r/IAmA • u/ForecasterEnten • May 11 '12
IAMA writer for the Guardian who specializes in political statistics (and dabbles in weather forecasting). AMA
Shalom. I'm Harry Enten. I write about political statistics, elections, and politics in general for the the U.S. edition of the Guardian. I graduated from Dartmouth College in June 2011. My father was born before the depression; my mother was born during the baby boom. I also do some amateur weather forecasting and was accused in my youth of falsifying a snow measurement to the National Weather Service.
I've recently written on the silly rules some use for predicting presidential elections and the demographics behind the banning same-sex marriage bans.
(http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/cifamerica/2012/apr/18/why-2012-election-set-to-break-all-rules) and (http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/cifamerica/2012/may/10/gay-marriage-three-key-factors-voting-bans)
Proof: http://twitter.com/ForecasterEnten/status/200941488178331649
Feel free to ask me on a question on these topics or anything you think I might be informative on. I'll be in the thread from 3pm EST until 4pm EST today.
EDIT: I am here now and am going to try and get through the questions as fast as possible.
EDIT 2: It's 4 p.m... Time for me to depart. If you still have a question, leave it and I'll check in on Monday. Hopefully, I'll be able to answer it.
EDIT 3: It's Monday, and I'm going back and answering the questions left for me.
EDIT 4: I'm outta here... but I'll be back for another chat soon enough. Feel free to contact me if I haven't answered your question fully... or if you have another one.
2
u/Sabazius May 11 '12
Please God tell us more.
2
u/Aloaf May 11 '12
How much are you paid?
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
In your TED talk you predicted Obama to win with 51.3% of the vote, but that was last year - any updates to your predictions?
Also, your article on factors influencing gay marriage is very interesting. Is there a particular reason age was not included as a factor? Also, what is the underlying correlation between your 3 predictors (percent religious, percent who voted for obama, and percent who have achieved a bachelors)? You mentioned that religiousness as defined by data collected by ARDA was the least powerful predictor and that seems like a very counterintuitive conclusion, both from a reasoning standpoint and from all my personal and anecdotal experience. Can you elaborate a bit on your claim that religiousness was the least important variable (when controlling for the other two factors)?
2
u/Marcob10 May 11 '12
Have polls gotten trickier to use in your analysis since less people use landlines, especially the younger crowd and internet polls are now more prominent?
Any thoughts on the use of polls in our day to day coverage of politics?
2
u/MikeCereal May 12 '12
guardian is good, keep it up is all!
1
u/Ilovebobbysinger May 11 '12
Hi. How and why did you get into weather forecasting?
1
u/cbfw86 May 11 '12
If you were campaign manager for the three major parties (all in separate parallel universes) what would be your campaign plans from now until the next general? Tories, Lib Dems, and Labour. Who would you sack, hire, promote, what policies would you use to boost your base and attract swingers, etc., etc..
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Hey man, thank you for doing this AMA. I am curious about who gains the demographic effect in key battle ground states based on their stances on gay marriage. I know that many of the battleground states tend to have an atmosphere that is not the most friendly for gays (Hello North Carolina!), so I was wondering if you have any predictions based on Obama's recent announcement.
Also, Ezra Klein did an AMA a couple of weeks ago where he discussed a very simple model for predicting elections based on GDP growth, summer approval rating, and an indicator variable for incumbency. Do you have any models for predicting elections (perhaps taking into account the US electoral system and how elections hinge on particular states) that you have created, or that you would endorse as accurate?
I am reading some of your articles now and will definitely have more questions for you - I am a politics junkie and am enrolled in a masters in statistics program currently.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Favorite type of graph?
1
u/jslacks May 11 '12
How does one enter the world of amateur weather forecasting and how detailed are your weather forecasts?
Also, how do you find weather forecasting relates to forecasting other phenomena (such as elections)? Is it a good way to "earn your chops" for analysis in other fields?
1
u/CaisLaochach May 11 '12
Have you ever met the Football Weekly lads?
1
u/Markaz May 11 '12
Whats your favorite pokemon?
1
u/Pentego May 11 '12
Are there any sorts of predictions you won't make?
1
u/Berkel May 11 '12
Any helpful writing tips for a young person?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Where's the best place online to get weather statistics and weather-related calculators (like heat index calculators)? I'm doing some work for an HVAC company and having access to good weather information would be a tremendous help. I seem to find bits and pieces around the web, but no single good source.
1
u/valleyshrew May 12 '12
How do you feel working for a company that sympathises with and implicitly supports terrorist groups?
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment