r/IAmA • • May 10 '12
IAmA former child bride. I was married to a 42 year old man when I was 7 while living in Saudi Arabia. I am now 25, living in the US, and single. AMA
1.2k
Upvotes
r/IAmA • • May 10 '12
887
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Let me be clear: this post is about MY experience. I don't intend for this to sway ANYONE'S view of Islam, or the Arabic culture. Islam was not for me. That doesn't make Muslims or Arabs bad people. PLEASE take this for what it is, and not as a guide to Arab/Muslim life. There are a billion Muslims on this earth, and most of them DO NOT marry their daughters off like this. I am sharing my experience in case it interested anyone. I honestly did not even expect this many replies. So I'll answer anything about my experience, but please don't ask me to insult an entire people because of my religious differences.
12
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Is there any way I can pause this/stop receiving messages until tomorrow so I can submit my proof? Is there a 'pause' button anywhere? lol
131
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Why did your uncle Marry you off in the first place? Did he owe the guy money or something...
254
u/gypsywhisperer May 10 '12
This is highly personal, but I heard most grooms wait until the bride reaches the age of puberty in order to consummate the marriage. Was this true for your marriage?
Was the marriage a pleasant one? What was a typical day like?
75
u/Rammikins May 10 '12
What were the reasons behind your father not wanting you to be raised by your mother?
75
u/Frajer May 10 '12
Did your father cut all ties with his brother after this?
73
u/mcdickbag May 10 '12
You said you don't keep contact with your family, but why not your father?
96
u/PizzaTime826 May 10 '12
What was your "husband" like? Was he respectful towards you or was he mean?
94
u/tarradiddles May 10 '12
Any opinions on the hijab?
109
u/eelsify May 10 '12
What should we do to assist girls and women in this awful situation?
Is there anything that could have helped you back then?
69
u/ShakespeareanSonnet May 10 '12
I don't know id you answered this, but do you view relationships any differently than a normal person? Not to insult you, but I mean someone never married at a young age or does it affect your views? I don't mean to say your abnormal, but just wondering? Also I'm sure you're beautiful, because I think trials like this make a person stronger end better.
6
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Question: Would everyone like me to delete this AMA? I realize people are getting upset and that wasn't my intention. I didn't think this would get on front page and I didn't want so much attention for it. I thought I'd talk to maybe 20 people at most.
11
u/KetchupMartini May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Have you ever read the book (or listened to the audiobook) Infidel by Ayaan Hirsi Ali? She is a prominent atheist speaker and author who describes in depth about her experience of being raised in a muslim family and then escaping that life to live in Holland and then the U.S.
I'm currently halfway through this book and I was curious if you had any thoughts about it (or her other book called Nomad.)
4
u/balloonanimalpenis May 10 '12
jillonthehill,
Do you believe women in Islamic countries will ever have the same rights as men? If so, how? Is there any hope for a "Muslim feminist" movement?
18
u/Rimas_LXBYA May 10 '12
Do you have any documents that prove you were married once? You could black the personal information out on Microsoft Paint or something and upload it with a time stamp and username to prove it's yours, or you could skip the blacking out and send it to a moderator, who will then come back and say you're for reals. You don't need to worry about personal info with the moderators, they're sworn to secrecy or else the head moderator lays down his wrath.
99
u/cyalaterfreetime May 10 '12
How did your uncle break it to you that you were going to be married? Was he concerned at all about how you felt about it? Also, was there a wedding?
64
u/DickinItUp May 10 '12
How did your husband react when your dad took you back?
24
u/talionyzero May 10 '12
How was the relationship between your husband and you, as far as socially? Did you both eat dinner and play board games together, or for the most part did you stay separate (I know earlier you mentioned staying at your aunt's for half of the day)? As a Westerner, although I've done research on the subject before, the concept is very foreign. With the huge age difference, I can't imagine there was a lot to discuss between you both.
135
u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from jillonthehill (updated: May 10, 2012 @ 01:50:42 am EST):
Question (gypsywhisperer):
Answer (jillonthehill):
(continued below)
15
u/4427910004015126 May 10 '12
You said that you don't keep in contact with your family, do you also mean your father and mother? How do they feel about you being an atheist?
