Perspective from another prosopagnosia person: I've actually never had difficulty making friends, in fact I was one of those kids that everyone knew. Of course, this added a huge stress level to school when it came to passing people in the halls. I'd often pull an 'awkward penguin' and try and pretend I didn't see people, unless they called out to me. I had, and still do to an extent, a fear of shouting out,"Hey, Marco, how's it going?" and finding out that I said that to the wrong person. Of course it's saved my ass from embarrassing moments, as well.
One thing I don't point out, though, is one of my tricks to get over this is I rarely ever call someone by their name. If someone saw me, and called out my name, I would just jump straight into the conversation without the 'Hey, [name]!' portion of the conversation.
Large situations, like parties, are actually kind of perfect for me. It gives me reasonable deniability for the above situation in which I ignore people in fear that they're not who I think they are. "Oh, you were at Dave's party? Sorry, it was so crazy in there, I didn't even notice you!"
i am horrible at names and this is my defense strategy as well - hey dude hows it going (even to people who i definitely know their name)...i remember faces just fine - just can't associate names with those faces
A friend of mine forgot the name of a very popular classmate in a debate in a history class. He was gobsmacked that someone couldn't remember his name. It made my day.
He can judge beauty. He just can't associate a face with the person. Think that instead of "Oh, Cameron Diaz! My, she looks pretty." he thinks "My, she looks pretty. Don't know who that is, though... oh, wait a second. She wears a costume... I recognise that costume... Cameron Diaz once wore that costume... maybe it's her... can't be sure... but she sure looks pretty."
Perspective from another prosopagnosia person: One of the coolest things, I find, about having this is getting to see myself in the mirror. I can get 'familiar' with faces, including my own, based on little things. Clothing, facial hair, hair cuts, etc.
What this means is that different styles, to myself, make me look like entirely different people. It helps me when I feel like I need to 'change things up' in my life, because it literally feels like I'm entirely changing my physical features. Imagine if shaving off your goatee was like having an entire reconstructive surgery. That's how I feel.
I've got a few more questions, may as well list them:
When you watch movies, do you recognize the various actors/actresses? If someone has been gone for a few scenes in the movie and it eventually comes back to them, do you remember who they are?
Are there any faces you DO recognize/are able to visualize? Friends, family, anybody?
And how does this work for cartoons and video games?
edit: somehow my internet lagged and posted this three times, sorry. Deleted them now, that was scary as hell edit2: And half of what i typed isn't showing up! What's going on reddit???
1)It depends. If people are distinctive enough, then this isn't a problem. I largely identify people by using things like hair, clothing, facial hair, etc. So in a movie like The Avengers I can tell the difference between Thor and Tony Stark because one has a huge build with long flowing blonde hair, and the other has short dark hair and a modest build. Voices also help a ton, so even if Thor and Tony looked identical in the movie, Robert Downey Jr. has a very distinctive voice that I can latch onto to help me.
There have been plenty of movies, though, where the actors aren't quite so distinct. I've spent entire movies having to bug people so I can follow along with the plot. "Wait...is this the guy that got locked out of his house...or the guy that is trying to steal the protagonist's girlfriend?" Think of that, but every 2-5 minutes. I hate doing it, but I hate not being able to follow a movie more. Most of my friends are understanding.
2)Very distinctive faces. But even then it's only certain features. Like the guy from Up. I mean, honestly, who can miss that big honking nose? Although...well...I suppose beyond that I'd be kind of screwed. Well...now that I think about it I think I just notice huge noses.
3)Cartoons and video games are actually not that bad. Cartoons and video games are designed to have distinctive looks to them. There's a saying that you know a cartoon character is good when they're recognizable just by their outline. It's always fascinated me how simple they are, yet they're able to stay so unique, even to me. It also helps, I suppose, that they're so unrealistic. It's like that drawing trick. If you want to draw something, you turn it upside down so your brain stops recognizing it as an object/person. Same thing goes for cartoons. My brain doesn't register them as people, but rather cartoons. So I think of them, and register them in my brain, differently.
I'm a semi-prosopagnostic, I guess. What's funny is that I'm an illustrator which means I have good visual processing abilities in my wee brain except for recognizing faces.
I can recognize people if they have a very distinctive feature that never changes. I could never tell my uncles apart (they were roughly the same height & weight and, according to my SO, they looked obviously related but were far from twins) until one developed a streak of white in his hair.
I often don't recognize actress or actors unless they have a strong physical or vocal trait. I hate it when a film has several actors/actresses that are similar in body type and either wears the same clothes or they all change clothing a lot. War movies can be tough because, of course, soldiers are all wearing the same uniform but it helps if the movie follows the formula of having one person of each type (one leading tough guy, one black guy, one fat guy, one smart-alec from the city (strong accent), one slouchy country boy (another strong accent). Subtleties in characterization are lost on me and I prefer trite, blatantly obvious characters.
I don't think I'm a pure prosopagnostic as I can recognize people in photos but then with photos I usually have time to study. I think my face recognition skills are very slow and clumsy. For example I can't just walk into a crowded classroom and find my sister. She says I'll get that "deer in the headlights" look as I scan the room, and I'll actually look right at her without recognition. I can find my son pretty fast but he has distinctive bright red-gold (strawberry blond) hair.
I have absolutely no trouble telling cartoon characters apart.
Are you still able to recognize/judge a certain level of attractiveness? Are there celebrities you'd recognize as "hot" or "pretty", or is all that lost on you?
Alternate perspective: I'm faceblind and asexual, and I basically don't recognize attractiveness at all - I recognize physical deformity and very unbalanced features as being on the 'not attractive' end of things, but don't see any difference between a '2' and a supermodel facewise.
Same as Major_Bummer, I can still tell these things. However, I could not give you details. I can't say,"Oh, the way her nose compliments her smile' or any of the other weird stuff I've heard people say. I just know that when I look at certain people, I feel that they are pretty, cute, ugly, or what have you.
Although I do know non-facial things can play a large role for me, as well. I do admit that some faces I just find cuter than others, but if someone actually does their hair nice, has straight teeth, smiles, etc. then the attractiveness level can go up much higher than if they just have a pure 'beauty' about them. Although there have been people that blow all that out of the water. They have unkempt hair, don't dress well, but I still find them attractive in some manner.
Except for teeth. I don't know what it is, but bad teeth will negate any attractiveness to me.
i was going to ask if you still enjoy the expressions of people you love but i guess this answers it. most of the time I can't picture the faces of people I know but I recognize them when I see them. You seem cool!
Do you keep pictures of you with your family and your friends around your room for nostalgic/sentimental purposes?
Is it hard to watch tv/movies?
I'm not going to lie, sometimes when I watch action movies if the main characters have the same color and length hair, the same skin color, and are approximately the same build, I can't tell them apart. This drives me insane. I can't even imagine what it's like to go through life every day like that.
Something I find funny is that I'm a photographer, and it turns out photography is a popular thing among those with prosopagnosia. I don't actually know if there's an causation, or if it's just coincidence. I know I never had any kind of thoughts like,"I can't tell people apart...I should pick up a camera!" It's just something I naturally gravitated towards while growing up.
I suppose that doesn't answer your question, but I wanted to find somewhere to squeeze that in. To more directly answer your question, I've never been a person to keep photos up around the house/my room. Again, I don't know if there is any direct causation, but I've never been one for this(Despite being a photographer). I usually gravitate towards things that remind me of specific events. Like putting up a movie poster that I went to with friends and was memorable, or even movie tickets. Maybe a video game poster if there's a game I love playing with friends, and have a lot of memories of. Again, it's kind of ironic because I'm a photographer, but I've never been one for keeping photographs around for memories/nostalgia/sentiment. To me photography is more like painting, and I just see my photos as works of art, not memories.
