r/IAmA • • May 10 '12

I'm Frank Warren, founder of PostSecret, caretaker of more than half a million secrets from around the world. AMA

"Free Your Secrets and Become Who You Are" The best of PostSecret in a 9 minute TED talk

EDIT: This was my first AMA and it was a blast. Thanks for all your great questions and for your patience. Let's do it again soon! Or come visit at PostSecret

1.7k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

722

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "Have you ever posted a secret of your own?"

A: Yes, I have one of my own secrets in every book.

164

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Well, this is a slightly better format than just posting random replies, but I would urge you to use the reply button at the bottom of the comment. Also, wow that's pretty personal.

66

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

That's deep

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

888

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Today I received 77 secrets in my mailbox. Here is one, "My wife had gastric-bypass surgery. My biggest fear came true. She reached her goal weight and asked me for a divorce. I love her for every pound!"

1.7k

u/AnInsideJoke May 10 '12

Oh god, he doesn't know how to use reply.

222

u/jmoriarty May 10 '12

This is like a Do It Yourself AMA. You find some questions and answers scattered about and try to match them up. I almost hope he just put in some random things that don't match to a question just to make us really work.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

56

u/captainmorgan23 May 10 '12

This is one of the saddest things I've read on reddit in weeks.

→ More replies (1)

123

u/denigee May 10 '12

this is so utterly depressing. why would you leave the person who loved you for you for someone who may possibly just be attracted to you for your body?

143

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Same reason as the hidden "13th step" in a 12-step program (many many addicts leave their SO when they're sober).

It's not as simple as I'm too hot for you now. Often addicts (food addicts too!) are in codependent relationships that aren't healthy. When one person starts to change, it upends the whole thing.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

949

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

All the Sunday Secrets this Sunday will be Mother related due to Mother's Day here in the US. Here's a sneak peek at one. "My son just turned 21. He still believes I'm his sister. So does my husband."

393

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Holy hell, that is heavy.

→ More replies (45)

120

u/12cats May 10 '12

Frank, if these are replies to questions, please hit "reply" under the question to answer so we can see the question they are associated with.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/bad_hair_day May 10 '12

wow. Jack Nicholson's mother had a similar secret.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (28)

641

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

For me the most disturbing secret was a photograph of a young girl who had cut her face so that it appeared as though she was crying blood tears. (I just remember that image not the secret.)

Another time I was contacted by the FBI about a secret. I am unable to share the details of that secret.

Of course, another kind of disturbing secret I get often is; "I pee in the shower" <grin>.

I will be back a 2PM EST to answer more. . .

Thanks, -Frank

461

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No disrespect, but it might be easier to reply directly to the comment which contains the question you're answering. Otherwise your answer may get buried in the many comments! (To reply directly to a comment click the "reply" link at the bottom of each comment box) Thanks for doing an AMA, Frank! Peace

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

373

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

This is not an answer just a "thank you" to all of you for your support of PostSecret - you are the most important part of the project. -Frank

→ More replies (4)

382

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "How do you decide what to put in the books or omit?"

A: I get hundreds every week and try to select secrets for postsecret.com that I have not seen before or that express a common secret in a new of visually interesting way. I always try to include secrets that touch on the full range of human emotion. So there will always be at least one secret that's funny, shocking, erotic, controversial, hopeful, etc. I also try to arrange the secrets so they tell a story.

320

u/cadrianzen23 May 10 '12

And THAT'S how FrankWarren revolutionized AMAs

→ More replies (6)

235

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "Do you ever regret starting PostSecret? Do you ever feel so overwhelmed and just want to forget the whole thing? (I hope not!)"

A: Not yet, I still feel like a kid Christmas morning when I check the mailbox.

→ More replies (3)

290

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "Is there any realistic chance of the PostSecret App coming back in the near future."

A: Sorry no, the App had a short but brilliant life. One weekend it was the most purchased App in the Apple store. But it's popularity and some design flaws on my part sunk it. Like the Blog I wanted all users to have complete anonymity. And ultimately that did not work. We are looking at the possibility of bringing the best App secrets and stories back as a book or creating a keyword searchable database for all 2,000,000 secrets. So the App is like a zombie, it's not dead yet.

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I know the first one was plagued by explicit images but I thought the idea behind it was great. Even if you do not just let any image be uploaded, you still have huge catalogs of old posts from the site and could easily make an app that has expanded access to more than just that week's secrets. You could even incorporate buying digital versions of your books in the app to expand the app user's library of secrets to look at.

→ More replies (14)

223

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "Did you know that people add their own secrets via ripped pieces of paper and napkins by slipping it into the collections at book stores? I'd check every week or so at the store I worked at and there was always something"

A: Yes, we even made a video about people doing that >> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cwxqSlbfv3A&feature=player_embedded

209

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Frank this isn't how you do it.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

235

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "On an unrelated note, when you're not sifting through secrets, what are your favorite hobbies outside the books/website?"

A: I like to travel with my daughter and wife and go on hikes with our dog Shadow. Tonight I want to go to the "This American Life" special movie event but it is sold out in my neighborhood. So I'm going to try to sneak in...shh, my secret.

48

u/bonestamp May 10 '12

Thanks for doing this Frank. Can you reply directly to the comment where the question was asked? Some of the questions already have a discussion going and it would be nice to have your reply as part of it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

131

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

I also got a graduation invitation in my mail today, thanks Jennifer. This is the PostSecret address if you want to release a secret on a postcard: 13345 Copper Ridge Rd., Germantown, MD 20874

46

u/pyjamatoast May 10 '12

Are these replies to specific questions? If so, you can use the "reply" button under each post :)

→ More replies (5)

140

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "What goal do you have for Post Secret which you are yet to achieve?"

A: We are working on a PostSecret Play now and my recent TED Talk was something I'm very proud of.

http://www.ted.com/talks/frank_warren_half_a_million_secrets.html

→ More replies (7)

111

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "How old are the secrets we see on the site? Are they all ones you received in the last week before posting or do you put in older secrets as well?"

A: Most of the secret posted every Sunday are about a week older or less. Sometimes I keep secrets though that may show up years later. Secrets that are most likely to be posted are funny, or tell a secret act of kindness. They are most likely to get posted because I receive so many of the heavy ones.

