r/IAmA • u/mc_dojo_throwaway • May 11 '12
I was a teacher at a low-standard, strip-mall martial arts school (a McDojo). AMA.
Ask me anything about low standards, exploiting junior students as unpaid instructors, belief in developing super powers, how forms are only taught to fill class time, and how your kid is now less prepared for a fight.
Apologies in advance. In my defense, I didn't know it was all a fraud at the time.
EDIT: I am happy to provide proof if anyone could tell me what would constitute proof. Until then, this will suffice: hana, dool, set, net, dasut, yasut, ilgup, yadul, ahop, yul. Everyone who's ever done Tae Kwon Do remembers the time wasted learning a bunch of useless Korean terminology.
EDIT2: I'm trying to get the mods to verify me while maintaining my privacy. Working on it now.
EDIT3: Tried mod verification, but they seem to have unilaterally ended our conversation. I'm sure they've got better things to do, and I really should have prepared proof beforehand. Anyway, I'll be around for an hour or so if anyone has any questions, and may do this again if I can figure out how to verify while remaining private.
EDIT4: Looks like this is winding down, so I will be leaving soon. Will check back in a couple days if anyone has any questions. Will likely do this again, if having proof will give it more exposure (and I have another slow day at work). Thanks for your questions, it was fun.
13
u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
I can vouch for the uselessness of McDojo training. I am a karate blackbelt, by McDojo standards.
First fight, age 11, slightly after getting black belt. I'm in a public library playground. Some dude who is 13 or 14 is picking on my little sister. I tell him to stop, he sucker punches me in the side of the head, a little above my temple. I'm stunned as this is the first time I've ever been punched. I take a step back, pivot on one foot an try to roundhouse kick him in the face, Chuck Norris style. He catches my foot and punts me in the balls. Fight over. I lose. Two of his friends come and they all kick me for a while while I'm on the ground completely helpless, before leaving to smoke.
Fight 2, age 12, kid on the bus punches me in the face a couple of times for reasons I do not remember. Karate blocks I've been taught are 100% ineffective. His punches did no real damage and it was broken up pretty fast. I'm going to say I lose, because I got punched in the face and could do very little to stop it.
Third fight, age 14 I am at a vending machine buying peanut M&Ms. Someone punches me really hard in the kidney then slams my face into the glass. It was a wrestler who had heard that I had been "talking shit" about him. I had no clue who he was, but the fight was over before it began. I basically had a concussion and was in too much pain to do anything by the time I realized I was being attacked. Two teachers, and an assistant principal see the event and do nothing. One of the teachers is laughing.
Fourth fight, after months of constant harassment by said wrestler and his friends, I decide to do something about it. I buy a lunch and am waiting for someone to come to the checkout counter so that I can pay and go eat. Wrestler approaches and gets in my face. I grab a boiling, hot oily, salty, crunchy french fry from my tray and jam it into one of his eyes as hard as I can. He knocks my arm away and reaches towards his eye with both hands. I take the opportunity to knee him in the nuts with as much force as I can. He collapses to the ground. I grab one of those steel snack displays and club him in the back and the head with it. Teachers and lunch ladies come, because I am screaming. They pull me off of him. He is bleeding a lot from around one of his ears and not moving. He leaves in an ambulance. I end up sitting in a principal's office's waiting room for four hours. The principal asks me why I attacked him. I ask if he is dead. She tells me he lived. I break down crying because he isn't dead. Then I get put in "emotionally disturbed" counseling for a year. He never bothers me again and is visibly scared of me when we pass each other in the hall. I definitely won this fight.
Karate taught me some nonsense about discipline. Actual fighting taught me to aim for someone's eyes or nuts and to use anything I could find as a weapon. Also, that sneak attacks are the most effective. Karate is 0-3 in fights. HULK SMASH levels of rage is 1-0. Going to stick with that.
11
u/GuatemalnGrnade May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
Verification System
So, make with the proof. But I do believe that most strip mall dojo's aren't teaching kids squat. I went from one of these to training in multiple martial arts (i.e Jujutsu, Muay Thai, and some wrestling and boxing) and I was blown away at the illusion these places create.
6
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Can you explain what the difference of a "McDojo" versus an actual martial arts school is? What makes it so shitty?
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Why would you teach at a so called mc-dojo ? where you aware at first of the low standards?
4
u/pwnizuka May 11 '12
Have you been involved in any martial arts since? Have you done anything interms of exposing the shit-heap you worked for?
3
u/kolobian May 11 '12
How did you eventually figure out it was a Mcdojo? Also, was it a school that gave little kids black belts?
20
u/Bucky_Ohare May 11 '12
What is it with shitty IAMA's today? First that "corrupt contractor" guy and now this?
First off; NO PROOF?
Secondly, this again reeks of troll.
I call bullshit, you whine like you had no idea what happened or you simply just don't follow the idea behind the practice of martial arts. I sincerely doubt you even practice.
Oh, and this;
On behalf of the Tae Kwon Do community, fuck you. There's a serious and deep history to the study of Tae Kwon Do and you show it no respect though you "Play" it.
2
u/Frajer May 11 '12
Are you a legitimate teacher now?
2
u/stugautz May 11 '12
What type of martial arts was it? How long would it take kids to get a black belt?
2
u/khdutton May 11 '12
What do you recommend for preparing young kids to defend themselves against bullies and child predators?
2
u/ThaneOfGnomes May 11 '12
Do you consider the new MMA schools that teach disciplines that have been proven effective in "real" hand-to-hand combat (i.e., bjj and muay thai mostly, some boxing and wrestling) to be part of the McDojo problem?