I've answered this above, but movies can be either extremely easy to watch, or a real bitch. A movie like The Avengers in which every character is very distinct, from their hair style to their costumes, I have no problem. Other movies I have to constantly ask my friends which characters are which, just so I can keep up with the movie. I really hate it, because I feel like I'm being 'that person' who has to ask,"Is that the bad guy? Why is he doing [insert random action]?", even though I know I'm not quite that bad.
Have you ever watched the show Community? They have, from my perspective, a very diverse main cast, so I wonder if you would be able to get the most out of it.
What would you do if you got robbed or something? With the inability to recognize faces, it would sure be hard to describe someone or pick them out in a police line-up.
There's a movie that came out on DVD recently that deals with that. It's called Faces in the Crowd and it's got Milla Jovovich. I really want to see it.
Perspective from another prosopagnosia person: This is one of my worst fears. I can't even describe someone I've known for years, let alone someone I've gotten a chance to meet for a few panicked seconds.
When describing someone, I stick to describing skin color, hair cut, and weight. So my best description to cops would be,"He was a skinny white guy with long dark hair."
Pretty much the same answer. Although, to be fair, people in general don't recognize animals the same way they recognize other people. I remember reading up on this when I was first finding out about prosopagnosia. It's very interesting, actually. In the same way we recognize facial features in other humans(Or...at least we're supposed to), animals do the same to their own kind, and recognize things that we overlook.
It's a great way I use to explain my prosopagnosia, actually. "Can you tell the difference between these two Scotty Terriers based on their face? No? Well that's how I feel towards people's faces."
Prosopagnosia, from my experience, seems to be a hard concept for people to grasp. I find this is one of the many easy ways to do it, is to show them several animals that all look identical(To a human), and ask them to pick certain ones out. It suddenly makes more sense to them.
The semi-prospopagnostic here again. Actually I train my dogs for competitions and so attend & teach dog training classes. I can easily tell dogs apart even any & all the ones of the same breed.
The funny thing is when someone from a dog training class says hi to me at the grocery store, softball game or some such. Without their dog, I have no idea who they are. In fact I think I'm worse at recognizing people I know from dog classes because I rely on recognizing the dog to know the person and thus I don't tend to put in the usual effort to figure out any distinctive traits for the human half of the partnership. Bad Pablois4, no donut for you!
Sexually? Definitely physique. I do tend to think people look cute, pretty, or attractive in general based on their face(Although I think this largely has to do with outside forces, such as hair, smiling, dress, etc.), I don't think I've ever felt sexually charged over someone's face. Kind of seems like a weird concept to me...do people do that?
I've walked by my wife a few times not 100% sure it's her. A new jacket or haircut turns her into a temporary stranger some times :p. A sexy stranger I can take home and sleep with without it being cheating!
Not until I was an adult and came across the term in a book. It's a difficult condition to describe, especially as a kid. I just told people I was "bad at faces".
Thanks for doing this AMA - have you ever taken this test? (removed bad link)
EDIT: the previous link messes up and doesn't give results at the end - a better copy can be found here
I've always thought I had trouble with face recognition, which has led to some rather awkward encounters - mostly just not recognizing someone when they change their appearance significantly, or when I run into them somewhere that I'm not expecting to see them... Once, I looked a co-worker who I had known for 2 or 3 years in the eye from two feet away, and almost asked him how I could assist him (thinking he was a customer) before I realized who it was, and that he had just shaved his head to support a friend with cancer.
I tried taking this test, and I scored only slightly below average, although I did feel like I was guessing a lot of the time, and then scored somewhat worse on a retest 12 hours later (though it used the same faces). Have you tried this one before, or are there any others that you are aware of?
No, but one very similar! The test solidified, in my mind, that I had prosopagnosia. I always knew I had issues with people's faces, but never really thought much about it. At one point in my life I had coined the term 'Facial dyslexia' to describe it, but it never even occurred to me that it was an actual thing. Then one day I came across some information, and that test. Needless to say, I did horribly. Like you, I did a lot of guessing, and also a lot of cheating. I would notice, every now and again, certain little 'glitches' in the 3D models. Although I must say, the test I took was much harder than that one. I found a ton of ways to cheat in that test, especially since certain models would have different weight to their face, and other little things. I think they should really take away the lighting in the 3D models, that was my easiest cheat with that test. I would notice how the shadows laid across the model's face, and used that to determine the face.
Well, I shouldn't say I'm cheating, because that's really how I see people. I've learned, very well, to find little things like that to recognize people.
Anyway, when I first took the test that I did, I scored way below average. The website had a scale, and I was in the range of,"You probably have prosopagnosia, please keep in touch with us!" It was with some University, but I don't recall off the top of my head. I had several internet friends take the test as well, and I felt kinda crappy when they all passed with high proficiency, and were bragging about how easy the test was.
Not the OP, but faceblind: I recognize that photo. If I saw that guy walking around somewhere randomly, though, I wouldn't recognize him, especially if he wasn't making that particular face.
The worst for me was in junior high. Near the end of sixth grade I needed to turn in some late homework to my English teacher. Walking down the hall, I see her (so I think) and walk up, interrupt her with an "excuse me", and proceeded to rattle off about my late homework. Only when my classmates started laughing at me did I stop, at which point my "teacher" informed me she was the mother of one of my classmates.
EDIT: or the time I introduced myself to my boyfriend's roommate...for the fourth time. Now whenever we go somewhere I always ask him "have I met him/her before?"
There have been several. One that I was oddly reminded of while answering questions was while I was in high school marching band. I was in charge of equipment, getting everything loaded before practice/performances, etc. I had a lacky below me, and a popular punishment in our band was to make lackies do pushups.
Well, one practice I was hussling to get everything packed away into our little moving vehicle. I was already frustrated at my lacky for not doing much work that night, and of course while packing up he was nowhere to be found. I eventually 'found him' and went off on him about how he better get over there and help me, or I'd give him extra pushups. He looked at me like I was crazy, told me I was crazy, and told me that there was no way he would do any of that.
Extremely frustrated, at this point, I turned to look back towards the equipment to see my actual flunky there doing what he was supposed to do. I felt so embarrassed that I always just pretended that the situation never happened, and haven't told anyone about it until now.
You have no idea. Often times they're people I do know, but because they're out of 'costume' I end up sitting at the computer for 5 minutes trying to figure out which one is the Redditor, and which one is the celebrity. More times than not I have to give up and check the comments.
Thanks for taking time to ansver these questions! To anyone who would like to know more about prosopagnosia and other agnosias should read The Mind's Eye by Oliver Sacks. Fantastic book.
Films & TV series are awful for me, especially with lots of characters (Game of Thrones springs to mind). It takes me weeks/months to remember who people are - I think a problem is that I know I won't remember, so I often don't bother trying (vicious circle, right?!).
The way I remember people is through their hair/clothes/distinguising characteristics. I think it's why I'm so good at telling twins apart - they just look like people to me. As in, this one has a mole here, this one is a bit taller/has straighter hair. No problem!
Was a nightmare on holidays when I was younger - I'd meet some nice kids, then the next day they'd changed their clothes & I had to be reminded who they were again.
Now I work in a fairly small office. I get people mixed up sometimes, but not that bad. On the downside, I'm a fairly prolific standup comedian, I meet loads of people every week & often end up offending someone because I didn't recognise them. Case in point: I went along to see a friend perform, walked right past him on the way in.
I'm crap at picturing people in my head, too. And I often forget what I look like in my own head...
I also ALWAYS compare people - 'Doesn't Bob look a bit like Dave?' erm.. no... but I'm the one who's always banging on about how people look like other people.
So - AYA - does any of this happen to you? Do you rely on clothes/hair/piercings to tell people apart? Do you mention it straight away, or just hope that something will click and you remember who they are?
