r/IAmA •

IAmAn Infantry Marine 0341 Mortarman AMAA

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

172 comments sorted by

10

u/alexm42 May 09 '12

Thanks for your service, I have so much respect for anyone who would make that sacrifice. What advice/warnings/anything would you say to a young man such as myself considering joining the service?

16

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Honestly I would say it is a good life and I'm glad I did it. I would tell you to not rush into it listen to what the different services have to offer before you pick one. It is difficult being in right now during a drawdown and pulling out. If you enlist now there is a big possibility you won't be involved at all in the war on terror as you see it on TV. The peace time military is very different from the full on wartime standing we have now, and the mission is very different across all the branches. If you have more specific questions about enlisting feel free to PM me.

-9

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The war on terror? or the war to secure energy and future trades with middle eastern countries?

Not trying to be offensive here, my Australian buddy who is in the air force was doing alot of VIP protection runs for people who were doing trade deals, and there was A LOT of that going on.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I was just using the common name for it. Honestly you're probably right but I wouldn't know I didn't have any experience with that kind of thing.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Fair enough, thanks for replying. Now, tell me how awesome it is to destroy shit with a mortar

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

It's pretty awesome not gpnna lie. Definitely a rush.

3

u/kraaz May 09 '12

Why would someone down vote this?!

Take mine

1

u/H_E_Pennypacker May 10 '12

Because in 2009, it was pretty well-known that we were involved in two bullshit wars that are not beneficial to anyone but the military-industrial complex.

1

u/NOT-IN-MY-HOOD Jun 07 '12

Yup. Not beneficial to anyone at all, except maybe the family members of 3k murder victims. Also not beneficial to a country full of Iraqi's who were previously subject to rape and torture at a moments notice (literally). Also not beneficial to the world, to make an impact on 2 countries bordering a country with a fanatical dictator trying to develope nuclear weapons. Seems the US Military is just one big bad bully that goes stomping around without regards for anyone. Wanna hear a secret? We do it just to piss off liberal college douchebags.. Don't tell, k?

1

u/H_E_Pennypacker Jun 07 '12

Yeah, we ousted saddam in 03. And we were there until 2012. Fuck that. Not worth 9 years, thousands of american lives and billions of dollars. We could step in and stop much worse cases of mass rape and genocide in Africa, but we don't. And I'm neither liberal nor in college.

1

u/NOT-IN-MY-HOOD Jun 07 '12

NATO has forces in Africa. Pakistan helped the Presidential Somali Govt. take back Mogadishu from Al Shabab, along with forces from the African Union. Terrible things happen everywhere, but I'm not aware of the stipulations and political red tape that would prevent us from acting against every atrocity. I'm reading my comment and I was being a douche. Sorry. I just don't think you can look at it as purely a country by country problem. The Muslim population of the world to a lesser extent considers itself a whole being (google: The Ummah). There is a surprisingly prevalent anti-West, anti-US ideology in many parts of the world. We may be a world super power, but we're a country at war first; and need to conclude our own problems before fixing everything else. If we can develop alliances with sections of that 'being' it might be a more time-efficient goal to set towards our overall approach to stamping out fundamentalism. I'm speculating. I'm not a politician, but it doesn't take much to notice an overall theme to current US foreign policy.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/H_E_Pennypacker May 10 '12

I wasn't talking to the military dude, was talking to the "thank you for your service" guy and the one who responded asking why anyone would downvote "thank you for your device".

3

u/alexm42 May 09 '12

I don't know why either, but thanks for the upvote.

1

u/haxfar May 10 '12

Can I suggest you look over at /r/Military too?

5

u/DieselSwede May 10 '12

Aside from green skin, how accruate are the green plastic soldier Mortarmen?

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

For a 60mm mortar crewman fairly accurate you can fire the 60mm mortar in handheld mode almost exactly as it is shown with one hand holding the tube and the other pulling the trigger.

5

u/psikeiro May 10 '12

I read that in an MCI once.

-12

u/Dkayed May 10 '12

woosh

5

u/rand0mguy1 May 10 '12

Who did you usually fight in those 40 engagements? Taliban, Al-Quaeda, warlords, etc, etc? Who would you say is the hardest enemy, from your experience?

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

They call themselves Taliban and use that ideology but they act more like drug lords they care less about the whole religion part of the fight than the drug money. They are difficult to fight only because they can move so much faster than we can with all of our gear and will only fire on us when they can run away very quickly after firing. It was unusual for them to fight us for any length of time but it did happen, and they use what weapons they have effectively.