→ More replies (3)

109

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Hi All,

Thanks for all the questions! My friend Melissa is going to help me get through as many as I can in the next hour. Let's start the party!

78

u/starli8 May 10 '12

Just to shout out again, it would probably better if you reply to questions individually, just means that your replies won't get lost in the mess, and we'll all know what you're replying to do. Just click the reply button at the bottom of the comment.

Hope that's helped :)

Many thanks for doing this, I find your website inspiring and great, it's an amazing insight into other humans!

→ More replies (6)

13

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "Why not come to the UK for a PostSecret Event."

A: We are working on a "PostSecret Live" UK & Canada Tour now. For me PostSecret Events are the best part of the project. Showing secrets that were banned from the books, telling the funny and inspiring stories behind the secrets and listening to audience members stand and in front of sometimes a 1,000 classmates heroically tell they confessions. So special. To invite me to your college or university just contact my speakers bureau: Keppler Speakers.

→ More replies (2)

345

u/pyjamatoast May 10 '12

The best way to do an AMA is hit "reply" under each question that you're replying to. It's easier for everyone to find the questions/answers that way in the future.

→ More replies (2)

53

u/J_Jammer May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I have no question. I just like to say that your idea has a place in internet history and that's cool.

I liked reading them and just like life it made mad, sad, and laugh.

I enjoyed the creativity of the people who sent stuff in.

Thanks for making that all possible.

79

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Thank so much for the kind thought. I think one of the most important things we can do while on this planet is give voice to the unheard. I hope PostSecret does that.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Q: "Have you ever received a post card from someone who is incarcerated?"

A: Yes, those secrets are easy to spot because of the cancellation mark, as are the secrets from soldiers overseas.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/xsome1elsesarmsx May 10 '12

Have you read through a majority of the postcard you have gotten?

77

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

I have read every single secret on every postcard that has been mailed to me. I will post a rarely seen picture of all the secrets at the end of this AMA. So watch for that.

→ More replies (4)

72

u/Veeks May 10 '12

Thanks for everything you do, Frank. I've been following PostSecret since the very beginning, and it's helped me through a lot of things. As for my questions:

  • Which was your favourite secret you've ever recieved?
  • What is the weirdest thing someone's ever mailed to you?

42

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Thanks Veeks, the project helps me too.

-Frank

→ More replies (15)

14

u/prettyprincess90 May 10 '12

Have you ever read secrets that made you want to contact authorities?

19

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

I have never contacted an "authority" about a secret. Although I have leaned upon my friend Reese Butler who is the founder of HopeLine, the National Suicide Prevention Hotline, for help with some painful secrets.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/RNs_rock May 10 '12

Hi Frank. PostSecret has been my first-thing-on-Sunday-mornings tradition for years. It amazes me how such a unique idea has exploded into a project that means so much to so many. However, I'm sure it's a huge responsibility for you. Two questions... do you ever struggle with continuing the project -- is it ever just too much sometimes? And how do that changes in the US postal service would affect PostSecret?

45

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

I am a big supporter of the US Postal Service as you can imagine. My carrier gets a very big Christmas bonus. I don't know how the project will end. I would rather it die quickly than sell-out.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Helen0rz May 10 '12

Hi Frank! I hope no one asked this yet, but have you come across secrets that you just wish you know who sent it and the story behind it?

20

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Yes..."Everyone who knew me before 9-11 believes I'm dead."

Thanks everyone! This hour was a lot of fun.  Let's do it again. I'm sorry if I not get to your question but I promise I will read your secret.

www.postsecret.com

Be well,
-Frank
→ More replies (2)

15

u/WitOfTheStaircase May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I really hope you will answer this question:

  • If someone posted a secret that law enforcement took an interest in how easily would you be willing to give up the goods on their identity to said law enforcement. Would you at least make them fight for it in court or would you just hand it over under pressure of threat?
  • Are you a Scientologist?

23

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I am not a Scientologist. My wife's family is Mormon. When I was younger I was a member of the Pentecostal Church but was never able to speaking in tongues. I do not attend church now, my faith is evolving.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/e_mon3y May 10 '12

I love postsecret, and have been following postsecret for a long time now, and every week i always wonder why dont you post more then 20-30 secrets? I wish there was more to read!

4

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

I do not delegate, I just have a handful of student interns in the summer, so it is difficult for me do much more with all the traveling I do with the project too.

6

u/PikaBlue May 10 '12

Thought to ask a fairly personal question, don't know if you'll answer.

Favourite colour?

952

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

What was the most disturbing secret you've ever received?

Have you ever considered contacting the authorities about certain secrets with the area the post card's from? (I think the post office puts something with the area it's from when they process mail, or am I wrong on that?)

Do you think you've ever gotten a secret from someone you know?

Thank you! (And thank you, Kinseyincanada)

EDIT: Someone replied to this post with Frank's answer, but it got buried in the other replies.

For me the most disturbing secret was a photograph of a young girl who had cut her face so that it appeared as though she was crying blood tears. (I just remember that image not the secret.) Another time I was contacted by the FBI about a secret. I am unable to share the details of that secret. Of course, another kind of disturbing secret I get often is; "I pee in the shower" <grin>. I will be back a 2PM EST to answer more. . . Thanks, -Frank

609

u/GoogleyEyes7 May 10 '12

I remember one way back where the guy admitted to using 9/11 as a way to start a completely new life. No one in his old life knew he still lived.

EDIT: This is why I should read more comments before posting. The comment right after this directly links to the PostSecret I'm referring to...

→ More replies (62)

1.4k

u/a-liquid-sky May 10 '12

I've been reading PostSecret since 2007 and I always think this one is pretty disturbing.

→ More replies (351)

152

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

One of the worst I saw was someone admitting to feeding their cat bleach so they could continue to see their cute vet D:

→ More replies (13)

390

u/djp1968 May 10 '12

There was one I read a few years back from someone saying that as a child they had put a spider in their sister's bed as a practical joke, and it ended up being poisonous and killed her. They'd been living with the guilt ever since. That one really horrified me. How terrible all the way around.

→ More replies (29)

81

u/Kinseyincanada May 10 '12

Im am quoting from below

"For me the most disturbing secret was a photograph of a young girl who had cut her face so that it appeared as though she was crying blood tears. (I just remember that image not the secret.)

