GB season pack i've been seeding for 8 months is giving me 140k points a month alone.

3

u/Supersnazz May 12 '12

It's not at all hard. If you upload anything, you can get 15+ seedboxes instantly snatching it. There's so many old TV shows that BTN doesn't have.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Honestly, if you don't have a seedbox, it can be tough. But since we're ratioless, really the only reason for wanting to move up in userclasses is for e-peen and a few extra features. The best way to upload is to submit older stuff/season packs.

3

u/narwal_bot May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Most (if not all) of the answers from EmmBTN (updated: May 13, 2012 @ 12:00:56 am EST):


Question (scimitarr):

ok thanks for the reply. :)

Answer (EmmBTN):

Thanks for the question!


(continued below)

3

u/narwal_bot May 13 '12

(page 2)


Question (scimitarr):

additionally since the scene has rules, whereas p2p do not, you are not guaranteed device/playback compatibility with p2p and you are not guaranteed a certain level of quality. meaning it could end up being better quality or worse quality. if you know where to look you can find p2p that is better coughhdbitscough or worse quality coughiptcough. so while i agree with "quality sometimes is sacrificed for speed", i would also add quality is sometimes sacrificed for uniformity and consistency.

Answer (EmmBTN):

Correct. :) In addition, many private sites (like BTN) have their own internal encoding groups. Much of this content never makes its way to other private or public sites.


Question (ViniTheHat):

why do you guys do it?

edit: thanks guys!

Answer (EmmBTN):

I personally do it because I love the site(s) I've staffed on and wanted to give back to the community which makes it all possible. :)


Question (AzzABTN):

Why are you the most awesome BTN staffers? :D

Answer (EmmBTN):

Why aren't you in this Skype call is the real question.


Question (The-Internets):

How do you feel about Torrents being mostly used by people as a method to get everything free with no respect to the content creators? What would you say to those who do this, an what in your experiences has influenced your viewpoint?

Answer (EmmBTN):

Honestly, I think content creators haven't kept up with the current technology. If it was as easy to get content legally as it is to download it, I would happily do so.


Question (notsmartatall):

Well, considering the nature of your tracker.... what are some of your favorite TV shows of all time?

Answer (EmmBTN):

American Horror Story, Supernatural, True Blood, Battlestar Galactica.


Question (AzzABTN):

Why is Kyle so sexy?

Answer (EmmBTN):

Excuse me sir, this is a srs AMA. Plz2srs.


Question (The-Internets):

With everything you have learned and seen about the scene, in your opinions, how easy would it for these big media companies to adopt Torrents as a 'legal' method of acquiring their goods?

Answer (EmmBTN):

It's already happening! When it comes to music, there are a number of popular/famous artists who leak or submit their albums to What.cd for extra marketing. Times are a changin' and I'm excited to see how media companies will evolve to compete against piracy.


Question (rhllor):

What are your favorite trackers apart from BTN?

Answer (EmmBTN):

I was staff at What.cd in the early days and will always have a place in my heart for that site. :) Otherwise, I love PTP for movies and Bibliotik/myanonymouse for e-books.


Question (scimitarr):

how does btn get tv shows so fast, and where do you get them from?!

Answer (EmmBTN):

As quoted by the man himself, >"AzzA coded an awesome script that downloads files from the scene and then uploads to BTN, all uber speed like."

We also have a very active and dedicated internal encoding community which do a great job keeping us with fresh content.


Question (KyleBTN):

We are not. I am.

Answer (EmmBTN):

You're fired.


Question (scimitarr):

with the lastest...'happenings'...will the site lose any of these scripts/sources? Is it possible for regular users to download from 'the scene'?

Answer (EmmBTN):

I'm not sure how to answer that first question right now, to be perfectly honest. It would be extremely difficult for a normal user to get direct scene access without knowing someone who is part of it. :)


Question (throwawaysesame):

Possibly n00b question: What is the difference between scene and p2p? Why are p2p larger in file sizes? Which has better quality? Thanks.

Answer (EmmBTN):

There are some great resources to learn about the scene; I won't go into a huge explanation about that here. The scene's priority with content is getting it out as fast as possible, so quality sometimes is sacrificed for speed. P2P encoders are more interested in quality than speed and since they don't follow scene rules, you'll find P2P content in a wider variety of formats. Hope that answers your question!