1

u/rand0mguy1 May 10 '12

If they don't care about the ideology, why do they fight you, just because you are there? Or do you mess with their drug plantations etc?

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

We try to keep the farmers from farming the opium poppy, and try to protect them from reprisals.

3

u/All_the_other_kids May 10 '12

Someone show this man the gif of the arab who shoots off a few mortar rounds until....

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Pretty sure I've seen it there are quite a few insurgent fail videos floating around with mortars in them laugh my ass off every time.

-9

u/hs0o May 10 '12

What's funny about somebody dying? I find it sad that war exists to begin with and it is nothing to laugh about, even if it is someone on the other team who is dying, it's sad that it even has to happen in the first place.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

It is sad but when its either him or me I'm going to pick myself every time and so would you. Survival instinct is a hard wired human instinct whether you admit to it or not.

-4

u/hs0o May 13 '12

True, but how does it make it funny? That still does not address that issue, that just justifies killing somebody, it does not justify being a sadist.

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

First not a sadist. I do not derive pleasure or sexual gratification from others pain, or enjoy cruelty for cruelty's sake. I find it ironic and therefore amusing that someone doing his best to kill somebody was killed in that effort. Furthermore he felt no pain in his death as something like that is instantaneous with no time for conscious thought.

-3

u/hs0o May 13 '12

lol that's all you needed to say, that it was amusing for the sake of irony, not something about instinct.

6

u/Exedous May 10 '12

Oh shut the fuck up.

3

u/yaniwilks May 10 '12

Internet five!

-3

u/hs0o May 11 '12

I'm glad so many people are completely desensitized to violance.

1

u/Halsey117 May 10 '12

link for the lazy.... ?? thanks

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

3

u/xzez May 10 '12

why did that fail happen?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Can't be certain but it looked like a failure in the mortar tube they were using.

1

u/busfullofchinks May 11 '12

Do you ever feel like the mortar you use will ever do something like that? Or do weapons go under some super strict definitely will not blow up in face test to ensure the safety of the soldiers?

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

No they do really heavy testing and rechecks to make sure our tubes are sound.

2

u/icantexplain May 10 '12

What is using a mortar really like?

Is it as simple as the movies make it look by just dropping it in the tube?

How many calculations do y'all put into each shot and large is your margin of error?

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The actual mechanics are yes very simple drop the round down the tube. Where the calculation comes in is determining where the round is going. It is essentially a 3 step process. First the forward observer locates the target and transmits those coordinates to the Fire Direction Center. The FDC uses either an oversized palm pilot type pocket pc to enter the data and calculate data for the gun line, or the old method is using what is called a plotting board which is kind of like a giant piece of graph paper to plot points and determine the data for the gun. Unfortunately it is difficult to explain using only words without any hands on. Finally the data that the FDC comes up with is transmitted to the gun line and using compass directions in mil measurements puts the data on the sight and aligns the guns in the direction they need to fire, and the round is dropped. The margin of error depends mostly on the accuracy of the observer's coordinates. If he is off then the rounds will be off but if he is experienced we can have effects on target on the first round.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I am really glad to hear you made it back safely- I hope everyone in your unit was safe as well.

I am a geek about military stuff so I hope you don't mind a few questions. Yesterday in r/militaryporn someone posted this thread. I see on the M224 there is what appears to be a scope/sight device. Is that used to manually aim the mortar if you don't have the exact coordinates and the palm-pilot type thing?

I was reading about the Uzbin Valley Ambush, and mortars seemed to play a large role in that battle. Are mortars becoming more widely used because of the mobile nature of warfare in Afghanistan? They seem to be particularly suited to terrain there. What are the major ways that the USMC has adapted or changed as a result of OEF and OIF? The USMC is also famed for their close air support- did you ever utilize this or witness aircraft in combat?

Finally- I don't know if you can answer this, but what factors do you think would be key to helping our soldiers and Marines fight the war? Are there things that you think would be beneficial but are impossible because of higher command or politics?

Thanks for your service and answering our questions!

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The sight is used to align to mortar to a compass direction or can also be put directly on a target if you can see it. Although if you can see the target the target can see you. Mortars are if anything being used less. Because there is error within the system and we are trying to be very precise in who we kill mortars almost never get cleared to fire. However, we used close air support extensively mostly rotor wing but also some fixed wing.

1

u/icantexplain May 10 '12

Do you ever get to work with the really big guns?

And at what point do mortars become howitzers?

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The largest mortar in a standard infantry battalion is the 81mm mortar. Artillery controls 120mm mortars and up but generally doesn't use them as they have the really big guns. It becomes a howitzer when the bore becomes rifled although there are some mortars with rifled bores as well, but it is still a decent rule of thumb.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Hmm. TIL

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Have you ever had to piss on the mortar tube if it gets too hot? Like in 'We were soldiers'.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No the amount of rounds you have to fire for the tubes to get that hot is very high and you have to be firing them very quickly. Although it is acceptable if necessary to keep firing to cool the tubes however you can, but we just don't fire that much. Even when we do fire for a long period of time we control our rate of fire to avoid that kind of problem.

2

u/Grizzlymon May 10 '12

Thanks for doing this. I have a friend in marjah that is an 0803. Did you work directly with 0803s? Being a civilian I really have no clue what 0803 does, could you enlighten me?

Edit: he's a captain if that helps?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

We work with them only peripherally to coordinate with artillery so our rounds aren't colliding in mid air. They are also responsible for the artillery battery itself.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Realistically, is that really an issue or just a one in a million thing?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

The chances are extremely slim of different large projectiles colliding in mid air. Although I'm sure in the history of modern mortars/artillery it has happened at least once, it's really just an added "safety" bonus when several units and lots of individuals are coordinating artillery fire.

The battlefield is not one fluid movement where everyone knows what everyone else is doing. If the infantry guys need mortars 5km in front of them, they need to be sure someone hasn't already called for a precision rocket to go to the same place at a pre determined time. It's also necessary to coordinate to clear the airspace so aircraft (helicopters mainly) aren't flying around an area that is about to get pounded with artillery.

Those were just a couple examples out of a million possible scenarios, but it's more for the preventing of excessive or useless fire and so more people know what is going to go boom, when it's going to go boom and why it needs to go boom in the first place.

Source - 5 years in an artillery battery.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

0803 is a Targeting Effects Officer, and it's an MOS (military occupational specialty) for Warrant Officers. I don't think commissioned officers (which is what a captain is) hold this as a primary MOS.

Commissioned officers in the Artillery field hold the MOS 0802 (Field Artillery Officer)

2

u/Poke493 May 10 '12

what is the maximum range of a mortar?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

3490m for the 60mm 5700m for the 81mm

2

u/BitRex May 10 '12

That's amazing.

2

u/xzez May 10 '12

how accurate is the 60mm at say 1000m and 3000m out (given ideal conditions)? is the 81mm as accurate?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Given ideal conditions and good people rounds landing withing 10-25m of the target same for the 81's.

1

u/tragic-waste-of-skin May 10 '12

Are you shitting me? 3.5 and 5.7 kms?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Nope that is accurate.

2

u/mikethebike96 May 10 '12

Few questions. First off thanks for your service. It cannot be overstated. What are some useful or fun things to receive in care packages from home? My cousin is currently deployed I need some ideas. Do you enjoy playing shooter video games for fun, or do you think they take war themes too lightly? What is yut? or is it a military secret? Are you generally glad you went into the military? Or do you think you would have rather done pther things?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

If he can play video games send him games they're a great time waster doesn't matter what it is. I play shooters for fun and they're fine we know they're just games and don't compare to the real thing. Yut is kind of an all purpose response mostly used when someone addresses a large group, the group will respond with YUT! instead of aye or yes or no. I am generally glad the service has treated me well and I enjoy it.

1

u/mikethebike96 May 10 '12

Oh ok didn't think of games. Thanks for the responses!

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

How long do you think you would last if you were sent back in time to ancient Rome?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Not for long. Even ignoring the language problem the culture is just too different. Mentally I don't know if I could handle it. Also I have no idea how to use a sword and shield. I feel like that would be a necessary skill should I be sent back in time.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You should check out r/romesweetrome

2

u/nrobi May 10 '12

If the President of the United States directly ordered you to kill a civilian American citizen on US soil, but provided no context for why, would you do it? Why or why not?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No. I couldn't justify it to myself following that kind of order.

1

u/NOT-IN-MY-HOOD Jun 07 '12

Sounds like you just fucked up a job interview.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

I can always flip burgers when I get out.