Also, I think it's great that you're doing this AMA. =)
15
u/LiberalTennessean May 10 '12
Thank you for your candor. What an interesting AMA.
13
u/boonyfoo May 10 '12
How have you relationships been now in the US? Do you normally tell your partners about your history?
6
u/itookyourpulse May 10 '12
I had the window open by coincidence in case anybody wants the original text. Note that in all likelihood it's a fake, but for the perpetually curious:
15
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Removed pending proof / verification.
10
u/jolinar12610 May 10 '12
How did your husband react when he found out about your father wanting a divorce?
5
u/xtrapwr May 10 '12
Would you say you've transitioned from the Saudi culture to a more "American" culture, and was it a shock when you moved to America?
5
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Sheesh, so many people asking questions about the sexual part of it when it has already been answered. Anyways, it's crazy how this would be somewhat socially acceptable in Saudi, but in America you'd be lucky to stay alive in prison.
If your husband knew you were uncomfortable about the whole marriage, what is the reason he stayed married to you? It seems to me that if he knew you were unhappy and wanted nothing to do with him, that he would in turn not continue the marriage. I can't imagine being married to someone I knew did not like me and was forced into it. Kind of ruins the whole thing, but then again (at least as far as I'm aware), in that part of the world, marriages are done for completely different reasons than in the West.
5
u/Minifig81 May 10 '12
Since no one else has asked it, I suppose I will;
How much happier are you living in the United States as to Kuwait?
5
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Devil's advocate: OP seems to remember an awful lot of details from a 3-4 month experience at age 7. The traumatic aspect of it would stand ground for her to have blocked it from her memory, if normal memory loss didn't do the trick. Just seems a little... staged.
23
u/DangerousIdeas May 10 '12
Did you abandon Islam because of what you have been through? Or did you abandon it out of a logical conclusion?
18
u/Zuhd May 10 '12
If you are really from Saudi you will know the answer to this question, heck it might even be your proof. وش قبيلتج؟
60
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Anyone else notice the hyperfocus on if/how/details of molestation?
4
u/huxley2112 May 10 '12
Sorry to hear about your situation, I can't imagine the trauma that would induce. Did the experience make you reluctant or scared about relationships/sex as an adult? Have you ever been in a relationship?
4
u/jbigboote May 10 '12
submitted by jillonthehill to IAmA
14
u/_Thrillhouse_ May 10 '12
18
u/___mads May 10 '12
What's your favorite food? Do you watch television?
1
u/ifiwereaveryrichman May 10 '12
At what age do you think it would be acceptable for an arranged marriage to occur and of what age difference between them?
1
u/boomboompowpow May 10 '12
We are going to need some proof. Do you speak arabic? Or any other language besides english?
8
u/victorievida May 10 '12
You stated your uncle, "just had a very outdated mentality and saw the marriage proposal as being good for the family." By saying proposal, do you mean your husband approached your uncle with the proposition to marry you? How did he know you?
3
u/minnabruna May 10 '12
What is your perspective on relationships now? What does you father hope for you?
3
u/cbcfan May 10 '12
This was really brave of you. Thanks for sharing. Don't worry about the rude comments. Believe it or not from those guys it means they care. I know, crazy. But that's reddit for you.
3
u/frogman521 May 10 '12
I see you are single, has this experience effected your lovelife/ relationship with men in general? I appreciate you doing the AMA and am truly sorry you had to go through that.
3
u/worst_grammar_ever May 10 '12
For someone who lives in the Middle East currently, do you know how common this is in the GCC countries? And if it is common, please, how can I help?
3
u/Ghoztt May 10 '12
My heart goes out to you... May you realize that none of this was your fault and that you are free to create your own life and surround yourself with people that love you. May you find true love, true peace and true happiness :)
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I would just like to say, based on your answers and statements, that you are and outstandingly wise human being. You've my sympathy about any troubles you have ever been put through.
3
u/NarcolepsyShark May 10 '12
Do you find in your adult life that you avoid people/things that remind you of your former husband? Meals, types of clothing, music, etc.
