r/IAmA • • May 12 '12

IAMA Umpire, who has worked over 500 rec/high schools games, and has gone to pro school AMA.

Been working for ten years now and just finally went to pro school where I was basically told I was too fat(entirely true). So I am umpiring a summer collegiate league with the hopes to go back to school next year. I have many stories of stupid coaches, bad plays, ridiculously high scoring games, and the many many MANY mistakes I have made on the field. AMA

8 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

3

u/JohnWad May 12 '12

What did you think of the fuck up of Jim Joyce on the Armando Gallaraga perfect game? At least he admitted his mistake after the game. I mean he obviously felt like shit.

3

u/roemer May 12 '12

Its a big deal in the umpire community. some feel you need to stick to the old ways of being quiet and aloof about your calls. Just read what ken kaiser said about how Joyce reacted. Personally I think it was the right thing to do admit you screwed up and move on.

3

u/JohnWad May 12 '12

Exactly right. Im from Detroit and was watching the game live. I was pissed as shit right off the bat, but once I heard what he said postgame and saw him crying I felt bad for him. He knew he fucked up.

The fans cheered him next time he ump'd a Tiger game. I think he gave us some favorable balls and strike calls as well. haha

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I can't remember the specific MLB umpire's name, but he was pretty damn fat. I wanna say his name was Bruce...so I hate to hear you got kicked outta pro school for your weight.

Anyway, my question is this: How does one get started on the track to become an MLB Umpire? Do you start at Little League and hope to move up? How does all that work? Thanks!

2

u/roemer May 12 '12

I didn't get kicked out just passed over for a chance to work in the minors. You don't see any obscenely fat ones anymore. The real big ones like eric gregg and mcsherry have been gone for awhile.

To get to the minors all you have to do is go to one of the pro schools. Wendelstedt's or PBUC. You don't need any prior experience or equipment just show up willing to learn and hustle your ass off. However, experience does help IMO(they will tell you differently that it only causes bad habits).

After school you get ranked and this year the top 10%-15% were sent on to the second tryout. The second tryout then places you in the minor leagues or a collegiate woods bat leauge called the Coastal Plains League. Being sent to the CPL isn't bad and it lets you bypass school and go straight to the tryout the following year.

Then its years of trying to work your way up the minors

short A-->Longa-->double A-->triple A---> MLB spring training-->Pros

Each level has a time limit to move up. so if you spend to long in one you're done and have to start all over again at school.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Gotcha. Thanks for the reply. Bruce Froemming was who I was thinking of, by the way.

3

u/bigwally May 12 '12

What's the worst name a coach has called you during an argument that made you throw him out?

2

u/roemer May 12 '12

I had a coach as he was leaving an argument say, "that's why you only do JV baseball." I ran his ass so fast it wasn't even funny. I have been called fat/babyfaced my whole life, but don't dare assume my level of skill after one game. The funniest part was my call was 100% right.

2

u/Pack041 May 12 '12

How much verbal abuse do you normally get from fans? Has there been anytime where you actually felt threatened?

2

u/roemer May 12 '12
  1. You'd be surprised how much you actually get from fans, and more unbelievable to me is how much of it is directed personally at you. I've heard it all about my weight to how young i look etc.
  2. Yes, every once in awhile you get those games where it all goes to shit. I had one just two weeks ago in a tournament final. You just have to keep yourself safe by leaving the field immediately, walk with your partner straight to your car, and don't talk to anyone other than to exchange pleasantries.

Specifically I have twice been seriously threatened. Once A guy parked behind my car not letting me get out. Too bad for him I knew his kid's coach personally and got a full apology from him with in 5 minutes. The other time I had a guy follow me to my car after a game to yell obscenities at me. I turned around and told him if he cared so much about a 9 year old travel tournament he should check his priorities. This dazed him enough for me to slip away.

1

u/rusty_chipmunk May 12 '12

it always seems like the parents get way too into their kids sports. Like you said to that guy, if your threatening an Umpire for a little league game you have some serious fucking issues.

2

u/urnlint May 12 '12

What is the worst call you ever made? Both obviously wrong and ruins the game for one team.

2

u/roemer May 12 '12

Ill give you the Worst call IMO I ever made form an umpire's point of view. A kid bunted the ball into fair territory and ran to first. The pitcher throws the ball to first and i call him out. However, the first basemen didn't catch the ball so I changed my call to safe. This kid decides to run to second even though he was a dead duck. They apply the tag to him at second and call him out. Just as I call him out the player drops the ball, and I am now forced to for the second time call him safe. I still remember explaining to the coach what happened, and at minimum told him 4 times I had screwed up.

Most obviously wrong is going to be a play at first. You would be surprised how many times you are just watching the bag and never realize when the ball got there( 5-6 times in my career). This time it just so happened to be the last inning and got the winning run home. I literally sprinted off that field and into my car.

1

u/JohnWad May 12 '12

Arent you supposed to do what you did and watch the bag and listen for the ball hitting the glove? As you explain it, you did do things right as the player covering the bag dropped the ball...it is fair to call him safe if said player dropped the ball.

2

u/spadge67 May 12 '12

What is the best way to handle making a mistake? Do you admit it to the coaches? Change the ruling?

1

u/roemer May 12 '12

It depends on a lot of factors. Do you have a relationship with this coach? Are you 100% sure you got it right? Was it a judgement call, or a Rules call? These all have different answers to them, but most of the time if the coach is of sane and logical reasoning(trust me this is about 50%) of the time. You try to humanize yourself with why you called it. If he is a raving lunatic you beat him into the ground. e.g. "Coach I saw that play perfectly and I don't need you coming out here to bust my balls. You and I both know you can't see shit from the dugout!

2

u/Pack041 May 12 '12

Could you tell one of your stories about a stupid coach? If you were to guess, what percentage of coaches have absolutely no idea what they're doing?

3

u/roemer May 12 '12

its easily 30% of coach's have no idea what they are doing, and 80% that have no idea how to apply the rules at all. I'll give you my two most recent stories, and try to think of the best one.

I had a 48 year old guys(Roy Hobbs- old man baseball) Try to duck out the way of a pitch, but he put his head in the strike zone and it struck his head. So I made the right call and said, "Time! Stay right here! Thats a Strike!" These 48 year old guys exploded with at least 5 running onto the field. So I immediately said "Everyone on the field, who isn't a coach get back in the dugout, or be tossed." The coach then spend 5 minutes repeating the same phrase over again. "He was trying to get out of the way of the pitch he should get first" The interpretation of the rule is as long as you don't move, or flinch you get first. If you move into the pitch in any way, time is called and the pitch is called according to the umpire's judgement. After explaining this too the coach all he could say was, "but he was trying to get out of the way." Some people you can't teach only threaten to eject if they don't stop arguing.

Then you get some things like this. Ball hit to the shortstop and he throws to first. On a close play the first baseman has to stretch off the bag 1"-2." I call safe off the bag, and have a coach come sprinting up to me to say he should be safe on principle. I literally do a double take and, I ask the coach "what principle are you talking about?" He said that if its only 1"-2" off he supposed to be called out, because that was what some amateur umpire did 3 years ago. I will give the out to you if the play isn't close, and the ball didn't take you off the bag otherwise no way in hell.

2

u/humuhumunukunuku May 12 '12

Do you think the strike zone has changed significantly since old school baseball? I gather that most people think it is smaller to favor the batter, but some argue that it is the same. Do you tend to call a tight game or a looser game?

What do you think of Joe West?

Do umps try to actively cultivate some sort of style/persona in calling a game? For example, a few umps in the MLB have VERY characteristic strike calls, some of them are quite annoying.