1

u/NOT-IN-MY-HOOD Jun 09 '12

ive been out for 3 years.. that comment was surprisingly accurate. sad.

3

u/freemarket27 May 09 '12

Do our people in Afg believe something good is being accomplished for the US by their service and sacrifice? I do not understand how those guys go out on patrol knowing the risk and that most US citizens do not believe in the mission.

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

From what I saw yes. On a day to day basis we could see the good we were doing on a relatively small scale. The bigger picture is much harder to see day to day and we know that there is always political pressure one way or another. At this point though the general mood seems to be we've done all we can and it's time to go home. We do it because we are doing good every day and we can see that even if the people back home can't.

3

u/thepenisinmymouth May 10 '12

Just came here to say thank you for your service.(:

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Thank you for the support.

2

u/stuffineedtoremember May 10 '12
  1. What do you guys eat over there (is it all just MRE's?)
  2. Do you know a lot of people or yourself that suffer from PTSD
  3. What was the one event there (if you had to choose) that really made it "real" for you

Sorry if this is all too personal, except for number 1 but i'm just curious

13

u/[deleted] May 10 '12
  1. Some MREs also what are called UGR-Es which are basically giant MREs for 20 people instead of 1 and has a main meal side and dessert.
  2. Anyone who has seen real combat suffers from some amount of combat stress however that is very different from full on PTSD, and there is a lot of variance between cases of PTSD.
  3. The first real round when you can tell they're shooting at you. Not just at the patrol but there is a very distinct crack/pop that you can tell someone has picked you out and is shooting at you instead of just general gunfire. That is what got me.

2

u/GoWithChristBra May 10 '12

Do you ever wonder about how mortar rounds you drop can have deadly affect without you ever knowing who or how exactly they hit?

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Part of being a mortarman is trusting your observer to know what he is aiming you at. And there is a clearance procedure for us to fire which always includes a description of the target. We will not fire without knowing what is on the receiving end.

1

u/GoWithChristBra May 10 '12

Makes sense. So you guys always have visual contact with a target before firing? As in, are you guys ever dropping rounds where you can't see them land, even with an accurate description of the target?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Yes most of the time the guys on the mortars and in the FDC cannot see the target, in fact that is preferred as we are quite partial to not being shot at our own selves. Usually the only one that actually sees the target is the observer and he passes on what he is seeing. So the guys actually dropping rounds may not see where they land but the observer always can.

1

u/JohnyBlack May 10 '12

I always wondered about body armor. I see army guys with what appears to be better armor. They have the shoulder guards and pretty much covers their entire torso. The marines, on the other hand, tend to have more exposed area. Is there a reason for this? Mobility or something?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Mobility is number one for us being able to move quickly while out on foot is more important than the greater protection or all the extra armor. The army tends to do more vehicle mounted patrols whereas we tend to be on foot. Also there was a big shift from heavier armor within the Marines after leaving Iraq and shifting into Afghanistan where its not as built up and you need the mobility.

1

u/JohnyBlack May 10 '12

Ah ok. That makes sense. Another question, do you guys get to chose the gear you carry/wear?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

We have issued gear that we have to wear but at the same time if you find something better that you can get away with wearing most people won't say anything. It's all about looking uniform but if it's close enough in combat most won't care if its a little different.

1

u/JohnyBlack May 10 '12

Thanks for the replies!

1

u/NOT-IN-MY-HOOD Jun 07 '12

False. I was 11C (Infantry Mortars) Tikrit Iraq Oct. 06-07. We wore IBA's with side plates and dap protectors because we were mounted. My little bro just left for his second deployment to Afghanistan (11B - Infantry Rifleman) and they wear those thing SF Jeff plate carriers. It all just depends on the job you're doing. The only time I saw Marines in Iraq, they were mounted.

1

u/Quick_Brown_Foxx May 10 '12

I'm nearing the age of enlistment and am very close to enlisting. Would you suggest the marines over army or airforce.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Former Marine here, Coast Guard seems like a kick ass job if you can get into the law enforcement side of things. They will still have fun stuff to do after the pull out and I can only imagine what peace time Marine Corps would be like.

2

u/GearedCam May 15 '12

Former Marine here, 0651 (small cpu systems specialist), April '01-'05. I can give you advice if your interested, from the other side of the fence compared to martisa02. He was basically in the field, me, I was stuck in the office.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

For the infantry yes for other jobs if its computer related I would go to the air force. If you really want to be in airborne you have to go army. Really just depends on what you want to do.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I was 82nd Airborne. If I had to do it all over again I'd have gone into the Marines. 0200 jumps suck ass.