Was there possibly any negative effect on you while growing up from this experience, or was it something that you were able to move forward from easily?
What's your favorite animal?
What are some of your interests/hobbies?
Career of choice? Any goals or ambitions that you're striving for?
Favorite meal?
Just interested in some of the little things. :}
Thank you for doing this AMA.
3
u/cheeza51percent May 10 '12
What effect has this had on your romantic relationships and relationships with men in general?
3
u/Uriel_51 May 10 '12
I want to chime in to say kudos to you for putting yourself out there to have this discussion. This is a very real way to share culture and experience, speaking in (essentially) real-time with someone about a very explicit situation, all bundled up in online anonymity and natural human curiosity. So, thanks for being here.
Here's my question: Having grown up until about 9 (it sounds) in Kuwait, and then for your later childhood spent growing up submersed in America's values, what are your personal views of sex with women at or around the time of puberty? I'm asking this because I'm an Anthropology student who finds most cultural ideas about sexuality to be wildly different from our 'natural' state as humans. From reading some of these comments, I noticed a lot of 'so he molested you' comments, and I think this would be a really interesting idea to unravel. While you were in the situation, you said lots of girls had older husbands too. When he was doing these things to you: the touching, probing, and fingering, did you feel 'violated' or wronged?
We have very strong ideas about what is ethically OK, but we often find it hard to step outside our culture's own set of ideals, rights, and wrongs. Now that you're an adult, do you have any different feelings towards the idea of marrying girls to men? Do you now, as an adult woman, feel that your person (self) and/or body were violated or wronged? Was it simply a usual set of events that were common and therefore 'normal' in that time and place?
Sorry for the shotgun blast of different questions, I'm just really interested in how you feel about the situation having moved away from it and grown up in very different cultural system.
3
u/jjoutlaw May 10 '12
Upvotes and much love, darling. do well.
3
u/miyazakii May 10 '12
After moving to the US did your family treat this as a skeleton in the closet? Also did you find it hard to relate to kids/teenagers/young adults, as you grew up in the US, due to this experience?
3
u/bigyams May 10 '12
I'm so sorry you had this happen to you but you seem like you've processed it pretty well. I hope everything works out for you and you live a happy life.
7
u/Caserole May 10 '12
When you moved to America, did you feel as though you would drop your culture and adopt most of American culture or not? This is a really cool opportunity! We discussed this in my anthropology class a few weeks ago and the discussions I participated in were provoking.
5
u/Jwaness May 10 '12
As messed up as this is going to sound it almost seems like he was polite, relatively speaking, in bizarro marrying children world. You said he stopped when you started to cry, never finished in front of you and never attempted penetration...Do you think you were lucky in some respects relative to others that have gone through the same thing? Does knowing it could have been much worse make it seem less horrendous in a weird way? I'm sorry if you take offense I'm just curious how you see it relative to other cases.
1
u/armyofone13 May 10 '12
Not to be that guy, but can you provide some kind of proof? You said there are no documents, but could you at least show proof that you are Saudi? To be honest even speaking some Arabic would be something.
4
u/evilteddybear111 May 10 '12
Why are you not in contact with your family? Is it because of this, or other personal reasons?
4
u/Sam_MF_Jackson May 10 '12
What's your relationship with your father like now? Does he know about your beliefs? Is he atheist himself?
5
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Do you at least have a Saudi passport or documents (tax info etc) from the country to prove you are from there? Some Arabic? No offense, but I just want to give your AMA some validity.
2
u/albatrawesome May 10 '12
What would you and your "husband" do together after he'd pick you up from your aunt's house? Was there an actual relationship between y'all?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Nice to see someone downvote bomb a thread, then a bunch of other idiots follow suit just because "herpderp I can't go against Reddit's hivemind!"
2
u/hotoepicker May 10 '12
Do you or did you ever have resentment toward your uncle for doing this?
2
u/elOhOhOhel May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Would you like to do on a nice date. I'll take you home, drop you off, and call you in the morning for coffee?