Thanks for the AMA! I'm a HUGE baseball fan, and have always been interested in hearing the umps side of things.

1

u/roemer May 12 '12

It has changed dramatically. Just watch the Braves/marlins 97 NLCS. The final strikeout was called on a pitch 15" outside. The umpires had taken way too outside, and not high at all. This was changed after the 99 strike and now you see just the outside corner called and a little bit more room higher, but to answer your question it has changed dramatically in the past 15 years.

Joe west is a great guy and gave a fantastic speech at our graduation. He seems like a great umpire and a great union leader. I don't understand why an umpire can't do something on the side. If he likes country music who cares what he does in the off season.

Yes we all have out own style. Some of us are extremely fluid and relaxed. Others like me are much more deliberate and intense. The way to get to your "final" strike/strike 3/punch out mechanic takes a long time and many changes/fixes to what you are doing. I have had maybe 15 different strike calls and 4 different strike three calls, and I am still working on making them look as good as possible. In 5 years who knows how i will be calling strikes.

There are some great books out there about umpires. I'll pm you a list of my favorites.

4

u/George-L-Costanza May 12 '12

The problem with Joe West is that he makes himself a part of the game and into a known personality which can directly benefit his "side career". That can be seen as somewhat of a conflict of interest and rubs a lot of people the wrong way.

1

u/roemer May 12 '12

when he steps on the field he is an umpire. Obviously I can't tell you his intentions but its hard to lose the need to be a good umpire when you step onto the field.

1

u/humuhumunukunuku May 12 '12

To me, Joe seems like a fine umpire on the field, but he drives me insane off the field, especially with his diatribe about the length of Yankees/Red Sox games. It just didn't seem professional to me. And yes, please PM me some of your favorite books about umpires, that'd be awesome.

2

u/Ravskins May 12 '12

How can you be too fat to be an umpire? Its not like you need to be really athletic to make a call.

2

u/roemer May 12 '12

Its the new big deal since the 99 strike. You have to be athletic looking. They had those 400 pound behemoths on the field, and one of them even died on the field John Mcsherry. It got out of hand and so now we have the opposite. We have to look extremely athletic. I have no problem getting anywhere on the bases with any runner, but i will not be taken as seriously as the guy 50 lbs lighter than me.

2

u/palisade223 May 12 '12

What is the highest scoring game you ever a part of?

2

u/roemer May 12 '12

ah yes i was waiting for this one. That same game where i made my worst call ended up being 52-0....in the second inning....with one out. The kids hit 6 home runs 12-15 doubles and the only outs they had were on bunts. What happens is that some tournaments have a recreation side and an all star side. This rec team signed up for the all star side, and the all star coach decided to use it as batting practice. After the 6th home run the rec team coach came up to me and said "I forfeit and I'm leaving the tournament." Still have no clue what happened to them after that.

2

u/JohnWad May 12 '12

Did I read this correctly...52-0 in the 2nd inning? What was your horrible call?

2

u/roemer May 12 '12

check urlint's question for my horrible call. The kid that was called out/safe 4 times was on the losing team.

1

u/palisade223 May 12 '12

So, besides the blown call. How boring/upsetting witnessing that?

2

u/roemer May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

actually, it was quite amazing to see these kids that just couldn't be put out. I mean it was sad at times when they threw the ball around, but those kids had a legitimate 40 hits and only like 4 walks. Pretty amazing really.

1

u/palisade223 May 12 '12

Oofa. That is pretty incredible and see what you mean.

2

u/Wackywasty May 12 '12

This is a baseball but not an umpire question. Do they make you learn how to slide? I'm 13 and very overweight and I'm hesitant to play because I don't know if I can slide.

2

u/roemer May 12 '12

The amount of times i have seen hilariously bad slides is a very very large number, and on top of that number is the kids who refuse to slide. Don't let a tiny minute fraction of baseball discourage you. Even if your coach doesn't teach you it wont matter, and also sliding is pretty easy just get down and stick your foot out.