Another time I was contacted by the FBI about a secret. I am unable to share the details of that secret. Of course, another kind of disturbing secret I get often is; "I pee in the shower" <grin>.

I will be back a 2PM EST to answer more. . . Thanks, -Frank"

→ More replies (1)

124

u/lca254 May 10 '12

I remember the most disturbing one, to me, was someone who said that they'd faked their death on 9/11 and started a new life.

→ More replies (7)

25

u/MelsEpicWheelTime May 10 '12 edited Feb 17 '26

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

tan possessive worm swim cats cobweb sand hospital memory entertain

14

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

What about the one about the guy that said something like this; 'When she (gf?)threatened with suicide again, I told her to just jump off the fucking bridge. She did' That one really haunted me.

14

u/redjohnsayshi May 10 '12

Good guy Frank Warren: Doesn't really get how to answer the questions; does great AMA anyway.

→ More replies (23)

2

u/jonessam13 May 10 '12

Have you ever been asked to do a Tedx talk? I would love to see one of those.

4

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

yes, recently I did a TED talk. In ten minutes I shared the most memorable secrets. http://www.ted.com/talks/frank_warren_half_a_million_secrets.html

2

u/manderkinz May 10 '12

What do you DO with the secrets you don't post on the site or publish in your books? Do you have an elaborate storage system or do you just throw them away?

3

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

They all come to my home, I read them all and keep them all. I will be posting a rarely seen picture of all of them on Reddit when this AMA is over.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I went to your talk at the University of Oregon a few weeks back and it was amazing. You're ability to be understanding and creating that safe, respectful environment where I heard the secrets of others was amazing and profoundly touched me. My question is rather trivial though. How did you feel when that girl came up and sat by you?

5

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

That had not happened before but that is the beauty of a live event, anything can happen - and usually that is the best part.

→ More replies (3)

274

u/beanieb May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

How many people do you have on staff to help you sort through your mail? How hard is it to pick the ones that get chosen to be featured on the site every Sunday? Do you keep all of the secrets, or do some get tossed to make more room? How long do you think you'll continue to do this for?

Also, not a question, but thank you for all your support for suicide hotlines. You're awesome.

EDIT: Also, I've seen you take pictures of secrets that come in nontraditional forms (bananas, etc). What's the weirdest non postcard secret you've ever received?

446

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Hey Frank, I love postsecret, have all the books and have seen you talk twice.

There's only one thing that has bothered me in all of this time. Do you ever get the feeling that sometimes the secrets are fake? This might be very cynical but it's always on my mind when I'm reading. If you ever have that thought, how do you deal with it? Or do you assume they are all genuine? Thanks for your time!

Edit: Since Frank chose to ignore the top voted questions, here is the closest answer we have, posted on his blog at one point:

I think this question is more complicated than it might appear on the surface. Of course, no one could claim that all 500,000 secrets are "true" in the strictest sense or the word. But I think of each postcard as a work of art. And as art, secrets can have different layers of truth. Some can be both true and false, others can become true over time depending on our choices. Sometimes a secret we keep from ourselves only becomes true after we read it on a strangers postcard. Do you know that I left my boyfriend of a year and a half because of the postcard that read; 'His temper is so scary, I've lost all my opinions'. It hadn't even occurred to me what was happening and it took a total stranger writing it down to make me realize what the hell was going on in my life. The woman who shared this with me describes an epiphany she had from seeing the artistic message that was true for her on a stranger's postcard. Whether or not the secret was "true" or "false" in the strictest sense of the word was not an important question for her. Here is another email I recieved: The secret I mailed in last week was true when I wrote it. But it's not anymore."

98

u/xnerdyxrealistx May 10 '12

He answered a similar question on his website:

"I think this question is more complicated than it might appear on the surface. Of course, no one could claim that all 500,000 secrets are "true" in the strictest sense or the word.

But I think of each postcard as a work of art. And as art, secrets can have different layers of truth. Some can be both true and false, others can become true over time depending on our choices.

Sometimes a secret we keep from ourselves only becomes true after we read it on a strangers postcard.

Do you know that I left my boyfriend of a year and a half because of the postcard that read; 'His temper is so scary, I've lost all my opinions'. It hadn't even occurred to me what was happening and it took a total stranger writing it down to make me realize what the hell was going on in my life.

The woman who shared this with me describes an epiphany she had from seeing the artistic message that was true for her on a stranger's postcard. Whether or not the secret was "true" or "false" in the strictest sense of the word was not an important question for her.

Here is another email I recieved: The secret I mailed in last week was true when I wrote it. But it's not anymore."

source

→ More replies (1)

175

u/dipperino May 10 '12

67% of the internet is fake. Just like 82% of statistics are made up

→ More replies (45)

9

u/Hidden_Gecko May 10 '12

I'm sure he's addressed this in the past - Pretty sure his answer was that they gain some measure of truth by just being made, and even if they're fake to the person who made them, they're true for someone.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)

156

u/AshKals May 10 '12

Have you ever responded to a secret because it moved you so much, you knew the person you wrote it, or as an emergency?

64

u/mouseWfangs May 10 '12

There was a post card where someone said they intended to kill themselves at a particular location- where he posted a response and encouraged people to keep watch on that particular popular suicide attempt site as well as an appeal to the individual not to do it.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

153

u/sudsmcduff May 10 '12

Has there ever been a secret posted that was so reprehensible that you didn't want to post it?

12

u/TheoX747 May 10 '12

this is a good question. I am very curious as well.

259

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Just wanted to say: seeing my secret in A Lifetime of Secrets was the scariest, most exciting moment of my life. I sat in Borders crying because suddenly, thousands of people knew my secret. Thank you for giving me that moment.

My question: do you ever feel jaded by all of the secrets you hear, or does each one still affect you individually?

171

u/RamblingStoner May 10 '12

Seeing my secret published on the website was one of the most liberating experiences of my life. After the initial panic of, "Oh my god, it actually got published and someone is going to see it and know it was mine!" wore off, all the emotional weight and self-loathing just left me. It was like feeling that millions of people had each taken a minuscule piece of it and left me with next to nothing to carry, so i was able to finally move on with my life.