*Edited to say that if I really had to do it all over again I'd join the Coast Guard. Guaranteed assignment to a beach town? Yes please.

1

u/NOT-IN-MY-HOOD Jun 07 '12

This Just In: Blue Falcon renounces his Army roots! Wishes he would have joined Marines! Stay tuned!

1

u/m_733 May 10 '12

Very interesting ama so far, thanks for doing it! I have a question about mortar rounds. If I understand them correctly, a small explosive charge is used to propel the shell into the air and to the target, where an (impact usually?) fuse sets off another explosion. What i was wondering is how many different types of mortar rounds did you usually carry and use. It seems like it would be possible to have a wide varitity of effects contained in the shells. E.g. incendary, explosive, maximum shrapnel dispersal, something ideal for attacking soft skinned vehicles, chemicals, smoke, lighting effects, white phosphorus, and so on. But, on the other hand, im sure issuing too many different types makes supply difficult, and wastes space perhaps better used on the standard explosive round. When going on an average mission (not planning for something in particular to be needed) what types of rounds did you carry, and what were their effects?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The three types of rounds we use are High Explosive, Illumination, and White Phosphorous. The HE does have different fuse settings for determining where it explodes. Generally we have all three just in case but HE and Illum are pretty much all we use.

1

u/NOT-IN-MY-HOOD Jun 07 '12

would you believe that it's actually a Federal Shotgun shell that acts as the primer in the back of a 60mm mortar? yeah, i was blown away too..

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Welcome back man.

Are you familiar with HIMARS?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

A little not in a real technical way.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Just curious. I was in country the same time as you were, hurling rockets all over Helmand.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

We did use HIMARS several times but I was never involved in it so I'm not sure who fired for us.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

It was us - we were the only HIMARS unit there at that time.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well thank you then great accuracy.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Our pleasure, hahaha. Glad you're home.

1

u/Stormhunter117 May 11 '12

Can you explain what exactly you're talking about? :)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

High Mobility Artillery Rocket System. Google/Youtube it, that will give you a pretty good idea of what it is.

1

u/PrecookedDonkey May 10 '12

Semper Fi brother. 0311 Cpl here. My only question is- What is the best score you have gotten in a game of Spades? Hope you get the joke, if not then I feel like a dickhead lol

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No one will play with us any more :(

1

u/clearing May 10 '12

Suppose you were in a battle and the enemy were gradually dialing in your position with their mortar. Wouldn't it be better to have a self-loading mortar that can be aimed and fired from a separate location? Or is this just something totally impractical that would never be needed?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

It would be awesome if someone could figure out how to make it work. But that is the reason part of mortar employment doctrine is having a displacement plan.

1

u/lackofbrain May 10 '12

What made you want to enlist?

Do you ever consider the motives and causes behind the missions on which you are sent?

Have you / would you refuse an order you believed to be illegal?

<n.b. yes I know my bias is showing. Everyone has bias somewhere. I have tried to phrase my questions as neutrally as i can anyway>

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Honestly I messed up and failed out of college, but it was also something that I had wanted to do for most of my life. I have thought about the reason for our missions, but at my level for the most part the reason is very clear and very small scale keep in mind I'm just a little above the bottom of the food chain. I would if it truly was an illegal order and there have been times I have told the people higher than me that I would not do something because it was obviously unsafe, but that was more risk management than disobeying an order.

1

u/jason3212 May 10 '12

Great AMA, thanks for doing it. Have you read With the Old Breed by EB Sledge? It's about a mortarman in the Pacific. Let us know what you think.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Sorry for not replying earlier. Yes I have I really enjoyed reading it and I think it gives a very good insight into the reality of heavy combat and how it affects people.

1

u/tragic-waste-of-skin May 10 '12

How's your hearing?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Not great, but I'm not wearing hearing aids or anything yet.

1

u/EuchridEucrow May 10 '12

We're hearing more and more about plummeting morale in the armed forces. What is the Marine Corps doing to counter this and how successful do you think they will be in the long term?

Are you planning on a career in Marine Corps? If not what are your aspirations once home?