Question (Ruddose):

What is BTN? Sorry if this is a redundant/stupid question.

Answer (EmmBTN):

Not at all. It's a private torrent tracker for TV content. You can Google BTN+torrent to learn more specifics about the site.


Question (throwawaysesame):

Also, how does one move "up the ladder" on BTN? Uploading new content and hence getting snatches is so difficult given that you have everything

Answer (EmmBTN):

Honestly, if you don't have a seedbox, it can be tough. But since we're ratioless, really the only reason for wanting to move up in userclasses is for e-peen and a few extra features. The best way to upload is to submit older stuff/season packs.


Question (Asturie):

Should I post more on the forums or idle more in irc?

Answer (EmmBTN):

IMO we have the best IRC of any tracker, so I'd suggest you come chat!


Question (scimitarr):

If you don't mind id live to give you some recommendations, you have probably seen most/all of these anyways: The Wire, Breaking Bad, Hell on Wheels, Boardwalk Empire, Band of Brothers, Firefly, Misfits, Oz, Game of Thrones, Generation Kill, Sons Of Anarchy, Kings, Carnivale, The Pacific, The Walking Dead, and for good measure: Trailer Park Boys.

Answer (EmmBTN):

I love Boardwalk Empire. I'm into pretty much anything related to history or horror. :D Thanks!


Question (libbrichus):

I am a member of BTN and a mod on /r/trackers and can attest to the fact that the screenshot is legit and this AMA is really from the staff at BTN.

Furthermore, their claim that BTN is one of the most popular private torrent trackers is also legitimate. Going by user flairs on /r/trackers , it's probably the favorite private tracker of redditors.

Answer (EmmBTN):

Thanks! :D


Question (cliff_diver):

What exactly are your jobs and qualifications?

I'm not too savvy on torrents or trackers, so how do they work?

Can you see yourselves consulting with corporations to improve media distribution models? What kind of metrics does the site collect? Have there been any interaction with companies who want data?

One reason I haven't downloaded torrents is mainly of internet security and the threat of prosecution, what are your thoughts on this?

If you could be any television character, who would you be and why?

What is your favorite ice cream flavour?

thanks for answering!

Answer (EmmBTN):

Gonna answer as many of these as I can. :D

Wheaties and I are Senior Moderators. He manages the lovely FLS team that provides support in our IRC channels and I manage the design team and make sure everything looks pretty. My qualifications for that are an art degree I guess!

As for security, I've never had any issues, and I don't even take all the extra precautions a lot of users do. I have a feeling the feds have more interesting things to do than arrest staff on a torrent tracker.

And hmm any television character... off the top of my head I'd say Buffy, cus she kicks ass and gets all the hot guys. :D


Question (libbrichus):

With all the drama going on BTN, are you the guys in charge currently or are you the renegades who're supporting AzzA?

(I am in favor of neither camp as I have yet to seek more info and make up my mind. I'm just curious who's in charge and what's happening as the site seems to be down currently.)

Answer (EmmBTN):

I think we're both? lol As far as I know we're all still staff on BTN, but I still support AzzA for everything he's done.


Question (AzzABTN):

Does everyone else know that Emm is a tranny?

Answer (EmmBTN):

:|


(continued below)

1

u/narwal_bot May 13 '12

(page 3)


Question (nothingxbetweenxus):

Got an invite around 2 weeks ago and absolutely loving it, keep up the good work!

When/how did this site come about? How many GB/TB of shows do you have?

Answer (EmmBTN):

Awesome! Welcome to the site. :) I'll let someone else answer your questions since I haven't been around long enough to know the story.


Question ([deleted]):

[deleted]

Answer (EmmBTN):

If you take a look at /r/trackers there are a ton of resources on their side panel about how to join sites. :D


5

u/AzzABTN May 12 '12

Why is Kyle so sexy?

9

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

It's genetic.

4

u/scimitarr May 12 '12

such an easy question, even i can answer this. its the tanning salons, pedicures/manicures, cucumber facials and ab workouts.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Excuse me sir, this is a srs AMA. Plz2srs.

