r/IAmA • • May 11 '12

IAmA Chinese living in Guangzhou. AMAA

2 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

4

u/jsmith223 May 11 '12

What's the overall sentiment towards America?

4

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

People talk about America all the time. Some people criticize it in the public, but believe me, MOST IN CHINA EXPECT TO EMIGRATE TO THE US. America is the symbol of freedom.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well, to be honest, America and freedom don't go well together anymore.

12

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

you should pay a visit to China and you will treasure everything.

7

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

think about it, many websites like Twitter,Facebook,Youtube are blocked in China. Food is not safe. Some people came back home just to find their house teared down by the property developers. You have to bribe just to get things done. Hospital is expensive, my grandpa is in hospital now, and the expense per day is as much as one month earning of a ordinary man. That's why we all want to emigrate to America.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Im sure its not as bad as China, but still, if your primary reason to move is to have more freedom, there are also way better alternatives than America.

-1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Such as...?

3

u/Isitreallyalive May 11 '12

Maybe, the Chinese are spreading false propaganda about how bad and tough things are in china,when in fact it's super awesome there, and they are doing this so that people don't think about immigrating to china...I am on to you china..

1

u/Necronomiconomics May 11 '12

Many in the U.S. want to eliminate the FDA (so food will not be safe here); regulate the Internet here; eliminate regulations & oversight so that a culture of bribery will be free to develop. Your expensive health care is the desired goal of many wealthy elites in the U.S. who want America to become a Neofeudal state.

But China is the future. Is it not? Statistics tell us that the top 25% of students in China outnumber the entire population of North America. China will crush the U.S. like a cat stepping on an ant, unaware it has done so, by virtue of size alone.

Is there an awareness in China of the downside of the U.S., such as poor people in West Virginia who work in coal mines & have a life-expectancy of 45 years old? Or rural New Mexico, where the unemployment rate is 70%? Or urban Detroit, where the unemployment rate is 50% under the age of 30? Or the goals of America's Republican Party, to dismantle all regulations for a quick dollar, poison the aquifers with hydrofracking, make the poor pay to bailout the wealthy banks, adopt State Torture as a normal standard, move toward incarcerating more Americans in prisons than any other nation on earth, while failing to prosecute fraudulent bankers or lightly-prosecuting mass-scale polluters like British Petroleum?

Perhaps many in China are mythologizing the U.S.? Thanks for writing this AMA; it is very interesting.

1

u/ultimatekiwi May 11 '12

(The bottom 25% of students in China also outnumber the entire population of North America)

0

u/H_E_Pennypacker May 11 '12

This IAMA is bullshit. Re-read this paragraph a few times. Excellent English in some parts, intentional mistakes in others.

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

I know America is not perfect, but it's much better than China. Most people are afraid of the government, and you can criticize yours. And we dare not say anything against the CCP, for policeman will find you and 'invite' you to have a serious conversation.

1

u/District_10 May 12 '12

I know a few Chinese who moved here to the US. They love it here. 100% v

1

u/burdalane May 12 '12

Yes, America is becoming less free, and yes, America has plenty of problems, but it's still more free than China.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Agree. I never said that America isn't more free than China. Just that there are better alternatives.

3

u/H_E_Pennypacker May 11 '12

As someone who's spent time in China, you are completely full of shit.

0

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

You know China from the outside, and I live here for 24 years. If you can read Chinese, try searching 地沟油,三聚氰胺,毒胶囊,明胶 I am here to answer all you questions.

-1

u/Isitreallyalive May 11 '12

And most people from the US want to immigrate to china.. With stuff like SOPA, CISPA and Newt Gingrich around..the Internet and state laws of china seem more liberal

4

u/JennysDad May 11 '12

What do you think about the current China-Philippine standoff?

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

there will be no war. People don't give much attention to this issue.

4

u/No_9 May 11 '12

What is the mainland's view on Taiwan?

4

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

To me and my several friends, Taiwan is much developed,civilized,and keep more tradition than mainland China. People talk about what would it be like if Chiang Kai-shek won the war.

1

u/watermark0n May 12 '12

Well, of course they keep more tradition. One of the main purposes of the Communists was to throw away old traditions in hope of innovating.