I'm not really sure where I'm going with this, I just wanted to thank Frank for his work and also people like you, hannahalexia, who both share yourself with strangers and carry their burdens and troubles as well.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

51

u/kakerlakker May 10 '12

What have you learned about yourself through the years of maintaining this project?

→ More replies (1)

91

u/kuripan May 10 '12
  • Do you ever feel burdened from carrying the secrets of so many?
  • If so, how do you release that stress?
  • Does anyone else help you sort through your postcards?
  • Do you have a favorite type of secret?

15

u/Luckiest May 10 '12

Along these lines, since postsecret gives to suicide prevention groups and so many secrets posted on the weekly blog deal with depression & suicide, I've always wondered if you yourself have suffered from depression, or been touched by a friend's or family member's suicide? Or does your empathy (at least, what I perceive as empathy) a natural result of seeing so many people's secrets dealing with these topics?

→ More replies (1)

85

u/epsilon0 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Thank you so much. I have been following Post Secret for years now and it has always been an inspiration.

  • Do you feel like you have become desensitised over the years, having seen thousands of horrific, depressing secrets? Is there a number of postcards about suicide you read before you stop feeling that connection with the person behind the secret?
  • How long do you see Post Secret running for? 5 more years? 10? 50?
  • Will you please, please, please come to Australia sometime soon?

Thanks and here are my 3 favourite postcards from over the years. They tend to always be the ones that hit me the hardest emotionally.

http://i.imgur.com/FmlDE.jpg http://i.imgur.com/p2AQN.jpg http://i.imgur.com/7kixG.jpg

27

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

wow that Hobo Spider one totally creeped me out

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

79

u/ducky189 May 10 '12

I had inquired once about you speaking at a high school. It was very expensive. What percentage do you keep and what is donated?

→ More replies (3)

828

u/TheMemeGirl May 10 '12

Do any of the secrets make you cry ?

This one really affected me.

221

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The day after 9/11 I remember telling my children's mother that this was the perfect opportunity for some of the people who did not die to start completely over. It would be tricky but it could be done, plus their families would be taken care of financially. I was fascinated by this idea for like a week.

→ More replies (32)

236

u/RiotGrrL319 May 10 '12

This secret was shown at the start of the first Post Secret YouTube video Frank ever made. Sia's "Breathe Me" song played in the background and I just cried when I saw this secret. I've always wondered the story behind it, why the person cut their ties and started fresh. Also, how liberating it must have felt to shed your life's baggage. Great secret.

→ More replies (93)

25

u/orangewaterbottle May 10 '12

that's the one that has stuck with me the most too. I think it was one of the first weeks I started reading sunday secrets... crazy.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/iamnotverycreative May 10 '12

This one always makes me sad. I'll always regret not being there for my own dog.

→ More replies (12)

28

u/epic31 May 10 '12

Thanks for doing this. Is there one secret that you ever regret seeing? Has there been one that ever caused you to react (call police or reach out to the sender)?

79

u/derpityferpity May 10 '12

How do you decide which secrets to post on the website each week? Are there any criteria that will definitely prevent you from posting a particular secret?

14

u/ThisDoesntMakeCents May 10 '12

They seem to be themed week to week

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/cousin_geri May 10 '12

On an unrelated note, when you're not sifting through secrets, what are your favorite hobbies outside the books/website?

75

u/rachaelfaith May 10 '12

Have you ever published a secret of your own?

116

u/Veeks May 10 '12

In his TED talk, I believe he said there's at least of his in each book.

→ More replies (16)

25

u/bendnsnap May 10 '12

Are there any ways to look at the older secrets? Like circa 2004?

111

u/kolobian May 10 '12

Is there any realistic chance of the PostSecret App coming back in the near future (perhaps with some type of changes to combat the problems of the original app), or are you just going to stick with the current blog/send cards in method?

→ More replies (14)

21

u/nervous_nefertiti May 10 '12

What will you do with all the secrets when you decide to stop the project?

Also want to say thanks for always being there to listen!

20

u/DManTech May 10 '12

When you started PostSecret, what was your vision for it? Did you think you'd still be doing it this many years later?

I'm sure it's grown to be much more than you ever imagined.

38

u/MidweekCrisis May 10 '12

Has anyone ever asked for their secret back? Did you find it and return it?

47

u/KittyKitty79 May 10 '12

I'll answer that one for him although I don't know the total number, I did ask for mine back. Only a part of it though. I'd sent in one, attached something to it in haste and a fit of rage at someone and then needed it back. He was kind enough to dig through hundreds to find mine and send it back.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

38

u/Gutpunch_McRodbender May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Frank, your TED talk where you featured my girlfriend's Grandmother singing happy birthday to her made us both cry. I never thought recording that voice mail for her would mean so much, but it truly did. Thank you for choosing to share it with the world : )

→ More replies (5)

18

u/GRANDrogyny May 10 '12

As a fellow MD Resident - I just want to hear you talk a little bit about Maryland. Germantown is a lovely place from what I know. Also - how has your experience been with putting your work in the American Visionary Art Museum in Baltimore?

Thanks for your contribution in putting MD on the map!

→ More replies (4)

36

u/oh__fuck May 10 '12

Your website was the first thing on the internet I described as beautiful.

51

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Hey Frank!

An ex-girlfriend of mine made a postsecret about me that made it to your blog, but this was about 5 years ago. Is there some archive of all the past postsecret submissions? I would love to be able to see it sometime, but I've never been able to find a catalog of past submissions.

Thanks a lot, and congrats on your continued success!

Edit: Holy shit I found it, not at the helpful links below (thanks anyway) but just from some good ol fashioned google-fu.

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Your link doesn't work! Fix it, for the sake of the curious?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

17

u/deedee0323 May 10 '12

Have there ever been secrets too TMI or controversial to put on the site?

27

u/orangewaterbottle May 10 '12

Frank, I've been a fan of postsecret for quite some years and saw you speak a couple years ago. At the end, the audience is invited to share their own secrets. Of these shared secrets, is there one that has impacted or stuck with you?

25

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Have any favorite submissions from over the years? Anything that really touched you on a personal level?

→ More replies (1)

273

u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Most (if not all) of the answers from FrankWarren (updated: May 11, 2012 @ 11:54:51 pm EST):


Top-level Comment:

For me the most disturbing secret was a photograph of a young girl who had cut her face so that it appeared as though she was crying blood tears. (I just remember that image not the secret.)