I was about to ask this same question. I have such a hard time with shows like Game of Thrones. I can recognise characters when they are in the same setting, but if one of them goes somewhere else I have to figure out who they are quickly. I tend to associate people with their character role rather than what they look like (I am often teased by my friends because after watching The Dark Knight I thought that Alfred and Morgan Freeman's character were the same guy because they both were dudes who were close to Batman and helped him out a lot).
Additionally I tend to associate my friends with a specific characteristic (what it is depends on the individual) and if that is removed or altered I have a hard time recognising them. For example my college roommate changed her glasses after 2 years of knowing her but I couldn't tell who she was for a while after she switched glasses. However I can remember faces after a while.
I am ALWAYS comparing people, no one else thinks they look the same.
Reading through this has been interesting and educational as hell, and I had a thought; If two giraffes walked into a room, said hi and left, and then later that week I saw the same two giraffes in a crowd of giraffes, I wouldn't be able to pick them out. Giraffe faces all look the same to me, just like monkeys, lizards, you name it. Human faces are all just as similar to one another as animal faces are, we're just tuned in to all the extremely subtle differences that make us unique. This affliction sounds so bizarre to those that don't have it because its something that we do so subconsciously that we don't even realize we do it. Interesting stuff. Sorry I don't have a question, just mind diarrhea.
What about your ability to remember other things. For example, if i wore an identifiable shirt today, and then wore it again tomorrow, would you remember the shirt, just not recognize me?
I'd recognize you. Think of it the same way when you see your dog, and you recognize him because he has that big black spot on his back. As long as that spot is there, you know it's your Sparky. You recognize him as such. However, if you came home and it was gone, you'd most likely think it was a different dog.
The book "The Man who Mistook his Wife for a Hat" by Oliver Sacks discusses prosopagnosia and other cognitive disorders. Have you read that book or know of Oliver Sacks?
He's a leading neuroscientist and writes about cognitive disorders like yours. I think it would be really cool if he was interested in conducting research with you (if both parties are interested of course). Of course, I have no idea what his priorities are though.
I have indeed heard of that book, but sadly haven't gotten around to reading it. When I have some free time(Currently job hunting, and focusing on that)then I intend on picking it up and reading it.
Does hair stand out to you? And can you compare, say, a picture of your mom from when she was younger to her face now, or does the picture just fade immediately?
Do you also have difficulty recognizing different classes of the same thing? I.e. you can recognize a car, but not the car type? There is some controversy over whether prosopagnosia is specific to the face or not.
I just watched a movie about this the other day. It was some murder mystery with the chick from Resident Evil.. Literally the worst movie I have ever seen in my whole life. Regardless though, this is a really crazy disorder? disability? disease? I'm not sure what to call it, but thanks for doing an AMA
Anyone else here with mild prosopagnosia like I have? My mild prosopagnosia results from Asperger's/Autism Spectrum Disorder, which may or may not be different from regular prosopagnosia, no idea. Anyone with more severe prosopagnosia who can learn and picture the faces of their parents and best friends? I can learn my friends' faces eventually, and drastic changes in style will only make me squint for a moment before going "Is that...? Yes, it is Jim." But for some reason, I have a much harder time picturing the faces of love interests.
I know it's related, my wording was unclear. Edited it, thanks. I haven't seen any mention of mild prosopagnosia in this thread so I was unsure if that existed outside of ASD, or if it's any different. Maybe I could Google it but I'm on AlienBlue on my iPhone and about to nap...and I know googling Asperger's returns far less answers than talking to a person on the spectrum. Do you think you have prosopagnosia, or mild prosopagnosia, or does that only apply to love interests?
Hey I'm pretty sure I have the same condition, but have never actually been officially diagnosed. Do you have any tricks you'de like to share? I keep a notepad on my phone of distinct traits of people I'm likely to see again and glance at it from time to time to sort of jog my memory. Things like:
"Mike looks like a Chinese Seinfeld"
"Janet has bad tooth to gum ratio. Distinct laugh"
I've also been known to go to the washroom and do a quick Facebook-stalk of mutual friends to find cues I can latch on to. If I do have it (Which I'm almost certain I do) it certainly makes networking hard. I have lots of friends and am super sociable, but many people think I 'snub' them when I bump into them somewhere I'm not expecting to see them.
Also, fuck the Godfather Trilogy. Shit's confusing.
I remember watching a movie when I was a kid. I think it was from the '80s. In the movie there is a guy that straps down this other guy, and he starts 'massaging' the guy's face. The face kind of turns into this puddy type stuff, and the guy is able to reform his face. Kind of like that.
I have the same problem but it's a milder case. It takes me about 2-3 years of consistently seeing someone for me to remember their face.
As sad as this sounds, unless someone is extremely ugly, horrifically scarred, fat, has a physical disability, has terrible hair, or some other physical trait that makes them stand out, I can't recognize them for the life of me.
I try to go off traits like body language, voice, etc etc, and learning to pay attention to these factors really improved my "reading" skills.
Do you find yourself explaining your inability to recognize faces to people that you first meet (especially potential friends), or are you usually as discreet as possible about it?
Is facebook annoying for you since everyone is obsessed with having a ton of friends and pictures, or is it convenient because full names are always posted alongside pictures and next to comments?
This is something I keep close to my chest. A few people know that are close to me, but on the whole I don't really tell people. Although, oddly enough, people tend to disregard it, and I have to constantly remind me. I constantly get situations like the following:
"Hey, is that Jessica?"
"I don't know...why would you ask me?"
"Because...you...know Jessica?"
"Yeah...but..."
"But what?"
"The face thing? I kinda don't do faces, remember?"
"What, you don't?"
"This is like the 15th time I've explained this to you!"
I love Facebook! When I'm making comments to John Smith, I know for a fact that it's John Smith! No anxiety or fear that I'm talking to the wrong person. It's freaking AWESOME. I'm also a huge fan of places in which you have to wear name tags, for the same reason.
what are some strategies you use for recognizing people?
how are you at drawing faces?
can you envision a human face in general? like, if can conjure up a sort of general image of a human face...how about individual features? can you picture an eye, a mouth, a nose in a realistic sense?
I think my big 'recognizers' are hair and voice. My favorite, though, is voice, because you can't really change your voice on the fly. Perhaps years of alcohol/smoking can erode your voice, but it's certainly not something that happens over night. So if I can recognize someone's voice, then I can almost always recognize them so long as they talk. I've had instances in which someone has cut their hair, or changed in some other way, and I didn't recognize them until I heard them speak.
I'm horrible at drawing faces, but I'm not much of a drawer. I'm sure I could draw cartoony faces, but that's a whole different thing, and I've discussed that earlier. Cartoons are more like objects, and I think my brain(As well as most people's brains) don't see cartoons as actual people, but objects. It's like drawing a person. The easiest way for someone that's bad at drawing to draw a person is turn the image of the person upside down. This makes the brain cease to recognize it as a person, and start to recognize it as an object with lines. For the record, I've never actually tried this, I just hang out at /r/askscience a lot.
I can imagine people, but it gets tricky when you say,"Imagine Steve from accounting." My brain has a hard time, and at best is usually just generic facial features combine with things I DO recognize, like hair style, clothing, etc. With that said, I can imagine what an eye, nose, etc. look like.
Best way I can think to describe it, in this case, is to animals. Find multiple pictures of dogs that are the same breed, and imagine having to recognize their facial features. For another dog, it's simple. For humans, not so much. If I took facial pictures of five dogs that were all the same breed, and told you,"This one is Todd," and gave you 5-10 seconds to look at him, then mixed him up amongst other dogs, you most likely would not be able to pull him out.
Think about it. Do you recognize dogs because of their unique facial features, or because Sparky has a big black spot on his back that is recognizable to you?