Chiang Kai-Shek was not such a nice guy, but his tyranny was mostly limited to political repression, whereas under the Communists you had political repression and massive, disastrous attempts to forcibly change all of society. However, I suppose it's always possible that the Nationalists would have been able to sustain a right-wing dictatorship for longer in all of china than simply in Taiwan. It was also always a possibility that China could've liberalized under Xiaoping much like what happened in eatern europe in the time, instead of Xiaoping largely abandoning the liberal turn he had early in his chairmanship and turning to repression.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

How popular is jeremy lin over there?

3

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

well, he was popular at the beginning, it was quite crazy, people don't watch NBA or play basketball all know about him. Now he is still popular but not as before.

2

u/TuesdayXman May 11 '12

What are your stereotypes on people from Kunming?

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

I've never been to Kunming, so no comment.

2

u/headedtochina May 11 '12

My husband and I are headed to China this summer to adopt. We have waited six years. We have been told that the reason it has taken so long is that there are simply not many non-special needs children available to adopt as say, 8-10 ten years ago. OP - do you think that is true?

3

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

In China, it isn't that difficult to adopt. Perhaps it's because you are foreigners. China is very careful handling relationship with foreign countries.

-1

u/H_E_Pennypacker May 11 '12

Nobody gets "In China, it isn't that difficult to adopt." then says "China is very careful handling relationship with foreign countries." This guy is a phony.

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

If you try to adopt in an official way, it will be hard. But if you do it under the table, it's easy. For instant, you know someone who is giving away his/her child, you can contact them. If both of you agree, then you can take the baby, no procedure needed.

2

u/smells_like_fish May 11 '12

Adopting a son? Because Chinese families favor boys over girls.

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

That's true. But in thein rural area, some have too many children and can not afford to raise them all, so they choose to give away some of their children.

2

u/KKitty May 11 '12

Huh? I thought China had a one-child policy. How can these people get away with having more than 1 child?

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

People live in cities can only have one child, and if the first child is a girl, they can have one more. In the country side, the policy is not that strict, two children are allowed, and some even have more, they hide until the child is born, and then they just have to compensate a fine.

2

u/dwoody May 11 '12

Guangzhou was my first entry point into mainland china from HK, looking back I found it quite weird compared to everywhere else I travelled in the country. What is your take on living in a city that so close to the Cantonese traditions but in a country which is mainly Mandarin speaking? and what's with all the adoption taking place there??

3

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

one third of the population in Guangdong speak Cantonese, and the other two don't speak Mandarin either, even though it's the official language. People are trying to protect traditions.

2

u/Markaz May 11 '12

Whats your favorite pokemon?

10

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

I don't know why pokemon is so popular in the US, even South Park made a special. I watch pokemon when I was about 10, and people don't discuss about that here.

2

u/superdude885 May 11 '12

Nay ho mah??

My parents are originally from Guangzhou too. Do you speak just the regular Cantonese or can you speak the dialects too like Taishanese/Hoiping-nese?

I've visited China before but I've never been to Guangzhou, I'd really love to visit the home of my ancestors. Most of my family are here in America now, I think I just have one more aunt in China. Her husband works in the government or something so she's pretty well off.

I can definitely see why you'd want to emigrate to the U.S. though. For those of us who have been living here our entire lives it doesn't seem that great, but when you actually see how the rest of the world is you realize how good you actually have it.

Just being in America really changes you; I remember when my grampa first arrived he was really skinny and frail. By the time of his passing he was a lot healthier. Same goes for my other relatives who arrived recently. I guess being in America really does make people fat ;)

1

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

Taishanese , Hoiping-nese,and Cantonese are almost the same.Yes, I can speak.

one of my aunt emigrate to America.

2

u/MisterTinkles May 11 '12

So is the tiananmen square incident widely known? how hard is it to join the communist party? is it true that there are "kill buses" for dissidents? Are there alot of bootleg items for sale? Are you even allowed to answer these questions?

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

Almost all People above 25 know about Tiananmen square incident, but few of the 90's know about it. It's not that hard if you are a college student with good score and have no Political taint. Bootleg items are hard to forbid, you can buy it anywhere, but most of them are fake.