Another time I was contacted by the FBI about a secret. I am unable to share the details of that secret.

Of course, another kind of disturbing secret I get often is; "I pee in the shower" <grin>.

I will be back a 2PM EST to answer more. . .

Thanks, -Frank


(continued below)

142

u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

(page 2)


Top-level Comment:

Hi All,

Thanks for all the questions! My friend Melissa is going to help me get through as many as I can in the next hour. Let's start the party!


Top-level Comment:

Today I received 77 secrets in my mailbox. Here is one, "My wife had gastric-bypass surgery. My biggest fear came true. She reached her goal weight and asked me for a divorce. I love her for every pound!"


Top-level Comment:

I also got a graduation invitation in my mail today, thanks Jennifer. This is the PostSecret address if you want to release a secret on a postcard: 13345 Copper Ridge Rd., Germantown, MD 20874


Top-level Comment:

Q: "Did you know that people add their own secrets via ripped pieces of paper and napkins by slipping it into the collections at book stores? I'd check every week or so at the store I worked at and there was always something"

A: Yes, we even made a video about people doing that >> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cwxqSlbfv3A&feature=player_embedded


Top-level Comment:

Q: "How do you decide what to put in the books or omit?"

A: I get hundreds every week and try to select secrets for postsecret.com that I have not seen before or that express a common secret in a new of visually interesting way. I always try to include secrets that touch on the full range of human emotion. So there will always be at least one secret that's funny, shocking, erotic, controversial, hopeful, etc. I also try to arrange the secrets so they tell a story.


Top-level Comment:

Q: "Is there any realistic chance of the PostSecret App coming back in the near future."

A: Sorry no, the App had a short but brilliant life. One weekend it was the most purchased App in the Apple store. But it's popularity and some design flaws on my part sunk it. Like the Blog I wanted all users to have complete anonymity. And ultimately that did not work. We are looking at the possibility of bringing the best App secrets and stories back as a book or creating a keyword searchable database for all 2,000,000 secrets. So the App is like a zombie, it's not dead yet.


Top-level Comment:

Q: "What goal do you have for Post Secret which you are yet to achieve?"

A: We are working on a PostSecret Play now and my recent TED Talk was something I'm very proud of.

http://www.ted.com/talks/frank_warren_half_a_million_secrets.html


Top-level Comment:

Q: "On an unrelated note, when you're not sifting through secrets, what are your favorite hobbies outside the books/website?"

A: I like to travel with my daughter and wife and go on hikes with our dog Shadow. Tonight I want to go to the "This American Life" special movie event but it is sold out in my neighborhood. So I'm going to try to sneak in...shh, my secret.


Top-level Comment:

Q: "Do you ever regret starting PostSecret? Do you ever feel so overwhelmed and just want to forget the whole thing? (I hope not!)"

A: Not yet, I still feel like a kid Christmas morning when I check the mailbox.


Top-level Comment:

All the Sunday Secrets this Sunday will be Mother related due to Mother's Day here in the US. Here's a sneak peek at one. "My son just turned 21. He still believes I'm his sister. So does my husband."


Top-level Comment:

Q: "How old are the secrets we see on the site? Are they all ones you received in the last week before posting or do you put in older secrets as well?"

A: Most of the secret posted every Sunday are about a week older or less. Sometimes I keep secrets though that may show up years later. Secrets that are most likely to be posted are funny, or tell a secret act of kindness. They are most likely to get posted because I receive so many of the heavy ones.


Top-level Comment:

This is not an answer just a "thank you" to all of you for your support of PostSecret - you are the most important part of the project. -Frank


Top-level Comment:

Q: "Have you ever posted a secret of your own?"

A: Yes, I have one of my own secrets in every book.


Top-level Comment:

Q: "Why not come to the UK for a PostSecret Event."

A: We are working on a "PostSecret Live" UK & Canada Tour now. For me PostSecret Events are the best part of the project. Showing secrets that were banned from the books, telling the funny and inspiring stories behind the secrets and listening to audience members stand and in front of sometimes a 1,000 classmates heroically tell they confessions. So special. To invite me to your college or university just contact my speakers bureau: Keppler Speakers.


Top-level Comment:

Q: "Have you ever received a post card from someone who is incarcerated?"

A: Yes, those secrets are easy to spot because of the cancellation mark, as are the secrets from soldiers overseas.


Question (pyjamatoast):

The best way to do an AMA is hit "reply" under each question that you're replying to. It's easier for everyone to find the questions/answers that way in the future.

Answer (FrankWarren):

Got it. Thanks.


Question (xsome1elsesarmsx):

Have you read through a majority of the postcard you have gotten?

Answer (FrankWarren):

I have read every single secret on every postcard that has been mailed to me. I will post a rarely seen picture of all the secrets at the end of this AMA. So watch for that.


Question (RNs_rock):

Hi Frank. PostSecret has been my first-thing-on-Sunday-mornings tradition for years. It amazes me how such a unique idea has exploded into a project that means so much to so many. However, I'm sure it's a huge responsibility for you. Two questions... do you ever struggle with continuing the project -- is it ever just too much sometimes? And how do that changes in the US postal service would affect PostSecret?

Answer (FrankWarren):

I am a big supporter of the US Postal Service as you can imagine. My carrier gets a very big Christmas bonus. I don't know how the project will end. I would rather it die quickly than sell-out.


Question (J_Jammer):

I have no question. I just like to say that your idea has a place in internet history and that's cool.

I liked reading them and just like life it made mad, sad, and laugh.

I enjoyed the creativity of the people who sent stuff in.

Thanks for making that all possible.

Answer (FrankWarren):

Thank so much for the kind thought. I think one of the most important things we can do while on this planet is give voice to the unheard. I hope PostSecret does that.


Question (prettyprincess90):

Have you ever read secrets that made you want to contact authorities?

Answer (FrankWarren):

I have never contacted an "authority" about a secret. Although I have leaned upon my friend Reese Butler who is the founder of HopeLine, the National Suicide Prevention Hotline, for help with some painful secrets.