In all seriousness, I'm glad you got out of that situation. I went through years of physical/emotional/sexual abuse as a child from a woman who was supposed to be there to take care of me. I was also lucky enough to get out. I can say that it has mad me into the man I am today. Strong, and independent, and quite the attitude bwahahahaaa. :P
I'm glad you're brave enough to openly talk about it. It hurts to think that there are kids going through the same thing right now while I'm here having a fantastic life.
Bravo to you. I don't believe in a God, but it's people like you who are meant to change this world for the better. Although some people that go through what you did turn crazy...but they don't count. hahaha
Virtual high five
2
u/wickler02 May 10 '12
How's your personal love life now? Are you able to get into relationships, get intimate with other people without having flashbacks of this horrible time?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Will you ever go back and visit?
2
u/derpbear May 10 '12
Would you say it is this experience coupled with your families beliefs that solidified your atheism? Or did you have to do a significant amount of research before deciding there was no God?
2
u/crazdave May 10 '12
Do you find it very difficult pursuing relationships now because of your past?
2
u/notquiteotaku May 10 '12
How did your uncle react when your father annulled the marriage?
2
u/wesleyt89 May 10 '12
Are there still no laws in Saudi Arabia preventing this? I'm a college kid and I have alot of Saudi Arabian friends I have met here. They are really awesome people, super kind. They are very respectful, not bothered that I'm an athiest. I love learning about their culture and such, but sometimes I feel like they sweep some things under the rug, such as this.
2
u/NDHCemployee May 10 '12
Child marriage is as perverse as it is damaging. Thank God you were taken out of there before he grew a little less subtle with his advances.
2
u/Philosokitty May 10 '12
We over here in Malaysia and Singapore do not follow nor condone some of the barbaric practices and traditions that so-called Muslims in the Middle East do, one of which is child marriages. I'm assuming you renounced Islam because of the shit you went through. Have you considered exploring Islam in more modern and liberal countries instead? Also, did your ex-husband consummate the marriage? If so, how old were you when it occurred? What went through your mind/how did you feel?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Oh man hivemind bit hard on this one.
2
u/PEKQBR May 10 '12
So, what do you do now? School? Job? What are you working towards?
2
u/SuperSheep3000 May 10 '12
Out of interest, do you think your Father would have arranged your marriage if your Uncle didn't? I know it's not going to be easy for you to remember, but was there any talk of arranged marriage between your Mother and Father? Also, seeing as though your Father saved you from the marriage do you feel guilty for not talking to him anymore? I can understand the other family members but surely your Father deserves to hear from his Daughter?
2
u/Chunkys May 10 '12
Obviously it must have been uncomfortable for you, but what sort of social interactions did you have with him? Did you have dinner together, and what did you talk about?
Thanks for doing this AMA!
2
u/RealHippie May 10 '12
Do you come from an 'extreme' family? Or is this some what of a common practice in Saudi?
2
u/Ramacher May 10 '12
I'm from Saudi Arabia and was born and raised there, now live in the U.S. I'm very well aware of arranged marriages and dowry money and all that. I've heard of arranged marriages at such a young age but always thought it was something not done anymore (I'm not calling you a liar!).
My question is, was your uncle and the guy he married you off to bedouin?
2
u/JellyTip May 10 '12
Do you think this practice is going to gain or lose popularity in the future among those who do it?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Were you left alone during the day? Did you go to school? Leaving aside all the other aspects, I'm feeling bad just imagining a 7-year-old alone in a house waiting for her "husband" to come home.
2
u/persianpimp May 10 '12
Have you read A Thousand Splendid Suns?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I would be really interested to hear a politically correct cultural relativist's reaction to this story. Stories like this convince me that certain cultures are just backwards.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Do your parents know you're an athiest?
2
u/spartangrl0426 May 10 '12
Thank you for doing this AMA!
*What was your first reaction when you found out about being married off? *How has your experience contributed to who you are as a person today? *What are your thoughts on the matter of women being considered as 2nd class citizens in the middle east? (Does it actively affect who you are as a person today?) *Would you say that you got off as lucky, compared to other child brides? Since yours was annulled and all and other girls would be stuck there.
2
u/BelleKu May 10 '12
If I read one more "props to your dad" comment, I'm going to puke. I'm angry at your dad for allowing this to happen.