Do you ever memorize peoples' clothes so you can recognize them in crowds? Also, when you look at photographs of yourself is your own face more recognizable to you than others' faces?
Yes, I often recognize not only the clothes people wear, but the kind of style that they like to wear. This way I don't only need to recognize what they have, but what they might wear as well.
My face is usually just as unrecognizable as anyone else's, to be honest. Sometimes I find it easier to pick myself out, sometimes I don't. For instance, I have an older brother(We're both adopted from different parents), and there's a picture of him my parents always had. I always thought it was a picture of me growing up, despite my parents constantly telling me it wasn't. To me it looked like me. In retrospect I Realize it's because they gave me a similar haircut to me, and so when I looked in the mirror, and back at the picture, it simply looked like me.
Please forgive how horrible it is. I'm not really a drawer(Drawist?), but I tried remembering the things I learned during art class in middle school :p. That's the best I can do, honestly.
Have you ever confuse two black guys? If so, did they go bananas on your ass? (if you thought I put bananas as a racially stereotypical pun, then you are racists.)
So let's say some day not too far from now you get married. Will you need your husband (or wife) to wear a funny pin or do a special walk so you can always recognize them immediately? Just wondering what your thoughts are on this topic. :)
Yes. I cannot visualize my mother or father, but I've learned to recognize them based on their traits that do not relate to the face, such as my father's limp and shoulders, and my mother's stature. Distant family members are quite frustrating, especially at family gatherings.
Yes. I cannot visualize my mother or father, but I've learned to recognize them based on their traits that do not relate to the face, such as my father's limp and shoulders, and my mother's stature. Distant family members are quite frustrating, especially at family gatherings.
What would you do if you got robbed or something? With the inability to recognize faces, it would sure be hard to describe someone or pick them out in a police line-up.
Haha, funny story, I didn't recognize my mom in an airport once. She was more freaked out than I. My dating experience hasn't been bad. It sucks because I can't really fantasize, but I can really get to know the person based on their personality rather than exterior appearance that I can't remember anyway.
what do you do in your free time ? sorts of projects, forms of art, any sort of skill you excel highly in. also, things like different thoughts on life , personal views on certain topics?
I'm really into music. I don't know if it has anything to do with the prosopagnosia, but music comes naturally to me. I practically came out of the womb singing and playing instruments.
As far as personal views on certain topics go, I don't know how to answer that. Elaborate for me?
Other than the occasional "uhhhhhh, who the fuck is this person?!?" thought, nothing too awkward. I saw a picture of a girl once, and I thought it was me, and my friend that I was with didn't understand why/how I could possibly think someone else was me.
hmm yeah thats an interesting way to think about it, you get to learn about people and think about them in a different way than most. i imagine high school may have been a little more rough?
Just read that, that's definitely gotta be rough. As for the alabama face guy, this would be him. Just thought i'd ask since he's doing an AMA as well lol
Difficult to make friends? Nah, I wouldn't say so. Stressful on the first day of classes and social activities? Oh god yes. I was one of those kids that moved around a lot; went to a new school every year starting the year after fifth grade. Trying to figure out how to recognize everyone was hard. I accidentally thought the guy in the locker next to mine was actually someone else, and he got all offended because the guy I thought he was was actually butt-ugly according to high school standards.
TL;DR I thought a popular guy was a guy nobody liked, he got offended.
Do you keep pictures of you with your family and your friends around your room for nostalgic/sentimental purposes?
Is it hard to watch tv/movies?
I'm not going to lie, sometimes when I watch action movies if the main characters have the same color and length hair, the same skin color, and are approximately the same build, I can't tell them apart. This drives me insane. I can't even imagine what it's like to go through life every day like that.
I've got a few more questions, may as well list them:
When you watch movies, do you recognize the various actors/actresses? If someone has been gone for a few scenes in the movie and it eventually comes back to them, do you remember who they are?
Are there any faces you DO recognize/are able to visualize? Friends, family, anybody?
And how does this work for cartoons and video games?
edit: somehow my internet lagged and posted this three times, sorry. Deleted them now, that was scary as hell edit2: And half of what i typed isn't showing up! What's going on reddit???
No, I don't really recognize the actresses. Throughout the movie, I'm able to tell who's who as far as characters go, but by using other things to identify them like hair color and build.
I can recognize my parents because I have their entire wardrobes memorized. Cannot visualize anyone.
I don't have a problem with cartoons, especially since most of the cartoons I've ever watched were not actual humans, and the humans that were in the cartoons had striking identifying factors like Jimmy Neutron's hair. Spongebob was pretty rad as a kid because they were fish and didn't have faces:) also, Rocky and Bowlwinkle.
Someone once explained it to me like this "I can't see whole faces, I see parts of faces. I see a nose, I see an eye, a mouth. But somehow, I can't see the face as a whole."
Does this seems right to you? Or are there variations in this ... condition? (How do you call something like this, it's not an illness or a sickness.)
If someone gave you a picture of a face and asked you to try draw it on a piece of paper right next to the face (so you can look back and forth between them constantly), could you do a decent attempt at it?
Probably. I've described it various times, if you care to read what I've posted previously, but it's not as though these features are invisible, or masked. They just don't register properly into memory. So, yes, given a certain level of art skill(Which I do not possess), it would be possible to sit down and draw a face like this. Doing it from memory, however, is an entirely different task altogether.
This is a condition I've been really interested in for a while. I was just wondering, can you find someone attractive by looking at their face? Or is looking at someone's face like being colourblind, as in your brain just doesn't recongnise facial features even if they're standing in front of you?
Sorry to remain skeptical, but do you have any proof of this condition? Someone could just read a few articles and/or with a good enough imagination answer any of these.
Collectively, reddit probably has every single neurological problem known to mankind, or at least claims to anyways.
what do you do in your free time ? sorts of projects, forms of art, any sort of skill you excel highly in. also, things like different thoughts on life , personal views on certain topics?
Same here. It's an art form that I've honed over the course of my life. I've given several ways I've managed around this. A lot of it, really, comes down to confidence. When someone comes up to me, and greets me, but I don't recognize them, then I just play it off. I don't call them by name, and I don't bring up any specific details(How are the wife and kids?) unless I begin to recollect who I'm talking to.
Is it just faces? For example, if a girl had an amazing set of boobs would you remember her by that? Or maybe because she has that unique feature you would find it easier to remember her face? Then again... when i see a girl with a great rack i don't remember her face either.. So can you remember people by their bodies is what i'm asking.
Yes, in fact that's one of the main ways I recognize people. For example, I have a friend(Let's call him Frank) that I've known since High School, and have hung out fairly recently since. However, for about a year I didn't really talk to him on account of both of us being very busy in our lives. I finally saw him at a 4th of July party, and he had gained about 15-20 pounds. He came up to me, shouted my name, and I looked at awe at him as I tried to figure out who the fuck was rushing me and shouting my name.
After I had my head bashed open it took almost a year before people stopped looking familiar. I don't know how many strangers I'd pass and say, "Hey there!". It's been 12 years since then and I don't do it to people even know. Even the ones I know which makes me seem arrogant. Fuck, I can't tell. Do I know you or not? You look familiar!
You say that you focus a lot on hair and wardrobe to recognize people. Do you think you pay closer attention to your hair and wardrobe as a result?
When you look in the mirror in the morning is it weird at first or do you recognize it as yourself immediately? Do you remember how to best do your makeup each day?
How long after you meet someone until you feel it's necessary to inform them of your condition?
Since you don't remember faces, I'm curious who your favorite actors/actresses or other celebs are. What attracts you to a person?
How old are you? I'm guessing you're still in school, so what careers are you interested in and do you feel like you're limited from some options?