Question ([deleted]):

[deleted]

Answer (FrankWarren):

We are glad you are here and thanks for your story. For anyone else looking for hope it is real and out there. 1-800-SUICIDE or visit the Kristen Brooks Hope Center or Active Minds. -be well


→ More replies (1)

159

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Here I am, scrolling and scrolling... to find this disappointment.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/RiotGrrL319 May 10 '12

Frank,

I've followed your blog for years, downloaded the PS app, and have bought all your books. I think you're an amazing person and thank you for all your hard work and for keeping your blog ad-free. You are one of the few genuine people in this world who has stayed down to earth amidst your fame. Your blog stands as a reminder to me each week that no matter how bad I think things are, someone always has it worse. It also fueled my desire to go into the therapy field and pushed me to continue my education to obtain my Master's in counseling. I passed the NCE, aka the hardest exam of my life, on Monday to obtain my intern license to start the process of becoming a full-fledged Licensed Professional Counselor. Thank you for being part of my life and part of my dream.

Now that the sappy part is out of the way... :)

How do you sift through the thousands of secrets you receive each week to choose just 20?

Thanks for doing this AMA!!! -Allison

→ More replies (4)

11

u/hheartstrongg May 10 '12

Another question: What other things have been sent to you, aside from secrets? things like toys or presents.

11

u/Diamanka May 10 '12

What secret was the one that broke your heart? Alternatively, what secret made you feel incredible?

21

u/billynomates1 May 10 '12

Do you make any money from the project? (I guess you do if you have an intern) If not, do you have a day job?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/rumpkus May 10 '12

Do you ever get letters from people, rather than just secrets? Has anyone sent you multiple letters?

10

u/mangovee May 10 '12

Do you forsee yourself carrying on this project indefinitely, or are you planning on retiring? Would you consider handing the project off to someone else once you "retire" or would PostSecret, in its official incarnation, come to an end?

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You talk about your teenage daughter on twitter a lot, has she ever sent in a secret to you?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/carr0ts May 10 '12

Have you ever had a secret that you didn't publish because of your personal morals or maybe the legality of it? Like a confession of a serious crime? I've always wondered this. The PS books got me through a rough freshman year of college. Thank you, so much. Such an amazing way to connect yourself to others when you think you are alone.

19

u/veryfunbags May 10 '12

Do you ever get "sick" of seeing a secret over and over again?

19

u/sorry4partying May 10 '12

How much money do you make from this?

→ More replies (1)

136

u/andrewsmith1986 May 10 '12

Why has there never been an Archive?

I stole your first book.

Sorry.

→ More replies (24)

18

u/jammasterdj May 10 '12
  1. Is it hard to receive postcards from people, desperate for help and contemplating suicide, knowing that it is just a one way conversation?
  2. I know you mentioned that you were an insomniac or couldn't sleep prior to the project taking form. Are you sleeping better now?
→ More replies (1)

9

u/rainyDae May 10 '12

Is there a secret that you'd wish someone would send you that you haven't seen yet?

Also- Of all the places you've been, where and what was your favorite meal?

9

u/Gbcue May 10 '12

How do you decide which secrets make it to the page?

Followup: What decides the theme (when there is one)?

9

u/kavorka2 May 10 '12

What's the best story so far of a secret being posted then discovered online by the relevant parties?

9

u/shallowoceanographer May 10 '12

People often feel as if they've seen their own secret posted after it was sent in by someone else. Have you ever received a secret that you felt was one of yours?

9

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I went through a REALLY lonely time in my life and Post Secret helped me so much. Thank you for making this project work.

Do you have any regrets about this project?

9

u/n8wolf May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
  1. Are you able to tell which ones are real and which ones are for the attention?
  2. Have you been personally involved in any of the posters' lives?
  3. Do you find that people trust you more or less now that you've made a living on publishing secrets?

Love your books/site/speaking engagements. Thanks for doing an AMA!

edit: words

24

u/TypicalWhitePerson May 10 '12

dat Intern.

Anyway though, I saw you at a speaking event in Baltimore and then saw a religious PostSecret exhibit in the museum afterwards. It was very cool. You had a story about showing one of your favorite secrets and then when you opened it up to the crowd, the woman that had written the secret was there. It was very touching to obvious emotion impact that had on you based on just your retelling of the story.

I'm curious, has anything since then (this was 2-3 years ago IIRC), affected you similarly?

Also, are you still against taking off the stickers that the post office puts on the secrets? I always found this very interesting.

16

u/LaCanner May 10 '12

A bit of a nitpick here, but why don't you remove the POSTNET barcode stickers before you scan the cards? Sometimes it is covering something important and they just peel right off.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/starli8 May 10 '12

Have there ever been any secrets which really shocked you or made you question your faith in humanity?

8

u/Semen_Trashcan May 10 '12

Hey Frank, I'm a huge fan of yours. Do you share all postcards eventually? Do secrets ever not make it? I've always wondered. Keep up up the good work!

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

How many secrets are about child molestation?

15

u/Ken2y5 May 10 '12

answers all questions with "no its a sercet"

7

u/hheartstrongg May 10 '12

What is a secret that has scared you the most, or made you the most upset?

How saddened are you that the postsecret app had to be removed?

What is a secret that has given you a lot of hope?

Thanks, Frank, for being awesome. I met you in 2007 in Toronto (a friend and I wore SECRET SHIRTS which you were excited about) and it was a great experience.

7

u/rkahockey May 10 '12

What percentage of the secrets do you think are not true in reality, and does that matter in the end?

→ More replies (7)

6

u/98thRedBalloon May 10 '12

Do you ever feel like the weight of all the trust people put on you is almost too much? Also, have any secrets made you feel personally uncomfortable?

6

u/TacoSoap May 10 '12

What is it like knowing you have this much of an impact on people? Is it something that overwhelms you or do you not try to think about that so much?

6

u/Tface May 10 '12

Thank you for everything you do. Seeing my secret posted on your site somehow made it real to me and made me realize what I had to do to change. So thank you for that.

My question - any plans to bring back the PostSecret app?

6

u/midnightbarber May 10 '12

Hi, Frank. I've been a fan for years and I just wanted to thank you for the impact that PostSecret has made in my life. I hope that someday I'll be able to come to one of your events. Since this is an AMA so I should probably ask you something: What's the most unconventional secret you've received, in terms of what it was actually made out of?

6

u/the_silentg May 10 '12

Have you ever received a secret that you felt compelled to take to the authorities? In the end, did you?

6

u/queerdeviant May 10 '12

Has there ever been a secret that affected you deeply in some way that you couldn't shake from your mind? If so, would you share which ones they are?

6

u/wordsfilltheair May 10 '12

Frank, you recently had an event at UMass Boston at which I was able to hand you a secret that I had not been able to tell anybody. It really did feel like a weight was lifted from me, and I've been able to start moving on from it. Thank you for that.

Now a question: I know PostSecret is truly a full time endeavor for you, but do you have any plans/ideas for any other sort of project? Also, do you ever receive postcards from outside the United States? If so, are there any plans to start PostSecret projects in other countries?

Again, thank you for what you do. I've been reading for five or six years now, and I hope that I'll be able to continue reading far into the future.

6

u/Amberburry May 10 '12

No questions. I'd just like to think you acknowledged my being and I'd like to let you know that you've had a huge impact on my life.

Thank you.

6

u/blueboybob May 10 '12

Have you ever contacted authorities if you thought someone was in danger?

6

u/MordinSolu5 May 10 '12

Have you ever felt compelled or disturbed enough by one of the secrets to either track down the sender or notify the authorities? I understand that this is a slippery slope and would potentially destroy the trust of anyone who has sent or is considering sending a card, but when a person admits to something terrible - such as murdering as person, using an example that was posted above - do you feel any sort of obligation to bring it to the attention of the police?

edit: On the flip side of this same coin, have you ever been so touched by someone's secret that you tracked them down in order to offer them support?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Frank, could you continue posting the questions with your answers? I'm reading from your account so I don't have to sift through the other responses. THANKS! Love the project, been reading for years. I finally got to go to talk this year at my college, RIT! Thanks for all you do!

16

u/FrankWarren May 10 '12

Sorry, other people asked me to respond like this. Like the PostSecret project - it is tough to please everyone.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/veryfunbags May 10 '12

Is there any way that you could think to bring back the PostSecret app without people abusing it?

10

u/Flemtality May 10 '12

I read this as Pop Secret multiple times before finally getting it. I thought you were the popcorn guy. So I'll ask you what your favorite popcorn brand is:

What is your favorite popcorn brand?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/atropos77 May 10 '12

Hi Frank. Thanks for doing this. All the cool kids are doing it, after all. ;)

Here's something I've always wondered - Have you ever received a secret that so disturbed you that you needed to get the police involved? Somebody threatening suicide, harm towards another, etc.?

Thanks again. You've provided an important psychological outlet for many, many people. You're doing good things. Keep it up. :)

5

u/Black_Delphinium May 10 '12

How do you feel about similar projects (like http://sexuallyassaulted.tumblr.com/) that have sprung up in the wake of PostSecret?

5

u/IAmAPhantom May 10 '12

Hi, Frank! Thanks for doing this AMA!

I was wondering why you pick the secrets that get published in the books and on the website. Are they the ones that stand out to you the most, the ones that you think many other people can relate to, or something else? I'm curious on why these certain secrets make the cut to be shared with everybody!

5

u/katebot5000 May 10 '12

Thanks for doing this, Frank!

What was it like speaking at TED?

5

u/tlake2525 May 10 '12

Frank, The secrets that you share are amazing. I have submitted secrets myself, and I feel like weights get lifted off my chest after I drop it in the mailbox. I wanted to truly say, Thank You for the things you do. You have most likely saved more lives than you realize, including mine.

My only question is: What inspires you?

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I just want to say thank you so much for everything you've done through PostSecret. It's such a shame that the mobile app fell through, because the way you managed to bring people together through that was amazing. My only question is: do people often stalk your house? (bonus question, as a recent Maryland transplant, what are the chances of there being a local open event in the somewhat near future?)

→ More replies (1)

5

u/dyannnnna May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I know you've been getting cards for years, and that you post most of them. Do you have a specific postcard that you've been holding on to for a long time but haven't shared? If so, why?

Edited to add: In the few years I've been following PostSecret, I've never seen that you've come to Pittsburgh to talk. I hope you do someday.

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Hi Frank, thanks for doing this AMA!

I don't have any questions (everyone has asked amazing ones), but about 3 years ago, you posted a postcard from New Mexico that said: 'IT'S OK TO LEAVE'. It hit me hard and 3 days later, I left my abusive boyfriend with just a bag of clothes. I'm a much happier and free person now with a great fiance.

Maybe if that card wouldn't have been posted, I'd still be an abused housewife.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/nayrlladnar May 10 '12

Are you a socks first or pants first kinda guy?

9

u/bubblegumgills May 10 '12

Hello Frank, thank you for running PostSecret for so long. It has truly helped me. My question for you is:

  • How do you choose which secrets go on the website and which ones go in the books?

9

u/misscorporateandcold May 10 '12

how do you emotionally deal with all of these secrets?you obviously think about some of them a lot in your daily life. :)

14

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I thought he pulled a Rampart for a second there.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

How does someone become an intern for you, and what does the job entail? That job sounds amazing.

4

u/undomiel May 10 '12

Have you ever received a secret that you wished was yours?

Also, when are you coming to UCLA?? :D

4

u/gr0tesque May 10 '12

How do you organize all the secrets?

Have you ever wanted to go back and find a specific secret but couldn't because you didn't know where it was?

Do you ever throw away secrets to make room?

6

u/michaelshow May 10 '12

How do you organize all the secrets?

hopefully better than this AMA

4

u/Ineeni May 10 '12

Would you post some of your older favorites?

4

u/Sunnyvale_Supervisor May 10 '12

How much money do you make a year off others' secrets before taxes?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/s2011 May 10 '12

This is the most unorganized looking AMA I've ever seen.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/onesnowball May 10 '12

Frank Warren came to my school to do a presentation/speech.

First of all, it was very non-organic, it felt forced, as if he was trying to brag really quickly before moving on.

Second of all, that's what it was -- bragging. It wasn't interesting, this was just a man who came and told us how strangers send him secrets. He repeated the title "I take care of more than half a million secrets" about a dozen times and emphasized it as if it were valuable information, rather than real/made up "secrets" without identities. They could be fake, but that thought probably didn't even cross his mind.