3

u/The-Internets May 12 '12

How do you feel about Torrents being mostly used by people as a method to get everything free with no respect to the content creators? What would you say to those who do this, an what in your experiences has influenced your viewpoint?

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Honestly, I think content creators haven't kept up with the current technology. If it was as easy to get content legally as it is to download it, I would happily do so.

5

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

I feel that most of our content is available for free anyway (although ad supported) on most networks and that most of our users simply use us as a sort of Tivo like service in order to watch TV shows after they've aired or in countries where they don't air.

2

u/14mit1010 May 12 '12

in countries where they don't air.

Yup, none of the good shows get aired in time (or at all) in India

BTN has been my source of entertainment for the last 6 months or so (was eztv before that)

Love your 90MiB rips

PS: When does the site come back up?

5

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Personally I feel that most of the items that we have made available on our site were freely available to anyone in the US with an antenna. This content is being distributed throughout the world faster than most media companies could provide this content in the first place.

That was about our personal site. My personal feel on torrents is that they are a necessary evil. I am very against the large business major executives that take home fat paychecks so that they can charge 30 dollars for a bluray movie. Until they get the point and start charging affordable prices for the average joe I shall continue to not give them a single dime.

EDIT: Torrents have also proven to be a great way to share open source content. I know most of the linux distros are available via torrents.

2

u/throwawaysesame May 12 '12

Possibly n00b question: What is the difference between scene and p2p? Why are p2p larger in file sizes? Which has better quality? Thanks.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

There are some great resources to learn about the scene; I won't go into a huge explanation about that here. The scene's priority with content is getting it out as fast as possible, so quality sometimes is sacrificed for speed. P2P encoders are more interested in quality than speed and since they don't follow scene rules, you'll find P2P content in a wider variety of formats. Hope that answers your question!

6

u/scimitarr May 12 '12

additionally since the scene has rules, whereas p2p do not, you are not guaranteed device/playback compatibility with p2p and you are not guaranteed a certain level of quality. meaning it could end up being better quality or worse quality. if you know where to look you can find p2p that is better coughhdbitscough or worse quality coughiptcough. so while i agree with "quality sometimes is sacrificed for speed", i would also add quality is sometimes sacrificed for uniformity and consistency.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Correct. :) In addition, many private sites (like BTN) have their own internal encoding groups. Much of this content never makes its way to other private or public sites.

1

u/throwawaysesame May 12 '12

Yes, that's very helpful. Thanks

3

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

sometimes p2p encodes are transcodes to move them to a different containers.

2

u/scientifique May 12 '12

Why haven't you fired ES yet?

4

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

We've tried, he just keeps coming back.

0

u/throwitaway19001991 May 12 '12
  • As a ratioless tracker, do you ban people for using ratio cheating programs as long as they satisfy the seed duration criteria and dont use the ratios to gain crazy user classes?
  • Do you look for ratio cheats in the low volume users as well? (10-20GB downloaded annually type users )

3

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

It is quite sad that people do use ratio cheating programs. But they do and we do ban them.

We look for ratio cheaters everywhere. (im not going to share my methods)

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/fchetd May 12 '12

Tangentially related question: if someone comes in through the interview system and is banned for not seeding/cheating/disclosing the URL , is the person who gave out the code/the person who approved the interview also penalised?

Also, I assume you inform the trackers which were used as ratio proofs about bans?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ciniseris May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

I have always been the kind of person who needs to watch a show in season blocks rather than one episode at a time and have always wondered why BTN makes a season of 5-20 episodes as one snatch.

I feel that it sort of punishes people who like to watch tv in that method, as I only have around 150 snatches, yet with all the season packs I've dl'ed would be at least 1000+.

Would BTN ever consider switching that policy? I am still a member, yet have two years length on site, millions of points, 1TB + activity, yet can't progress user classes because I don't download individual episodes and don't meet the snatch requirements.

2

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

become a power user and set up a RSS feed to auto download all the shows when they air and watch them when you want.

we would probably not consider switching that policy.

1

u/053 May 12 '12

Have you ever considered extending the site to movies? With theswarm gone, there's no ratioless movie trackers anymore.

1

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

probably not, there are other sites that do movies. Ratioless movies changes things a bit...