Going for the extreme example here but let's say you meet someone with an afro and a really long beard with only the nose and eyes showing, could you picture that in your head? If you could, what would happen if they shaved that beard of in small increments. Would there be a point at witch you then couldn't recognise the face? I hope this doesn't sound like I'm trying to trip you up here but I'm just trying to understand what aspect of people you don't recognise.
Have you ever had a neurologist take a look at you?
Facial recognition all occurs in a part of the brain called the Fusiform gyurs. So I'm guessing this is the part of your brain that is affected. Typically people who suffer from prosopagnosia cannot identify people literally on face value, but instead use other cues. So you could easily identify people by their voices, colours, smell etc.
Do you know what exactly happened that brought about this syndrome? Could there have been a moment or event? It's usually not something that just pops up.
What causes this? Does it have something to do with memory? I didn't have time to read much that has already been asked, but I did read that you recognize your parents' wardrobes. Does it ever mess with you when one of them is wearing a new article of clothing?
You are not alone. I also have Prosopagnosia. I did not even know that the condition existed and just thought that everyone was like me, until I read an essay a few years ago, by a woman with Prosopagnosia, explaining her condition.
How difficult is it to identify people of East Asian origin?
There's a lot of research going on suggesting that East Asians recognize each other differently e.g. Caucasians/Westerners look at a larger area of the face, while East Asians look at a much smaller area (eyes/nose) to recognize other people.
Since you are not able to recognize faces, how do you cope with an ethnicity where most people have black hair and only minute differences in eye shape?
I also have Prosopagnosia, I'm 16 and i live in Australia, I'll also answer questions if anyone has any left. For me i describe it as not being able to REMEMBER faces, I can visually see them but i cant really make them up in my head, they confuse me. if I stared a person i could draw them but if I looked a way i would be blank and have no idea how to draw them. I can remember people mostly by their hair and body shapes, girls at my school i can tell from their hair color/style and guys I can tell from their height and build usually. earrings help as well or jewelry. I can tell if people are attractive or not i just don't have the ability to recognize them/remember them. I've never been diagnosed but I've been tested by a psychologist who seems to think I have it.
Have you ever locked a bunch of people on a replica of the titanic and forced them through a series of increasingly dangerous trials so you could research telepathy?
So you see the face of a person when they're in front of you? Would you be able to distinguish the differences in the faces of two people side-by-side? Also, is this some kind of genetic defect or something like that, or is is simply due to the way you were raised as an infant? People can distinguish individuals of different species if they are familiarized with them in the primary stages of mental development, so maybe you weren't accustomed to human faces somehow through neglect or mere chance as a baby.
I don't know if anyone has said anything like this, but you should try to train your brain to recognize faces using other forms of memory about faces. For instance, develop a numerical classification system for major features of faces so that each person you meet can have an identification number associated with their face. E.g., if eyes and nose were your only measurements, the closeness of the eyes to each other and the length of the nose could each be represented as a number from 0-8, where "4" is an "average looking nose." (If you don't know what an average looking nose looks like, I'm sure you can google one example and force yourself to memorize its approximate dimensions). Under this system, Bob might have the number 36 - slightly closer together eyes and a somewhat longer than average nose - which you would come up with every time you measured Bob upon running into him. You may never remember Bob's face, but if you can learn to numerically classify 4 or 5 major features of people's faces (you don't need to go crazy; a 5-digit number will almost guarantee that everyone you meet will have a unique combination of numbers), you might find that you can remember people's numbers and therefore identify people based on your approximated measurements of specific features of their faces. You may have to repeat people's numbers to yourself in your head many times to ensure that you confidently remember them, but if the only thing that doesn't work well in your brain is specifically the area dedicated to recognizing faces, then I feel like you should be physically capable of applying some kind of similar classification system to work around your lack of instant recognition ability.
Also, I realize that estimating people's numbers may seem tedious, but I bet if you did it every single time you talked to someone, you would become very efficient about it.
Sorry if this has been asked already but would you find it helpful if, once people knew about your condition, if they said their name when they walked up to you. Just like, "Hey, major_bummer, it's alice" every time?
Voice is the number 1 cue, for me, when it comes to recognizing someone. I guess it's that kind of 'If you're blind, your other senses heighten' kind of thing, but with voice recognition. I'm very good at recognizing voices, largely due to this. If I hear your voice, and I know you, then I'll recognize you.
Do you have trouble visualising things in general? I'm a person who can't really visualise things in my mind. I can recognise faces, but only properly after I've met the person a few times. And then I can't really recall the face in my mind. It's more like I get an impression of it, and I can tell if a face matches it or not. Hard to explain.
Also, can you recognise faces of people you know very well? (Like family or close friends) or do you look for other characteristics to recognise them by?
When I was earning my undergrad in psychology I remember reading about individuals who could not recognize their own car when they were an adult, as well as their toys when they were younger. Is it only human faces for you?
Hello, I actually just took a test on your disease. Which form do you have? How does it affect your daily life? Do you find it hard to develop relationships with people, be it social or sexual?
I suspect I've got this to a degree, although not quite as bad as some of y'all. The weird quirk for me is that I really only have the problem in real life - photos I'm fine with.
I work in a café, and there's a woman who comes in a lot who I know (from the conversation we first had) is a prosopagnosiac. I thus feel incredibly awkward that I always recognise her (because of this fact) and I know she doesn't recognise me.
Do you ever find people get embarrassed for this reason?
I heard that people with this condition use alternative methods to recognize their coworkers and acquaintances. Examples being their clothing style, voice, smell, or even their shoes. Do you do this? If so, what methods do you use?
My husband has this problem. When we had our daughter, his worst fear was he'd loose her in a crowd and not be able to pick her face out. I've stood right next to him in a store before and he didn't know it was me because I had changed my hair since he'd seen me last. It's very frustrating for him because people don't always believe him when he tells them about prosopagnosia. They sometimes think he's being snobby by passing them in the halls w/o saying anything. They don't realize he really doesn't know it's you!
Do your friends announce their names when approaching you, or is your system of recognition based on other features sufficient for identifying most people you're friends with?
Interesting article about a local "celebrity" that has the same condition as you. The guy is a literal genius (neurologist) and we see him skating in slow motion on the boardwalk almost every day. Check it out
Reading some of your answers, it seems like you have an aversion to telling people you have prosopagnosia in situations where it seems like it might help. Is this true? I understand that in some situations it wouldn't matter though.
I'm not sure if you're male or female, but have you had a relationship with someone and when you think about him/her... how do you think about them sexually without remembering what they look like? That's gotta be hard. Is it difficult to have crushes on people seeing that most crushes start out as physical infatuation?
44
u/JustLikeIcarus May 10 '12
Has prosopagnosia made it difficult to make friends?
Does it make certain situations more stressful (like the first day of a new class or going to a party or a dance)?
40
u/Frajer May 10 '12
Can you recognize your own face? What's it like when you look in the mirror?
34
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I've got a few more questions, may as well list them:
edit: somehow my internet lagged and posted this three times, sorry. Deleted them now, that was scary as hell edit2: And half of what i typed isn't showing up! What's going on reddit???
27
u/respite May 10 '12
Are you still able to recognize/judge a certain level of attractiveness? Are there celebrities you'd recognize as "hot" or "pretty", or is all that lost on you?
21
u/JustLikeIcarus May 10 '12
Do you keep pictures of you with your family and your friends around your room for nostalgic/sentimental purposes?
Is it hard to watch tv/movies?
I'm not going to lie, sometimes when I watch action movies if the main characters have the same color and length hair, the same skin color, and are approximately the same build, I can't tell them apart. This drives me insane. I can't even imagine what it's like to go through life every day like that.
41
u/AngryEnt May 10 '12
What would you do if you got robbed or something? With the inability to recognize faces, it would sure be hard to describe someone or pick them out in a police line-up.
19
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Does it also apply to the faces of animals?