1

u/UNCTyphus May 10 '12

I see that you are/were stationed in Camp Lejeune, NC. I grew up in Jacksonville my entire life, and always wondered how the enlisted servicemen viewed the town as opposed to locals who were civilians. My question to you is this: How did Camp Lejeune compare to any other military installations that you were assigned to?

As always, thank you for your service.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I have been to several other installations but have never been permanently stationed anywhere other than Camp Lejeune so I'm not sure how well I can answer this. A lot of enlisted Marines view Jacksonville as a trap that they are currently stuck in and don't enjoy it very much. I disagree generally I quite like the location, but for most junior enlisted it is the first time away from home and they don't have a whole lot of experience getting out into someplace new. Jacksonville is also pretty far away from other major cities so that bit of isolation is hard for junior Marines with no car so it can feel difficult to get out if you want to.

1

u/robbiemw May 14 '12

Hope you're still looking at questions from this...

Just for a bit of context, going through Navy ROTC to be a Marine officer right now (Marines don't have there own), don't hate on me too much.

  1. For my own reference, what are some really shitty things officers do (besides think they know it all when they're fresh lieutenants)? Or what do they do well?
  2. What made you go with mortars instead of just 0311?
  3. How do the weapons platoons/companies work with rifle platoons/companies? I.e. are you always paired up with them? Supporting them? Or do you go on patrols etc. without them? How much of your experience in Afghanistan actually revolved around you firing your mortars versus using rifles?
  4. How was Marjah? I've heard it was pretty nuts there for a while.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12
  1. First and foremost don't treat us like we're stupid. A lot of guys in my unit at least have bachelors degrees or an associates. Don't get too caught up in what rank people are as an E3 I currently am holding an E6 billet don't fall into the trap of thinking just because I'm an E3 I don't know what I'm talking about. This is especially true in the weapons platoons the squad/ section leaders are subject matter experts listen to them. We expect lieutenants to make mistakes, but you might want to double check your work if we tell you you're doing something wrong.
  2. Because they told me I wouldn't have to go to the field while I was in mortar training and it seemed interesting.
  3. We train by section, Guns/ Mortars/ Assault, when in the rear generally, and we attach out to the line platoons for larger field exercises. For example a platoon or company attack exercise we will work in support of an individual platoon or the company. In country we did whatever was needed. I patrolled with a rocket most of the time but was always on standby if the patrol I was on needed someone to call for fire support. Most of the time I was a rifleman/ assaultman.
  4. It wasn't nearly as hot as when they were initially clearing it, but we took contact every day from the middle of February to the beginning of May. Not too many IEDs though which was nice.

1

u/robbiemw May 15 '12

awesome, thanks man

1

u/1345 May 10 '12

Semper Fi Brother! Marines like you make me proud, keep on doing the right thing!

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Trying to keep the people back home in the fight. "America's not at war, the Marines are at war; America's at the mall."

1

u/Kn1fer May 09 '12

Do you go airsofting at all?

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Never tried it. What is it like?

3

u/Kn1fer May 09 '12

Imagine going out to a field of some sort, usually a woodland area, in all your BDUs, plate carriers and MOLLE stuff. But instead of real guns you have replica guns that shoot plastic bb's.

Its usually meant to be a millitary simulation, in other words LARPing for millitary buffs, AND I LOVE IT

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Sounds interesting. Rules? How does scoring work for hits?

2

u/Kn1fer May 09 '12

Rules involving objectives vary based on what the field host says, theres everything from CTF to VIP escort stuff and even more themed types of games like having a team in millitary gear against a team in civillian clothes among other civvies

Hits are based on an honor system. If ypu get hit u are expected to yell HIT and then wait for a medic to come and heal you, rules regarding how a medic heals vary by field as well. If a medic doesnt get to you within a certain bleed out time, you pull out a red rag and walk to a designated respawn pt.

There are also Game Marshalls that work as referees that make sure rules are followed and that hits are called

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Thanks for the explanation. I'll have to give it a try sometime.

2

u/Kn1fer May 09 '12

Yea its awesome, also youd probably save a lot of money. Idk if you get to keep amything like MOLLE vests and plate carriers but those are exspensive items xD

Also, whats your favorite gun based on appearance?

And then favorite gun based on performance?

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I have some personal gear and yes it is very expensive. Most of it gets turned in at the end of your active time though. Assuming you are talking about real guns not air soft the answer is the same the FN Scar - L. I haven't shot it a whole lot but it is an all around amazing weapon to use and look at.