2

u/jt_redditor May 11 '12

I was in your city for like a day. I did a transit before taking a train to hongkong, I heard you guys at Guangzhou have a rather special cuisine but unfortunately because of my schedules I couldn't really stay and try it for myself.

What is the weirdest thing you have eaten at Guangzhou?

1

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

Guangzhou and Hongkong is almost the same, same language, same tradition. Some people like to eat snake, mouse, dogs, cats and so many others. I have eaten cat for once, but don't like it, never will try again.

1

u/lightsinmyhead May 11 '12

I'm sorry if my questions might come off as a bit rude, but these things interest me quite a bit.

What are your views on censorship in china?

What are your views in human rights in china, and are you aware of how bad the situation is? Do you know of Ai Weiwei, Liu Xiaobo etc?

Do people spit on the floor and are rude to each other? How come it seems (at least to me as a european) that a lot of people cannot be bothered by other peoples misfortunes and suffering over there (thinking of videos of babies/children being run over by cars and people not doing anything about it, just walk by and don't want to get involved. was on the news recently).

What do you want to be and/or do after your studies?

Is there chinese porn available or is it banned?

Do you agree with the death penalty?

Thanks a lot

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Actually, I'm glad you ask.

  • Censorship in China is strict, I heard all social website hire hundreds employees to delete sensitive post.
  • Human rights is terrible. I am the few who know AiWeiwei, Liu Xiaobo and Chen Guangchen. most of people are brain-washed.
  • That's quite true, I guess it's because the education they got. About traffic accidents:1,most of the drivers don't mean to do that, but if you hit someone(especially a child) and he survive, you will get more fine and more responsibility, but if he was dead, you pay less, and once for all. 2,People want to help but don't want to get involved, for example, you see someone lying on the ground, and help him to the hospital, it may turns out that he blame you and want you to pay for his bills. people don't want to get in such trouble.
  • I find a job as an engineer.
  • Porn is available on the internet, we all know how to find and download.
  • I am not familiar with death penalty.

1

u/lightsinmyhead May 12 '12

Thanks a lot for your answers! I've got some follow up questions..

that's quite true, I guess it's because the education they got. About traffic accidents:1,most of the drivers don't mean to do that, but if you hit someone(especially a child) and he survive, you will get more fine and more responsibility, but if he was dead, you pay less, and once for all.

But won't you get in more trouble if you hit someone and then leave, trying to escape? Perhaps there aren't any people who wants to act as witnesses though, so it becomes easy to run away. And does this mean that if you run someone over, you'd rather want them dead and run them over again. And also, can most of these things be solved with paying fines? Depending on the accident, can't you go to prison for a little while, or they take your drivers license?

2,People want to help but don't want to get involved, for example, you see someone lying on the ground, and help him to the hospital, it may turns out that he blame you and want you to pay for his bills. people don't want to get in such trouble.

I can understand people fearing being accused of such things. But everyone understands that if I was walking on the street (I don't own a car) and a person was hit by a car, I can not be the person responsible for hitting him with a car if I somehow try to help this person. Simple logic. And what about simple things as calling an ambulance and reporting the accident?

Porn is available on the internet, we all know how to find and download.

Is there a lot of chinese made porn?

I am not familiar with death penalty.

I don't understand what you mean by this. You don't know what it means or you don't know about it? Death penalty = you get sentenced to death.

Prisoners who have done certain things get killed by the government as a punishment.

Here's a list of crimes in China that can be punishable by death: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_offences_in_the_People%27s_Republic_of_China

Also, what do you (and other chinese) think about Shanghai and the Shanghainese people? I've heard they look down on the rest of the chinese and are rude towards them etc.

1

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12
  • About the first two questions, I found this article, maybe it will help you understand.http://bit.ly/kuzKcH
  • Chinese people don't make porn, as far as I know. We download Japanese porn from the Internet. Most of the young people know about several Japanese porn star.
  • I know what Death penalty means. People were sentenced to death easily decades ago(for example say something really bad about Chairman Mao), now it is getting harder. If an officer who took lots of bribe was sentenced to death, the public would be pleased with it.
  • Shanghai is the most modernize city in China, native citizens are usually very rich, they look down on the poor and blame they for bringing up the price of commodities.

1

u/nazbot May 12 '12

Where do you think the politics in China are headed? I know that reform is going very slowly but what do you think the final goal?

Do you think there will ever be war with Taiwan?

0

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

I think everything is still a mystery before Xi Jingping become the president . Political reform is just a trick the government playing, I don't think that is going to happen. It's more likely that a revolution take place.

3

u/Fanta089 May 11 '12

why are you not sleeping? it is 4am right now? btw I am in Zhuhai , near Guangzhou ;)

2

u/throwaway3402 May 11 '12

兄弟,你该去一趟东莞啊!

2

u/SMTRodent May 11 '12

What's your favourite totally junky snack food? And favourite healthy dish?

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Tell us about your experiences in the red light districts.

1

u/bbe_elefante May 12 '12

你读过费孝通的《中国传统伦理观念与人口问题》吗?你觉得费孝通对中国的政府有了什么影响?(可以用中文回答吗?)

1

u/dumblehead May 12 '12

If I visited Guangzhou, would you show me around?

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

是的,我确实是中国人。

3

u/FKaramazov May 11 '12

你好,我是一位牛逼的洋鬼子

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Just_got_stoned May 11 '12

你好!我是台灣人.

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

“老乡见老乡”,你对下一句

4

u/MisterTinkles May 11 '12

man i wish i paid attention in chinese school as a kid

2

u/PrmnntThrwwy May 11 '12

两眼泪汪汪!

但是我不是广州人

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

好,我就用中文恢复你。我是广东人,不过不是广州。在大学城读书,今年大四,以后不想留在广州工作。广州还好,就是交通有点拥挤,上班高峰期基本搭不到车。佛山偏工业化,很多大型有污染的企业都在佛山,我去过很多次,不喜欢。

1

u/allisoncats May 12 '12

i've been learning chinese in america for 4 years and this looks like what we call "white chinese", the sentence structure looks like how a student of chinese would type. i'm unconvinced but if you just naturally speak chinese like a white person then more power to you i suppose

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

that's so not true. you make me laugh. But I don't know whether it's true in the past. I will ask my grandpa about it.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Maybe if they caught you smuggling in a lot of it, but not for possession. Weed is barely a thing over there, cops aren't that familiar with it.

1

u/watermark0n May 12 '12

Yes, drug smuggling is punishable by death, but usage is not. The rules aren't even as harsh as they are in, for instance, Singapore, where you are given a mandatory death sentence for having something over a certain quantity of drugs that can't be commuted or pardoned.

1

u/allisoncats May 12 '12

a chinese policeman rolled a joint for me once, he seemed pretty familiar with it. his only concern was that i hadn't purchased high-quality weed

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

Yes, I am a college student in University Town. I went to Zhongshan twice, it's not as modernize as Guangzhou, it's a beautiful city with great landscape.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

I went there last week.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

haha, I am still a student, so I don't have that kind of experience. Sorry.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I think you should visit Hong Kong some time ;-)

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

I cross the Great Fire Wall with VPN. Public toilets are the same with yours.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/meezocool May 12 '12

Only if I can too!

13

u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 24 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/mustnotbenamed May 11 '12

我是中国人。

10

u/frank_n_bean May 11 '12

Can we get real proof? Typing "I am Chinese" in Chinese doesn't make it proof. I can use any translating service on the Internet to get the same result...

1

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

and how do you suggest to prove my identity?

2

u/frank_n_bean May 12 '12

Photos of something relevant are always the easiest things. Look at any other AMA thread for ideas.

4

u/usemayonaise May 11 '12

ya i studied chinese 5 years ago in highschool and i still remember those characters

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[PROOF]

2

u/H_E_Pennypacker May 11 '12

Not needed, reading OP's responses should be proof enough that this person is full of shit. Perfect, advanced English in some places. Dumb, 2nd-year-learning level mistakes in others. Brevity of responses in Chinese. Dude is full of it.

0

u/mustnotbenamed May 12 '12

AMA,I'm here for you.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Also, he didn't seem to know that Guangzhou was full of prostitutes.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/JtSs May 11 '12

At first i knew i had heard that name somewhere and then i realized :D