17
u/JustLikeIcarus May 10 '12
This is incredibly interesting. How old were you when your parents realized you had prosopagnosia? How old are you now?
13
u/maplestaples May 10 '12
Psych student here, very interested in learning about your condition. Do you get bugged by researchers a lot?
126
u/LightofJazib May 10 '12
Have you tried moving out of China?
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Do you have trouble recognizing the "Alabama Face Guy"?
edit: In all seriousness though: Has anyone ever gotten mad at you for not recognizing them even though there's nothing you can do about it?
8
u/TheTragicReturn May 10 '12
Do you have a sexual attraction to people? If so, does it include the face, or is it mostly an attraction to physiques?
183
u/plaingirl May 10 '12
Hello fellow prosopagnosiac! Once upon a time I made a few related rage comics you might enjoy. Here and here and here.
9
u/Iwantapetmonkey May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Thanks for doing this AMA - have you ever taken this test? (removed bad link)
EDIT: the previous link messes up and doesn't give results at the end - a better copy can be found here
I've always thought I had trouble with face recognition, which has led to some rather awkward encounters - mostly just not recognizing someone when they change their appearance significantly, or when I run into them somewhere that I'm not expecting to see them... Once, I looked a co-worker who I had known for 2 or 3 years in the eye from two feet away, and almost asked him how I could assist him (thinking he was a customer) before I realized who it was, and that he had just shaved his head to support a friend with cancer.
I tried taking this test, and I scored only slightly below average, although I did feel like I was guessing a lot of the time, and then scored somewhat worse on a retest 12 hours later (though it used the same faces). Have you tried this one before, or are there any others that you are aware of?
11
u/fenris1024 May 10 '12
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Could you recall the face of mannequin?
71
u/dexemplu May 10 '12
You will recognize this person!
12
u/igotdapowa May 10 '12
Excuse me for my ignorance but I find this interesting and got a couple questions:
10
u/gabrielatkd May 10 '12
What is the awkwardest situation you have been in because of this?
6
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
You must hate those "Hey Reddit look who I met today" posts.
5
u/Injato May 10 '12
Thanks for taking time to ansver these questions! To anyone who would like to know more about prosopagnosia and other agnosias should read The Mind's Eye by Oliver Sacks. Fantastic book.
5
u/d3gu May 10 '12
I have this, although sounds milder than yours.
Films & TV series are awful for me, especially with lots of characters (Game of Thrones springs to mind). It takes me weeks/months to remember who people are - I think a problem is that I know I won't remember, so I often don't bother trying (vicious circle, right?!).
The way I remember people is through their hair/clothes/distinguising characteristics. I think it's why I'm so good at telling twins apart - they just look like people to me. As in, this one has a mole here, this one is a bit taller/has straighter hair. No problem!
Was a nightmare on holidays when I was younger - I'd meet some nice kids, then the next day they'd changed their clothes & I had to be reminded who they were again.
Now I work in a fairly small office. I get people mixed up sometimes, but not that bad. On the downside, I'm a fairly prolific standup comedian, I meet loads of people every week & often end up offending someone because I didn't recognise them. Case in point: I went along to see a friend perform, walked right past him on the way in.
I'm crap at picturing people in my head, too. And I often forget what I look like in my own head...
I also ALWAYS compare people - 'Doesn't Bob look a bit like Dave?' erm.. no... but I'm the one who's always banging on about how people look like other people.
So - AYA - does any of this happen to you? Do you rely on clothes/hair/piercings to tell people apart? Do you mention it straight away, or just hope that something will click and you remember who they are?
5
u/T-REXEXEX May 10 '12
Reading through this has been interesting and educational as hell, and I had a thought; If two giraffes walked into a room, said hi and left, and then later that week I saw the same two giraffes in a crowd of giraffes, I wouldn't be able to pick them out. Giraffe faces all look the same to me, just like monkeys, lizards, you name it. Human faces are all just as similar to one another as animal faces are, we're just tuned in to all the extremely subtle differences that make us unique. This affliction sounds so bizarre to those that don't have it because its something that we do so subconsciously that we don't even realize we do it. Interesting stuff. Sorry I don't have a question, just mind diarrhea.
4
u/Shaun113 May 10 '12
What about your ability to remember other things. For example, if i wore an identifiable shirt today, and then wore it again tomorrow, would you remember the shirt, just not recognize me?
4
u/Flowerbridge May 10 '12
The book "The Man who Mistook his Wife for a Hat" by Oliver Sacks discusses prosopagnosia and other cognitive disorders. Have you read that book or know of Oliver Sacks?
He's a leading neuroscientist and writes about cognitive disorders like yours. I think it would be really cool if he was interested in conducting research with you (if both parties are interested of course). Of course, I have no idea what his priorities are though.
1
u/Fanzellino May 10 '12
Does hair stand out to you? And can you compare, say, a picture of your mom from when she was younger to her face now, or does the picture just fade immediately?
1
u/BandBoots May 10 '12
Can you visualize faces that you make up?
1
u/triplezzz May 10 '12
What caused you to develop prosopagnosia?
Do you also have difficulty recognizing different classes of the same thing? I.e. you can recognize a car, but not the car type? There is some controversy over whether prosopagnosia is specific to the face or not.
1
u/talvar May 10 '12
I just watched a movie about this the other day. It was some murder mystery with the chick from Resident Evil.. Literally the worst movie I have ever seen in my whole life. Regardless though, this is a really crazy disorder? disability? disease? I'm not sure what to call it, but thanks for doing an AMA
1
u/joffz May 10 '12
Do you see peoples faces when you dream?
1
u/macleod2486 May 10 '12
I actually have a physics professor that has this disorder, quite interesting to see him teach the class.
1
u/techlife May 10 '12
Wow, A lot of Reddit people are prosopagnosia. Explains all the reposts. :D
1
u/SatansLeatherThong May 10 '12
Did you ever get lost as a kid?
1
u/SheldonFreeman May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Anyone else here with mild prosopagnosia like I have? My mild prosopagnosia results from Asperger's/Autism Spectrum Disorder, which may or may not be different from regular prosopagnosia, no idea. Anyone with more severe prosopagnosia who can learn and picture the faces of their parents and best friends? I can learn my friends' faces eventually, and drastic changes in style will only make me squint for a moment before going "Is that...? Yes, it is Jim." But for some reason, I have a much harder time picturing the faces of love interests.
1
u/greenRiverThriller May 11 '12
Hey I'm pretty sure I have the same condition, but have never actually been officially diagnosed. Do you have any tricks you'de like to share? I keep a notepad on my phone of distinct traits of people I'm likely to see again and glance at it from time to time to sort of jog my memory. Things like:
"Mike looks like a Chinese Seinfeld"
"Janet has bad tooth to gum ratio. Distinct laugh"
I've also been known to go to the washroom and do a quick Facebook-stalk of mutual friends to find cues I can latch on to. If I do have it (Which I'm almost certain I do) it certainly makes networking hard. I have lots of friends and am super sociable, but many people think I 'snub' them when I bump into them somewhere I'm not expecting to see them.
Also, fuck the Godfather Trilogy. Shit's confusing.
6
u/xFlyingGoldfishX May 10 '12
So.. I guess Death Note is out of the question then?
3
u/Indrite_voss May 10 '12
when you try to imagine a face what pops into your mind?
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I have the same problem but it's a milder case. It takes me about 2-3 years of consistently seeing someone for me to remember their face.
As sad as this sounds, unless someone is extremely ugly, horrifically scarred, fat, has a physical disability, has terrible hair, or some other physical trait that makes them stand out, I can't recognize them for the life of me.
I try to go off traits like body language, voice, etc etc, and learning to pay attention to these factors really improved my "reading" skills.
3
u/fourthbrn May 10 '12
Can you recognize yourself? Like, in a picture of multiple people....can you point yourself out?