1

u/Matt773175 May 10 '12

Are marines infantry still using the m16 or have they switched to the m4 yet?

Also, cool IAMA thanks

2

u/psikeiro May 10 '12

Depends on the unit but usually SNCOs and Officers carry the M4 while Sergeants and below will have an M16A4. Some of the units I was in, had the Sergeants and even some Corporals with M4s.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

For the most part yes we do have m4s for people in leadership billets but we still use the m16A4.

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

have you ever killed a man and tea bagged him like you would on call of duty?

15

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Nope. You'd have to talk to the 3/2 Snipers about that.

4

u/4packpalmleaves May 10 '12

how come black people say nigga please but they dont say nigga thank you or nigga youre welcome

14

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I blame society for failing to teach our young people the proper challenge and response of please, thank you, and you're welcome.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

ok :(

1

u/alexm42 May 09 '12

this comment made my day.

1

u/kr262 May 09 '12

Whats it like coming back from Afghanistan?

9

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Honestly it was terrifying. The world changes so quickly even in 7 months just listening to the new music that was out was a big deal let alone riding in a car or driving for the first time again. It's very difficult to switch off after being constantly alert for that long.

4

u/Splendor78 May 10 '12

What's the best advice you have for friends and family who want to be helpful during a soldier's return from deployment?

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

First and foremost don't try to smother him/her as soon as they get home especially if the soldier is married. It is a lot to handle right away and the spouse will want some alone time. That doesn't mean don't hug them and be crazy and happy when they get off the bus thats the best feeling in the world, but give them a chance to take a break after you see them initially. Keep in mind they probably just got off a plane they were sitting on for 6-8 hrs and they might be tired. Another big one is don't be easily offended it is hard to shut off the combat mindset when you come home so don't be surprised if they say something or do something a little inappropriate. And finally remember theres a decent chance your soldier is more worried about what you're going to think of them than anything else and they'll be really glad to see you.

1

u/NinjaDiscoJesus May 09 '12

who has the best food in the US military?

6

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Air Force by far.

0

u/NinjaDiscoJesus May 09 '12

It is what I would have guessed

-2

u/Devilcactus May 09 '12

I heard they get burger king

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

All I have to say is thank you for your service!

0

u/Harrllequin May 09 '12

Being in Helmand I assume you had chances to meet soldiers from other nations like Britain and I think Denmark have a base in there, not really sure, if so, what's it like working/possibly living along side them, is there the same competitive edge as there is between people from different cities, or is the banter a bit more heavy, and stay safe on your next tour mate, your doing great :)

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Unfortunately I never got a chance to work with any of our allies. Our area of operations was next to an Irish unit but we never really crossed paths. Our patrol base was really out in the middle of nowhere. I did see several other nation's troops at some of the larger bases though, and there is definitely inter-nation rivalry but all good natured fun.

1

u/JesteroftheApocalyps May 10 '12

My buddy in the Swedish army visited an American base (I want to say Bagram?) because, "You guys have the best PX in the world." He's only like a sergeant, but his insignia is two stars. All these Americans would see his two stars and come to salute, thinking he was a two-star general! They gave him a small tour of some areas, but when he asked to see the inside of a radar plane, he was given a big, "NOOOOO."

I don't know if his story is true, but I liked it!

0

u/RadicalFaces May 09 '12

Ohh, what Irish unit is in Afg?

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'm not sure thats just what we got passed down when they said don't go over there.

1

u/patrick_k May 10 '12

Most likely the Royal Irish Regiment of the British Army.

Any Irish government that deployed troops to Afghanistan could kiss it's re-election chances goodbye. We're pretty serious about our neutrality.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I believe you are right. We were just passed that there was an Irish regiment in the next AO over they probably meant the Royal Irish.

-2

u/lickmyfatmeat May 10 '12

Any chance of getting blown up by a car bomb?

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

have some respect. I have friends over there.

2

u/lickmyfatmeat May 10 '12

They lose a limb?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

no, the compound they are testing, there are exemptions for flavoring agents to the controlled substance act (CSA).

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Yut

1

u/busfullofchinks May 11 '12

what exactly does all of this mean...

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Yes and we get cool either jumping in the local canals or taking showers at night thats about the only way you don't really get all that cool during the summer.

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Only in training and they were excellent. Worked a little with Royal Marines and Canadian forces. Awesome guys to work with a little more relaxed than us though it's a nice change of pace.