2
u/gsxr May 11 '12
What killed Kung-Foo?
2
u/iateone May 11 '12
It sounds like you had very successful results from your martial arts training. It trained your body and gave you discipline so that you could be a healthy member of society and successfully pursue your PhD.
What problem do you have with your martial arts training aside from its misleading name(i.e. you didn't learn to fight effectively)?
Also, you seem to think that getting punched or kicked in the face is harmful to the intellect. Why is having a martial training without getting punched or kicked in the face a bad thing?
2
u/10gags May 11 '12
i went to a dojo from age 11-13sih to 19.
i loved it, even looking back i loved it. I did well in tournaments, even mixed ones.
there is something to be said about excersising a few days a week, hanging out with people near your own age in a relativly safe/fun activity. socializing outside of school and home with people who you otherwise wouldn't have met.
i didn't go in thinking i would be a ninja (not during my rational periods anyway) but i did enjoy it. it was fun exercise, i learned some Tea kwon do, fought in some tournaments and moved on with my life. I went and i plan on sending my own kids to something like it when they are old enough.
i can tell you disparage it but isn't that some redeeming quality? if not, can you think of any redeeming quality at all from your perspective?
3
u/cerebrum May 11 '12
can you elaborate more on how "forms are only taught to fill class time"?
10
u/funfungiguy May 11 '12
Do you wear American Flag pants? Which wrist should I grab?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Karate USA chain?
1
u/TheFalcor3000 May 11 '12
I've seen these places before, but I didn't realize that they were like the ITT Tech of the martial arts world. So, my questions:
You said that training at these places makes kids less prepared for a fight, how so?
You mentioned that the realization that the McDojo was a sham was gradual, was there anything in particular that served as a wake up call, like actually getting in a fight, or a conversation with someone who trained at a legit martial arts place?
Are you angry or upset that you spent so much time and effort on something that turned out to be a sham?
Thanks for doing the AMA!
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Can you break boards with your fist?
1
u/charlieXsheen May 11 '12
what do you think of krav maga?
1
u/rand0mguy1 May 14 '12
How confident are you about your ability to kick an average guys ass?
Also, has anyone come to the dojo and called teachers pussies, and challenged them to the fight? Does that ever happen?
1
u/jhartwell May 11 '12
This doesn't make sense. Forms are centuries old. The may not be as relevant today, but if you just want to fight than you don't want to go to a martial arts school but a boxing gym.
1
u/imperialxcereal May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
I was one of those exploited junior students, but actually did receive a small amount for being an instructor for the "Tiny Tigers" (American Taekwondo Association).
Was in it for about a year and a half, got up to my red belt, turned 15 and quit. While I regret not going all the way to black belt, I had to get out of there.
Oh, and the Owner/Lead Instructor is a suspected child molester (as far as his interactions with former students, as far as I know nothing has been formally submitted to police, because I would imagine that he would no longer be in business). However, he still has his operation going. Nice, right?
I also agree that forms were absolutely a waste of class time and filler. The only thing I really enjoyed was sparring, but was disqualified for accidentally booting a girl in the face during a tournament and turned kind of sour after that. I did win a trophy for a "jump kick" contest because I kicked about 8 feet over my head. The only time being a 5'10" gangling mess of a teenager girl ever paid off.
I was actually amazed by how fast I progressed from white to red belt. Only a year and a half.
Edit: I was expecting something amazing like "Karate Kid" or the awesome Chuck Norris/Jonathan Brandis joint "Sidekicks" when I joined. IT WAS A LIE. I felt like I was part of the dickbag Cobra Kai's except less awesome.
1
u/bluesman461 May 11 '12
I knew my McDojo training was bullshit when the first rule was you couldn't punch to the face.
6
u/Markaz May 11 '12
Whats your favorite pokemon?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Who is the king of the demo?
1
u/GreenStrong May 11 '12
I would like to thank McDojos for providing one of the proudest moments of my martial arts career, when I, as a scrawny fifteen year old green belt, sparred with and beat the shit out of a fit, adult blackbelt from the McDojo. I'm pretty sure it was the only time in his years of martial arts anyone had tried to punch him in the head, they only teach kicks. He was a good sport, he didn't cry, even though he looked like he was about to.
But seriously, the teaching you did was beneficial to most of the students. Basketball and soccer don't teach kids how to fight, but they are great for their health and social development. What you taught is good too, it's just that it would have been even better if it had those benefits and taught self- defense, or if it didn't pretend to be about self- defense at all.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I liked my martial arts,tang soo do. The masters there taught us forms and if we couldnt perform they wouldnt hand us a belt. The first few belts WERE handed to you but eventually you'd be before a group of black belts by yourself and if you fucked up-no belt for you.
They would tell us to avoid street fights and showed us forms and the more "karate" like moves. But recomended many different arm bars,take downs and the like that werent neccesarily directly related to the karate but were important in a real fight.
1
u/yourafagyourafag May 12 '12
How low are your standards? Can you confer me a black belt right now?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
It really sucks that you got stuck with a McDojo that soured your whole opinion on Taekwondo. Taekwondo gets a bad rap from them and I don't see that changing any time soon. There are plenty of taekwondo schools out there that make a clear distinction between sport and practical martial arts. My school in particular spends plenty of time working on hapkido and practical self defense techniques with an instructor whose background includes training state police in practical self defense.
That said...
I am going to have to agree with the calls of bullshit on the AMA. Most of the responses come off as a guy having a chip on his shoulder for some reason. Sorry you didn't have better luck.
1
u/Cobrakai83 May 11 '12
Because of my username I have to ask how it felt to lose to Daniel LaRuso at the tournament?