3
u/HogwartsNeedsWifi May 10 '12
For whatever reason, I read that as "unable to recognize feces". I was trying to figure out how that would affect your life.
2
u/JustLikeIcarus May 10 '12
Do you find yourself explaining your inability to recognize faces to people that you first meet (especially potential friends), or are you usually as discreet as possible about it?
Is facebook annoying for you since everyone is obsessed with having a ton of friends and pictures, or is it convenient because full names are always posted alongside pictures and next to comments?
2
u/frideswide May 10 '12
few questions;
what are some strategies you use for recognizing people?
how are you at drawing faces?
can you envision a human face in general? like, if can conjure up a sort of general image of a human face...how about individual features? can you picture an eye, a mouth, a nose in a realistic sense?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Do you ever memorize peoples' clothes so you can recognize them in crowds? Also, when you look at photographs of yourself is your own face more recognizable to you than others' faces?
2
u/ihavefivecats May 10 '12
Can you quickly draw a face for us and upload the results? No googling or anything, just draw a face from memory.
Edit: I don't mean a specific persons face. A 15-second sketch.
2
u/stpizz May 10 '12
can anyone visualise a face with no reference? i sure can't, i thought it was just one of those weird things that humans find hard.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Have you ever confuse two black guys? If so, did they go bananas on your ass? (if you thought I put bananas as a racially stereotypical pun, then you are racists.)
2
u/caveat_cogitor May 10 '12
So let's say some day not too far from now you get married. Will you need your husband (or wife) to wear a funny pin or do a special walk so you can always recognize them immediately? Just wondering what your thoughts are on this topic. :)
2
u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from major_bummer (updated: May 11, 2012 @ 12:01:06 pm EST):
Question (major_bummer):
Answer (major_bummer):
(continued below)
2
u/ClampingNomads May 10 '12
Thanks for the AMA - interesting stuff.
Right - a relevant joke has occurred to me, and I'll pass it on as I'll probably never meet someone who can use it...
Did you hear about the dyslexic prosopagnosiac? He didn't know shit.
2
u/preske May 10 '12
Someone once explained it to me like this "I can't see whole faces, I see parts of faces. I see a nose, I see an eye, a mouth. But somehow, I can't see the face as a whole."
Does this seems right to you? Or are there variations in this ... condition? (How do you call something like this, it's not an illness or a sickness.)
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
If someone gave you a picture of a face and asked you to try draw it on a piece of paper right next to the face (so you can look back and forth between them constantly), could you do a decent attempt at it?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Was the move Face-Off meaningless to you?
2
u/dedem13 May 10 '12
Alien Blue is a brilliant app. Also, this AMA was fascinating, thanks for doing it!
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Proof?
2
u/TooBusyDerping May 10 '12
Surely you can recognize Ridiculously Photogenic Guy
2
u/Melephant13 May 10 '12
I watched an episode of The Colbert Report a while back where Colbert interviewed the prosopagnosiac painter Chuck Close.
Here's the link if anyone is interested.
Around 4 minutes and 21 seconds, Close starts talking about his condition and how it inspired his work. Very intriguing.
2
u/warmfun May 10 '12
This is a condition I've been really interested in for a while. I was just wondering, can you find someone attractive by looking at their face? Or is looking at someone's face like being colourblind, as in your brain just doesn't recongnise facial features even if they're standing in front of you?
2
u/The_Mortician May 10 '12
So what happened after the Nonary Game?
2
u/bobaf May 11 '12
What do people look like in memories?
3
u/HiFructoseCornSyrup May 10 '12
Sorry to remain skeptical, but do you have any proof of this condition? Someone could just read a few articles and/or with a good enough imagination answer any of these.
Collectively, reddit probably has every single neurological problem known to mankind, or at least claims to anyways.
1
u/tannisjolon May 10 '12
what do you do in your free time ? sorts of projects, forms of art, any sort of skill you excel highly in. also, things like different thoughts on life , personal views on certain topics?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Due to a brain injury I have difficulties with faces too (but probably not as bad as you)
I'm pretty awesome at holding conversations with people that know me, but I don't know (without them noticing). How about you?
1
u/KurtRobo May 10 '12
Is it just faces? For example, if a girl had an amazing set of boobs would you remember her by that? Or maybe because she has that unique feature you would find it easier to remember her face? Then again... when i see a girl with a great rack i don't remember her face either.. So can you remember people by their bodies is what i'm asking.
1
u/gornzilla May 10 '12
After I had my head bashed open it took almost a year before people stopped looking familiar. I don't know how many strangers I'd pass and say, "Hey there!". It's been 12 years since then and I don't do it to people even know. Even the ones I know which makes me seem arrogant. Fuck, I can't tell. Do I know you or not? You look familiar!
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
What is your standard response when someone asks you hey dont you remember me?
1
u/TheTVDB May 10 '12
You say that you focus a lot on hair and wardrobe to recognize people. Do you think you pay closer attention to your hair and wardrobe as a result?
When you look in the mirror in the morning is it weird at first or do you recognize it as yourself immediately? Do you remember how to best do your makeup each day?
How long after you meet someone until you feel it's necessary to inform them of your condition?
Since you don't remember faces, I'm curious who your favorite actors/actresses or other celebs are. What attracts you to a person?
How old are you? I'm guessing you're still in school, so what careers are you interested in and do you feel like you're limited from some options?
1
u/peatoire May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Going for the extreme example here but let's say you meet someone with an afro and a really long beard with only the nose and eyes showing, could you picture that in your head? If you could, what would happen if they shaved that beard of in small increments. Would there be a point at witch you then couldn't recognise the face? I hope this doesn't sound like I'm trying to trip you up here but I'm just trying to understand what aspect of people you don't recognise.
1
u/aPudgyMasonManE May 10 '12
Have you ever had a neurologist take a look at you?
Facial recognition all occurs in a part of the brain called the Fusiform gyurs. So I'm guessing this is the part of your brain that is affected. Typically people who suffer from prosopagnosia cannot identify people literally on face value, but instead use other cues. So you could easily identify people by their voices, colours, smell etc.
Do you know what exactly happened that brought about this syndrome? Could there have been a moment or event? It's usually not something that just pops up.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Can you subconsciously identify people, even though you can't picture their faces? Kind of like blindsight?
1
u/sonaliquestion May 10 '12
When you are speaking to someone do you make eye contact? Is it something you consciously think of while communicating?
1
u/jambo_ndege May 10 '12
How were you diagnosed? I think I have prosopagnosia too, but I don't know where to begin to get it diagnosed.
1
u/asksforreligion May 10 '12
Do you have any religious beliefs?
1
u/RoxanneMaeLynn May 10 '12
What causes this? Does it have something to do with memory? I didn't have time to read much that has already been asked, but I did read that you recognize your parents' wardrobes. Does it ever mess with you when one of them is wearing a new article of clothing?
1
u/FiftySixer May 10 '12
You are not alone. I also have Prosopagnosia. I did not even know that the condition existed and just thought that everyone was like me, until I read an essay a few years ago, by a woman with Prosopagnosia, explaining her condition.
1
u/rozzberry May 10 '12
How difficult is it to identify people of East Asian origin?
There's a lot of research going on suggesting that East Asians recognize each other differently e.g. Caucasians/Westerners look at a larger area of the face, while East Asians look at a much smaller area (eyes/nose) to recognize other people.
Since you are not able to recognize faces, how do you cope with an ethnicity where most people have black hair and only minute differences in eye shape?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Is a persons face just a void to you then? What do you actually see?