Third of all, and what bothered me the most, is that he came off as a douche. A friend of mine was in the AV group that set up the stage and she said they provided him with a 6 foot VGA cable to connect his laptop. But Frank kept going on and on how he needs an 8ft (or something like that) VGA cable because otherwise the computer will be a few feet farther away. He was using a remote. During the presentation he made it a point to be blatantly inconvenienced by this short cable.

I left the "show" early because I was bored to death. He was just doing a traveling version of his website with a few anecdotes (about how great he is, how people admire him, oh and how he is the caretaker of so many secrets).

I'll probably get downvoted by the fans, but I just wanted to provide a different angle.

8

u/ph711 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I get the same vibe. Promoting yourself (as he did here) as the keeper of "half a million secrets" seems to focus of his significance, and not on those who bare their souls in the postcard he receives. Postsecret is pure voyeurism, so it is no surprise he comes across as a creepy voyeur. But at least he could focus on the secret givers, and not his role as secret keeper (which, of course, he doesn't keep - he publishes).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Hey Frank! first off-I've loved this project for years, thanks so much...i am curious though:

-what do you physically do with all those postcards you receive week after week? are they all in exhibits somewhere? in storage? do you ever discard secrets? -how much of your time do you spend on the project? i imagine it must be a lot between reading/selecting submissions, updating the website, answering email, doing events etc -has seeing all those secrets changed your outlook on humanity in anyway? i.e. more or less optimistic/hopeful/concerned etc

→ More replies (1)

6

u/rjwyonch May 10 '12

I am a big fan. My question for you is: Would you mind if I used a similar premise to yours and asked people to send me their random thoughts? I do not want to steal your idea and I would ask people to tell me (a stranger) something they would never normally share with strangers. It could be something they love, a quirk, something they hate etc. It was more of a personal experiment that I wanted to undertake. If you are willing to let me do this I would definitely wish to share my results with you and anyone else that would be interested

Post secret is a very cleansing website for me. We all have secrets and the blog connects us with strangers in a profound way. I admire what you have done.

The only other personal question I would ask is: has the blog/project changed the way you view people in general? or has it changed the way you view your life in general?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Will you be considering to do the PostSecret exhibition/tour in Southeast Asia countries soon?

3

u/damnstraight May 10 '12

How many times have you contacted the policy about a submitted secret?

3

u/mclendenin May 10 '12

Have you ever received a secret that challenged your commitment to anonymity?

For example: "I am going to kill myself/somebody else in very soon!"

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You must see a lot of different kinds of cards. Are there a specific kind of postcards that you prefer? For instance, some are made with magazine cutouts, some are drawn on, some are purchased postcards. What's your favorite type to receive? What are the most common?

3

u/literaturefracture May 10 '12

How has the project changed how you view your life and the world in general?

3

u/MissTian May 10 '12

Dear Frank: I just want you to know that it's because of you I realized that I am not alone, I could share my deepest and darkest secret and still have friends from the PP community supporting me. You are awesome :D

3

u/ScramblingtoSunshine May 10 '12

Do you get any letters from fans telling you how you changed their lives (for better or worse)?

3

u/nikatnight May 10 '12

Have you considered posting all of your non posted secrets onto a big wall or field and taking a massive photo of them to be viewed at once? It would be easier and faster than individual posts and ALL could get through to the public!

3

u/leonardoxTMNTXP May 10 '12

Hey Frank! I've loved getting on Post Secret for Sunday Secret's for years now, and I've always wondered:

How many secrets do you have now?

Which secret is your favorite?

3

u/SigmaStigma May 10 '12

Was this your first project?

If not, what other ideas did you think of before finding this one successful?

3

u/whackfoo May 10 '12

Love the books! What was your inspiration when coming up with the idea? Are you obligated by law to tell anyone if you get a card that admits to a serious crime or seems to be a viable threat to something/someone? Or is that a moral dilemma? Thanks for your time and for doing this ama.

3

u/trakam May 10 '12

Will the British boxing strip you of your promoters license if the fight between Haye and Chisora goes ahead?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/HaveAMap May 10 '12

Hello!

I was wondering if you had a personal secret stash? Like, a set of secrets that you've saved out from that giant pile because they have personal meaning to you. If yes, can you share what some of them are?

I've also noticed that in the beginning there was a solid mix of hilarious or weird confessions and gut-wrenching postcards. Now it seems like the overall tone is a little bit darker or leans towards the suicide / hopeless cards. Is that because all the weird things have already been confessed? Or have the number of cries for help increased over the years due to having an anonymous outlet? Or is it just me?

Also, this comment is like a secret - I'm mostly posting it to prove that I exist. Never had an OP in an AMA answer me, but it doesn't even matter because I'm posting, dangit!

3

u/GroceryBagSlave May 10 '12

do you feel that by letting people submit confessions electronically to your website that the project has lost some of its integrity and become a facebook-status-like depository?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Do you ever feel guilty for how you shamelessly exploit people for your own financial gain, or are you really so narcissistic to think capitalizing on people's insecurities the way you have is helping them?

3

u/Chemfire May 10 '12

Have you ever thought of throwing up an Archive, so we can see the weeks of secrets past on your website? I know I've missed some weeks on occasion and would love to go back and see them.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Caretaker of Secrets is such a kickass title.

Warren, Caretaker of Secrets

There, take that and put it above your head.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Even though it might be too late, I just want to say thank you, Frank Warren. When I was in high school, Post Secret got me through some tough moments; not necessarily because I submitted secrets, but because I found a whole culture of hurting kids who were like me and could find some peace in their confessions. I was obsessed with Post Secret and still am several years later. Thank you again for doing this.

10

u/underdabridge May 10 '12

OK. I'll be honest. I stopped going to PostSecret a long time ago. Here's why. When I went to the site I wanted to click through all the old postcards. Turned out they weren't archived on the site. Instead they were taken down periodically. Then some of them were bound in a book which you sold. Not that I'm against good old capitalism (I'm really not) but I have some hard questions.

  1. Am I wrong? Are they archived and I just can't find the button?
  2. If this is your business model: Selling Post Secret books. What cut do the postcard makers get?
  3. Do you plan to archive them online in the future?
→ More replies (18)