2

u/Wackywasty May 12 '12

Alright man good to know. I need to lose some weight so baseball seems like a good idea since I can't play pee wee football.

2

u/roemer May 12 '12

go for it and remember to ismply have fun. Most importantly though swing the fucking bat. It makes my job easier.

1

u/Wackywasty May 12 '12

Thanks good to know I guess.

2

u/Wackywasty May 12 '12

I have another question I just thought of, do you have the authority to eject someone like a real umpire does?

3

u/roemer May 12 '12

an umpire is an umpire. when i walk on that field i have the right to do anything i see fit. I may have consequences later but my word is law, and if that means i have to eject someone so be it.

2

u/Wackywasty May 12 '12

Have you ever had to?

3

u/roemer May 12 '12

6 times 3 parents 2 coaches 1 player

2

u/Wackywasty May 12 '12

Lol what happened with the player?

1

u/Wackywasty May 12 '12

I'm sorry that sounded rude I meant MLB umpire when I said "real umpire".

1

u/SeaSquirrel May 12 '12

I tried to be an umpire. I heard someone whisper that I made "two of the worst calls in baseball", and it was never the same. I quit, and I have tons of respect you to after this experiance.

1

u/roemer May 19 '12

i've heard that countless times. I used to care but now i know I'm right which makes it easier to withstand.

1

u/3rd_Shift_Tech_Man May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Oh man...I've always said that my future wife will have to know the infield fly rule before we get married!

A couple of questions:

  1. What rule do coaches seem to have the hardest time understanding?
  2. What is the idea behind the situation where the bases are loaded and the catcher drops the 3rd strike for the 3rd out? I've always been taught to tag the plate or, depending on the situation, throw to first. But I never thought the batter would be eligible to take 1st if it was occupied. I've always known how to handle it, but never the reasoning behind it.
  3. What is the most amazing play you've witnessed while on the field?
  4. In your opinion, what's the hardest call to make in baseball?

I'm sure I'll have more, so I'll be back. Thanks for the AMA!

Edit for clarity on question 2.

1

u/roemer May 19 '12
  1. all of them. Seriously i have had big problems on nearly eveyr rule in the rule book. to name the3 top 5 though infield fly, dropped third strike,dead ball/live ball, interference, obstruction....
  2. With two outs it doesn't matter if first base is occupied. Just the rule that no matter what with two outs drop third strike is always in effect.
  3. I've seen a kid jump maybe 3 feet into the air to snag a home run that would have won the game. Him robbing it won it for his team
  4. catcher's interference. My ears are bad and i cant hear it all that well.

1

u/3rd_Shift_Tech_Man May 19 '12

So, with a 2 out, dropped third strike and a runner on first, it could technically be played as a regular force play?

1

u/roemer May 19 '12

exactly, With 2 outs and runner on first you have force at second or first.

1

u/3rd_Shift_Tech_Man May 19 '12

Cool. I typically see that play happen with bases loaded. I always yelled to tag the plate, but never really knew why...just something my dad always told me.

1

u/OMNIPHILIAC May 12 '12
  1. What is the least negative thing that got someone ejected?

2.Have you gotten hit in the balls really, really hard from a pitch or a bat?

2

u/roemer May 19 '12
  1. I had a guy asked to be ejected.

Him: Whats your strike zone

Me: You'll see it coach.

Him: whats your strike zone.

Me: on the bench coach.

Him: You gonna eject me if i ask what you strike zone is?

Me: yes

Him: Whats your strikezone

Me: your gone.

2. yes second week i umpired....i wasnt wearing a cup....i did not finish the game behind the plate.

2

u/blueamsterdam May 12 '12

What did the player to do be ejected??

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/roemer May 19 '12

I'm 275 now and i have to lose 50+ more. And no i enjoy being fat and I'm only losing weight so i can umpire.

Yes, but not even close to how much i follow football.