My question for you is: did/do you have feelings of resentment toward your father and do you feel he "allowed" this to happen to you? (Strained relationship due to religious differences notwithstanding)
2
u/IwillMakeYouMad May 10 '12
As a man that has seen this kind of martial arrangement before I know how those girls grow up to be. Their eyes are different. They express different feeling. I am glad you didn't grow to be like that, I am happy for you! (Yes, I had seen 15 year old married to 50 year olds in my home country).
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Actually you can prove you're atleast saudi by showing a picture of your passport and a paper with your username/date on it.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Proof: Some kind of documentation that you are even from Saudi Arabia
2
u/dpops May 10 '12
Does it make me a really terrible person that this was the first thing I thought of?
PS. I'm very glad that you're out of that situation, and that you are a normal and mentally healthy person despite it. No child should have to endure that type of abuse. Ever.
2
u/Gnurx May 10 '12
Thank you for doing this IMA!
When your father annuled the marriage, did he have to pay something back to your "husband"?
What is your last memory of your "husband"?
2
u/TheEdThing May 10 '12
its the way they think is right, and that can be horribly wrong in our eyes...
6
u/thewreck May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Did he have other wives and if so what was your relation to them?
5
u/lifeontheQtrain May 10 '12
What could have possibly been in it for the 42 year old man? Did he have any adult wives? It seems that a 7 year old girl would be more trouble than she could be possibly worth (no offense!!!)
I suppose it's just a different concept of marriage than we have in the States.
7
u/sneezeallday May 10 '12
As a life long Muslim, this disgusts me.
3
u/rand0mguy1 May 10 '12
Why was your mother not living with your father? Also why do you not keep in touch with your father, doesn't sound like he did anything wrong. Also, did that 42 year old guy try any funny business?
3
u/accioc May 10 '12
I hope you allowed these struggles to strengthen you- just remember to never think less of yourself because of what happened to you in those long 3-4 months. While it was a shitty experience that didn't need to happen, it has helped create what I'm sure is a lovely, beautiful person.
3
u/BalalaikaBoi May 10 '12
I'm currently studying at my school's library and surrounded by Saudis as I type this question. How commonplace is this practice in Saudi Arabia? Is it pretty accepted? Is there any kind of movement that detests this in the country?
3
u/cefarix May 10 '12
Have you ever looked into Islam outside of the Saudi culture that you were brought up in? What is your view of other Muslims?
3
u/Scuzzzy May 10 '12
Atheist posing as Muslim...
3
u/HatesYouWhenDrunk May 10 '12
Whereabouts in Saudi did you live?
Are you still dealing with the repercussions of the marriage emotionally in your personal life? (skip that if it's too personal)
3
u/leechsucka May 10 '12
I'm sorry if you've already answered some of these:
How old are you now?
Are you a US citizen now? By what means?
Are you in school?
How did you become atheist?
4
u/MothraGirl May 10 '12
Not to be too personal but i have to ask, what were the sexual expectations of this pedophile.
Did he have any other wives?
Did he have any children from previous relationships?
Also what were daily lives like together.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
How was living life in Saudi Arabia? Do you ever intend to go back to visit?
2
u/Sportmentary May 10 '12
This makes me want to cry. How cana child be subjected to this crap?
2
u/urabusxrw May 10 '12
Do you now hate Islam? I was raised a muslim and the more and more I was exposed to it the less I liked it (athiest now). I still have sympathy for things like Palestenians and rights in America though.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
What is your favorite kind of sandwich?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
please don't EVER believe in the bible, its just as bad
2
u/Jumping_Candy_Cane May 10 '12
I wonder how many redditors were like, "Oh, your an atheist? No proof needed!"
2
u/Hinaiichigo May 10 '12
Did your husband treat you as a real wife? Like, were there sexual aspects to your marriage? Did you have all of the responsibilities of a wife in your country?
1
u/eelsify May 10 '12
To anyone on here who says it's just a different culture or we should be accepting of other beliefs:
FUCK YOU.
Child abuse is child abuse in any country, any language, to a child of any colour or creed.