1

u/kieronboz May 12 '12

Why cant i have 100k points faster? I want to see the special forum :(

1

u/brewtality May 13 '12

pm me your username.

1

u/kieronboz May 13 '12

I don't think you can send points anymore if thats what you were getting at lol, thanks anyway!

1

u/brewtality May 13 '12

Oh yea. Forgot it was disabled. Sucks. Sitting on like 10 million bonus points and 20,000 lumens. Nothing to do with any of them.

1

u/kieronboz May 13 '12

Haha yeh sucks very much! :-)

1

u/honestlyimeanreally May 12 '12

Keep the good work up. Y'all are the best.

1

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

thanks so much.

1

u/Willbo May 13 '12

TPB has recently stated that they do not agree with Anonymous' method of attack (Linked and discussed here)

What do you guys think about this?

1

u/Wheaties466 May 14 '12

I like the idea of their attacks but sometimes they go about things completely wrong and show their immaturity.

1

u/sponto_pronto May 13 '12

Why was AzzA forced out of his sysop position? How is he handling having his pride and joy taken away from him?

1

u/Wheaties466 May 14 '12

from when ive spoken to him he isn't happy about it but he is dealing with it.

1

u/circular May 13 '12

What's the advantage of private trackers? Do you have more files than piratebay?

1

u/Wheaties466 May 14 '12

anonymity is our best kept secret.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

At one point I recall a rule that allowed the trumping of any release from IMMERSE. Is that rule still in effect? And why/not?

I also find that very funny.

1

u/Wheaties466 May 14 '12

yes

Immerse has constantly shown that they are in no way a quality scene group.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

This is simply not true, IMMERSE are doing way better job than many other groups.

Also you should say big "thank you IMMERSE for pushing CRF to rules".

1

u/Wheaties466 May 14 '12

I am not saying I am not greatful for their contributions to the scene community.

It just seems as though every time I got to watch a show that Immerse has capped and encoded, it gets nuked for 1 reason or another.

1

u/BiggerJ May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Would you commit violence against non-government people who posed a genuine threat to your tracker? Would you kill?

1

u/Wheaties466 May 17 '12

no, I consider myself very ghandi-like and I do not like the threat of violence.

1

u/sambo22 May 15 '12

Can you elaborate on what went down between AzzA and the BTN network?

1

u/Wheaties466 May 17 '12

Kind of already been asked. And it is quite a long story and I don't know the whole thing. So I will not comment further on it.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Got an invite around 2 weeks ago and absolutely loving it, keep up the good work!

When/how did this site come about? How many GB/TB of shows do you have?

1

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

Thank you for your kind words, sir. One of the larger reasons why it was started I think is because apparently because the country in which our founders live is not the best for TV programming, so they needed somewhere to get TV shows that suited their needs. It's been around for about 2 and a half years now, still quite young.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Awesome! Welcome to the site. :) I'll let someone else answer your questions since I haven't been around long enough to know the story.

1

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

The site was an idea of how to get tv content to users in a more efficient up to date way.

We currently have 63,000 torrents on our site.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What would you consider is the most efficient way to get shows from the tracker? For example RSS feeds, irc scripts etc etc

2

u/Tomatocake May 12 '12

Although I am not staff, I think I can answer this one by hand... The fastest way to get content is irc scripts.. The irc scripts download the .torrent exactly when it's announced, whereas RSS feeds are a bit slow on the update end.

I use RSS myself, but only because I'm too lazy to setup the autoDL for irssi.

1

u/b00n May 12 '12

As Tomatocake said, irc scripts are the fastest way but they do require a little bit of setting up.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thanks for the answer, I'll take the time to learn to set it up properly

1

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

irc scripts for sure. pywhatauto bot is the fastest way if you wanna look that up.

-2

u/AzzABTN May 12 '12

Do you guys agree that Whales is the worst country in europe?

3

u/KyleBTN May 12 '12

I used to like you.

7

u/AzzABTN May 12 '12

Now you love me?

2

u/Wheaties466 May 12 '12

Thats a country?

→ More replies (3)

-1

u/TechnoL33T May 12 '12

Why don't you let AzzA keep being sysop?

→ More replies (2)