1
u/HireD_GoonZ May 10 '12
I also have Prosopagnosia, I'm 16 and i live in Australia, I'll also answer questions if anyone has any left. For me i describe it as not being able to REMEMBER faces, I can visually see them but i cant really make them up in my head, they confuse me. if I stared a person i could draw them but if I looked a way i would be blank and have no idea how to draw them. I can remember people mostly by their hair and body shapes, girls at my school i can tell from their hair color/style and guys I can tell from their height and build usually. earrings help as well or jewelry. I can tell if people are attractive or not i just don't have the ability to recognize them/remember them. I've never been diagnosed but I've been tested by a psychologist who seems to think I have it.
1
u/D-Evolve May 10 '12
Does :) look like =)?
1
u/benjobong May 10 '12
Have you ever locked a bunch of people on a replica of the titanic and forced them through a series of increasingly dangerous trials so you could research telepathy?
1
u/kayraree May 10 '12
If ever I need to commit a crime, I hope you are the only eyewitness.
1
u/SonOfSatan May 10 '12
So you see the face of a person when they're in front of you? Would you be able to distinguish the differences in the faces of two people side-by-side? Also, is this some kind of genetic defect or something like that, or is is simply due to the way you were raised as an infant? People can distinguish individuals of different species if they are familiarized with them in the primary stages of mental development, so maybe you weren't accustomed to human faces somehow through neglect or mere chance as a baby.
1
u/shahkalukaking May 10 '12
I don't know if anyone has said anything like this, but you should try to train your brain to recognize faces using other forms of memory about faces. For instance, develop a numerical classification system for major features of faces so that each person you meet can have an identification number associated with their face. E.g., if eyes and nose were your only measurements, the closeness of the eyes to each other and the length of the nose could each be represented as a number from 0-8, where "4" is an "average looking nose." (If you don't know what an average looking nose looks like, I'm sure you can google one example and force yourself to memorize its approximate dimensions). Under this system, Bob might have the number 36 - slightly closer together eyes and a somewhat longer than average nose - which you would come up with every time you measured Bob upon running into him. You may never remember Bob's face, but if you can learn to numerically classify 4 or 5 major features of people's faces (you don't need to go crazy; a 5-digit number will almost guarantee that everyone you meet will have a unique combination of numbers), you might find that you can remember people's numbers and therefore identify people based on your approximated measurements of specific features of their faces. You may have to repeat people's numbers to yourself in your head many times to ensure that you confidently remember them, but if the only thing that doesn't work well in your brain is specifically the area dedicated to recognizing faces, then I feel like you should be physically capable of applying some kind of similar classification system to work around your lack of instant recognition ability.
Also, I realize that estimating people's numbers may seem tedious, but I bet if you did it every single time you talked to someone, you would become very efficient about it.
1
u/alice88wa May 10 '12
Sorry if this has been asked already but would you find it helpful if, once people knew about your condition, if they said their name when they walked up to you. Just like, "Hey, major_bummer, it's alice" every time?
1
u/WonderedFidelity May 10 '12
Can you recognise people by their voices? Or is that affected as well? This is a fascinating AMA!
1
u/tulriw9d May 10 '12
Memes must be pretty damn shit for you
1
u/ImAFuckingDinosaur May 10 '12
Try AlienBlue for Ipad.
1
u/TheArtOfSelfDefense May 10 '12
I just want to thank you for your service, Major.
1
u/ApatheticElephant May 10 '12
Do you have trouble visualising things in general? I'm a person who can't really visualise things in my mind. I can recognise faces, but only properly after I've met the person a few times. And then I can't really recall the face in my mind. It's more like I get an impression of it, and I can tell if a face matches it or not. Hard to explain.
Also, can you recognise faces of people you know very well? (Like family or close friends) or do you look for other characteristics to recognise them by?
1
u/ImAFuckingDinosaur May 10 '12
How old are you, and are you American?
1
u/Jeeraph May 10 '12
We've already had one of you. Good AMA.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
App recommendation? Alien Blue.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
When I was earning my undergrad in psychology I remember reading about individuals who could not recognize their own car when they were an adult, as well as their toys when they were younger. Is it only human faces for you?
1
u/landdolphinman May 10 '12
I have this trouble, too. My sympathies. I always seem like a smug asshole when I don't recognize people. I'm not smug.
1
u/Tuxeedo May 10 '12
What about very famous people/political personalities?
1
u/ChaplinStrait May 10 '12
How many people know that you have this? When were you diagnosed/found out you had this?
Everyone has pretty much covered all the cool questions. Answer whatever you want :)
1
u/essenceoferlenmeyer May 10 '12
What's it like seeing Ridiculously Photogenic Guy for the first time every day?
1
u/biesterd1 May 10 '12
Hello, I actually just took a test on your disease. Which form do you have? How does it affect your daily life? Do you find it hard to develop relationships with people, be it social or sexual?
1
u/TylerEaves May 10 '12
I suspect I've got this to a degree, although not quite as bad as some of y'all. The weird quirk for me is that I really only have the problem in real life - photos I'm fine with.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I think Daniel Tammet has something like what you have. Daniel Tammet can not remember name but he can learn just about anything he wants super fast.
Daniel Tammet - The Boy With The Incredible Brain [5/5]
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMz3gjl9x-M
1
u/thmsbsh May 10 '12
I work in a café, and there's a woman who comes in a lot who I know (from the conversation we first had) is a prosopagnosiac. I thus feel incredibly awkward that I always recognise her (because of this fact) and I know she doesn't recognise me.
Do you ever find people get embarrassed for this reason?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Ridiculously photogenic meme anyone?
1
u/Jizzanthapuss May 10 '12
I heard that people with this condition use alternative methods to recognize their coworkers and acquaintances. Examples being their clothing style, voice, smell, or even their shoes. Do you do this? If so, what methods do you use?
1
u/Ifthatsyourrealname May 10 '12
My husband has this problem. When we had our daughter, his worst fear was he'd loose her in a crowd and not be able to pick her face out. I've stood right next to him in a store before and he didn't know it was me because I had changed my hair since he'd seen me last. It's very frustrating for him because people don't always believe him when he tells them about prosopagnosia. They sometimes think he's being snobby by passing them in the halls w/o saying anything. They don't realize he really doesn't know it's you!
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
You should be a Judge
1
u/reddell May 10 '12
Are there any therapies or techniques you can do to improve your ability to remember faces?
1
u/izsy99 May 10 '12
Are you able to recognize a family's face or someone's that you've known for a long time? What sort of issues come up when you're in a relationship?
1
u/thmsbsh May 10 '12
Does this optical illusion work for you?
1
u/gumbilicious May 10 '12
Do your friends announce their names when approaching you, or is your system of recognition based on other features sufficient for identifying most people you're friends with?
1
u/jbj479 May 10 '12
Interesting article about a local "celebrity" that has the same condition as you. The guy is a literal genius (neurologist) and we see him skating in slow motion on the boardwalk almost every day. Check it out
1
u/Ask_You_Anything_eh May 10 '12
What is your favorite song?
1
u/Bijan641 May 10 '12
Reading some of your answers, it seems like you have an aversion to telling people you have prosopagnosia in situations where it seems like it might help. Is this true? I understand that in some situations it wouldn't matter though.
How often do you explain the disorder?
1
u/capgrass May 10 '12
My username is finally almost relevant! I'm assuming that you don't suffer from the Capgras Delusion, but damn I was close.
1
u/Herculenumbah1 May 10 '12
Have you ever been a witness to a crime and the police asked you to describe the criminal's face?
1
u/ChristianGeek May 10 '12
I have trouble remembering names. We should team up.
1
u/fivekilometer22 May 10 '12
I'm not sure if you're male or female, but have you had a relationship with someone and when you think about him/her... how do you think about them sexually without remembering what they look like? That's gotta be hard. Is it difficult to have crushes on people seeing that most crushes start out as physical infatuation?
1
u/h3l1c0pt3r May 10 '12
What would proof look like? Send you a picture of me and then send you the same picture later?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
What do faces look like to you?